82
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Miscellany

Death, body and soul: The cremation debate in New South Wales, 1863–1925

Pages 323-339 | Published online: 30 Sep 2008

References

  • Aries , P. 1983 . The Hour of Our Death Edited by: Weaver , H. 577 – 8 . London
  • Farrell , J.J. 1980 . Inventing the American Way of Death, 1830–1920 157 – 69 . Philadelphia
  • Curl , J.S. 1980 . A Celebration of Death London chap. 10
  • Morley , J. 1971 . Death, Heaven and the Victorians London chap. 8
  • Inglis , K.S. 1970 . “ ‘Religious Behaviour’ ” . In Australian Society: A Sociological Introduction , 2nd edn Edited by: Davies , A.F. and Encel , S. 469 Melbourne
  • Griffin , G.M. and Tobin , D. 1982 . In the Midst of Life . . . The Australian Response to Death 63 – 9 . Melbourne
  • Thompson , Sir H. 1899 . Modern Cremation , 3rd edn 2 London
  • Lee , S. , ed. 1920 . Dictionary of National Biography: Supplement 1901–1911 503 – 5 . Oxford On Thompson
  • Thompson , Sir H. On Cremation, From ‘The Argus’ of March 1874 Melbourne n.d.
  • Wilson , Sir A. and Levy , H. 1938 . Burial Reform and Funeral Costs London chap. 3
  • Eassie , W. , ed. 1880 . Transactions of the Cremation Society of England Containing a Short History of the Subject of Cremation at Home and Abroad Up to the Date of the Sixth Anniversary of the Society, Jan. 13, 1880 London
  • Leaney , J. 1989 . “ ‘Ashes to Ashes: Cremation and the Celebration of Death in Nineteenth‐Century Britain’ ” . In Death, Ritual and Bereavement Edited by: Houlbrooke , R. 118 – 35 . London
  • Rowell , G. 1970 . “ ‘Nineteenth‐century Attitudes and Practices’ ” . In Dying, Death and Disposal Edited by: Cope , G. 55 London
  • Neild , J.E. 1873 . ‘On the Advantages of Burning the Dead’ . Royal Society of Victoria—Transactions , 11 : 18 – 27 .
  • Australian Dictionary of Biography , 5 327 – 9 . on Neild (hereafter ADB)
  • Love , H. 1989 . James Edward Neild: Victorian Virtuoso Melbourne esp. pp. 308, 310, 351 n.10)
  • 1875 . “ ‘Resurgam’ ” . In Cremation is Not Opposed to the Scriptural Doctrine of the Resurrection Melbourne
  • Atkinson , J. Fife . 1878 . What Shall We Do With Our Dead? Discussed as a Sanitary Question Melbourne
  • Embling , T. 1882 . ‘Premature Interments’ . Victorian Review , 6 May–October : 105 – 19 .
  • Dunstan , K. 1974 . Wowsers Sydney chap. 7
  • 1863 . Empire , 4 November
  • 1863 . Sydney Morning Herald , 4 November : 5 (hereafter SMH
  • 1863 . SMH , 10 November
  • Creed , J.M. 1916 . My Recollections of Australia & Elsewhere 1842–1914 124 London
  • 1884 . The Queen v. Price, Queen's Bench Division , 12 : 247 – 56 .
  • 3 June 1886 . New South Wales Parliamentary Debates , first series vol. 20 , 3 June , 2371 – 2 . 2375 – 6 . (hereafter NSWPD)
  • 24 June 1886 . NSWPD , first series vol. 20 , 24 June , 2924 – 34 .
  • Creed , J.M. 1886 . Cremation Bill: Speech . . . On Moving the Second Reading in the Legislative Council of N.S.W., On June 24 1886 Sydney
  • 1886 . ‘On Cremation’ . Australasian Medical Gazette , 5 July : 252 – 6 .
