Peasants, plantations, and pulp: The politics of eucalyptus in Thailand

References

• Hirsch, Philip , 1990. Forests, Forest Reserve, and Forest Land in Thailand , Geographical Journal 156 (2) (1990), pp. 168–168, In 1985 National Reserve Forests covered 42 percent of Thailand's land area; additional forest land is contained in national parks and wildlife sanctuaries.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Uhlig, Harald , 1988. "Spontaneous and Planned Settlement in South-East Asia". In: Manshard, Walther , and Morgan, William , eds. Agricultural Expansion and Pioneer Settlements in the Humid Tropics . Tokyo: United Nations University; 1988. pp. 9–16, Philip Hirsch, “Deforestation and Development in Thailand,” Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, vol. 8, no. 2 (1987), pp. 130-38. For the role of the World Bank, see Grit Permtanjit, The Political Economy of Dependent Capitalist Development: A Study on the Limits of the Capacity of the State to Rationalize in Thailand (Bangkok: Chulalongkorn University Social Research Institute, 1982).
   Google Scholar
• Myers, Norman , 1989. Deforestation Rates in Tropical Forests and Their Climatic Implications . London: Friends of the Earth; 1989, Assuming 9 percent of this is protected, then perhaps 6 percent of the nonprotected area is forested. Even if we assume that all of this nonprotected forested area is in National Reserve Forests (NRFs), that would suggest that well over a quarter of the country's land area is degraded or unforested NRFs.
   Google Scholar
• Riethmuller, Robert , "Differentiation and Dynamics of Land-Use Systems in a Mountain-Valley Environment". In: Agricultural Expansion . pp. 89–89, in Manshard and Morgan;In late 1989 Pairote Suwannakorn, the director general of the Royal Forestry Department, stated in public that 6 million people would have to be evicted from National Reserve Forests. The Land Distribution Project for the Poor in Degraded Forests under the military's Internal Security Operations Command envisages the resettlement of some 970,000 families from the reserves.
   Google Scholar
• Samutwanit, Chai-anan , and Morell, David , 1981. Political Conflict in Thailand: Reform, Reaction and Revolution . Cambridge, MA: Gunn and Hill; 1981, Struggles between peasants and eucalyptus planters are also well known in India and Portugal. See Vandana Shiva, H.C. Sharatchandra, and J. Bandyopad-hyay, “Social Forestry-No Solution Within the Market,” Ecologist, vol. 12, no. 4 (1982); H. Lamb and S. Percy, “Indians Fight Eucalyptus Plantations on Commons,” New Scientist, 16 July 1987; Jill Joliffe, “Greens and Farmers Fight the Eucalyptus Tree,” Guardian (UK), 22 June 1989; Christopher Joyce, “The Tree That Started a Riot,” New Scientist, 18 Feb. 1988, pp. 51-61; Lars Kardell, Eliel Steen, and Antonio Fabiao, “Eucalyptus in Portugal-a Threat or a Promise?,” Ambio, vol. 15, no. 1 (1986), pp. 6-13..
