Advanced search
Publication Cover
Accounting History Review Volume 31, 2021 - Issue 3
Submit an article Journal homepage
652
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

The problematical nature of auditor independence: a historical perspective

John Richard Edwardsa Business School, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UKCorrespondence[email protected]
&
Brian Westb Retired, formerly Business School, Federation University Australia, Ballarat, Australia
Pages 255-285 | Received 11 Apr 2019, Accepted 28 Jan 2022, Published online: 19 Feb 2022

References

Parliamentary papers

  • BPP 1844 (119). First Report of the Select Committee on Joint Stock Companies.
  • BPP 1849 (371). First and Second reports from the Select Committee of the House of Lords on Audit of Railway Accounts.
  • BPP 1849 (421). Third Report from the Select Committee of the House of Lords appointed to consider ‘Whether the Railway Acts do not require Amendment, with a view of providing for a more Effectual Audit of Accounts’.
  • BPP 1856. Railway Department, the Board of Trade. Report to the Lords of the Committee of Privy Council for Trade and Foreign Plantations of the Proceedings of the Department Relating to Railways, for the year 1855. London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office.
  • BPP 1888 (406). Report from the Select Committee on Trustee Savings Banks. London: Eyre & Spottiswoode.
  • BPP 1889 (301). Report from the Select Committee on Trustee Savings Banks. London: Eyre & Spottiswoode.
  • BPP 1889 (304). Report from the Select Committee on Friendly Societies Act, 1875. London: Eyre & Spottiswoode.
  • BPP 1890. A Bill to Amend the Law Relating to Trustee Savings Banks.
  • Hansard 1891. Savings Banks Bill. Second Reading. Commons Sitting, 17 March 1891. Vol. 351, cols 1248–1258.

Primary sources

  • Derbyshire Record Office. Staveley Coal and Iron Co Ltd. Directors’ meetings signed minutes, November 1866 – April 1871, D3808/1/2/2. Minutes of general meetings, August 1875 – September 1890, D3808/1/4/2.
  • National Archives. Bolckow Vaughan & Company Ltd. Articles of Association, BT31/30734/1705C.

Other sources

  • 19th Century British Library Newspapers. Gale Cengage Learning. https://www.gale.com/intl/primary-sources/british-library-newspapers.
  • Abbott, A. D. 1988. The System of Professions. An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
  • Aberdeen Railway. 1850. Aberdeen Journal, October 23, issue 5363.
  • A.E. 1883. “Accountants: Their Duties and Responsibilities.” Accountant 9 (422): 4–6.
  • Agra & Masterman’s Bank. 1866. Daily News, March 19, issue 6199.
  • Anderson, M., J. R. Edwards, and D. Matthews. 1996. “A Study of the Quoted Company Audit Market in 1886.” Accounting, Business & Financial History 6 (3): 363–387.
  • Armstrong, P. 1987. “The Rise of Accounting Controls in British Capitalist Enterprises.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 12 (5): 415–436.
  • Armstrong, P. 1991. “Contradiction and Social Dynamics in the Capitalist Agency Relationship.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 16 (1): 1–25.
  • Arnold, A. J., and S. McCartney. 2008. “The Transition to Financial Capitalism and its Implications for Financial Reporting: Evidence from the English Canal Companies.” Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 21 (8): 1185–1209.
  • Audit of Railway Accounts. 1849. Daily News, November 9, issue 1079.
  • Audit Quality Forum. 2005. Audit Quality. Agency Theory and the Role of Audit. Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
  • Auditing Practices Board. 2011. APB Ethical Standard 5 (Revised). Non-audit Services Provided to Audited Entities. http://www.frc.org.uk/Our-Work/Publications/APB/ES-5-(Revised)-Non-audit-services-provided-to-audi.aspx.
  • Barker, T. C. 1960. Pilkington Brothers and the Glass Industry. London: Allen & Unwin.
  • Bazerman, M. H., K. P. Morgan, and G. F. Loewenstein. 1997. “The Impossibility of Auditor Independence.” MIT Sloan Management Review 38 (4): 89–94.
  • Beattie, V., and S. Fearnley. 2002. Auditor Independence and Non-Audit Services: A Literature Review. London: Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.
  • Benson, H. 1989. Accounting for Life. London: Kogan Page.
  • Birmingham Joint-Stock Bank. 1888. Birmingham Daily Post, February 16, issue 9248.
  • Birmingham Wagon Company. 1868. Birmingham Daily Post, February 17, issue 2987.
  • Blay, A. D., and M. A. Geiger. 2013. “Auditor Fees and Auditor Independence: Evidence from Going Concern Reporting Decisions.” Contemporary Accounting Research 30 (2): 579–606.
  • Blough, C. G. 1960. “Responsibility to Third Parties.” Journal of Accountancy 109 (5): 58–65.
  • Boyns, T., and J. R. Edwards. 1997. “The Construction of Cost Accounting Systems in Britain to 1900: The Case of the Coal, Iron and Steel Industries.” Business History 39 (3): 1–29.
  • Bristol & Exeter Railway. 1857. Bristol Mercury, February 28, issue 3493.
  • Bryer, R. A. 2000. “The History of Accounting and the Transition to Capitalism in England. Part Two: Evidence.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 25 (4/5): 327–381.
  • Bryer, R. A. 2006. “Capitalist Accountability and the British Industrial Revolution: The Carron Company, 1759–Circa. 1850.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 31 (8): 687–734.
  • Buffett, W. 1999. “To the Shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc.” http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1998pdf.pdf.
  • Burton, F. G. 1894. “Engineering Cost Accounts.” Engineering, February 23, 240–252.
  • Capital & Counties Bank, Limited. 1883. Hampshire Advertiser, July 28, issue 3873.
  • Capital & Counties Bank, Limited. 1885. Southampton Herald, July 25, issue 4081.
  • Carey, J. L. 1956. Professional Ethics of Certified Public Accountants. New York: American Institute of Accountants.
  • Carnegie, G., and C. Napier. 1996. “Critical and Interpretive Histories: Insights into Accounting’s Present and Future Through Its Past.” Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 9 (3): 7–39.
  • Cooper, D. J., and D. Neu. 2006. “Auditor and Audit Independence in an Age of Financial Scandals.” Advances in Public Interest Accounting 12: 1–15.
  • Chandler, R. A., and J. R. Edwards. 1996. “Recurring Issues in Auditing: Back to the Future?” Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 9 (2): 4–29.
  • Chandler, R. A., J. R. Edwards, and M. Anderson. 1993. “Changing Perceptions of the Role of the Company Auditor, 1840-1940.” Accounting and Business Research 23 (92): 443–459.
  • Chester & Holyhead. 1853. Morning Chronicle, March 10, issue 26898.
  • Competition Commission. 2013. Statutory Audit Services Market Investigation. February 22. https://assets.digital.cabinet-office.gov.uk/media/5329db3240f0b60a73000023/pfs_summary.pdf/.
  • Cooper, E. 1886. “Chartered Accountants as Auditors of Companies.” Accountant 12 (623): 644–649.
  • Coventry Machinists Company. 1894. Birmingham Daily Post, January 30, issue 11112.
