892
Views
2
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Women and black employees at the Central Intelligence Agency: from fair employment to diversity management

Pages 673-703 | Received 03 Apr 2020, Accepted 20 Oct 2020, Published online: 04 Dec 2020

References

  • Acting Director of Personnel (1964) ‘Negro employees – 1964’, 3 August, Central Intelligence Agency Records Search Tool (thereafter CREST).
  • Andrew, Christopher (1995) For the President's Eyes Only (New York: HarperCollins).
  • Bakos, Nada (2019) The targeter: my life in the CIA, Hunting terrorists and challenging the white house (New York: Little, Brown and Company).
  • Barrett, David M (2005) The CIA and congress: the untold story from Truman to Kennedy (Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas).
  • Bean, Hamilton (2018) ‘Intelligence theory from the margins: questions ignored and debates not had’, Intelligence and National Security, 33:4, 527–540.
  • Bell, Joyce M, and Douglas Hartmann (2007) ‘Diversity in everyday discourse: the cultural ambiguities and consequences of “Happy Talk”’, American Sociological Review, 72:6, 895–914.
  • Blake, John F (1978a) ‘Recruitment of personnel’, 8 August, CREST.
  • Blake, John F (1978b) ‘Suggestions from Congressional Women’s Caucus’, 15 September, CREST.
  • Boyle, Barbara (1973) ‘Equal opportunity for women is smart business’, Harvard Business Review, 51:3, 85–95.
  • Callum, Robert (2001) ‘The case for cultural diversity in the intelligence community’, International Journal of Intelligence and Counterintelligence, 14:1, 25–48.
  • Career Service Panel (1974) ‘Office of research and development’, 11 March, CREST.
  • Carey, Maeve P (2012) ‘The Senior Executive Service: background and options for reform’, Congressional Research Service Report, 6 September.
  • Carpenter, Charli R (2016) ‘The future of global security studies’, Journal of Global Security Studies, 1:1, 92–94.
  • Central Intelligence Agency [thereafter CIA] (1951a) ‘Daily Staff Meeting’, 15 August, CREST.
  • Center for the Study of Intelligence (2003) ‘The Petticoat panel: a 1953 study of the role of women in the CIA career service’, March, CREST.
  • Chen, Anthony (2009) The fifth freedom: jobs, politics, and civil rights in the United States, 1941-1972 (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
  • Chief Career Training Program (1971) ‘Black employment in CIA’, 20 July, CREST.
  • CIA (1951b) ‘Daily Staff Meeting’, 6 September, CREST.
  • CIA (1953) ‘Transcript of Steering Group CIA Career Service Board’, 10 August, CREST.
  • CIA (1955) ‘Deputies’ Meeting’, 31 August, CREST.
  • CIA (1964) ‘Acting Director of Personnel, Negro Employees – 1964’, 3 August, CREST.
  • CIA (1965) ‘Equal employment opportunity policy and procedures’, 7 November, CREST.
  • CIA (1970) ‘Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) Program Report to Civil Service Commission (CSC)’, 8 October, CREST.
  • CIA (1972a) ‘Agency report on women federal employees in higher level positions GS-12 and above period covered 1 January 1972 through 30 September 1972’, CREST.
  • CIA (1972b) ‘EEO program report, CY 1971’, CREST.
  • CIA (1975) ‘Course report – midcareer course No. 45, 2 February – 7 March 1975’, 20 March, CREST.
  • CIA (1978) ‘Report of investigation equal employment opportunity complaint of Harritte T. Thompson’, CREST.
  • CIA (1988) ‘Affirmative employment program for minorities and women, EEO Policy Statement’, CREST.
  • CIA (1992a) ‘Glass Ceiling Study summary’, CREST.
  • CIA (1992b) ‘Glass ceiling action discussion’, 27 August, CREST.
  • CIA (1992c) ‘Implementation of the Glass Ceiling Study: intelligence excellence through diversity’, 3 August, CREST.
