Criminal sanctions versus psychologically-based interventions with offenders: A Comparative empirical analysis

References

• Alexander , M. A. 1999 . Sexual offender treatment efficacy revisited . Sexual Abuse: Journal of Research and Treatment , 11 : 101 – 116 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Andrews , D. A. 1995 . “ The psychology of criminal conduct and effective treatment ” . In What Works: Reducing Re‐offending: Guidelines from Research and Practice , Edited by: McGuire , J. Chichester : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Andrews , D. A. and Dowden , C. 1999 . A meta‐analytic investigation into effective correctional intervention for female offenders . Forum on Corrections Research , 11 : 18 – 20 .
   Google Scholar
• Andrews , D. A. , Zinger , I. , Hoge , R. D. , Bonta , J. , Gendreau , P. and Cullen , F. T. 1990 . Does correctional treatment work? A clinically relevant and psychologically informed meta‐analysis . Criminology , 28 : 369 – 404 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Axelrod , S. and Apsche , J. , eds. 1983 . The Effects of Punishment on Human Behavior , New York, NY : Academic Press .
   Google Scholar
• Baron , S. W. and Kennedy , L. W. 1998 . Deterrence and homeless male street youths . Canadian Journal of Criminology , 40 : 27 – 60 .
   Google Scholar
• Berkowitz , L. 1993 . Aggression: Its Causes, Consequences, and Control , New York, NY : McGraw‐Hill .
   Google Scholar
• Blackman , D. E. 1996 . “ Punishment: An experimental and theoretical analysis ” . In Does Punishment Work? , Edited by: McGuire , J. and Rowson , B. London : Institute for the Study and Treatment of Delinquency .
   Google Scholar
• Bonta , J. , Law , M. and Hansen , K. 1998 . The prediction of criminal and violent recidivism amongst mentally disordered offenders: A meta‐analysis . Psychological Bulletin , 123 : 123 – 142 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Borack , J. I. 1998 . An estimate of the impact of drug testing on the deterrence of drug use . Military Psychology , 10 : 17 – 25 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Brody , S. 1976 . The Effectiveness of Sentencing , Home Office Research Study No. 35 London : HMSO .
   Google Scholar
• Carroll , J. and Weaver , F. 1986 . “ Shoplifters' perceptions of crime opportunities: a processtracing study ” . In The Reasoning Criminal: Rational Choice Perspectives on Offending , Edited by: Cornish , D. B. and Clarke , R. V. New York, NY : Springer‐Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Cheatwood , D. 1993 . Capital punishment and the deterrence of violent crime in comparable counties . Criminal Justice Review , 18 : 165 – 181 .
   Google Scholar
• Cleland , C. M. , Pearson , F. S. , Lipton , D. S. and Yee , D. 1997 . Does age make a difference? A meta‐analytic approach to reductions in criminal offending for juveniles and adults . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology . 1997 , San Diego, California.
   Google Scholar
• Copas , J. 1995 . “ On using crime statistics for prediction ” . In Interpreting Crime Statistics , Edited by: Walker , M. A. Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Copas , J. and Marshall , P. 1998 . The offender group reconviction scale: a statistical reconviction score for use by probation officers . Applied Statistics , 47 : 159 – 171 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Copas , J. , Marshall , P. and Tarling , R. 1996 . Predicting Reoffending for Discretionary Conditional Release , Home Office Research Study No. 150 London : Home Office Research and Statistics Directorate .
   Google Scholar
• Cullen , F. T. , Cullen , J. B. and Wozniak , J. F. 1988 . Is rehabilitation dead? The myth of the punitive public . Journal of Criminal Justice , 16 : 303 – 317 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dorn , N. , Murji , K. and South , N. 1992 . Traffickers: Drug Markets and Law Enforcement , London : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Dowden , C. and Andrews , D. A. 1999 . What works in young offender treatment: a meta‐analysis . Forum on Corrections Research , 11 : 21 – 24 .
   Google Scholar
• Dowden , C. and Andrews , D. A. 2000 . Effective correctional treatment and violent reoffending: A meta‐analysis . Canadian Journal of Criminology , 42 : 449 – 467 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Evans , W. N. , Neville , D. and Graham , J. D. 1991 . General deterrence of drunk driving: Evaluation of recent American policies . Risk Analysis , 11 : 279 – 289 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Farrell , D. M. 1985 . The justification of general deterrence . Philosophcal Review , XCIV : 367 – 394 .
   Google Scholar
• Fitzmaurice , C. and Pease , K. 1986 . The Psychology of Judicial Sentencing , Manchester : Manchester University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Garrett , C. G. 1985 . Effects of residential treatment on adjudicated delinquents: A meta‐analysis . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency , 22 : 287 – 308 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. 1996a . Offender rehabilitation: What we know and what needs to be done . Criminal Justice and Behavior , 23 : 144 – 161 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. 1996b . “ The principles of effective intervention with offenders ” . In Choosing Correctional Options That Work: Defining the Demand and Evaluating the Supply , Edited by: Harland , A. T. Thousand Oaks, Cal : Sage Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. and Andrews , D. A. 1990 . Tertiary prevention: what the meta‐analyses of the offender treatment literature tell us about ‘what works’ . Canadian Journal of Criminology , 32 : 173 – 184 .
   Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. and Goggin , C. 1996 . Principles of effective correctional programming . Forum on Corrections Research , 8 : 38 – 41 .
   Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. , Goggin , C. and Cullen , F. T. 1999 . The Effects of Prison Sentences on Recidivism , Ottawa : Solicitor General of Canada . Report to the Corrections Research and Development and Aboriginal Policy Branch
   Google Scholar
• Gendreau , P. , Paparozzi , M. , Little , T. and Goddard , M. 1993 . Does ‘Punishing Smarter’ work? An assessment of the new generation of alternative sanctions in probation . Forum on Corrections Research , 5 : 31 – 34 .
   Google Scholar
• Gensheimer , L. K. , Mayer , J. P. , Gottschalk , R. and Davidson , W. S. 1986 . “ Diverting youth from the juvenile justice system: A meta‐analysis of intervention efficacy ” . In Youth Violence: Programs and Prospects , Edited by: Apter , S. A. and Goldstein , A. P. Elmsford, NJ : Pergamon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Gibbs , J. P. 1986 . “ Deterrence theory and research ” . In The Law as a Behavioral Instrument: Nebraska Symposium on Motivation 1985 , Edited by: Melton , G. B. Lincoln and London : University of Nebraska Press .
   Google Scholar
• Gottschalk , R. , Davidson , W. S. , Gensheimer , L. K. and Mayer , J. P. 1987 . “ Community‐based interventions ” . In Handbook of Juvenile Delinquency , Edited by: Quay , H. C. New York, NY : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Gottschalk , R. , Davidson , W. S. , Mayer , J. P. and Gensheimer , L. K. 1987 . “ Behavioral approaches with juvenile offenders: A meta‐analysis of long‐term treatment efficacy ” . In Behavioral Approaches to Crime and Delinquency , Edited by: Morris , E. K. and Braukmann , C. J. New York, NY : Plenum Press .
   Google Scholar
• Greenwood , P. , Rydell , C. P. , Abrahamse , A. F. , Caulkins , J. P. , Chiesa , J. , Model , K. E. and Klein , S. P. 1996 . “ Estimated costs and benefits of California's new mandatory‐sentencing law ” . In Three Strikes and You're Out: Vengeance as Public Policy , Edited by: Shichor , D. and Sechrest , D. K. Thousand Oaks, Cal : Sage Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Harland , A. T. , ed. 1996 . Choosing Correctional Options That Work: Defining the Demand and Evaluating the Supply , Thousand Oaks, Cal : Sage Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Henstridge , J. , Homel , R. and Mackay , P. 1997 . The Long‐term Effects of Random Breath Testing in Four Australian States: A Time Series Analysis , Canberra : Federal Office of Road Safety .
   Google Scholar
• Hollin , C. R. 1993 . Advances in the psychological treatment of delinquent behaviour . Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health , 3 : 142 – 157 .
   Google Scholar
• Hollin , C. R. 1999 . Treatment programmes for offenders: Meta‐analysis, ‘What Works’, and beyond . International Journal of Law and Psychiatry , 22 : 361 – 371 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Home Office . 1993 . Digest 2: Information on the Criminal Justice System in England and Wales , London : Home Office Research and Statistics Department .
   Google Scholar
• Honderich , T. 1976 . Punishment: The Supposed Justifications , Harmondsworth : Penguin Books .
   Google Scholar
• Hood , R. 1996 . The Death Penalty: A World‐Wide Perspective , 2nd edition , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Howe , E. S. and Loftus , T. C. 1996 . Integration of certainty, severity and celerity information in judged deterrence value: Further evidence and methodological equivalence . Journal of Applied Social Psychology , 26 : 226 – 242 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Izzo , R. L. and Ross , R. R. 1990 . Meta‐analysis of rehabilitation programmes for juvenile delinquents . Criminal Justice and Behavior , 17 : 134 – 142 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kershaw , C. 1999 . Reconviction of offenders sentenced or released from prison in 1994 , London : Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate . Research Findings No. 90
   Google Scholar
• Klemke , L. W. 1982 . Reassessment of Cameron's apprehension‐termination of shoplifting finding . California Sociologist , 5 : 88 – 95 .
   Google Scholar
• Lambert , M. J. and Bergin , A. E. 1994 . “ The effectiveness of psychotherapy ” . In Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change , Edited by: Bergin , A. E. and Garfield , S. L. New York, NY : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Light , R. , Nee , C. and Ingham , H. 1993 . Car Theft; The Offender's Perspective , London : HMSO . Home Office Research Study No. 130
   Google Scholar
• Lipsey , M. W. 1992 . “ Juvenile Delinquency treatment: A meta‐analytic inquiry into the variability of effects ” . In Meta‐analysis for explanation: A casebook , Edited by: Cook , T. , Cooper , D. , Corday , H. , Hartman , H. , Hedges , L. , Light , R. , Louis , T. and Mosteller , F. New York, NY : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Lipsey , M. W. and Wilson , D. B. 1993 . The efficacy of psychological, educational, and behavioral treatment: Confirmation from meta‐analysis . American Psychologist , 48 : 1181 – 1209 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lipsey , M. W. and Wilson , D. B. 1998 . “ Effective intervention for serious juvenile offenders: A synthesis of research ” . In Serious & Violent Juvenile Offenders: Risk Factors and Successful Interventions , Edited by: Loeber , R. and Farrington , D. P. Thousand Oaks, Cal : Sage Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Lipton , D. S. , Martinson , R. and Wilks , J. 1975 . The Effectiveness of Correctional Treatment: A Survey of Treatment Evaluation Studies , New York, NY : Praeger .
   Google Scholar
• Lipton , D. S. , Pearson , F. S. , Cleland , C. and Lee , D. 1997 . Synthesizing Correctional Treatment Outcomes: Preliminary CDATE Findings . Paper presented at the 5th Annual National Institute of Justice Conference on Research and Evaluation in Criminal Justice . July 1997 , Washington.
   Google Scholar
• Lloyd , C. , Mair , G. and Hough , M. 1994 . Explaining Reconviction Rates: A Critical Analysis , London : HMSO . Home Office Research Study No. 136
   Google Scholar
• Logan , C. H. , Gaes , G. G. , Harer , M. , Innes , C. A. , Karacki , L. and Saylor , W. G. 1991 . Can Meta‐analysis Save Correctional Rehabilitation? , Washington, DC : Federal Bureau of Prisons .
   Google Scholar
• Lösel , F. 1995 . “ The efficacy of correctional treatment: A review and synthesis of meta‐evaluations ” . In What Works: Reducing Re‐offending: Guidelines from Research and Practice , Edited by: McGuire , J. Chichester : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Lösel , F. and Koferl , P. 1989 . “ Evaluation research on correctional treatment in West Germany: A meta‐analysis ” . In Criminal Behaviour and the Justice System: Psychological Perspectives , Edited by: Wegener , H. , Lösel , F. and Haisch , J. New York, NY : Springer‐Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Mackenzie , D. L. 1997 . “ Criminal justice and crime prevention ” . In Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn't, What's Promising , Edited by: Sherman , L. W. , Gottfredson , D. , Mackenzie , D. L. , Eck , J. , Reuter , P. and Bushway , S. Washington, DC : Office of Justice Programs .
   Google Scholar
• MacKenzie , D. L. , Brame , R. , McDowall , D. and Souryal , C. 1995 . Boot camp prisons and recidivism in eight states . Criminology , 33 : 327 – 357 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• MacKenzie , D. L. and Souryal , C. 1994 . Multisite Evaluation of Shock Incarceration , Washington, DC : National Institute of Justice .
   Google Scholar
• Martin , S. E. , Annan , S. and Forst , B. 1993 . The special deterrent effects of a jail sanction on first‐time drunk drivers: A quasi experimental study . Accident Analysis and Prevention , 25 : 561 – 568 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Martinson , R. 1974 . What works? Questions and answers about prison reform . The Public Interest , 10 : 22 – 54 .
   Google Scholar
• Martinson , R. 1979 . New findings, new views: A note of caution regarding sentencing reform . Hofstra Law Review , 7 : 243 – 258 .
   Google Scholar
• Mayer , J. P. , Gensheimer , L. K. , Davidson , W. S. and Gottschalk , R. 1986 . “ Social learning treatment within juvenile justice: A meta‐analysis of impact in the natural environment ” . In Youth Violence: Programs and Prospects , Edited by: Apter , S. A. and Goldstein , A. P. Elmsford, NJ : Pergamon Press .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , J. , ed. 1995 . What Works: Reducing Re‐offending: Guidelines from Research and Practice , Chichester : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , J. , Mason , T. and O'Kane , A. 2000 . “ Effective interventions, service and policy implications ” . In Behaviour, Crime and Legal Processes: A Guide for Forensic Practitioners , Edited by: McGuire , J. , Mason , T. and O'Kane , A. Chichester : John Wiley & Sons .
   Google Scholar
• Moffitt , T. E. 1983 . The learning theory model of punishment: implications for delinquency deterrence . Criminal Justice and Behavior , 10 : 131 – 158 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Morrison , S. and O'Donnell , I. 1994 . Armed Robbery: A Study in London , Oxford : Centre for Criminological Research .
   Google Scholar
• Nagayama Hall , G. C. 1995 . Sexual offender recidivism revisited: A meta‐analaysis of recent treatment studies . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology , 63 : 802 – 809 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Nuttall , C. , Goldblatt , P. and Lewis , C. 1998 . Reducing offending: an assessment of research evidence on ways of dealing with offending behaviour , London : Home Office . Home Office Research Study No. 187
   Google Scholar
• Palmer , T. 1992 . The Re‐Emergence of Correctional Intervention , Newbury Park, Cal : Sage Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Paternoster , R. 1987 . The deterrent effect of the perceived certainty and severity of punishment: A review of evidence and issues . Justice Quarterly , 4 : 173 – 217 .
   Google Scholar
• Paternoster , R. , Saltzman , L. E. and Waldo , G. P. 1983 . Perceived risk and social control: do sanctions really deter? . Law and Society Review , 17 : 457 – 479 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pearson , F. S. , Lipton , D. S. and Cleland , C. M. 1997 . Rehabilitative programs in adult corrections: CDATE meta‐analyses . Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology . November 1997 , San Diego.
   Google Scholar
• Petersilia , J. and Turner , S. 1993 . Intensive probation and parole . Crime and Justice , 17 : 281 – 335 .
   Google Scholar
• Redondo , S. , Sánchez‐Meca , J. and Garrido , V. 1999 . The influence of treatment programmes on the recidivism of juvenile and adult offenders: An European meta‐analytic review . Psychology, Crime & Law , 5 : 251 – 278 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Roberts , A. R. and Camasso , M. J. 1991 . The effect of juvenile offender treatment programs on recidivism: a meta‐analysis of 46 studies . Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics and Public Policy , 5 : 421 – 441 .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. 1994 . “ Parametric measures of effect size ” . In Handbook of Research Synthesis , Edited by: Cooper , H. and Hedges , L. V. New York, NY : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , J. D. and Sherman , L. W. 1993 . Does arrest deter domestic violence? . American Behavioral Scientist , 36 : 601 – 609 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sherman , L. W. 1988 . “ Randomized experiments in criminal sanctions ” . In Lessons from Selected Program and Policy Areas , Edited by: Bloom , H. S. , Cordray , D. S. and Light , R. J. San Francisco, Cal : Jossey‐Bass . New Directions for Program Evaluation, No. 37
   Google Scholar
• Sherman , L. W. 1990 . “ Police crackdowns: initial and residual deterrence ” . In Crime and Justice: A Review of Research , Edited by: Tonry , M. and Morris , N. Chicago III, London : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Sherman , L. W. and Breck , A. 1984 . and Minneapolis Police Department. The specific deterrent effects of arrest for domestic assault . American Sociological Review , 49 : 261 – 272 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sherman , L. , Gottfredson , D. , McKenzie , D. , Eck , J. , Reuter , P. and Bushway , S. 1997 . Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn't, What's Promising , Washington, DC : Office of Justice Programs .
   Google Scholar
• Stack , S. 1993 . Execution publicity and homicide in Georgia . American Journal of Criminal Justice , 18 : 25 – 39 .
   Google Scholar
• Stafford , M. C. and Warr , M. 1993 . A reconceptualisation of general and specific deterrence . Journal of Research on Crime and Delinquency , 30 : 123 – 135 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sundel , S. S. and Sundel , M. 1993 . Behavior Modification in Human Services: A Systematic Introduction to Concepts and Applications , Newbury Park, Cal : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Taylor , R. 1999 . Predicting reconvictions for sexual and violent offences using the revised offender group reconviction scale , London : Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate . Research Findings No. 104
   Google Scholar
• Thornton , D. , Curran , L. , Grayson , D. and Holloway , V. 1984 . Tougher Regimes in Detention Centres: Report of an evaluation by the Young Offender Psychology Unit , London : HMSO .
   Google Scholar
• Tonry , M. 1996 . Sentencing Matters , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Vennard , J. , Sugg , D. and Hedderman , C. 1997 . Changing Offenders' Attitudes and Behaviour: what works? , London : HMSO . Home Office Research Study No. 171
   Google Scholar
• Vold , G. B. , Bernard , T. J. and Snipes , J. B. 1998 . Theoretical Criminology , 4th edition , New York, NY : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• von Hirsch , A. and Ashworth , A. , eds. 1998 . Principled Sentencing: Readings on Theory and Policy , 2nd edition , Oxford : Hart Publishing .
   Google Scholar
• Walker , N. 1991 . Why Punish? Theories of Punishment Reassessed , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Walker , N. and Padfield , N. 1996 . Sentencing: Theory, Law and Practice , 2nd edition , London : Butterworths .
   Google Scholar
• Weisburd , D. , Sherman , L. and Petrosino , A. J. 1990 . Registry of Randomized Criminal Justice Experiments in Sanctions , Rutgers University, University of Maryland and Crime Control Institute . Unpublished report
   Google Scholar
• Welsh , B. C. and Farrington , D. P. 2000 . Correctional intervention programs and cost benefit analysis . Criminal Justice and Behavior , 27 : 115 – 133 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Whitehead , J. T. and Lab , S. P. 1989 . A meta‐analysis of juvenile correctional treatment . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency , 26 : 276 – 295 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zimring , F. E. and Hawkins , G. 1994 . The growth of imprisonment in California . British Journal of Criminology , 34 : 83 – 96 . Special Issue
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zimring , F. E. and Hawkins , G. 1995 . Incapacitation: Penal Confinement and the Restraint of Crime , New York, NY : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar