838
Views
29
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The development of caregiving: A comparison of attachment theory and psychoanalytic approaches to mothering

&
Pages 618-646 | Published online: 20 Oct 2009

References

  • Aber , L. , Slade , A. , Cohen , L. and Meyer , J. Parental representations of their toddlers: Their relationship to parental history and sensitivity and toddler security . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development . Kansas City, MO.
  • Ainsworth , M. D. S. 1989 . Attachments beyond infancy . Amer. Psychol. , 44 : 709 – 716 .
  • _____ , Blehar , M. C. , Waters , E. and Wall , S. 1978 . Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of the Strange Situation , Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • _____ and Eichberg , C. 1991 . “ Effects on infant‐mother attachment of mother's unresolved loss of an attachment figure, or other traumatic experience ” . In Attachment Across the Life Cycle , Edited by: Parkes , C. M. , Stevenson‐Hinde , J. and Marris , P. 160 – 186 . New York : Routledge .
  • Ammaniti , M. 1994 . “ Maternal representations during pregnancy and early infant‐mother interaction ” . In Psychoanalysis and Development: Representations and Narratives , Edited by: Ammaniti , M. and Stern , D. S. 79 – 96 . New York : New York University Press .
  • _____ and Stern , D. 1992 . Attachment and Psychoanalysis , Rome : Gius, Laterza, & Figli .
  • Anthony , E. J. and Benedek , T. 1970 . “ Parenthood ” . In Psychology and Psychopathol‐ogy , Boston : Little, Brown .
  • Belsky , J. , Campbell , S. , Conn , J. and Moore , J. 1996 . Instability of attachment security . Dev. Psyc. , 32 : 921 – 924 .
  • Belsky , J. 1999 . “ Patterns of attachment in a modern evolutionary perspective ” . In Handbook of Attachment Theory and Research , Edited by: Cassidy , J. and Shaver , P. 141 – 161 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • _____ , Rosenberger , K. and Crnic , K. 1995 . “ The origins of attachment security: “Classical” and contextual determinants ” . In Attachment Theory: Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Goldberg , S. , Muir , R. and Kerr , J. 153 – 184 . Hillsdale, NJ : The Analytic Press .
  • Benedek , T. 1959 . Parenthood as a developmental phase: A contribution to the libido theory . J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn. , 7 : 389 – 417 .
  • Benoit , D. and Parker , K. 1994 . Stability and transmission of attachment across three generations . Child Dev. , 65 : 1444 – 1456 .
  • Bibring , G. , Dwyer , T. , Huntington , D. and Valenstein , A. 1961 . A study of the psychological processes in pregnancy and of the earliest mother‐child relationship . The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child , 16 : 9 – 24 . New York: International Universities Press
  • Blatt , S. J. and Blass , R. B. 1994 . “ Relatedness and self‐definition: A dialectic model of personality development ” . In Development and Vulnerability in Relationships , Edited by: Noam , G. G. and Fischer , K. 309 – 338 . Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Bowlby , J. 1969 . Attachment and Loss. Vol. 1: Attachment , Vol. 1 , New York : Basic Books . 1982
  • _____ . 1973 . Attachment and Loss. Volume 2: Separation , Volume 2 , New York : Basic Books .
  • _____ . 1980 . Attachment and Loss. Volume 3: Loss , Volume 3 , New York : Basic Books .
  • _____ . 1984 . “ Caring for the young: Influences on development ” . In Parenthood: A Psychodynamic Perspective , Edited by: Cohen , R. S. , Cohler , B. J. and Weissman , S. H. 269 – 284 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Bretherton , I. 1985 . “ Attachment theory: Retrospect and prospect ” . In Growing Points in Attachment Theory and Research , Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development Edited by: Bretherton , I. and Waters , E. Vol. 50 , 3 – 35 .
  • _____ , Biringen , Z. , Ridgeway , D. , Maslin , D. and Sherman , M. 1989 . Attachment: The parental perspective . Infant Mental tilth. J. , 10 : 203 – 221 .
  • Bus , A. G. and van IJzendoorn , M. H. 1992 . Patterns of attachment in frequently and infrequently reading mother‐child dyads . J. Genetic Psychol. , 153 : 395 – 403 .
  • Carlson , E. A. 1998 . A prospective longitudinal study of disorganized/disoriented attachment . Child Devel. , 69 : 1107 – 1128 .
  • Cassidy , J. 1994 . “ Emotion regulation: Influences of attachment relationships ” . In The Development of Emotion Regulation: Biological and Behavioral Considerations , Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development Edited by: Fox , N. A. Vol. 59 , 228 – 249 .
  • _____ and Kobak , T. 1988 . “ Avoidance and its relation to other defensive processes ” . In Clinical Implications of Attachment , Edited by: Belsky , J. and Nezworski , T. 300 – 326 . Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Cicchetti , D. and Carlson , V. 1989 . Handbook of Child Maltreatment: Clinical and Theoretical Perspectives , New York : Cambridge University Press .
  • Cohen , R. S. , Cohler , B. J. and Weissman , S. H. 1984 . Parenthood: A Psychodynamic Approach , New York : Guilford Press .
  • Cole , M. and Cole , S. R. 1996 . The Development of Children , New York : Freeman .
  • Cowan , C. , Cowan , P. , Heming , G. and Miller , N. 1991 . “ Becoming a family: Marriage, parenting and child development ” . In Family Transitions , Edited by: Cowan , P. and Hetherington , M. Vol. 2 , 79 – 108 . Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Cowan , P. 1991 . “ Individual and family life transitions: A proposal for a new definition ” . In Family Transitions , Edited by: Cowan , P. and Hetherington , M. Vol. 2 , 3 – 30 . Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Crittenden , P. M. 1995 . “ Attachment and psychopathology ” . In Attachment Theory: Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Goldberg , S. , Muir , R. and Kerr , J. 367 – 406 . Hillsdale, NJ : The Analytic Press .
  • de Wolff , M. and van Uzendoorn , M. H. 1997 . Sensitivity and attachment: A meta‐analysis on parental antecedents of infant attachment . Child Dev. , 68 : 571 – 591 .
  • Deutscher , M. 1971 . “ First pregnancy and family formation ” . In Psychoanalytic Contributions to Community Psychology , Edited by: Milmen , D. and Goldman , G. 233 – 255 . Springfield, IL : Charles C. Thomas .
  • Diamond , D. and Blatt , S. J. 1994 . “ Internal working models of the representational world in attachment and psychoanalytic theories ” . In Attachment in Adults: Clinical and Developmental Perspectives , Edited by: Sperling , M. B. and Berman , W. H. 72 – 97 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • _____ , Heinicke , C. and Mintz , J. 1996 . Separation‐individual as a family transac‐tional process in the transition to parenthood . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 24 – 42 .
  • Eagle , M. 1995 . “ The developmental perspectives of attachment and psychoanalytic theory ” . In Attachment theory: Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Goldberg , S. , Muir , R. and Kerr , J. 123 – 152 . Hillsdale, NJ : The Analytic Press .
  • Elson , M. 1984 . “ Parenthood and the transformation of narcissism ” . In Parenthood: A Psychodynamic Perspective , Edited by: Cohen , R. S. , Cohler , B. J. and Weissman , S. H. 297 – 324 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Emde , R. N. 1994 . Developing psychoanalytic representations of experience . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 14 : 42 – 49 .
  • _____ , Gaensbauer , T. J. and Harmon , R. J. 1976 . Emotional expression in infancy: A behavioral study , Psychological Issues Monograph Series Vol. 10 , (l, Serial No. 37)
  • Fairbairn , W. R. D. 1952 . An Object Relations Theory of Personality , New York : Basic Books .
  • Fischer , K. W. , Kenny , S. L. and Pipp , S. L. 1990 . “ How cognitive processes and environmental conditions organize discontinuities in the development of abstractions ” . In Higher Stages of Human Development: Perspectives on Adult Growth , Edited by: Alexander , C. and Langer , E. 162 – 187 . New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Fleming , A. S. , Corter , C. and Steiner , M. 1995 . “ Sensory and hormonal control of maternal behavior in rat and human mothers ” . In Motherhood in Human and Nonhuman Primates , Edited by: Pryce , C. R. , Martin , R. D. and Skuse , D. 106 – 114 . Basel : Karger .
  • Fonagy , P. 1994 . Mental representations from an intergenerational cognitive science perspective . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 15 : 37 – 68 .
  • _____ , Steele , H. and Steele , M. 1991 . Maternal representations of attachment during pregnancy predict organization of infant‐mother attachment at one year of age . Child Dev. , 62 : 891 – 905 .
  • _____ , Steele , M. , Steele , H. , Leigh , T. , Kennedy , R. , Mattoon , G. and Target , M. 1995 . “ Attachment, the reflective self, and borderline states: The predictive specificity of the Adult Attachment Interview and pathological emotional development ” . In Attachment Theory: Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Goldberg , S. , Muir , R. and Kerr , J. 233 – 278 . Hillsdale, NJ : The Analytic Press .
  • Fraiberg , S. 1980 . Clinical studies in infant mental health: The first year of life , New York : Basic Books .
  • George , C. , Kaplan , N. and Main , M. 1984/1985/1996 . Adult attachment interview , Berkeley : University of California . Unpublished interview
  • _____ and Solomon , J. 1989 . Internal working models of caregiving and security of attachment at age six . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 10 : 222 – 237 .
  • _____ and _____ . 1996 . Representational models of relationships: Links between caregiving and attachment . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 198 – 216 .
  • _____ and _____ . 1999 . “ Attachment and caregiving: The caregiving behavioral system ” . In Handbook of Attachment , Edited by: Cassidy , J. and Shaver , P. 649 – 670 . New York : Guilford .
  • _____ and West , M. in press . Developmental vs. social personality models of adult attachment and mental health . Brit. J. Med. Psychol. ,
  • Greenberg , M. T. , Cicchetti , D. and Cummings , E. M. 1990 . Attachment in the Preschool Years , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Grossmannn , K. , Fremmer‐Bombik , E. , Rudolph , J. and Grossmannn , K. E. 1988 . “ Maternal representations as related to patterns of infant‐mother attachment and maternal care during the first year ” . In Relationships within Families , Edited by: Hinde , R. A. and Stevenson‐Hinde , J. 241 – 260 . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Haft , W. and Slade , A. 1989 . Affect attunement and maternal attachment: A pilot study . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 10 : 157 – 172 .
  • Hinde , R. A. 1982 . Ethology , New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Horowitz , M. J. 1988 . Introduction to Psychodynamics , New York : Basic Books .
  • Kernberg , P. K. 1994 . Mechanisms of defense: Development and research perspectives . Bull. Menninger Clin. , 58 : 55 – 87 .
  • Kermoian , R. and Liederman , P. H. 1986 . Infant attachment to mother and child caretaker in an east African community . Internat. J. Behav. Dev. , 9 : 455 – 469 .
  • Kihlstrom , J. F. 1990 . “ The psychological unconscious ” . In Handbook of Personality Theory and Research , Edited by: Pervin , L. 445 – 464 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Klaus , M. H. , Kennell , J. H. and Klaus , P. H. 1995 . Bonding , New York : Addison‐Wesley .
  • Kohut , H. and Wolf , E. S. 1978 . The disorders of the self and their treatment: An outline . Internet. J. Psycho‐Anal , 59 : 413 – 425 .
  • Lee , R. E. 1995 . Women look at their experience of pregnancy . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 16 : 192 – 205 .
  • Lieberman , A. 1996 . Aggression and sexuality in relation to toddler attachment: Implications for the caregiving system . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 276 – 292 .
  • Liefer , M. 1980 . Psychological Effects of Motherhood , New York : Praeger .
  • Liotti , G. 1999 . “ Disorganization of attachment as a model for understanding dissociative psychopathology ” . In Attachment Disorganization , Edited by: Solomon , J. and George , C. 291 – 317 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Lyons‐Ruth , K. 1996 . Attachment relationships among children with aggressive behavior problems: The role of disorganized early attachment patterns . J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. , 64 : 64 – 73 .
  • _____ and Block , D. 1996 . The disturbed caregiving system: Relations among childhood trauma, maternal caregiving, and infant affect and attachment . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 257 – 275 .
  • Mahler , M. , Pine , F. and Bergman , A. 1975 . The Psychological Birth of the Human Infant: Symbiosis and Individuation , New York : Basic Books .
  • Main , M. 1990 . Cross‐cultural studies of attachment organization: Recent studies, changing methodologies and the concept of conditional strategies . Human Dev. , 33 : 48 – 61 .
  • _____ . 1995 . “ Recent studies in attachment: Overview, with selected implications for clinical work ” . In Attachment Theory: Social, Developmental and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Goldberg , S. , Muir , R. and Kerr , J. 407 – 474 . Hillsdale, NJ : The Analytic Press .
  • _____ and Hesse . 1990 . “ Parents’ unresolved traumatic experiences are related to infant disorganized attachment status: Is frightened and/or frightening parental behavior the linking mechanism? ” . In Attachment in the Preschool Years , Edited by: Greenberg , M. T. , Cicchetti , D. and Cummings , E. M. 161 – 182 . Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • _____ and Hesse , E. 1992 . “ Disorganized/disoriented infant behavior in the Strange Situation, lapses in the monitoring of reasoning and discourse during the parent's adult attachment interview, and dissociative states ” . In Attachment and Psychoanalysis , Edited by: Ammaniti , M. and Stern , D. Rome : Gius, Laterza & Figli .
  • _____ , Kaplan , N. and Cassidy , J. 1985 . “ Security in infancy, childhood, and adulthood: A move to the level of representation ” . In Growing Points in Attachment Theory and Research , Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development Edited by: Bretherton , I. and Waters , E. Vol. 50 , 66 – 104 .
  • _____ and Morgan , H. 1996 . “ Disorganization and disorientation in infant strange situation behavior ” . In Handbook of Dissociation: Theoretical, Empirical, and Clinical Perspectives , Edited by: Michelson , L. K. and Ray , W. J. 107 – 138 . New York : Plenum Press .
  • Manning‐Orenstein , G. 1998 . A birth intervention: The therapeutic effects of Doula support versus Lamaze preparation on first‐time mothers’ working models of caregiving . Alternative therapies , 4 : 73 – 81 .
  • Moss , E. , Parent , S. , Gosselin , C. , Rousseau , D. and St‐Laurent , D. 1996 . Attachment and teacher‐reported behavior problems during the preschool and early school‐age period . Dev. & Psychopathol , 8 : 511 – 525 .
  • _____ , Rousseau , D. , Parent , S. , St‐Laurent , D. and Saintonge , J. 1998 . Correlates of attachment at school‐age: Maternal reported stress, mother‐child and behavior problems . Child Dev. , 69 : 177 – 197 .
  • Perry , B. D. , Pollard , R. A. , Blakeley , T. L. , Baker , W. L. and Vigilante , D. 1995 . Childhood trauma, the neurobiology of adaptation, and “use dependent” development of the brain: How “states” become “traits.” . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 16 : 271 – 289 .
  • Pianta , R. C. , Marvin , R. , Britner , P. and Borowitz , K. 1996 . Mothers’ resolution of their children's diagnoses: Organized patterns of caregiving representations . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 239 – 256 .
  • Pryce , C. R. 1995 . “ Determinants of motherhood in human and nonhuman primates: A biosocial model ” . In Motherhood in Human and Nonhuman Primates , Edited by: Pryce , C. R. , Martin , R. D. and Skuse , D. 1 – 15 . Basel : Karger .
  • Sadow , L. 1984 . “ The psychological origins of parenthood ” . In Parenthood: A psychodynamic perspective , Edited by: Cohen , R. S. , Cohler , B. J. and Weissman , S. H. 285 – 296 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Sameroff , A. J. and Chandler , M. J. 1975 . “ Reproductive risk and the continuum of caretaking casualty ” . In Review of Child Development Research , Edited by: Horowitz , F. D. Vol. 4 , 187 – 243 . Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Sandier , J. 1994 . “ The unconscious and the representational world ” . In Psychoanalysis and Development: Representations and Narratives , Edited by: Ammaniti , M. and Stern , D. N. 63 – 75 . New York : New York University Press .
  • Scarr , S. and McCartney , K. 1983 . How people make their own environments: A theory of genotype‐environment effects . Child Dev. , 54 : 424 – 435 .
  • Schwartz , D. D. 1984 . “ Psychoanalytic developmental perspectives on parenthood ” . In Parenthood: A Psychodynamic Perspective , Edited by: Cohen , R. S. , Cohler , B. J. and Weissman , S. H. 356 – 372 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Slade , A. and Aber , J. L. 1992 . “ Attachments, drives, and development: Conflicts and convergences in theory ” . In Interface of Psychoanalysis and Psychology , Edited by: Barren , J. W. , Eagle , M. N. and Wolitzky , D. L. 154 – 185 . Washington, D.C. : American Psychological Association .
  • _____ , Belsky , J. , Aber , J. L. and Phelps , J. L. 1997 . “ Maternal representations of their toddlers: Links to adult attachment and observed mothering ” . Submitted manuscript
  • _____ , Dermer , M. , Gerber , J. , Gibson , L. , Graf , F. , Siegal , N. and Tobias , K. Prenatal representation, dyadic interaction, and the quality of attachment . Paper presented at the biennial meetings of the Society for Research in Child Development .
  • Solomon , J. and George , C. Role reversal and the disorganized attachment system . Paper presented at the 9th International Conference on Infant Studies . Paris, France.
  • _____ and _____ . 1996 . Defining the caregiving system: Toward a theory of caregiving . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 17 : 183 – 197 .
  • _____ and _____ . 1999a . “ The place of disorganization in attachment theory: Linking classic observations with contempory findings ” . In Attachment Disorganization , Edited by: Solomon , J. and George , C. New York : Guilford Press .
  • _____ . 1999b . The development of attachment in separated and divorced families . Attachment & Human Development , 1 : 2 – 33 .
  • _____ , _____ and Ivins , B. Mother‐child interaction in the home and security of attachment . Paper presented at the biennial meetings of the Society for Research in Child Development .
  • _____ , _____ and Silverman , N. “ Maternal caretaking Q‐sort: Describing age‐related changes in mother‐child interaction ” . In Patterns of Secure Base Behavior: Q‐sort Perspectives on Attachment and Caregiving , Edited by: Waters , E. , Vaughn , B. and Teti , D. Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum . (in press)
  • _____ , _____ and Wallerstein , J. The development of attachment in separated and divorced families . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development .
  • Sroufe , L. A. 1979 . “ Socioemotional development ” . In Handbook of Infant Development , Edited by: Osofsky , J. 462 – 518 . New York : Wiley .
  • _____ . 1988 . “ Relationships, self and individual adaptation ” . In Relationship Disturbances in Early Childhood , Edited by: Sameroff , A. J. and Emde , R. N. 70 – 96 . New York : Basic Books .
  • _____ and Fleeson , J. 1986 . “ Attachment and the construction of relationships ” . In The Nature and Development of Relationships , Edited by: Hartup , W. and Rubin , Z. 51 – 71 . Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
  • Stern , D. N. 1985 . The Interpersonal World of the Infant , New York : Basic Books .
  • Stern‐Bruschweiler , N. and Stern , D. N. 1989 . A model for conceptualizing the role of the mother's representational world in various mother‐infant therapies . Infant Mental Hlth. J. , 10 : 142 – 156 .
  • Stevenson‐Hinde , J. 1994 . An ethological perspective . Psychol. Inq. , 5 : 62 – 65 .
  • Stovall , C. and Dozier , M. The evolution of attachment in new relationships: Single subject analysis of ten foster infants . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development . Washington, DC.
  • Tan , A. 1989 . The Joy Luck Club , New York : Ballantine Books .
  • Thompson , R. A. “ Early attachment and later behavior ” . In Handbook of Attachment , Edited by: Cassidy , J. and Shaver , P. 265 – 286 . New York : Guilford Press . (in press)
  • Trivers , R. L. 1974 . Parent‐offspring conflict . Amer. Zool. , 11 : 249 – 264 .
  • Tronick , E. 1989 . Emotions and emotional communication in infants . Amer. Psycol. , 44 : 112 – 119 .
  • True , M. 1994 . Mother—infant attachment and communication among the Dogon of Mali (West Africa) , Berkeley : University of California . Unpublished doctoral dissertation
  • van IJzendoorn , M. H. 1995 . Adult attachment representations, parental responsiveness, and infant attachment: A meta‐analysis on the predictive validity of the Adult Attachment Interview . Psychol. Bull. , 117 : 387 – 403 .
  • Wallerstein , R. S. 1983 . Defenses, defense mechanisms, and the structure of the mind . J. Amer. Psychoanal. Assn. , 31 : 201 – 225 .
  • Ward , M. J. , Botyanski , N. , Plunket , S. and Carlson , E. The concurrent and predictive validity of the Adult Attachment Interview for adolescent mothers . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development . Seattle, WA.
  • Waters , E. and Deane , K. E. 1985 . “ Defining and assessing individual differences in attachment relationships: Q‐methodology and the organization of behavior in infancy and early childhood ” . In Growing Points in Attachment Theory and Research , Monogr. of the Society for Research in Child Development Edited by: Bretherton , I. and Waters , E. Vol. 50 , 41 – 65 .
  • Waters , R. 1979 . “ Mother ” . In The Wall , New York : Pink Floyd Music Limited . Columbia Records
  • West , M. and George , C. in press . Violence in intimate adult relationships: An attachment theory perspective . Attachment and Human Development ,
  • Westen , D. 1990 . “ Psychoanalytic approaches to personality ” . In The Handbook of Personality Theory and Research , Edited by: Pervin , L. 21 – 65 . New York : Guilford Press .
  • Winnicott , D. W. 1958 . Collected Papers , London : Tavistock .
  • Zeanah , C. H. and Barton , M. L. 1989 . Internal representations and parent‐infant relationships . Inf. Mental Hlth. J. , 10 : 135 – 141 .
  • _____ , Benoit , D. , Hirschberg , L. , Barton , M. and Regan , C. 1995 . Mothers’ representations of their infants are concordant with infant attachment classifications . Dev. Issues in Psychiat. & Psychol. , 1 : 1 – 14 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.