484
Views
2
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Whaling under a scientific auspice: The ethics of scientific research whaling operations

Pages 1-49 | Published online: 26 Nov 2008

References

  • Gillespie , A. 1997 . International Environmental Law, Policy and Ethics .
  • Gillespie , A. 1997 . The Ethical Question in the Whaling Debate . Georgetown Int'l Envtl. L. Rev. , 9 : 355 – 387 .
  • Callicott , J.B. 1997 . Whaling in Sand County: A Dialectical Hunt for Land Ethical Answers to Questions About the Morality of Norwegian Minke Whale Catching . Colorado J. Int'l Envtl. L & Pol'y. , 8 : 1 – 30 .
  • McLay , J. 1998 . Whale Research Needs Moral Compass . N.Z. HERALD , March 23 : A13
  • Commins , S. , ed. 1967 . The Philosophers of Science 73 78
  • Gillespie , A. in press . International Environmental Law . Policy & Politics , at Chapter 2
  • Commission on Sustainable Development . 1995 . Education, Science and the Transfer of Environmentally Sound Technologies: Science for Sustainable Development . 2 March E/CN.17/1995/16.
  • Dickson , J.P. 1986 . Science and Scientific Researchers In Modern Society , 144 – 149 . Geneva : UNESCO .
  • Muller‐Hill , B. 1933–1945 . Murderous Science: Elimination By Scientific Procedure of Jews , Germany : Gypsies and Others . (1988)
  • Graham , L. 1978 . “ Attitudes Towards Eugenics in Germany and Soviet Russia in the 1920s: An Examination of Science and Values ” . In Morals, Science and Sociality , Edited by: Report , Hastings Centre . 119 – 148 . Sydney : Institute of Society, Ethics and Life Science .
  • Diesendorf , M. 1982 . Science Under Social and Political Pressures . Science & Ethics (Australian Academy of Science , : 48 – 73 .
  • Plimmer , I. 1996 . Telling Lies for God: Reason Against Creationism .
  • Passmore , J. 1972 . The Revolt Against Science . Search , 3 : 415 – 422 .
  • Roszak , T. 1974 . Science, Knowledge and Gnosis . Daedalus , 31
  • Johnson , A.L. 1971 . “ Science— Scapegoat or Scared Cow? ” . In Science: Demonic, Angelic or What ? , 69 – 106 . Lutheran Academy . ed.
  • Slosson , E. 1976 . “ The Relative Value of Life and Learning ” . In Animal Rights Edited by: Linzey , A. 51
  • Macrakis , K. 1993 . Surviving the Swastika .
  • Lifton , R.J. 1986 . The Nazi Doctors .
  • Oppenhcimcr , R. 1955 . “ Lecture to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology ” . In The Open Mind Edited by: Oppenheimer , R.
  • Popper , K. 1993 . “ The Moral Responsibility of the Scientist ” . In The Myth of the Framework Edited by: Nutturno , M. and Popper , K. 121 – 129 .
  • Keeton , W. and Gould , S.J. 1986 . Biological Science . : 6
  • Mader , S. 1987 . Biology, Evolution, Destiny and the Environment . : 15
  • Rotblat , J. 1982 . Scientists, The Arms Race and Disarmament , UNESCO .
  • Zuckerman , J. 1966 . Scientists and War . : 125 – 161 .
  • 1995 . Genome Research Risks Abuse, Panel Reports . Nature , 387 : 529
  • Yearley , S. 1996 . Sociology, Ideology, Globalisation .
  • Jasanoff , S. 1990 . The Fifth Branch: Science Advisers As Policy Makers .
  • Livingston , F. and Mason , G. 1979 . Ecological Crisis and the Autonomy of Science in Capitalist Society . Alternatives , 8 : 3 – 15 .
  • Feyerabend , P. 1978 . Science in a Free Society . : 88 – 91 .
  • Butler , D. 1995 . French Ethics Panel Warns of ‘Crisis’ In Science Reporting . Nature , 376 : 108
  • Herbert , F. 1931 . Readings in the Philosophy of Science . : 596 – 601 .
  • Brown , D. 1987 . Ethics, Science and Environmental Regulation . Envtl. Ethics , 9 : 331 – 349 .
  • Wadman , M. 1997 . Clinton Sketches Out His ‘Ethical Guideposts’ For Modern Biology . Nature , 387 : 323
  • British Medical Association . 1981 . The Handbook of Medical Ethics 63 – 64 .
  • Katz , J. 1997 . Human Sacrifice and Human Experimentation: Reflections on Nuremberg . Yale J. Int'l L. , 22 : 401 – 418 .
  • Lederer , S. 1995 . Subjected to Science: Human Experimentation Before the Second World War .
  • Nelken , D. 1973 . “ Science as a Source of Political Conflict ” . In Proceedings of a Nobel Symposium , 9 – 23 . Ethics for Science Policy . ed.
  • Gerth , H. 1967 . From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology . : 129 – 158 .
  • The Royal Society . 1995 . Peer Review: An Assessment of Recent Developments . : 1 – 8 .
  • Greenaway , F. 1996 . Science International‐ A History of the ICSU .
  • World Health Organisation . 1997 . Report of WHO Consultation on Xenotransplantation 5 – 7 .
