Undermining Assessment: EIA follow-up, stake-holder advisory groups, and extractive industries in Nunavut, Canada

References

• [AEM] Agnico Eagle Mines. 2020a. Terrestrial ecosystem management plan v. 8. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [AEM] Agnico Eagle Mines. 2020b. Terrestrial ecosystem management plan responses, 2020 Jul 13. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [AEM] Agnico Eagle Mines. 2020c. Agnico Eagle waterline addendum TC responses. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [AEM] Angico Eagle Mines. 2021a. Agnico Eagle response to FWS. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [AEM] Agnico Eagle Mines. 2021b. Agnico Eagle response to meadowbank and whale Tail annual report comments, July 29, 2021. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [AEM] Agnico Eagle Mines. 2021c. Exhibition 21: final list of commitments. NIRB File No. 11MN034
   Google Scholar
• Andronak B. 2017. Achieving next generation environmental impact assessment follow-up and monitoring. Winnipeg (MB): University of Manitoba. master’s thesis.
   Google Scholar
• Arnold L, Hanna K. 2017. Best practices in environmental assessment: cases studies and application to mining. Vancouver (BC): Canadian International Resources and Development Institute (CIRDI). Report 2017-003.
   Google Scholar
• Associates G. 2020. Agnico Eagle response to SDNF technical comment 1 for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034
   Google Scholar
• Atlin C, Gibson R. 2017. Lasting regional gains from non-renewable resource extraction: the role of sustainability-based cumulative effects assessment and regional planning for mining development in Canada. Extr Ind Soc. 4(1):36–52. doi:10.1016/j.exis.2017.01.005.
   Google Scholar
• Baffinland Iron Mines Corp. 2018. Mary river project – 2017 annual report. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Banks G 2013. Little by little, inch by inch: Project expansion assessments in the Papua New Guinea mining industry. Resources Policy. 38(4):688–695. doi:10.1016/j.resourpol.2013.03.003.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• [BQCMB] Beverly and Qamanirjuaq Caribou Management Board. 2004. Protecting Calving Grounds, Post-Calving Areas and Other Important Habitats for Beverly and Qamanirjuaq Caribou: A Position Paper. https://arctic-caribou.com/pdf/Position_Paper.pdf
   Google Scholar
• [BLHTO] Baker Lake Hunters and Trappers Organization. 2019. Technical review comments for the Whale Tail pit expansion project. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [BLHTO] Baker Lake Hunters and Trappers Organization 2020a. Letter to Agnico Eagle re: caribou road crossing mitigation memo, 2020 Apr 30. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [BLHTO] Baker Lake Hunters and Trappers Organization. 2020b. Changes to Agnico Eagle’s terrestrial ecosystem management plan, February 24, 2020. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [BLHTO] Baker Lake Hunters and Trappers Organization. 2020c. Technical comments for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [BLHTO] Baker Lake Hunters and Trappers Organization. 2021. Re technical meeting closing remarks for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034
   Google Scholar
• Boulanger J, Kite R, Campbell M, Shaw J, Lee D. 2020. Kivalliq caribou monitoring program – analysis of caribou movements relative to the Meadowbank mine and roads. Iqaluit (NU): Government of Nunavut Department of Environment.
   Google Scholar
• Bowman L. 2011. Sealing the deal: environmental and Indigenous justice and mining in Nunavut. Rev. Eur. Comp. Int 20(1):19–28. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9388.2011.00699.x.
   Google Scholar
• Chang I, Wang W, Wu J, Sun Y, Hu R. 2018. Environmental impact assessment follow-up for projects in China: Institution and practice. Environ Impact Assess Rev. 73:7–19. doi:10.1016/J.EIAR.2018.06.005.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Clyde River (Hamlet &Nangmautaq Hunters and Trappers Association). 2022. Closing comments, 2022 Jan 18. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Compendium of testimonies on the impacts of BaffinLand Iron Mines’s Mary River project on ecosystems, wildlife, and residents of Pond Inlet. [video]. 2021. L’Herault V, Cyr A, Simonee Jeditor, interviews. Pond Inlet (NU)& Quebec City (QC): Mittimatalik Hunters and Trappers Organization & ArtctiConnexion. 31 min, Pond Inlet, Nunavut. https://vimeo.com/505376532
   Google Scholar
• Devlin JF. 2011. Community engagement for adaptive management in environmental assessment follow-up: final report. Ottawa (ON): Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency. Catalogue No. En106-99/2011E-PDF.
   Google Scholar
• Dylan D, Thompson S. 2019. Nunavut impact review board’s inchoate incorporation of Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit. McGill J Sustainable Dev Law and Policy. 51(1):54–84.
   Google Scholar
• Fisheries and Oceans Canada. 2020. Comments on Baffinland Iron Mine Corp. 2019 annual report – Mary river project. 2020 Jul 27. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Fisheries and Oceans Canada. 2021. Comments on Baffinland Iron Mine’s 2020 annual report for the Mary river project. 2021 Jul 6. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Fisheries and Oceans Canada. 2022. Final closing statement for Baffinland’s phase 2 proposal. January. 10: NIRB File No. 08MN053
   Google Scholar
• Fitzpatrick P, Sinclair AJ. 2003. Learning through public involvement in environmental assessment hearings. J Environ Manage. 67(2):161–164. doi:10.1016/S0301-4797(02)00204-9.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fitzpatrick P, Williams B. 2020. Building the system: follow-up, monitoring and adaptive management. Winnipeg (MB): The University of Winnipeg; p. 51.
   Google Scholar
• Gibson G, Hoogeveen D, MacDonald A. 2018. Impact assessment in the Arctic: emerging practices of indigenous-led review. Edmonton: The Firelight Group. Submitted to Gwich’in Council International (GCI).
   Google Scholar
• [GN] Government of Nunavut. 2020a. Comment’s on Baffinland’s 2019 annual report for the Mary river Iron mine. 2020 Jul 27. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [GN] Government of Nunavut. 2020b. Changes to Whale Tail pit TEMP. 2020 May 22. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [GN] Government of Nunavut. 2020c. GN technical comments for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034
   Google Scholar
• [GN] Government of Nunavut. 2021. Comments on Agnico Eagle’s 2020 annual report for the Whale Tail pit project. 2021 Jun 25. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• Gondor D. 2016. Inuit knowledge and environmental assessment in Nunavut. Sustain. Sci. 11(1):153–162. doi:10.1007/s11625-015-0310-z.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gunton JT, Rutherford M, Rutherford M. 2015. Good practices for environmental assessment. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais 33(4):238–254. doi:10.1080/14615517.2015.1063811.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hackett P, Liu J, Noble B. 2018. Human health, development legacies, and cumulative effects: environmental assessments of hydroelectric projects in the Nelson river watershed, Canada. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais 36(5):413–424. doi:10.1080/14615517.2018.1487504.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hicks J, White G. 2015. Made in Nunavut. Vancouver (BC): University of British Columbia Press.
   Google Scholar
• Hollands J, Palframan L. 2014. EIA and EMS integration: not wasting the opportunity. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais 32(1):43–54. doi:10.1080/14615517.2014.875670.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Igloolik Working Group. 2022. Closing comments. 2022 Jan 18. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Iron Mines Corp B. 2014. 2013 annual report to the NIRB for the Mary river project. NIRB File No. 08MN053
   Google Scholar
• Jagors S, Matti S, Poelzer G, Yu S. 2018. The impact of local participation on community support for natural resource management. Arct. Rev. Law Politics. 9:124–147. doi:10.23865/arctic.v9.730.
   Google Scholar
• Jalava K, Haakana A, Kuitunen M. 2015. The rationale for and practice of EIA follow-up: an analysis of Finnish road projects. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais. 33(4):255–264. doi:10.1080/14615517.2015.1069997.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jha-Thakur U, Fischer T. 2008. Are open-cast coal mines casting a shadow on the Indian environment? Int. Dev. Plan. Rev 30(4):441–459. doi:10.3828/idpr.30.4.7.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Jha-Thakur U, Khosravi F. 2021. Beyond 25 years of EIA in India: Retrospection and way forward. Environ Impact Assess Rev. 87:106533. doi:10.1016/j.eiar.2020.106533.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Keeling A, Sandlos J, Boutet JS, Longley H, Dance A. 2019. Knowledge, sustainability, and the environmental legacies of resource development in Northern Canada. In: Southcott C, Abele F, Natcher D Parlee B, editors. Resources and Sustainable Development in the Arctic. New York (NY): Routledge; pp. 187–203.
   Google Scholar
• Kennedy Dalseg S, Kuokkanen R, Mills S, Simmons D. 2018. Gendered environmental assessment in the Canadian north: marginalization of indigenous women and traditional economies. North Rev. 47:135–166. doi:10.22584/nr47.2018.007.
   Google Scholar
• [KIA] Kivalliq Inuit Association. 2020a. Review of the Meadowbank terrestrial ecosystem management plan v. 8. 2020 May 21. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [KIA] Kivalliq Inuit Association. 2020b. Review of KIA involvement in the development of TEMP v. 8. 2020 May 21. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [KIA] Kivalliq Inuit Association. 2020c. Technical comments for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [KIA] Kivalliq Inuit Association. 2021. Comments on Agnico Eagle mine’s 2020 annual report for the Meadowbank and Whale Tail projects. 2021 Jun 25. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• Kulchyski P. 2015. Trail to tears: concerning modern treaties in northern Canada. Can J Native Stud. 35(1):69–81.
   Google Scholar
• [KWB] Kivalliq Wildlife Board. 2020. Technical comments for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [KWB] Kivalliq Wildlife Board. 2021. Final written submission for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• Larsen R 2018. Impact assessment and indigenous self-determination: a scalar framework of participation options. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal. 36(3):208–219.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lindgren A, Reed MG, Robson JP. 2021. Process makes perfect: perceptions of effectiveness in collaborative environmental governance. Environ Manage. 67(2):228–241. doi:10.1007/s00267-020-01402-5.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lindgren A, Robson JP, Reed MG, Sinclair AJ, Parkins JP, Nadeau S, Teitelbaum S, Hitomi MK 2019. Engaging the public in sustainable forest management in Canada: results from a national survey of advisory committees. Ottawa (ON): Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service. Information Report LAU-X-142E. 79 pp.
   Google Scholar
• [MHTO] Mittimitalik Hunters and Trappers Organization. 2022. Closing comments. 2022 Jan 17. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Morrison-Saunders A, Arts J. Eds. 2004. Assessing impact: handbook of EIA and SEA follow-up. London: Earthscan.
   Google Scholar
• Morrison-Saunders A, Arts J, Bond A, Pope J, Retief F. 2021. Reflecting on, and revising, international best practice principles for EIA follow-up. Environ Impact Assess Rev. 89:106596. doi:10.1016/j.eiar.2021.106596.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Morrison-Saunders A, Marshall R, Arts J. 2007. EIA follow-up: international best practice principles. Fargo (ND): International Association for Impact Assessment. Special Publication Series No. 6.
   Google Scholar
• Muir B. 2018. Closing the regulatory gap: revisions to the conventional practice of ex-post plans for EIAs to protect the valued components of Aboriginal peoples in Canada. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais 36(2):186–203. doi:10.1080/14615517.2017.1390873.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nenko A, Parkins JR, Reed MG, Sinclair AJ. 2019. Rethinking effective public engagement in sustainable forest governance. Soc Nat Resour. 32(12):1383–1398. doi:10.1080/08941920.2018.1539198.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nicolaisen MS, Fischer T. 2016. Editorial: special issue on ex-post evaluation of environmental assessment. J. Environ. Assess. 18(1):1601001. Eds. doi:10.1142/S1464333216010018.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2006. Final hearing report for the meadowbank gold project. NIRB File No. 03MN107.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2009. Project certificate no. 004, Amended 2009 Nov 20. NIRB File No. 03MN107.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2017a. Final hearing transcript for the Whale Tail pit project. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2017b. Final hearing report for the Whale Tail pit project. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2018. Reconsideration report: production increase proposal. August. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2019a. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 1. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2019b. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 3. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2019c. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 2. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2019d. Final hearing transcript for the Whale Tail expansion. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2019e. Final hearing report for the Whale Tail expansion. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021a. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 11. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021b. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 10. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021c. Final hearing transcript for the phase 2 expansion. vol. 15. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021d. Annual report for Agnico Eagle’s Whale Tail gold project. December, 2020. NIRB File No. 16MN056.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021e. Public hearing transcript for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2021f. Nunavut Impact Review Board. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• [NIRB] Nunavut Impact Review Board. 2022. Nunavut Impact Review Board. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Noble B 2020. Follow-up and monitoring in impact assessment: synthesis of knowledge and practice. Ottawa (ON): Impact Assessment Agency of Canada. 78 pp.
   Google Scholar
• Noble B, Hanna K, Blakly J. 2019. Northern environmental assessment: a gap analysis and research agenda. In: Southcott C, Abele F, Natcher D, Parlee B, editors. Resources and sustainable development in the Arctic. London: Routledge; pp. 65–87 .
   Google Scholar
• O’Faircheallaigh C. 2016. Negotiations in the indigenous world: aboriginal peoples and the extractive industry in Australia and Canada. London: Routledge.
   Google Scholar
• O’Faircheallaigh C. 2017. Shaping projects,shaping impacts:community-controlled impact assessments and negotiated agreements. Third World Q. 38(5):1181–1197. doi:10.1080/01436597.2017.1279539.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Olszynski M. 2017. Failed experiments: an empirical assessment of adaptive management in Alberta’s energy resources sector. University of British Columbia Law Review. 50(3):697.
   Google Scholar
• Parkins J. 2010. The problem with trust: insights from advisory committees in the forest sector of Alberta. Soc Nat Resour. 23(9):822–836. doi:10.1080/08941920802545792.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Parkins J, Sinclair AJ. 2014. Patterns of elitism within participatory environmental governance. J. Environ. Plan.c. 32(4):746–761. doi:10.1068/c1293.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Parks Canada. 2021. Comments on Baffinland Iron Mine’s 2020 annual report for the Mary river project. June 23, 2021. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Parlee B, Sandlos J, Natcher D 2018. Undermining Subsistence: Barren-ground caribou in a “tragedy of open access”. Science Advances 4(2). doi:10.1126/sciadv.1701611.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Peletz N, Hanna K, Noble B. 2020. The central role of Inuit Qaujimaningit in Nuanvut’s impact assessment process. Impact Assess. Proj. Apprais 38(5):412–426. doi:10.1080/14615517.2020.1786763.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pinto E, Morrison-Saunders A, Bond A, Pope J, Retier F. 2019. Distilling and applying criteria for best practice EIA follow-up. J. Environ. Assess. 21(2):1950008. doi:10.1142/S146433321950008X.
   Google Scholar
• [QIA] Qikiqtani Inuit Association. 2020. Comment’s on Baffinland’s 2019 annual report for the Mary river Iron mine. 2020 Jul 28. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• [QIA] Qikiqtani Inuit Association. 2021. Comments on Baffinland Iron mine’s 2020 annual report for the Mary river project. 2021 Jul 6. NIRB File No. 08MN053.
   Google Scholar
• Rodon, T. 2021. Land-Use Co-Management in Canada: A Mixed Experience. Pages 289-311. In: Finnmark Act 15 years after. Gyldendal. Oslo, Norvège.
   Google Scholar
• Ross WA. 2004. The independent environmental watchdog: a Canadian experiment in EIA follow-up. In: Morrison-Saunders A, Arts J, editors. Assessing impact: handbook of EIA and SEA follow-up. New York (NY): Earthscan; p. 178–196.
   Google Scholar
• Scobie W, Rodgers K. 2013. Contestation of resource extraction projects via digital media in two Nunavut communities. Etud Inuit. 37(2):83–101.
   Google Scholar
• Scobie W, Rodgers K. 2019. Diversions, distractions, and privileges: consultation and the governance of mining in Nunavut. Stud. Political Econ. 100(3):232–251. doi:10.1080/07078552.2019.1682782.
   Google Scholar
• [SDFN] Sayisi Dene First Nation. 2020. Sayisi Dene first Nation technical comments for the Meliadine pipeline modification. NIRB File No. 11MN034.
   Google Scholar
• Sinclair AJ, Diduk A. 2001. Public involvement in environmental assessment in Canada: a transformative learning perspective. Environ Impact Assess Rev. 21(2):113–136. doi:10.1016/S0195-9255(00)00076-7.
   Google Scholar
• Venn D 2021 Nov 6. Community reps oppose mine expansion at final day of Baffinland hearing. Nunatsiaq News. [accessed 2021 Nov 7]; Business [about 2021 Nov 7]; Business [about 4 screens]. https://nunatsiaq.com/stories/article/community-reps-oppose-mine-expansion-at-final-day-of-Baffinland-hearing/.
   Google Scholar
• Watt C, Simonee J, L’Herault V, Zhou R, Ferguson SH, Marcoux M, Black S. 2021. Cortisol levels in narwhal (Monodon monoceros) blubber from 2000 to 2019. Arctic Sci. 7(3):690–698. doi:10.1139/as-2020-0034.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• White G. 2008. Not the almighty: evaluating Aboriginal influence in northern land claims boards. Arctic. 61(1):71–85.
   Google Scholar
• Williams A 2015. Governmentality and mining: analyzing the environmental impact assessment for the Mary River Mine (Nunavut, Canada) [ master’s thesis]. Ottawa (ON): Carleton University.
   Google Scholar