“You take your oath only once:” Crimea, the black sea fleet, and national identity among Russian officers

References

• Simonsen , Sven Gunnar . 1999 . "Inheriting the Soviet Policy Toolbox. Russia's Dilemma Over Ascriptive Nationality" . Europe-Asia Studies , 51 ( 6 ) : 1069 – 1087 . Russian ethnicity is as a rule here used to describe those with russkiy listed in their "point five" in official documents; the so-called "passport nationality." For a detailed discussion of the issue of nationality in the Soviet Union and Russia, see
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Szporluk , Roman . 1994 . "Statehood and Nation Building in Post-Soviet Space" ” . In Nation, Identity and Ethnicity in Russia and the New States of Eurasia , Edited by: Szporluk , R. 9 Armonk , NY : M. E. Sharpe .
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . Figures from The Military Balance 1993-1994 , 103 London : International Institute for Strategic Studies . The Fleet counted 21 submarines, 35 principal surface combatants and some 240 other surface ships; as well as other forces, including naval aviation (some 244 combat aircraft and 85 combat helicopters), naval infantry and coastal defense forces
   Google Scholar
• Huntington , Samuel P. 1957 [1985] . The Soldier and the State. The Theory and Politics of Civil-Military Relations , 79 London : Belknap Press of Harvard University . Among the classic works in this field, see
   Google Scholar
• Perlmutter , Amos . 1977 . The Military and Politics in Modern Times. On Professionals, Praetorians, and Revolutionary Soldiers , 2 New Haven : Yale University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Markus , Ustina . 1995 . "Black Sea Fleet Dispute Apparently Over" . Transition , 1 ( 13 ) : 30 – 34 . For a more detailed chronology up to this event, see
   Google Scholar
• Baranovsky , Vladimir . 1998 . "Russia: Conflicts and Peaceful Settlement of Disputes" ” . In SIPRI Yearbook 1998 , 118 – 120 . Oxford : Oxford University Press . The current state of Crimea and the BSF in Russian-Ukrainian relations was defined in May 1997. On 28 May, the prime ministers of the two countries signed three agreements related to the BSF issue: on the division of the fleet, on Russia's rights to bases in Crimea, and on debt settlement. The parties agreed that Russia's fleet would remain based in Sevastopol, leasing facilities there for 20 years. Then, on 31 May, Presidents Yeltsin and Kuchma signed a Treaty on Friendship, Cooperation and Partnership, declaring respect for the respective countries' territorial integrity. Both countries' federal assemblies have since ratified these agreements. For a brief outline of the agreements
   Google Scholar
• Sherr , James . 1997 . "Russia-Ukraine Rapprochement The Black Sea Fleet Accords" . Survival , 39 ( 3 ) : 33 – 50 . A thorough analysis is provided in
   Google Scholar
• ToIz , Vera . 1998 . "Conflicting 'Homelands Myths' and Nation-State Building in Postcommurrist Russia" . Slavic Review , 57 ( 2 ) : 283 Starovoitova and Tishkov both had left the Yeltsin team by the end of 1992
   Google Scholar
• Galeotti , Mark . 1995 . The Age of Anxiety. Security and Politics in Soviet and Post-Soviet Russia , 153 New York : Longman .
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Galina Starovoytova: Mistakes Are Costly" . Krasnaya zvezda , 22 January FBIS-SOV92-016
   Google Scholar
• Solchanyk , Roman . 1992 . "Ukrainian-Russian Confrontation over the Crimea" . RFE/RL Research Report , 10 February : 26 IR920096.RIR
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Krym v fevrale 1954 goda" . Moskovskie novosti , 2 February This article also features the brief decree from the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Soviet on the transfer
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . Chernomorskoy Flat, gorod Sevastopol i nekotorye problemy rossiysko-ukrainskikh otnosheniy. Khronika, dbkumenty, analiz, mneniya (1991-1997 gg.) , 25 Moscow : Nezavisimaya gazeta . "Postanovlenie Verkhovnogo Soveta Rossiyskoy Federatsii. O pravovoy otsenke resheniy vysshikh organov gosudarstvennoy vlasti RSFSR po izmenrriyu statusa Kryma, prinyatykh v 1954 gody." Reprinted
   Google Scholar
• Solchanyk , Roman . 1992 . "The Crimean Imbroglio: Kiev and Moscow" . RFE/RL Research Report , 9 October : 6
   Google Scholar
• Solchanyk , Roman . 1992 . "Ukrainian-Russian Confrontation over the Crimea" . RFE/RL Research Report , 10 February : 26
   Google Scholar
• Larrabee , Stephen F. and Karasik , Theodore W. 1997 . Foreign and Security Policy Decisionmaking under Yeltsin , Santa Monica : National Defense Research Institute/ RAND . For an examination of the role of key institutions in the formation of Russian foreign and security policy, see
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Nasha Rossiya-Vestnik FNS , 21 (45)
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Dagens Neeringsliv , 3 December Estimate made by Associated Press, quoted in
   Google Scholar
• ManifestFronta Natsionalnogo Spaseniya (1992).
   Google Scholar
• Alksnis , Viktor . 1993 . Vystoim i pobedim , 9 Moscow : SSSR (sic) .
   Google Scholar
• Dawson , Jane I. 1997 . "Ethnicity, Ideology and Geopolitics in Crimea" . Communist and Post-Communist Studies , 30 ( 4 ) : 433 Under Kruglov, the FNS has been described as displaying "little caution in dealing with sensitive ethnic and geopolitical issues and [Kruglov's] statements have been highly incendiary"
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sherr , James . 1994 . "Russia's Elections-the Military Implications" . Jane's Intelligence Review , February : 67 – 68 . For an analysis of the military's vote
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 12 August
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 12 July
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Malcolm , Neil and Pravda , Alex . 1996 . "Introduction" ” . In Internal Factors in Russian Foreign Policy , Edited by: Malcolm , Neil , Pravda , Alex , Allison , Roy and Light , Margot . Oxford : Oxford University Press . For a convincing analysis of phases in the regime's foreign policy, see
   Google Scholar
• Melvin , Neil J. 1998 . “ 'The Russians: Diaspora and the End of Empire" ” . In Nations Abroad. Diaspora Politics and International Relations in the Former Soviet Union , Edited by: King , Charles and Melvin , Neil J. Boulder : Westview Press . For a parallel analysis of policy phases related to the diaspora issue
   Google Scholar
• Melvin , Neil . 1994 . Forging the New Russian Nation. Russian Foreign Policy and the Russian-Speaking Communities of the Former USSR , Russian and CIS Programme Discussion Paper 50 17 – 22 . London : Royal Institute of Internationa] Affairs . A detailed discussion of the different definitions of Russianness that were employed is provided in
   Google Scholar
• Simonsen , S. G. 1996 . "Raising 'the Russian Question': Ethnicity and Statehood-Russkie and Rossiya" . Nationalism and Ethnic Politics , 2 ( 1 ) : 91 – 110 . These terms are also discussed in
   Google Scholar
• 1991 . Figures from Natsionalnyy sostav naseleniya SSSR , 82 Moscow : Goskomstat SSSR, Finansy i statistika . As for other groups, the number of Crimean Tatars was 38, 000; of Belarusians 50, 000
   Google Scholar
• Bremmer , Ian . 1993 . "Ethnic Issues in Crimea" . RFE/RL Research Report , 2 ( 18 ) : 25 Within a few years, the return of Tatars brought the number much higher; by 1992, it was estimated at 210, 000
   Google Scholar
• Zevelev , Igor . 1996 . "Russia and the Russian Diasporas" . Post-Soviet Affairs , 12 ( 3 ) : 266 – 272 . The treaty involving Tajikistan has not been ratified by Russia. For an in-depth discussion of the issue of dual citizenship, see
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . "My vsegda otkryty dlya vsekh" . Oppozitsiya ,
   Google Scholar
• Dunlop , John B. 1993 . "Russia: Confronting a Loss of Empire" ” . In Nation and Politics in the Soviet Successor States , Edited by: Bremmer , Ian and Taras , Ray . 58 – 60 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . For a discussion of this work
   Google Scholar
• Baev , Pavel . 1996 . The Russian Army in a Time of Troubles , London : Sage/PRIO . The best study of Russian military policy in the "near abroad" and the Russian military in general is
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Ofitserskoe sobranie nastaivaet na edinstsve vooruzhermykh sil" . Izvestiya , 18 January
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Manevry vokrug ochen vooruzhennykh sil" . Izvestiya , 20 January
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Russian Press Digest , 14 February Krasnaya Zvezda, as reported by
   Google Scholar
• Stolyarov , Nikolay . 1992 . "Integratsiya tak zhe tsenna, kak i nezavisimost" . Izvestiya , 16 January Stolyarov was an aide to the Commander in Chief of the CIS forces, and chairman of the personnel committee
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Soviet Officers Start Political Movement; Aim Is to Preserve Military Unity, Benefits" . Washington Post , 17 January
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Lopatin , Vladimir . 1992 . "Zashchitit Ii krasnaya armiya belyy dom" . Izvestiya , 13 February
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Voennaya Mysl , May The doctrine was published in a special issue of
   Google Scholar
• Dick , Charles J. 1992 . "Initial Thoughts on Russia's Draft Military Doctrine" . Journal of Slavic Military Studies , 5 ( 4 ) : 553
   Google Scholar
• Greene , James M. 1993 . "The Peacekeeping Doctrines of the CIS" . Jane's Intelligence Review , 5 ( 4 )
   Google Scholar
• Dick . 1994 . "The Military Doctrine of the Russian Federation" . Jane's Intelligence Review , 6 ( 1 ) Dick speculated that differences between the 1992 draft and this doctrine could be explained by the fact that the General Staff had a heavy influence on the earlier one, whereas the latter was mainly the work of the MO
   Google Scholar
• Dick, ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Jones , Ellen . 1985 . Red Army and Society. A Sociology of the Soviet Military , 180 – 209 . Boston : Unwin Hyman . For a thorough examination of the relationship between Slavs and non-Slavs within the Soviet armed forces
   Google Scholar
• Stalbo , Vice-Admiral Kazimir . 1993 . "Prestuplenie veka; obekt i podelniki" . Rossiyskaya gazeta , 24 June Another example of Rossiyskaya gazeta publishing articles at odds with goverment policy over Crimea is the Academy of Sciences member Georgiy Shakhazarov's flaming article "Mne stydno za Prezidenta" ("I Am Ashamed of the President"), published on 29 June 1993, as a response to Yeltsin's criticism of the Supreme Soviet
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "Sevastopol-gorod rossiyskiy" . Pravda , 22 June
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Dlya chego perevozit chto-to iz Rossii v Rossiyu?" . Nezavisimaya gazeta , 7 April
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Itar-Tass , 5 October FBIS-SOV-92-194
   Google Scholar
• Parrish , Scott . 1995 . "Admiral Eduard Baltin: Presiding Reluctantly over the Fleet's Division" . Transition , 1 ( 13 ) : 32 For a profile of Baltin, see
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "I snova predshtormovaya pogoda" . Rossiya , 12-18 May
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . Interfax , 14 October FBIS-SOV-93-199
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Ethnic Turmoil Tears Apart Armed Forces" . The Independent , 12 January At this point. Admiral Kasatonov stated that Ukrainians accounted for 1996 of the officers and 30 of the seamen and petty officers of the BSF
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Troops Begin to Take the Oath on Ukrainian Territory" . Izvestiya , 7 January FBIS-SOV-92-004
   Google Scholar
• Klyamkin , I. , Lapkin , V. and Pantin , V. 1994 . Politicheskiy kurs B. Eltsina: predvaritelnye itogi , 70 – 71 . Moscow : Fond "Obshchestvennoe mnenie" . Two other positions that may also be identified above all with the policies of Vladimir Zhirinovskiy, the winner of the Duma election four months earlier, also scored particularly well in the military. The first was the elimination of the current ethno-territorial divisions of the state for one of a territorial-administrativesystem. Here, the officers were among the top categories, scoring 26, compared with the average 14. The position that Russia should be "cleansed" of aliens (inorodtsy) was supported more by officers than by any other group: 23 versus the 16 average
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Ukraine: The Crimean Question" . The Economist , 11 January
   Google Scholar
• Oldberg , Ingemar . 1996 . "Vad hande med Svarthavsflottan?" . Intemationella Studier , : 12 Establishing beyond doubt the details of the financing of the BSF is very difficult for several reasons; some sources claim Ukraine still made some contributions
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 24 August
   Google Scholar
• Ustina , Markus . 1995 . "Ukraine: Stability amid Political Turnover" . Transition , 15 February : 70
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Black Sea Fleet-An Insoluble Problem?" . Moscow News , 15 January
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Agreements Say One Thing, but Another Is Actually Done" . Krasnaya zvezda , 26 February FBIS-SOV-92-042
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . 'O chem zabyl mayor Astakhov" . Izvestiya , 3 March
   Google Scholar
• Duncan , Peter J. S. 1996 . "Ukraine and the Ukrainians" ” . In The Nationalities Question in the post-Soviet States, , 2nd edn , Edited by: Smith , Graham . 201 London : Longman .
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . Financial Times , 11 July as reported in SIPRI Yearbook 1993
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . World Armaments and Disarmament , 184 London : SIPRI/Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . TASS , 29 January
   Google Scholar
• Klyamkin , I. , Lapkin , V. and Pantin , V. 1994 . Politicheskiy kurs B. Eltsina: predvaritelnye itogi , 70 – 71 . Moscow : Fond "Obshchestvennoe mnenie" .
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "I. Kapitanets: Kak skazal Eltsin, "Chernomorskiy flot byl, est i budet rossiyskim" . Rossiyskie vesti. , February
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . Nesokrushimaya i legendarnaya. V ogne politicheskikh bataliy 1985-1993 gg. Rossiyskiy nezavisimyy institut sotsialnykh i natsionalnykh problem , 328 – 330 . Moscow : Terra .
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Moscow Russian Television Network , 16 March FBIS-SOV-92-052
   Google Scholar
• Webber , Mark . 1996 . The International Politics of Russia and the Successor States , 185 Manchester : Manchester University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Ostankino TV , 23 April Creative intermediate positions were proposed on the way. By April, Shaposhnikov, as well as, e.g.. Admiral Chernavin, spoke of Ukraine's obvious right to create its own navy. For that purpose, it should receive some 10-20 of the BSF, whereas the CIS should have the rest. See
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 19 June FBIS-SOV-92-080. In June, he suggested that the BSF might be divided up between all the CIS members, and that the other republics, less Ukraine, thereafter "delegate" their shares to Russia
   Google Scholar
• Webber , Mark . 1996 . The International Politics of Russia and the Successor States , 185 Manchester : Manchester University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Trenin , Dimitry . 1992 . "Divide and Flourish?" . New Times , September
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 10 January
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Glavkom dovolen rabotoy, provedennoy s prezidentami" . Izvestiya , 24 March
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "Igrat v politiku armiya ne namerena" . Uteraturnaya gazeta , 17 March
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Radio Mayak , 6 January FBIS- SOV-92-004
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . Radio Rossii , 7 April FBIS-SOV-92-068-S
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "Igrat v politiku armiya ne namerena" . Literatumaya gazeta , 17 March
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "Black Sea Fleet Is All Russia's, Yeltsin Insists" . LOJ Angeles Times , 10 January
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "I. Kasatonov: Prisyagu na vernost Ukraine, kak i drugim respublikam byvshego suyuza, ya uzhe daval" . Krasnaya zvezda , 4 March Reprinted in Nesokrushimaya i legendarnay, op. cit., pp. 334-335.
   Google Scholar
• Shafarevich , Igor . 1993 . "Oborona Sevastopolya prodolzhaetsya" . Uteraturnaya Rossiya , 4 June
   Google Scholar
• Kolstø , Pal . 1998 . Nasjonsbygging. Russland og de nye statene i øst , 253 – 254 . Oslo : Universitetsforlaget .
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "The Navy Serves the Whole Fatherland" . Sovetskaya Rossiya , 9 January FBIS-SOV92-006
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . "I. Kapitanets: Kak skazal Eltsin, "Chernomorskiiy flot byl, est i budet rossiyskim" . Rossiyskie vesti , 13 February
   Google Scholar
• 1992 . RFE/RL DaIy Brief , 3 April Nesokrushimaya i legendarnaya, op. àt., pp. 328-330. Kapitanets retired in April 1992, and was replaced by Admiral Feliks Gromov
   Google Scholar
• Pleshakov , Konstantin . 1993 . "Krym: kuda nas tolkayut glupye natsionalisty" . Novoe vremya ,
   Google Scholar
• Belitser , Natalia and Bodruk , Oleg . 1998 . "Conflicting Loyalties in the Crimea" ” . In Conflicting Loyalties and the State in Post-Soviet Russia and Eurasia , Edited by: Waller , Michael , Coppieters , Bruno and Malashenko , Alexei . 72 London : Frank Cass .
   Google Scholar
• Vasily , Kremen . 1997 . "The East Slav Triangle" ” . In Russia and Europe. The Emerging Security Agenda , Edited by: Baranovsky , Vladimir . 283 Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1993 . "Chem budet Krym: yablokom razdora ili svyazyuyshchim zvenom?" . Kommersant-Daily , 10 July
   Google Scholar
• Kovalenko , Vladimir . 1993 . "Govaryat 'flot'-podrazumevayut Krym" . Izvestiya , 29 May
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . Ukrayina segodnya , May Reported by
   Google Scholar
• Bukkvoll , Tor . 1997 . Ukraine and European Security , 70 London : Chatham House Papers .
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . RFE/RL Daily Brief , 25 October
   Google Scholar
• Hall , Deborah Yarsike and Gerber , Theodore P. 1996 . "The Political Views of Russian Field Grade Officers" . Post-Soviet Affairs , 12 ( 2 ) : 168
   Google Scholar
• ToIz , Vera . 1998 . "Conflicting 'Homelands Myths' and Nation-State Building in Postcommurrist Russia" . Slavic Review , 57 ( 2 ) : 274 – 275 .
   Google Scholar