Essay Review

References

• Barnes , S. B. and Dolby , R. G. A. 1970 . The Scientific Ethos: a Deviant Viewpoint' . Archives Européennes de Sociologie , 11 : 3 – 25 . 3
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Shapin , S. 1992 . 'Discipline and Bounding: the History and Sociology of Science Seen through the Externalism-Internalism Debate' . History of Science , 30 : 333 – 69 . 338
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Giesecke , H. 1993 . Hitlers Pädogogen: Theorie und Praxis nationalsozialistischer Erziehung Weinheim and Munich A notable example is the Nazi sociology of knowledge presented in Alfred Baeumler's Männerbund und Wissenschaft (Berlin, 1934); on Baeumler's political pedagogics see eh. 3
   Google Scholar
• Toulmin , S. 1955-56 . 'History and Philosophy of Science: a Pioneer Department' . Universities Quarterly , 10 : 346 – 58 . For a typical denunciation of the polemical character of earlier writings in the name of professional objectivity see (I am indebted to Anna-K. Mayer for drawing my attention to this issue and this article)
   Google Scholar
• Plessner , H. 1990 . “ The Concept of Ideology and its Vicissitudes' ” . In Knowledge and Politics: the Sociology of Knowledge Dispute Edited by: Mehta , V. and Stehr , N. 241 – 60 . London and New York Perhaps the most explicit of the many 'anticipations' of the Strong Programme in SSK is to be found in
   Google Scholar
• Fleck , L. 1979 . Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact [1935] Edited by: Bradley , F. and Trenn , T. J. Chicago, IL
   Google Scholar
• Bottomore , T. and Goode , P. 1978 . Austro-Marxism Oxford Selections from Adler translated in
   Google Scholar
• Borkenau , F. 1987 . “ The Sociology of the Mechanistic World-Picture' [1932] ” . In Science in Context Edited by: Hadden , R. W. Vol. 1 , 109 – 27 .
   Google Scholar
• Grossmann , H. 1987 . “ The Social Foundation of Mechanistic Philosophy and Manufacture' [1935] ” . In Science in Context Edited by: Shalit , G. Vol. 1 , 129 – 80 . H. Plessner (note 6)
   Google Scholar
• Fleck , C. 1993 . “ 'Marxistische Kausalanalysis und functionale Wissenschaftssoziologie. Ein Fall unterbliebenen Wissenstransfers' ” . In Wien-Berlin-Prag. Der Aufstieg der wissenschaftlichen Philosophie. Zentenarien Rudolf Carnap-Hans Reichenbach-Edgar Zilsei Edited by: Haller , R. and Stadier , F. 501 – 24 . Vienna On reasons for the limited reception of Zilsel's writings see
   Google Scholar
• Zilsel himself was strongly critical of academic philosophy and ways of writing, Wissenchaft und Weltanschauung. Aufsätze 1929-1933 (hereafter WW). ed. by G. Mozetic (Vienna. 1992), pp. 43-44.
   Google Scholar
• The Social Origins of Modern Science (hereafter SOMS), Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Vol. 200, ed. by D. Raven, W. Krohn and R.S. Cohen (Dordrecht: Kluwer, 2000).
   Google Scholar
• Translated from E. Zilsel, 'Philosophische Bemerkungen' [1929], in WW, pp. 31-44 (pp. 41-42).
   Google Scholar
• Shapin , S. “ The Zilsel Thesis' ” . Edited by: Bynum , W. F. , Browne , E. J. and Porter , R. 450 See, for example, P. Rossi, 'Craftsman-and-Scholar Thesis' (note 3); (note 3)
   Google Scholar
• Dahms , H.-J. “ 'Edgar Zilsels Projekt "the Social Roots of Science" und seine Beziehungen zur Frankfurter Schule' ” . Edited by: Haller , R. and Stadier , F. 474 – 500 . 487 – 90 . On Zilsel's thesis in relation to the theses of Borkenau and Grossmann see (note 9)
   Google Scholar
• Zilsel , E. 1932-33 . 'Bemerkungen zur Wissenschaftslogik' . Erkenntnis , 3 : 143 – 61 . Zilsel's arguments are well analysed by
   Google Scholar
• Rutte , H. “ 'Zu Zilsels erkenntnistheoretischen Ansichten in der Phase des Wiener Kreises' ” . Edited by: Haller , R. and Stadier , F. (note 9)
   Google Scholar
• Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik, 65 (1931), 475-524 (reprinted in WW, pp. 101-44).
   Google Scholar
• E. Zilsel 'Materialismus und marxistische Geschichtsauffassung' [1931], in WW, pp. 77-87, and 'Partei, Marxismus, Materialismus, Neukantianismus' [1931], in WW, pp. 88-98.
   Google Scholar
• E. Zilsel 'Bemerkungen zur Wissenschaftslogik' (note 21).
   Google Scholar
• Burger , T. 1987 . Max Weber's Theory of Concept Formation: History, Laws and Ideal Types, expanded Durham, NC In these remarks I have been guided by
   Google Scholar
• Ringer , F. 1997 . Max Weber's Methodology: the Unification of the Cultural and Social Sciences Cambridge, MA
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 228-29. In the course of this ideal-typical characterization of science, Zilsel refers to 'disenchantment of the world (Max Weber)'. Zilsel's definition of science here is. in fact, close to that offered by H. Plessner in his explicitly ideal-typical and Weberian account of the origins of modern scientific research as an 'industrialisation of knowledge' that accompanied a general 'rationalisation of social life': 'Zur Soziologie der modernen Forschung und ihrer Organization in der deutschen Universität Tradition und Ideologie' [1924]. in Gesammelte Schriften (Frankfurt am Main, 1985). x, 7-30.
   Google Scholar
• Zilsel , E. 1926 . Die Entstehung des Geniebegriffes. Ein Beitrag zur Ideengeschichte der Antike und des Frühkapitalismus 324 – 26 . Tübingen SOMS. pp. 204-05
   Google Scholar
• Winch , P. 1958 . The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy London On the problematic distinction between anachronisms and anatropisms (impositions of concepts on cultures which lack them) legitimate for explanatory purposes and those which are illegitimate by virtue of false presuppositions, see
   Google Scholar
• Jardine , N. 2000 . 'The Uses and Abuses of Anachronism in the History of the Sciences' . History of Science , 38 : 251 – 70 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar