Phrenology’s frontal sinus problem: An insurmountable obstruction?

References

• Anon. [Brown, T.]. 1803. Lettre de Charles Villers à Georges Cuvier, de l’Institut National de France, &c. A letter from Charles Villers to Georges Cuvier, member of the National Institute of France, on a new theory of brain, as the immediate organ of the moral faculties, by Dr. Gall of Vienna. Edinburgh Review 2: 147–60.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. [Gordon, J.]. 1815. The doctrines of Gall and Spurzheim. Edinburgh Review 25: 227–168.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1828a. Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and phrenology. Correspondence [in the Caledonian Mercury] relative to phrenology, between Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Dr. Spurzheim, and between Sir William Hamilton and Mr George Combe. Phrenological Journal and Miscellany 5: 1–69.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1828b. Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Phrenology. Correspondence [in the Caledonian Mercury] relative to phrenology, between Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Dr. Spurzheim, and between Sir William Hamilton and Mr George Combe, in January, February, and March, 1828. Edinburgh: J. Anderson.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1828c. Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Phrenology. I. Correspondence published in the Caledonian Mercury relative to phrenology, between Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Dr. Spurzheim, and between Sir William Hamilton and Mr George Combe. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1829. Renewed correspondence between Sir William Hamilton, Bart., and Mr George Combe. Phrenological Journal and Miscellany 5: 153–58.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1837-38. Sewall’s lectures on Phrenology. American Medical Intelligencer 1: 76–77.
   Google Scholar
• Anon. 1886. On the frontal sinus. Phrenological Journal of Science and Health 82: 292–96.
   Google Scholar
• Ackermann J. F. 1806. Die Gall’sche Hirn- Schedel- und Organenlehre vom Gesichtspunkte der Erfahrung aus beurtheilt und widerlegt. Heidelberg: Mohr und Zimmer.
   Google Scholar
• Bartholin T. 1677. Anatome quartum renovata. Lugduni: Joan. Ant. Huguetan
   Google Scholar
• Bérard F., and A. F. J. de Montègre. 1813. Cranioscopie. In Dictionnaire des sciences médicales, ed. C. L. F. Panckoucke, Vol. 7, 500–19. Paris: Panckoucke.
   Google Scholar
• Bischoff C. H. E. 1805. Darstellung der Gall’schen Gehirn- und Schädel-Lehre; nebst Bemerkungen über diese Lehre von Christoph Wilh. Hufeland. Berlin: Wittich.
   Google Scholar
• Bischoff C. H. E. 1807. Some account of Dr. Gall’s new theory of physiognomy founded upon the anatomy and physiology of the brain and the form of the skull with the critical strictures of C. W. Hufeland. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme. Translation and Preface by H. C. Robinson.
   Google Scholar
• Caldwell C. 1838. Phrenological vindicated, in a series of remarks, physiological, moral, and critical. New York: Samuel Colman.
   Google Scholar
• Cantor G. N. 1975. The Edinburgh phrenology debate: 1803–1828. Annals of Science 32:195–218. doi:10.1080/00033797500200251.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Combe A. 1823. Remarks on the article Cranioscopy, by Dr Roget, in the Supplement to the Encyclopaedia Britannica. Phrenological Journal and Miscellany 1:165–76.
   Google Scholar
• Combe A. 1838. Remarks on the article Cranioscopy, by Dr Roget, in the Supplement to the Encyclopaedia Britannica. In On the functions of the cerebellum …, ed. G. Combe, 229–40. Edinburgh: MacLachland & Stewart.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1819. Essays on phrenology, or an inquiry into the principles and utility of the system of Drs. Gall and Spurzheim, and into the objections made against it. Edinburgh: MacLachland & Stewart.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1825. A system of phrenology. Edinburgh: John Anderson.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1827. Controversy with Sir William Hamilton. Phrenological Journal and Miscellany 4:377–407.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1828. The constitution of man and its relation to external objects. Edinburgh: John Anderson.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1834. Elements of phrenology. Boston: Marsh, Capen & Lyon.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1838. On the functions of the cerebellum …. Edinburgh: MacLachland & Stewart.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1838-40. Notes on the United States of North America during a phrenological visit in 1838-39-40, Vol. 3. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1873. Elements of phrenology. Edinburgh: MacLachland & Stewart.
   Google Scholar
• Combe G. 1890. A system of phrenology. New York: Fowler & Wells.
   Google Scholar
• Cooter R. J. 1976. Phrenology: The provocation of progress. History of Science 14:211–34. doi:10.1177/007327537601400401.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Cooter R. J. 1984. The cultural meaning of popular science: Phrenology and the organization of consent in nineteenth-century Britain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
   Google Scholar
• de Giustino D. 1975. Conquest of mind: Phrenology and Victorian social thought. London: Croom Helm.
   Google Scholar
• Eling P., and S. Finger. 2019. Franz Joseph Gall on the cerebellum as the organ for the reproductive drive. Frontiers of Neuroanatomy 13 (Article 40):1–13. doi:10.3389/fnana.2019.00040.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Eling P., and S. Finger. 2020. Gall’s German enemies. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 29:70–89.
   Google Scholar
• Eling P., and S. Finger. 2021. Franz Joseph Gall on God and religion: “Dieu et Cerveau, rien que Dieu et cerveau! Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences. Advance online publication. 10.1002/jhbs.22151
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Emblen D. L. 1970. Peter Mark Roget: The word and the man. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell Company.
   Google Scholar
• Finger S., and P. Eling. 2019. Franz Joseph Gall: Naturalist of the mind, visionary of the brain. New York: Oxford University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Finger S., and P. Eling. In press. The quest for objectivity and measurements in phrenology’s “bumpy” history. History of Psychology.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fowler L. N. 1875. Objections to phrenology: Considered and answered. In The Phrenological and Physiological Register, edited by L. N. Fowler, 1–16. London: L. N. Fowler.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J. 1791. Philosophisch-medicinische Untersuchungen über Natur und Kunst im kranken und gesunden Zustande des Menschen. Wien: Rudolph Graffer.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J. 1798. Schreiben über seinen bereits geendigten Prodromus über die Verichtungen des Gehirns der Menschen und der Thiere an Herrn Jos.Fr. von Retzer. Der Neue Teutsche Merkur 3:311–23.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J. 1806. Beantwortung der Ackermannschen Beurtheilung und Widerlegung der Gall’s chen Hirn- Schedel- und Organen-Lehre vom Gesichtspuncte der Erfahrung. Hrsg. von einigen Schülern des Hrn. Dr. Gall, und von ihm selbst berichtigt. Halle: Neue Societäts und Kunsthandlung.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J. 1825. Sur les fonctions du cerveau et sur celles de chacune de ses parties …, Vol. 6. Paris: J.-B. Baillière.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J. 1835. On the functions of the brain and each of its parts …, ed. N. Capen, trans. W. Lewis. Boston: Marsh, Capen and Lyon.
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J., and J. G. Spurzheim. 1810-19. Anatomie et physiologie du système nerveux en général, et du cerveau en particulier, Vol. 4, with an atlas. Paris: F. Schoell. [Gall was the sole author of the last two volumes in this series].
   Google Scholar
• Gall F. J., and J. G. Spurzheim. 1813. Crane. In Dictionnaire des Sciences Médicales, ed. C. L. F. Panckoucke, Vol. 7, 260–69. Paris: Panckoucke.
   Google Scholar
• Hagner M. 2003. Skulls, brains, and memorial culture: On cerebral biographies of scientists in the nineteenth century. Science in Context 16:195–218. doi:10.1017/S0269889703000784.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hamilton W. 1831. An account of experiments on the weight and relative proportions of the brain, cerebellum, and tuber annulare, in man and animals, under the various circumstances of age, sex, country, etc. Preface to A. Monro, The anatomy of the brain, with some observations on its functions, 4–8. Edinburgh: J. Carfrae.
   Google Scholar
• Hamilton W. 1845. Researches on the frontal sciences, with observations on their bearings on the dogmas of phrenology. Medical Times 12:159–160, 177–179, 371–379.
   Google Scholar
• Jackson S. 1832. Principles of medicine. Philadelphia: Carey & Lea.
   Google Scholar
• Kaufman M. H. 1998. The Edinburgh phrenological debate of 1823 held in the Royal Medical Society. Journal of Neurolinguistics 11:377–89. doi:10.1016/S0911-6044(98)00025-6.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kaufman M. H. 1999. Phrenology—Confrontation between Spurzheim and Gordon, 1816. Proceedings of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh 29:150–70.
