Advanced search
Publication Cover
The Journal of Peasant Studies Volume 17, 1989 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
166
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The feudalism debate once more: The case of Byzantium

John Haldon Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham, PO Box 363, Birmingham, B15 2TT, England
Pages 5-40 | Published online: 05 Feb 2008

Notes

References

  • Ahrweiler , H. 1960 . ‘Recherches sur l'administration byzantin aux IXe‐XIe siècles’ . Bulletin de Correspondance Hellénique , 84 : 1 – 109 . (repr. in Ahrweiler [1971], No.VIII).
  • Ahrweiler , H. 1971 . Études sur les structures administratives et sociales à Byzance , London : Variorum .
  • Ahrweiler , H. 1980 . “ ‘La Pronoia à Byzance’ ” . In Structures féodales et féodalisme dans l'Occident méditerranéen (X'‐XIH’ siècles), Bilan et perspectives de recherches Vol.44 , 681 – 9 . Rome (=Collection de l'Ecole française de Rome,
  • Albert , G. 1984 . Goten in Konstantinopel. Untersuchungen zur oströmischen Geschichte um das Jahr 400 n. Chr. , Paderborn‐Munich‐Vienna‐Zurich : Schöningh . (Studien zur Geschichte und Kultur des Altertums, N.F. 1)
  • Althusser , L. 1969 . For Marx , London : Penguin .
  • Althusser , L. and Balibar , E. 1970 . Reading Capital , London : Penguin .
  • Amin , S. 1976 . Unequal Development , Hassocks : Harvester .
  • Anderson , P. 1974 . Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism , London : NLB‐Verso .
  • Anderson . 1974/1979 . Lineages of the Absolutist State , London : NLB‐Verso .
  • Angold , M. 1984 . The Byzantine Empire, 1025–1204: A Political History , London : Longman .
  • Asad , T. 1987 . ‘Are There Histories of Peoples Without Europe?’ . Comparative Studies in Society and History , 29/3 : 594 – 607 .
  • Aubin , H. 1948 . ‘Vom Absterben antiken Lebens im Frühmittelalter’ . Antike und Abendland , 3 : 88 – 119 . (repr. in
  • Hübinger , P. , ed. 1968 . Kulturbruch oder Kultur kontinuität von der Antike zum Mittelalter 205 – 58 . Darmstadt
  • Berktay , H. 1987 . ‘The Feudalism Debate: The Turkish End ‐ is ‘Tax vs. Rent’ Necessarily the Product and Sign of a Modal Difference?’ . Journal of Peasant Studies , 14 ( 3 ) : 291 – 333 .
  • Bonnassie , P. 1980 . “ ‘Du Rhône à la Galice: genèse et modalités du régime féodale’ ” . In Structures féodales et féodalisme dans l'Occident méditerranéen (X'‐XIIIe siècles), Bilan et perspectives de recherches Vol.44 , 17 – 44 . Rome (= Collection de l'École française de Rome,
  • Bonnassie , P. 1985 . ‘Survie et extinction du régime esclavagiste dans l'Occident du haut moyen âge (IVe‐XIe siècle)’ . Cahiers de Civilisation Médiévale, X'‐X1Ie Siècles , 28 : 307 – 43 .
  • Bonte , P. 1977 . ‘Classes et parenté dans les sociétés segmentaires’ . Dialectiques , 21 : 103 – 15 .
  • Brandes , W. 1988 . ‘Die byzantinische Stadt Kleinasiens im 7. und 8. Jahrhundert ‐ ein Forschungsbericht’ . Klio , 70 : 176 – 208 .
  • Brandes , W. 1989 . Das byzantinische Städlewesen Kleinasiens , Berlin : Academy of Sciences of GDR .
  • Browning , R. 1958 . ‘Rabstvo v Vizantijskoj imperii (600–1200 gg.)’ (Slavery in the Byzantine Empire, 600–1200 A.D.) . Vizantijskij Vremennik , 14 : 38 – 55 .
  • Bukharin , N.I. 1921/1925 . Historical Materialism: A System of Sociology , Moscow : Progress .
  • Bury , J.B. 1958 . History of the Later Roman Empire from the Death of Theodosius I to the Death of Justinian , New York : Dover .
  • Carandini , A. 1979 . Uanatomía della scimmia Turin
  • Claude , D. 1969 . Die byzantinische Stadt im 6. Jahrhundert Vol.13 , Munich (Byzantinisches Archiv,
  • Cohen , G.A. 1978 . Karl Marx's Theory of History, A Defence , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Currie , K. 1984 . ‘The Asiatic Mode of Production: Problems of Conceptualising State and Economy’ . Dialectical Anthropology , 8
  • Dagron , G. 1969 . ‘Aux origines de la civilisation byzantine: langue de culture et langue d'état’ . Revue Historique , 241 : 23 – 56 . (repr. in Dagron, 1984, I).
  • Dagron , G. 1984 . La romanité chrétienne en Orient , London : Variorum .
  • de Ste Croix , G.E.M. 1981 . The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World , London : Duckworth .
  • Dennis , G.T. , ed. 1985 . The Anonymous Byzantine Treatise on Strategy, in Three Byzantine Military Treatises , 1 – 136 . Washington, DC : Dumbarton Oaks .
  • Dewing , H.B. , ed. 1914 . Procopius, History of the Wars , 7 vols , London/Cambridge, MA : Loeb .
  • Dölger , F. 1927/1960 . Beiträge zur Geschichte der byzantinischen Finanzverwaltung besonders des 10. und 11. Jahrhunderts Vol.9 , Munich/ Darmstadt (Byzantinisches Archiv,
  • Eibach , D. 1977 . Untersuchungen zum spätantiken Kolonat in der kaiserlichen Gesetz gebung unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Terminologie Cologne
  • Finley , M.I. 1973 . The Ancient Economy , London : Chatto & Windus .
  • Finley , M.I. 1980 . Ancient Slavery and Modern Ideology , London : Chatto & Windus .
  • Frančes , E. 1966 . ‘La ville byzantine et la monnaie aux VIIe‐VIIIe siècles’ . Byzantino‐ bulgarica , 2 : 3 – 14 .
  • Ganshof , F.L. 1975 . Le polyptyque de l'Abbaye de Saint‐Bertin (844–859). Edition critique et commentée Paris
  • Giardina , A. and Schiavone , A. , eds. 1981 . Società romana e produzione schiavistica , Rome/Bari : Laterza .
  • Giardina , A. , ed. 1986 . Società romana e impero tardoantico, III. Le merci. Gli insediamenti , Rome/Bari : Laterza .
  • Godelier , M. , ed. 1977 . Perspectives in Marxist Anthropology , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Gold , D. , Lo , C. and Wright , E.O. 1975 . ‘Recent Developments in Marxist Theories of the State’ . Monthly Review , 27 ( 5–6 )
  • Grohova , V. 1979 . ‘Mesto Vizanti v tipologii evropejskogo feodalizma’ (the place of Byzantium in the typology of European feudalism) . Vizantijskij Vremennik , 40 : 3 – 8 .
  • Haldon , J.F. 1984 . Byzantine Praetorians , Vol.3 , Bonn : Habelt . (Poikila Byzantina,
  • Haldon , J.F. 1985 . ‘Some Considerations on Byzantine Society and Economy in the Seventh Century’ . Byzantinische Forschungen , 10 : 75 – 112 .
  • Haldon , J.F. 1986 . ‘Ideology and Social Change in the Seventh Century: Military Discontent as a Barometer’ . Klio , 68 : 139 – 90 .
  • Haldon , J.F. 1988 . ‘A Touch of Class?’ . Rechlshistorisches Journal , 7 : 37 – 50 .
  • Haldon , J.F. 1990 . Byzantium c. 610–717. The Transformation of a Culture , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . (forthcoming),
  • Hendy , M.F. 1985 . Studies in the Byzantine Monetary Economy, 300–1450 , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Herrin , J. 1987 . The Formation of Christendom , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Hilton , R. 1952 . ‘Capitalism: What's in a Name?’ . Past and Present , : 32 – 43 .
  • Hilton , R. , ed. 1976/1978 . The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism , London : NLB .
  • Hindess , B. and Hirst , P.Q. 1975 . Pre‐Capitalist Modes of Production , London : Routledge .
  • Hirst , P.Q. 1975 . ‘The Uniqueness of the West’ . Economy and Society , 4/4 : 446 – 75 .
  • Hohlweg , A. 1967 . ‘Zur Frage der Pronoia in Byzanz’ . Byzantinische Zeitschrift , 60 : 288 – 308 .
  • Hopkins , K. 1978 . Conquerors and Slaves , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Hunger , H. 1965 . Reich der neuen Mitte: der christliche Geist der byzantinischen Kultur , Vienna/Graz/Cologne : Austrian Academy .
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1940 . The Greek City from Alexander to Justinian , Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1954 . ‘The Cities of the Roman Empire: Political, Administrative and Judicial Functions’ . Recueils de a Société Jean Bodin , 6 : 135 – 73 . (repr. in Jones, 1974: 1–34).
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1963 . “ ‘The Social Background of the Struggle between Paganism and Christianity’ ” . In The Conflict Between Paganism, and Christianity in the Fourth Century Edited by: Momigliano , A. 13 – 37 . Oxford
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1955 . ‘The Economic Life of the Towns of the Roman Empire’ . Recueils de la Société Jean Bodin , 7 : 161 – 92 . (repr. in Jones, 1974: 35–60).
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1964 . The Later Roman Empire , Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Jones , A.H.M. 1974 . The Roman Economy. Studies in Ancient Economic and Social History , Edited by: Brunt , P.A. Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Každan , A.P. 1956 . ‘K voprosu ob osobennostyakh feodalnoj sobstvennosti v Vizantii 8‐ 10 vv.’ (on the question of the specific form of feudal property in Byzantium, 8th‐10th centuries) . Vizantijskij Vremennik , 10 : 48 – 65 .
  • Každan , A.P. 1960 . Derevnija i gorod v Vizantii 9–10 w. (village and town in Byzantium in the ninth and tenth centuries) , Moscow : Academy of Sciences .
  • Každan , A.P. 1974 . Social'nyj sostav gospodstvujuščego klassa v Vizantii XI‐X1I vv. (the social structure of the Byzantine ruling class in the eleventh and twelfth centuries) , Moscow : Academy of Sciences .
  • Každan , A.P. 1968 . Vizantijskaja kul'tura (Byzantine Culture), Moscow (available in German translation as Byzanz und seine Kultúr , Berlin : Academy of Sciences . 1973
  • Khovostova , K.V. 1980 . Količestvennyj podhod k srednevokovoj social'no‐ekonomičeskoj istorii (the quantitative approach to medieval social‐economic history) , Moscow : Academy of Sciences .
  • Khvostova , K.V. 1984 . ‘K vopTosu o štruktúre pozdnevizantijskogo selskogo poselenija’ (concerning the structure of late Byzantine rural communities) . Vizantijskij Vremennik , 45 : 3 – 19 .
  • Kirsten , E. 1958 . “ ‘Die byzantinische Stadt ” . In Berichte zum XL Internalionalen Byzantinisten‐Kongress 10ff Munich
  • Kobiščanov , Ja.M. 1975 . “ ‘Tipy i sistemy feodalnikh obščestv’ (types and systems of feudal societies) ” . In Tipologija razvitogo feodalizma v stranakh Vostoka 40ff Moscow
  • Köpstein , H. 1965 . ‘Die byzantinische Sklaverei in der Historiographie der letzten 125 Jahre’ . Klio , 43–5 : 560 – 76 .
  • Köpstein , H. 1966 . Zur Sklaverei im ausgehenden Byzanz , Berlin : Academy of Sciences of GDR .
  • Krader , L. 1968 . The Formation of the State , Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice‐Hall .
  • Kurbatov , G.L. 1971 . Osnovnye problémy vnutrennogo razvitija vizantijskogo goroda v IV—VII vv. (the fundamental problems of the internal evolution of the Byzantine city in the 4th‐7th centuries) , University of Leningrad .
  • Kurbatov , G.L. and Lebedeva , G. Je. 1984 . Vizantija: problemy perekhoda ot antičnosti k feodalhmu (Byzantium: problems of the transition from Antiquity to Feudalism) , University of Leningrad .
  • Lattimore , O. 1957 . ‘Feudalism in History’ . Past and Present , : 47 – 57 .
  • Lebedeva , G.E. 1980 . Socialnaja struktura rannevizantijskogo obščestva (po dannym Kodeksov Feodosija i Justiniand) (the social structure of early Byzantine society [according to the Theodosian and Justinianic codes]) , University of Leningrad .
  • Lemerle , P. 1959 . ‘Recherches sur le régime agraire à Byzance: la terre militaire à lépoque des Comnénes’ . Cahiers de Civilisation Médiévale, Xe‐XIIe Siècles , 2 : 265 – 81 .
  • Lemerle , P. 1979 . The Agrarian History of Byzantium: from the Origins to the Twelfth Century , Galway : Galway University Press .
  • Litavrin , G.G. 1971 . ‘Otnositel'nye razmery isostav imuščestva provincialnoj vizantij‐ skoj aristokratii’ (the structure and extent of Byzantine provincial aristocratic properties) . Vízantijskie Očerki , : 152 – 68 .
  • Litavrin , G.G. 1977 . Vizantijskoe obščestvo i gosudarstvo v X‐XI w. Problemy istorii odnogo stoletija 976–1081 (Byzantine society and state in the 10th‐11th centuries. Problems in the history of a century 976–1081) , Moscow : Academy of Sciences .
  • Litavrin , G.G. 1978 . “ ‘Zur Lage der zyantinischen Bauernschaft im 10.‐11‐. Jahrhundert (strittige Fragen)’ ” . 47 – 70 . Vavrínek, 1978:
  • Lubarz , H. 1984 . ‘Marx’ Concept of the Asiatic Mode of Production: a Genetic Analysis’ . Economy and Society , 13 : 456 – 83 .
  • Marx , K. 1894/1974 . Capital , Vol.III , Moscow/London : Lawrence & Wishart .
  • Marx , K. 1964 . P re‐Capitalist Economic Formations , Edited by: Hobsbawm , E. London : Lawrence & Wishart .
  • Marx , K. 1972 . Theories of Surplus Value , Vol.III , Moscow : Progress .
  • Marx , K. 1970 . A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy , Edited by: Dobb , M. Moscow : Progress .
  • Marx , K. and Engels , F. 1935 . Selected Correspondence , Moscow/London : Progress .
  • Marx , K. and Engels , F. 1968 . Selected Works , Moscow/London : Lawrence & Wishart .
  • McLennan , G. 1986 . ‘Marxist Theory and Historical Research: Between the Hard and Soft Options’ . Science and Society , 50 ( 1 ) : 85 – 95 .
  • Meillassoux , C. 1979 . ‘Historical Modalities of the Exploitation and Over‐Exploitation of Labour’ . Critique of Anthropology , 13/14 : 7 – 16 .
  • Morris , R. 1976 . ‘The Powerful and the Poor in Tenth‐Century Byzantium: Law and Reality’ . Past and Present , : 3 – 27 .
  • Nadel , S.F. 1942 . A Black Byzantium , London : Oxford University Press .
  • Oikonomidès , N. 1966 . “ ‘The Donation of Castles in the Last Quarter of the Eleventh Century (Dölger, Regesten, No. 1012)’ ” . In Polychronion. Festschrift Franz Dölger zum 75. Geburtstag 413 – 17 . Heidelberg
  • Oikonomidès , N. 1976 . Documents et études sur les institutions de Byzance (VIIIe‐XVe siècles) London no.XIV
  • Oikonomidés , N. 1987 . ‘De limpôt de distribution à limpôt de quotité à propos du premier cadastre byzantin (7e—9” siècle)’ . Zborník Radova Vizantološkog Insitituta , 26 : 9 – 19 .
  • Ostrogorsky , G. 1954 . Pour lhistoire de la féodalité byzanline , Brussels : Institute of Oriental and Slav Philology and History .
  • Ostrogorsky , G. 1968 . A History of the Byzantine State , Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Ostrogorsky , G. 1970 . ‘Die Pronoia unter den Komncnen’ . Zborník Radová Vizantoloi‐ kog Instituta , 12 : 41 – 54 .
  • Ostrogorsky , G. 1971 . ‘Observations on the Aristocracy in Byzantium’ . Dumbarton Oaks Papers , 25 : 1 – 32 .
  • Patlagean , E. 1975 . ‘"Economie paysanne” et “féodalité byzantine'” . Annales E.S.C. , 30 : 1371 – 96 .
  • Patlagean , E. 1977 . Pauvreté économique et pauvreté sociale á Byzance, 4e—7e siècle , Paris : Mouton .
  • Patterson , O. 1979 . ‘On Slavery and Slave Formations’ . New Left Review , : 31 – 67 .
  • Plekhanov , G.V. 1956 . The Development of the Monist View of History , Moscow : Progress .
  • Poly , J.‐P. 1980 . “ ‘Régime domanial et rapports de production “féodalistes” dans le Midi de la France’ ” . In Structures féodales et féodalisme dans l'Occident Méditerranéen (Xe— XIII’ siècles), Bilan et perspectives de recherches Vol.44 , 57 – 84 . Rome (Collection de l'École française de Rome,
  • Poulantzas , N. 1975/1978 . Political Power and Social Classes , London : NLB/Verso .
  • Rathbone , D. 1983 . review of Giardina, Schiavone, 1981 . Journal of Roman Studies , 73 : 160 – 68 .
  • Rey , P.‐Ph. 1979 . ‘Class Contradiction in Lineage Societies’ . Critique of Anthropology , 13/14 : 41 – 60 .
  • Sjuzjumov , M. Ja. 1973a . ‘Suverenitet, nalog i zemelnaja renta v Vizantii’ (sovereignty, tax and feudal rent in Byzantium) . Antičnaja Drevnosti Srednie Veka , 9 : 57 – 65 .
  • Sjuzjumov , M. Ja. 1973b . ‘Nekotorye problemy istoriceskogo razvitija Vizantii i Zapada’ (some questions on the historical development of Byzantium and the West) . Vizantijskij Vremennik , 35 : 3 – 18 .
  • Sjuzjumov , M. Ja. 1976 . ‘Problemy asinkhronogo razvitija v Drevnosti’ (problems of asynchronic development in Antiquity) . Antičnaja Drevnosti Srednie Veka , 13 : 30 – 48 .
  • Skalník , P. and Claessen , H.J.M. , eds. 1979 . The Early State , The Hague : Mouton .
  • Skalník , P. and Claessen , H.J.M. , eds. 1981 . The Study of the State , The Hague : Mouton .
  • Southall , A. 1988 . ‘The Segmentary State in Africa and Asia’ . Comparative Studies in Society and History , 30 : 52 – 82 .
  • Štajermann , Je.M. 1975 . Krizis antičnoj Kultury (the crisis of ancient civilisation) , Moscow : Academy of Sciences .
  • Stein , E. 1959/1968 . Histoire du Bas‐Empire I: de létat romain ä létat byzantin (284–476) , Paris/Bruges/Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Stein , E. 1949/1968 . Histoire du Bas‐Empire, H: de la disparition de l empire d Occident ä la mort de Justinien (476‐S65) , Paris/Bruges/Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Stratos , A.N. 1968 . Byzantium in the Seventh Century, I: 602–634 , Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Stratos , A.N. 1972 . Byzantium in the Seventh Century, II: 634–641 , Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Stratos , A.N. 1975 . Byzantium in the Seventh Century, III: 642–668 , Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Terray , E. 1969 . Le marxisme devant les sociétés primitives , Paris : Maspero .
  • Tinnefeld , F. 1977 . Die frühbyzantinische Gesellschqft. Štruktur ‐ Gegensätze ‐ Spannungen , Munich : Wilhelm Finke .
  • Udal'cova , Z.V. 1971 . ‘K voprosu o genezise feodalizma v Vizantii (postanovka problemy)’ (on the question of the genesis of Feudalism in Byuzantium [definition of the problem]) . Vizantijskie Očerki , : 3 – 25 .
  • Udal'cova , Z.V. 1978 . “ ‘Nekotorye osobennosti feodalizma v Vizantii’ (some peculiarities of feudalism in Byzantium) ” . 5 – 30 . in Vavrínek, 1978:
  • Udal'cova , Z.V. and Osipova , K.A. 1985 . “ ‘Formirovanie feodalnogo krestjanstva v Vizantii (VII‐XI vv.)’ (the formation of the feudal peasantry in Byzantium, 7th‐11th centuries) ” . In Istorija krestjanstva v Evrope. Epokha feodalizma, I: Formirovanie feodalno‐zavsimogo krestjanstva (history of the peasantry in Europe. The feudal epoch, I: the formation of a dependent feudal peasantry) 428 – 61 . Leningrad
  • Vavrínek , V. , ed. 1978 . Beiträge zur byzantinischen Geschichte im 9.—11. Jahrhundert , Prague : Czech Academy of Sciences .
  • Verhulst , A. 1966 . “ ‘La genèse du régime domaniale classique en France au haut moyen age’ ” . In Agricoltura e mondo rurale in Occidente nellalto Medioevo (Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull'alto Medioevo, XIII) 135 – 60 . Spoleto
  • Verhulst , A. 1983 . “ ‘La diversité du régime domaniale entre Loire et Rhin ä lépoque carolingienne’ ” . In Villa‐Curtis‐Grangia: Économie rurale entre Loire et Rhin de lépoque gallo‐romaine au XIIe—XIIIe siècle Edited by: Janssen , W. and Lohrmann , D. 133 – 48 . Munich
  • Verlinden , Ch. 1977 . “ ‘Le “mariage” des esclaves’ ” . In Il matrimonio nella società alto‐ medievale (Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull'alto Medioevo, XXIV) 569 – 93 . Spoleto
  • Vryonis , Sp. 1959 . ‘Byzantium: The Social Basis of Decline in the Eleventh Century’ . Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies , 2 : 159 – 75 .
  • Vryonis , Sp. jr. 1971 . Byzantium: its internal History and Relations with the Muslim World London No.II)
  • Vryonis , Sp. 1971 . The Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor and the Process of Islamization from the Eleventh through the Fifteenth Century , Berkeley/Los Angeles CA/London : University of California Press .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1984 . ‘The Other Transition: From the Ancient World to Feudalism’ . Past and Present , : 3 – 36 .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1985 . ‘The Uniqueness of the East’ . Journal of Peasant Studies , 12 : 166 – 96 .
  • Wickham , C.J. 1988 . review of Giardina, 1986 . Journal of Roman Studies , 78 : 188 – 92 .
  • Winkelmann , F. 1987 . Byzantinische Rang‐ und Ämterstruktur im 8. und 9. Jahrhundert , Berlin : Academy of Sciences of GDR .
  • Wood , E. 1981 . ‘Marxism and Ancient Greece’ . History Workshop Journal , : 3 – 22 .
  • Wright , E.O. 1978 . Class, Crisis and the State , London : NLB .
  • Zepos , J. and P. 1931/1962 . Jus Graecoromanum , Athens/Amsterdam : Hakkert .
  • Centre for Byzantine, Ottoman and Modern Greek Studies, University of Birmingham, PO Box 363, Birmingham B15 2TT, England. The author is particularly grateful to Rodney Hilton and Chris Wickham for reading and commenting on an earlier draft of this article.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.