  • CIA (1994) ‘Divine secrets of the RYBAT sisterhood: four senior women of the directorate of operations discuss their careers’, CREST.
  • CIA (2010a) ‘Dr. Ralph J. Bunche: an African-American leader in the intelligence community’, at <https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/2010-featured-story-archive/dr.-ralph-j.-bunche.html> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • CIA (2010b) ‘Workforce trends 1980-2009’, 1 September, CREST.
  • CIA (2013) From typists to trailblazers: the evolving view of women in the CIA’s workforce. (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office).
  • CIA (2014) ‘Remembering CIA's African American heroes’, at <https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/2014-featured-story-archive/remembering-cias-african-american-heroes.html> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • CIA (2015a) ‘CIA achieves key milestone in agency-wide modernization initiative’, 1 October, at <https://www.cia.gov/news-information/press-releases-statements/2015-press-releases-statements/cia-achieves-key-milestone-in-agency-wide-modernization-initiative.html> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • CIA (2015b) ‘Director’s diversity in leadership study. Overcoming Barriers to Advancement’, April 15, at <https://www.cia.gov/library/reports/dls-report.pdf> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • CIA (2018) ‘CIA makes progress on women in leadership’, 11 July, at <https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/2018-featured-story-archive/cia-makes-progress-on-women-in-leadership.html> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • CIA (2020) ‘The 20th anniversary of angle’, at <https://www.cia.gov/news-information/featured-story-archive/2016-featured-story-archive/images/angle/ANGLE_TimelineDisplay.pdf> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • Civil Service Commission (1972) ‘Equal opportunity in federal employment’, Monthly Bulletin, 5:2, 1–4.
  • Colby, William E (1972) ‘Minority recruitment – the target group’, 18 July, CREST.
  • Colby, William E (1974) ‘The Status of the Agency Equal Employment Opportunity Program’, 4 March, CREST.
  • Colby, William E and Director of Equal Employment Opportunity (1973) ‘Affirmative action plan for equal employment opportunity, calendar year 1974’, 1 November, CREST.
  • Colby, William, and Peter Forbath (1978) Honorable men: my life in the CIA (London: Hutchinson).
  • Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction (2005) Report to the President of the United States, 31 March.
  • Crenshaw, Kimberlé W (1991) ‘Mapping the margins: intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of colour’, Stanford Law Review, 43:6, 1241–1299.
  • Davis Graham, Hugh (1994) ‘Race, history, and policy: African Americans and civil rights since 1964’, Journal of Policy History, 6:1, 12–39.
  • Department of Commerce (1951) 1950 census of population. Preliminary reports (Washington, DC: Bureau of the Census).
  • Department of Labor (1953) The status of women in the United States (Washington, DC: Women’s Bureau Bulletin 249).
  • Department of Labor (1991) A report on the glass ceiling initiative (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office).
  • Deputy Chief History Staff (1984) ‘Career opportunity for women’, 26 March, CREST.
  • Deputy Director of Central Intelligence (1983) ‘CIA women’, 15 December, CREST.
  • Deputy Director of Personnel for Recruitment and Placement (1972a) ‘EEO program, and related data concerning female and minority employees’, 17 March, CREST.
  • Deputy Director of Personnel for Recruitment and Placement (1972b) ‘Minority recruitment – The Target Group’, July, CREST.
  • Deutch, John M (1995) ‘Statement before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, hearing on diversity and minority hiring in intelligence agencies, 104th Congress’, 1st sess., 29 November.
  • DiPrete, Thomas A (1987) ‘The professionalization of administration and equal employment opportunity in the U.S. federal government’, American Journal of Sociology, 93:1, 119–140.
  • Director of Training and Education (1981) ‘A proposed training course, women and leadership’, 30 July, CREST.
  • Director Planning and Policy Office (1988a) ‘Talking points on NAPA personnel study’, 18 February 1988, CREST.
  • Director Planning and Policy Office (1988b) ‘National Academy of Personnel Administration (NAPA) Study of Intelligence Community Personnel Systems’, 1 July, CREST.
  • Director’s Advisory Group Implementation (2017) ‘Year four report to the workforce’, August, CREST.
  • Director’s Advisory Group on Women in Leadership [DAG] (2013) ‘Unclassified report’, 19 March, CREST.
  • Drumheller, Tyler (2006) On the brink: an insider’s account of how the white house compromised american intelligence (New York: Caroll & Grad).
  • Durbin, Brent (2013) ‘Addressing “this woeful imbalance”: efforts to improve women’s representation at CIA, 1947-2013’, in CIA (ed), From typist to trailblazer: the evolving view of women in the CIA’s workforce (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office), 16–27.
  • Echols, Emmett D (1963) ‘Minority report as of 30 June 1963’, 21 August, CREST.
  • Echols, Emmett D (1964) ‘Utilization of Negro employees’, 13 March, CREST.
  • Eckstein, Marie H (1978) ‘Director's Meeting with Members of the Congressional Women's Caucus on Thursday, 20 July 1978’, 20 July, CREST.
  • Edelman, Lauren B, Riggs Sally Fuller, and Iona Mara-Drita (2001) ‘Diversity rhetoric and the managerialization of law’, American Journal of Sociology, 106:6, 1589–1641.
  • EEO Black Advisory Panel (1974) ‘Recruitment program’, 23 May, CREST.
  • EEO Officer Support Directorate (1970) ‘Support Directorate Equal Employment Report’, 16 November, CREST.
  • Elias, Allison L (2018) ‘“Outside the pyramid”: clerical work, corporate affirmative action, and working women’s barriers to upward mobility’, Journal of Policy History, 30:2, 301–333.
  • Ellison, Dawn (2002) ‘One woman’s contribution to social change at CIA’, Studies in Intelligence, 46:3, 45–53.
  • Executive for Administration and Management (1947) ‘Grievance and complaints procedure’, 23 April 1947, CREST.
  • Farhi, Paul (1991) ‘Uncle Sam says come spy for me as CIA begins appeal to minorities’, Washington Post, 1 November.
  • Federal Women’s Program Board (1977) ‘Themes on women’, 27 May, CREST.
  • Federal Women’s Program Board (1981) ‘Executive career development for women in the CIA’, 13 May, CREST.
  • Federal Women’s Program Manager (1981) ‘A proposal for a training course, women and leadership’, 15 July, CREST.
  • Federal Women’s Program Manager (1983) ‘Projected activities for CIA Federal Women’s Program for 1984’, 15 December, CREST.
  • Ferner, Anthony, P hil Almond, and T revor Colling (2005) ‘Institutional theory and the cross-national transfer of employment policy: the case of ‘workforce diversity’ in US multinationals’, Journal of International Business Studies, 36:3, 304–321.
  • Foy, David A (2017) ‘Review of ‘Liza Mundy, Code girls: the untold story of the American women codebreakers of World War II (New York: Hachette, 2017)’, Studies in Intelligence, 61:4, 81–83.
  • Fox, Amaryllis (2019) Life undercover: coming of age in the CIA (New York: Penguin).
  • Gates, Robert M (1992) ‘The glass ceiling assessment’, 21 April, CREST.
  • Gilligan, Tom (1991) CIA life: 10,000 days with the agency (Guilford: Foreign Intelligence Press).
  • Government Accounting Office (1996) Intelligence agencies. Personnel practices at CIA, NSA, and DIA compared with those of other agencies, Report to the Honorable Patricia Schroeder, House of Representatives, 11 March.
  • Hancock, Ange-Marie (2007) ‘When multiplication doesn’t equal quick addition: examining intersectionality as research paradigm’, Perspectives on Politics, 5:01, 63–79.
  • Haynes, Bryan (2006) ‘Black undergraduates in higher education: an historical perspective’, Metropolitan Universities, 17:2, 8–21.
  • Heeg Maruska, Jennifer (2010) ‘When are states hypermasculine?’, in Laura Sjoberg (ed), Gender and international security: feminist perspectives (New York: Routledge), 235–255.
