The use of mechanical restraint in the management of psychiatric patients: Is it ever appropriate?

References

• Airy , A. and Mason , T. 1994 . Seclusion and Mental Health: a Break with the Past , London : Chapman & Hall. .
   Google Scholar
• Archer , J. 1988 . The Behavioural Biology of Aggression , New York : Cambridge University Press. .
   Google Scholar
• Bastian , H. and Conroy , C. 1997 . ‘Commentary: Is Caesarian Section a Treatment for Medical Paranoia’. . British Medical Journal , 314 : 1187
   Google Scholar
• Belden , L. R. and Moniz , D. M. 1996 . “ ‘The Hospital's Liability for Safety’. ” . In Creating a Secure Workplace: Effective Policies and Practices in Health Care , Edited by: Lion , J. R. , Dubin , W. R. and Futrell , D. E. Chicago : American Hospitals Publishing. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• Betemps , E. J. , Somoza , E. and Buncher , C. R. 1993 . ‘Hospital Characteristics, Diagnoses and Staff Reasons Associated with Use of Seclusion and Restraint’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 44 ( 4 ) : 367 – 71 . ()
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Bewley , S. 1997 . ‘Commentary: Bad Medicine and Bad Law’. . British Medical Journal , 314 : 1184 – 5 .
   Google Scholar
• Bordnick , P. S. , Thyer , B. A. and Ritchie , B. W. 1994 . ‘Feather Picking Disorder and Trichotillomania: an Avian Model of Human Psychopathology’. . Journal of Behaviour Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry , 25 ( 3 ) : 189 – 96 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bowden , P. 1990 . “ ‘The European Convention on Human Rights’. ” . In Principles and Practice of Forensic Psychiatry , Edited by: Bluglass , R. and Bowden , P. London : Churchill Livingstone. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• Brahams , D. 1994 . ‘Detention and Enforced Feeding’. . Lancet , 344 : 1697 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Braun , J. V. and Lipson , S. 1993 . Toward a Restraint-free Environment: Reducing the Use of Physical and Chemical Restraints in Long-term and Acute Care Settings , London : Health Professions Press. .
   Google Scholar
• British Medical Association . 1992 . Medicine Betrayed: the Participation of Doctors in Human Rights Abuses , London : Zed Books. .
   Google Scholar
• British Medical Association . 1993 . Medical Ethics Today: its Practice and Philosophy , London : BMJ Publishing. .
   Google Scholar
• Brooks , K. L. , Mulaik , J. S. , Gilead , M. P. and Daniels , B. S. 1994 . ‘Patient Overcrowding in Psychiatric Hospital Units: Effects on Seclusion and Restraint’. . Administration and Policy in Mental Health , 22 ( 2 ) : 133 – 44 . ()
   Google Scholar
• Bruhwyler , J. , Chleide , E. and Liegeois , J. F. 1990 . ‘Anxiolytic Potential of Sulpiride, Clozapine and Derivatives in the Open Field Test’. . Pharmacological Biochemical Behaviour , 36 : 57 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Bursten , B. 1975 . ‘Using Mechanical Restraints on Acutely Disturbed Psychiatric Patients’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 26 : 757 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Carmel , H. and Hunter , M. 1989 . ‘Staff Injuries from Inpatient Violence’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 40 : 41 – 6 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 1992 . Committee of Inquiry into Complaints about Ashworth Hospital Vols 1 and 2. Cmnd 2028-1 and 2029-11. London: HMSO.
   Google Scholar
• Conolly , J. 1856 . The Treatment of the Insane: Mechanical Restraints , London : Smith, Elder. .
   Google Scholar
• Cornfield , R. B. and Fielding , S. D. 1980 . ‘Impact of the Threatening Patient on Ward Communications’. . American Journal of Psychiatry , 137 : 616 – 19 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Crenshaw , W. B. and Francis , P. S. 1995 . ‘A National Survey on Seclusion and Restraint in State Psychiatric Hospitals’. . Psychiatric Services , 46 ( 10 ) : 1026 – 31 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Crenshaw , W. B. , Cain , K. A. and Francis , P. S. 1997 . ‘An Updated National Survey on Seclusion and Restraint’. . Psychiatric Services , 48 ( 3 ) : 395 – 7 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Crighton , J. 1995 . “ ‘A Review of Psychiatric Inpatient Violence’. ” . In Psychiatric Patient Violence: Risk and Response , Edited by: Crighton , J. London : Duckworth. . In (ed.)
   Google Scholar
• Department of Health and the Welsh Office . 1993 . Code of Practice. Mental Health Act 1983 , London : HMSO. .
   Google Scholar
• Dillner , L. 1996 . ‘Shackling Prisoners in Hospital’. . British Medical Journal , 312 : 200
   Google Scholar
• Dolan , B. and Parker , C. 1997 . British Medical Journal , 314 : 1 – 4 . ‘Caesarian Section: a Treatment for Mental Disorder: Tameside and Glossop Acute Services Unit v CH (a patient)(1996 FLR 762’.: 1183
   Google Scholar
• Esther , R. J. 1997 . ‘Use of Physical Restraints in a Nineteenth-century State Hospital’. . History of Psychiatry , viii : 83 – 93 .
   Google Scholar
• Favell , J. E. , McGinsey , J. F. and Jones , M. L. 1978 . ‘The Use of Physical Restraint in the Treatment of Self-injury and as Positive Reinforcement’. . Journal of Applied Behavioural Analysis , 11 : 225 – 41 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fine , R. 1962 . Freud: a Critical Re-evaluation of his Theories , New York : McKay. .
   Google Scholar
• Fisher , W. A. 1994 . ‘Restraint and Seclusion: a Review of the Literature’. . American Journal of Psychiatry , 151 ( 11 ) : 1584 – 91 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• General Medical Council . 1987 . Professional Conduct and Discipline: Fitness to Practise , London : GMC. .
   Google Scholar
• General Medical Council . 1993 . Professional Conduct and Discipline: Fitness to Practise , London : GMC. .
   Google Scholar
• Gordon , H. , Oyebode , B. and Minne , C. 1997 . ‘Death by Homicide in Special Hospitals’. . Journal of Forensic Psychiatry , 8 ( 3 ) : 602 – 19 . ()
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gordon , H. , Hammond , S. and Veeramani , R. 1998 . ‘Special Care Units in Special Hospitals’. . Journal of Forensic Psychiatry , 9 : 571 – 87 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Greenblatt , M. 1980 . ‘Seclusion as a Means of Restraint’. . Psychiatric Opinion , 17 : 13 – 14 .
   Google Scholar
• Gurguis , E. F. 1978 . ‘Management of Disturbed Patients as an Alternative to the Use of Mechanical Restraints’. . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 34 : 295 – 303 .
   Google Scholar
• Hanauske-Abel , H. M. 1996 . ‘Not a Slippery Slope or Sudden Subversion: German Medicine and National Socialism in 1933’. . British Medical Journal , 313 : 1453 – 63 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hanson , R. H. and Balk , J. A. 1992 . ‘A Replication Study of Staff Injuries in a State Hospital’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 43 : 836 – 7 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Harris , J. 1996 . ‘Physical Restraint Procedures for Managing Challenging Behaviours Presented by Mentally Retarded Adults and Children’. . Research in Developmental Disabilities , 17 ( 2 ) : 99 – 134 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Harris , J. , Allen , D. , Cornick , M. , Jefferson , A. and Mills , R. 1996 . Physical Interventions: a Policy Framework , Kidderminster, Worcestershire : British Institute of Learning Disabilities. .
   Google Scholar
• Hay , D. and Cromwell , R. 1980 . ‘Reducing the Use of Full-leather Restraints on an Acute Adult Inpatient Ward’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 31 : 198 – 200 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Herrera , J. N. , Sramek , J. J. and Costa , J. F. 1988 . ‘High Potency Neuroleptic and Violence in Schizophrenics’. . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorder , 176 : 558 – 61 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hill , J. and Spreat , S. 1987 . ‘Staff Injury Rates Associated with the Implementation of Contingent Restraint’. . Mental Retardation , 25 ( 3 ) : 141 – 5 . ()
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Hoggett , B. 1996 . Mental Health Law , London : Sweet & Maxwell. .
   Google Scholar
• Honig , W. 1966 . Operant Behaviour: Areas of Research and Application , New York : Appleton-Century-Crofts. .
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . ‘News and Notes: Montana State Court Establishes Constitutional Requirements for Use of Seclusion and Restraint’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 42 ( 12 ) : 1266 – 7 . Hospital and Community Psychiatry
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , R. and MacAlpine , I. 1963 . Three Hundred Years of Psychiatry: 1535–1860 , London : Oxford University Press. .
   Google Scholar
• Infantino , A. and Musingo , S. 1985 . ‘Assault and Injuries amongst Staff with and without Training in Aggression Control Techniques’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 36 : 1312 – 14 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Kalogjera , I. J. , Bedi , A. , Watson , W. N. and Meyer , A. D. 1989 . ‘Impact of Therapeutic Management in Use of Seclusion and Restraint with Disruptive Adolescents’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 40 ( 3 ) : 280 – 5 . ()
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Kumar , A. K. 1997 . ‘Sudden Unexplained Death in a Psychiatric Patient - a Casereport: the Role of Phenothiazines and Physical Restraint’. . Medicine, Science and Law , 37 ( 2 ) : 170 – 5 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Laposata , E. A. , Hale , P. Jr and Poklis , A. 1988 . ‘Evaluation of Sudden Death in Psychiatric Patients with Special Reference to Phenothiazine Therapy’. . Journal of Forensic Science , 33 : 432 – 40 .
   Google Scholar
• Larkin , E. , Murtagh , S. and Jones , S. 1988 . ‘A Preliminary Study of Violent Incidents in a Special Hospital (Rampton)’. . British Journal of Psychiatry , 153 : 226 – 31 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Law Commission . 1995 . Mental Incapacity: a Law Commission Report , Law Commission Report no. 231 London : HMSO. .
   Google Scholar
• Lester , D. 1991 . ‘Overcrowding in Prisons and Rates of Suicide and Homicide’. . Perceptual Motor Skills , 71 ( 1 ) : 274 ()
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lieberman , J. A. , Johns , C. A. and Kane , J. M. 1988 . ‘Clozapine-induced Agranulocytosis: Non-cross-reactivity with Other Psychotropic Drugs’. . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 49 : 271 – 7 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lifton , R. J. 1986 . The Nazi Doctors: a Study of the Psychology of Evil , London : Macmillan. .
   Google Scholar
• Lion , J. R. and Danto , B. L. 1996 . “ ‘The Hardware of Violence Containment’. ” . In Creating a Secure Workplace: Effective Policies and Practices in Health Care , Edited by: Lion , J. R. , Dubin , W. R. and Futrell , D. E. Chicago : American Hospitals Publishing. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• Lion , J. R. and Pasternak , S. A. 1973 . ‘Counter Transference Reactions to Violent Patients’. . American Journal of Psychiatry , 130 : 207 – 10 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lion , J. R. , Snyder , W. and Merrill , G. L. 1981 . ‘Under-reporting of Assaults on Staff in a State Hospital’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 32 : 497 – 8 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Lofgren , R. P. , MacPherson , D. S. and Granieri , R. 1989 . ‘Mechanical Restraints in the Medical Wards: Are Protective Devices Safe?’. . American Journal of Public Health , 79 : 730 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Lyon , C. M. 1994a . Legal Issues Arising from the Care and Control of Children with Learning Disabilities Who Also Present Challenging Behaviour , London : Mental Health Foundation. .
   Google Scholar
• Lyon , C. M. 1994b . Legal Issues Arising from the Care, Control and Safety of Children with Learning Disabilities Who Also Present Severe Challenging Behaviour: a Guide for Parents and Carers , London : Mental Health Foundation. .
   Google Scholar
• Madden , D. 1983 . “ ‘Recognition and Prevention of Violence in Psychiatric Facilities’. ” . In Assaults within Psychiatric Facilities , Edited by: Lion , J. R. and Reid , W. H. New York : Grune & Stratton. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• Maier , G. J. and Van Rybroek , G. J. 1990 . ‘Managing Aggression Isn't Pretty’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 41 : 357 editorial
   Google Scholar
• Maier , G. J. , Stava , L. J. , Morrow , B. R. , van Rybroek , G. J. and Bauman , K. G. 1987 . ‘A Model for Understanding and Managing Cycles of Aggression among Psychiatric Patients’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 38 : 520 – 4 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Mason , T. and Chandley , M. 1995 . ‘The Chronically Assaultive Patient: Benchmarking Best Practices’. . Psychiatric Care , 2 ( 5 ) : 180 – 3 . ()
   Google Scholar
• Mehtonen , O. P. , Aranko , K. , Malkonez , L. and Vapaatalo , H. 1991 . ‘Survey of Sudden Death Associated with the Use of Antipsychotic or Antidepressant Drugs: 49 Cases in Finland’. . Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica , 84 : 58 – 64 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mezey , G. and Shepherd , J. 1994 . “ ‘Effects of Assault on Health Care Professionals’. ” . In Violence in Health Care: a Practical Guide to Coping with Violence and Caring for Victims , Edited by: Shepherd , J. Oxford : Oxford University Press. . In (ed.)
   Google Scholar
• Monahan , J. 1993 . “ ‘Mental Disorder and Violence: Another Look’. ” . In Mental Disorder and Crime , Edited by: Hodgins , S. Newbury Park, CA : Sage. . In (ed.)
   Google Scholar
• Morales , E. and Duphorne , P. L. 1995 . ‘Least Restrictive Measures: Alternatives to Four-point Restraints and Seclusion’. . Journal of Psychosocial Nursing , 33 ( 10 ) : 13 – 16 . ()
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Morgan , R. 1992 . ‘The European Torture Committee’. . Journal of Forensic Psychiatry , 3 ( 3 ) : 405 – 8 . ()
   Google Scholar
• Mullen , J. K. 1987 . Safe Physical Management Training Effect: an Investigation of Staff Confidence and Works Norms Related to the Management of Aggressive Clients for the Children's Residential Services of the Commonwealth of Kentucky , New Bloomfield, PA : JKM Training. .
   Google Scholar
• Murphy , G. H. , Oliver , C. , Corbett , J. , Crayton , L. , Hales , J. , Head , D. and Hall , S. 1993 . “ ‘Epidemiology of Self-injury, Characteristics of People with Severe Self-injury and Initial Treatment Outcome’. ” . In Research to Practice? Implications of Research on Challenging Behaviour of People with Learning Disability , Edited by: Kiernan , C. Clevedon : BILD Publications. . In (ed.)
   Google Scholar
• Musto , D. 1991 . “ ‘An Historical Perspective’. ” . In Psychiatric Ethics, , 2nd edn , Edited by: Bloch , S. and Chodoff , P. Oxford : Oxford University Press. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• Nelson , S. H. , McKinney , A. , Ludwig , K. and Davis , R. 1983 . ‘An Unusual Death of a Patient in Seclusion’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 34 : 259
   Google Scholar
• Okin , R. L. 1985 . ‘Variation among State Hospitals in Use of Seclusion and Restraint’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 36 ( 6 ) : 648 – 52 . ()
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Oppenheimer , C. 1991 . “ ‘Ethics and Psychogeriatrics’. ” . In Psychiatric Ethics, , 2nd edn , Edited by: Bloch , S. and Chodoff , P. Oxford : Oxford University Press. . In (eds)
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Oxford Pocket Dictionary , Oxford : Oxford University Press. .
   Google Scholar
• Pace , G. M. , Iwata , B. A. , Edwards , G. L. and McCosh , K. C. 1986 . ‘Stimulus Fading and Transfer in the Treatment of Self-restraint and Self-injurious Behaviour’. . Journal of Applied Behavioural Analysis , 19 : 381 – 9 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ratey , J. J. , Leveroni , C. , Kilmer , D. , Gutheil , C. and Swartz , B. 1993 . ‘The Effects of Clozapine on Severely Aggressive Psychiatric Inpatients in a State Hospital’. . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 54 ( 6 ) : 219 – 23 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Robinson , B. E. , Sucholeiki , R. and Schocken , D. D. 1993 . ‘Sudden Death and Resisted Mechanical Restraint: a Case-report’. . Journal of American Geriatrics Society , 41 ( 4 ) : 424 – 5 . ()
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosen , H. and di Giacomo , J. N. 1978 . ‘The Role of Physical Restraint in the Treatment of Psychiatric Illness’. . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 39 : 228 – 32 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Royal College of Nursing, working group of the forum for nurses caring for the elderly, mentally ill . 1987 . Focus on Restraint: Guidelines on the Use of Restraint in the Care of Elderly People , London : RCN. .
   Google Scholar
• Royal College of Psychiatrists . 1995 . Strategies for the Management of Disturbed and Violent Patients in Psychiatric Units , Council Report CR41 London : RCP .
   Google Scholar
• Royal College of Psychiatrists . 1998 . Management of Imminent Violence: Clinical Practice to Support Mental Health Services , Occasional Paper OP41 London : RCP .
   Google Scholar
• Simpson , G. , Davis , J. , Jefferson , J. W. and Perez-Cruet , J. F. 1988 . Sudden Death in Psychiatric Patients: the Role of Neuroleptic Drugs , Task Force Report no. 27 Washington, DC : American Psychiatric Association .
   Google Scholar
• Smith , R. 1997 . ‘Don't Treat Shackled Patients: and Keep Trying to Understand what the Nuremberg Trials Taught Us’. . British Medical Journal , 314 : 164
   Google Scholar
• Soloff , P. H. , Gutheil , T. G. and Wexler , D. B. 1985 . ‘Seclusion and Restraint in 1985: a Review and Update’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 36 : 652 – 7 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Sovner , R. , Fox , C. J. , Lowry , M. J. and Lowry , M. A. 1993 . ‘Fluoxetine Treatment of Depression and Associated Self-injury in Two Adults with Mental Retardation’. . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 37 : 301 – 11 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Special Hospitals Service Authority . 1993a . Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Death in Broadmoor Hospital of Orville Blackwood and a Review of the Deaths of Two Other Afro-Caribbean Patients: Big, Black and Dangerous , London : SHSA. . ?
   Google Scholar
• Special Hospitals Service Authority . 1993b . The Use of Seclusion and the Alternative Management of Disturbed Behaviour within the Special Hospitals , London : SHSA. .
   Google Scholar
• Strumpf , N. E. and Evans , L. K. 1989 . ‘Tying down the Elderly - a Review of the Literature on Physical Restraints’. . Journal of American Geriatrics Society , 37 : 65 – 74 .
   Google Scholar
• Taylor , P. J. 1993 . “ ‘Mental Illness and Violence’. ” . In Violence in Society , Edited by: Taylor , P. J. London : Royal College of Physicians. . In (ed.)
   Google Scholar
• Telintelo , S. , Kuhlman , T. L. and Winget , C. 1983 . ‘A Study of the Use of Restraint in a Psychiatric Emergency Room’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 34 : 164 – 5 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Thomas , G. 1988 . Journey into Madness: Medical Torture and the Mind Controllers , London : Bantam. .
   Google Scholar
• Van Rybroek , G. J. , Kuhlman , T. L. , Maier , G. J. and Kaye , M. S. 1987 . ‘Preventive Aggression Devices (PADS): Ambulatory Restraints as an Alternative to Seclusion’. . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry , 38 : 882 – 4 .
   Google Scholar
• Way , B. B. 1986 . ‘The Use of Restraint and Seclusion in New York State Psychiatric Centers’. . International Journal of Law and Psychiatry , 8 : 383 – 93 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Way , B. B. and Banks , S. M. 1990 . ‘Use of Seclusion and Restraint in Public Psychiatric Hospitals: Patient Characteristics and Family Effects’. . Hospital and Community Psychiatry , 41 ( 1 ) : 75 – 81 . ()
   Google Scholar
• Wexler , D. B. 1982 . ‘Seclusion and Restraint: Lessons from Law, Psychiatry and Psychology’. . International Journal of Law and Psychiatry , 5 : 285 – 94 .
   Google Scholar
• Whaley , M. S. and Ramirez , L. F. 1980 . ‘The Use of Seclusion Rooms and Physical Restraints in the Treatment of Psychiatric Patients’. . Journal of Psychiatric Nursing and Mental Health Services , 18 : 13 – 16 .
   Google Scholar
• Whitfield , A. 1997 . ‘Commentary: a Decision that Stretches the Law Too Far’. . British Medical Journal , 314 : 1185 – 6 .
   Google Scholar