Nationalism and the Russian political spectrum: Locating and evaluating the extremes

References

• Urban , Joan Barth and Solovei , Valerii D. 1997 . Russia's Communists at the Crossroads , Boulder , CO : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Evans , Geoffrey and Whitefield , Stephen . 1998 . 'The evolution of left and right in post-Soviet Russia' . Europe-Asia Studies , 50/6 : 1036
   Google Scholar
• Carlsen , Aksel V. 1999 . 'Partier i det post-sovjetiske Rusland-et forsø0g pÛ typologisering' . Nordisk Østforum , 13/4 : 5 – 21 . For two different surveys that both present different Russian scholars' systems of categories, see
   Google Scholar
• Godzimirski , Jakub . “ 'Russian political landscape, 1991-99' ” . NUPI Center for Russian Studies . database, http://www.nupi.no/forskning/
   Google Scholar
• Heritage Foundation's Dateline Moscow, 15 December 1998 and 19 July 1999.
   Google Scholar
• Lenin , V. I. February-July 1974 . “ 'Left-wing childishness and the petty-bourgeois mentality' ” . In Collected Works , Edited by: Lenin , V. I. vol. 27 , February-July , 327 Moscow : Progress Publishers . 1918
   Google Scholar
• Eatwell , Roger and O'Sullivan , Noël , eds. 1989 . The Nature of the Right: European and American Political Thought Since 1789 , 62 – 75 . London : Pinter Publishers .
   Google Scholar
• Surovell , Jeffrey . 1994 . 'Gorbachev's last year: leftist or rightist?' . Europe-Asia Studies , 46/3 For a discussion of this process, see, In this article Surovell uses the terms 'conservative' and 'right', and 'democratic' and 'left' interchangeably
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• 1994 . 'Novogo izdaniya Oktyabrskoy revoliutsii ne budet' . Rossiya , 40 19-25 October
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . 'Situatsiyu vzryvaet natsionalnaya ushchemlennost russkikh' . Nezavisimaya gazeta , 9 January
   Google Scholar
• Dmitriev , Mikhail . 1999 . “ 'Party economic programs and implications' ” . In Primer on Russia's 1999 Duma Elections , Edited by: McFaul , Michael , Petrov , Nikolai , Ryabov , Andrei and Reisch , Elizabeth . 39 Moscow : Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Carnegie Moscow Center . The survey, which covers the programmes of the KPRF, LDPR, Yabloko, OVR, and NDR, is also covered in the article
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . 'Cherez vybory k rynku' . Itogi , 14 December
   Google Scholar
• Zlobin , Nikolai V. 1993 . “ 'The political spectrum' ” . In Political Parties in Russia , IAS Research Series, no. 68 Edited by: Dallin , Alexander . 77 Berkeley , CA : University of California at Berkeley . Even Vladimir Zhirinovskiy, who by his rhetoric many would describe as a nationalist-imperialist, has spoken of his party as being 'right-centrist'. In a 1994 interview, he said that centrism was 'the very best form …. To stay in the centre, not go to the extremes':
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . 'My vsegda otkryty dlya vsekh' . Oppozitsiya , 4
   Google Scholar
• Popov , Vladimir . 1999 . 'The razor's edge, or centrism the Russian way' . Rossiyskaya Gazeta , 24 February Poll by the Russian Independent Institute of Social and National Problems. Supporters of radical market reforms constituted 7.2%, of 'an independent Russian path of development ' 15.6%, of communist ideology 10%, and of social-democracy 5.2%:
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Luzhkov, the biggest (business) man in Moscow' . St. Petersburg Times , 15-21 September
   Google Scholar
• Buzgalin , Aleksandr . 1999 . 'Luzhkov as a "new socialist": a collage in the post-modern style' . Jamestown Foundation Prism , 4/6 16 July
   Google Scholar
• December 1995 . Kratkoe opisanie vsekh predvybornykh blokov , December , Moscow : Informat sionno-Ekspernay a gruppa 'Panorama' . Pribylovskiy, Vladimir, 43 linii spektra
   Google Scholar
• 23 September 1998 . “ 'Russia poll: bring on dictatorship' ” . 23 September , Associated Press . For instance, a 1998 poll found that one third of Russians believed that the president should have 'supreme power', and that dictatorship was the only way out of the current economic crisis. 45% of respondents disagreed that dictatorship was the only solution:
   Google Scholar
• Popov , Nikolai . 1999 . "The quiet appeal of dictatorship' . Vremya MN , 6 December poll by VTsIOM. Similarly, in a late 1999 poll, 45% answered that the Russian people 'needs an iron hand', while another 27% said that power 'should be concentrated in one pair of hands now':, reported by RIA Novosti, poll by ARPI
   Google Scholar
• V. V. Putin, 'Rossiya na rubezhe tysyachetletiy',
   Google Scholar
• Vladimir Putin, Otkrytoe pismo Vladimira Purina k rossiyskim izbiratelyam',
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . 'The difference? I do not drink!' . Die Woche (Hamburg) , 1 December Interfax, 31 January 2000. As a matter of fact, this peculiar phrasing-which he repeated later-is not only Putin's. A few years earlier, at the peak of his popularity, Aleksandr Lebed expressed himself in exactly the same way-leaving open questions about his dedication to democracy: see, e.g.,, FBIS-SOV-95-232
   Google Scholar
• 1970-81 . Bolshaya Sovetskaya entsiklopedia, , 3rd edn. Moscow The definitions are from
   Google Scholar
• KoIsto , Pål . 1984 . "The concept of "patriotic internationalism": a contribution to the understanding of Soviet ideology' . Nordic Journal for Soviet and East European Studies , 4 : 2 – 6 .
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Raising the Russian question: ethnicity and statehood, russkie and Rossiya' . Nationalism & Ethnic Politics , 2/1 : 91 – 110 . This model was developed and elaborated upon by this author in a different article: see
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . 'Milliard dollarov-I ya u vlasti' . Rossiya , 27 1-7 June
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . 'Lekarstvo ot geopoliticheskogo psikhoza' . Obozrevatel , 6
   Google Scholar
• Stankevich , Sergei . 1992 . 'Russia has already made an anti-imperial choice' . Nezavisimaya gazeta , 6 November Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press, 44/45 (9 December 1992), p. 11
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . 'Dlya chego perevozit chto-to iz Rossii v Rossiyu?' . Nezavisimaya gazeta , 7 April
   Google Scholar
• Baburin , Sergey . 1995 . 'Volya, pobeda' . Zavtra , 27 July
   Google Scholar
• Lebed , Aleksandr . 1992 . 'Armiya-eto vsegda zashchita naroda' . Literaturnaya Rossiya , 31 July
   Google Scholar
• Lebed , Aleksandr . 1997 . My Life and My Country , 359 Washington, DC : Regnery Publishing .
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Programma Kommunisticheskoy partii Rossiyskoy Federatsii' . Informatsionniy byulleten , 50/9 15 May : 12 This programme may also be found on the internet, at www.kprf.ru.
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . Jamestown Foundation Monitor , 30 September
   Google Scholar
• Simonsen , Sven Gunnar . 1997 . 'Still favoring the power of the workers' . Transitions , 4/7 : 53
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . 'Lyubaya diktatura besperspektivna: boyarskaya, proletarskaya, prezidentskaya' . Oppozitsiya , 11
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . 'Betrayal of Serbs is a deadly sin' . Stem (Hamburg) , 21 September FBIS-SOV-95-183
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . 'Russian militarism risks new Hitler' . Chicago Sun-Times , 8 July
   Google Scholar
• Evans , Alfred B. Jr. 1994 . 'Yeltsin and Russian nationalism' . The Soviet and Post-Soviet Review , 21/1 : 38
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Moscow: open season, closed city' . Human Rights Watch , 9/10 September For one early report on Moscow's policies against Caucasians, see, (D)
   Google Scholar
• Brym , Robert J. and Degtyarev , Andrei . 1993 . 'Anti-semitism in Moscow: results of an October 1992 survey' . Slavic Review , 52/1 : 5
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . 'Russian left descends into dark well of anti-semitism' . The Guardian , 5 November Similarly, in a speech reprinted in the radical newspaper Zavtra, Makashov said: 'Usury, deceit, corruption, and thievery are flourishing in the country. That is why I call the reformers yids. Who are these Jews? … Yid is not a nationality, yid is a profession':
   Google Scholar
• Makashov , General Albert . 1998 . 'Usurers of Russia' . Zavtra , 4220 October
   Google Scholar
• Zyuganov , G. 1998 . On the national pride of patriots: statement by Communist Party of the Russian Federation Central Committee Chairman' . Sovetskaya Rossiya , 24 December
   Google Scholar
• December 1995 . Kratkoe opisanie vsekh predvybornykh blokav , December , 22 – 23 . Moscow : Informatsionno-Ekspernay a gruppa 'Panorama' . Vladimir Pribylovskiy, 43 linii spektra
   Google Scholar
• Simonsen , Sven Gunnar . 1996 . 'Blackshirt friends of the nation' . Nationalities Papers , 24/4 : 625 – 639 . Based on a district court decision, Spas was later removed from the election register. For a background on Barkashov and the RNE, see
   Google Scholar
• Umland , Andreas . 1997 . Vladimir Zhirinovskii in Russian Politics: Three Approaches to the Emergence of the Liberal-Democratic Party of Russia, 1990-1993 , 331 – 361 . Berlin : Promotionsausschuss, FB Geschichtswissenshaft, Freie Universitat Berlin . To illustrate, Yegor Gaidar lost a court suit by Vladimir Zhirinovskiy in 1994, for having called Zhirinovskiy a 'fascist'. The court agreed with Zhirinovskiy's lawyer that fascism should be used to describe only the regimes of Hitler and Mussolini before and during the Second World War, and thus could not apply to Zhirinovskiy. The defendant's argument that something that looks, walks, and talks like fascism in fact is fascism was not supported. For an in-depth examination of this issue, see
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . Ob istokakh politicheskogo ekstremizma v Rossiyskoy Federatsii' . Zayavlenie Gosudarstvennoy Dumy , 19 March Thus, a statement from the State Duma, reprinted in a KPRF publication, expressed concern about political extremism in Russia, and at the same time basically described such extremism as a provocation by the Yeltsin regime itself: 'There is reason to believe that these [extremist] organizations are using support from forces that are interested in creating an impression that there is such a thing as a "Russian fascism"': see
   Google Scholar
• Bindyukov , Nikolay and Lopata , Petr . 1999 . Osobaya tretya sila-novyy politicheskiy fenomen , 318 Moscow : ITRK .
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . 'Podrobnosti' , 14 February Interview with Fedorov on Russian Television
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Yeltsin calls for "unifying national idea'" . Itar-Tass , 12 July FBIS-SOV-96-135
   Google Scholar
• Simonsen , Sven Gunnar . 1999 . 'Inheriting the Soviet policy toolbox: Russia's dilemma over ascriptive nationality' . Europe-Asia Studies , 51/6 : 1069 – 1087 . For details on this process, see
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• V. V. Putin: Rossiya na rubezhe tysyachetletiy', www.government.gov.ru/government/minister/articlevvpl.html. (www.government.gov.ru/government/minister/articlevvpl.html.)
   Google Scholar
• Simonsen , Sven Gunnar . 2000 . 'Vladimir Putin's leadership style: ethnocentric patriotism' . Security Dialogue , 31/3 : 220 – 222 .
   Google Scholar
• Vladimir Putin, 'Vystuplenie na torzhestvennom prieme v oznamenovanie 55-y godovshchiny Pobedy v Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyne 1941-1945 godov', http://president.kremlin.ru/events/32.html. (http://president.kremlin.ru/events/32.html.)
   Google Scholar