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Tham boon lawm pa thii don Na Nong Chuek. .. choom chon phitak pa". In: Poo Jatgarn . 1990, Making merit encircling the forest at Na Nong Chuek: a community protects a forest;“Villagers Destroy 100 Rai of Trees,” Bangkok Post, Mar. 1990; “Villagers Seek To Halt Forestry Scheme,” Bangkok Post, 13 Mar. 1990; “Activist in Fight To Save Dong Yai Threatened,” Bangkok Post, 19 Feb. 1990; Tunya Sukpanich, “NE Leaders Seek Say in Reforestation Effort,” Bangkok Post, 9 Nov. 1987; “Fiery Protest Greets Green Esam Project,” Nation (Bangkok), 17 Mar. 1988; “Eucalyptus Bonfire To Protest Against Arrests,” Bangkok Post, 4 June 1988; “Eucalyptus Planting Sparks Fiery Protest,” Nation, 14 June 1988; Suda Kanjanawanawan, “Eucalyptus Protests Going Straight to the Top” and “Villagers To Demand Land Rights at Cabinet Meet,” ibid., 30 Mar. 1989; “Private Sector ‘To Blame’ for Ruined Forests,” Bangkok Post, 3 May 1989; “Govt Urged To Give Villagers a Role in Conserving Forests,” ibid., 29 July 1989; “Villagers Unite To Defend Forest and Own Livelihood,” ibid., 1 Aug. 1989;Rapee Sakrik, “Khwaam sap son kiaw kap kam plook yookaliptat” (Confusion about eucalyptus planting), Siam Rath, 11 Apr. 1990; “Prawes Slams Govt Eucalyptus Policy,” Bangkok Post, 27 Feb. 1990; “Mob tarn yooka khluen phol aang het tham laai paa tua yong” (Eucalyptus opponents agitate, refer to forest destruction), Tharn Set-takit, 29 Jan.-4 Feb. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Solving the Problem of Agricultural Land in Forests . held in Bangkok at Government House.
   Google Scholar
• 1989. Panhaa paa maai thü tham kin lae thaang awk . Bangkok: Thai Volunteer Service; 1989, The problem of forests and agricultural land and the way out, Sanitsuda Ekachai, “Ordaining trees to save the woods,” Bangkok Post, 21 Mar. 1990; Union for Civil Liberty, Alternative Technology Association, and Project for Ecological Recovery, Paa choomchon (Community forest), proceedings of a seminar on villagers' organizations and commercial tree plantations in six northeastern provinces (Bangkok: Project for Ecological Recovery, 1987).
   Google Scholar
• 1988. "NE Villagers Plan Own ‘Green project’". In: Bangkok Post . 1988, Mangkorn Tengpravat, “Villagers in Northeast Launch Green Campaigns”; ibid., 4 June 1988.
   Google Scholar
• Ekachai, Sanitsuda , 1990. Behind the Smile . Bangkok: Thai Development Support Committee; 1990. pp. 52–61.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "The IIU Case: Pulp and Paper Versus the People". In: Environesia . Vol. 4. 1990. pp. 3–7, no. 2.
   Google Scholar
• Sargent, Caroline , 1990. The Khun Song Plantation Project . London: International Institute for Environment and Development; 1990. pp. 16–17, Figures cited for current eucalyptus cultivation come from Rerngchai Paosajja of the Royal Forestry Department and “Pert pho big turakit soo kam plook pa chemg panit,” Prachachart turakit, 4–6 Jan. 1989. Over 50 percent of eucalyptus planting so far has been on state land. See “Kaan perm mool khaa maai khong suan paa maai tow rayo” (mimeo, Bangkok: Royal Forestry Department, 1988).
   Google Scholar
• 1989. "Plook sang suan paa jaak brazil theung thai". In: Prachachart turakit . 1989, gives the figure of 2 million families in National Reserve Forests, although a more commonly cited figure is 1.2 million.
   Google Scholar
• Fuller, Doug , 1988. "Eucalypts Fuel the Furnace of Brazil's Steelworks". In: New Scientist . 1988. pp. 56–56.
   Google Scholar
• Sargent, , Khun Song Plantation . pp. 26–26, See the similar estimate by another leading eucalyptus planter, Kitti Damnoenchamwanit, in “Irate Kitti Denies He's the Nation's Enemy,” Nation, 4 Mar. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Chirapandea, S. , and Tamrongtanyalak, W. , 1980. Resettlement in Thailand . Bangkok: Agricultural Land Reform Office; 1980, that in the 1970s, 5–6 million people were squatting on 40,000–50,000 square kilometers of land, suggesting a density of 100–150 persons per square kilometer. Current government estimates of “degraded” land in National Reserve Forests that needs to be replanted with trees range between 48,000 and 71,840 square kilometers. See “Ministry Announces Reforestation Target,” Nation, 29 Jan. 1990; “Sanan: Govt's Policy of Promoting Reforestation Scheme To Continue,” Nation, 28 Apr. 1990). Assuming that this is coextensive with the land occupied by the 7 to 10 million estimated occupants of National Reserve Forests, the population density would be in the same range or higher.
   Google Scholar
• Thai Development Research Institute, 1987. Thailand Natural Resources Profile . Bangkok: Thai Development Research Institute; 1987. pp. 19–19.
   Google Scholar
• Panyacheewin, Saowarop , 1990. "Hilltribes People Find Life in Lowland Villages Hard". In: Bangkok Post . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Tangwisutthijit, Nantiya , 1990. "Forest Conservation Versus Land Reform". In: Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "‘Leh’ nak lowng toon kwaan sue thii pan rakhaa chaaw naa lom lalaai". In: Krungthep Thurakit Sapdaa . 1990, Investors speculate in land, farmers go bankrupt;Sargent, Khun Song Plantation, pp. 23, 53-54, 87; “The Forest for the Trees,” “The Quiet Gang Rape,” pp. 11-13, Manager, 26 Feb.-ll Mar. 1990; Veera Prateepchaikul and Surapol Tourn-ngern, “Degrading by Degrees,” Bangkok Post, 11 Mar. 1990; Jeerawat Krongkaew, “How Suan Kitti Cornered the Land Market,” Nation, 6 Feb. 1990. In 1989 3.6 million land transfers were recorded in Thailand-an increase of 56 percent in a single year. Eastern Thailand was one of the biggest boom areas.
   Google Scholar
• Milner, Edward , 1990. "Lessons from a Peasant Revolt". In: Telegraph . London. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Scholz, Ulrich , "Spontaneous Pioneer Settlement in Thailand". In: Agricultural Expression . pp. 54–55, in Manshard and Morgan.
   Google Scholar
• Tiwootanon, Niyom , 1990. Withi tham laai paa duai karn chao . 1990, Destroying the forest by renting it.
   Google Scholar
• 1988. Thai Rath . 1988, Matichon, 22 May 1988.
   Google Scholar
• Sargent, , Khun Song Plantation . pp. 21–21.
   Google Scholar
• 1987;1988. Matichon . 1987;1988, Krungthep Thurakit, 15 Dec. 1987; Settakit, 11 Feb. 1988.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Pertpho: suan paa yookhaaliptat phaen din nü khrai jawng?". In: Matichon . 1990, Who has reserved this land?;Sargent, Khun Song Plantation, pp. 1, 7; interview with Philip Maxwell, Shell International Petroleum Company, London, 14 Aug. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Krungthep Thurakit Sapdaa . 1990, Niyom Tiwootanon, “Destroying the Forest.”.
   Google Scholar
• Phantumvanit, Dhira , Panyoutou, Theodore , and Jetanavanich, Songpol , 1990. "Eucalyptus: for Whom and for What?". In: Thai Development Research Institute Quarterly Review . 1990, Ann Danaiya Usher, “Eucalyptus-Widening the Gap,” Nation, 15 June 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Siam Rath Sapdaa Wijarn . 1990. pp. 17–20.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Yiipoon lae mafia thurakit phanuek phaen luek thalome suan kitti". In: Poo Jatgarn . 1990, Japan and the business mafia schemed to destroy Suan Kitti;“Shell nai songkhraam see khio” (Shell in the Green War), Poo Jatgarn, Nov. 1988, pp. 50-84.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Manager . 1990, Ann Danaiya Usher, “After the Forest...,” Nation, 7 June 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Goldstein, C. , 1988. "Not Just Paper Profits". In: Far Eastern Economic Review . 1988. pp. 95–97, “Squatters' Rights,” Manager, 26 Feb.-ll Mar. 1990, p. 14.
   Google Scholar
• Dhanasettakorn, Apisak , 1990. "Eucalyptus Processor To Start Despite Uncertainty". In: Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Manager . 1990, Ann Danaiya Usher, “What Price the Eucalyptus Tree?” Nation, 22 Feb. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Sukpanich, Tunya , 1990. "Killing the Land for Money". In: Bangkok Post . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Dhira, Panyoutou , and Songpol, , Eucalyptus , interview with Wiboon Khemchalerm, Sanam Chai Khet District, Chachoengsao, Dec. 1988.
   Google Scholar
• Jongsawat, Suphakit , 1990. "Khrai chao phuen thü paa sanguan haeng chaat". In: Siam Rath . 1990, Who rents National Reserve Forest land?;Adisak Limprungpattanakit, “Kitti Vows To Pursue Plantation Dream,” Nation, 27 Feb. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Dhanasettakorn, Apisak , 1990. "Forest Policy Revision Clouds ADB Plan". In: Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1989. "Ootasahakam yuea lae kradaat". In: Warasarn settakit grungthep . 1989. pp. 328–333, The pulp and paper industry.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Aw aw paw bae tha ruam toon kap baw kaset roong rueng plook pa-tang rongngan yuea kradaat". In: Siam Rath . 1990, Forest Industry Organization move to invest in plantations, pulp factory with Kaset Roong Rueng Company;“Phaen ekkachon plook paa 33 larn rai” (Plan for the private sector to plant 52,800 square kilometers), Matichon, 3 Feb. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Pholcheewin, Chamaiporn , 1988. "Karn plook paa phuea ootasahagam taw nueang: yyuea kradaat". In: People and Forests: the Current Situation, Problems and the Future . Bangkok: Chulalongkorn University Social Research Institute; 1988, contribution to seminar.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Ecumenical Coalition on Third World Tourism". In: Death of the Siew River: Chronology of a Protest . Bangkok. 1990. pp. 28–29, “Salt in the Wound,” Far Eastern Economic Review, 7 June 1990,.
   Google Scholar
• Wirotnakoot, Prakorb , 1990. Khuen kap karn cholprathaan . 1990. pp. 439–51, (Dams and irrigation), contribution to a seminar on dams, their effects, and energy solutions, Chulalongkorn University;Philip Hirsch and Larry Lohmann, “The Contemporary Politics of Environment in Thailand,” Asian Survey, vol. 29, no. 4 (Apr. 1989),.
   Google Scholar
• Lohmann, Larry , 1989. Forestry in Thailand: The Logging Ban and Its Consequences , Ecologist 19 (2) (1989), pp. 76–77.
   Google Scholar
• Hirsch, , and Lohmann, , Contemporary Politics .
   Google Scholar
• Khemchalerm, Wiboon , 1986. Sai phan cheewit . Bangkok: Komon Keemthong Foundation; 1986.
   Google Scholar
• Usher, , 1990. "Eucalyptus-Widening the Gap". In: Nation . 1990, Sargent, Khun Song Plantation, pp. 16-17; Dhira, Panyoutou, and Songpol, “Eucalyptus”; Matichon, 3 Mar. 1990; “Bol Will Seek Help for Paper Industry,” Nation, 30 Mar. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Tunya, , Killing the Land .
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Siam Rath . 1990, Nation, 11 Apr. 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• Tunya, , Killing the Land .
   Google Scholar
• Usher, Ann Danaiya , 1990. "A Forest Policy Sadly Gone Awry". In: Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. "Sanan: Govt's Policy of Promoting Reforestation Scheme To Continue". In: Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1989. Naew Naa . Bangkok: mimeo; 1989, is Raw rak paa maai: roo rak roo raksaa paa maai khoo thai wai chua niran (We love the forest: we know to love it, we know to preserve it; forest together with Thailand for all time).
   Google Scholar
• 1988. Teknoloyee thee maw som . Vol. 7. 1988, Appropriate technology, no. 2, For data confirming village reports of scant insect and other wildlife in eucalyptus plantations, see M.E.D. Poore and C. Fries, The Ecological Effects of Eucalyptus (Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization, 1985), pp. 48-49. Confirmation that even paddy-bund planting “is detrimental to the current agricultural production systems of some Northeastern agroecosystems” can be found in Iain A. Craig, Sasithorn Wasunan, and Manit Saenlao, “Effects of Paddy-Bund-Planted Eucalyptus Trees on the Performance of Field Crops,” paper presented at the Fifth Annual Farming Systems Conference, 4–7 Apr. 1988, Kamphaengsaen. The general Thai village picture of eucalyptus corresponds quite closely to that outlined in Vandana Shiva and J. Bandyopadhyay, Ecological Audit of Eucalyptus Cultivation (Dehra Dun, Thailand: Research Foundation for Science and Ecology, 1987), esp. p. 39.
   Google Scholar
• Nectoux, Francois , and Kuroda, Yoichi , 1989. Timber from the South Seas . 1989. pp. 123–123, Gland: World Wide Fund for Nature;Japan International Cooperation Agency, Annual Reports: 1985, p. 45; 1986, p. 56; 1987, p. 57.
   Google Scholar
• 1989. "Aid Sought from Japan for Green Northeast Plan". In: Bangkok Post . 1989.
   Google Scholar
• Tunya, , Killing the Land .
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Globe and Mail . Canada. 1990, Nation (Bangkok), 14 Oct. 1989.
   Google Scholar
• 1990. Nation . 1990.
   Google Scholar
• 1987. The Tropical Forestry Action Plan . Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization; 1987, Marcus Colchester and Larry Lohmann, The Tropical Forestry Action Plan: What Progress? (Penang: World Rainforest Movement, 1990).
   Google Scholar
• Poyry, Jaakko , 1989. "Sia Kitti (Soon Hua Seng) sang lui". In: Prachachart thurakit . 1989, has served commercial logging, pulp-mill, and refinery and gasifier projects in Brazil and is a consultant to the Aracruz eucalyptus plantation currently being held up as a model for Thailand. In addition to logging, plantation, and pulp industries in dozens of other countries, it has also worked with PT Indorayon and transmigrasi operations in Indonesia, both of which have aroused opposition from environmentalist and human rights groups. The Jaakko Poyry-written Tropical Forest Action Plan exercise for Sri Lanka, meanwhile, drew such vociferous criticism from conservationists that it had to be withdrawn. See;(Kitti [Soon Hua Seng] orders the move ahead);Jaakko Poyry Projects (Helsinki: Jaakko Poyry, Nov. 1988); Know-How Wire (Jaakko Poyry client magazine), Jan. 1989; Ann Danaiya Usher, “The Shaping of a Master Plan,” Nation, 25 June 1990; and Ranjen Fernando and S.W.R. de A. Samarasinghe, eds., Forest Conservation and the Forestry Master Plan for Sri Lanka-a Review (Colombo: Wildlife and Nature Protection Society of Sri Lanka, 1987).
   Google Scholar
• Master Plan for Forestry Development in Thailand: Terms of Reference , (Bangkok: FINNIDA, 1989). Representatives of 214 nongovernmental organizations notified the Thai government on 1 August 1990 that they would refuse to participate in the plan, citing its bias toward commercial forestry and lack of recognition of the inequalities that have led to forest colonization (“NGOs Pull Out of Forestry Project,” Nation, 2 Aug. 1990).
   Google Scholar
• Jaakko Poyry in Brief , Helsinki: Jaakko Poyry, n.d..
   Google Scholar
• 1987. "Eucalyptus Project Faces Stiff Opposition". In: Bangkok Post . 1987.
   Google Scholar
• Houghton, Richard , 1990. "The Future Role of Tropical Forests in Affecting the Carbon Dioxide Concentration of the Atmosphere". In: Ambio . Vol. 19. 1990. pp. 204–209, no. 4, the documents circulated at the G-7 summit in Houston, 22 June 1990; and “Brazilians launch plan to bring back the trees,” New Scientist, 8 Sept. 1990, p. 32.
   Google Scholar