  • 1997 . Britain Plays It Cautious On Animal‐Human Transplants . Nature , 385 : 285
  • 1996 . Xenotransplation in The United States . Nature , 382 : 197
  • Saegusa , A. 1997 . Japanese Bioethics Debate Lags Behind Thinking in the West . Nature , 389 : 661
  • Butler , D. 1995 . Pope Condemns ‘Immoral’ Embryo Research . Nature , 374 : 489
  • Butler , D. 1994 . Ethics Bill Prompts Second Thoughts Among Scientists . Nature , 367 : 209
  • Beardsley , T. 1997 . Profile: Francis Collins: Where Science and Religion Meet . Sci. Am , February : 18 – 19 .
  • Lehrman , S. 1996 . Genome Ethics Chair Resigns Amid Worries Over Autonomy . Nature , 380 : 96
  • Dickson , D. 1996 . HUGO Approves Ethics Code for Genomics . Nature , 380 : 279
  • Maddox . 1993 . New Genetics Means No New Ethics . Nature , 364 : 97
  • Lehrman , S. 1996 . Genome Ethics Panel Comes Under the Microscope at NIH . Nature , 381 : 357
  • 1997 . High Level Ethics Committee Needed to Guide Genetics Policy . Nature , 385 : 756
  • Dickson , D. 1996 . UK Takes Pride in ‘Principled Pragmatism . Nature , 389 : 663
  • International Bioethics Committee of UNESCO . 1997 . Proceedings of the Fourth Session . I & II
  • Butler , D. 1997 . Call for Cloning Ban Sell Science Short . NATURE , 386 : 8 – 9 .
  • 1997 . Politicians Accused of ‘Shooting from the Hip’ On Human Cloning . Nature , 386 : 97
  • Wadman , M. 1997 . US Senators Urge Caution On Cloning Ban . Nature , 386 : 204
  • 1997 . US Panel to Back Longer Cloning Ban, Ducks Thornier Questions.’ . Nature , : 387 217
  • 1997 . WHO Chief Defends Use of Animal Models . Nature , 386 : 204
  • Wadman , M. 1997 . White House Bill Would Ban Human Cloning . Nature , 386 : 217
  • 1997 . WHO Chief Defends Use of Animal Models . Nature , 386 : 204
  • Butler , D. 1997 . Calls For Human Cloning Ban ‘Stem From Ignorance . Nature , 387 : 324
  • 1997 . Council of Europe Urged to Ban Human Cloning . Nature , 389 : 656
  • Wadman , M. 1997 . White House Bill Would Ban Human Cloning . Nature , 386 : 214
  • Wadman , M. 1997 . Cloning For Research Should Be Allowed . Nature , 388 : 6
  • Maehle , A. and Trohler , U. 1987 . “ Animal Experimentation from Antiquity To the End of the Eighteenth Century ” . In Vivisection in Historical Perspective Edited by: Rupke , G. 14 – 47 .
  • Carson , G. 1972 . Men, Beasts and Gods: A History of Cruelty and Kindness to Animals . : 192
  • Orlans , B. 1993 . In the Name of Science: Issues in Responsible Animal Experimentation . : 3
  • Turner , J. 1980 . Animals, Pain And Humanity in the Victorian Mind: Reckoning With the Beast . : 24 – 38 .
  • Garner , R. 1993 . Animals, Politics and Morality . : 121 – 123 . 135 – 137 .
  • Watson , T. 1992 . Proposal Opens Debate Over US Data on Animals. . Nature , 360 : 530
  • Botting , J. and Morrison , A. 1997 . Trends in Animal Research . Sci. Am. , 71 : 76
  • Humane Society of the United States . 1997 . Fact Sheets: Animals in Laboratories , 1 Washington : HSUS .
  • Mukerjee , M. 1997 . Trends in Animal Research . 70 Sci. Am. , : 70
  • Rowan , A.N. 1996 . “ The Use of Animals in Experimentation: An Examination of the Technical Arguments ” . In Animal Rights: The Changing Debate Edited by: Garner , R. 104
  • Fano , A. 1997 . Lethal Laws: Animal Testing, Human Health, and Environmental Policy . : 21 – 25 .
  • Leahy , M.P.T. 1991 . Against Liberation: Putting Animals Into Perspective .
  • Aldhous , P. 1992 . Court Favours Mice, Rats, Birds . Nature , 355 : 191
  • Animal Welfare Institute . 1952–1997 . The Animal Dealers: Evidence of Abuse of Animals . The Commercial Trade , (1998)
  • Eckersley , R. 1989 . Divining Evolution: The Ecological Ethics of Murray Book . Envtl. Ethics , 11 : 724 – 726 .
  • Brophy , B. 1989 . The Rights of Animals . : 134
  • Aristotle . 1963 . Ethics . : 83
  • Aquinas . 1945 . Basic Writings . 2 : 220
  • Ficino , M. 1948 . “ Letters ” . In The Renaissance Philosophy of Man Edited by: Casserirer , E. 1
  • Locke , J. 1972 . An Essay Concerning Human Understanding . : 88 – 91 . Book II
  • Schopenhauer , A. 1819 . The World as Will and Representation . : 228 – 30 . (1969)
  • Pascal , B. and B. 1656 . Lettres Provincials . : 148 (1928)
  • Pufendorf , S. 1688 . The Law of Nature and of Nations vol II , 147 – 448 . 180 – 83 . 526 – 27 . 530 – 31 . Oceana, New York 1931
  • Rousseau , H. 1913 . The Social Contract and Discourses . : 184 – 186 .
  • Kant , I. 1780 . Lectures on Ethics , 239 Oxford : Harper and Rowe . 1963
  • _____ . 1973 . Fundamental Principles Of Metaphysics And Morals , 345 – 346 . London : Bobbs Merill .
  • Hobbes , T. 1642 . “ De Cave ” . Edited by: Molesworth , D. 1841
  • The English Works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmsbury , vol 2 , 63 – 75 . 113 – 114 . London : John Bohn .
  • Descartes , R. 1966 . Letter to Henry Moore , Edited by: Chomsky , N. 6 Cartesian Linguistics .
  • Hegel , F. 1830 . Lecture on the Philosophy of World History . : 48 – 51 . 1975
  • Nietzsche , F. 1886 . Human, All Too Human , Oxford University Press .
  • Wittgenstein , L. 1953 . Philosophical Investigations .
  • Eckersley , R. 1992 . Environmentalism and Political Theory: Towards an Ecocentric Approach . : 50
  • Short , J. R. 1991 . Imagined Country: Society, Culture and Environment . : 5 – 6 . 40 – 44 . (1991)
  • Engels , F. 1987 . “ ‘Dialects of Nature’ ” . In Collected Works , Edited by: Marx , K. and Engels , F. 48 404 – 05 . Oxford : Lawrence and Wishart .
  • _____ and Marx , K. 1956 . Economic and Social Manuscripts vol 3 , 275 – 277 . 329 London
  • _____ . 1965 . Capital , vol 3 , 812 Moscow : Foreign Language Publishing .
  • McLean , D. , ed. 1978 . Karl Marx: Selected Writings , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Diamond , J. 1991 . The Rise and the Fall of the Third Chimpanzee , 152 London : Radius .
  • Aquinas , T. 1928 . “ ‘Summa Contra Gentiles’ ” . In The English Dominion Fathers , Vol. 3 , 112 London : Burns and Oates . 2
  • Descartes , R. 1976 . Discourse on Method and the Meditations , Harmondsworth : Penguin .
  • Leibniz , G. W. 1714 . Monadology , 259 – 271 . London : Lowe and Brydone . 1898
  • Hooker , R. 1594 . Laws of Ecclesiastical Policy 166 – 67 . Dent 1907
  • Fox , W. 1984 . ‘Deep Ecology: A New Philosophy of Our Time?’ . Ecologist , : 14 194
  • Naess , A. 1985 . “Identification as a Source of Deep Ecological Attitudes’ ” . In Deep Ecology Edited by: Tobias , D. 48 San Diego
  • Norton , B. 1984 . ‘Environmental Ethics and Weak Anthropocentricism’ . Environmental Ethics , 6 : 141
  • O'Neill , J. 1993 . Ecology, Policy and Politics: Human Well‐Being And The Natural World , 149 – 152 . London : Routledge .
  • Sherrard , P. 1987 . The Rape of Man and Nature , 76 – 89 . Suffolk : Golgonooza .
  • Whitehead , A. N. 1925 . Science and the Modern World , 29 167 175 London : MacMillan .
  • Callicott , J. B. 1986 . ‘The Metaphysical Implications of Ecology’ . Environmental Ethics , 8 : 301
  • Sterling , S. 1990 . “ ‘Towards an Ecological World View’ ” . In The Ethics of Environment and Development: Global Challenge, International Response , Edited by: Engell , J. R. and J. B. 77 – 81 . London : Belhaven .
  • Capra , F. 1982 . The Turning Point: Science, Society and the Rising Culture , 80 – 84 . New York : Flamingo .
  • Oelschlaeger , M. 1991 . The Idea of Wilderness: From Prehistory to the Age of Ecology , 301 – 309 . New York : Yale University Press .
  • Sheldrake , S. 1990 . The Rebirth of Nature: The Greening of Science and God . : 68 – 75 .
  • Capra , F. 1975 . The Tao of Physics . : 68 – 87 .
  • Heisenberg , W. 1958 . The Physicist's Conception of Nature . : 29
  • Callicott , J.B. 1985 . Intrinsic Value, Quantum Theory and Environmental Ethics . Envtl. Ethics , 7 : 270 – 274 .
  • Gleick , J. 1987 . Chaos: Making of a New Science . : 273
  • Caldwell , L. 1990 . Between Two Worlds: Science, The Environmental Movement and Policy Choice . : 45
  • Commoner , B. 1970 . “ The Ecological Facts of Life ” . In The Ecological Conscience Edited by: Disch , R. 2 – 15 .
  • Shepard , P. Ecology and Man Disch . 56
  • Wall , D. 1990 . Green History; A Reader in Environmental Literature, Philosophy and Politics . : 98 – 99 . 133 – 135 .
  • Clarke , J.J. 1993 . Nature in Question: An Anthology of Ideas and Arguments . : 147 149 – 150 . 178 – 180 .
  • Lovelock , J. 1979 . Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth . : 9 – 11 . 92 148 – 149 . 152
  • Joseph , L. E. 1990 . Gaia: The Growth of an Idea . : 207
  • Darwin , C. 1859 . On the Origin of Species . : 51 – 53 . 196
  • Rachels , J. 1987 . Darwin, Species and Morality . Monist , 70 : 98
  • Rachels , J. 1994 . “ Created From Animals ” . In People, Penguins and Plastic Trees: Basic Issues in Environmental Ethics Edited by: Pierce , C. and Veer , D. Vande . 59 – 72 .
  • Goldsmith , E. 1972 . The Way: Towards an Ecological World View . : 122 – 123 .
  • Darwin , C. 1871 . The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex , 94 – 171 . New York : Collier .
  • Midgley , M. 1980 . The Beast and Man: The Roots of Human Nature . : 25 – 26 . 205
  • Cavalieri , P. , ed. 1993 . The Great Ape Project: Equality Beyond Humanity , Fourth Estate .
  • Routley , R. and V. 1976 . “ ‘Against the Inevitability of Human Chauvinism’ ” . In Ethics and Problems of the 21st Century , Edited by: Goodpaster , K. E. and Sayre , K. M. 41 43 Notre Dame : University of Notre Dame Press .
  • Naess , A. 1979 . Self Realisation in Mixed Communities . Inquiry , 22 : 201
  • Gelb , F. 1974 . Man and Land: The Psychological Theory of Jung . Zygon , 9 : 288
  • Dworkin , R. 1977 . Taking Rights Seriously .
  • Lukes , T. 1973 . Individualism . : 49
  • MacPherson , C.B. 1962 . The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism . : 220
  • Goodpaster , K.E. 1978 . On Being Morally Considerable . J. Philos. , 75 : 317
  • Taylor , P. 1981 . Frankena On Environmental Ethics . Monist , 64 : 375
  • Lombardi , L.G. 1983 . inherent Worth, Respect and Animals Rights . Envtl. Ethics , 5 : 260
  • Marcuse , H. 1964 . One Dimensional Man . : 146 – 148 .
  • Regan , T. 1988 . The Case for Animal Rights . : 243
  • Taylor , P. 1984 . Are Humans Superior to Animals and Plants? . Environmental Ethics , : 157
  • Regan , T. and Regan , T. 1982 . “ ‘Animal Experimentation: First Thoughts.’ ” . In All That Dwell Within: Animal Rights and Environmental Ethics , 61 65 California : University of California Press .
  • Regan , T. 1998 . Cruelty, Kindness and Unnecessary Suffering . Philosophy , 55 : 532 – 541 .
  • Salt , H. 1892 . Animal Rights Connected in Relation to Social Progress , 98 London : George Bell .
  • Singer , P. 1976 . Animal Liberation: Towards an End to Man's Inhumanity to Animals . : 21 – 44 .
  • Singer , P. 1993 . Practical Ethics . : 1 – 15 . 110 – 135 .
  • Singer , P. 1974 . All Animals are Equal . Philosophic Exchange , 1 : 103 – 116 .
  • Bentham , J. 1789 . An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation , 328 London : Russell . 1962 Book 1
  • Singer , P. 1979 . “ Unsanctifying Human Life ” . In Ethical Issues Relating to Life and Death Edited by: Ladd , J. 41
  • Anstotz , C. “ ‘Profoundly Intellectually Disabled Humans and the Great Apes: A Comparison’ ” . Edited by: Cavalieri . 158 168 – 170 . supra note 92
  • Montaigne , M.E. 1576 . “ Apology for Raymond Sebond ” . In Essays of Montaigne Edited by: Trechman , E.J. 451 – 52 . 460 1927
  • Primatt , H. 1776 . A Dissertation on the Duty of Mercy and the Sin of Cruelty to Animals , 21 Edinburgh : Constable . 1834
  • Rousseau , J.J. 1772 . The Social Contract 41 – 2 . 178 – 80 . 184 – 6 . Dent 1973
  • Hume , D. 1751 . An Inquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals , La Salle : Open Court . 1946
  • Mill , J.S. 1986 . Collected Works , Toronto : University of Toronto Press .
  • Mill , J.S. 1969 . “ Three Essays on Religion ” . In John Stuart Mill: Essays on Ethics, Religions and Society , Edited by: Robinson , J.M. 184 – 187 . London : Routledge .
  • Whewell , W. 1852 . Lectures on the History of Moral Philosophy of England , 233 – 225 . London : Parker .
  • Mill , J. S. 1954 . “ Whewell on Moral Philosophy ” . In Collected Works of J.S. Mill , Edited by: Priestly , T. 128 Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Thomas , K. 1984 . Man and the Natural World: Changing Attitudes in England 1500–1800 , 159 176 – 181 . Harmondsworth : Penguin .
  • Singer , P. 1976 . “ ‘Not for Humans Only: The Place of Non‐humans in Environmental Issues’ ” . In Ethics and the Twenty‐first Century , Edited by: Regan , T. 194 New York : Random House .
  • Zak , S. 1987 . ‘The Case for Animal Rights’ . Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review , : 20 1236
  • Hoch , D. 1989 . ‘Environmental Ethics and Non‐human Interests. A Challenge to Anthropocentric License . Gonzaga Law Review , : 23 335
  • Singer , P. 1979–80 . ‘Utilitarianism and Vegetarianism’ . Philosophy and Public Affairs , 9 : 327
  • Singer , P. 1979 . ‘Killing Humans and Killing Animals’ . Inquiry , 22 : 152
  • Johnson , L. E. 1991 . A Morally Deep World: An Essay on Moral Significance and Environmental Ethics , 47 – 49 . 53 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Nozick , R. 1974 . Anarchy, State and Utopia , 35 – 42 . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Singer , P. 1991 . “ ‘To Do or Not to Do ?’ ” . In Animal Experimentation: The Moral Issues , Edited by: Baird , R.M. 145 – 150 . London : Prometheus .
  • Rollin , B.E. 1981 . Animal Rights and Human Morality , 92 – 96 . London : Prometheus .
  • Hettinger , E.C. 1991 . ‘The Responsible Use of Animals in Biomrdical Research,’ . The Moral Issues , : 115 120 – 122 . Id.
  • Francione , G. 1996 . Animal Rights and Animal Welfare . Rutgers Law Review , 48 : 397
  • Francione , G. 1994 . ‘Animals, Property and Legal Welfarism: ‘Unnecessary Suffering and the Humane Treatment of Animals.’ . Rutgers Law Review , 46 : 721
  • Ryder , D. 1971 . “ ‘Experiments on Animals.’ ” . In Animals, Men and Morals , Edited by: Godlovitch , S. and R. 41 46 – 56 . New York : Gollancz .
  • 1992 . “Leave the Man Alone.” . Nature , 356 : 644
  • ACCART (Australian Council for the Care of Animals in Research and Teaching) . News , 4 (1) 1 – 2 .
  • Nomura , T. 1995 . ’Japan.’ . Institute of Laboratory Animal Resources Journal , 37 : 60 – 61 .
  • Brown , L. 1988 . Cruelty to Animals: The Moral Debt. , 130 – 136 . London : Macmillan .
  • 1965 . The Littlewood Report , 189 – 190 . London : Departmental Committee of Inquiry Into Animal Experimentation. HMSO .
  • Bayvel , A. 1997 . “ ‘Animal Welfare in New Zealand: Concepts, Committees, Consultation and Codes of Practice.’ ” . ANZCCART . (the Australian”
  • NZ Council for the Care of Animals in Research and Teaching) . News , 10 (4) 5 – 6 .
  • Jessings , M. 1994 . Ethics Committees for Laboratory Animals: A Basis for Their Composition and Function , Horsham : RSPCA .
  • National Research Council . 1996 . Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals , 10 – 12 . Washington : NRC .
  • Brody , M. 1989 . ‘Animal Research: A Call For Legislative Reform Requiring Ethical Merit Review.’ . Harvard Environmental Law Review , 13 : 423 – 484 .
  • Hampson , J. 1989 . “ Animal Experimentation: Practical Dilemmas and Solutions.’ ” . In The Status of Animals: Ethics, Education and Welfare , Edited by: Patterson , D. and Palmer , M. 100 Oxford : CAB International .
  • Halsbury . 1973 . Laws of England , 4th Edn Volume 2 , 190 Butterworths
  • Anon . 1992 . ‘Swiss Conundrums.’ . Nature , 355 : 574
  • Aldhous , P. 1992 . ‘Swiss Vote Sunday Could Restrict Animal Research.’ . Nature , 355 : 575
  • Webster , J. 1994 . Animal Welfare: A Cool Eye Towards Eden , 229 – 234 . London : Blackwell .
  • Morton , D.B. 1987 . ‘Summarisation of Colloquium Highlights From an International Perspective.’ . Journal of American Veterinary Association , 191 ( 10 ) : 1294 – 1296 .
  • Mayo , D. 1983 . “ ‘Against A Scientific Justification of Animal Experiments.’ ” . In Ethics and Animals , Edited by: Miller , H.B. 343 – 349 . New York : Humana Press .
  • LaFollette , H. and Shanks , N. 1994 . ‘Animal Models in Animal Research: Some Epistemological Worries.’ . Public Affairs Quarterly , 7 : 113 – 129 .
  • Gershon , D. 1993 . ‘US Panel Disagrees on Cancer Testing Method.’ . Nature , 361 : 389
  • Sharpe , R. 1988 . Cruel Deception: The Use of Animals in Medical Research , 72 – 73 . 86 – 92 . 105 – 107 . London : Thorsons .
  • Fox , M. 1986 . The Casé for Animal Experimentation: An Evolutionary and Ethical Perspective , 124 – 126 . California : California University Press .
  • Goldman , L. 1979 . “ ‘Controversial Aspects of Current Experimentation.’ ” . In Animal Rights: A Symposium , Edited by: Patterson , D. and Ryder , D. 187 189 – 191 . London : Centaur .
  • Jennings , M. 1995 . ‘Benefits, Necessity and Justification in Animal Research.” . ATLA , 23 : 828 – 836 .
  • Favre , D. 1996 . ‘Some Thoughts on Animal Experimentation.’ . Animal Law , 2 : 161 – 165 .
  • Abbott , A. 1996 . ‘Delays in Alternative Tests Defer Animal Bans.’ . Nature , 383 : 748
  • Elliot , C. 1997 . ‘Limited Ban on Animal Tests.’ . Guardian International , November 16 : 12
  • Abbott , A. 1993 . ‘German University Faces Ban on Animal Tests in Class.’ . Nature , 365 : 778
  • Abbott , A. 1994 . ‘German Court Blocks Ban on Animal Tests.” . Nature , 367 : 103
  • National Research Council . 1997 . Principles and Guidelines for the Use of Animals in Precollege Education , Washington : NRC .
  • Russell , W.M.S. and Burch , R.L. 1959 . The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique , London : Allen & Unwin .
  • Anon . 1985 . Scientific Procedures on Living Animals , London : HMSO .
  • Balls , M. 1995 . ‘The Three R's: The Way Forward.’ . ATLA , 23 : 838 – 866 .
  • Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care International . 1997 . Connection: Connecting Science and Responsible Animal Care : Special International Issues Edition . 1 : 6 – 7 . 10 – 12 .
  • International Council for Laboratory Animal Science . 1995 . Working Group on Complementary Methods , Texas : ICLAS .
  • Balls , M. 1994 . ‘Replacement of Animal Procedures: Alternatives in Research, Education and Testing.’ . Laboratory Animals , 28 : 193 – 211 .
  • US Congress Office of Technology Assessment . 1986 . Alternatives to Animal Use in Research, Testing and Education 136 – 140 . Washington
  • Hegarty , T. 1989 . ‘Alternatives.’ .
