Oralism: A Sign of the Times? The Contest for Deaf Communication in Education Provision in Late Nineteenth-century Scotland

Books

• Addison , W.H. 1898 . The Present State of Deaf Mute Education , Glasgow : Philosophical Society of Glasgow .
   Google Scholar
• Addison , W.H. 1899 . Glasgow Society for the Education of the Deaf and Dumb: A Brief Sketch of its Origin and Progress , Glasgow : Blackie .
   Google Scholar
• Anderson , R.D. 1997 . Scottish Education since the Reformation , Edinburgh : Economic & Social History Society of Scotland .
   Google Scholar
• Baynton , Douglas C. 1993 . “ ‘Savages and Deaf-Mutes’: Evolutionary Theory and the Campaign Against Sign Language in the Nineteenth Century ” . In Deaf History Unveiled , Edited by: van Cleve , John V. Washington, DC : Gallaudet University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Baynton , Douglas C. 1996 . Forbidden Signs: American Culture and the Campaign against Sign Language , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Bender , Ruth E. 1981 . The Conquest of Deafness , Danville : Interstate .
   Google Scholar
• Branson , J. and Miller , D. 2002 . Damned for Their Difference: The Cultural Construction of Deaf People as Disabled , Washington, DC : Gallaudet University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Burch , Susan . 2001 . “ Reading between the Signs: Defending Deaf Culture in Early Twentieth-Century America ” . In The New Disability History: American Perspectives , Edited by: Longmore , P.K. and Umansky , L. New York : New York University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Checkland , Olive . 1980 . Philanthropy in Victorian Scotland , Edinburgh : John Donald .
   Google Scholar
• Clerc , Laurent . 2001 . “ Autobiography ” . In Deaf World: A Historical Reader and Primary Sourcebook , Edited by: Bragg , Lois . New York : New York University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Corr , Helen . 1990 . “ An Exploration into Scottish Education ” . In People and Society in Scotland, Vol. 2: 1830–1914 , Edited by: Fraser , W.H. and Morris , R.J. Edinburgh : John Donald .
   Google Scholar
• Department of Education and Science . 1968 . The Education of Deaf Children: The Possible Place of Finger Spelling and Signing , London : Her Majesty's Stationery Office .
   Google Scholar
• Eriksson , Per . 1998 . History of Deaf People: A Sourcebook , Örebro, Sweden : Daufr .
   Google Scholar
• Fischer , R. and Lane , H. 1993 . Looking Back: A Reader on the History of Deaf Communities and their Sign Languages , Hamburg : Signum Press .
   Google Scholar
• Grant , Brian . 1990 . The Deaf Advance: A History of the British Deaf Association 1890–1990 , Edinburgh : Pentland Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hay , John . 1978 . “ Courtesy, Humour and Adjustment to a Mad World ” . In Of Sound and Mind , Edited by: Montgomery , George . Edinburgh : Scottish Workshop Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , Samuel . 1775 . A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland , London : Strahan .
   Google Scholar
• Kyle , J.G. and Woll , B. 1985 . Sign Language: The Study of Deaf People and their Language , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Ladd , Paddy . 1978 . “ Communication and Dummification: A Consumer Viewpoint ” . In Of Sound and Mind: Papers on Deafness, Personality and Mental Health , Edited by: Montgomery , George . Edinburgh : Scottish Workshop Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Ladd , Paddy . 1994 . “ Deaf Culture: Finding It and Nurturing It ” . In The Deaf Way: Perspectives from the International Conference on Deaf Culture , Edited by: Erting , Carol . Washington, DC : Gallaudet University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Lane , Harlan . 1988 . When the Mind Hears: A History of the Deaf , London : Penguin .
   Google Scholar
• Love , James Kerr . 1906 . Plea for the Study of the Deaf Child , Glasgow : MacDougall .
   Google Scholar
• McLoughlin , M.G. 1987 . History of the Education of the Deaf in England , Liverpool : McLoughlin .
   Google Scholar
• McMillan , Corry T. 2004 . Changing Standards of Education, 1950 to 1990: Using Statistics to Test Historical Myths . Deaf History Review , 1 : 56 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Mitchell , William . 1899 . School Board of Glasgow—Remarks and Review , Glasgow : School Board of Glasgow .
   Google Scholar
• Montgomery , George . 1997 . Silent Destiny: A Brief History of Donaldson's College , Edinburgh : Scottish Workshop Publications .
   Google Scholar
• Morgan , N. and Trainor , R. 1990 . “ The Dominant Classes ” . In People and Society in Scotland, Vol. II: 1830–1914 , Edited by: Fraser , W.H. and Morris , R.J. Edinburgh : John Donald .
   Google Scholar
• Rée , Jonathan . 1999 . I See A Voice: A Philosophical History of Sign Language, Deafness and the Senses , London : Flamingo .
   Google Scholar
• Sacks , Oliver . 1991 . Seeing Voices , London : Picador .
   Google Scholar
• Scouten , Edward L. 1984 . Turning Points in the Education of Deaf People , Danville : Interstate .
   Google Scholar
• Smith , Robert J. 2001 . The City Silent: A History of Deaf Connections , Coleford : MacLean .
   Google Scholar
• Watson , Joseph . 1809 . Instruction of the Deaf and Dumb , London : Darton & Harvey .
   Google Scholar
• Watson , Linda . 1998 . “ Oralism—current policy and practice ” . In Issues in Deaf Education , Edited by: Gregory , Susan , Powers , Stephen , Watson , Linda , Knight , Pamela and McGracken , Wendy . London : David Fulton Publishers .
   Google Scholar
• Watson , Thomas J. 1967 . The Education of Hearing-handicapped Children , London : University of London Press .
   Google Scholar
• Whetnall , E. , Fry , D.B. and Niven , R.B. 1970 . Learning to Hear , London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar

Periodicals

• Bell, Alexander Graham. (1898) “The Question of Sign-Language and the Utility of Signs in the Instruction of the Deaf: Two Papers by Alexander Graham Bell.” First published in 1898. Reproduced in Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education 10, no. 2, (2005), 111–121.
   Google Scholar

Unpublished Material

Theses, Dissertations

• Hutchison, Iain. “Child disability in Scotland, c.1872–c.1914.” BA(Hons) diss., University of Strathclyde, 2000.
   Google Scholar
• Love, James Kerr. “On the limits of hearing.” MD thesis, University of Glasgow, 1888.
   Google Scholar
• Maxwell, John. “School Board and Pupil Welfare: Govan School Board 1873–1919.” MLitt thesis, University of Strathclyde, 1973.
   Google Scholar
• Philip, Graham. “Donaldson's Hospital, the first fifty years: A study of deaf education in Edinburgh 1850–1900.” MEd diss., University of Stirling, 1987.
   Google Scholar
• Watson, Thomas J. “A History of Deaf Education in Scotland, 1760–1939.” PhD thesis, University of Edinburgh, 1949.
   Google Scholar

Papers Presented at Meetings

• Weygand, Zina. “From Charity to Citizenship: Deaf-mutes and the Blind in France, from the Middle Ages to the legacy of the French Revolution.” Paper presented at Enabling the Past: New Perspectives in the History of Disability, University of Manchester, June 2005.
   Google Scholar

Public Documents

Aberdeen University Archives (AUA)

• Aberdeen Deaf & Dumb Institution (ADDI) “Account of the General Institution for the Education of the Deaf and Dumb on the Principles of the Abbé Sicard, Established in Aberdeen. July 1, 1821.” Thomson's Collection, Vol. 96, Pamphlet No. 7.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI, Minute Book, 1877, MS3724.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI, “Report from Alexander Pender, November 1883”, MS3428.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI (1886) Annual Report, 1885, Ref: Herald, Vol. 89, H 89/8.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI (1887) Annual Report, 1886, Ref: Herald, Vol. 89, H 89/8.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI, Reports on Methods of Teaching in response to requests from ADDI, 1903, MS3428.
   Google Scholar
• ADDI, “Report by the Committee appointed by the Directors of the Institution for Deaf and Dumb to confer with the Aberdeen School Board in regard to the future relations between the Institution and the School for the Deaf carried on by the Board”, 1914, MS3428.
   Google Scholar

Archdiocese of Glasgow Archives (AGA)

• Letter from Sister Teresa Farrell to the Archbishop, 14 September 1908.
   Google Scholar
• Smyllum Orphanage, Annual Report, 1889.
   Google Scholar
• Glasgow Institution for the Deaf and Dumb (GIDD).
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1872) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1877) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1878) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1879) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1880) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1881) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1884) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1886) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1888) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1896) Report submitted to the Directors of the Glasgow Institution for the Education of the Deaf and Dumb, by the sub-committee appointed to investigate and report upon the various methods followed in schools and institutions in which the teaching of deaf-mutes is carried on.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1908) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar
• GIDD (1912) Annual Report.
   Google Scholar

National Library of Scotland

• Donaldson's Hospital (1861–1888) Minute Book of Meetings of Governors, Dep.263/15.
   Google Scholar
• Edinburgh Royal Institute for the Education of Deaf and Dumb Children (ERIEDDC) (1870) Annual Report, Dep.263/154.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1872) Annual Report, Dep263/154.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1880) Annual Report, Dep263/155.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1881) Annual Report, Dep263/155.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1886) Annual Report, Dep263/155.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1888) Annual Report, Dep263/155.
   Google Scholar
• ERIEDDC (1891) Annual Report, Dep263/156.
   Google Scholar