Communists and democracy: Two Indian cases and one debate

References

• Therborn, Göran , 1977. "The Rule of Capital and the Rise of Democracy". In: New Left Review . 1977, no. 103.
   Google Scholar
• Törnquist, Olle , 1989. What's Wrong with Marxism? On Capitalists and State in India and Indonesia . New Delhi: Manohar Publications; 1989, chaps. 5 and 6.
   Google Scholar
• Törnquist, Olle , 1991. What's Wrong with Marxism? Vol. 2: On Peasants and Workers in India and Indonesia . New Delhi: Manohar Publications, forthcoming; 1991.
   Google Scholar
• Frankel, Francine , 1971. India's Green Revolution: Economic Gains and Political Costs . Princeton University Press; 1971, In this section I draw on results from an evaluation of the political struggles for land reforms in Kerala, West Bengal, and on Java. All sources are found in Törnquist, What's Wrong? Vol. 2. In the following text I give priority to references with special emphasis on local democracy, while sources relating to the more general struggle for land reforms are excluded because of lack of space and time. This means that there are comparatively few references in support of the first analysis of Kerala. The best studies, which I frequently draw on, include; K.N. Raj and M. Tharakan, “Agrarian Reform in Kerala and Its Impact on the Rural Economy—A Preliminary Assessment,” in Agrarian Reform in Contemporary Developing Countries, ed. A.K. Ghose (New Delhi: Selectbook Service Syndicate, 1984); TJ. Nossiter, Communism in Kerala: A Study in Political Adaptation (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1982); the writings of Ronald Herring, particularly Land to the Tiller: The Political Economy of Agrarian Reform in South Asia (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1983); and “Managing the ‘Great Transformation’: The Truly Awkward Class in Rural Development,” Paper delivered at the International Workshop on Rural Transformation in Asia (New Delhi, 2–4 Oct. 1986).
   Google Scholar
• Mitter, Swasi , 1977. Peasant Movements in West Bengal . Cambridge University; 1977. pp. 48–48, Dept. of Land Economy, Occasional Paper no. 8; See also the revealing statement by the late main CPI-M peasant leader Konar in Bhabani Sen Gupta, CPI-M: Promises, Prospects, Problems (New Delhi: Young Asia Publications, 1979), pp. 74f.
   Google Scholar
• Mukhopadhyay, A.K. , 1980. The Panchayat Administration in West Bengal . Calcutta: The World Press; 1980. pp. vi–vi.
   Google Scholar
• Gupta, Sen , 1982. Documents of the Eleventh Congress of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) . New Delhi: Desraj Chadha and the CPI-M; 1982. pp. 168–168, CPI-M, p. 125. The CPI-M says that it contested 47,000 seats. See.
   Google Scholar
• Gupta, Sen , CPI-M . pp. 118–134.
   Google Scholar
• 1985. Reports of the CPI-M and Its Various Frontal Activities (1982–1985) . Calcutta: Sushil Chowdhury and West Bengal CPI-M State Committee; 1985. pp. 68–68, part 1; and part 2, p. 145. Cf. Amit Roy, “Panchayat Polls Reviewed,” in Frontier (Calcutta), 25 June 1983.
   Google Scholar
• Chaudhuri, Kalyan , 1988. "Testing Time for Left Front in West Bengal". In: Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) . 1988, and “CPI(M) Rides Left Front Squabbles,” in EPW, 19 Mar. 1988.
   Google Scholar
• Mukhopadhyay, , The Panchayat Administration . pp. vii–xvii, chap. 12; S. Dasgupta and L.S.N. Murty, Panchayati Raj Institutions in West Bengal: A Study in Communist Participation (New Delhi: National Institute of Public Cooperation and Child Development, 1983), pp. 9-14; and Sen Gupta, CPI-M, pp. 134-39. Cf. also Significant Six Years of the Left Front Government of West Bengal (Sushil Chowdhury and West Bengal CPI-M State Committee, 1983), pp. 50ff.
   Google Scholar
• Dasgupta, Biplab , 1987. Monitoring and Evaluation of the Agrarian Reform Programme of West Bengal . Calcutta: Mimeographed manuscript; 1987. pp. 39–39, part 1; part 2, pp. 46-52; and part 3, pp. 9f. I also draw on discussions in New Delhi with the author (who is also a CPI-M agrarian reform organizer, peasant leader, and member of the union parliament), 16 and 17 Nov. 1988. Cf. the CPI-M leader and ex-leading member of the West Bengal state planning board Satyabrata Sen's way of putting it: “The panchayats undermine the power of the landlords. Now people come instead to the panchayats to get advice, etc.” Interview by author, Calcutta, 20 Feb. 1985.
   Google Scholar
• Herring, , Great Transformation . pp. 32–32, Managing the.
   Google Scholar
• Westergaard, Kirsten , 1986. People's Participation, Local Government and Rural Development: The Case of West Bengal, India . Copenhagen: Centre for Development Research Report no. 8; 1986, Cf. also Boudhayan Chattopadhyay et al., Agrarian Structure, Tensions, Movements, and Peasant Organisations in West Bengal 1936–1976: Vol. 1, Part 3: Field Reports, (Calcutta: Manuscript, 1983), on the predominance of parties as compared to mass organizations.
   Google Scholar
• 1968. Asian Drama: An Inquiry into the Poverty of Nation . New York: {cxNew York}; 1968. pp. 1063f–1063f.
   Google Scholar
• Dasgupta, Biplab , 1986. "Comprehensive Rural Development: The CADC Experience". In: Dantwala, M.L. , , eds. Asian Seminar on Rural Development: The Indian Experience . New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing Co.; 1986. pp. 356–356.
   Google Scholar
• Dasgupta, , Monitoring and Evaluation . pp. 31–31, part 2; part 3.
   Google Scholar
• Westergaard, , People's Participation . pp. 90–90, and Ashok Rudra, “Panchayati Raj,” in Frontier, 9 Jan. 1982. I also draw on my interview with the then finance minister Ashok Mitra, Calcutta, 5 Mar. 1985.
   Google Scholar
• Mukhopadhyay, , The Panchayat Administration . pp. xviii–xviii, chap. 12.
   Google Scholar
• Documents of the Eleventh Congress . pp. 173–173.
   Google Scholar
• Roy, Amit , 1983. "Panchayat Polls Reviewed". In: Frontier . 1983.
   Google Scholar
• Westergaard, , People's Participation . pp. 79–79, Profulla Roy Choudhury, Left Experiment in West Bengal (New Delhi: Patriot Publishers, 1984), p. 161 (referring to a West Bengal government workshop); and T.K. Ghosh, Operation Barga and Land Reforms (Delhi: B.R. Publishing Corporation, 1986), pp. 83f.
   Google Scholar
• Bose, Pardip Kumar , 1984. Classes in Rural Society . Delhi: Ajanta Publications; 1984. pp. 213–213, for examples from the early seventies.
   Google Scholar
• Sethi, Harsh , 1984. "Groups in a New Politics of Transformation". In: Ofstad, Arve , , ed. Policy Issues for Indo-Norwegian Development Cooperation . Oslo: NORAD; 1984, in EPW.
   Google Scholar
• Kothari, Rajni , 1983. "The Non-Party Political Process". In: The Non-Party Political Process: Uncertain Alternatives . Delhi: UNRISD/Lokayan; 1983. pp. 28–30, (Also in EPW, 4 Feb. 1984.) Cf. Sudipta Kaviraj, “On the Crisis of Political Institutions in India,” in Contributions to Indian Sociology, New Series, vol. 18, no. 2 (1984).
   Google Scholar
• Frank, A.G. , and Fuentes, M. , 1987. "Nine theses on social movements". In: EPW . 1987. pp. 1503–1503.
   Google Scholar
• EPW . pp. 1505–1505.
   Google Scholar
• EPW . pp. 1509–1509.
   Google Scholar
• Patankar, Bharat , 1985. Transcendence of the Traditional Communist Movement: The Case of India . Kasegaon, Maharashtra: manuscript; 1985.
   Google Scholar
• Karat, Parkash , 1984. "Action Groups/Voluntary Organisations: A Factor in Imperialist Strategy". In: The Marxist . 1984, and Foreign Funding and The Philosophy of Voluntary Organisations: A Factor in Imperialist Strategy (New Delhi: Rajendra Prasad and National Book Centre, 1988).
   Google Scholar
• Karat, , Foreign Funding . pp. 57–57.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 14–14, for example.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 16–16, for example.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 10–10.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 30–30.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 13–13.
   Google Scholar
• Karat, , Foreign Funding . pp. 45–45.
   Google Scholar
• Foreign Funding . pp. 65–65.
   Google Scholar
• Petras, James , 1989. "Metamorphosis of Latin America's intellectuals". In: EPW . 1989.
   Google Scholar
• Dhanagare, D. , and John, J. , 1988. "Cyclical Movement Toward the ‘Eternal’". In: EPW . 1988.
   Google Scholar
• Parra, Bosco , 1991. "Labour and democracy in Chile". In: Brandell, Inga , , ed. Strategies and Practices: Workers in Third World Industrialisation . London: Macmillan, forthcoming; 1991.
   Google Scholar
• 1983. Beyond the State? Dominant Theories and Socialist Strategies . London: Macmillan; 1983.
   Google Scholar
• Törnquist, , What's Wrong? . Vol. 1.
   Google Scholar
• 1988. Frontline . 1988, and particularly the computer analysis in Frontline, 18 Apr.-l May.
   Google Scholar
• Frontline .
   Google Scholar
• Törnquist, Olle , 1987. "Krav på fördjupad demokrati i Kerala ledde till valseger". In: Socialistisk Debatt . 1987, Demands for democratisation in Kerala led to electoral victory; no. 5; I am particularly thankful for valuable discussions with senior researchers with the Centre for Development Studies in Trivandrum-Michael Tharakan, Trivandrum, 20 July 1987; John Kurien, Trivandrum, 20 July 1987; and Thomas Issac, Trivandrum, 21 July 1987-as well as with Nalini Nayak, 21 July 1987; and leading intellectual and journalist within the CPI-M in Kerala, Govinda Pillai, Trivandrum, 20 and 23 July 1987; plus with senior anthropologist Richard Franke, Kovalam, 22 July 1987, with experience from Java and recently during the 1987 elections in Kerala.
   Google Scholar
• 1988. Frontline . 1988.
   Google Scholar
• 1988. Peoples' Democracy . 1988.
   Google Scholar