  • 29 July 1886 . NSWPD , first series vol. 21 , 29 July , 3672
  • ADB , 5 443
  • NSWPD , first series vol. 26 , 1319
  • (NSWPD , first series vol. 28 , 306
  • (NSWPD , first series vol. 29 , 1580
  • NSWPD , first series vol. 26 , 1566 – 7 . but nothing came of it
  • 1890 . New South Wales Cremation Funeral and Sanitary Reform Review , 1 ( 1 ) 26 June : 28
  • Cooke , S. 1989 . “ ‘The Cremation Debate in New South Wales 1886–1933’ ” . University of New South Wales . B.A. (Hons) thesis chap. 3
  • Cremation Society of New South Wales . 1908 . Constitution and By‐Laws ,
  • 1924 . Cremation and Its Cost Sydney
  • 1911 . SMH , 15 December : 4 11 26 March 1914
  • ADB , 3 492 – 3 .
  • 1930 . Medical Journal of Australia , 6 December : 772 – 4 . (hereafter MJA)
  • Macintosh , A. , ed. 1988 . Memoirs of Dr Robert Scot Skirving 1859–1956 292 – 4 . Sydney
  • Carton , S. 1987 . ‘“Once a Drunkard Always a Dunkard”: Social Reform and the Problem of “Habitual Drunkenness” in Australia, 1880–1914’ . Labour History , : 47 – 8 . no. 53
  • 24 June 1886 . NSWPD , first series Vol. 20 , 24 June , 2924 – 34 . esp. pp. 2926, 2928
  • James , T. 1893 . “ ‘Cremation: How Far is its Adoption Desirable in Australasia?’ ” . In Australasian Association for the Advancement of Science: Report of the Fourth Meeting . . . 1892 Edited by: Morton , A. 748 – 9 . published by the Association
  • Fitzgerald , S. 1987 . Rising Damp: Sydney 1870–90 76 Melbourne
  • Creed , J.M. 1923 . ‘Cremation as a Public Health Measure’ . Health , 1 ( 4 ) April : 98
  • 1923 . Cremation: An Essay by Dr. J. Mildred Creed M.L.C. Edited and Revised by Ernest Watt 2 Sydney
  • 1909 . SMH , 14 June : 9
  • Cobb , C. 1925 . Mr Moffatt London
  • Le Goff , J. 1984 . The Birth of Purgatory Edited by: Goldhammer , Arthur . Chicago
  • Goldhammer , Arthur , ed. 1988 . The Medieval Imagination Chicago
  • Parkes , C.M. 1986 . Bereavement: Studies of Grief in Adult Life , 2nd edn 71 85 London
  • Badham , P. 1976 . Christian Beliefs About Life After Death 47 London
  • Richardson , R. 1988 . Death, Dissection and the Desitute Harmondsworth
  • Linebaugh , P. 1975 . “ ‘The Tyburn Riot Against the Surgeons’ ” . In Albion's Fatal Tree: Crime and Society in Eighteenth‐Century England Edited by: Hay , D. 65 – 117 . London
  • Knott , J. 1985 . ‘Popular Attitudes to Death and Dissection in Early Nineteenth Century Britain: The Anatomy Act and the Poor’ . Labour History , : 1 – 18 .
  • Gittings , C. 1988 . Death, Burial and the Individual in Early Modem England London
  • Atkinson , A. and Aveling , M. , eds. 1987 . Australians 1838 422 – 3 . Sydney
  • O'Farrell , P. 1983 . ‘In Search of Hidden Ireland’ . Journal of Religious History , 12 June : 322 – 30 .
  • Jackson , H. 1987 . Churches and People in Australia and New Zealand 1860–1930 44 – 5 . Wellington
  • Creed , J.M. 1890 . Cremation: A Lecture Delivered ...at the Town Hall, Sydney, On Monday, March 3rd 1890 4 Sydney
  • Eassie . Cremation of the Dead , 12 n.1, a work Creed was familiar with
  • 1911 . SMH , 7 December : 10
  • Hickey , S. 1951 . Travelled Roads 12 64 – 5 . Melbourne
  • ADB , 9 281 – 2 .
  • 1910 . SMH , 8 July : 10 (M.J. Fitzgerald) 2 December 1911, p. 19 (G. Kollerstrom)
  • 1886 . Bulletin , 26 June : 3
  • Curl , J.S. 1972 . The Victorian Celebration of Death 163 – 4 . Detroit
  • 1910 . SMH , 2 July : 16
  • 1912 . SMH , 17 January : 18
  • Roe , J. 1986 . Beyond Belief: Theosophy in Australia 1879–1939 246 Kensington
  • 1927 . Australian Theosophist , 15 July : 14
  • 1895 . Theosophy in Australasia , 4 May : 2 11 April 1896, p. 2
  • 1896 . Bulletin , 11 July : 10
  • 1900 . SMH , 19 November : 8
  • 1900 . Daily Telegraph , 20 November : 4
  • 1900 . Sydney Mail , 24 November : 1216
  • 1900 . Freeman's Journal , 1 December : 13
  • 1927 . Advance! Australia , 1 December : 277 – 8 .
  • 1910 . Theosophy in Australasia , 2 May : 33
  • 1902 . An Outline of Theosophy 59 – 61 . Sydney 1915
  • Leadbeater , C.W. The Life after Death and How Theosophy Unveils It Sydney n.d.
  • 1903 . The Soul and Its Vestures Harrogate
  • 1903 . Guardian Angels and Other Unseen Helpers Harrogate
  • Walters , George , ed. 1 May 1901 . Modem Thought 1 May , esp. pp. 4–7
  • 1894 . Daily Telegraph , 11 December
  • Creed . My Recollections , 256 chap. 12
  • Carton , S. 1988 . Medicine and Madness: A Social History of Insanity in New South Wales, 1880–1940 68 Kensington
  • Roe , M. 1984 . Nine Australian Progressives: Vitalism in Bourgeois Social Thought 1890–1960 St Lucia chap. 6
  • 1902 . ‘Newspaper Cuttings’ . S.D. Telegraph , 3 February : 139 op. cit.
  • Zaleski , C. 1987 . Otherworld Journeys: Accounts of Near‐Death Experience in Medieval and Modem Times 48 – 52 . 114 – 17 . Oxford
  • Roe . Beyond Belief , 37 – 41 . 98
  • Smith , F.B. 1964–5 . ‘Spiritualism in Victoria in the Nineteenth Century’ . Journal of Religious History , 3 : 246 – 60 .
  • Addis , W.E. , Arnold , T. and Scannell , T.B. 1909 . A Catholic Dictionary , 8th edn 257 London
  • O'Farrell , P. and O'Farrell , D. , eds. 1969 . Documents in Australian Catholic History vol. 1 , 126 38 – 40 . London and also vol. 2
  • Watson , M. 1905 . Veneration For Our Dead 21 Melbourne Rev. n.d.
  • Nazianzen . 1903 . ‘Cremation of the Dead’ . Austral Light , 1 November : 729
  • Morrison , R.A. 1919 . ‘Cremation: Its Pagan Significance’ . Austral Light , 1 January : 56
  • Clarke , A.G. 1926 . SMH , 21 July Rev. a Catholic Priest replying
  • 1926 . SMH , 20 July
  • 1926 . SMH , 22, 24, 26 July
  • Sutherland‐Gower , Lord R. 1910 . Cleanliness versus Corruption 33 – 4 . London
  • 1929 . SMH , 9 February : 10
  • Inglis , K.S. 1987 . “ ‘Passing Away’ ” . In Australians 1938 Edited by: Gammage , B. and Spearritt , P. 247 Sydney
  • 1933 . SMH , 30 October : 17
  • Grimshaw , P. , McConville , C. and McEwen , E. , eds. 1985 . “ ‘Death and the Family in Nineteenth‐Century Western Australia’ ” . In Families in Colonial Australia 32 – 41 . Sydney
  • Stannage , C.T. , ed. 1981 . “ ‘Western Australian Society: The Religious Aspect 1829–1895’ ” . In A New History of Western Australia 586 – 9 . Nedlands
  • 1977 . “ ‘Time, Death and the Family in Nineteenth Century Western Australia’ ” . Melbourne delivered to the 48th ANZAAS Congress
  • Kingston . 1988 . The Oxford History of Australia, 1860–1900 vol. 3 , 65 Melbourne
  • Faulkner , R. 1984 . ‘Death and the Australian Colonial Family’ . Lilith , : 12 – 22 .
  • 1890 . ‘A Lecture Delivered by Dr R.E. Roth, On Chemical Cremation, at the Town Hall, Sydney, Monday, 9th June, 1890’ . New South Wales Cremation Funeral and Sanitary Reform Review , 19 August : 19 – 28 .
  • Milford , F. 1886 . ‘Cremation’ . Australasian Medical Gazette , 5 July : 249
  • Young , J.A. , eds. 1984 . Centenary Book of the University of Sydney Faculty of Medicine 112 – 15 . Sydney
  • Thompson . On Cremation , 5
  • Creed , Dr. 24 June 1886 . NSWPD , first series vol. 20 , 24 June , 2930
  • Stevens , E.V. 1916 . ‘The Case for Cremation’ . MJA , 8 January : 26
  • Williams , C. 1927 . ‘Cremation: Its Sentimental Side’ . Advance! Australia , 1 August : 87
  • Crucis , Alpha . 1882 . The Song of the Stars; and other poems 86 London
  • Smith , A.G. 1987 . A Biographical Register 1788–1939: Notes from the Name Index of the Australian Dictionary of Biography Edited by: Gibbney , H.J. 4 Canberra and the references cited there
  • 1900 . SMH , 12 April : 8 demanding cremation on hygienic grounds
  • Gorer , G. 1965 . Death, Grief and Mourning in Contemporary Britain 44 London
  • 1893 . The Book of Common Prayer 297 London
  • Prior , L. 1989 . The Social Organization of Death: Medical Discourse and Social Practices in Belfast Basingstoke part 1
  • 1909 . SMH , 17 August : 5
  • Cremation Society of New South Wales . 1909 . Annual Report and Balance Sheet , : 10 – 11 .
  • Troupe , C. E. , Byrne , W.P. and Parsons , H. Franklin . 1903 . Report of the Departmental Committee Appointed . . . to prepare a Draft of the Regulations to be Made Under the Cremation Act 1902 London
  • 22 July 1886 . NSWPD , first series vol. 21 , 22 July , 3531 – 2 . (Mr J. Stewart)
  • 1909 . SMH , 17 August : 5 8 18 25 August 1910 17 January 1912
  • 1898 . ‘The Prevention of Crime’ . D.T. , 5 September newsclipping, attributed
  • Newsclipping . 1886 . Evening News , 24 December
  • Journal of the New South Wales Legislative Council , 40 1885 – 6 . 179 – 265 . part 4
  • Cremation Society of New South Wales . 1908 . Constitution and By‐Laws , : 2
  • Creed . My Recollections , 135
  • Thompson . On Cremation , 5
  • 1890 . New South Wales Cremation Funeral and Sanitary Reform Review , 1 ( 2 ) 19 August : 24
  • Sprott , G. 1897 . ‘The Disposal of Our Dead by Cremation’ . Royal Society of Tasmania—Papers and Proceedings , : 20
  • Scott , Rose . 1909 . February untitled speech in Scott Family Papers, MSS 38/56, item 1, ML.
  • 1910 . SMH , 25 August : 8
  • 1910 . ‘Newspaper Cuttings’ . S. Times , 11 September
  • 1911 . SMH , 10 March : 11 14 3 May 1911
  • Thompson . On Cremation , 5
  • Armstrong , W.G. 1917 . ‘Cremation’ . MJA , 28 July : 72
  • 1932 . SMH , 2 March : 18 5 10 May 1932
  • Poe , E.A. 1844 . “ ‘The Premature Burial’ ” . In The Tales and Poems of Edgar Allan Poe vol. 4 , 129 – 46 . London 1884
  • Hadwen , W.R. , Tebb , W. , Vollum , E. and Hadwen , W.R. 1896 . Premature Burial and How it May be Prevented With Special Reference to Trance, Catalepsy, and Other Forms of Suspended Animation , 2nd edn 21 – 2 . London esp. chaps 91905
  • McManners , J. 1981 . Death and the Enlightenment: Changing Attitudes to Death among Christians and Unbelievers in Eighteenth‐century France 48 – 9 . London
  • Gilbert , A. 1987 . “ ‘Old Age and Death’ ” . In Australians 1888 Edited by: Davison , G. , McCarty , J.W. and McLeary , A. 323 – 41 . Sydney
  • * Many people have assisted me in the preparation of this article. In particular, I would like to thank David Walker for reading several drafts and Margaret Cooke for typing them for me.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.