82
Views
2
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Miscellany

Confederation rejected: The British debate on Canada, 1837–1840

Pages 33-57 | Published online: 01 Jul 2008

Notes

  • 1839 . Parliamentary Papers , xxxiii : 59 – 60 .
  • Burroughs , P. 1972 . The Canadian Crisis and British Colonial Policy, 1828–1841 London
  • Craig , G. M. 1963 . Upper Canada: the Formative Years 1784–1841 Toronto
  • Ward , J. M. 1976 . Colonial Self‐Government 38 – 81 . London
  • Manning , H. T. 1962 . The Revolt of French Canada, 1800–1835 Toronto
  • Ouellet , F. 1979 . Lower Canada, 1791–1840: social change and nationalism Edited by: Claxton , P. Toronto
  • Martin , Ged . 1972 . The Durham Report and British Policy Cambridge
  • Martin , G. W. 1972 . “ ‘Britain and the Future of British North America, 1837–1867’ ” . Cambridge Ph.D. thesis
  • Lucas , C. P. , ed. 1912 . “ ‘The maintenance of an absolute form of government on any part of the North American Continent, can never continue for any long time, without exciting a general feeling in the United States against a power of which the existence is secured by means so odious to the people’ ” . In Lord Durham's Report on the Affairs of British North America 3 vols , 297 Oxford ii
  • Davenport , T. R. H. 1969 . “ ‘The Consolidation of a New Society: the Cape Colony’ ” . In The Oxford History of South Africa: I, South Africa to 1870 Edited by: Wilson , M. and Thompson , L. 317 – 20 . Oxford
  • Lucas , ed. Lord Durham's Report Vol. ii , 308
  • Ormsby , W. G. 1969 . The Emergence of the Federal Concept in Canada 1839–1845 3 – 5 . Toronto
  • Sturgis , James . 1979 . ‘Anglicisation as a Theory in Lower‐Canadian History 1807–1843’ . Bulletin of Canadian Studies , 3 : 29 – 53 .
  • Goldring , Philip . 1980 . ‘Province and Nation: Problems of Imperial Rule in Lower Canada 1820 to 1841’ . Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History , 9 : 45
  • Kriegel , A. D. , ed. 1977 . The Holland House Diaries. 1831–1841 290 London
  • Marindin , G. E. , ed. 1896 . Letters of Frederic Lord Blachford 233 – 4 . London
  • 1979 . ‘Two Cheers for Lord Glenelg’ . Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History , 7 : 213 – 27 .
  • Upton , L. F. S. 1968 . “ ‘The Idea of Confederation: 1754–1858’ ” . In The Shield of Achilles Edited by: Morton , W. L. 184 – 207 . Toronto
  • Trotter , R. G. 1924 . Canadian Federation; Its Origins and Achievement: a Study in Nation Building Toronto
  • Brymner , D. 1885 . Report on Canadian Archives for 1884 xxvii – lix . Ottawa
  • Upton , L. F. S. 1969 . The Loyal Whig: William Smith of New York and Quebec 202 – 5 . Toronto
  • Harvey , D. C. 1936 . ‘Uniacke's Memorandum to Windham, 1806’ . Canadian Historical Review , 17 : 41 – 58 .
  • 1923 . Report on the Manuscripts of Earl Bathurst , Historical Manuscripts Commission, no. 76 460 – 1 . London
  • Martin , K. L. P. 1924 . ‘The Union Bill of 1822’ . Canadian Historical Review , 5 : 42 – 54 .
  • Ormsby , W. 1958 . ‘The Problem of Canadian Union’ . 39 : 277 – 95 . ibid.
  • Strachan and Robinson . 1824 . Observations on the Policy of a General Union of all the British Provinces in North America London
  • 1826 . Considerations of the Claims and Conduct of the United States Respecting their North‐Eastern Boundary, and of the Value of the British Colonies in North America London
  • Spragge , G. W. 1942 . ‘John Strachan's Connexion with Early Proposals for Confederation’ . Canadian Historical Review , 23 : 363 – 73 .
  • Gourlay , Robert . 1822 . General Introduction to Statistical Account of Upper Canada cccxxxiii – cccl . London
  • Robinson , C. W. 1904 . Life of Sir John Beverley Robinson 152 – 4 . Edinburgh
  • Trotter , R. G. 1925 . ‘An Early Proposal for the Federation of British North America’ . Canadian Historical Review , 6 : 149 – 50 .
  • Gourlay . General Introduction , cccxxxviii – cccl .
  • Loyal Whig , 204 – 5 .
  • Gourlay , R. 1826 . An Appeal to the Common Sense, Mind and Manhood of the British Nation 149 – 50 . London
  • Upton . ‘Idea of Confederation’ . 190
  • 1837 . Parliamentary Papers. , xxiv : 93
  • Manning , H. T. 1965 . ‘Who Ran the British Empire?’ . Journal of British Studies , 5 Nov. : 100
  • 1837 . Parliamentary Papers , xxiv : 93
  • Head , F. B. 1839 . A Narrative , 3rd ed. 121 – 37 . London
  • 1837 . Parliamentary Papers , xxiv 17 Nov. : 246 – 48 . 1836
  • 1837 . Parliamentary Papers , xlii : 1 – 4 . 0.42
  • 6 March 1837 . Hansard's Parliamentary Debates , 3rd series Vol. xxxvi , 6 March , (cited as 3PD)
  • MacNutt , W. S. 1965 . The Atlantic Provinces: the Emergence of Colonial Society, 1712–1857 200 – 1 . London
  • 1838 . Examiner , 9 Dec. : 777
  • Flint , J. E. and Williams , G. , eds. 1973 . Perspectives of Empire 54 – 92 . London
  • 1837 . Sun , 18 Dec.
  • 1838 . Examiner , 21 Jan. : 32 – 3 .
  • 1838 . Spectator , 3 Feb. : 97 – 8 .
  • 1838 . Eclectic Review , Jan. : 235 – 8 . n.s. iii
  • 1838 . The Canadian Crisis and Lord Durham's Mission 42 – 8 . London
  • 1838 . The Times , 11 Jan.
  • 1838 . Hints on the Case of Canada 28 London
  • 1839 . 3PD , xlvii 3 June
  • Brougham and Kriegel , eds. “ ‘Lower Canadians’ replaces the deleted ‘french’ ” . 375 – 6 . For Roebuck's relations with
  • Broughton , Lord . Jan. 1909–11 . Recollections of a Long Life 6 vols , Jan. , London v, 116(18, 1838
  • Burroughs , Both . Canadian Crisis , 97
  • Martin . Durham Report and British Policy , 11 – 15 .
  • Morley , J. 1903 . Life of William Ewart Gladstone 3 vols , 641 – 2 . London i
  • Roebuck , J. A. 1849 . The Colonies of England 191 – 220 . London
  • Sanderson , C. R. , ed. 1957–59 . The Arthur Papers 3 vols , 245 – 51 . Toronto i
  • Reid , S. J. , ed. 1906 . Life and Letters of the First Earl of Durham. 1792–1840 2 vols , 222 – 6 . London ii
  • Sanders , L. C. , ed. 1889 . Lord Melbourne's Papers 432 – 3 . London
  • Doughty , A. G. , ed. 1924 . Report of the Public Archives for the year 1923 326 – 8 . Ottawa
  • Martell , J. S. 1938 . ‘Some Editorial Opinions from the Newspapers of the Maritime Provinces in the 1830s’ . Canadian Historical Review. , 19 : 50 – 6 .
  • Harvey , D. C. 1939 . ‘Nova Scotia and the Durham Mission’ . 20 : 161 – 77 . 165 – 71 . ibid.
  • Globe. , 8 10 Oct.
  • Spectator , 20 Oct. : 988 – 89 .
  • 1838 . Morning Chronicle. , 17 Oct.
  • 1838 . The Times. , 18 Oct.
  • Long , D. E. T. 1942 . ‘The Elusive Mr Ellice’ . Canadian Historical Review , 23 : 42 – 57 .
  • Colthart , J. M. ‘Edward Ellice and the Decision for Self‐Government, 1839’ . Canadian Historical Association Annual Papers, 1975 , 113 – 33 .
  • Martin . Durham Report and British Policy , 44 – 9 .
  • Sanders , ed. Lord Melbourne's Papers 441 – 2 . 444
  • Ormsby , W. , ed. 1964 . Crisis in the Canadas: 1838–39. The Grey Journals and Letters 190 – 2 . 198 – 201 . Toronto
  • Goldring , P. 1978 . “ ‘British Colonists and Imperial Interests in Lower Canada 1820 to 1841’ ” . 276 338 University of London . Ph.D. thesis
  • Russell and Thomson . 1839 . Parliamentary Papers, 1840 , xxxi ( 1 ) 7 Sept. : 7 – 12 .
  • 1847 . Edinburgh Review , 85 : 390 – 1 .
  • Haliburton , T. C. 1839 . A Reply to the Report of the Earl of Durham. By a Colonist 30 – 1 . London
  • Bliss , H. 1839 . An Essay on the Re‐Constitution of Her Majesty's Government in Canada 19 – 30 . 50 – 5 . 97 – 101 . 104 – 5 . London
  • Martin . ‘Britain and the future of British North America’ . 130 – 4 .
  • Doughty , A. G. Report of the Public Archives for 1923 338 – 40 .
  • Kerr , D. G. G. and Gibson , J. A. 1954 . Sir Edmund Head: a scholarly governor 41 Toronto
  • 1849 . The colonies of England: a plan for the government of some portion of our colonial possessions London
  • Martin . ‘Britain and the future of British North America’ . 156 – 65 .
  • 1847 . Edinburgh Review , 85 : 397
  • Doughty , A. G. , ed. 1937 . The Elgin‐Grey Papers 4 vols , 437 – 8 . Ottawa i
  • Browne , G. P. , ed. 1969 . Documents on the Confederation of British North America 30 – 1 . 51 – 2 . Toronto
  • Knox , Bruce A. 1976 . ‘The British Government, Sir Edmund Head, and British North American Confederation, 1858’ . Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History , 4 : 212 – 15 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.