Advanced search
Publication Cover
School Leadership & Management
Formerly School Organisation
Volume 19, 1999 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
674
Views
58
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Reviews

'Well. That about wraps it up for school choice research': A state of the art review

Stephen Gorard
Pages 25-47 | Published online: 25 Aug 2010

  • Adler , M , Petch , A and Tweedie , J . 1989 . Parental Choice and Educational Policy , Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press .
  • Arons , S . 1982 . “ Educational choice ” . In Family Choice in Schooling , Edited by: Manley-Casimir , M . Toronto : Lexington .
  • Ball , S . 1993 . Education markets, choice and social class: the market as a class strategy in the UK and the USA . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 14 (1) : 3 – 19 .
  • Ball , S . 1994 . Education Reform: a critical and post-structural approach , Buckingham : Open University Press .
  • Ball , S , Bowe , R and Gewirtz , S . Circuits of Schooling: a sociological exploration of parental choice in social class contexts . presentation to the British Educational Research Association Annual Conference . Stirling.
  • Ball , S , Bowe , R and Gewirtz , S . 1996 . School choice, social class and distinction: the realization of social advantage in education . Journal of Education Policy , 11 (1) : 89 – 112 .
  • Ball , S and Gewirtz , S . 1997 . Is research possible? A rejoinder to Tooley's 'On schools choice and social class' . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 18 (4) : 575 – 586 .
  • Bauch , P . 1989 . “ Can poor parents make wise educational choices? ” . In Private Schools and Public Policy: International Perspective , Edited by: Boyd , W and Cibulka , J . Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Bentley-Ball , W . 1982 . “ Parents in court ” . In Family Choice in Schooling , Edited by: Manley-Casimir , M . Toronto : Lexington .
  • Blair , M . 1994 . Black teachers, black students and education markets . Cambridge Journal of Education , 24 (2) : 277 – 291 .
  • Bottery , M . 1992 . The Ethics of Educational Management , London : Cassell .
  • Bowe , R , Ball , S and Gerwirtz , S . 1994a . 'Parental choice', consumption and social theory: The operation of micro-markets in education . British Journal of Educational Studies , 42 (1) : 38 – 52 .
  • Bowe , R , Gerwirtz , S and Ball , S . 1994b . Captured by the discourse? Issues and concerns in researching parental choice . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 15 (1) : 63 – 78 .
  • Boyd , W and Lugg , C . 1997 . “ Markets, choice and educational reform ” . In International Handbook of Educational Change , Edited by: Hargreaves , A , Lieberman , A , Fullan , M and Hopkins , D . Amsterdam : Kluwer .
  • Boyd , W , Crowson , R and van Geel , T . 1994 . Rational choice theory and the politics of education: promise and limitations, Politics of Education Association Yearbook 1994 , 127 – 145 . Thousand Oaks, CA : Corwin Press .
  • Bourdieu , P . 1997 . “ The forms of capital ” . In Education Culture, Economy, and Society , Edited by: Halsey , A , Lauder , H , Brown , P and Wells , A . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Brown , S . 1994 . School effectiveness research and the evaluation of schools . Evaluation and Research in Education , 8 (1 and 2) : 55 – 68 .
  • Child , H . 1962 . The Independent Progressive School , London : Hutchinson .
  • Clark , P and Round , E . 1991 . Good State Schools Guide , London : Ebury .
  • Coldron , J and Boulton , P . 1991 . 'Happiness' as a criterion of parents' choice of school . Journal of Education Policy , 6 (2) : 169 – 178 .
  • Coldron , J and Boulton , P . 1996 . What do parents mean when they talk about 'discipline' in relation to their childrens' school'? . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 17 (1) : 53 – 64 .
  • Coleman , J . 1990 . “ Choice, community and future schools ” . In Choice and Control in American Education , Edited by: Clune , W and Witte , J . Volume I , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Coleman , J and Hoffer , T . 1987 . Public and Private High Schools , New York : Basic Books .
  • Conway , S . 1997 . The reproduction of exclusion and disadvantage: symbolic violence and social class inequalities in 'parental choice' of secondary education . Sociological Research On-line , 2 (4)
  • Cookson , P . 1994 . School Choice , London : Yale University .
