The Canary, the Ostrich, and the Black Swan: A Historical Perspective on our Understanding of BWR Severe Accidents and Their Mitigation

REFERENCES

• “Report of the Japanese Government to the IAEA Ministerial Conference on Nuclear Safety—The Accident at TEPCO’s Fukushima Nuclear Power Stations,” Nuclear Emergency Response Headquarters, Government of Japan (2011).
   Google Scholar
• R. E. HENRY, TMI-2: An Event in Accident Management for Light-Water-Moderated Reactors, American Nuclear Society, La Grange Park, Illinois (2011).
   Google Scholar
• N. N. TALEB, The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable, Random House (2007).
   Google Scholar
• W. R. CORCORAN, “Crisis Learning in the United States Nuclear Power Generation Industry,” Firebird Forum, 15, 4 (2012).
   Google Scholar
• “Theoretical Possibilities and Consequences of Major Accidents in Large Nuclear Plants,” WASH-740, U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (1957).
   Google Scholar
• F. R. FARMER, “Reactor Safety and Siting: A Proposed Risk Criterion,” Nucl. Saf., 8, 6, 539 (1967).
   Google Scholar
• “The Safety of Nuclear Power Reactors (Light Water Cooled) and Related Facilities,” WASH-1250, U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (1973).
   Google Scholar
• “Reactor Safety Study: An Assessment of Accident Risk in U.S. Commercial Nuclear Power Plants,” WASH-1400 (NUREG-75/014), U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1975).
   Google Scholar
• “NRC Action Plan Developed as a Result of the TMI-2 Accident,” NUREG-660, Rev. 1, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionU.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1980).
   Google Scholar
• A. R. BUHL, J. C. CARTER, and M. H. FONTANA, “The IDCOR Program—Severe Accident Issues, Individual Plant Examination, and Source Term Developments,” presented at Commission of the European Communities Source Term Workshop, Brussels, Belgium, 1985.
   Google Scholar
• “Interim Reliability Evaluation Program: Analysis of the Browns Ferry Unit 1 Nuclear Plant,” NUREG/CR-2802, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1982).
   Google Scholar
• Sustainable Energy Today Online Bibliography; http://sustainableenergytoday.blogspot.com/2012/06/post-65-ornl-light-water-reactor-safety.html (accessed June 29, 2012).
   Google Scholar
• D. H. COOK et al., “Station Blackout at Browns Ferry Unit One—Accident Sequence Analysis,” NUREG/CR-2182, Vol. 2, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1981).
   Google Scholar
• R. P. WICHNER et al., “Station Blackout at Browns Ferry Unit One—Iodine and Noble Gas Distribution and Release,” NUREG/CR-2182, Vol. 2, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1982).
   Google Scholar
• R. O. WOOTEN and H. I. AVCI, “MARCH Code Description and User’s Manual,” NUREG/CR-1711, Battelle Columbus Laboratories (1980).
   Google Scholar
• W. A. CONDON et al., “SBLOCA Outside Containment at Browns Ferry Unit One—Accident Sequence Analysis,” NUREG/CR-2672, Vol. 1, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1982).
   Google Scholar
• R. P. WICHNER et al., “SBLOCA Outside Containment at Browns Ferry Unit One—Volume 2. Iodine, Cesium, and Noble Gas Distribution and Release,” NUREG/CR-2672, Vol. 1, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1983).
   Google Scholar
• D. H. COOK et al., “Loss of DHR Sequences at Browns Ferry Unit One—Accident Sequence Analysis,” NUREG/CR-2973, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1983).
   Google Scholar
• R. P. WICHNER et al., “Noble Gas, Iodine, and Cesium Transport in a Postulated Loss of Decay Heat Removal Accident at Browns Ferry,” NUREG/CR-3617, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1984).
   Google Scholar
• L. G. GREIMANN et al., “Reliability Analysis of Steel Containment Strength,” NUREG/CR-2442, Ames Laboratory, University of Iowa (1982).
   Google Scholar
• D. D. YUE, “BWR4/Mark I Blackout Sequence Assessment and Containment Failure Mode Analysis,” Trans. Am. Nucl. Soc, 39, 602 (1981).
   Google Scholar
• D. D. YUE, “BWR Containment Failure Analysis During Degraded Core Accidents, Trans. Am. Nucl. Soc., 41, 413 (1982).
   Google Scholar
• C. H. HOFMAYER, G. BAGCHI, and V. S. NOONAN, “Containment Leakage During Severe Accident Conditions,” BNL-NUREG-35286, Brookhaven National Laboratory (1984).
   Google Scholar
• “Mark I Containment Severe Accident Analysis,” Chicago Bridge and Iron NA-CON, Inc. (1987).
   Google Scholar
• T. L. BRIDGES, “Containment Penetration Elastomer Seal Leak Rate Tests,” NUREG/CR-4944, Idaho National Engineering Laboratory (1987).
   Google Scholar
• K. R. PERKINS et al., “Containment Performance for Core Melt Accidents in BWRs with Mark I and Mark II Containments,” BNL-NUREG-37676, Proc. Topl. Mtg. Probabilistic Safety Methods and Applications, San Francisco, California, February 1985, American Nuclear Society, European Nuclear Society (1985).
   Google Scholar
• G. A. GREENE, K. R. PERKINS, and S. A. HODGE, “Impact of Core-Concrete Interactions in the Mark I Containment Drywell on Containment Integrity and Failure of the Drywell Liner,” IAEA-SM-281/36/BNL-NUREG-37131, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1985).
   Google Scholar
• “Individual Plant Examination Program: Perspectives on Reactor Safety and Plant Performance,” NUREG-1560, Vol. 1, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1997).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “The Role of BWR MK I Secondary Containments in Severe Accident Mitigation,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 14th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Bethesda, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1986).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE et al., “The Response of BWR Mark II Containments to Station Blackout Severe Accident Sequences,” NUREG/CR-5565, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1991).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE et al., “The Response of BWR Mark III Containments to Short-Term Station Blackout Severe Accident Sequences,” NUREG/CR-5571, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1991).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE et al., “BWR Mark II Ex-Vessel Corium Interaction Analyses,” NUREG/CR-5623, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1991).
   Google Scholar
• J. J. CARBAJO, “Recovery Sequences for a Station Blackout Accident at the Grand Gulf Nuclear Station,” Trans. Am. Nucl. Soc, 72, 226 (1995).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “The Impact of BWR MK I Primary Containment Failure Dynamics on Secondary Containment Integrity,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 15th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Bethesda, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1987).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “The Role of BWR Secondary Containments in Severe Accident Mitigation: Issues and Insights from Recent Analyses,” NUREG/CP-0095, Proc. 4th Workshop Containment Integrity, Arlington, Virginia, 1988.
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “The Role of BWR Secondary Containments in Severe Accident Mitigation: Issues and Insights from Recent Analyses,” Nucl. Eng. Des., 120, 75 (1990); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(90)90286-7.
   Google Scholar
• K. D. BERGERON et al., “User’s Manual for CONTAIN 1.0, A Computer Code for Severe Nuclear Reactor Accident Containment Analysis,” NUREG/CR-4085, Sandia National Laboratories (1984).
   Google Scholar
• R. M. SUMMERS et al., “MELCOR 1.8.0: A Computer Code for Nuclear Reactor Severe Accident Source Term and Risk Assessment Analyses,” NUREG/CR-5531, Sandia National Laboratories (1991).
   Google Scholar
• W. A. CONDON, S. R. GREENE, and H. L. DODDS, Jr., “Investigation of Drywell Flooding at the Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant,” Trans. Am. Nucl. Soc., 41, 419 (1982).
   Google Scholar
• W. J. LUCKAS, Jr., J. J. VANDENKIEBOOM, and J. R. LEHNER, “Assessment of Candidate Accident Management Strategies,” NUREG/CR-5474, Brookhaven National Laboratory (1990).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE and M. PETEK, “Assessment of Two BWR Accident Management Strategies,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 19th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Bethesda, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1991).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE et al., “Identification and Assessment of BWR In-Vessel Severe Accident Mitigation Strategies,” NUREG/CR-5869, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1992).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “Application of MARCH to BWR Severe Accident Analysis,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 10th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Gaithersburg, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1982).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “Improvement of MARCH for BWR Applications,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 10th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Gaithersburg, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1982).
   Google Scholar
• S. R. GREENE, “Realistic Simulation of Severe Accidents in BWRs—Computer Modeling Requirements,” NUREG/CR-2940, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1984).
   Google Scholar
• “SCDAP/RELAP5-3D Code Manual,” INEEL/EXT-02-00589, Vol. 1, Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory (2003).
   Google Scholar
• R. M. HARRINGTON and L. C. FULLER, “BWR-LTAS: A Boiling Water Reactor Long-Term Accident Simulation Code,” NUREG/CR-3764, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1985).
   Google Scholar
• L. J. OTT, “Advanced Severe Accident Response Models for BWR Application,” Nucl. Eng. Des, 115, 289 (1989); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(89)90054-X.
   Google Scholar
• L. J. OTT and S. A. HODGE, “Modeling of Time-Dependent Emergence of Core Debris from A Boiling Water Reactor Vessel Under Severe Accident Conditions,” ORNL/M-1015, Letter Report to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1988); http://www.ornl.gov/info/reports/1988/3445606042939.pdf (current as of March 28, 2013).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE and L. J. OTT, “BWRSAR Calculations of Reactor Vessel Debris Pours for Peach Bottom Short-Term Station Blackout,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 16th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Gaithersburg, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1988).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE and L. J. OTT, “Failure Modes of the BWR Reactor Vessel Bottom Head,” ORNL/M-1019, Letter Report to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1989); http://www.ornl.gov/info/reports/1989/3445606042920.pdf (current as of March 28, 2013).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE and L. J. OTT, “BWRSAR Calculations of Reactor Vessel Debris Pours from Peach Bottom Short-Term Station Blackout,” Nucl. Eng. Des., 121, 337 (1990); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(90)90015-P.