  • Hirsch, James V (1992) ‘Comments on implementation of the glass ceiling’, 25 August, CREST.
  • Holliday, Janet (2012) ‘Female engagement teams: the need to standardize training and employment’, Military Review, March-April, 90–94.
  • Jeffery, Keith (2010) MI6: the history of the secret intelligence service 1909-1949 (London: Bloomsbury).
  • Jeffreys-Jones, Rhodri (2003) The CIA and American democracy (London: Yale University Press).
  • Jeffreys-Jones, Rhodri (2013) In spies we trust. The story of western intelligence (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
  • Johnson, Lyndon B (1965) Executive Order 11246, 24 September.
  • Johnson, Lyndon B (1967) Executive Order 11375, 13 October.
  • Johnston, William B, and Arnold E Packer (1987) Workforce 2000: work and workers for the 21st century (Indianapolis: Hudson Institute).
  • Jones, Abigail (2018) ‘She was a CIA spy. Now she’s a lawyer battling her old agency. This is her story’, New York Times, 5 June.
  • Kean, Thomas H, et al (2004) The 9/11 Commission report. Final report of the national commission on terrorist attacks upon the United States (New York: W.W. Norton).
  • Kellough, J Edward, and Katherine C Naff (2004) ‘Responding to a wake-up call. An examination of federal agency diversity management programs’, Administration & Society, 36:1, 62–90.
  • Kelly, Erin, and Frank Dobbin (1998) ‘How affirmative action became diversity management’, American Behavioral Scientist, 41:7, 960–984.
  • Kennedy, John F (1961) Executive Order 10925, 6 March.
  • Kirkpatrick, Lyman B (1953) ‘Inspection of the Personnel Office’, 10 November, CREST.
  • LaGumina, Salvatore J (2016) The office of strategic services and Italian Americans. The untold story (Cham: Palgrave Macmillan).
  • Langan, Patrick A (1991) Race of prisoners admitted to state and federal institutions, 1926-1986 (Washington, DC: Department of Justice).
  • Lorbiecki, Anna and Gavin Jack (2000) ‘Critical turns in the evolution of diversity management’, British Journal of Management, 11:s1, S17–S31.
  • Macintosh, Elizabeth (1998) Sisterhood of spies: the women of the OSS (Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press).
  • Malkiel, Nancy W (2016) “Keep the damned women out”: the struggle for coeducation (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
  • Marchetti, Victor and John D Marks (1974) The CIA and the cult of intelligence (New York: Alfred A. Knopf).
  • Martin, Amy J (2015) ‘America’s evolution of women and their roles in the intelligence community’, Journal of Strategic Security, 8:3Suppl, 99–109.
  • Meloon, George E (1953) ‘Colored (Negro) Personnel Employed by CIA’, 5 October, CREST.
  • Miller, Max (1969) Black and White: uptight (Santa Monica: Avanti Films), at <https://archive.org/details/blackandwhiteuptight> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • Moran, Christopher (2019) ‘Nixon's axe man: CIA director James R’, Journal of American Studies, 53:1, 95–121.
  • Moran, Christopher, Mark Stout, Ioanna Iordanou, and Paul Maddrell (2017) Spy chiefs: volume 1 (Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press).
  • National Academy of Public Administration (1989) ‘The intelligence workforce for the 1990s: a review of personnel and compensation systems to meet current and future missions’, 19 January, CREST.
  • National Security Agency [thereafter NSA] (2020a) ‘Cryptologic pioneers: the African American experience’, at <https://www.nsa.gov/about/cryptologic-heritage/historical-figures-publications/african-americans/> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • NSA (2020b) ‘William Coffee’, at ≤<seurld≥https://www.nsa.gov/About-Us/Current-Leadership/Article-View/Article/1621571/william-coffee/> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • NSA (2020c) ‘Women in American cryptology’, at <https://www.nsa.gov/about/cryptologic-heritage/historical-figures-publications/women/Article/1620951/renetta-predmore-lynch/> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • ODNI (2014) ‘The U.S. intelligence community’s human capital vision 2020’, 5 March.
  • Office of Personnel Management (1988) Civil Service 2000, June.
  • Office of the Director of National Intelligence [thereafter ODNI] (2006) ‘Five year strategic human capital plan, An Annex to the US National Intelligence Strategy’, 22 June.
  • Office of the Inspector General (1978) ‘Letter to Admiral Stanfield Turner’, 28 June, CREST.
  • Panel on Career Service for Women (1953a) ‘Career employment of women in the Central Intelligence Agency’, November, CREST.
  • Panel on Career Service for Women (1953b) ‘Report of the Committee on Professional Women in the Overt Offices’, 1 November, CREST.
  • Pattinson, Juliette (2016) ‘The twilight war: gender and espionage, Britain, 1900–1950’, in Simona Sharoni, et al Handbook on gender and war (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing).
  • Pear, Robert (1995) ‘C.I.A. settles suit on sex bias’, New York Times, 30 March.
  • Pearson, Judith (2005) Wolves at the door: the true story of America’s greatest female spy (Guildford, CT: The Lyon Press).
  • Peterson, V Spike (1992) ‘Transgressing boundaries: theories of knowledge, gender and international relations’, Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 21:2, 183–206.
  • Petraeus, David H (2012) ‘SIS promotions’, 1 January, CREST.
  • Pitts, David (2009) ‘Diversity management, job satisfaction, and performance: evidence form U.S. federal agencies’, Public Administration Review, 69:2, 328–338.
  • Pitts, David W (2005) ‘Diversity, representation, and performance: evidence about race and ethnicity in public organizations’, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 15:4, 615–631.
  • Porter, Benn Jackie (2013) ‘Typists and trailblazers: defining the roles of women in the early years of the CIA’, in Central Intelligence Agency (ed), From typist to trailblazer: the evolving view of women in the CIA's workforce (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office), 6–15.
  • Purnell, Sonia (2019) A woman of no importance: the untold story of the american spy who helped win world war II (New York: Viking).
  • Rhodan, Maya (2015) ‘The CIA’s Latest mission: improving diversity’, Time, 20 April.
  • Rodriguez, Jose (2007) ‘Border security: strengthening intelligence through diversity’, C-SPAN, 13 August, at https://www.c-span.org/video/?200443-2/border-security-strengthening-intelligence-diversity&start=741> (accessed 24 November 2020).
  • Rose, Winfield H, and T iang Ping Chia (1978) ‘The impact of the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972 on Black Employment in the Federal Service: a preliminary analysis’, Public Administration Review, 38:3, 245–251.
  • Shahan, Jessica R (2019) ‘Spying gender: women in British intelligence 1969-1994’, PhD thesis, Department of International Politics, Aberystwyth University.
  • Sjoberg, Laura (2011) ‘Gender, the state, and war redux: feminist international relations across the ‘levels of analysis’’, International Relations, 25:1, 108–134.
  • Skrentny, John David (1996) Ironies of affirmative action: politics, culture and justice in America (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
  • Slatkin, Nora (1996) ‘Speech’, 15 May, CREST.
  • Smith, R Jeffrey (1995) ‘Female officers reject CIA bias settlement’, Washington Post, 5 June.
  • Stachowitsch, Saskia (2012) ‘Military gender integration and foreign policy in the United States: a feminist international relations perspective’, Security Dialogue, 43:4, 305–321.
  • Stewart, Gordon M (1957) ‘Employment of Negroes’, 1 April, CREST.
  • Stokes, Louis (1994) ‘Statement before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, Hearing on Hiring, Promotion, Retention and Overall Representation of Minorities, women and Disabled Persons within the Intelligence Community’, 103rd Congress, 2nd sess., 20 September.
  • Sulick, Michael J (2013) American spies (Washington DC: Georgetown University Press).
  • Tenet, George (2007) At the center of the storm. My years at the CIA (New York: HarperCollins).
  • Thomas, R Roosevelt (1990) ‘From affirmative action to affirming diversity’, Harvard Business Review, 68:2, 107–117.
  • Thurber, Timothy M (2006) ‘Racial liberalism, affirmative action, and the troubled history of the President’s Committee on government contracts’, Journal of Policy History, 18:4, 446–476.
  • Truman, Harry S (1948) Executive Order 9980, 26 July.
  • Turner, Stansfield (1978a) ‘Blacks/Women in Operations Directorate’, 17 July, CREST.
  • Turner, Stansfield (1978b) ‘Employment of women at grades GS-11 and above’, 26 December, CREST.
  • US Congress (2003) Intelligence Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2004, 108th Congress, 1st sess., 13 December.
  • US Court of Appeals for the Fourth District (2013) United States of America v. Jeffrey Alexander Sterling, No.11-5028, 19 July.
  • US District Court for the District of Columbia (1980a) Brown v. Turner, 22 May.
  • US District Court for the District of Columbia (1980b) Weber v. Turner, 2 October.
  • US District Court for the District of Columbia (1981a) Neely v. Central Intelligence Agency, 8 October.
  • US District Court for the District of Columbia (1981b) Turbeville v. Casey, 30 October.
  • US District Court for the District of Columbia (1983) Vymetalik v. Central Intelligence Agency, 28 July.
  • US District Court for the District of Maryland (1976) Predmore v. Allen, 16 March.
  • US House of Representatives (1994) Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence ‘Hiring, promotion, retention and overall representation of minorities, women and disabled persons within the intelligence community’, 103rd Congress, 2nd sess., 20 September.
  • Ukova, Martina (2016) ‘Women in CIA: from typists to trailblazers?’, Diploma thesis, Charles University, Prague.
  • Van Puyvelde, Damien, and Stephen Coulthart (2016) ‘The intelligence community must remove barriers to minority recruitment’, Defense One, 25 January.
  • van Seters, Deborah (1992) ‘“Hardly Hollywood’s ideal”: female autobiographies of secretive work 1914-1945’, Intelligence and National Security, 7:4, 403–424.
  • Walder, Tracy and Jessica A Blau (2019) The unexpected spy: from CIA to the FBI, my secret life taking down some of the world’s most notorious terrorists (New York: St. Martin’s Press).
  • Ware, Omego J C (1975) ‘Office of Equal Employment Opportunity (OEEO)’, 22 August, CREST.
  • Ware, Omego J C (1979) ‘Final Agency Decision in the Discrimination Complaint Case of Harritte T. Thompson’, 1 March, CREST.
  • Wattles, Robert S (1970) ‘Employment of Negroes’, 31 August, CREST.
  • Webster, William H (1989) ‘Letter to the Honorable Anthony C. Beilenson’, 18 January, CREST.
  • Weiner, T ime (1994) ‘C.I.A. Colleagues Call Fallen Star a Bias Victim’, New York Times, 14 September.
  • Wibben, Annick T R (2020) ‘Everyday security, feminism, and the continuum of violence’, Journal of Global Security Studies, 5:1, 115–121.
  • Wilcox, Jennifer (1998) Sharing the burden: women in cryptology during world war II (Fort George G. Meade: Center for Cryptologic History).
  • Williams, B enton (2015) ‘You Were the Best Qualified”: Business Beyond the Backlash Against Affirmative Action’, Journal of Policy History, 27:1, 61–92.
  • Willmetts, Simon (2016) In secrecy’s shadow: the OSS and CIA in hollywood cinema, 1941-1979 (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press).
  • Windrem, Robert (2019) ‘Sisterhood of Spies’, NBC News, 5 January.
  • Winkler, Elizabeth (2019) ‘The CIA’s Former Chief of Disguise Drops her Mask’, Wall Street Journal, 12 December.
  • Yuval-Davis, Nira (2011) The politics of belonging: Intersectional contestations (London: Sage).

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.