The Politics of Multiple Identities: Lineage and Ethnicity in Kazakhstan

References

• Young , Crawford , ed. 1993 . “ 'The Demise of an Empire-State: Identity, Legitimacy, and the Deconstruction of Soviet Politics' ” . In The Rising Tide of Cultural Pluralism: The Nation-State at Bay? , Madison : University of Wisconsin Press . Mark Beissinger gives us good reason to distinguish Russian overland imperialism from more traditional overseas imperialism. See his). Of all the regions that came under Russian imperial control, Central Asia had the most classically colonial relationship to Russia, given the rapidity of conquest of the region and the exploitation of this peripheral region's raw materials
   Google Scholar
• Young , Crawford . 1994 . The African Colonial State in Comparative Perspective , New Haven : Yale .
   Google Scholar
• Akbarzadeh , Shahram . 1996 . 'Why Did Nationalism Fail in Tajikistan?' . Europe-Asia Studies , 48 ( 7 ) : 1105 – 1129 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lewis , I. M. 1994 . Blood and Bone: The Call of Kinship in Somali Society , Lawrenceville , NJ : Red Sea Press .
   Google Scholar
• Gurr , Ted Robert . 1993 . Minorities At Risk , Washington, DC : United States Institute for Peace . Work derived from Gurr's enormous Minorities at Risk data-set is one example of this tendency. See
   Google Scholar
• presented at the annual meetings of the Association for the Study of Nationalities . 17 April . Columbia University . I would like to thank Mark Beissinger, Bhavna Dave, Martha Merritt, Michael Schatzberg, Crawford Young and several anonymous reviewers from Europe-Asia Studies for their perceptive comments on previous versions of this article. In its earlier stages, the article was and the American Political Science Association (Atlanta, 3 September 1999). Research for the article was supported by a grant from the International Research and Exchanges Board (IREX), with funds provided from the National Endowment for the Humanities and the US Department of State. The author alone is responsible for the views expressed
   Google Scholar
• Brubaker , Rogers . 1996 . Refraining Nationalism , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Brubaker, Refraining Nationalism, p. 5.
   Google Scholar
• Suny , Ronald . 1993 . The Revenge of the Past: Nationalism, Revolution, and the Collapse of the Soviet Union , Stanford : Stanford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Slezkine , Yuri . 1994 . 'The USSR as Communal Apartment, or How a Socialist State Promoted Ethnic Particularism' . Slavic Review , 53 : 414 – 453 . and Brubaker, Refraining Nationalism
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gurr, Minorities At Risk.
   Google Scholar
• Horowitz , Donald . 1985 . Ethnic Groups in Conflict , 563 – 684 . Berkeley : University of California .
   Google Scholar
• Lijphart , Arend . 1977 . Democracy in Plural Societies , New Haven : Yale University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Young , Crawford . 1993 . “ 'The Dialectics of Cultural Pluralism' ” . In The Rising Tide of Cultural Pluralism: The Nation-State at Bay? , Edited by: Young , Crawford . Madison : University of Wisconsin Press . For an important overview of trends in the literature on ethnicity and cultural pluralism see
   Google Scholar
• Shryock , Andrew . 1996 . 'Tribes and the Print Trade: Notes from the Margins of Literate Culture in Jordan' . American Anthropologist , 98 ( 1 ) : 26 – 40 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Andaya , Barbara Watson and Andaya , Leonard Y. 1982 . A History of Malaysia , London : Macmillan . In this sense, its post-colonial nation-building experience might be fruitfully compared with that of Malaysia. See
   Google Scholar
• Stafford , Geoffrey . 1998 . “ 'Ethnicity in the Age of Globalization: Economic Development Policy in Multi-Ethnic Malaysia' ” . University of Wisconsin-Madison . unpublished PhD dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Schatz , Edward A. D. 1999 . 'Notes on the "Dog that Didn't Bark": Eco-Internationalism in Late Soviet Kazakstan' . Ethnic and Racial Studies , 22 ( 1 ) January : 136 – 161 . On some of the political implications of this internationalism for social mobilisation see
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Nazarbaev , Nursultan . 1997 . Strategiya--2030: poslanie Prezidenta strany narodu Kazakhstana , 104 Almaty : Bilim . Some of the historically sedentary areas of what is today southern Kazakhstan were on the northern fringe of this trading corridor; the Silk Route is less central to a history of the areas that today comprise Kazakhstan than to a history of those regions that today comprise Uzbekistan and Tajikistan. This fact did not prevent Nazarbaev from appropriating it for its symbolic value
   Google Scholar
• Levkovsky , Al'bert Grigor'evich . 1998 . 'Qazaqstan--mening ekinshi otanym' . Turkistan , 29 April-5 May All translations from Russian and Kazakh are the author's
   Google Scholar
• A dangerous economic contraction in the post-Soviet period, broad-scale privatisation of state industries, the geographical contiguity of colonising power and colonised region, among other factors, also distinguish the Kazakhstani case from the Malaysian case. See Andaya & Andaya, A History of Malaysia; and Stafford, 'Ethnicity in the Age of Globalization'.
   Google Scholar
• Nazarbaev , Nursultan . 1996 . Na poroge XXI veka , 104 – 105 . Almaty : Oner .
   Google Scholar
• Qozha-Akhmet , Khasen . 1996 . 'Oqighany kim uimdastyrdy?' . Ana tili , 21 November : 6
   Google Scholar
• Bazarbaev , M. 1992 . '"Kazakhstanskaya pravda" seet vrazhdu?' . Kazakhstanskaya pravda , 8 August : 3
   Google Scholar
• See Laitin, Identity in Formation, for a comparative analysis of the politics of language revival in the former USSR.
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . O yazykakh v Respublike Kazakhstan , 25 Almaty : Zheti Zharghy .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 24.
   Google Scholar
• Masanov , Nurbulat and Savin , Igor . 1997 . Model' etnopoliticheskogo monitoringa: Kazakhstan , 71 Moscow and Almaty : MOST .
   Google Scholar
• Nauryzbai , Zh. 1997 . 'Etnokul'turnoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane' . Mysl' (Almaty) , 9 : 65 – 75 . The data presented here on language use in education come from
   Google Scholar
• Savin , Igor . 1998 . “ 'Spetsifika osushchestvelniya i rezul'taty kul'turno-yazykovoi i obrazovatel'noi politiki v Kazakhstane' ” . 13 Kazakhstan Academy of Sciences . unpublished paper (Shymkent branch,
   Google Scholar
• Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty electronic report--Kazakh Service, 20 January 1999.
   Google Scholar
• Dave, 'The Politics of Language Revival', for a full account of how the large numbers of russified Kazakhs significantly alter the dynamic of what otherwise might be viewed as a simple bi-ethnic linguistic 'tipping game'. Most of the data presented by Laitin, Identity in Formation, on Kazakhstan come from Dave's field-work.
   Google Scholar
• Dave, 'The Politics of Language Revival'.
   Google Scholar
• Masanov and Savin . Model' etnopoliticheskogo monitoringa 35
   Google Scholar
• Conversation with the editors of the newspaper Yuzhnyi variant (Shymkent), 25 May 1998.
   Google Scholar
• Askar Kumakovich Tulegulov, Rekrutirovanie politicheskoi elity v usloviyakh transformatsii Kazakhstanskogo obshchestva, kandidat dissertation (Almaty, Institut Razvitiya Kazakhstana), 1998, p. 88.
   Google Scholar
• Gregory Gleason & Gulnara Dadabaeva ask whether the technocratic or the ethnic principle is more significant in their 'The Ethnic Factor in Government Reform in Kazakhstan', paper presented at the meeting of the American Political Science Association (Boston, MA), 2-4 September 1998.
   Google Scholar
• Stafford, 'Ethnicity in the Age of Globalization'.
   Google Scholar
• Mendikulova , G. M. 1998 . Istoricheskie sud'by Kazakhskoi diaspory , Almaty : Ghylym .
   Google Scholar
• Tatimov , Maqash . 1993 . Qazaq alemi: qazaqtyng sany qansha? , Almaty : Atamura-Qazaqstan .
   Google Scholar
• Kolsto , Pal . 1998 . 'Anticipating Demographic Superiority: Kazakh Thinking on Integration and Nation-Building' . Europe-Asia Studies , 50 ( 1 ) : 51 – 69 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• The image was one of Kazakhs as a monolithic unit standing in opposition to other groups. The internal divisions among Kazakhs, especially along linguistic lines, were routinely left out of this understanding of majoritarian democracy. See Dave, 'The Politics of Language Revival'.
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . Mestnoe vremya (Mangystau oblast') , 9 December : 3
   Google Scholar
• Naumova , Ol'ga . 1992 . “ 'Nekotorye aspekty formirovaniya sovremennoi bytovoi kul'tury Kazakhov v mnogonatsional'nykh raionakh Kazakhstana' ” . In Sovremennoe razvitie etnicheskikh grupp Srednei Azii i Kazakhstana , Edited by: Zhilina , A. and Cheshko , S. Moscow : Institut etnologii i antropologii . For a perceptive ethnography of such multi-ethnic rural locales, see
   Google Scholar
• 1995 . Kontseptsiya stanovleniya istoricheskogo soznaniya v Respublike Kazakhstan Almaty
   Google Scholar
• Kekilbaev , Abish . 1998 . Secretary of State, Republic of Kazakhstan, 'Vozrozhdenie istoricheskoi pamyati--put' k obshchestvennomu vozrozhdeniyu' . Kazakhstanskaya pravda , 9 January
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . Konstitutsiya Respubliki Kazakhstan , 9 Almaty : Zheti Zharghy .
   Google Scholar
• Savin , Igor . 1998 . “ 'O kategoriyakh gruppovogo soznaniya u Kazakhov-kochevnikov' ” . 6 Shymkent branch : Kazakhstan Academy of Sciences . unpublished paper
   Google Scholar
• Kunaev , Dinmukhammed . 1992 . O moem vremeni 10 – 11 . Almaty This mode of introducing oneself stands in contrast to alternatives that emphasise physical location and geographical landmarks, as well as to those which centre on the person's given name understood as separate from family lineage
   Google Scholar
• Masanov , Nurbulat . 1995 . Kochevaya tsivilizatsiya Kazakhov , Almaty : Sotsinvest . By suggesting that segmentation was a necessary, functional response of nomadic societies to harsh ecological conditions,
   Google Scholar
• Evans-Pritchard , E. E. 1940 . The Nuer: A Description of the Modes of Livelihood and Political Institutions of a Niolitic People , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Nurkadilov , Zamanbek . 1996 . Ne tol'ko o sebe , 11 Almaty : Shartarap .
   Google Scholar
• Qudaiberdy-uly , Shakarim . 1992 . Rodoslovnaya Tyurkov, Kirgizov, Kazakhov i khanskikh dinastii , Edited by: Kairbekov , Bakhyt . Alma-Ata : Zhazushy .
   Google Scholar
• Sadibekov , Zaiyr . 1994 . Qazaq shezhiresi , Tashkent : Uzbekiston .
   Google Scholar
• Sariev , Izturghan . 1997 . Ush zhuzding shezhiresi , Almaty : Olke .
   Google Scholar
• Serikbaiuly . 1992 . Kongyrattyng shezhiresi Almaty
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . Qazaq adebieti , 18 February : 3
   Google Scholar
• Gellner , Ernest . 1990 . “ 'Tribalism and the State in the Middle East' ” . In Tribes and State Formation in the Middle East , Edited by: Khoury , Philip S. and Kostiner , Joseph . Berkeley : University of California Press .
   Google Scholar
• Masanov , Nurbulat . 1998 . 'Migratsii v Kazakhstane: istoriya, problema i metod' . paper presented at Soros Foundation seminar on interethnic relations . March 25 1998 , Almaty . pp. 19
   Google Scholar
• Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty-Kazakh Service, 8 January 1998.
   Google Scholar
• National Statistical Agency, p. 12.
   Google Scholar
• Alekseenko , Aleksandr . 1998 . “ 'Etnodemograficheskie protsessy i emigratsiya iz suverennogo Kazakhstana: prichiny i perspektivy' ” . In Sovremennye etnopoliticheskie protsessy i migratsionnaya situatsiya v tsentral'noi azii , Edited by: Vitkovskaya , Galina . 106 Moscow : Carnegie Endowment for International Peace .
   Google Scholar
• 1999 . Perepis' naseleniya, Pervaya natsional'naya perepis' naseleniya v Respublike Kazakhstan: predvaritel'nye rezul'taty 23 Almaty
   Google Scholar
• Daniyarov , K. 1998 . Al'ternativnaya istoriya Kazakhstana , 175 Almaty : Zhibek zholy .
   Google Scholar
• For manifestations of this trend in other contexts see Verdery, What Was Socialism and What Comes Next?; and Shnirelman, Who Gets the Past?.
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . Novoe pokolenie (Almaty) , 19-26 April : 11
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Dzhezkazganskaya pravda , 19 November : 3
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . Tsentral'nyi Kazakhstan (Dzhezkazgan) , 26 June : 1
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . Industrial'naya Karaganda (Karaganda) , 6 March : 1
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . Mestnoe vremya (Aktau) , 9 December : 3
   Google Scholar
• Saduakasov , A. and Bolgozhina , A. 1994 . 'Sokhranim svyaz' vremen' . Madeniet (Semei) , 4 15-28 February : 11
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Kazakhstanskaya pravda , 31 October : 2
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Kazakhstanskaya pravda , 14 August
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Tselinogradskaya pravda , 8 June
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Tselinogradskaya pravda , 23 May
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Tselinogradskaya pravda , 12 June
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Kyzylordinskie vesti , 7 May : 3
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . Akmolinskaya pravda , 23 November : 4
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . Mestnoe vremya (Aktau) , 27 January : 2
   Google Scholar
• Swidler , Ann . 1986 . 'Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies' . American Sociological Review , 51 : 273 – 286 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar