Advanced search
Publication Cover
Rethinking History
The Journal of Theory and Practice
Volume 10, 2006 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
414
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Rorty, ‘Historicism’ and the practice of history: A polemic

John H. Zammito
Pages 9-47 | Published online: 15 Aug 2006

References

  • Anchor , R. 1987 . ‘Narrativity and the transformation of historical consciousness’ . Clio , vol. 16 : 121 – 137 .
  • Ankersmit , F. A. 1986 . “ ‘The dilemma of contemporary Anglo-Saxon philosophy of history’ ” . In Knowing and Telling History: The Anglo-Saxon Debate, History and Theory Edited by: Ankersmit , F. A. 1 – 27 . Beiheft 25
  • Ayers , M. 1970 . ‘Substance, reality, and the great, dead philosophers’ . American Philosophical Quarterly , vol. 7 : 38 – 49 .
  • Ayers , M. 1978 . “ ‘Analytical philosophy and the history of philosophy’ ” . In Philosophy and Its Past , Edited by: Rée , J. , Ayers , M. and Westoby , A. 41 – 66 . Atlantic Highlands, NJ : Humanities .
  • Bambach , C. 1995 . Heidegger, Dilthey, and the Crisis of Historicism , Ithaca and London : Cornell University Press .
  • Behler , E. 1984 . “ ‘What it means to understand an author better than he understood himself: idealistic philosophy and romantic hermeneutics’ ” . In Literary Theory and Criticism: Festschrift Presented to René Wellek in Honor of His 80th Birthday , vol. 1 , 69 – 92 . Bern, Frankfurt and New York : Peter Lang .
  • Bennett , J. 1965 . ‘Substance, reality, and primary qualities’ . American Philosophical Quarterly , vol. 2 : 1 – 17 .
  • Bennett , J. 1966 . Kant's Analytic , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Bennett , J. 1984 . A Study of Spinoza's Ethics , Indianapolis : Hackett .
  • Bennett , J. 1988 . “ ‘Response to Garber and Rée’ ” . In Doing Philosophy Historically , Edited by: Hare , P. 62 – 69 . Buffalo, NY : Prometheus Books .
  • Bernstein , R. 1985 . “ ‘From hermeneutics to praxis’ ” . In Hermeneutics and Praxis , Edited by: Hollinger , R. 272 – 296 . Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • Bernstein , R. 1986 . “ ‘What is the difference that makes a difference? Gadamer, Habermas, and Rorty’ ” . In Hermeneutics and Modern Philosophy , Edited by: Wachterhauser , B. 343 – 376 . Albany : SUNY Press .
  • Bernstein , R. 1987 . “ ‘History, philosophy, and the question of relativism’ ” . In At the Nexus of Philosophy and History , Edited by: Dauenhauer , B. 3 – 19 . Athens and London : University of Georgia Press .
  • Bloom , H. 1973 . The Anxiety of Influence: A Theory of Poetry , New York : Oxford University Press .
  • Caputo , J. 1985 . “ ‘The thought of being and the conversation of mankind: the case of Heidegger and Rorty’ ” . In Hermeneutics and Praxis , Edited by: Hollinger , R. 248 – 262 . Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • Carr , D. , Dray , W. , Geraets , T. , Ouellet , F. and Watelet , H. , eds. 1982 . La philosophie de l'histoire et la pratique historienne d'aujourd'hui/Philosophy of History and Contemporary Historiography , Ottawa : University of Ottawa Press .
  • Carroll , N. 1990 . ‘Interpretation, history and narrative’ . The Monist , vol. 73 : 134 – 166 .
  • Cascardi , A. 1989 . “ ‘An afterword: the lines redrawn’ ” . In Redrawing the Lines: Analytic Philosophy, Deconstruction, and Literary Theory , Edited by: Dasenbrock , R. 217 – 244 . Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press .
  • Cohen , L. 1986 . ‘Doing philosophy is doing history’ . Synthese , vol. 67 : 51 – 55 .
  • Cohen , S. 1978 . ‘Structuralism and the writing of intellectual history’ . History and Theory , vol. 17 : 175 – 206 .
  • Davidson , D. 1984 . Inquiry into Truth and Interpretation , Oxford : Clarendon .
  • Davidson , D. 1986 . “ ‘A coherence theory of truth and knowledge’ ” . In Truth and Interpretation , Edited by: LePore , E. 307 – 319 . Oxford and New York : Blackwell .
  • Davidson , D. 1990 . “ ‘Afterthoughts, 1987’ ” . In Reading Rorty: Critical Responses to Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature (and Beyond) , Edited by: Malachowski , A. 134 – 137 . Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Dewey , J. 1977 . “ ‘The influence of Darwin on philosophy’ ” . In The Middle Works of John Dewey , vol. 4 , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
  • Dilthey , W. 1989 . Introduction to the Human Sciences. Selected Works, Vol. I , Edited by: Makkreel , R. and Rodi , F. Princeton : Princeton University Press .
  • Dreyfus , H. 1980 . ‘Holism and hermeneutics’ . Review of Metaphysics , vol. 34 : 3 – 23 .
  • Dreyfus , H. 1986 . “ ‘Why studies of human capacities modeled on ideal natural science can never achieve their goal’ ” . In Rationality, Relativism and the Human Sciences , Edited by: Margolis , J. , Krausz , M. and Burian , R. 3 – 22 . Dordrecht : Martinus Nijhoff .
  • Ermarth , M. 1981 . Wilhelm Dilthey: The Critique of Historical Reason , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Feyerabend , P. 1975 . Against Method , Atlantic Highlands, NJ : Humanities .
  • Foucault , M. 1972 . The Archaeology of Knowledge and the Discourse on Language , New York : Harper .
  • Foucault , M. 1973 . The Order of Things: An Archaeology of the Human Sciences , New York : Vintage .
  • Foucault , M. 1977 . “ ‘Nietzsche, genealogy and history’ ” . In Language, Counter-Memory, Practice , 139 – 164 . Ithaca : Cornell University Press .
  • Foucault , M. 1988 . Politics, Philosophy, Culture: Interview and Other Writings 1977–1984 , New York and London : Routledge .
  • Gadamer , H. G. 1976 . Philosophical Hermeneutics , Berkeley, Los Angeles and London : University of California Press .
  • Gadamer , H. G. 1980 . Dialogue and Dialectic , New Haven and London : Yale University Press .
  • Gadamer , H. G. 1986 . The Idea of the Good in Platonic–Aristotelian Philosophy , New Haven and London : Yale University Press .
  • Gadamer , H. G. 1992 . Truth and Method, , 2nd rev. edn , New York : Continuum .
  • Geertz , C. 1986 . ‘The uses of diversity’ . Michigan Quarterly Review , vol. 24 : 105 – 123 .
  • Giddens , A. 1976 . New Rules for the Sociological Method , New York : Basic .
  • Graham , G. 1982 . ‘Can there be history of philosophy?’ . History and Theory , vol. 21 : 37 – 52 .
  • Guignon , C. 1982 . “ ‘Saving the difference: Gadamer and Rorty’ ” . In PSA , Edited by: Asquith , P. D. and Nickles , T. vol. 2 , 360 – 367 . East Lansing, MI : Philosophy of Science Association .
  • Hahn , N. , Bellah , R. , Rabinow , P. and Sullivan , W. , eds. 1983 . Social Science as Moral Inquiry , New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Hall , D. 1994 . Richard Rorty: Prophet and Poet of the New Pragmatism , Albany : SUNY Press .
  • Hiley , H. , Bohman , J. and Shusterman , R. , eds. 1991 . The Interpretive Turn: Philosophy, Science, Culture , Ithaca and London : Cornell University Press .
  • Hirsh , E. D. 1967 . Validity in Interpretation , New Haven and London : Yale University Press .
  • Hollinger , D. 1985 . “ ‘The voice of intellectual history in the conversation of mankind: a note on Richard Rorty’ ” . In In the American Provice: Studies in the History and Historiography of Ideas , 167 – 175 . Bloomington : Indiana University Press . 215–216
  • Hollinger , D. 1993 . ‘How wide the circle of the “we”? American intellectuals and the problem of the ethnos since World War II’ . American Historical Review , vol. 98 : 317 – 337 .
  • Hollinger , R. , ed. 1985 . Hermeneutics and Praxis , Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • Hoy , D. C. 1978 . The Critical Circle: Literature, History, and Philosophical Hermeneutics , Berkeley, Los Angeles and London : University of California Press .
  • Iggers , G. 1995 . ‘Historicism: the history and meaning of the term’ . Journal of the History of Ideas , vol. 56 : 129 – 152 .
  • Ingram , D. 1985 . “ ‘Hermeneutics and truth’ ” . In Hermeneutics and Praxis , Edited by: Hollinger , R. 32 – 53 . Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • Jauss , H. R. 1982 . Towards an Aesthetics of Reception , Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press .
  • Kellner , H. 1989 . Language and Historical Representation: Getting the Story Crooked , Madison : University of Wisconsin Press .
  • Kisiel , T. 1985 . “ ‘The hermeneutics of Gadamer and Heidegger’ ” . In Hermeneutics and Praxis , Edited by: Hollinger , R. 3 – 31 . Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • Kuhn , T. S. 1970 . The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, , 2nd rev. edn , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Kuhn , T. S. 1977 . The Essential Tension , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • LaCapra , D. 1983 . Rethinking Intellectual History , Ithaca : Cornell University Press .
  • LaCapra , D. 1985 . History and Criticism , Ithaca : Cornell University Press .
  • LaCapra , D. 1989 . Soundings in Critical Theory , Ithaca : Cornell University Press .
  • Lakatos , I. 1970 . “ ‘History of science and its rational reconstruction’ ” . In PSA 1970 = Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science , vol. 8 , 91 – 136 . Dordrecht, , Holland : Reidel .
  • Lakatos , I. and Musgrave , A. , eds. 1970 . Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Laudan , L. 1976 . ‘Two dogmas of methodology’ . Philosophy of Science , vol. 43 : 585 – 597 .
  • Livingston , D. 1993 . ‘Good and bad shadow history of philosophy’ . Journal of the History of Philosophy , vol. 31 : 111 – 113 .
  • MacIntyre , A. 1977 . ‘Epistemological crises, dramatic narrative and the philosophy of science’ . The Monist , vol. 60 : 453 – 472 .
  • MacIntyre , A. 1982 . ‘Philosophy, the “other” disciplines, and their histories: a rejoinder to Richard Rorty’ . Soundings , vol. 45 : 127 – 145 .
  • MacIntyre , A. 1984 . “ ‘The relationship of philosophy to its past’ ” . In Philosophy in History , Edited by: Rorty , R. , Schneewind , J. and Skinner , Q. 31 – 48 . Notre Dame, IN : Notre Dame University Press .
  • MacIntyre , A. 1987a . “ ‘Relativism, power, and philosophy’ ” . In After Philosophy: End or Transformation? , Edited by: Baynes , K. , Bohman , J. and McCarthy , T. 385 – 411 . Cambridge : MIT Press .
  • MacIntyre , A. 1987b . “ ‘Postscript to the second edition: the relationship of philosophy to history’ ” . In After Virtue , 265 – 272 . Notre Dame, IN : University of Notre Dame Press .
  • Makkreel , R. 1975 . Dilthey: Philosopher of the Human Studies , Princeton : Princeton University Press .
  • Makkreel , R. 1990 . ‘Traditional historicism, contemporary interpretations of historicity, and the history of philosophy’ . New Literary History , vol. 21 : 977 – 991 .
  • Mash , R. 1987 . ‘How important for philosophers is the history of philosophy?’ . History and Theory , vol. 26 : 287 – 299 .
  • Michelfelder , D. and Palmer , R. , eds. 1989 . Dialogue and Deconstruction: The Gadamer–Derrida Encounter , Albany : SUNY Press .
  • Mink , L. 1978 . “ ‘Narrative form as a cognitive instrument’ ” . In The Writing of History: Literary Form and Historical Understanding , Edited by: Canary , R. and Kozicki , H. 129 – 149 . Madison : University of Wisconsin Press .
  • Müller-Vollmer , K. 1972 . ‘To understand an author better than the author himself: on the hermeneutics of the unspoken’ . Language and Style , vol. 5 : 43 – 52 .
  • Nietzsche , F. 1989 . The Genealogy of Morals , New York : Vintage .
  • Norris , C. 1985 . “ ‘Philosophy as a kind of narrative’ ” . In Contest of Faculties: Philosophy and Theory After Deconstruction , 139 – 166 . London and New York : Methuen .
  • Oakeshott , M. 1991 . “ ‘The voice of poetry in the conversation of mankind’ ” . In Rationalism in Politics and Other Essay, , new rev. edn , 488 – 541 . Indianapolis : Liberty Press .
  • Okrent , M. 1984 . ‘Hermeneutics, transcendental philosophy and social science’ . Inquiry , vol. 27 : 23 – 49 .
  • Ormison , G. and Shrift , A. , eds. 1990 . The Hermeneutic Tradition , Albany : SUNY Press .
  • Palmer , R. 1969 . Hermeneutics , Evanston : Northwestern University Press .
  • Powers , L. 1986 . ‘On philosophy and its history’ . Philosophical Studies , vol. 50 : 1 – 38 .
  • Quine , W. V. and Ullian , J. S. 1978 . The Web of Belief, , 2nd edn , New York : Random House .
  • Rabinow , P. and Sullivan , W. , eds. 1979 . Interpretive Social Science: A Reader , Berkeley, Los Angeles and London : University of California Press .
  • Rabinow , P. and Sullivan , W. , eds. 1987 . Interpretive Social Science: A Second Look , Berkeley, Los Angeles and London : University of California Press .
  • Rée , J. 1978 . “ ‘Philosophy and the history of philosophy’ ” . In Philosophy and Its Past , Edited by: Rée , J. , Ayers , M. and Westoby , A. 3 – 41 . Atlantic Highlands, NJ : Humanities .
  • Rée , J. 1985 . “ ‘The end of metaphysics: philosophy's supreme fiction?’ ” . In Philosophy, Its History and Historiography , Edited by: Holland , A. 3 – 26 . Dordrecht, , Holland : Reidel .
  • Rée , J. 1988 . “ ‘Philosophy, history, and interpretation: some reactions to Jonathan Bennett's Study of Spinoza's Ethics’ ” . In Doing Philosophy Historically , Edited by: Hare , P. 44 – 61 . Buffalo, NY : Prometheus Books .
  • Rée , J. 1990 . ‘Historicisms’ . Radical Philosophy , vol. 56 : 53 – 57 .
  • Rée , J. 1991 . ‘The vanity of historicism’ . New Literary History , vol. 22 : 961 – 983 .
  • Ricoeur , P. 1981 . Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1979 . Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature , Princeton : Princeton University Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1980 . ‘A reply to Dreyfus and Taylor’ . Review of Metaphysics , vol. 34 : 39 – 46 . 47 – 55 .
  • Rorty , R. 1982 . “ ‘Method, social science, and social hope’ ” . In Consequences of Pragmatism , 191 – 210 . Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1984 . “ ‘Historiography of philosophy: four genres’ ” . In Philosophy in History , Edited by: Rorty , R. , Schneewind , J. and Skinner , Q. 49 – 76 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1985 . “ ‘’ ” . In Habermas and Modernity , Edited by: Bernstein , R. 161 – 175 . Cambridge : MIT Press . 224–225
  • Rorty , R. 1986a . ‘On ethnocentrism: a reply to Clifford Geertz’ . Michigan Quarterly Review , vol. 25 : 525 – 534 .
  • Rorty , R. 1986b . “ ‘Pragmatism, Davidson and truth’ ” . In Truth and Interpretation: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson , Edited by: LePore , E. 333 – 355 . Oxford : Blackwell .
  • Rorty , R. 1989 . Contingency, Irony and Solidarity , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1991 . Objectivity, Relativism, and Truth: Philosophical Papers, Volume I , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rorty , R. 1992 . “ ‘The pragmatist's progress’ ” . In Interpretation and Overinterpretation , Edited by: Collini , S. 89 – 108 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . U. Eco
  • Rorty , R. , Skinner , Q. and Schneewind , J. B. , eds. 1984a . “ ‘Introduction’ ” . In Philosophy in History , 1 – 14 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rorty , R. , Skinner , Q. and Schneewind , J. , eds. 1984b . Philosophy in History , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Rosenberg , A. 1989 . ‘Superseding explanation versus understanding: the view from Rorty’ . Social Research , vol. 56 : 479 – 510 .
  • Roth , P. 1988 . ‘Narrative explanations: the case of history’ . History and Theory , vol. 27 : 1 – 13 .
  • Roth , P. 1989 . ‘How narratives explain’ . Social Research , vol. 56 : 449 – 478 .
  • Silverman , H. and Ihde , D. , eds. 1985 . Hermeneutics and Deconstruction , Albany : SUNY Press .
  • Simon , J. 1989 . “ ‘Good will to understand and the will to power: remarks on an “improbable debate”’ ” . In Dialogue and Deconstruction: The Gadamer–Derrida Encounter , Edited by: Michelfelder , D. and Palmer , R. 162 – 175 . Albany : SUNY Press . 307–308
  • Skinner , Q. 1966 . ‘The limits of historical explanations’ . Philosophy , vol. 41 : 199 – 215 .
  • Skinner , Q. 1969 . ‘Meaning and understanding in the history of ideas’ . History and Theory , vol. 8 : 3 – 53 .
  • Skinner , Q. 1970 . ‘Conventions and the understanding of speech acts’ . Philosophical Quarterly , vol. 20 : 118 – 138 .
  • Skinner , Q. 1971 . ‘On performing and explaining linguistic actions’ . Philosophical Quarterly , vol. 21 : 1 – 21 .
  • Skinner , Q. 1972a . ‘Motives, intentions and the interpretation of texts’ . New Literary History , vol. 3 : 393 – 408 .
  • Skinner , Q. 1972b . “ ‘“Social meaning” and the explanation of social action’ ” . In Philosophy, Politics and Society , Edited by: Laslett , P. , Runciman , W. and Skinner , Q. 136 – 157 . Oxford : Blackwell . (4th Series)
  • Skinner , Q. 1975 . ‘Hermeneutics and the role of history’ . New Literary History , vol. 7 : 209 – 232 .
  • Taylor , C. 1977 . ‘Interpretation and the science of man’ . Review of Metaphysics , vol. 25 : 3 – 51 .
  • Taylor , C. 1980 . ‘Understanding in human science’ . Review of Metaphysics , vol. 34 : 3 – 23 .
  • Taylor , C. 1981 . “ ‘Understanding and the Geisteswissenschaften’ ” . In Wittgenstein: To Follow a Rule , Edited by: Holtzman , S. and Leich , C. 191 – 210 . London, Boston and Henley : Routledge and Kegan Paul .
  • Taylor , C. 1985a . Human Agency and Language , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Taylor , C. 1985b . Philosophy and the Human Sciences , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Taylor , C. 1987 . “ ‘Overcoming epistemology’ ” . In After Philosophy: End or Transformation? , 464 – 486 . Cambridge : MIT Press .
  • Thompson , M. 1993 . ‘Reception theory and the interpretation of historical meaning’ . History and Theory , vol. 32 : 248 – 272 .
  • Tully , J. , ed. 1988 . Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics , Princeton : Princeton University Press .
  • Warnke , G. 1985 . ‘Hermeneutics and social science: a Gadamerian critique of Rorty’ . Inquiry , vol. 28 : 339 – 357 .
  • Warnke , G. 1987 . Gadamer: Hermeneutics, Tradition and Reason , Stanford : Stanford University Press .
  • Weinsheimer , J. 1985 . Gadamer's Hermeneutics , New Haven and London : Yale University Press .
  • White , H. 1973 . Metahistory , Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press .
  • Williams , B. 28 April 1983 . Consequences of Pragmatism, New York Review of Books 28 April , Review of
  • Wilson , M. 1992 . ‘History of philosophy in philosophy today; and the case of sensible qualities’ . Philosophical Review , vol. 101 : 191 – 243 .
  • Winfield , R. 1987 . “ ‘Can philosophy have a rational history?’ ” . In At the Nexus of Philosophy and History , Edited by: Dauenhauer , B. 42 – 57 . Athens and London : University of Georgia Press .
  • Yolton , J. 1985 . ‘Some remarks on the historiography of philosophy’ . Journal of the History of Philosophy , vol. 23 : 571 – 578 .
  • Zammito , J. 2004 . A Nice Derangement of Epistemes: Post-Positivism in the Study of Science from Quine to Latour , Chicago and London : University of Chicago Press .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.