  • Crewdson, E. 1902. “Codification of an Audit.” Accountant 28 (1420): 214–219.
  • Dattin, C. F. 2014. “The Practice of Statutory Auditing in France (1867-1935). The Case of Pont-à-Mousson and Saint-Gobain Companies.” Accounting History 19 (3): 351–368.
  • DeFond, M., and J. Zhang. 2014. “A Review of Archival Auditing Research.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 58 (2-3): 275–326.
  • de Paula, F. R. M. 1915. The Principles of Auditing. A Practical Manual for Students and Practitioners. London: Pitman.
  • Dicksee, L. R. 1892. Auditing: A Practical Manual for Auditors. London: Gee.
  • Dicksee, L. R. 1912. Auditing: A Practical Manual for Auditors. 9th ed. London: Gee.
  • Dopuch, N., R. R. King, and R. Schwartz. 2003. “Independence in Appearance and in Fact: An Experimental Investigation.” Contemporary Accounting Research 20 (1): 79–114.
  • Edwards, J. R. 1976. “The Accounting Profession and Disclosure in Published Reports, 1925-1935.” Accounting and Business Research 6 (24): 289–303.
  • Edwards, J. R. 1985. “The Origins and Evolution of the Double Account System: An Example of Accounting Innovation.” Abacus 21 (1): 19–43.
  • Edwards, J. R. 2019. A History of Corporate Financial Reporting in Britain. New York: Routledge.
  • Edwards, J. R., M. Anderson, and R. Chandler. 2007. “Claiming a Jurisdiction for the ‘Public Accountant’ in England Prior to Organisational Fusion.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 32 (1-2): 61–100.
  • European Commission. 2011. Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Specific Requirements Regarding Statutory Audit of Public-Interest Entities. Brussels: European Commission.
  • Financial Reporting Council. 2006. Key Facts and Trends in the Accountancy Profession. London: Financial Reporting Council.
  • Financial Reporting Council. 2013. Scope and Authority of Audit and Assurance Pronouncements. London: Financial Reporting Council.
  • Financial Reporting Council. 2021. Key Facts and Trends in the Accountancy Profession. London: Financial Reporting Council.
  • General Stock Exchange. 1883. Morning Post, October 30, issue 34742.
  • Glasgow, Paisley, & Greenock Railway. 1850. Glasgow Herald, September 13, issue 4969.
  • Grace, Darbyshire & Todd. 1957. A Short History of Grace, Darbyshire & Todd Chartered Accountants of Bristol 1818-1957. Bristol: Grace, Darbyshire & Todd.
  • Great Ship Company. 1859. Daily News, December 14, issue 4239.
  • Great Western Railway. 1850. Bristol Mercury, August 17, issue 3152.
  • Howitt, H. G. 1966. The History of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales 1880–1965 and of its Founder Accountancy Bodies 1870–1880. London: Heinemann.
  • Humphrey, C. 2008. “Auditing Research: A Review across the Disciplinary Divide.” Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 21 (2): 170–203.
  • Jones, E. 1981. Accountancy and the British Economy 1840-1980: The Evolution of Ernst & Whinney. London: Batsford.
  • Jones, E. 1995. True and Fair. A History of Price Waterhouse. London: Hamish Hamilton.
  • Jones, E., ed. 1988. The Memoirs of Edwin Waterhouse. A Founder of Price Waterhouse. London: Batsford.
  • Kemp, C. F. 1875. “Fourth Annual General Meeting of the Institute of Accountants.” Accountant 1 (21): 4–5.
  • Larson, M. S. 1977. The Rise of Professionalism. A Sociological Analysis. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
  • Leading Article. 1875a. Accountant 1 (9): 2–3.
  • Leading Article. 1875b. “Auditors. No. 2 – (Their Duties).” Accountant 1 (10): 4.
  • Leading Article. 1875c. Accountant 1 (22): 2–3.
  • Levitt, A. 2000. “Speech by SEC Chairman: A Profession at the Crossroads.” U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. http://www.sec.gov/news/speech/spch399.htm.
  • Liverpool Savings Bank. 1888. Liverpool Mercury, July 25, issue 12649.
  • Local and District News. 1857. Cheshire Observer, January 3, issue 139.
  • London General Omnibus Company. 1859. Daily News, December 16, issue 4241.
  • London Joint-Stock Bank. 1879. Pall Mall Gazette, January 16, issue 4338.
  • London & North Western Railway. 1850. Standard, February 23, issue 7967.
  • London & North Western. 1850a. Morning Post, February 16, issue 23772.
  • London & North Western. 1850b. Morning Post, August 10, issue 23921.
  • London & South Western. 1850. Daily News, February 4, issue 1152.
  • London & Westminster Bank. 1879. Morning Post, January 16, issue 33246.
  • Maltby, J. 1999. “‘A Sort of Guide, Philosopher and Friend’: The Rise of the Professional Auditor in Britain.” Accounting, Business & Financial History 9 (1): 29–50.
  • Maltby, J., and R. Chandler. 2020. “Auditing.” In Routledge Companion to Accounting History, edited by J. R. Edwards, and S. P. Walker, 252–275. London: Routledge.
  • Manchester, Sheffield, & Lincolnshire Railway Company. 1857. Daily News, January 14, issue 3327.
  • Mather, J. 1898. “The Influence of the Accountancy Profession in the Commercial Sphere.” Accountant 24 (1246): 999–1005.
  • Matthews, D. 2006. A History of Auditing: The Changing Audit Process in Britain from the Nineteenth Century to the Present Day. London: Routledge.
  • Matthews, D., and J. Pirie. 2001. The Auditors Talk. An Oral History of a Profession from the 1920s to the Present Day. New York: Garland Publishing.
  • Matthews, D., M. Anderson, and J. R. Edwards. 1998. The Priesthood of Industry. The Rise of the Professional Accountant in British Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • McMillan, S. J. 1997. “The Audit-Auditor Ideal: A Positive Image for British Accountants, 1875–1890.” Paper presented at the 20th European Accounting Association Annual Congress, University of Graz, Graz.
  • MeasuringWorth. 2021. “Purchasing Power of British Pounds from 1270 to Present.” https://www.measuringworth.com/ppoweruk/.
  • Meetings of Joint Stock Banks. 1879. Pall Mall Gazette, January 16, issue 4338.
  • Miller, P., and C. Napier. 1993. “Genealogies of Calculation.” Accounting, Organizations and Society 18 (7/8): 631–647.
  • Mitchell, A., and P. Sikka. 1993. “Accounting for Change: The Institutions of Accountancy.” Critical Perspectives on Accounting 4 (1): 29–52.
  • Moore, D. A., P. E. Tetlock, L. Tanlu, and M. H. Bazerman. 2006. “Conflicts of Interest and the Case of Auditor Independence: Moral Seduction and Strategic Issue Cycling.” Academy of Management Review 31 (1): 10–29.
  • Old Union Mill Flour & Bread Company. 1872. Birmingham Daily Post, April 29, issue 4301.
  • Parker, R. H. 1986. The Development of the Accountancy Profession in Britain to the Early Twentieth Century. Atlanta, GA: The Academy of Accounting Historians.
  • Pixley, F. W. 1881. Auditors: Their Duties and Responsibilities. London: Effingham Wilson.
  • Pixley, F. W. 1882. “The Joint Stock Companies’ Acts and Auditors.” Accountant 8 (374): 4–5.
  • Pixley, F. W. 1922. The Accountant’s Dictionary. London: Waverley Book Company.
  • Popp, A. 2000. “Specialty Production, Personal Capitalism and Auditors’ Reports: Mintons Ltd, c.1870-1900.” Accounting, Business & Financial History 10 (3): 347–369.
  • Porter, B., J. Simon, and D. Hatherly. 2014. Principles of External Auditing. 4th ed. Chichester, UK: Wiley.
  • Poullaos, C., and C. Ramirez. 2020. “Professionalisation.” In Routledge Companion to Accounting History, edited by J. R. Edwards, and S. P. Walker, 279–306. London: Routledge.
  • PwC. 2017. “Who We Are.” http://www.pwc.co.uk/who-we-are/index-more.html.
  • Reiter, S. A., and P. F. Williams. 2004. “The Philosophy and Rhetoric of Auditor Independence Concepts.” Business Ethics Quarterly 14 (3): 355–376.
  • Robb, G. 1992. White-Collar Crime in Modern England: Financial Fraud and Morality, 1845-1929. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Searcy, D. L., and J. B. Woodroof. 2003. “Continuous Auditing: Leveraging Technology.” CPA Journal 73 (5): 46–48.
  • Second Freeholder Building Society. 1873. Birmingham Daily Post, April 10, issue 4598.
  • Securities and Exchange Commission. 2000. Proposed Rule: Revision of the Commission's Auditor Independence Requirements. https://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/34-42994.htm.
  • South Eastern. 1849. Daily News, September 21, issue 1037.
  • Spicer, E. E., and E. C. Pegler. 1914. Practical Auditing. 2nd ed. London: H. Foulks Lynch.
  • The Times Digital Archive 1785–1985. Gale Cengage Learning.
  • Union Bank of Scotland. 1879. Glasgow Herald, April 24, issue 12274.
  • Waldron, R. S. 1969. Dicksee’s Auditing. 18th ed. London: Gee.
  • Walker, S. P. 1996. “The Criminal Upperworld and the Emergence of a Disciplinary Code in the Early Chartered Accountancy Profession.” Accounting History 1 (2): 7–35.
  • Wallace, W. A. 1980. The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets. Rochester, NY: University of Rochester.
  • Wallace, W. A. 2004. “The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets: A Look Back and a Look Forward.” Research in Accounting Regulation 17: 267–298.
  • Watson Sime, T. 1892. “Fraud and Error in Books and Accounts.” Accountant 18 (911): 426–431.
  • Watts, R. L., and J. L. Zimmerman. 1979. “The Demand for and Supply of Accounting Theories: The Market for Excuses.” Accounting Review 54 (2): 273–305.
  • Weekly Notes. 1897. “Continuous Audits.” Accountant 17 (892): 805–806.
  • West India and Pacific Steamship Company. 1864. Liverpool Daily Post, 22 November, issue 2927.
  • Whinney, F. 1887. “President’s Address to the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales.” Accountant 13 (656): 386–390.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Supercharge Your Next Research Paper: Research and write your next paper with Jenni AI.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.