4,904
Views
93
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Articles

Have We Forsaken Reading Theory in the Name of “Quick Fix” Interventions for Children With Reading Disability?

, , &

REFERENCES

  • Balota , D. A. , Yap , M. J. , Cortese , M. J. , Hutchison , K. A. , Kessler , B. , Loftis , B. and Treiman , R. 2007 . The English lexicon project . Behavior Research Methods , 39 : 445 – 459 .
  • Barca , L. , Burani , C. , Di Filippo , G. and Zoccolotti , P. 2006 . Italian developmental dyslexic and proficient readers: Where are the differences? . Brain and Language , 98 : 347 – 351 .
  • Barnes , M. A. , Davis , C. , Priebe , S. , Arrington , N. , Francis , D. and Fletcher , J. 2012 . “ Word-level, text-level and general purpose cognitive skills in struggling adolescent readers: Implications for assessment and intervention ” . In (Chairs), Assessment and intervention research with struggling adolescent and adult readers , Edited by: Lovett , M. W. and Greenberg , D. Montreal , Canada : Symposium conducted at the annual meeting of the Society for the Scientific Study of Reading . JulyIn
  • Berninger , V. W. 1994 . The varieties of orthographic knowledge I: Theoretical and developmental issues , Dordrecht : the Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Press .
  • Bransford , J. D. and Johnson , M. K. 1972 . Contextual prerequisites for understanding: Some investigations of comprehension and recall . Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior , 11 : 717 – 726 .
  • Bransford , J. D. , Stein , B. S. , Shelton , T. S. and Owings , R. A. 1981 . “ Cognition and adaptation: The importance of learning to learn ” . In Cognition, social behavior and the environment , Edited by: Harvey , J. 93 – 110 . Hillsdale , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Brasseur-Hock , I. , Hock , M. F. , Kieffer , M. J. , Biancarosa , G. and Deshler , D. D. 2011 . Adolescent struggling readers in urban schools: Results of a latent class analysis . Learning and Individual Differences , 21 : 438 – 452 .
  • Brooks , L. 1977 . “ Visual pattern in fluent word identification ” . In Towards a psychology of reading , Edited by: Reber , A. S. and Scarborough , D. L. 95 – 110 . Hillsdale , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Bruck , M. 1992 . Persistence of dyslexics’ phonological awareness deficits . Developmental Psychology , 28 : 874 – 886 .
  • Cain , K. and Oakhill , J. V. 1999 . Inference making ability and its relation to comprehension failure in young children . Reading and Writing , 11 : 489 – 503 .
  • Cain , K. , Oakhill , J. V. , Barnes , M. A. and Bryant , P. E. 2001 . Comprehension skill, inference-making ability, and the relation to knowledge . Memory & Cognition , 29 : 850 – 859 .
  • Cain , K. , Oakhill , J. V. and Bryant , P. E. 2000 . Investigating the causes of reading comprehension failure: The comprehension–age match design . Reading and Writing , 12 : 31 – 40 .
  • Carnine , D. W. , Kameenui , E. J. and Woolfson , N. 1982 . Training of textual dimensions related to text-based inferences . Journal of Reading Behavior , 14 : 335 – 340 .
  • Catts , H. W. , Adlof , S. M. , Hogan , T. P. and Weismer , S. E. 2005 . Are specific language impairment and dyslexia distinct disorders? . Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research , 48 : 1378 – 1396 .
  • Catts , H. W. , Compton , D. L. , Tomblin , J. B. and Bridges , M. S. 2012 . Prevalence and nature of late-emerging poor readers . Journal of Educational Psychology , 104 : 166 – 181 .
  • Catts , H. W. , Hogan , T. P. and Fey , M. E. 2003 . Subgrouping poor readers on the basis of individual differences in reading-related abilities . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 36 : 151 – 164 .
  • Chiesi , H. L. , Spilich , G. J. and Voss , J. F. 1979 . Acquisition of domain-related information in relation to high and low domain knowledge . Journal of Verbal Learning & Verbal Behavior , 18 : 257 – 273 .
  • Clinton , V. and van den Broek , P. 2012 . Interest, inferences, and learning from texts . Learning and Individual Differences , 22 : 650 – 663 .
  • Coltheart , M. , Rastle , K. , Perry , C. , Langdon , R. and Ziegler , J. 2001 . DRC: A dual route cascaded model of visual word recognition and reading aloud . Psychological Review , 108 : 204 – 256 .
  • Compton , D. L. , Miller , A. C. , Gilbert , J. K. and Steacy , L. M. 2013 . “ What can be learned about the reading comprehension of poor readers through the use of advanced statistical modeling techniques? ” . In Unraveling the behavioral, neurobiological, & genetic components of reading comprehension , Edited by: Miller , B. , Cutting , L. E. and McCardle , P. 135 – 147 . Baltimore , MD : Brookes .
  • Cunningham , A. E. and Stanovich , K. E. 1998 . “ What reading does for the mind ” . In American Educator 8 – 15 .
  • De Luca , M. , Borrelli , M. , Judica , A. , Spinelli , D. and Zoccolotti , P. 2002 . Reading words and pseudowords: An eye movement study of developmental dyslexia . Brain and Language , 80 : 617 – 626 .
  • Ehri , L. C. 2005 . Learning to read words: Theory, findings, and issues . Scientific Studies of Reading , 9 : 167 – 188 .
  • Ehri, L. (2014). Orthographic mapping in the acquisition of sight word reading, spelling memory, and vocabulary learning. Scientific Studies of Reading, 18, 5–21. doi:10.1080/10888438.2013.819356
  • Ehri , L. C. and Saltmarsh , J. 1995 . Beginning readers outperform older disabled readers in learning to read words by sight . Reading and Writing , 7 : 295 – 326 .
  • Elbro , C. and Buch-Iversen , I. 2013 . “ Activation of background knowledge for inference making: effects on reading comprehension ” . In Scientific Studies of Reading 17, 435–452.
  • Elleman , A. M. , Compton , D. L. , Fuchs , D. , Fuchs , L. S. and Bouton , B. 2011 . Exploring dynamic assessment as a means of identifying children at-risk of developing comprehension difficulties . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 44 : 348 – 357 .
  • Emery , D. W. and Milhalevich , C. 1992 . Directed discussion of character perspectives . Reading Research and Instruction , 31 : 51 – 59 .
  • Ericsson , K. A. and Kintsch , W. 1995 . Long-term working memory . Psychological Review , 102 : 211 – 245 .
  • Fletcher , J. M. , Lyon , G. R. , Fuch , L. S. and Barnes , M. A. 2006 . Learning disabilities: From identification to intervention , New York , NY : Guilford .
  • Florit , E. and Cain , K. 2011 . The simple view of reading: Is it valid for different types of alphabetic orthographies? . Educational Psychology Review , 23 : 553 – 576 .
  • Foorman , B. R. 1994 . The relevance of a connectionist model of reading for “the great debate.” . Educational Psychology Review , 6 : 25 – 47 .
  • Foorman , B. R. , Francis , D. J. , Winikates , D. , Mehta , P. , Schatschneider , C. and Fletcher , J. M. 1997 . Early intervention for children with reading disabilities . Scientific Studies of Reading , 1 : 255 – 276 .
  • Frank , S. L. , Koppen , M. , Noordman , L. G. M. and Vonk , W. 2003 . Modeling knowledge-based inferences in story comprehension . Cognitive Science , 27 : 875 – 910 .
  • Frank , S. L. , Koppen , M. , Noordman , L. G. M. and Vonk , W. 2008 . World knowledge in computational models of discourse comprehension . Discourse Processes , 45 : 429 – 463 .
  • Frith , U. 1985 . “ Beneath the surface of developmental dyslexia ” . In Surface dyslexia , Edited by: Patterson , K. , Marshall , J. and Coltheart , M. 301 – 330 . London , UK : Erlbaum .
  • Gersten , R. , Fuchs , L. S. , Williams , J. P. and Baker , S. 2001 . Teaching reading comprehension strategies to students with learning disabilities: A review of research . Review of Educational Research , 71 : 279 – 320 .
  • Gough , P. B. , Juel , C. and Griffith , P. L. 1992 . “ Reading, spelling, and the orthographic cipher ” . In Reading acquisition , Edited by: Gough , P. B. , Ehri , L. C. and Treiman , R. 35 – 48 . Hillsdale , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Hansen , J. and Pearson , D. P. 1983 . An instructional study: Improving the inferential comprehension of good and poor fourth-grade readers . Journal of Educational Psychology , 75 : 821 – 829 .
  • Harm , M. W. and Seidenberg , M. S. 1999 . Phonology, reading acquisition, and dyslexia: Insights from connectionist models . Psychological Review , 106 : 491 – 528 .
  • Harris , A. and Jacobson , M. 1982 . Basic reading vocabulary , New York , NY : Macmillan .
  • Hirsch , E. D. 2006 . Reading-comprehension skills? What are they really? . Education Week , 25 ( 33 ) : 52
  • Holmes , B. C. 1985 . The effects of a strategy and sequenced materials on the inferential comprehension of disabled readers . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 18 : 543 – 546 .
  • Hutzler , F. and Wimmer , H. 2004 . Eye movements of dyslexic children when reading in a regular orthography . Brain and Language , 89 : 235 – 242 .
  • Johnston , A. M. , Barnes , M. A. and Desrochers , A. 2008 . Reading comprehension: Developmental processes, individual differences, and interventions . Canadian Psychology/Psychologie Canadienne , 49 : 125 – 132 .
  • Kamhi , A. G. 2009 . The case for the narrow view of reading . Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools , 40 : 174 – 177 .
  • Kendeou , P. and van den Broek , P. 2005 . The effects of readers’ misconceptions on comprehension of scientific text . Journal of Educational Psychology , 97 : 235 – 245 .
  • Kendeou , P. and van den Broek , P. 2007 . The effects of prior knowledge and text structure on comprehension processes during reading of scientific texts . Memory & Cognition , 35 : 1567 – 1577 .
  • King , A. 1994 . Guiding knowledge construction in the classroom: Effects of teaching children how to question and how to explain . American Educational Research Journal , 31 : 338 – 368 .
  • Kintsch , W. 1988 . The role of knowledge in discourse comprehension: A construction-integration model . Psychological Review , 95 : 163 – 182 .
  • Kintsch , W. 1998 . Comprehension: A paradigm for cognition , Cambridge , UK : Cambridge University Press .
  • Kintsch , W. 2009 . “ Learning and constructivism ” . In Constructivist instruction: Success or failure? , Edited by: Tobias , S. and Duffy , T. M. 223 – 241 . New York , NY : Routledge .
  • Kintsch , W. and Kintsch , E. 2005 . “ Comprehension ” . In Children's reading comprehension and assessment , Edited by: Paris , S. G. and Stahl , S. A. 71 – 92 . Mahwah , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Kintsch , W. and Rawson , K. A. 2005 . “ Comprehension ” . In The science of reading: A handbook , Edited by: Snowling , M. J. and Hulme , C. 209 – 226 . Oxford , UK : Blackwell .
  • Landauer , T. K. and Dumais , S. T. 1997 . A solution to Plato's problem: The latent semantic analysis theory of acquisition, induction, and representation of knowledge . Psychological Review , 104 : 211 – 240 .
  • Landauer, T. K., Foltz, P. W., & Laham, D. (1998). An introduction to the latent semantic analysis. Discourse Processes, 25(2–3), 259–284.
  • Langer , J. A. and Nicolich , M. 1981 . Prior knowledge and its relationship to comprehension . Journal of Reading Behavior , 13 : 373 – 379 .
  • Levy, B. A., & Lysynchuk, L. (1997). Beginning word recognition: Benefits of training by segmentation and whole word methods. Scientific Studies of Reading, 1, 359–387.
  • Linderholm , T. , Everson , M. G. , van den Broek , P. , Mischinski , M. , Crittenden , A. and Samuels , J. 2000 . Effects of causal text revisions on more- and less-skilled readers’ comprehension of easy and difficult texts . Cognition and Instruction , 18 : 525 – 556 .
  • Long , D. L. , Oppy , B. J. and Seely , M. R. 1994 . Individual differences in the time course of inferential processing . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition , 20 : 1456 – 1470 .
  • Lyon , G. R. 1998 . Why reading is not natural . Educational Leadership , 55 ( 6 ) : 14 – 18 .
  • Martens , V. E. G. and de Jong , P. F. 2006 . The effect of visual word features on the acquisition of orthographic knowledge . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology , 93 : 337 – 356 .
  • Masterson , J. , Stuart , M. , Dixon , M. and Lovejoy , S. 2010 . Children's printed word database: Continuities and changes over time in children's early reading vocabulary . British Journal of Psychology , 101 : 221 – 242 .
  • McCandliss , B. , Beck , I. L. , Sandak , R. and Perfetti , C. 2003 . Focusing attention on decoding for children with poor reading skills: Design and preliminary tests of the word building intervention . Scientific Studies of Reading , 7 : 75 – 104 .
  • McKeown , M. G. , Beck , I. L. and Blake , R. G. K. 2009 . Rethinking reading comprehension instruction: A comparison of instruction for strategies and content approaches . Reading Research Quarterly , 44 : 218 – 253 .
  • McNamara , D. S. , de Vega , M. and O'Reilly , T. 2007 . “ Comprehension skill, inference making, and the role of knowledge ” . In Higher level language processes in the brain: Inference and comprehension processes , Edited by: Schmalhofer , F. and Perfetti , C. A. 233 – 251 . Mahwah , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • McNamara , D. S. and Kintsch , W. 1996 . Learning from texts: Effects of prior knowledge and text coherence . Discourse Processes , 22 : 247 – 288 .
  • McNamara , D. S. , Kintsch , E. , Songer , N. B. and Kintsch , W. 1996 . Are good texts always better? Interactions of text coherence, background knowledge, and levels of understanding in learning from text . Cognition and Instruction , 14 : 1 – 43 .
  • McNamara, D. S., & Magliano, J. (2009). Toward a comprehensive model of comprehension. In B. H. Ross (Ed.), Psychology of learning and motivation (pp. 297–384). San Diego, CA: Elsevier Academic Press.
  • Miller , A. C. and Keenan , J. M. 2009 . How word decoding skill impacts text memory: The centrality deficit and how domain knowledge can compensate . Annals of Dyslexia , 59 : 99 – 113 .
  • Miller , A. C. and Keenan , J. M. 2011 . Understanding the centrality deficit: Insight from foreign language learners . Memory & Cognition , 39 : 873 – 883 .
  • Nation , K. , Angell , P. and Castles , A. 2007 . Orthographic learning via self-teaching in children learning to read English: Effects of exposure, durability, and context . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology , 96 : 71 – 84 .
  • National Institute of Child Health and Human Development . 2000 . Report of the National Reading Panel (NIH Publication No. 00–4754) , Washington , DC : Government Printing Office .
  • Oakhill , J. 1983 . Instantiation in skilled and less skilled comprehenders . The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A: Human Experimental Psychology , 35 : 441 – 450 .
  • Oakhill , J. V. and Cain , K. 2012 . The precursors of reading ability in young readers: Evidence from a four-year longitudinal study . Scientific Studies of Reading , 16 : 91 – 121 .
  • O'Connor , R. and Fuchs , L. S. 2013 . “ Responsiveness to intervention in the elementary grades: Implications for early childhood education ” . In Handbook of response to intervention (RTI) in early childhood education , Edited by: Buysse , V. , Peisner-Feinberg , E. and Cantler , J. 41 – 56 . Baltimore , MD : Brookes .
  • Olson, R., Keenan, J., Byrne, B., & Samuelsson, S. (2014). Why do children differ in their development of reading and related skills? Scientific Studies of Reading, 18, 38–54. doi:10.1080/10888438.2013.800521
  • Olson , R. K. , Wise , B. , Ring , J. and Johnson , M. 1997 . Computer-based remedial training in phoneme awareness and phonological decoding: Effects on the posttraining development of word recognition . Scientific Studies of Reading , 1 : 235 – 254 .
  • Perfetti , C. A. 1992 . “ The representation problems in reading acquisition ” . In Reading acquisition , Edited by: Gough , P. B. , Ehri , L. C. and Treiman , R. 145 – 174 . Hillsdale , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Perfetti , C. A. 2007 . Reading ability: Lexical quality to comprehension . Scientific Studies of Reading , 11 : 357 – 384 .
  • Perfetti , C. A. , Landi , N. and Oakhill , J. 2005 . “ The acquisition of reading comprehension skill ” . In The science of reading: A handbook , Edited by: Snowling , M. J. and Hulme , C. 227 – 247 . Malden , MA : Blackwell .
  • Perfetti , C. A. , Marron , M. A. and Foltz , P. W. 1996 . “ Sources of comprehension failure: Theoretical perspectives and case studies ” . In Reading comprehension difficulties: Processes and interventions , Edited by: Cornoldi , C. and Oakhill , J. 137 – 165 . Mahwah , NJ : Erlbaum .
  • Perfetti, C., & Stafura, J. (2014). Word knowledge in a theory of reading comprehension. Scientific Studies of Reading, 18, 22–37. doi:1080/10888438.2013.827687
  • Rawson , K. A. and Van Overschelde , J. P. 2008 . How does knowledge promote memory? The distinctiveness theory of skilled memory . Journal of Memory and Language , 58 : 646 – 668 .
  • Rayner , K , Foorman , B. , Perfetti , C. A. , Pesetsky , D. and Seidenberg , M. S. 2001 . How psychological science informs the teaching of reading . Psychological Science in the Public Interest , 2 : 31 – 74 .
  • Recht , D. R. and Leslie , L. 1988 . Effect of prior knowledge on good and poor readers’ memory of text . Journal of Educational Psychology , 80 : 16 – 20 .
  • Reitsma , P. 1983 . Printed word learning in beginning readers . Journal of Experimental Child Psychology , 36 : 321 – 339 .
  • Reutzel , D. R. and Hollingsworth , P. M. 1988 . Highlighting key vocabulary: A generative-reciprocal procedure for teaching selected inference types . Reading Research Quarterly , 23 : 358 – 378 .
  • Rosenshine , B. and Meister , C. 1994 . Reciprocal teaching: A review of the research . Review of Educational Research , 64 : 479 – 530 .
  • Seifert , T. L. 1993 . Effects of elaborative interrogation with prose passages . Journal of Educational Psychology , 85 : 642 – 651 .
  • Shapiro , A. M. 2004 . How including prior knowledge as a subject variable may change outcomes of learning research . American Educational Research Journal , 41 : 159 – 189 .
  • Share , D. L. 1995 . Phonological recoding and self-teaching: Sine qua non of reading acquisition . Cognition , 55 : 151 – 218 .
  • Slavin , R. E. 1987 . Mastery learning reconsidered . Review of Educational Research , 57 : 175 – 213 .
  • Snow , C. E. , Burns , M. S. and Griffin , P. 1998 . Preventing reading difficulties in young children , Washington , DC : National Academic Press .
  • Solis , M. , Ciullo , S. , Vaughn , S. , Pyle , N. , Hassaram , B. and Leroux , A. 2012 . Reading comprehension interventions for middle school students with learning disabilities: A synthesis of 30 years of research . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 45 : 327 – 340 .
  • Spires , H. A. and Donley , J. 1998 . Prior knowledge activation: Inducing engagement with informational texts . Journal of Educational Psychology , 90 : 249 – 260 .
  • Stanovich , K. E. , Cunningham , A. E. and Feeman , D. J. 1984 . Relation between early reading acquisition and word decoding with and without context: A longitudinal study of first-grade children . Journal of Educational Psychology , 76 : 668 – 677 .
  • Stanovich, K. E., West, R. F., Cunningham, A. E., Cipielewski, J., & Siddiqui, S. (1996). The role of inadequate print exposure as a determinant of reading comprehension problems. In C. Cornoldi & J. Oakhill (Eds.), Reading comprehension difficulties: Processes and interventions (pp. 15–68). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  • Stein , B. S. , Bransford , J. D. , Franks , J. J. , Owings , R. A. , Vye , N. J. and McGraw , W. 1982 . Differences in the precision of self-generated elaborations . Journal of Experimental Psychology: General , 111 : 399 – 405 .
  • Stitt , J. H. 1967 . “ Effects of instruction on children's inferential thinking ” . In Unpublished doctoral dissertation , Los Angeles. : University of California .
  • Sundbye , N. 1987 . Text explicitness and inferential questioning: effect on story understanding and recall . Reading Research Quarterly , 22 : 82 – 98 .
  • Swanson , H. L. 1999 . Reading research for students with LD: A metaanalysis in intervention outcomes . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 32 : 504 – 532 .
  • Torgesen , J. K. 1998 . “ Catch them before they fall: Identification and assessment to prevent reading failure in young children ” . In American Educator 32 – 40 .
  • Torgesen , J. K. 2000 . Individual differences in response to early interventions in reading: The lingering problem of treatment resisters . Learning Disabilities Research & Practice , 15 : 55 – 64 .
  • Torgesen , J. K. , Alexander , A. W. , Wagner , R. K. , Rashotte , C. A. , Voeller , K. S. and Conway , T. 2001 . Intensive remedial instruction for children with severe reading disabilities: Immediate and long-term outcomes from two instructional approaches . Journal of Learning Disabilities , 34 : 33 – 58 .
  • Torgesen , J. K. , Wagner , R. K. and Rashotte , C. A. 1997 . Prevention and remediation of severe reading disabilities: Keeping the eye in mind . Scientific Studies of Reading , 1 : 217 – 234 .
  • Treiman , R. , Mullennix , J. , Bijeljac-Babic , R. and Richmond-Welty , E. 1995 . The special role of rimes in the description, use, and acquisition of English orthography . Journal of Experimental Psychology: General , 124 : 107 – 136 .
  • Venezky, R. L. (1999). The American way of spelling: The structure and origins of American English Orthography. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
  • Wang , H. , Nickels , L. , Nation , K. and Castles , A. 2013 . “ Predictors of orthographic learning of regular and irregular words ” . In Scientific Studies of Reading 17, 369–384.
  • Willingham , D. 2006 . The usefulness of brief instruction in reading comprehension strategies , 39 – 50 . American Educator . Winterpp.
  • Wilson , M. M. 1979 . The processing strategies of average and below average readers answering factual and inferential questions of three equivalent passages . Journal of Reading Behavior , 11 : 235 – 245 .
  • Wolfe , M. B. W. , Schreiner , M. E. , Rehder , B. , Laham , D. , Foltz , P. W. , Kintsch , W. and Landauer , T. K. 1998 . Learning from text: Matching readers and texts by latent semantic analysis . Discourse Processes , 25 : 309 – 336 .
  • Yuill , N. and Joscelyne , T. 1988 . Effect of organizational cues and strategies on good and poor comprehenders’ story understanding . Journal of Educational Psychology , 80 : 152 – 158 .
  • Yuill , N. and Oakhill , J. 1988 . Effects of inference awareness training on poor reading comprehension . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 2 : 313 – 345 .
  • Ziegler , J. C. and Goswami , U. 2005 . Reading acquisition, developmental dyslexia, and skilled reading across languages: A psycholinguistic grain size theory . Psychological Bulletin , 131 : 3 – 29 .
  • Ziegler , J. C. , Perry , C. and Coltheart , M. 2003 . Speed of lexical and nonlexical processing in French: The case of the regularity effect . Psychonomic Bulletin & Review , 10 : 947 – 953 .
  • Zoccolotti , P. , De Luca , M. , Di Pace , E. , Gasperini , F. , Judica , A. and Spinelli , D. 2005 . Word length effect in early reading and in developmental dyslexia . Brain and Language , 93 : 369 – 373 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.