THE INDUSTRIAL ROBOTS SELECTION PROBLEM: LITERATURE REVIEW AND DIRECTIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH

REFERENCES

• Abdel-Malek , L. , and Wolf , C. , “ Evaluating Flexibility of Alternative FMS Designs-A Comparative Measure ,” International Journal of Production Economics , 23 , 3 – 10 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , and Zhiming , L. , “ The Application of Inverse Kinematics in the Optimum Sequencing of Robot Tasks ,” International Journal of Production Research , 28 , 1 , 75 – 90 ( 1990 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , “ Assessment of the Economic Feasibility of Robotic Assembly While Conveyor Tracking (RACT) ,” International Journal of Production Research , 27 , 1209 – 1224 ( 1989 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , “ The Effect of Robots with Overlapping Envelopes on Performance of Flexible Transfer Lines ,” IIE Transactions , 20 , 2 , 213 – 222 ( 1988 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , “ Robot's Economic Repeatability ,” Engineering Costs and Production Economics , 12 , 93 – 97 ( 1987 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , “ A Framework for the Robotic Assembly of Parts With General Geometries ,” International Journal of Production Research , 24 , 1025 – 1041 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , and Boucher , T. O. , “ A Framework for the Economic Evaluation of Production System and Product Design Alternatives for Robot Assembly ,” International Journal of Production Research , 23 , 197 – 208 ( 1985 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Abdel-Malek , L. , “ A Case Study on the Use of Robots in Assembly Process ,” Engineering Costs and Production Economics , 9 , 99 – 102 ( 1985 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Agrawal , V. P. , Khohl , V. , and Gupta , S. , “ Computer Aided Robot Selection The Multiple Attribute Decision Making Approach ,” International Journal of Production Research , 29 , 1629 – 1644 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Albertson , P. , “ Verifying Robot Performance ,” Robotics Today , 33 – 36 ( October 1983 ).
   Google Scholar
• Altiok , T. and Stidham , S. , “ The Allocation of Interstage Buffer Capacities in Production Lines ,” IIE Transactions , 14 , 4 , 292 – 298 ( 1983 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Booth , D. E. , Khouja , M. , Hu , Michael , “ A Robust Multivariate Procedure for Evaluation and Selection of Industrial Robots ,” International Journal of Operations and Production Management , 12 , 2 , 15 – 24 ( 1992 ).
   Google Scholar
• Boubekri , N. , Sahoui , M. , Lakrib , C. , “ Development of an Expert System for Industrial Robot Selection ,” Computers and Industrial Engineering , 20 , 119 – 127 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Brady , M. , Robot Motion Planning and Control , Cambridge , MA MIT Press ( 1983 ).
   Google Scholar
• Brady , M. , Paul , R. (Eds.) , Robotic Research , Cambridge , MA MIT Press ( 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Chandra , M. J. , Rosenshine , M. , and Soyster , A. L. , “ Analysis of Robot Positioning Error ,” International Journal of Production Research , 24 , 1159 – 1169 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Critchlow , A. J. , Introduction to Robotics , New York Mac-millan Publishing ( 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Doydum , C. , and Perreira , N. D. , “ A Method for Selecting Dimensions, Tolerances and Precisions for Alignment ,” International Journal of Production Research , 29 , 1035 – 1052 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Doydum , C. , and Perreira , N. D. , “ Use of Monte Carlo Simulation to Select Dimensions, Tolerances and Precision for Automated Assembly ,” Journal of Manufacturing Systems , 10 , 209 – 222 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fisher , E. L. , and Maimon , O. Z. , “ Specification and Selection of Robots ,” In Kusiak, A., (Ed.) , Artificial Intelligence Implications for CIM , Bedford IFS Publications ( 1988 ).
   Google Scholar
• Gunn , T. G. , Manufacturing for Competitive Advantage , Cambridge , Ma Ballinger Publishing ( 1987 ).
   Google Scholar
• Gustavsson , S. O. , “ Flexibility and Productivity in Complex Production Processes ,” International Journal of Production Research , 22 , 801 – 808 ( 1984 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Huang , P. Y. , and Ghandforoush , P. , “ Procedures Given for Evaluating, Selecting Robots ,” Industrial Engineering , 16 , 44 – 48 ( April 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Hwang , C. L. , and Yoon , F. S. , “ Multiple Attribute Decision Making-a State of the Art Survey ,” Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematics , Berlin Springer-Verlag ( 1982 ) .
   Google Scholar
• Imany , M. M. , and Schlesinger , R. J. , “ Decision Models for Robot Selection A Comparison of Ordinary Least Squares and Linear Goal Programming methods ,” Decision Sciences , 20 , 40 – 53 ( 1989 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jiang , B. C. , Chen , D. W. , Black , J. T. , and Hool , J. N. , “ Tagucbi-based Methodology for Detennining/Optimizing Robot Process Capability ,” IIE Transactions , 23 , 169 – 184 ( 1991 ).
   Google Scholar
• Jones , M. S. , Malmborg , C. J. , and Agee , M. H. , “ Decision Support System Used for Robot Selection ,” Industrial Engineering , 17 , 66 – 73 ( September 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Keen , P. G. W. , “ The Evolving Concept of Optimality ,” in M. K. Stair and M. Zeleny (Eds.) , Multiple Criteria Decision Making , 31 – 57 , New York North-Holland Publishing Company ( 1977 ).
   Google Scholar
• Keeney , R. L. , and Raiffa , H. , Decisions with Multiple Objectives Preferences and Value Tradeoff , New York John Wiley ( 1976 ).
   Google Scholar
• Khouja , M. and Booth , D. E. , “ A Decision Model for the Robot Selection Problem Using Robust Regression ,” Decision Sciences , 22 , 656 – 662 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kim , S. and Knott , K. , “ The Effect of Tolerancing When Assembling a Peg Into a Hole Using a Robot ,” Quality, Design, Planning, and Control PED , 27 , 191 – 203 ( 1987 ).
   Google Scholar
• Knott , K. , Getto , Jr. , R. D. , “ A Model for Evaluating Alternative Robot Systems Under Uncertainty ,” International Journal of Production Research , 20 , 155 – 165 ( 1982 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Leung , L. C. , and Tanchoco , J. M. A. , “ Multiple Machine Replacement Within an Integrated System Framework ,” The Engineering Economist , 32 , 89 – 114 ( 1987 ).
   Google Scholar
• Mehrez , A. and Oftbdile , O. F. , “ A Statistical-Economic Framework for Evaluating the Effect of Robot Repeatability on Profit ,” Working paper , Kent State University , Kent , OH 44242 ( 1992 ).
   Google Scholar
• Menipaz , E. , “ A Taxonomy of Economically Based Quality Control Procedures ,” International Journal of Production Research , 16 , 2 , 153 – 167 ( 1978 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Miller , R. K. , Industrial Robot Handbook , New York Van Nostrend Reinhold ( 1989 ).
   Google Scholar
• Narasimhan , R. , and Vickery , S. K. , “ An Experimental Evaluation of Articulation of Preferences in Multiple Criterion Decision-Making (MCDM) Methods ,” Decision Sciences , 19 , 880 – 888 ( 1988 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nnaji , B.O. , Yannacopoulou , M. , “ A Utility Theory Based Robot Selection and Evaluation for Electronics Assembly ,” Computers and Industrial Engineering . 14 , 477 – 493 ( 1989 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nnaji , B. O. , “ Evaluation Methodology for Performance and System Economics for Robotic Devices ,” Computers and Industrial Engineering , 14 , 27 – 39 ( 1988 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nnaji , B. O. , Computer-Aided Design, Selection and Evaluation of Robots , New York Elsevier ( 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Nof , S. Y. , “ Robot Ergonomics Optimizing Robot Work ,” in S. Y. Nof (Ed.) , Handbook of Industrial Robotics , 549 – 604 , New York John Wiley ( 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Nof, S. Y. (Ed.) , Handbook of Industrial Robotics . New York John Wiley ( 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Nof , S. Y. , and Lechtman , H. , “ Robot Time and Motion Provides Means for Evaluating Alternative Work Methods ,” Industrial Engineering , 14 , 38 – 48 , ( April 1982 ).
   Google Scholar
• Offodile , O. F. , and Ugwu , U. , “ Evaluating the Effect of Speed and Payload on Robot Repeatability ,” International Journal of Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing , 8 , 1 , 27 – 33 ( 1991 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Offodile , O. F. , Lambert , B. K. , and Dudek , R. A. , “ Development of a Computer Aided Robot Selection Procedure (CARSP) ,” International Journal of Production Research , 25 , 1109 – 1121 ( 1987 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Prange , J. M. , and Peyton , J. A. , “ Standards Development ,” Robotics Today , 23 – 24 ( December 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Redford. A. H., (Ed.) , Robotic Assembly , LondonWashington , D.C Taylor and Francis ( 1991 ).
   Google Scholar
• Saary , T. L. , The Analytical Hierarchy Process , New York McGraw-Hill ( 1980 ).
   Google Scholar
• Schlesinger , R. J. , and Imany , M. M. , “ Statistical Investigation of Robot Performance Specifications ,” Human Systems Management , 6 , 157 – 165 ( 1986 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Seidmann , A. , and Nof , S. Y. , “ Operational Analysis of an Autonomous Assembly Robotic Station ,” IEEE Transactions on Robotics and Automation , 5 , 4 – 15 ( 1989 ).
   Google Scholar
• Seidmann , A. , Arbel , A. , and Shapira , R. , “ A Two-phase Analytic Approach to Robotic System Design ,” Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing , 12 , 181 – 190 ( 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Sethi , A. K. , and Sethi , P. S. , “ Flexibility in Manufacturing A Survey ,” The International Journal of Flexible Manufacturing Systems . 2 , 289 – 328 ( 1990 ).
   Google Scholar
• Sivilich , M. , and Zebrowski , J. , “ Smart Arm 6 Robot Repeatability Test Based on Velocity and Load Variation ,” unpublished report , Rutgers University ( 1983 ).
   Google Scholar
• Starr , M. K. , and Zeleny , M. , “ State and Future of the Arts ,” in M. K. Starr and M. Zeleny, (Eds.) , Multiple Criteria Decision Making , 5 – 29 , New York North-Holland Publishing Company ( 1977 ).
   Google Scholar
• Strum , A. J. , and Matz , I. , “ Robot Testing and Evaluation ,” Robotics Engineering , 4 – 10 ( December 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Sullivan , W. G. and Liu , M. , “ Economic Analysis of Proposed Industrial Robot ,” Industrial Engineering , 16 , 118 – 123 ( 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Tech Tran Consultants, Inc. , Industrial Robots, a Summary and Forecast ( 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Warnecke , H. , and Schraft , R. , Industrial Robots Application Experience , Bedford IFS Publications ( 1982 ).
   Google Scholar