  • Cookson , P and Persell , C . 1985 . Preparing for Power , New York : Basic Books .
  • David , M , West , A and Ribbens , J . 1994 . Mother's Intuition? Choosing secondary schools , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Davies , P . Choice, rationality and risk in credit based systems of learning: a working paper . presentation to ESRC Learning Society Seminar . Bristol.
  • Dennison , W . Researching the competitive edge: detractors and attractors in school marketing . presentation at ESRC/CEPAM Invitation Seminar . Milton Keynes.
  • Devlin , T and Knight , B . 1990 . Public Relations and Marketing for Schools , Harlow : Longman .
  • Dooley , P . 1991 . “ Muslim private schools ” . In Private Schools. Tradition, change and diversity , Edited by: Walford , G . London : Chapman .
  • Echols , F and Willms , J . 1995 . Reasons for school choice in Scotland . Journal of Educational Policy , 10 (2) : 143 – 156 .
  • Echols , F , McPherson , A and Willms , J . 1990 . Parental choice in Scotland . Journal of Educational Policy , 5 (3) : 207 – 222 .
  • Edwards , T , Fitz , J and Whitty , G . 1989 . The State and Private Education: an evaluation of the assisted places scheme , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Eiser , J and van der Plight , J . 1988 . Attitudes and Decisions , London : Routledge .
  • Erickson , D . 1989 . “ A libertarian perspective on schooling ” . In Private Schools and Public Policy: international perspective , Edited by: Boyd , W and Cibulka , J . Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Evans , L . 1971 . Education in Industrial Wales 1700-1900 , Cardiff : Avalon .
  • Fitz , J , Halpin , D and Power , S . 1993 . Education in the Market Place: grant maintained schools , London : Kogan Page .
  • Fitz , J , Halpin , D and Power , S . 1997 . 'Between a rock and a hard place': diversity, institutional identity and grant-maintained schools . Oxford Review of Education , 23 (1) : 17 – 30 .
  • Forster , P . 1992 . Whose choice is it anyway? . Managing Schools Today , 1 (6) : 36 – 37 .
  • Foskett , N and Hesketh , A . 1997 . Constructing choice in contiguous and parallel markets: institutional and school leavers' responses to the new post-16 market . Oxford Review of Education , 23 (3) : 299 – 320 .
  • Fowler-Finn , T . 1994 . Why have they chosen another school system? . Educational Leadership , December : 60 – 62 . 1993/January 1994
  • Fox , I . 1989 . “ Elitism and the British "public" schools ” . In Private Schools and Public Policy: international perspectives , Edited by: Boyd , W and Cibulka , J . Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Fox , I . 1990 . “ The demand for public school education: a crisis of confidence in comprehensive schooling? ” . In Privatisation and Privilege in Education , Edited by: Walford , G . London : Routledge .
  • Gaffney , E . 1981 . Private Schools and the Public Good , Indiana : University of Notre Dame .
  • Garner , W and Hannaway , J . 1982 . “ Private schools: the client connection ” . In Family Choice in Schooling , Edited by: Manley Casimir , M . Toronto : Lexington .
  • Gewirtz , S , Ball , S and Bowe , R . 1995 . Markets, Choice and Equity in Education , Buckingham : Open University Press .
  • Gibson , A and Asthana , S . 1998 . Schools, pupils and examination results: contextualising school 'performance' . British Educational Research Journal , 24 (3) : 269 – 282 .
  • Glatter , R , Woods , P and Bagley , C . 1997 . “ Diversity, differentiation and hierarchy. School choice and parental preferences ” . In Choice and Diversity in Schooling. Perspectives and Prospects , Edited by: Glatter , R , Woods , P and Bagley , C . London : Routledge .
  • Goldring , E . Communal Opportunities to Learn, Parental Involvement and School Choice: Israel and the United States . presentation at ESRC/CEPAM invitation Seminar . Milton Keynes.
  • Gorard , S . 1996a . Three steps to "Heaven": The family and school choice . Educational Review , 48 (3) : 237 – 252 .
  • Gorard , S . 1996b . Fee-paying schools in Britain: A peculiarly English phenomenon . Educational Review , 48 (1) : 89 – 93 .
  • Gorard , S . 1997a . School Choice in an Established Market , Aldershot : Ashgate .
  • Gorard , S . 1997b . Paying for a little England: school choice and the Welsh language . Welsh Journal of Education , 6 (1) : 19 – 32 .
  • Gorard , S . 1997c . Who pays the piper? Intergenerational aspects of school choice . Intergenerational aspects of school choice , 17 (2) : 245 – 256 .
  • Gorard , S . 1997d . A choice of methods: the methodology of choice . Research in Education , 57
  • Gorard , S . 1998a . Social movement in undeveloped markets: an apparent contradiction in education policy studies . Educational Review , 50 (3) : 249 – 258 .
  • Gorard , S . 1998b . Under starters orders: the established market, the Cardiff study and the Smithfield project . International Studies in Sociology of Education , 8 (3)
  • Gorard , S . 1998c . Four errors… and a conspiracy? The effectiveness of schools in Wales . The effectiveness of schools in Wales , 24 (4) : 459 – 472 .
  • Gorard , S . 1999 . Planning ahead in a 'market' for schools: predicting patterns of school choice . Evaluation & Research in Education , (forthcoming)
  • Gorard , S and Fitz , J . 1998 . The more things change… the missing impact of marketisation . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 19 (3) : 365 – 376 .
  • GPDSA . 1995 . School Marketing/PR: key points , Girls Public Day Schools Association . handout to member schools
  • Griffiths , J . 1991 . “ Small private schools in South Wales ” . In Private Schools. Tradition, Change and Diversity , Edited by: Walford , G . London : Chapman .
  • Haertel , E , James , T and Levin , H . 1987 . Comparing Public and Private Schools , Volume 2 , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Hahn , F . 1988 . “ On market economies ” . In Thatcherism , Edited by: Skidelsky , R . Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Hammond , T and Dennison , W . 1995 . School choice in less populated areas . Educational Management and Administration , 23 (2) : 104 – 113 .
  • Hargreaves , D . 1996 . Diversity and choice in school education: a modified libertarian approach . Oxford Review of Education , 22 (2) : 131 – 147 .
  • Harris Research Centre . 1988 . Secondary Education in Kent: research among customers , Maidstone : Kent County Council .
  • Hartley , D . 1994 . Mixed messages in education policy: sign of the times? . British Journal of Educational Studies , 42 (3) : 230 – 245 .
  • Hatcher , R . 1998 . Class differentiation in education: rational choices? . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 19 (1) : 5 – 24 .
  • Headington , R and Howson , J . 1995 . The school brochure: a marketing tool? . Education Management and Administration , 23 (2) : 89 – 95 .
  • Hesketh , A and Knight , P . 1998 . Secondary school prospectuses and educational markets . Cambridge Journal of Education , 28 (1) : 21 – 35 .
  • Hirsch , D . 1997 . “ What can Britain learn from abroad? ” . In Choice and Diversity in Schooling. Perspectives and Prospects , Edited by: Glatter , R , Woods , P and Bagley , C . London : Routledge .
  • Hirschman , A . 1970 . Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States , Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Hughes , M , Wikeley , F and Nash , T . 1994 . Parents and their Children's Schools , Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Hunter , J . 1991 . Which school? A study of parents' choice of secondary school . A study of parents' choice of secondary school , 33 (1) : 31 – 41 .
  • ISIS . 1992 . Choosing Your Independent School , London : Independent Schools Information Service .
  • James , C and Phillips , P . 1995 . The practice of educational marketing in schools . Education Management and Administration , 23 (2) : 75 – 88 .
  • Johnson , D . 1987 . Private schools and state schools. Two systems or one? , Milton Keynes : Open University Press .
  • Jowett , S . 1995 . Allocating Secondary School Places: a study of policy and practice , Slough : NFER .
  • Lee , E , Forthofer , R and Lorimor , R . 1989 . Analyzing Complex Survey Data , London : Sage .
  • Lee , V , Croninger , R and Smith , J . 1994 . Parental choice of schools and social stratification in education: the paradox of Detroit . Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis , 16 (4) : 434 – 457 .
  • Le Grand , J and Bartlett , W . 1993 . Quasi-Markets and Social Policy , London : Macmillan .
  • Levacic , R , Hardman , J and Woods , P . Competition as a spur to improvement? Differential improvement in GCSE examination results . presented to International Congress for School Effectiveness and Improvement . Manchester.
  • Levin , B and Riffel , J . School system responses to external change: implications form school choice . presentation at ESRC/CEPAM Invitation Seminar . Milton Keynes.
  • Levin , B and Riffel , J . 1997 . “ School system responses to external change: implications for school choice ” . In Choice and Diversity in Schooling. Perspectives and prospects , Edited by: Glatter , R , Woods , P and Bagley , C . London : Routledge, 44-58 .
  • Levin , H . 1992 . Market approaches to education: vouchers and school choice . Economics of Education Review , 11 (4) : 279 – 285 .
  • Macbeth , A , Strachan , D and Macaulay , C . 1986 . Parental Choice of School in Scotland , Glasgow : University of Glasgow .
  • Macrae , S , Maguire , M and Ball , S . Whose 'learning' society? A tentative deconstruction . presentation to ESRC Learning Society Seminar . Bristol.
  • Maddala , G . 1992 . Introduction to Econometrics , New York : Macmillan .
  • Madsen , J . Parent efficacy in independent private schools: lessons for public schools . presentation to American Educational Research Association Annual Conference . New Orleans.
  • Maynard , A . 1975 . Experiments with Choice in Education , London : Institute of Economic Affairs .
  • McPherson , A and Willms , J . 1987 . Equalisation and improvement: some effects of comprehensive reorganisation in Scotland . Sociology , 21 (4) : 509 – 539 .
  • Measor , L and Woods , P . 1991 . “ Breakthroughs and blockages in ethnographic research: contrasting experiences during the 'changing schools' project ” . In Doing Educational Research , Edited by: Walford , G . London : Routledge .
  • Menter , I , Muschamp , Y and Ozga , J . The primary market-place: a study in small service providers . presentation at American Educational Research Association Annual Conference . San Francisco.
  • National Commission on Education . 1993 . Learning to Succeed , London : Heinemann .
  • OECD . 1994 . School: a matter of choice , Paris : Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development .
  • Oppenheim , A . 1992 . Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement , London : Pinter .
  • Raven , J . 1989 . “ Equity in diversity ” . In Parents and Schools: the contemporary challenge , Edited by: Macleod , F . Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Reay , D . 1998 . Engendering social reproduction: mothers in the educational marketplace . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 19 (2) : 195 – 209 .
  • Reay , D and Ball , S . 1997 . 'Spoilt for choice': the working classes and educational markets . Oxford Review of Education , 23 (1) : 89 – 101 .
  • Rees , G , Fevre , R , Furlong , J and Gorard , S . 1997 . History, place and the learning society: towards a sociology of lifetime learning . Journal of Education Policy , 12 (6) : 485 – 497 .
  • Reynolds , D . 1990 . The great Welsh education debate . History of Education , 19 (3) : 251 – 260 .
  • Reynolds , D . 1995 . Creating an educational system for Wales . The Welsh Journal of Education , 4 (2) : 4 – 21 .
  • Reynolds , D and Bellin , W . Summer 1996 . Welsh-medium schools. Why they are better, Agenda , Summer , The Institute of Welsh Affairs .
  • Riley , K . 1994 . The active parent myth . Education , 1 April : 251
  • Rogers , M . 1992 . Opting Out , Wiltshire : Cromwell .
  • Smedley , D . 1995 . Marketing secondary schools to are parents--some lessons from the research on parental choice . Education Management and Administration , 23 (2) : 96 – 103 .
  • Smith , D and Tomlinson , S . 1989 . The School Effect , London : PSL .
  • Smyth , J . 1993 . A Socially Critical View of the Self-Managing School , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Stalker , K . The antinomies of choice in community care . presentation to ESRC Learning Society Seminar . Bristol.
  • Terrell , I and Clinton , C . 1992 . Voicing their views . Managing Schools Today , 2 (1) : 26 – 28 .
  • Thiessen , E . 1982 . “ Religious freedom and educational pluralism ” . In Family Choice in Schooling , Edited by: Manley-Casimir , M . Toronto : Lexington .
  • Thomas , A and Dennison , B . 1991 . Parental or pupil choice: who really decides in urban schools? . Education Management and Administration , 19 (4) : 243 – 251 .
  • Thomas , G and McClelland , R . 1997 . Parents in a market-place: some responses to information, diversity and power . Educational Research , 39 (2) : 185 – 194 .
  • Tomlinson , S . 1994 . What is really going on in school? . Parliamentary Brief on Education , December : 103 – 110 .
  • Tooley , J . 1997 . On school choice and social class: a response to Ball, Bowe and Gewirtz . British Journal of Sociology of Education , 18 (2) : 217 – 230 .
  • Tooley , J and Darby , D . 1998 . Educational Research: a critique , London : Of STED .
  • Walford , G . 1989 . Private Schools in Ten Countries: policy and practice , London : Routledge .
  • Walford , G . 1991 . Choice of school at the First City Technology College . Educational Studies , 17 (1) : 65 – 75 .
  • Walford , G . Bargain offer! Build your own school! The fate of sponsored grant-maintained schools . presentation to BERA Annual Conference . York.
  • Waslander , S and Thrupp , M . 1997 . “ Choice, competition, and segregation: an empirical analysis of a New Zealand secondary school market, 1990-93 ” . In Education Culture, Economy, and Society , Edited by: Halsey , A , Lauder , H , Brown , P and Wells , A . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • West , A . 1992 . Factors affecting choice of school for middle class parents: implications for marketing . Educational Management and Administration , 20 (4) : 212 – 221 .
  • West , A and Varlaam , A . 1991 . Choosing a secondary school: parents of junior school children . Educational Research , 33 (1) : 22 – 30 .
  • West , A , David , M , Hailes , J and Ribbens , J . 1995 . Parents and the process of choosing secondary schools: implications for schools . Educational Management and Administration , 23 (1) : 28 – 38 .
  • West , A , Pennell , H and Noden , P . Secondary schools: who's doing the choosing parents or schools? . presentation to BERA Annual Conference . York.
  • West , A , Pennell , H and Noden , P . 1998 . School admissions: increasing equity, accountability and transparency . British Journal of Educational Studies , 46 (2) : 188 – 200 .
  • Whitty , G . 1997 . Creating quasi-markets in education . Review of Research in Education , 22 : 3 – 48 .
  • Whitty , G , Power , S , Edwards , T and Wigfall , V . March 1998 . Destined for success? Educational biographies of academically able pupils, report on project funded by the ESRC March , 1998
  • Willms , J and Echols , F . 1992 . Alert and inert clients: the Scottish experience of parental choice of schools . Economics of Education Review , 11 (4) : 339 – 350 .
  • Witte , J . 1990a . “ Choice and control: an analytical overview ” . In Choice and Control in American Education, Volume 1: the theory of choice and control in education , Edited by: Clune , W and Witte , J . Volume 1 , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Witte , J . 1990b . “ Introduction ” . In Choice and Control in American Education, Volume 1: the theory of choice and control in education , Edited by: Clune , W and Witte , J . Volume 1 , Lewes : Falmer Press .
  • Witte , J . Educational choice in America: the gap between theory and practice . presentation to BERA Annual Conference . Lancaster.
  • Woods , P . 1992 . Empowerment through choice? Towards an understanding of parental choice and school responsiveness . Towards an understanding of parental choice and school responsiveness , 20 (4) : 204 – 211 .
  • Woods , P , Bagley , C and Clatter , R . 1997 . The public market in England: school responsiveness in a competitive climate , Occasional Research Paper 1 School of Education: Open University .
  • Woods , P , Bagley , C and Glatter , R . 1998 . Choosing grammars? Parental perspectives on secondary schools . Parental perspectives on secondary schools , 40 (1) : 26 – 28 .
  • Woods , P , Bagley , C and Glatter , R . 1998 . School choice and competition: markets in the public interest?
  • Young , S . 1994 . Beware the perils of parental power . Times Educational Supplement , 6 May : 1

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.