   Google Scholar
• Kruger L., and S. Finger. 2013. Peter Mark Roget: Physician, scientist, systematist; his thesaurus and his impact on 19th-century neuroscience. In Literature, neurology, and neuroscience: Historical and literary connections, ed. S. Finger, A. Stiles, and F. Boller, 173–95. Oxford/New York: Elsevier.
   Google Scholar
• Lesky E. 1981. Der angeklagte Gall. Gesnerus 38:301–11. doi:10.1163/22977953-0380304002.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Lesky E. 1967. Gall und Herder. Clio Medica 2:85–96.
   Google Scholar
• Monck W. H. S. 1881. Sir William Hamilton. London: Sampson, Low, Marston, Searle, & Rivington.
   Google Scholar
• Noel P. S., and E. T. Carlson. 1970. Origins of the word “phrenology. American Journal of Psychiatry 127:154–57. doi:10.1176/ajp.127.5.694.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Parssinen T. M. 1974. Popular science and society: The phrenology movement in Early Victorian Britain. Journal of the Society for History 8:1–20, 39. doi:10.1353/jsh/8.1.1.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Poskett J. 2019. Materials of mind: Phrenology, race, and the global history of science, 1815–1920. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
   Google Scholar
• Roget P. M. 1824. Cranioscopy. Supplement to the fourth, fifth, and sixth editions of the Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol. 3. Edinburgh: Printed for A. Constable and Co. [Originally published 1818.]. 419-437.
   Google Scholar
• Roget P. M. 1838. Treatises on physiology and phrenology, Vol. 2. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.
   Google Scholar
• Roget P. M. 1839. Outlines of physiology, with an appendix on phrenology. Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard.
   Google Scholar
• Roget P. M. 1842. Phrenology. In Encyclopaedia Britannica, Vol. 17, 454–73. Edinburgh: A. Constable and Co.
   Google Scholar
• Roget P. M. 1852. Thesaurus of English words and phrases …. London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longmans.
   Google Scholar
• Sewall T. 1837. An examination of phrenology; in two lectures, delivered to the students at Columbia College, District of Columbia, February 1837. Washington City: B. Homans.
   Google Scholar
• Sewall T. 1838. An examination of phrenology; in two lectures, delivered to the students at Columbia College, District of Columbia, February 1837. London: James S. Hodson.
   Google Scholar
• Shapin S. 1975. Phrenological knowledge and the social structure of early nineteenth-century Edinburgh. Annals of Science 32:219–43. doi:10.1080/00033797500200261.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sizer N. 1882. Forty years in phrenology; Embracing recollections of history, anecdote, and experience. New York: Fowler & Wells.
   Google Scholar
• Sizer N. 1885. Heads and faces, and how to study them. New York: Fowler & Wells.
   Google Scholar
• Spurzheim J. G. 1815. The physiognomical system of Drs. Gall and Spurzheim … London: Baldwin, Cradock and Joy.
   Google Scholar
• Spurzheim J. G. 1817. Examination of the objections made in Britain against the doctrines of Gall and Spurzheim. Edinburgh: Baldwin, Cradock & Joy. London, Underwood.
   Google Scholar
• Spurzheim J. G. 1818. Observations sur la phraenologie, ou la connaissance de l’homme moral et intellectuel, foundée sue les fonctions du système nerveux. Paris: Treittel at Wurtz.
   Google Scholar
• Spurzheim J. G. 1832. Outlines of phrenology. Boston: Marsh, Capen and Lyon.
   Google Scholar
• Spurzheim J. G. 1833. Examination of the objections made in Britain against the doctrines of Gall and Spurzheim. Boston: Marsh, Capen and Lyon.
   Google Scholar
• Stern M. B. 1971. Heads and headlines: The phrenological Fowlers. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
   Google Scholar
• Temkin O. 1947. Gall and the phrenological movement. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 21:275–321.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Tupper J. P. 1819. An inquiry into Doctor Gall’s system … . London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown.
   Google Scholar
• Van Wyhe J. 2004. Phrenology and the origins of Victorian scientific naturalism. Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
   Google Scholar
• von Froriep L. F. 1802. Über Dr. Gall’s Vorlesung in Wien und das kaiserliche Verbot derselben. Der Neue Teutsche Merkur 2: 248–64.
   Google Scholar
• Whitaker H., and G. Jarema. 2017. The split between Gall and Spurzheim (1813–1818). Journal of the History of the Neurosciences 26:216–23. doi:10.1080/0964704X.2016.1204807.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar