131
Views
20
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The feudalism debate: The Turkish end – is ‘tax – vs. – rent’ necessarily the product and sign of a modal difference?

Pages 291-333 | Published online: 05 Feb 2008

Notes

  • 1984 . A recent CNRS colloquium on ‘Genèse de l'Etat Moderne’ . November 16–17 1984 , Fontevraud (France) .

References

  • Akat , A.S. 1977 . ‘Tarihî Maddecilik ve Kapitalizm‐Öncesi Toplumlar: Asya Toplumu‐Feodalite Tartişmasina Yeni Bir Yaklaşim’ (Historical Materialism and Pre‐Capitalist Societies: A New Approach to the Asian Society‐vs.‐Feudalism Debate) . Toplum ve Bilim (Society and Science) , : 34 – 48 .
  • Althusser , L. and Balibar , E. 1972 . Reading Capital , London : New Left Books .
  • Anderson , P. 1974 . Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism , London : New Left Books .
  • Bailey , A.M. and Llobera , J. , eds. 1981 . The Asiatic Mode of Production London
  • Balibar , E. 1967 . “ ‘The Basic Concepts of Historical Materialism’ ” . Edited by: Althusser and Balibar . [1972]
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1937–38 . ‘Osmanli Imparatorluğunda Çiftçi Siniflarin Hukukî Statüsü’ (The Legal Status of Agrarian Classes in the Ottoman Empire) . Ülkü Mecmuasi , IX‐X ( 49–59 )
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1939 . ‘Malikâne‐Divani Sistemi’ (The Half‐Estate, Half‐State System) . Türk Hukuk ve Iktisat Tarihi Mecmuasi (The Journal of Turkish Legal and Economic History) , 11
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1939–40 . ‘XV ve XVI'nci Asirlarda Osmanh Imparatorlugunda Toprak Işçiliğinin Organizasyonu Şekilleri’ (Forms of Organisation of Agricultural Labour in the Ottoman Empire in the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries) . Iktisat Fakültesi Mecmuasi (Journal of the Faculty of Economics) , I ( 1, 2, 4 )
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1943 . XV ve XVI'nci Asirlarda Osmanli İmparatorluğunda Ziraî Ekonominin Hukukî ve Malî Esaslari (Legal and Financial Principles of the Agricultural Economy in the Ottoman Empire in the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries) Istanbul
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1964 . “ ‘16. Asrin İkinci Yarisinda Türkiye'nin Geçirdigi Iktisadî Buhranlarin Sosyal Yapi Üzerindeki Tesirleri’ (The Effects of the Economic Crises Experienced by Turkey in The Second Half of the Sixteenth Century on the Social Structure) ” . In İktisadî Kalkinmanin Sosyal Meseleleri (Social Aspects of Economic Development) Istanbul
  • Barkan , Ö.L. ‘ “Feodal” Düzen ve Osmanli Timari (The ‘Feudal’ System and the Ottoman Timar) . in Türkiye İktisat Tarihi Semineri (Proceedings of the Seminar on Turkish Economic History) . Ankara . Hacettepe Üniversitesi (published in 1975) .
  • Barkan , Ö.L. 1974 . ‘Timar’ . İslâm Ansiklopedisi (Encyclopaedia of Islam, Turkish version) , XII ( 1 )
  • Berkes , N. 1969 . 100 Soruda Türkiye İktisat Tarihi (Turkish Economic History in 100 Questions) , Vol.1 , Istanbul : Gerçek Yayinevi .
  • Berktay , H. 1983a . Cumhuriyet İdeolojisi ve Fuat Köprülü (Republican Ideology and Fuat Köprülü) , Istanbul : Kaynak Yayinlari .
  • Berktay , H. 1983b . Kabileden Feodalizme (From Tribe to Feudalism) , Istanbul : Kaynak Yayinlari .
  • Berktay , H. 1985 . “ ‘Tarih Çalişmalari’ (Historiography) ” . In Cumhuriyet Dönemi Tiirkiye Ansiklopedisi (Encyclopaedia of Republican Turkey) , Vol.9 , Istanbul : İletiişim Yayilari . Fasc.78
  • Berktay , H. 1986 . “ ‘Osmanli Devletinin Yükselişine Kadar Türklerin İktisadî ve Toplumsal Tarihi’ (Economic and Social History of the Turks up to the Rise of the Ottoman Empire) ” . In Türkiye Tarihi , Edited by: Akşin) , Sina . Vol.1 , Istanbul : Cem Yayinlari .
  • Bloch , M. 1931/1966 . French Rural History: An Essay on Its Basic Characteristics (translated by Janet Sondheimer) , Berkeley : University of California Press . (original printing in 1931)