  • Wiebers , D. 1997 . ‘Monkey Business in Space.’ . Nature , 389 : 537
  • Reines , B. 1990 . ‘The Relationship Between Laboratory and Clinical Studies in Psychopharmacologic Discoveries.’ . Perspectives on Animal Research , 2 : 13 – 26 .
  • Kaufman , S. 1989 . ‘An Evaluation of Ten Randomly‐Chosen Animal Modes of Human Disease.’ . Perspectives on Animal Research , 1 : 1 – 131 .
  • Gandhi , M. 1996 . Animal Laws of India , 40 New York : Universal Publishing .
  • Masood , E. 1997 . ‘UK Tightens Regime for Animal Research.’ . Nature , 389 : 986
  • Ball , M. and Southee . 1989 . ‘Reducing Animal Experiments by Questioning Their Necessity.’ . The Status of Animals , : 111 112 supra note 143
  • Anon . 1996 . ‘Whistle‐Blowing.’ . Nature , 376 : 543
  • Balls , M. 1995 . “In Vitro methodologies and Alternatives in Testing Cosmetics.” . Toxicology In Vitro , 9 : 871 – 929 .
  • Loprieno , N. 1995 . ‘Alternatives in Cosmetic Testing.’ . Toxicology In Vitro , 9 : 827 – 838 .
  • Abbott , A. 1996 . ‘Delays in Alternative Tests Defer Animal Bans.’ . Nature , 383 : 748
  • Balls , M. 1994 . ‘Reduction of Animal Use: Experimental Design and Quality of Experiments.’ . Laboratory Animals , 28 : 212 – 221 .
  • Abbott , A. 1993 . ‘Glowing Report May Not Avert Closure of Dutch Primate Centre.’ . Nature , 363 : 4
  • Brown , L. 1988 . Vital Signs: The Trends That Are Shaping Our Future , 100 London : Earthscan .
  • Blum , D. 1994 . The Monkey Wars , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
  • Honjo , S. 1993 . “ ‘Non‐Human Primate Health Programme.’ ” . In Guidelines for Breeding and Care of Laboratory Animals , Edited by: Fujikura , T. 77 – 89 . Geneva : WHO . WHO/ZOON./93.169
  • Flecknell , P. 1994 . ‘Refinement of Animal Use: Assessment and Alleviation of Pain and Distress.’ . Laboratory Animals , 28 : 222 – 231 .
  • Harrop , S.R. 1997 . ‘The Dynamics of Wild Animal Welfare Law.’ . Journal of Environmental Law , 9 (2) : 287 – 302 .
  • Harrison , P. 1991 . ‘Animal Pain.’ . The Moral Issues , : 128 – 139 . supra note 125
  • Anon . 1990 . ‘The Study of Chronic Pain: Ethical and Scientific Dilemmas.’ . ACCART News , 3 (1) : 7 – 9 .
  • Porter , D.G. 1992 . ‘Ethical Scores for Animal Experiments.’ . Nature , 356 : 101
  • Aquinas , T. 1922 . Summa Theologica , Volume 2 , 1 London : Burns and Oats . Q64
  • Smith , S. 1949 . ‘The Messes Animals Make In Metaphysics’ . Journal of Philosophy , 46 : 833 851
  • O'Neil , J. 1993 . Ecology, Policy and Politics: Human Well‐Being and the Natural World , 152 – 155 . London : Routledge .
  • Marshall , P. 1993 . Natures Web: An Exploration of Ecological Thinking , 168 – 172 . London : Simon and Schuster .
  • Rollin , B.E. 1993 . ‘Animal Welfare, Science and Value.’ . Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics , 6 : 45 – 50 .
  • Birnie , P. 1997 . ‘Are Twentieth Century Marine Conservation Conventions Adaptable to Twenty First Century Goals and Principles ? : Part Two.’ . International Journal of Marine and Coastal Law , 12 (4) : 488 496 – 498 .
  • Birnie , P. 1985 . The International Regulation of Whaling , Volume 1 , 177 – 179 . 187 – 188 . 486 – 488 . 506 New York : Oceana .
  • 1986 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Permits.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 36 , 26 Resolution 3
  • 1987 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Permits.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 37 , 25 Recommendation 4
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Research Programmes.’ ” . In Reporr of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 27 Recommendation 4
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Whaling Under Special Permit in Sanctuaries.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 46 Consideration 1
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Special Permit Catches By Japan.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission 47
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Whaling Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 46 – 47 .
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Whaling Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 46 – 47 . Recommendation 1
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Whaling Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 46 – 47 . Request 1
  • IWC . 1993 . Report of the Scientific Committee, Annex M: Comments on the Norwegian Proposal for a Scientific Permit. Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 43 , 208 – 214 .
  • IWC . 1989 . “ ‘Report of the Scientific Committee.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 39 , 56 – 59 .
  • 1990 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal For Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 40 , 36 Consideration 1
  • 1991 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal for Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 41 , 47 Invitation 1
  • 1994 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal for Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 44 , 33 Invitation 1
  • 1995 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal for Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 45 , 48 Reiteration 1
  • 1990 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal For Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 40 , 36 Consideration 1
  • 1991 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal For Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 41 , 47 Invitation 1
  • 1994 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal For Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 44 , 33 Invitation 1
  • 1995 . “ ‘Resolution on Norwegian Proposal For Special Permits’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 45 , 48 Reiteration 1
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Icelandic Proposal For Scientific Catches’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 28 Recommendation 1
  • 1989 . “ ‘Resolution on Icelandic Proposal For Scientific Catches’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 39 , 30 – 31 . Consideration 1
  • 1990 . “ ‘Resolution on Icelandic Proposal For Scientific Catches.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 40 , 35 Invitation 1
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Republic of Korea's Proposal for Special Permits.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 28
  • 1992 . “ ‘Resolution on the USSR Proposal For Scientific Catches’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 42 , 47
  • Nagasaki , F. 1995 . “ The Moratorium and Japanese Research on Whales in the Antarctic: An Overview.” . In Research on Whales , Edited by: Institute of Cetacean Research . 8 – 9 . Tokyo : ICR .
  • “ ‘Report of the JARPA Review Meeting‐ Chairman's Summary of SCIENTIFIC COMMIT‐TEE/49/Rep 1.’ ” . In Report of the Scientific Committee 58 IWC/49/4
  • Ohsumi , S. 1995 . “ ‘The Necessity of Employing Lethal Methods in the Study of Whale Resources.’ ” . In Research on Whales , 13 – 24 . Institute of Cetacean Research . Ibid.
  • IWC . 1993 . “ Report of the Scientific. Committee ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 43 , 75 – 81 .
  • Ikeda , I. 1990 . “ ‘Refutation of Annex O2: A Comment on the Objectives of the Proposals For A Japanese Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 142 – 144 .
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Japanese Proposal For Special Permits’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 29 Recommendation 1
  • 1990 . “ ‘Resolution on Japanese Proposed Take By Japan of Whales in the Southern Hemisphere Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 40 , 36 Consideration 1
  • 1994 . “ ‘Resolution on Japanese Proposed Take By Japan of Whales in the Southern Hemisphere Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 44 , 33 Consideration 1
  • 1995 . “ ‘Resolution on Japanese Proposed Take By Japan of Whales in the Southern Hemisphere Under Special Permit’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 45 , 47 Consideration 1
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Japanese Proposed Take By Japan of Whales in the Southern Hemisphere Under Special Permit’ ” . In Report of International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 47 Request 1
  • IWC . 1995 . “ ‘Report of the Scientific Committee.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 45 , 80 – 85 .
  • IWC . 1995 . “ ‘Resolution on Special Permit Catches by Japan in the North Pacific.” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 45 , 47
  • IWC . 1992 . Chairman's Report of the 44th Meeting . 1992 . pp. 19
  • Smith , P. 1995 . “Japan Continues Scientific Whaling in Southern Ocean.” . Journal of Australian Foreign Affairs and Trade , 4 March. 7
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Special Permit Catches By Japan.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 47
  • Motluk , A. 1995 . “Whale Hunts are Irrelevant for Research.” . New Scientist , June 10 : 7
  • Burke , W.T. 1995 . His opinion is noted in the Chairman's Report of the 47th Meeting . 1995 . pp. 23 – 24 . IWC .
  • Butterworth , D. 1992 . ‘Science and Sentimentality.’ . Nature , 357 : 532 – 534 .
  • Rose , G. 1996 . “ ‘International Law and the Status of Cetaceans.” . In The Conservation of Whales and Dolphins: Science and Practice , Edited by: Simmonds , M. 23 37 – 38 . Chichester : Wiley .
  • Holt , S. 1988 . “ ‘Comments on the Japanese Proposal to Catch Southern Hemisphere Minke Whales Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 142 – 146 .
  • Tillman , M. 1990 . “ ‘A Comment on the Objectives of the Proposal for A Japanese Scientific Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 40 , 172 – 173 .
  • 1996 . “ ‘Resolution on Whaling Under Special Permit.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 46 – 47 . Recommendation 1
  • Hutchinson , J. 1996 . Benign Answers: A Review of the Methods of Assessment of Cetacean Populations , London : University of Greenwich .
  • Anon . 1991 . “ ‘Report of the Workshop on the Genetic Analysis of Cetacean Populations.’ ” . In Genetic Ecology of Whales and Dolphins , Report of the International Whaling Commission: Special Issue 13 Edited by: Hoelzel , A.R. 3 – 21 . Cambridge : IWC .
  • Hoelzel , A.R. ‘Genetic Ecology of Marine Mammals.’ . Symposium of the Zoology Society of London . Vol. 66 , pp. 15 – 32 .
  • Hoelzel , A. R. 1994 . ‘Genetics and the Ecology of Whales and Dolphins.’ . Annual Review of EcologicaJ Systems , 25 : 377 – 399 .
  • Pastene , L. 1993 . “ Mitochondrial DNA Differentiation in Antarctic Minke Whales.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 43 , 349 – 355 .
  • Hammond , P.S. 1986 . “ ‘Line Transect Sampling of Dolphin Populations.’ ” . In Research on Dolphins , Edited by: Bryden , S. and Harrison , J. 251 – 279 . London : Simon and Schuster .
  • Hammond , P.S. , eds. 1990 . “ Individual Recognition of Cetaceans: Use of Photo‐Identification and Other Techniques to Estimate Population Parameters ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission , Cambridge : IWC . (Special Issue 12)
  • Allen , J.M. 1994 . ‘Regional and Sexual Differences in Fluke Pigmentation in Humpback Whales.’ . Canadian Journal of Zoology , 72 : 274 – 279 .
  • Gewalt , W. 1990 . ‘The Jacobita or Commerson's Dolphin.’ . Aquatic Mammals , 16 (2) : 53 – 64 .