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE and L. J. OTT, “BWR Lower Plenum Debris Bed Models for MELCOR,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s 19th Water Reactor Safety Information Mtg., Gaithersburg, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, p. 325 (1991).
   Google Scholar
• F. P. GRIFFIN and K. A. SMITH, “BWR Control Blade/ Channel Box Interaction and Melt Relocation Models for SCDAP, Revision 1,” ORNL/NRC/LTR-92/12/R1, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1992).
   Google Scholar
• F. P. GRIFFIN, “BWR Control Blade/Channel Box Interaction Models for SCDAP/RELAP,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 21st Water Reactor Safety Research Information Mtg., Bethesda, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1993).
   Google Scholar
• S. A. HODGE, “BWR Severe Accident Sequence Analyses at ORNL—Some Lessons Learned,” Proc. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission s 11th Water Reactor Safety Mtg., Bethesda, Maryland, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (1983).
   Google Scholar
• D. C. ALDRICH et al., “Technical Guidance for Siting Criteria Development,” NUREG/CR-2239, Sandia National Laboratories (1982).
   Google Scholar
• “Policy Statement on Severe Reactor Accidents Regarding Future Designs and Existing Plants,” 50 FR 32138, Federal Register (Aug. 8, 1985).
   Google Scholar
• “Safety Goals for the Operations of Nuclear Power Plants Policy Statement,” 51 FR 28044, Federal Register (Aug.4,1986). 60. “Individual Plant Examination for Severe Accident Vulnerability,” Generic Letter 88-20, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1988).
   Google Scholar
• “Severe Accident Risks: An Assessment for Five U.S. Nuclear Power Plants,” NUREG-1150, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1990).
   Google Scholar
• A. C. PAYNEETAL, “EvaluationofSevereAccidentRisks: Peach Bottom, Unit 2,” NUREG/CR-4551, Vol. 4, Sandia National Laboratories (1990).
   Google Scholar
• T. D. BROWN et al., “Evaluation of Severe Accident Risks: Grand Gulf, Unit 1,” NUREG/CR-4551, Vol. 6, Sandia National Laboratories (1990).
   Google Scholar
• “Individual Plant Examination of External Events (IPEEE) for Severe Accident Vulnerabilities—10 CFR 50.54(f),” Generic Letter 88-20, Suppl. 4, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (1991).
   Google Scholar
• M. KHATIB-RAHBAR et al., “Insights and Comparisons of the Level-2 Results of Recent Probabilistic Safety Analyses,” Nucl. Eng. Des., 162, 175 (1996); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0029-5493(95)01144-7.
   Google Scholar
• M. K. RAVINDRA, “Seismic Individual Plant Examination of External Events of US Nuclear Power Plants: Insights and Implications,” Nucl. Eng. Des., 175, 227 (1997); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0029-5493(97)00040-X.
   Google Scholar
• J. T. CHEN et al., “Preliminary Perspectives Gained from Individual Plant Examination of External Events (IPEEE) Seismic and Fire Submittal Review,” Nucl. Eng. Des., 181, 91 (1998); http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0029-5493(97)00337-3.
   Google Scholar
• “Perspectives Gained from the Individual Plant Examination of External Events (IPEEE) Program,” NUREG-1742, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2001).
   Google Scholar
• “State-of-the-Art Reactor Consequence Analysis Project Volume 1: Peach Bottom Integrated Analysis,” NUREG/CR-7110, Vol. 1, Sandia National Laboratories (2012).
   Google Scholar
• SECY-00-0077, “Modifications to the Reactor Safety Goal Policy Statement,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2000).
   Google Scholar
• Regulatory Guide 1.174, “An Approach for Using Probabilistic Risk Assessment in Risk-Informed Decisions on Plant-Specific Changes to the Licensing Basis,” Rev. 1, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2002).
   Google Scholar
• SECY-13-0029, “History of the Use and Consideration of the Large Release Frequency Metric by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2013).
   Google Scholar
• ASME TASK FORCE ON RESPONSE TO JAPAN NUCLEAR POWER PLANT EVENTS, “Forging a New Nuclear Safety Construct,” American Society of Mechanical Engineers (2012).
   Google Scholar
• “Recommendations for Enhancing Reactor Safety in the 21st Century, the Report of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s Near-Term Task Force Review of Insights from the Fukushima Daiichi Accident,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2011).
   Google Scholar
• A. M. WEINBERG, “Social Institutions and Nuclear Energy,” Science, 177, 27 (1972); http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.177.4043.27.
   Google Scholar
• Code ofFederal Regulations, Title 10, “Energy,” Part 50, “Domestic Licensing of Production and Utilization Facilities,” Sec. 50.109, “Backfitting,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (2012).
   Google Scholar
• “GE Technology Advanced Manual,” Chap. 6, “BWR Differences,” U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission; http://pbadupws.nrc.gov/docs/ML0230/ML023010606.pdf (current as of Feb. 21, 2014).
   Google Scholar