Publication Cover
Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part C
Environmental Carcinogenesis and Ecotoxicology Reviews
Volume 27, 2009 - Issue 2
882
Views
92
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Predictive Models for Carcinogenicity and Mutagenicity: Frameworks, State-of-the-Art, and Perspectives

, , , , , , , , , , , & show all
Pages 57-90 | Received 29 Jan 2009, Accepted 09 Mar 2009, Published online: 01 May 2009

REFERENCES

  • StruCture-Activity Relationships Leading ExperTs in mutagenicity and carcinogenicity (SCARLET) Available at: http://scarlet-project.eu European Commission Project SPSA-CT-2007-014166
  • Moore , M M , Honma , M , Clements , J , Bolcsfoldi , G , Burlinson , B , Cifone , M , Clarke , J , Delongchamp , R , Durward , R , Fellows , M , Gollapudi , B , Hou , S , Jenkinson , P , Lloyd , M , Majeska , J , Myhr , B , O'Donovan , M , Omori , T , Riach , C , San , R , Stankowski , L F Jr , Thakur , A , Van Goethem , F , Wakuri , S and Yoshimura , I . 2006 . Mouse Lymphoma Thymidine Kinase Gene Mutation Assay: Follow-up Meeting of the International Workshop on Genotoxicity Tests-Aberdeen, Scotland, 2003—Assay acceptance criteria, positive controls, and data evaluation . Environ Mol Mutagen , 47 : 1 – 5 .
  • Kirkland , D , Pfuhler , S , Tweats , D , Aardema , M , Corvi , R , Darroudi , F , Elhajouji , A , Glatt , H , Hastwell , P , Hayashi , M , Kasper , P , Kirchner , S , Lynch , A , Marzin , D , Maurici , D , Meunier , J-R , Müller , L , Nohynek , G , Parry , J , Parry , E , Thybaud , V , Tice , R , van Benthem , J , Vanparys , P and White , P . 2007 . How to reduce false positive results when undertaking in vitro genotoxicity testing and thus avoid unnecessary follow-up animal tests: Report of an ECVAM Workshop . Mutation Research , 628 : 31 – 55 .
  • Snyder , R D , Ewing , D E and Hendry , L B . 2004 . Evaluation of DNA intercalation potential of pharmaceuticals and other chemicals by cell-based and three-dimensional computational approaches . Environ Mol Mutagen , 44 : 163 – 173 .
  • Snyder , R D , Ewing , D and Hendry , L . 2006 . DNA intercalative potential of marketed drugs testing positive in in vitro cytogenetics assays . Mutation Res , 609 : 47 – 59 .
  • van der Lelie , D , Regniers , L , Borremans , B , Provoost , A and Verschaeve , L . 1997 . The VITOTOX® test, an SOS bioluminescence Salmonella typhimurium test to measure genotoxicity kinetics . Mutagenesis , 20 : 449 – 454 .
  • Verschaeve , L , Van Gompel , J , Thilemans , L , Regniers , L , Vanparys , P and van der Lelie , D . 1999 . VITOTOX® bacterial genotoxicity and toxicity test for the rapid screening of chemicals . Environ Mol Mutagen , 33 : 240 – 248 .
  • Van Gompel , J , Woestenborghs , F , Beerens , D , Mackie , C , Cahill , P A , Knight , A W , Billinton , N , Tweats , D J and Walmsley , R M . 2005 . An assessment of the utility of the yeast GreenScreen assay in pharmaceutical screening . Mutagenesis , 20 : 449 – 454 .
  • Pastink , A , Eeken , J CJ and Lohman , P HM . 2001 . Genomic integrity and the repair of double-strand DNA breaks . Mut Res , 480-481 : 37 – 50 .
  • Clever , B , Interthal , H , Schmuckli-Maurer , J , King , J , Sigrist , M and Heyer , W-F . 1997 . Recombinational repair in yeast: functional interactions between Rad51 and Rad54 proteins . EMBO J , 16 : 2535 – 2544 .
  • Sonoda , E , Sasaki , M S , Buerstedde , J-M , Bezzubova , O , Shinohara , A , Ogawa , H , Takata , M , Yamaguchi-Iwai , Y and Takeda , S . 1998 . Rad51-deficient vertebrate cells accumulate chromosomal breaks prior to cell death . EMBO J , 17 : 598 – 608 .
  • Arbel , A , Zenvirth , D and Simchen , G . 1999 . Sister chromatid-based DNA repair is mediated by RAD54, not by DMC1 or TID1 . EMBO J , 18 : 2648 – 2658 .
  • Dronkert , M LG , Beverloo , H B , Johnson , R D , Hoeijmakers , J HJ , Jasin , M and Kanaar , R . 2000 . Mouse RAD54 affects DNA Double-strand break repair and sister chromatid exchange . Mol Cell Biol , 20 : 3147 – 3156 .
  • Van Gompel , J , Woestenborghs , F , Beerens , D , Mackie , C , Cahill , P A , Knight , A W , Billinton , N , Tweats , D J and Walmsley , R M . 2005 . An assessment of the utility of the yeast GreenScreen assay in pharmaceutical screening . Mutagenesis , 20 : 449 – 454 .
  • Billinton , N , Barker , M G , Michel , C E , Knight , A W , Heyer , W-D , Goddard , N J , Fielden , P R and Walmsley , R M . 1998 . Development of a green fluorescent protein reporter for a yeast genotoxicity biosensor . Biosensores Bioelectronics , 13 : 831 – 838 .
  • Cahill , P A , Knight , A W , Billington , N , Barker , M G , Walsh , L , Keenan , P O , Williams , C V , Tweats , D J and Walmsley , R M . 2004 . The GreenScreen® genotoxicity assays: a screening validation programme . Mutagenesis , 19 : 105 – 119 .
  • Knight , A W , Billinton , N , Cahill , P A , Scott , A , Harvey , J S , Roberts , K J , Tweats , D J , Keenan , P O and Walmsley , R M . 2007 . An analysis of results from 305 compounds tested with the yeast RAD54-GFP genotoxicity assay (GreenScreen GC)—including relative predictivity of regulatory tests and rodent carcinogenesis and performance with autofluorescent and coloured compounds . Mutagenesis , 22 : 409 – 416 .
  • Cole , G M , Schild , D , Lovett , S T and Mortimer , R K . 1987 . Regulation of RAD54- and RAD52-lacZ gene fusions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae in response to DNA damage . Mol Cell Biol , 7 : 1078 – 1084 .
  • Averbeck , D and Averbeck , S . 1994 . Induction of the genes RAD54 and RNR2 by various damaging agents in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mut Res , 315 : 123 – 138 .
  • Joosten , H FP , Acker , F AA , Dobbelsteen van den , D J , Horbach , G JMJ and Krajnc , E I . 2004 . Genotoxicity of hormonal steroids . Toxicol Lett , 151 : 113 – 134 .
  • International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) . Available at: http://www.iarc.fr/ENG/Databases/index.php
  • Zhao , C , Boriani , E , Chana , A , Roncaglkioni , A and Benfenati , E . 2008 . A new hybrid system of QSAR models for predicting bioconcentration factor (BCF) . Chemosphere , 73 : 1701 – 1707 .
  • EPA DSSTox . 2009 . U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's Distributed Structure-Searchable Toxicity (DSSTox) Database Network Available at: http://www.epa.gov/ncct/dsstox/
  • Benigni , R , Bossa , C , Jeliazkova , N G , Netzeva , T I and Worth , A P . 2008 . The Benigni/Bossa rulebase for mutagenicity and carcinogenicity—a module of Toxtree , Luxembourg : Office for the Official Publications of the European Communities . Report EUR 23241 EN. EUR—Scientific and Technical Report Series
  • Benigni , R , Bossa , C , Netzeva , T I and Worth , A P . 2007 . Collection and evaluation of (Q)SAR models for mutagenicity and carcinogenicity , EUR—Scientific and Technical Research Series Luxembourg : Office for the Official Publications of the European Communities . EUR 22772 EN
  • Benigni , R and Bossa , C . 2008 . Predictivity and reliability of QSAR models: the case of mutagens and carcinogens . Toxicol Mechanisms Meth , 18 : 137 – 47 .
  • Benigni , R , Netzeva , T I , Benfenati , E , Bossa , C , Rainer , R , Helma , C , Hulzebos , E , Marchant , C , Richard , A , Woo , Y-T and Yang , C . 2007 . The expanding role of predictive toxicology: an update on the (Q)SAR models for mutagens and carcinogens . J Environ Sci Health C Environ Carcinog Ecotoxicol Revs , 25 : 53 – 97 .
  • European Partnership for Alternative Approaches to animal testing (EPAA) . Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/epaa/brochure.htm
  • Brown , D and Superti-Furga , G . 2003 . Rediscovering the sweet spot in drug discovery . Drug Discovery Today , 8 : 1067 – 1077 .
  • DiMasi , J A . 2001 . Risks in new drug development: Approval success rates for investigational drugs . Clin Pharmacol Ther , 69 : 297 – 307 .
  • Kola , I and Landis , J . 2004 . Can the pharmaceutical industry reduce attrition rates? . Nature Reviews Drug Discovery , 3 : 711 – 715 .
  • Fingerhut , M A , Halperin , W E , Marlow , D A , Piacitelli , L A , Honchar , P A , Sweeney , M H , Greife , A L , Dill , P A , Steenland , K and Suruda , A J . 1991 . Cancer mortality in workers exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin . N Engl J Med , 324 : 212 – 218 .
  • Manz , A , Berger , J , Dwyer , J H , Flesch-Janys , D , Nagel , S and Waltsgott , H . 1991 . Cancer mortality among workers in chemical plant contaminated with dioxin . Lancet , 338 : 959 – 964 .
  • Zober , A , Messerer , P and Huber , P . 1990 . Thirty-four-year mortality follow-up of BASF employees exposed to 2,3,7,8-TCDD after the 1953 accident . Int Arch Occup Environ Health , 62 : 139 – 157 .
  • Westerink , W MA , Stevenson , J CR and Schoonen , W GEJ . 2008 . Pharmacologic profiling of human and rat cytochrome P450 1A1 and 1A2 induction and competition . Arch Toxicol , 82 : 909 – 921 . Doi 10.1007/S00204-008-0317-7
  • Snyder , R D and Smith , M D . 2005 . Computational prediction of genotoxicity: room for improvement . Drug Discovery Today , 10 : 1119 – 1124 .
  • Ertl , P , Roggo , S and Schuffenhauer , A . 2008 . Natural Product-likeness score and its application for prioritization of compound libraries . J Chem Inf Model , 48 : 68 – 74 .
  • Contrera , J F , Jacobs , A C and DeGeorge , J J . 1997 . Carcinogenicity testing and the evaluation of regulatory requirements for pharmaceuticals . Regul Toxicol Pharmacol , 25 : 130 – 145 .
  • CCRIS (Chemical Carcinogenesis Research Information System), developed and maintained by National Cancer Institute . Available at: http://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/htmlgen?CCRIS
  • Available at: http://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/htmlgen?GENETOX Gene-Tox: Created by US EPA
  • National Toxicology Program (NTP) . Available at: http://ntp.niehs.nih.gov
  • International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) . INCHEM, a product cooperation between the International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) and the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety (CCOHS) Available at: http://www.inchem.org/
  • IRIS EPA . Integrated risk information system for carcinogen classification, originally prepared in US EPA Available at: http://www.epa.gov/iris/index.htm
  • FDA Cooperative Research and Development Agreemen) database. Leadscope Available at: http://www.leadscope.com/fda_databases/
  • Tokyo-Eiken, Tokyo Metropolitan Institute of Public Health providing primary mutagenicity of food additives for about 300 chemicals Available at: http://www.tokyo-eiken.go.jp/henigen/
  • The Mutants, a database of mutagenicity/genetic toxicity database sponsored by Dr. Motoi Ishidate Available at: http://members.jcom.home.ne.jp/mo-ishidate/index.html
  • Available at: http://potency.berkeley.edu/chemicalsummary.html CPDB Summary Tables. Summary Table of Chemicals in the Carcinogenic Potency Database: Results for Positivity, Potency (TD50), and Target Sites. 2007
  • Gold , L S , Slone , T H , Williams , C R , Burch , J M , Stewart , T W , Swank , A E , Beidler , J and Richard , A M . 2008 . DSSTox Carcinogenic Potency Database Summary Tables—All Species, SDF Files and Documentation, CPDBAS_v5c_1547_20NOV2008 Available at: http://www.epa.gov/ncct/dsstox/sdf_cpdbas.html
  • Benigni , R , Bossa , C , Richard , A M and Yang , C . 2008 . A novel approach: chemical relational databases, and the role of the ISSCAN database on assessing chemical carcinogenicity . Ann Ist Super Sanità , 44 : 48 – 56 .
  • Ohio, , USA : Leadscope Inc. . http://www.leadscope.com
  • Leeds, , UK : Lhasa Limited . http://www.lhasalimited.org/
  • RTECS Registry of toxic effects of chemical substances, created by NIOSH, maintained and marketed by MDL Symix Available at: http://mdl.com/products/predictive/rtecs/index.jsp
  • Available at: http://www.multicase.com/products/prod01.htm MultiCASE MC4PC
  • Available at: http://accelrys.com/products/discovery-studio/toxicology/ TOPKAT
  • MDL QSAR . Available at: http://www.mdl.com/products/predictive/qsar/index.jsp
  • Available at: http://www.leadscope.com/product_info.php?products_id=66 Leadscope FDA Model Applier
  • OncoLogic. A computer system to evaluate the carcinogenic potential of chemicals Available at: http://www.epa.gov/oppt/newchems/tools/oncologic.htm
  • LAZAR (Lazy Structure Activity Relationship) . Available at: http://www.predictive-toxicology.org/lazar/
  • Available at: http://ecb.jrc.it/qsar/ Toxtree
  • Benigni , R . 2005 . Structure-activity relationship studies of chemical mutagens and carcinogens: mechanistic investigations and prediction approaches . Chem Revs , 105 : 1767 – 1800 .
  • Sello , G , Sala , L and Benfenati , E . 2001 . Predicting toxicity: A mechanism of action model of chemical mutagenicity . Mutat Res Fundam Mol Mech Mutag , 479 : 141 – 171 .
  • Fung , V A , Huff , J , Weisburger , E K and Hoel , D G . 1993 . Predictive strategies for selecting 379 NCI/NTP chemicals evaluated for carcinogenic potential: scientific and public health impact . Fund Appl Toxicol , 20 : 413 – 36 .
  • Benigni , R . 2005 . Structure-activity relationship studies of chemical mutagens and carcinogens: mechanistic investigations and prediction approaches . Chem Revs , 105 : 1767 – 800 .
  • Benigni , R and Bossa , C . 2008 . Predictivity of QSAR . J Chem Inf Model , 48 : 971 – 980 .
  • Piegorsch , W W and Zeiger , E . 1991 . “ Measuring intra-assay agreement for the Ames Salmonella assay ” . In Lecture Notes in Medical Information (Statistical Methods in Toxicology) , Edited by: Rienhoff , O and Lindberg , D AB . 35 – 41 . Berlin : Springer-Verlag .
  • OECD . 2004 . The Report from the Expert Group on (Quantitative) Structure Activity Relationship ([Q]SARs) on the Principles for the Validation of (Q)SARs 49Paris OECD. OECD Series on Testing and Assessment
  • Katzius , J , McGuire , R and Bursi , R . 2005 . Derivation and validation of toxicophores for mutagenicity prediction . J Med Chem , 48 : 312 – 320 .
  • Ferrari , T and Gini , G . 2008 . A new Predictive Model of Mutagenicity, with statistical analysis and validation using data-mining tools in WEKA . Poster presented at SCARLET workshop . April 2–4 2008 , Milan, Italy. Available at: http://www.scarlet-project.eu/posters/Ferrari_T-scarlet.pdf
  • Toropov , A A , Toropova , A P and Benfenati , E . 2008 . QSAR modelling of carcinogenicity and mutagenic potentials by optimal SMILES-based descriptors . Poster presented at SCARLET workshop . April 2–4 2008 , Milan, Italy. Available at: http://www.scarlet-project.eu/posters/Toropov_A-scarlet.pdf
  • Martin , T M , Harten , P , Venkatapathy , R , Das , S and Young , D M . 2008 . A hierarchical clustering methodology for the estimation of toxicity . Toxicol Mech Method , 18 : 251 – 266 .
  • Romesburg , H C . 1984 . Cluster Analysis for Researchers , Belmont, CA : Lifetime Learning Publications .
  • Contrera , J F , Matthews , E J and Benz , R D . 2003 . Predicting the carcinogenic potential of pharmaceuticals in rodents using molecular structural similarity and E-state indices . Regulat Toxicol Pharmacol , 38 : 243 – 259 .
  • Franke , R , Gruska , A , Giuliani , A and Benigni , R . 2001 . Prediction of rodent carcinogenicity of aromatic amines: a quantitative structure-activity relationships model . Carcinogenesis , 22 ( 9 ) : 1561 – 1571 .
  • Bristol , D W , Wachsman , J T and Greenwell , A . 1996 . The NIEHS Predictive-Toxicology Evaluation Project . Environ Health Persp , 104 ( Supplement 5 ) : 1001 – 1010 .
  • Benigni , R and Richard , A M . 1996 . QSARS of mutagens and carcinogens: Two case studies illustrating problems in the construction of models for noncongeneric chemicals . Mutat Res , 371 : 29 – 46 .
  • Dix , D J , Houck , K A , Martin , T M , Richard , A M , Setzer , W and Kavlock , R J . 2007 . The ToxCast™ program for prioritizing toxicity testing of environmental chemicals . Tox Sci , 95 : 5 – 12 .
  • Richard , A M , Yang , C and Judson , R . 2008 . Toxicity Data Informatics: Supporting a New Paradigm for Toxicity Prediction . Tox Mech Meth , 18 : 103 – 118 .
  • Richard , A M . 2006 . Future of Predictive Toxicology: An Expanded View of “Chemical Toxicity”—Future of Toxicology Perspective . Chem Res Toxicol , 19 : 1257 – 1262 .
  • Richard , A M and Williams , C R . 2002 . “ Public sources of mutagenicity and carcinogenicity data: Use in structure-activity relationship models ” . In QSARs of Mutagens and Carcinogens , Edited by: Benigni , R . 145 – 173 . New York : CRC Press .
  • Richard , A M , Yang , C and Judson , R . 2008 . Toxicity Data Informatics: Supporting a New Paradigm for Toxicity Prediction . Tox Mech Method , 18 : 103 – 118 .
  • NCBI PubChem . 2007 . National Institutes of Health, National Library of Medicine, National Center for Biotechnology Information, PubChem Project Available at: http://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
  • Transue , T and Richard , A M . 2008 . U.S. Environmental Protection Agency DSSTox Structure-Browser v2.0 Available at: http://www.epa.gov/dsstox_structurebrowser/
  • National Research Council (NRC) . 2007 . Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: A Vision and a Strategy , Washington, DC : National Academies Press .
  • Collins , F S , Gray , G M and Bucher , J R . 2008 . Transforming Environmental Health Protection . Science , 319 : 906 – 907 .
  • Martin , T M , Houck , K A , McLaurin , K , Richard , A M and Dix , D J . 2007 . Linking Regulatory Toxicological Information on Environmental Chemicals with High-Throughput Screening (HTS) and Genomic Data. The Toxicologist CD . J Soc Toxicol , 96 : 219 – 220 .
  • Yang , C , Benz , R D and Cheeseman , M A . 2006 . Landscape of current toxicity databases and database standards . Curr Opin Drug Discovery Develop , 9 : 124 – 133 .
  • Houck , K , Dix , D , Judson , R , Martin , M , Wolf , M , Kavlock , R and Richard , A M . 2008 . DSS ToxEPA ToxCast High Throughput Screening Testing Chemicals Structure-Index File: SDF File and Documentation: TOXCST_v3a_320_12FEB2009 Available at: http://www.epa.gov/ncct/dsstox/sdf_toxcst.html
  • Judson , R , Richard , A M , Dix , D , Elloumi , F , Martin , M , Cathey , T , Transue , T , Spencer , R and Wolf , M . 2008 . ACToR—Aggregated Computational Toxicology Resource . Toxicol Appl Pharmacol , 233 : 7 – 13 .
  • ACToR . Aggregated Computational Toxicology Resource Available at: http://actor.epa.gov/actor/
  • 2009 . EPA ToxCast. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's National Center for Computational Toxicology ToxCastTM Program Available at: http://www.epa.gov/comptox/toxcast/
  • Zhu , H , Rusyn , I , Richard , A M and Tropsha , A . 2008 . The Use of Cell Viability Assay Data Improves the Prediction Accuracy of Conventional Quantitative Structure Activity Relationship Models of Animal Carcinogenicity . Enviro Health Persp , 116 : 506 – 513 .
  • Yang , C , Arnby , C H , Arvidson , K , Aveston , S , Benigni , R , Benz , R D , Boyer , S , Contrera , J , Dierkes , P , Han , X , Jaworska , J , Kemper , R A , Kruhlak , N L , Matthews , E J , Rathman , J F and Richard , A M . 2008 . Understanding Genetic Toxicity through Data-mining: The Process of Building Knowledge by Integrating Multiple Genetic Toxicity Databases . Tox Mech Method , 18 : 277 – 295 .
  • http://www.leadscope.com/toxml_editor Leadscope Inc. ToxML editor. Ohio USA
  • Ashby , J . 1985 . Fundamental structural alerts to potential carcinogenicity or non-carcinogenicity . Environ Mutagen , 7 : 919 – 921 .
  • Klassen , C D . 1996 . Casarett & Doull's Toxicology: The basic science of poisons , New York : McGraw-Hill .
  • Yang , C , Richard , A M and Cross , K P . 2006 . The Art of Data-mining the Minefields of Toxicity Databases to Link Chemistry to Biology . Curr Comp-Aided Drug Design , 2 : 135 – 150 .
  • Xia , M , Huang , R , Witt , K L , Southall , N , Fostel , J , Choi , M H , Jadhav , A , Smith , C S , Inglese , J , Portier , C J , Tice , R R and Austin , C P . 2008 . Compound Cytotoxicity Profiling Using Quantitative High-Throughput Screening . Environ Health Persp , 116 : 284 – 291 . Available at: http://www.ehponline.org
  • Gold , L S , Bernstein , L , MaGaw , R and Slone , T H . 1989 . Interspecies extrapolation in carcinogenesis: Prediction between rats and mice . Environ Health Persp , 81 : 211 – 219 .
  • Benigni , R , Giuliani , A , Franke , R and Gruska , A . 2000 . Quantitative structure-activity relationships of mutagenic and carcinogenic aromatic amines . Chem Revs , 100 : 3697 – 3714 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.