  • Carlson , C. 1990 . “ ‘Changes in Ventral Fluke Pattern of the Humpback Whale.’ ” . Edited by: Hammond . 105 – 111 . supra note 307
  • Kiernan , V. 1995 . ‘Ocean Ear Beats Whale Watchers.’ . New Scientist , 2007 : 7
  • Gordon , J. and Chappell , O. ‘The Potential for the Use of Passive Acoustic Techniques in Field Studies and Surveys of Porpoise Populations.’ . European Research on Cetaceans. Proceedings of the Seventh Annual Conference of the European Cetacean Society . pp. 274 – 276 . Cambridge : ERC .
  • 1987 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Permits.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 37 , 25 Recommendation 4
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Research Programmes.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 27 Recommendation 4
  • Tanabe , S. 1998 . “ Chemical Modernisation and Vulnerability of Cetaceans: Increasing Toxic Threat of Organochlorine Contaminants ” . In Persistent Pollutants in the Marine Environment Edited by: Walker , C.H. 161 – 177 .
  • Burns , William C. 1997 . From the Lance to the Laboratory: The Impact of Anthropogenic Environmental Degradation on Cetacean Species . Sea Wind , 10 (2) : 2 – 7 .
  • 1996 . Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 47 Resolution 1995–9
  • Resolution on the Environment and Whale Stocks . 1997 . Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 48 , 52
  • 1997 . “ ‘Report of the Standing Working Group on Environmental Concerns.’ ” . In Annex F in Report of the Scientific Committee 2 IWC/49/4
  • Simmonds , M.P. 1997 . ‘An Evaluation of Environmental and Other Factors in Some Recent Marine Mammal Mortalities in Europe: Implications for Conservation and Management.’ . Environment Review , 5 : 89 – 98 .
  • Mayer , S. and Simmonds , M. 1996 . “ ‘Science and Precaution in Cetacean Observation.” . Edited by: Simmonds . 134 – 143 . supra note 292
  • Slip , D.J. 1995 . ‘Stomach Content of Southern Bottlenose Whale, Hyperoodon Planifions, Stranded at Herald Island.’ . Marine Mammal Science , 11 (4) : 575 – 584 .
  • Nigro , M. 1994 . ‘Mercury and Selenium Localisation in Macrophages of the Striped Dolphin, Stenella Coeruleoalba.’ . Journal of the Marine Biological Association (UK) , 74 : 975 – 978 .
  • Reijnders , P. 1996 . “ ‘Organohalogen and Heavy Metal Contamination in Cetaceans: Observed Effects, Potential Impact and Future Prospects.’ ” . Edited by: Simmonds . 205 – 217 . supra note 292
  • Thompson , P. 1996 . “ ‘Defining Future Research Needs for Cetacean Conservation.’ ” . Edited by: Simmonds . 407 – 421 . supra note 292
  • Recchia , C.A. and Read , A.J. 1989 . ’Stomach Contents of Harbour Porpoises.” . Canadian Journal of Zoology , 67 : 2140 – 2146 .
  • Evans , P.G.H. 1990 . ‘European Cetaceans and Seabirds in an Oceanographie Context.” . Lutra , 33 : 95 – 125 .
  • Hoek , W. 1992 . ‘An Unusual Aggregation of Harbour Porpoises.’ . Marine Mammal Science , 8 (2) : 152 – 155 .
  • Relini , G. ‘Macroplankton and Fin Whales in the Liguro‐Provencal Basin.” . European Research Upon Cetaceans : Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Conference of the European Cetacean Society . Italy. Edited by: Evans , P.G. pp. 134 – 137 . San Remo
  • Smith , S.C. and Whitehead , H. 1993 . ‘Variations in the Feeding Success and Behaviour of Galapagos Sperm Whales.’ . Canadian Journal of Zoology , 71 (10) : 1991 – 1996 .
  • Baird , R.W. and Dill , L.M. 1995 . ‘Occurrence and Behaviour of Transient Killer Whales.’ . Canadian Journal of Zoology , 73 : 1300 – 1311 .
  • Hain , J. 1995 . ‘Apparent Bottom Feeding By Humpback Whales on Stellwagen Bank.’ . Marine Mammal Science , 11 (4) : 464 – 479 .
  • Scott , M.D. 1990 . “ ‘Tagging And Marking Studies on Small Cetaceans.’ ” . In The Botdenose Dolphin , Edited by: Leatherwood , S. 489 – 514 . San Diego : Academic Press .
  • 1987 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Permits.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 37 , 25 Recommendation 4
  • 1988 . “ ‘Resolution on Scientific Research Programmes.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 27 Recommendation 4
  • de la Mare . 1989 . “ ‘On the Simultaneous Estimation of Natural Mortality Rate and Population from Catch at Age Data.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 39 , 355 – 361 .
  • IWC . 1988 . “ ‘Report of the Scientific Committee.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 38 , 54 – 58 .
  • IWC . 1996 . “ ‘Report of the Scientific Committee.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 46 , 77 – 83 .
  • IWC . 1992 . “ ‘Report of the Scientific Committee.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 42 , 72 – 76 .
  • Kato , H. 1984 . “ ‘Readability of Antarctic Minke Whale Earplugs.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 34 , 719 – 722 .
  • Kato , H. 1991 . “ ‘Inter‐Reader Calibration in Age Readings of Earplugs From Southern Minke Whales.’ ” . In Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 41 , 287 – 292 .
  • Report of the Scientific Committee . 1988 . Report of the International Whaling Commission Vol. 48 , 41
  • LL.B; LL.M(Hons.) (Auckland); Ph.D.(Nottingham). Senior Lecturer at Law, Waikato University, New Zealand; [email protected].

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.