  • Bloch , M. 1940/1966 . Feudal Society , Edited by: Manyon , L.A. 2 vols , Chicago : University of Chicago Press . (original printing in 1940)
  • Bloch , M. 1941/1971 . “ ‘The Rise of Dependent Cultivation and Seignorial Institutions’ ” . In The Cambridge Economic History of Europe , Edited by: Postan , M.M. Vol.1 , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . (first edition in 1941)
  • Bois , G. 1980 . “ [Remarks during the discussion following Harbans Mukhia's paper titled ‘Peut‐on appliquer le concept de féodalisme au cas indien?'] ” . In Compte rendu des séances de la Société d'étude du féodalisme 1979–80 Vol. III‐IV , 54 – 63 .
  • Byres , T.J. 1985 . “ ‘Modes of Production and Non‐European, Pre‐Colonial Societies: The Nature and Significance of the Debate’ ” . Edited by: Byres and Mukhia . 1 – 16 . [1985]
  • Byres , T.J. and Mukhia , H. , eds. 1985 . Feudalism and Non‐European Societies , London : Frank Cass .
  • The Journal of Peasant Studies , 12 ( 2 and 3 ) Jan./April Special Issue
  • Cahen , C . 1968 . Pre‐Ottoman Turkey , Edited by: Williams , J. Jones . New York : Taplinger .
  • Cameron , K.N. 1977 . Humanity and Society: A World History , New York : Monthly Review Press .
  • Ciaessen , H.J.M. and Skalnik , P. , eds. 1977 . The Early State’ , The Hague : Mouton .
  • Duby , G. 1974 . The Early Growth of the European Economy: Warriors and Peasants from the Seventh to the Twelfth Century , Edited by: Clarke , Howard B. Ithaca : Cornell University Press .
  • Hill , C . 1986 . ‘The Bourgeois Revolutions in Soviet Scholarship’ . New Left Review , Jan.‐Feb. : 107 – 13 .
  • Hilton , R.H. 1953/1976 . “ ‘A Comment’ in The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism ” . Edited by: Hilton , R.H. London : New Left Books . (article originally appeared in 1953)
  • Hilton , R.H. 1976 . “ ‘Introduction’ ” . In The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism , Edited by: Hilton , R.H. London : New Left Books .
  • Hilton , R.H. 1978 . ‘A Crisis of Feudalism’ . Past and Present , : 3 – 19 .
  • Hilton , R.H. 1984 . ‘Feudalism in Europe: Problems for Historical Materialists’ . New Left Review , Sept.‐Oct. : 84 – 93 .
  • Hirst , P.Q. 1975 . ‘The Uniqueness of the West’ . Economy and Society , 4 : 446 – 75 .
  • Hobsbawm , E.J. 1964 . “ ‘Introduction’ ” . In Pre‐Capitalist Economic Formations , Edited by: Marx , Karl . London : Lawrence & Wishart .
  • Hodgson , M.G.S. 1974 . The Venture of Islam Vol.3, The Gunpowder Empires and Modern Times , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • İnalcik , H. 1954 . “ ‘Stefan Duşan'dan Osmanli İmparatorluğuna’ (From Stefan Dushan to the Ottoman Empire) ” . In Fatih Devri Üzerinde Tetkikler ve Vesikalar (Researches and Documents on the Period of Mehmet the Conqueror) , 136 – 84 . Ankara : Türk Tarih Kurumu Yayinlari .
  • İnalcik , H. 1955 . ‘Land Problems in Turkish History’ . The Muslim World , July : 221 – 8 .
  • İnalcik , H. 1959 . ‘Osmanlilar'da Raiyyet Rüsumu’ (The So‐Called Tenancy Tax of the Ottomans) . Belleten (Bulletin of the Turkish Historical Association) , XXIII ( 92 ) Oct. : 576 – 610 .
  • İnalcik , H. 1964 . “ ‘The Nature of Traditional Society: Turkey’ ” . In Political Modernization in Japan and Turkey , Edited by: Ward and Rustow . Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • İnalcik , H. 1969 . ‘Capital Formation in the Ottoman Empire’ . The Journal of Economic History , XXIX ( 1 ) : 97 – 140 .
  • İnalcik , H. 1972 . “ ‘The Ottoman Decline and its Effects upon the Reaya’ ” . In Aspects of the Balkans: Continuity and Change , Edited by: Birnbaum , H. and Vryonis , Speros Jr. 338 – 54 . The Hague : Mouton .
  • İnalcik , H. 1973 . The Ottoman Empire: The Classical Age 1300–1600 , London : Weidenfeld & Nicolson .
  • İnalcik , H. 1977 . “ ‘Centralisation and Decentralisation in Ottoman Administration’ ” . In Studies in Eighteenth Century Islamic History Edited by: Naff , T. and Owen , R. 27 – 52 . Carbondale
  • İnalcik , H. 1980a . “ ‘Ottoman Social and Economic History: A Review’ ” . In Türkiye'nin Sosyal ve Ekonomik Tarihi (1071–1920) (Social and Economic History of Turkey 1071–1920) , 1 – 8 . Ankara : Hacettepe Üniversitesi Yayinlari .
  • İnalcik , H. 1980b . ‘Military and Fiscal Transformation in the Ottoman Empire, 1600–1700’ . Archivum Ottomanicum , VI : 283 – 337 .
  • İslâmoğlu , H. and Keyder , C. 1977 . ‘Agenda for Ottoman History’ . Review , 1 ( 1 ) : 31 – 55 . Largely excerpted in Bailey and Llobera [1981]
  • Keyder , Ç. 1976 . ‘The Dissolution of the Asiatic Mode of Production’ . Economy and Society , 2 May
  • Keyder , Ç. 1981 . ‘Proto‐Endüstri Kayrami ve Çevre Ülkelerde Emperyalizmin Yol Açtiği Tahribat’ (The Concept of Proto‐Industrialisation and the Destruction caused by Imperialism in Peripheral Countries) . Toplum ve Bilim (Society and Science) , Spring : 93 – 106 .
  • Kiliçbay , M.À. 1982 . Feodalite ve Klasik Dönem Osmanli Üretim Tarzi (Feudalism and the Classical Ottoman Mode of Production) , Ankara : Gazi Üniversitesi Yayinlari .
  • Köprülü , F. Osmanli İmparatorluğunun Kurulusu (1981 reprint) İstanbul Otüken Neşriyat . originally presented as lectures at the Sorbonne . 1934 , Paris .
  • Küçükömer , I. 1977 . ‘Asyagil Üretim Biçimi, Yeniden Üretim ve Sivil Toplum’ (The Asiatic Mode of Production, Re‐production, and Civil Society) . Toplum ve Bilim (Society and Science) , Summer : 3 – 30 .
  • Marx , K. 1885/1967 . Capital , Vol.11 , New York : International Publishers .
  • Marx , K. 1894/1967 . Capital , Vol.III , New York : International Publishers .
  • McNeill , W. 1967 . A World History , New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Mukhia , H. 1981 . ‘Was There Feudalism in Indian History?’ . The Journal of Peasant Studies , 8 ( 3 ) : 273 – 310 .
  • Mukhia , H. 1985 . “ ‘Peasant Production and Medieval Indian Society’ ” . Edited by: Byres and Mukhia . 228 – 51 . [1985]
  • Oyan , O. 1983 . ‘1980’ ler Türkiyesi'nde Feodalizm Tartişmalari ve Bir Feodalizm Anlayişi’ (Feudalism Debates in Turkey of the 1980s and One Notion of Feudalism) . Yarin (Tomorrow) ,
  • Postan , M.M. 1961 . “ ‘Foreword’ ” . Edited by: Bloch . xi – xv . [1940/1966]
  • Perinçek , D. 1985 . ‘Kemalizm ve Devlet’ (Kemalism and the State) . Saçak , Dec.
  • Ste. Croix , G.E.M. de . 1981 . The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World , London : Duckworth .
  • Timur , T. 1979 . Kuruluş ve Yükseliş Döneminde Osmanli Toplumsal Düzeni (The Ottoman Social System in the Periods of its Foundation and Ascendancy) , Ankara : Siyasal Bilgiler Fakültesi Yayinlari .
  • Turan , O. 1950 . ‘İktâ’ . İslâm Ansiklopedisi , V ( 2 ) : 949 – 59 . (Encyclopaedia of Islam, Turkish version)
  • Turan , O. 1965 . Selçuklular Tarihi ve Türk‐İslâm Medeniyeti (Seljukid History and Turkish‐Islamic Civilisation) Istanbul
  • Turan , O. 1971 . Selçuklular Zamaninda Türkiye (Turkey in the Time of the Seljukids) , Istanbul : Turan Neşriyat Yurdu .
  • Verhulst , A. 1966 . ‘La genèse du régime dominial classique en France au haut moyen âge’ . Settimane di studio , XIII : 135 – 60 .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1981 . Early Medieval Italy : Government and Local Society, 400–1000 , London : Macmillan .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1984 . ‘The Other Transition: From the Ancient World to Feudalism” . Pastand Present , : 3 – 36 .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1985 . “ ‘The Uniqueness of the East’ ” . Edited by: Byres and Mukhia . 166 – 96 . [1985]
  • Wolf , E.R. 1966 . Peasants , New Jersey : Prentice‐Hall .
  • Postgraduate, School of History, University of Birmingham, PO Box 363, Birmingham B15 2TT, England; up to February 1983: lecturer in economic history, Faculty of Political Sciences, University of Ankara. Permanent address: Yazanlar Sok. 1112, Kavaklidere, Ankara, Turkey.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.