Development of a Gear Oil Scuff Test (GOST) Procedure to Predict Adhesive Wear Resistance of Turbine Engine Lubricants

REFERENCES

• “ Standard Test Method for Load Carrying Capacity of Petroleum Oil and Synthetic Fluid Gear Lubricants ,” ASTM Standard D1947-83 , ASTM , Philadelphia , PA , ( 1983 ).
   Google Scholar
• Eusepi , M. W. and Dill , J. F. , “ Twin Disc Gear Tooth Simulator ,” Wright Laboratories Report No. TR-94-2055 , Wright Laboratory , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1994 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Nomenclature of Gear Tooth Failure Modes ,” ANSI/AGMA 110.04 , AGMA , ( 1980 ).
   Google Scholar
• Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology , Blau , P. J. , ed., ASM Handbook , 18 , ASM , Materials Park , OH , p 535 , ( 1992 ).
   Google Scholar
• Ku , P. M. , Staph , H. E. , Carper , H. J. and Anderson , E. L. , “ Lubricant/ Metallurgy Interaction Effects on Turbine Engine Lubricant Load Rating ,” AFAPL Report No. AFAPL-TR-76-27 , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1976 ).
   Google Scholar
• Davoli , P. and Fattori , S. , “ An Experimental Study on the Effect of Lubricant on Surface Fatigue of Cr-Mo Steel Gears ,” ASME Paper No. 84-DET-225 , ASME , New York , ( 1984 ).
   Google Scholar
• Bosniac , D. S. and Metro , S. J. , “ Performance Advantages of High-Load Aviation Lubricants ,” in Aviation Gas Turbine Lubricants , SAE SP 633 , SAE , Warrendale , PA , pp 19 – 32 ( 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Blok , H. , “ Theoretical Study of Temperature Rise at Surfaces of Actual Contact Under Oiliness Lubrication Conditions ,” in Proc. General Discussion on Lubrication and Lubricants , 2 , IMechE , London , pp 222 – 235 ( 1937 ).
   Google Scholar
• Wisniewski , M. R. and Janczak , K. J. , “ Temperatures of Meshing Gears Under Conditions of Elastohydrodynamic Lubrication ,” Wear , 67 , pp 25 – 30 ( 1981 )
   Google Scholar
• Bathgate , J. , Kendall , R. B. and Moorhouse , P. , “ Thermal Aspects of Gear Lubrication ,” Wear , 15 , pp 117 – 129 ( 1970 ).
   Google Scholar
• Towle , A. and Graham , R. , “ The Scuffing of Automobile Gears ,” Chartered Mech. Eng. , 21 , 10 , pp 99 – 104 ( 1974 ).
   Google Scholar
• Beane , G. A. and Lawler , C. W. , “ Lubricant Evaluation with WADD High-Temperature Gear Machine ,” in Proc. of Gear Lubrication Symp. , 37 , p 1 , ( 1964 ).
   Google Scholar
• Beane , G. A. and Lawler , C. W. , “ Load Carrying Capacities of Gear Lubricants of Different Chemical Classes Based on Results Obtained with WADD High-Temperature Gear Machine Used with Induction Heated Test Gears ,” AFAPL Technical Report No. AFAPL-TR-65-23 , Air Force Aero Propulsion Laboratory , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1965 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Load Carrying Capacity of Lubricating Oils (Ryder Gear Machine) ,” Federal Test Method Standard No. 791C, Method 6508.2 , Naval Air Warfare Center , Trenton , NJ , ( 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Standard Test Method for Evaluating the Scuffing (Scoring) Load Capacity in Oils ,” ASTM Standard D5182 , ASTM , Philadelphia , PA , ( 1991 ).
   Google Scholar
• Michaelis , K. , “ Testing Procedures for Gear Lubricants with the FZG Test Rig ,” Industrial Lubr. and Trib. , 13 , 4 , pp 91 – 94 ( 1974 ).
   Google Scholar
• Lake , E. A. , “ A Study of Selected Parameters Influencing Lubricant Load Carrying Capacity Determination ,” WPAFB Report No. AFAPL-TR-74-98 , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1975 ).
   Google Scholar
• Rao , N. S. , Maciejewski , A. S. and Senholzi , P. B. , “ Precision Measurement of Gear Lubricant Load Carrying Capacity (Feasibility Study) ,” Report No. AFWAL-TR-81-2107 , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1981 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Temporary Methods for Assessing the Load Carrying Capacity of Aircraft Propulsion System Lubricating Oils ,” SAE Aircraft Information Report No. 4978 , SAE , Warrendale , PA , ( 1996 ).
   Google Scholar
• Nicolson , D. M. and Sayles , R. S. , “ Research on a Mini-Disc Machine for Gear Testing ,” AFWAL Report No. TR-87-2081 , Air Force Wright Aeronautical Laboratories , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1988 ).
   Google Scholar
• Winter , H. and Michaelis , K. , “ Scoring Tests of Aircraft Transmission Lubricants at High Speeds and High Temperatures ,” National Technical Information Service Report No. AD-P005069 , ( 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Michaelis , K. and Winter , H. , “ Development of a High Temperature FZG-Ryder Gear Lubricant Load Capacity Machine ,” WPAFB Report No. WRDC-TR-89-2028 , Wright Research and Development Center , Wright Patterson AFB , OH , ( 1989 ).
   Google Scholar
• Lacey , P. I. , “ Development of a Gear Oil Scuff Test (GOST) Procedure to Predict Lubricant Quality as Measured by the Ryder Gear Test ,” Letter Report No. TFLRF-96-002 , U.S. Army TARDEC Fuels and Lubricants Research Facility, Southwest Research Institute , San Antonio , TX , ( 1996 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Standard Test Method for Kinematic Viscosity of Transparent and Opaque Liquids (and the Calculation of Dynamic Viscosity) ,” ASTM Standard D 445-94 , Philadelphia , PA , ( 1994 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Standard Test Method for Measuring Apparent Viscosity by Capillary Viscometer at High-Temperature and High-Shear Rates ,” ASTM Standard D 4624-93 , Philadelphia , PA , ( 1993 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Lubricating Oil, Aircraft Turbine Engine, Synthetic Base ,” MIL-L-23699, NATO Code No. O-156 , Naval Air Systems Command , Arlington , VA , ( 1994 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Lubricating Oil, Helicopter Transmission System, Synthetic Base ,” DOD-L-85734 , Naval Air Warfare Center , Trenton , NJ , ( 1986 ).
   Google Scholar
• Hadley , J. W. and Blackhurst , P. , “ An Appraisal of the Ball-on-Cylinder Technique for Measuring Aviation Turbine Fuel Lubricity ,” Lubr. Eng. , 47 , 5 , pp 404 – 411 ( 1991 ).
   Google Scholar
• Lacey , P. I. , “ Development of a Lubricity Test Based on the Transition from Boundary Lubrication to Severe Adhesive Wear in Fuels ,” Lubr. Eng. , 50 , 10 , ( 1994 ).
   Google Scholar
• “ Test Method for Measurement of Lubricity of Aviation Turbine Fuels by the Ball on Cylinder Lubricity Evaluator (BOCLE) , ASTM Standard D 5001 , Philadelphia , PA , ( 1989 ).
   Google Scholar
• Lacey , P. I. , “ Development of a Laboratory Scale Wear Test Based on the Transition from Boundary Lubrication to Severe Adhesive Wear in Fuels ,” Lubr. Eng. , 50 , 10 , pp 749 – 757 ( 1994 ).
   Google Scholar
• Odi-Owei , S. , Roylance , B. J. and Xie , L. Z. , “ An Experimental Study of Initial Scuffing and Recovery in Sliding Wear Using a Four-Ball Machine ,” Wear , 117 , pp 267 – 287 ( 1987 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Torrance , A. A. and Cameron , A. , “ Surface Transformations in Scuffing ,” Wear , 28 , pp 299 – 311 ( 1974 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Durkee , D. B. and Cheng , H. S. , “ An Examination of a Possible Mode of Scuffing Failure in Simple Sliding ,” Wear , 59 , pp 223 – 230 ( 1980 ).
   Google Scholar
• Naruse , C. and Haizuka , S. , “ Limiting Loads for Scoring and Coefficient of Friction on a Disc Machine, Effects of Lubricating Oil, Specific Sliding and Sliding Velocity, in the Case of Steel/Steel ,” Bull, of the JSME , 21 , 158 , pp 1311 – 1316 ( 1978 ).
   Google Scholar
• Matveevsky , R. M. , “ The Critical Temperature of Oil With Point and Line Contact Machines ,” ASME Jour. Basic Eng. , 87D , pp 102 – 117 ( 1965 ).
   Google Scholar
• Archard , J. F. , “ The Temperature of Rubbing Surfaces ,” Wear , 2 , pp 438 – 455 ( 1958 /1959).
   Google Scholar
• Palacios , J. M. , “ Films Formed by Antiwear Additives and Their Incidence in Wear and Scuffing ,” Wear , 114 , pp 41 – 49 ( 1987 ).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Naruse , C. , Haizuka , S. and Nemoto , R. , “ Studies on Limiting Load for Scoring of Spur Gears, (Effects of Zn-P Anti-Wear Agent by Means of FZG Gear Test Rig) ,” Bull. Of the JSME , 22 , 164 , pp 367 – 381 ( 1979 ).
   Google Scholar
• Hoshino , M. and Nakayama , T. , “ Effective Viscosity of Polymer Thickened Oils in Gear Lubrication, Part II ,” SAE Paper No. 852114 , SAE , Warrendale , PA , ( 1985 ).
   Google Scholar
• Walker , D. L. , Sanborn , D. M. and Winer , W. O. , “ Molecular Degradation of Lubricants in Sliding Elastohydrodynamic Contacts ,” ASME Jour. Lubr. Tech. , 97F , 3 , p 390 , ( 1975 ).
   Google Scholar
• Hoshino , M. and Nakayama , T. , “ Effective Viscosity of Polymer Thickened Oils in Gear Lubrication ,” SAE Paper No. 811205 , SAE , Warrendale , PA , ( 1981 ).
   Google Scholar
• Born , M. , Hipeaux , J. C. , Marchand , P. and Pare , G. , “ The Relationship Between Chemical Structure and Effectiveness of Some Metallic Dialkyland Diaryl-dithiophosphales in Different Lubricated Mechanisms ,” Lubr. Sci. , 4 , 2 , pp 94 – 116 ( 1992 ).
   Google Scholar
• Lacey , P. I. , “ A Laboratory Test to Prcdict Lubricant Quality as Measured by the FZG Load Stage Test ,” SAE Paper No. 972953 , SAE , Warrendale , PA , ( 1997 ).
   Google Scholar