Eyewitness Identification and the English Courts: A Century of Trial and ErrorFootnote*

This article is based on a paper read at the 30th International Conference of the Academy of Law and Mental Health in Padua, Italy, June 2007. The review of pre-Devlin procedures is derived from a chapter written by the first author for Shepherd, Ellis and Davies (1982) which also contains further detail on the cases cited.

References

• BBC News . 1 November 2007a . What happened: Death of Jean Charles de Menezes 1 November , Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://news. bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/629/629/7073125. stm
   Google Scholar
• BBC News . 21 October 2007b . Menezes picture “was manipulated” 21 October , Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7048756.stm
   Google Scholar
• BBC News . 1 August 2008 . George not guilty of Dando Murder 1 August , Retrieved 22 September 2008, from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7536815.stm
   Google Scholar
• Bruce , V. , Henderson , Z. , Greenwood , K. , Hancock , P. , Burton , A. M. and Miller , P. 1999 . Verification of face identities from images captured on video . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied , 5 : 339 – 360 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Burton , A. M. , Wilson , S. , Cowan , M. and Bruce , V. 1999 . Face recognition in poor quality video: Evidence from security surveillance . Psychological Science , 10 : 243 – 248 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Clifford , B. R. 2008 . “ Role of the expert witness ” . In Forensic Psychology , Edited by: Davies , G. M. , Hollin, , C. R. and Bull , R. H.C. 235 – 261 . Chichester : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Cole , P. and Pringle , P. 1974 . Can you positively identify this man? George Ince and the Barn murder , London : Andre Deutsch .
   Google Scholar
• Crown Prosecution Service . 2008 . Review of the use of Low Copy Number DNA analysis in current cases Press release retrieved 26 March 08, from http://www. cps.gov.uk/news/pressreleases/101_08.html
   Google Scholar
• Daily Mail on line . 17 August 2005 . Tragic trail of police blunders over shooting 17 August , Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/ news.html?in_article_id=359494&in_page_id=1770
   Google Scholar
• Davies , G. M. 1996 . Mistaken identification: When law meets psychology head on . Howard Journal of Criminal Justice , 35 : 230 – 241 .
   Google Scholar
• Davies , G. and Thasen , S. 2000 . Closed circuit television: How effective an identification aid? . British Journal of Psychology , 91 : 411 – 426 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Devlin , Lord P. 1976 . Report to the Secretary of State for the Home Department on the Departmental Committee on Evidence of Identification in Criminal Cases , London : HMSO .
   Google Scholar
• Devlin , Lord P. 1982 . “ Forward ” . In Identification evidence: A psychological evaluation , Edited by: Shepherd , J. W. , Ellis, , H. D. and Davies , G. M. v – vii . Aberdeen : Aberdeen University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Foot , P. 1971 . Who killed Hanratty? , London : Jonathan Cape .
   Google Scholar
• Henderson , Z. , Bruce , V. and Burton , A. M. 2001 . Matching the faces of robbers captured on video . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 15 : 445 – 464 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Home Office . 1991 . Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (s 66). Codes of Practice. , Revised Edition , London : The Stationery Office .
   Google Scholar
• Home Office . 2004 . Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (s 60 (1)(a), s 60A(1) and s 66(1)). Codes of Practice A–F. , Revised Edition , London : The Stationery Office .
   Google Scholar
• Innocence Project . n.d. . Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://www.innocenceproject. org/
   Google Scholar
• Lindsay , R. C.L. and Wells , G. L. 1985 . Improving eyewitness identification from lineups: Simultaneous versus sequential presentation . Journal of Applied Psychology , 66 : 343 – 350 .
   Google Scholar
• Lomax , S. C. 2005 . Who killed Jill Dando? The case of Barry George, A shocking miscarriage of justice , Hertford : Kempton Marks .
   Google Scholar
• Maas , A. and Kohnken , G. 1989 . Eyewitness identification: Simulating the weapon effect . Law and Human Behavior , 13 : 397 – 408 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McCahill , M. 2003 . “ Media representations of visual surveillance ” . In Criminal visions: Media representations of crime and justice , Edited by: Mason , P. 192 – 213 . Cullompton, Devon : Willan .
   Google Scholar
• Meissner , C. A. and Brigham , J. C. 2001 . Thirty years of investigating the own-race bias in memory for faces: A meta-analytic review . Psychology, Public Policy, and Law , 7 : 3 – 35 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nardo , D. 2007 . DNA evidence (crime scene investigations) , Melbourne, , Australia : Cengage Learning .
   Google Scholar
• Norris , C. , McCahill , M. and Woods , D. 2004 . The growth of CCTV: A global perspective on the international diffusion of video surveillance in publicly accessible space . Surveillance and Society , 2 : 110 – 135 . Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://www.surveillance-and-society.org/cctv.htm
   Google Scholar
• Pike , G. , Brace , N. and Kyman , S. 2002 . The visual identification of suspects: procedures and practice Briefing note 2/02, Policing and Reducing Crime Unit, Home Office Research Development and Statistics Directorate. Retrieved 27 December 2007, from www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/prgbriefpubs1. html
   Google Scholar
• Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (s 60(1)(a), s 60(1), s 66(1)) Codes of Practice . 2005 . Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://police.homeoffice.gov.uk/operational-policing/powers-pace-codes/pace-code-intro/
   Google Scholar
• R v Turnbull and others . 1976 . 63 Cr App R 132
   Google Scholar
• Rawlinson , J. F.P. 1925 . Arrest of Major R.O. Sheppard. Report of the Enquiry held under the Tribunals of Enquiry (Evidence) Act, 1921. Cmd.2497 , London : His Majesty's Stationary Office .
   Google Scholar
• Report of the Royal Commission on Police Powers and Procedure . 1929 . Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://www.bopcris. ac.uk/bopall/ref8782.html
   Google Scholar
• Rolph , C. H. 1957 . Personal identity , London : Michael Joseph .
   Google Scholar
• Rozenberg , J. 2007 . Judge cleared of “flashing” young commuter Telegraph on line, 13 June 2007. Retrieved 26 March 2008, from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml? xml=/news/2007/06/13/njudge213.xml
   Google Scholar
• Rust , A. and Tredoux , C. 1997 . Identification parades: An empirical survey of legal recommendations and police practice in South Africa Retrieved 26 March 2008 from, http://web.uct.ac.za/depts/psychology/plato/Rust.pdf
   Google Scholar
• Shepherd , J. W. 1983 . “ Identification after long delays ” . In Evaluating eyewitness evidence , Edited by: Lloyd-Bostock , S. M.A. and Clifford , B. R. 173 – 187 . Chichester : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Shepherd , J. W. , Ellis , H. D. and Davies , G. M. 1982 . Identification evidence: A psychological evaluation , Aberdeen : Aberdeen University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Slater , A. 1994 . Identification parades: A scientific evaluation , London : Police Research Group (Police Research Award Scheme), Home Office: London .
   Google Scholar
• Thomson , D. M. 1988 . “ Context and False Recognition ” . In Memory in context: Context in memory , Edited by: Davies , G. M. and Thomson , D. M. 285 – 304 . Chichester : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Thomson , D. M. 1995 . “ Eyewitness testimony and identification tests ” . In Psychology and policing , Edited by: Brewer , N. and Wilson , C. 119 – 154 . Hillsdale, New Jersey, , USA : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Valentine , T. 2008 . “ Identifying perpetrators ” . In Forensic psychology , Edited by: Davies , G. M. , Hollin, , C. R. and Bull , R. H.C. 59 – 85 . Chichester : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Valentine , T. , Harris , N. , Colom Piera , A. and Darling , S. 2003 . Are police video identifications fair to African-Caribbean suspects? . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 17 : 459 – 476 .
   Google Scholar
• Valentine , T. and Heaton , P. 1999 . An evaluation of the fairness of police line-ups and video identifications . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 13 : S59 – S72 .
   Google Scholar
• Valentine , T. , Munro , R. and Hughes , C. in press . “ Recent developments in eyewitness identification procedures in the United Kingdom ” . In The handbook of psychology of investigative interviewing , Edited by: Bull , R. , Valentine, , T. and Williamson , T. Chichester : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Valentine , T. , Pickering , A. and Darling , S. 2003 . Characteristics of eyewitness identification that predict the outcome of real lineups . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 17 : 969 – 993 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Watson , E. R. 1924 . The trial of Adolf Beck. Notable British Trials Series , London : W. Hodge & Co .
   Google Scholar
• Weber , N. , Brewer , N. , Wells , G. L. , Semmuler , C. and Keast , A. 2004 . Eyewitness identification accuracy and response latency: The unruly 10–12 second rule . Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied , 10 : 139 – 147 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Williams , G. and Hammelmann , H. A. 1963 . Identification parades . Criminal Law Review , : 479 – 482 . 545–555
   Google Scholar
• Wright , D. B. and McDaid , A. T. 1996 . Comparing system and estimator variables using data from real lineups . Applied Cognitive Psychology , 10 : 75 – 84 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zhao , W. , Chellappa , R. , Phillips , P. J. and Rosenfeld , A. 2003 . Face recognition: A literature survey . ACM Computing Surveys , 35 : 399 – 458 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar