24
Views
20
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The psychological burden of proof: On the evolutionary development of Richard Whately's theory of presumption

Pages 115-129 | Published online: 02 Jun 2009

  • Fadely , L. Dean . 1967 . “The Validity of the Comparative Advantages Case,” . Journal of the American Forensic Association , 4 : 29 – 30 .
  • Dick , Robert C. 1972 . Argumentation and Rational Debating , 6 10 Dubuque : Wm. C. Brown .
  • Ehninger , Douglas and Brockriede , Wayne . 1963 . Decision by Debate , 84 97 New York : Dodd, Mead and Co. .
  • Eisenberg , Abne M. and Ilardo , Joseph A. 1972 . Argument: An Alternative to Violence , 26 Englewood Cliffs, N. J. : Prentice‐Hall .
  • Mills , Glen E. 1968 . Reason in Controversy: On General Argumentation, , 2nd ed. , 50 – 53 . Boston : Allyn and Bacon .
  • McBurney , James H. , O'Neill , James M. and Mills , Glen E. 1951 . Argumentation and Debate: Techniques of a Free Society , 13 – 14 . New York : MacMillan .
  • Thompson , Wayne . 1971 . Modern Argumentation and Debate: Principles and Practices , 45 New York : Harper and Row .
  • Rieke , Richard D. and Sillars , Malcolm O. 1975 . Argumentation and the Decision Making Process , 55 New York : Wiley .
  • Parrish , Wayland Maxfield . 1929 . “Whately and His Rhetoric,” . QJS , 15 : 58 – 79 .
  • Pence , Orville L. 1953 . “The Concept and Function of Logical Proof in the Rhetorical System of Richard Whately,” . SM , 20 : 23 – 38 .
  • Edney , Clarence W. 1954 . “Richard Whately on Disposito,” . SM , 21 : 227 – 34 .
  • Anderson , Floyd Douglas and Hayes , Merwyn . 1967 . “Presumption and Burden of Proof in Whately's Speech on the Jewish Civil Disabilities Repeal Bill,” . SM , 34 : 133 – 36 .
  • Sillars , Malcolm O. 1973 . “Audiences, Social Values, and the Analysis of Argument,” . ST , 22 : 297
  • Cronkhite , Gary . 1966 . “The Locus of Presumption,” . Central States Speech Journal , 17 : 270 – 76 .
  • Ehninger , Douglas . 1949 . “Selected Theories of Inventio in English Rhetoric, 1759–1828” . 350 – 53 . Ohio State Diss.
  • Gronbeck , Bruce E. 1966 . “Archbishop Richard Whately's Doctrine of ‘Presumption’ and ‘Burden of Proof: An Historical‐Critical Analysis,” . 6 – 29 . 103 – 06 . Iowa Thesis
  • Whately , Richard . 1828 . Elements of Rhetoric , Oxford : W. Baxter for John Murray and J. Parker .
  • Whately , Richard . 1828 . Elements of Rhetoric, , 2nd ed. , Oxford : W. Baxter for John Murray and J. Parker .
  • Ehninger , Douglas . 1963 . “Editor's Introduction,” . In Elements of Rhetoric by Richard Whately , Edited by: Ehninger , Douglas . xvii Carbondale : Southern Illinois Univ. Press .
  • Ehninger . “Editor's Introduction,” . xvii
  • Richard . 1830 . Whately, Elements of Rhetoric, , 3rd ed. , 97 – 105 . Oxford : W. Baxter for John Murray and J. Parker .
  • Whately , Richard . 1832 . Elements of Rhetoric, , 4th ed. , Oxford : W. Baxter for John Murray and J. Parker .
  • Whately , Richard . 1836 . Elements of Rhetoric, , 5th ed. , 112 – 13 . 114 – 18 . London : B. Fellows .
  • Whately , Richard . 1841 . Elements of Rhetoric, , 6th ed. , 129 – 32 . London : B. Fellows .
  • Whately , Richard . 1846 . Elements of Rhetoric, , 7th ed. , London : John W. Parker .
  • Hawkins , Edwrd . 1819 . A Dissertation Upon the Use and Importance of Unauthoritative Tradition, as an Introduction to the Christian Doctrines; Including the Substance of a Sermon, Preached before the University of Oxford, May 13, 1818, upon 2 Thess. ii. 15 , Oxford : W. Baxter for j. Parker and F. C. and J. Riving‐ton .
  • Whately . 1846 . Elements 130
  • Hawkins , Edward . 1842 . The Apostolical Succession: A Sermon Preached in the Chapel of Lambeth Palace, On Sunday February 27, 1842, At the Consecration of the Right Rev. Ashurst Turner, Lord Bishop of Chichester, , 2nd ed. , 16 22 London : B. Fellows .
  • 1854 . The Duty of Private Judgment: A Sermon Preached Before the University of Oxford, Nov. 11, 1838, , 3rd ed. , 11 – 15 . Oxford : John Henry Parker .
  • 1863 . The Liberty of Private Judgment Within the Church of England: A Sermon Preached Before the University of Oxford, February 1st, 1863 , 24 Oxford : John Henry and James Parker .
  • 1877 . Additional Notes on Church and State , 31 – 32 . Oxford and London : James Parker and Co. .
  • Hawkins . Dissertation on Tradition 83
  • Bate , W. J. and Strauss , Albrecht B. , eds. 1969 . The Yale Edition of the Works of Samuel Johnson , Rambler No. 95 Vol. IV , 143 – 48 . New Haven : Yale Univ. . Tuesday 12 February 1751
  • Hawkins . Dissertation on Tradition 83
  • Ehninger . “Editor's Introduction,” . xix
  • Biddle , Phillips R. 1963 . “Presumption and Burden of Proof in Selected Twentieth Century Textbooks on Argumentation” . 10 – 17 . Illinois Thesis
  • McKerrow , Ray E. 1974 . “Whately's Theory of Rhetoric” . 246 – 52 . Iowa Diss.
  • Ehninger . “Selected Theories,” . 353
  • Knoll , P. X. 1932 . “Presumption in the Introduction to the Argumentative Speech,” . QJS , 18 : 637 – 42 .
  • Maxcy , Melissa . 1974 . “The Implications of New Ideas About Presumption,” . paper presented at the Southern Speech Communication Association Convention . April 1974 . pp. 3
  • Henderson , Bill . 1974 . “Debate as a Paradigm for Demonstrating Truth Through Hypothesis Testing,” . paper presented at the SCA Convention . December 1974 . pp. 7 – 9 .
  • Robinson , James L. 1960 . “Are We ‘Over‐legalizing’ School Debate?” . ST , 9 : 109 – 15 .
  • 1974 . “Finding a Friendly Jury,” . Newsweek , 26 August : 49 – 50 .
  • Brooks , William D. 1971 . “Judging Bias in Intercollegiate Debate,” . Journal of the American Forensic Association , 7 : 197 – 200 .
  • Hill , Sidney Jr. 1975 . “Prestige as a Factor Influencing the Validity of Decisions in Intercollegiate Debate,” . Southern Speech Communication Journal , 40 : 351 – 64 .
  • Ehninger . “Editor's Introduction,” . xiv
  • Ehninger , Douglas . 1955 . “Campbell, Blair, and Whately: Old Friends in a New Light,” . Western Speech , 19 : 267
  • 1963 . “Campbell, Blair, and Whately Revisited,” . Southern Speech Journal , 28 : 179
  • Leathers , Dale G. 1969 . “Whately's Logically Derived ‘Rhetoric’: A Stranger in Its Time,” . Western Speech , 33 : 49 – 54 .
  • Whately . Elements 4
  • Ehninger , Douglas . 1954 . “Whately on Dispositio,” . QJS , 40 : 439 – 41 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.