4,136
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

How to Make DNA Methylome Wide Association Studies More Powerful

, &
Pages 1117-1129 | Received 23 Feb 2016, Accepted 23 Mar 2016, Published online: 07 Apr 2016

References

  • Stommel M , SchoenbornCA . Variations in bmi and prevalence of health risks in diverse racial and ethnic populations . Obesity (Silver Spring)18 ( 9 ), 1821 – 1826 ( 2010 ).
  • Consultation WHOE . Appropriate body-mass index for asian populations and its implications for policy and intervention strategies . Lancet363 ( 9403 ), 157 – 163 ( 2004 ).
  • Chambers JC , LohM , LehneBet al. Epigenome-wide association of DNA methylation markers in peripheral blood from Indian Asians and Europeans with incident type 2 diabetes: a nested case–control study . Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol.3 ( 7 ), 526 – 534 ( 2015 ).
  • Caspi A , SugdenK , MoffittTEet al. Influence of life stress on depression: moderation by a polymorphism in the 5-htt gene . Science301 ( 5631 ), 386 – 389 ( 2003 ).
  • Hartman S , WidamanKF , BelskyJ . Genetic moderation of effects of maternal sensitivity on girl’s age of menarche: replication of the Manuck et al. study . Dev. Psychopathol.27 ( 3 ), 747 – 756 ( 2015 ).
  • Manuck SB , CraigAE , FloryJD , HalderI , FerrellRE . Reported early family environment covaries with menarcheal age as a function of polymorphic variation in estrogen receptor-alpha . Dev. Psychopathol.23 ( 1 ), 69 – 83 ( 2011 ).
  • Holbrook JD . An epigenetic escape route . Trends Genet.31 ( 1 ), 2 – 4 ( 2015 ).
  • Arking D , RommensJ . Editorial overview: molecular and egnetic bases of disease: enter the post-GWAS era . Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev.33 , 77 – 79 ( 2015 ).
  • Barsh GS , CopenhaverGP , GibsonG , WilliamsSM . Guidelines for genome-wide association studies . PLoS Genet.8 ( 7 ), e1002812 ( 2012 ).
  • Pe’er I , YelenskyR , AltshulerD , DalyMJ . Estimation of the multiple testing burden for genomewide association studies of nearly all common variants . Genet. Epidemiol.32 ( 4 ), 381 – 385 ( 2008 ).
  • Hoggart CJ , ClarkTG , De IorioM , WhittakerJC , BaldingDJ . Genome-wide significance for dense SNP and resequencing data . Genet. Epidemiol.32 ( 2 ), 179 – 185 ( 2008 ).
  • Ladd-Acosta C , FallinMD . The role of epigenetics in genetic and environmental epidemiology . Epigenomics8 ( 2 ), 271 – 283 ( 2015 ).
  • Leon AC , HeoM . Sample sizes required to detect interactions between two binary fixed-effects in a mixed-effects linear regression model . Comput. Stat. Data Anal.53 ( 3 ), 603 – 608 ( 2009 ).
  • Smith PG , DayNE . The design of case–control studies: the influence of confounding and interaction effects . Int. J. Epidemiol.13 ( 3 ), 356 – 365 ( 1984 ).
  • Thomas D . Gene–environment-wide association studies: emerging approaches . Nat. Rev. Genet.11 ( 4 ), 259 – 272 ( 2010 ).
  • Khoury MJ , WacholderS . Invited commentary: From genome-wide association studies to gene–environment-wide interaction studies–challenges and opportunities . Am. J. Epidemiol.169 ( 2 ), 227 – 230 ; discussion 234–225 ( 2009 ).
  • Melkonian SC , DanielCR , YeYet al. Gene–environment interaction of genome-wide association study-identified susceptibility loci and meat-cooking mutagens in the etiology of renal cell carcinoma . Cancer122 ( 1 ), 108 – 115 ( 2016 ).
  • Mullins N , PowerRA , FisherHLet al. Polygenic interactions with environmental adversity in the aetiology of major depressive disorder . Psychol. Med.46 ( 4 ), 759 – 770 ( 2015 ).
  • Bibikova M , BarnesB , TsanCet al. High density DNA methylation array with single cpg site resolution . Genomics98 ( 4 ), 288 – 295 ( 2011 ).
  • Pan H , ChenL , DograSet al. Measuring the methylome in clinical samples: improved processing of the infinium human methylation450 beadchip array . Epigenetics7 ( 10 ), 1173 – 1187 ( 2012 ).
  • Teh AL , PanH , LinXet al. Comparison of methyl-capture sequencing vs. Infinium humanmethylation450 array for methylome analysis in clinical samples . Epigenetics11 ( 1 ), 36 – 48 ( 2016 ).
  • Allum F , ShaoX , GuenardFet al. Characterization of functional methylomes by next-generation capture sequencing identifies novel disease-associated variants . Nat. Commun.6 , 7211 ( 2015 ).
  • Klengel T , BinderEB . Fkbp5 allele-specific epigenetic modification in gene by environment interaction . Neuropsychopharmacology40 ( 1 ), 244 – 246 ( 2015 ).
  • Klengel T , BinderEB . Allele-specific epigenetic modification: a molecular mechanism for gene–environment interactions in stress-related psychiatric disorders?Epigenomics5 ( 2 ), 109 – 112 ( 2013 ).
  • Teh AL , PanH , ChenLet al. The effect of genotype and in utero environment on interindividual variation in neonate DNA methylomes . Genome Res.24 ( 7 ), 1064 – 1074 ( 2014 ).
  • Hernandez L , BlazerD . Study design and analysis for assessment of interactions - definitions of interactions . In : Genes, Behaviour, and the Social Envrionement: Moving Beyond the Nature/Nurture Debate . HernandezL , BlazerD ( Eds ). National Academires Press (US) , Washington, DC, USA ( 2006 ).
  • Rakyan VK , DownTA , BaldingDJ , BeckS . Epigenome-wide association studies for common human diseases . Nat. Rev. Genet.12 ( 8 ), 529 – 541 ( 2011 ).
  • Heijmans BT , MillJ . Commentary: the seven plagues of epigenetic epidemiology . Int. J. Epidemiol.41 ( 1 ), 74 – 78 ( 2012 ).
  • Michels KB , BinderAM , DedeurwaerderSet al. Recommendations for the design and analysis of epigenome-wide association studies . Nat. Methods10 ( 10 ), 949 – 955 ( 2013 ).
  • Godfrey KM , SheppardA , GluckmanPDet al. Epigenetic gene promoter methylation at birth is associated with child’s later adiposity . Diabetes60 ( 5 ), 1528 – 1534 ( 2011 ).
  • Lillycrop KA , CostelloPM , TehALet al. Association between perinatal methylation of the neuronal differentiation regulator hes1 and later childhood neurocognitive function and behaviour . Int. J. Epidemiol.44 ( 4 ), 1263 – 1276 ( 2015 ).
  • Desai M , JellymanJK , RossMG . Epigenomics, gestational programming and risk of metabolic syndrome . Int. J. Obes.39 ( 4 ), 633 – 641 ( 2015 ).
  • Dick KJ , NelsonCP , TsaprouniLet al. DNA methylation and body-mass index: a genome-wide analysis . Lancet383 ( 9933 ), 1990 – 1998 ( 2014 ).
  • Philibert RA , BeachSR , LeiMK , BrodyGH . Changes in DNA methylation at the aryl hydrocarbon receptor repressor may be a new biomarker for smoking . Clin. Epigenetics5 ( 1 ), 19 ( 2013 ).
  • Pan H , LinX , WuYet al. Hif3a association with adiposity: the story begins before birth . Epigenomics7 ( 6 ), 937 – 950 ( 2015 ).
  • Huang T , ZhengY , QiQet al. DNA methylation variants at hif3a locus, b vitamins intake, and long-term weight change: gene-diet interactions in two US cohorts . Diabetes64 ( 9 ), 3146 – 3154 ( 2015 ).
  • Monastero R , Garcia-SerranoS , Lago-SampedroAet al. Methylation patterns of VEGFB promoter are associated with gene and protein expression levels: the effects of dietary fatty acids . Eur. J. Nutr. doi:10.1007/s00394-015-1115-7 ( 2015 ) ( Epub ahead of print ).
  • Demerath EW , GuanW , GroveMLet al. Epigenome-wide association study (EWAS) of BMI, BMI change and waist circumference in African American adults identifies multiple replicated loci . Hum. Mol. Genet.24 ( 15 ), 4464 – 4479 ( 2015 ).
  • Richmond RC , SharpGC , WardMEet al. DNA methylation and body mass index: investigating identified methylation sites at HIF3A in a causal framework . Diabetes pii: db150996 ( 2016 ) ( Epub ahead of print ).
  • Novakovic B , RyanJ , PereiraN , BoughtonB , CraigJM , SafferyR . Postnatal stability, tissue, and time specific effects of ahrr methylation change in response to maternal smoking in pregnancy . Epigenetics9 ( 3 ), 377 – 386 ( 2014 ).
  • Liang L , CooksonWO . Grasping nettles: cellular heterogeneity and other confounders in epigenome-wide association studies . Hum. Mol. Genet.23 ( R1 ), R83 – R88 ( 2014 ).
  • Lam LL , EmberlyE , FraserHBet al. Factors underlying variable DNA methylation in a human community cohort . Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA109 ( Suppl. 2 ), 17253 – 17260 ( 2012 ).
  • Jaffe AE , IrizarryRA . Accounting for cellular heterogeneity is critical in epigenome-wide association studies . Genome Biol.15 ( 2 ), R31 ( 2014 ).
  • Reinius LE , AcevedoN , JoerinkMet al. Differential DNA methylation in purified human blood cells: implications for cell lineage and studies on disease susceptibility . PLoS ONE7 ( 7 ), e41361 ( 2012 ).
  • Kulis M , MerkelA , HeathSet al. Whole-genome fingerprint of the DNA methylome during human B cell differentiation . Nat. Genet.47 ( 7 ), 746 – 756 ( 2015 ).
  • Martino D , JooJE , Sexton-OatesAet al. Epigenome-wide association study reveals longitudinally stable DNA methylation differences in CD4+ T cells from children with IGE-mediated food allergy . Epigenetics9 ( 7 ), 998 – 1006 ( 2014 ).
  • Heyn H , LiN , FerreiraHJet al. Distinct DNA methylomes of newborns and centenarians . Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA109 ( 26 ), 10522 – 10527 ( 2012 ).
  • Bell JT , TsaiPC , YangTPet al. Epigenome-wide scans identify differentially methylated regions for age and age-related phenotypes in a healthy ageing population . PLoS Genet.8 ( 4 ), e1002629 ( 2012 ).
  • Houseman EA , AccomandoWP , KoestlerDCet al. DNA methylation arrays as surrogate measures of cell mixture distribution . BMC Bioinformatics13 , 86 ( 2012 ).
  • Houseman EA , MolitorJ , MarsitCJ . Reference-free cell mixture adjustments in analysis of DNA methylation data . Bioinformatics30 ( 10 ), 1431 – 1439 ( 2014 ).
  • Yousefi P , HuenK , QuachHet al. Estimation of blood cellular heterogeneity in newborns and children for epigenome-wide association studies . Environ. Mol. Mutagen.56 ( 9 ), 751 – 758 ( 2015 ).
  • Koestler DC , JonesMJ , UssetJet al. Improving cell mixture deconvolution by identifying optimal DNA methylation libraries (IDOL) . BMC Bioinformatics17 ( 1 ), 120 ( 2016 ).
  • Sun Y , VestergaardM , PedersenCB , ChristensenJ , BassoO , OlsenJ . Gestational age, birth weight, intrauterine growth, and the risk of epilepsy . Am. J. Epidemiol.167 ( 3 ), 262 – 270 ( 2008 ).
  • Leek JT , ScharpfRB , BravoHCet al. Tackling the widespread and critical impact of batch effects in high-throughput data . Nat. Rev. Genet.11 ( 10 ), 733 – 739 ( 2010 ).
  • Leek JT . Svaseq: removing batch effects and other unwanted noise from sequencing data . Nucleic Acids Res.42 ( 21 ), e161 ( 2014 ).
  • Singmann P , Shem-TovD , WahlSet al. Characterization of whole-genome autosomal differences of DNA methylation between men and women . Epigenetics Chromatin8 , 43 ( 2015 ).
  • Horvath S , ZhangY , LangfelderPet al. Aging effects on DNA methylation modules in human brain and blood tissue . Genome Biol.13 ( 10 ), R97 ( 2012 ).
  • Zampieri M , CiccaroneF , CalabreseR , FranceschiC , BurkleA , CaiafaP . Reconfiguration of DNA methylation in aging . Mech. Ageing Dev.151 , 60 – 70 ( 2015 ).
  • Du P , ZhangX , HuangCCet al. Comparison of beta-value and m-value methods for quantifying methylation levels by microarray analysis . BMC Bioinformatics11 , 587 ( 2010 ).
  • Relton CL , GroomA , St PourcainBet al. DNA methylation patterns in cord blood DNA and body size in childhood . PLoS ONE7 ( 3 ), e31821 ( 2012 ).
  • Bland M . An Introduction to Medical Statistics (3rd Edition) . Oxford University Press , Oxford, UK ( 1986 ).
  • Barton SJ , CrozierSR , LillycropKA , GodfreyKM , InskipHM . Correction of unexpected distributions of p values from analysis of whole genome arrays by rectifying violation of statistical assumptions . BMC Genomics14 , 161 ( 2013 ).
  • Saadati M , BennerA . Statistical challenges of high-dimensional methylation data . Stat. Med.33 ( 30 ), 5347 – 5357 ( 2014 ).
  • Pleasants AB , WakeGC , ShortenPRet al. A new, improved and generalizable approach for the analysis of biological data generated by -omic platforms . J. Dev. Orig. Health Dis.6 ( 1 ), 17 – 26 ( 2015 ).
  • Siegel S , CastellanNJ . Nonparametric Statistics For The Behavioural Sciences . McGraw-Hill Humanities , NY, USA ( 1988 ).
  • Ritchie ME , PhipsonB , WuDet al. Limma powers differential expression analyses for rna-sequencing and microarray studies . Nucleic Acids Res.43 ( 7 ), e47 ( 2015 ).
  • Hochberg Y . A sharper Bonferroni procedure for multiple tests of significance . Biometrika75 , 800 – 802 ( 1988 ).
  • Storey JD . A direct approach to false discovery rates . J. R. Stat. Soc. B64 , 479 – 498 ( 2002 ).
  • Storey JD , TibshiraniR . Statistical significance for genomewide studies . Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA100 ( 16 ), 9440 – 9445 ( 2003 ).
  • Stephens M . False discovery rates: a new deal ( 2016 ). http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/01/29/038216 .
  • Moran S , ArribasC , EstellerM . Validation of a DNA methylation microarray for 850,000 cpg sites of the human genome enriched in enhancer sequences . Epigenomics8 ( 3 ), 389 – 399 ( 2015 ).
  • Teh AL , PanH , LinXet al. Comparison of methyl-capture sequencing vs. Infinium humanmethylation450 array for methylome analysis in clinical samples . Epigenetics11 ( 1 ), 36 – 48 ( 2016 ).
  • Ong ML , HolbrookJD . Novel region discovery method for Infinium 450k DNA methylation data reveals changes associated with aging in muscle and neuronal pathways . Aging Cell13 ( 1 ), 142 – 155 ( 2014 ).
  • Jaffe AE , MurakamiP , LeeHet al. Bump hunting to identify differentially methylated regions in epigenetic epidemiology studies . Int. J. Epidemiol.41 ( 1 ), 200 – 209 ( 2012 ).
  • Pedersen BS , SchwartzDA , YangIV , KechrisKJ . Comb-p: software for combining, analyzing, grouping and correcting spatially correlated p-values . Bioinformatics28 ( 22 ), 2986 – 2988 ( 2012 ).
  • Robinson MD , KahramanA , LawCWet al. Statistical methods for detecting differentially methylated loci and regions . Front. Genet.5 , 324 ( 2014 ).
  • Zhao N . Kernel machine methods for analysis of genomic data from different sources. Department of Biostatistics PhD ( 2014 ). https://cdr.lib.unc.edu/record/uuid:c0af962a-6897-4afd-92a7-6749f288b565 .
  • Sofer T , SchifanoED , HoppinJA , HouL , BaccarelliAA . A-clustering: A novel method for the detection of co-regulated methylation regions, and regions associated with exposure . Bioinformatics29 ( 22 ), 2884 – 2891 ( 2013 ).
  • Langfelder P , HorvathS . WGCNA: An R package for weighted correlation network analysis . BMC Bioinformatics9 , 559 ( 2008 ).
  • Wang D , YanL , HuQet al. IMA: An R package for high-throughput analysis of Illumina’s 450k infinium methylation data . Bioinformatics28 ( 5 ), 729 – 730 ( 2012 ).
  • Warden CD , LeeH , TompkinsJDet al. Cohcap: an integrative genomic pipeline for single-nucleotide resolution DNA methylation analysis . Nucleic Acids Res.41 ( 11 ), e117 ( 2013 ).
  • Pongpanich M , NeelyML , TzengJY . On the aggregation of multimarker information for marker-set and sequencing data analysis: genotype collapsing vs. similarity collapsing . Front. Genet.2 , 110 ( 2011 ).
  • Basu S , PanW . Comparison of statistical tests for disease association with rare variants . Genet. Epidemiol.35 ( 7 ), 606 – 619 ( 2011 ).
  • Zhao Y , ChenF , ZhaiR , LinX , DiaoN , ChristianiDC . Association test based on snp set: logistic kernel machine based test vs. principal component analysis . PLoS ONE7 ( 9 ), e44978 ( 2012 ).
  • Assenov Y , MullerF , LutsikP , WalterJ , LengauerT , BockC . Comprehensive analysis of DNA methylation data with rnbeads . Nat. Methods11 ( 11 ), 1138 – 1140 ( 2014 ).
  • Schubeler D . Function and information content of DNA methylation . Nature517 ( 7534 ), 321 – 326 ( 2015 ).
  • Sun D , YiSV . Impacts of chromatin states and long-range genomic segments on aging and DNA methylation . PLoS ONE10 ( 6 ), e0128517 ( 2015 ).
  • Lewsey MG , HardcastleTJ , MelnykCWet al. Mobile small rnas regulate genome-wide DNA methylation . Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA113 ( 6 ), e801 – e810 ( 2016 ).
  • Plank JL , DeanA . Enhancer function: mechanistic and genome-wide insights come together . Mol. Cell55 ( 1 ), 5 – 14 ( 2014 ).
  • Huang B , JiangC , ZhangR . Epigenetics: the language of the cell?Epigenomics6 ( 1 ), 73 – 88 ( 2014 ).
  • Liu Y , AryeeMJ , PadyukovLet al. Epigenome-wide association data implicate DNA methylation as an intermediary of genetic risk in rheumatoid arthritis . Nat. Biotechnol.31 ( 2 ), 142 – 147 ( 2013 ).
  • Gevaert O . Methylmix: an R package for identifying DNA methylation-driven genes . Bioinformatics31 ( 11 ), 1839 – 1841 ( 2015 ).
  • Rauscher GH , KresovichJK , PoulinMet al. Exploring DNA methylation changes in promoter, intragenic, and intergenic regions as early and late events in breast cancer formation . BMC Cancer15 , 816 ( 2015 ).
  • Li Y , CamarilloC , XuJet al. Genome-wide methylome analyses reveal novel epigenetic regulation patterns in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder . BioMed Res. Int.2015 , 201587 ( 2015 ).
  • Liu Y , DevescoviV , ChenS , NardiniC . Multilevel omic data integration in cancer cell lines: advanced annotation and emergent properties . BMC Syst. Biol.7 , 14 ( 2013 ).
  • Marzi SJ , MeaburnEL , DempsterELet al. Tissue-specific patterns of allelically-skewed DNA methylation . Epigenetics11 ( 1 ), 24 – 23 ( 2016 ).
  • Vanderweele TJ , AsomaningK , Tchetgen TchetgenEJet al. Genetic variants on 15q25.1, smoking, and lung cancer: an assessment of mediation and interaction . Am. J. Epidemiol.175 ( 10 ), 1013 – 1020 ( 2012 ).
  • Relton CL , Davey SmithG . Mendelian randomization: applications and limitations in epigenetic studies . Epigenomics7 ( 8 ), 1239 – 1243 ( 2015 ).
  • Davey Smith G , HemaniG . Mendelian randomization: genetic anchors for causal inference in epidemiological studies . Hum. Mol. Genet.23 ( R1 ), R89 – R98 ( 2014 ).
  • Kato N , LohM , TakeuchiFet al. Trans-ancestry genome-wide association study identifies 12 genetic loci influencing blood pressure and implicates a role for DNA methylation . Nat. Genet.47 ( 11 ), 1282 – 1293 ( 2015 ).
  • Chadwick LH , SawaA , YangIVet al. New insights and updated guidelines for epigenome-wide association studies . Neuroepigenetics1 , 14 – 19 ( 2015 ).
  • Soh SE , ChongYS , KwekKet al. Insights from the growing up in singapore towards healthy outcomes (gusto) cohort study . Ann. Nutr. Metab.64 ( 3–4 ), 218 – 225 ( 2014 ).
  • Soh SE , TintMT , GluckmanPet al. Cohort profile: the gusto birth cohort study . Int. J. Epidemiol.43 ( 5 ), 1401 – 1409 ( 2012 ).
  • Ng JW , BarrettLM , WongA , KuhD , SmithGD , ReltonCL . The role of longitudinal cohort studies in epigenetic epidemiology: challenges and opportunities . Genome Biol.13 ( 6 ), 246 ( 2012 ).
  • Painter RC , OsmondC , GluckmanP , HansonM , PhillipsDI , RoseboomTJ . Transgenerational effects of prenatal exposure to the dutch famine on neonatal adiposity and health in later life . BJOG115 ( 10 ), 1243 – 1249 ( 2008 ).
  • Huang C , LiZ , NarayanKM , WilliamsonDF , MartorellR . Bigger babies born to women survivors of the 1959–1961 chinese famine: a puzzle due to survival selection?J. Dev. Orig. Health Dis.1 ( 6 ), 412 – 418 ( 2010 ).
  • Pembrey ME , BygrenLO , KaatiGet al. Sex-specific, male-line transgenerational responses in humans . Eur. J. Hum. Genet.14 ( 2 ), 159 – 166 ( 2006 ).
  • Marttila S , KananenL , JylhavaJet al. Length of paternal lifespan is manifested in the DNA methylome of their nonagenarian progeny . Oncotarget6 ( 31 ), 30557 – 30567 ( 2015 ).
  • Yehuda R , DaskalakisNP , BiererLMet al. Holocaust exposure induced intergenerational effects on fkbp5 methylation . Biol. Psychiatry doi:10.1016/j.biopsych.2015.08.005 ( 2015 ) ( Epub ahead of print ).
  • Kundaje A , MeulemanWet al. Integrative analysis of 111 reference human epigenomes . Nature518 ( 7539 ), 317 – 330 ( 2015 ).
  • Consortium EP . An integrated encyclopedia of DNA elements in the human genome . Nature489 ( 7414 ), 57 – 74 ( 2012 ).
  • Cancer Genome Atlas Research N , WeinsteinJN , CollissonEAet al.The cancer genome atlas pan-cancer analysis project . Nat. Genet.45 ( 10 ), 1113 – 1120 ( 2013 ).