1,462
Views
14
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
SEA comparative analysis

Applying strategic environmental assessment to land-use and resource-management plans in Scotland and New Zealand: a comparison

&
Pages 89-101 | Published online: 20 Feb 2012

References

  • ACC, Auckland City Council . 2003 . Section 32 Analysis of the Inclusion of the residential 8 Zone in the Auckland City District Plan 1999: Isthmus Section. , Auckland , NZ : Auckland City Council. .
  • ACC, Auckland City Council . 2005 . Section 32 Report Plan Change 61, Isthmus District Plan Glen Innes — Residential 6a and 8 rezoning. , Auckland , NZ : Auckland City Council. .
  • ARC, Auckland Regional Council . 2002 . Auckland Regional Economic Development Strategy. , Auckland , NZ : Auckland Regional Council .
  • ARC, Auckland Regional Council . 2003 . Auckland Regional Transport Strategy 2003. , Auckland , NZ : Auckland Regional Council. .
  • ARGF, Auckland Regional Growth Forum . 1999 . A Vision for Managing Growth in the Auckland Region: Auckland Regional Growth Strategy 2050. , Auckland , NZ : Auckland Regional Growth Forum, Auckland Regional Council. .
  • Baker Associates . 1999 . Proposals for a Good Practice Guide on Sustainability Appraisal of Regional Planning Guidance. , London : Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions. .
  • Benson-Pope, The Hon David . 2004 . Improving the RMA: a comprehensive package of measures designed to improve the workings of the RMA , Wellington , NZ : Office of the Associate Minister for the Environment . Media Release, 15 September
  • Berke , P. , Crawford , J. , Dixon , J. and Ericksen , N. 1999 . Do cooperative environmental planning mandates produce good plans? Empirical results from the New Zealand experience . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design , 24 : 451 – 468 .
  • Birley , T. 2001 . Reality Check: A Review of Scottish Executive Activity on Sustainable Development. , Aberfeldy : WWF-Scotland. .
  • Carter , J. , Wood , C. and Baker , M. 2003 . Structure plan appraisal and the SEA Directive . Town Planning Review , 74 ( 4 ) : 395 – 422 .
  • CEC, Commission of the European Communities . 2001 . Directive 2001/42/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Assessment of the Effects of Certain Plans and Programmes on the Environment. , Brussels : Commission of the European Communities. .
  • Counsell , D. and Houghton , G. 2002 . Sustainability Appraisal of Regional Planning Guidance Final Report. , London : Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions. .
  • Curran , J. M. , Wood , C. and Hilton , M. 1998 . Environmental appraisal of UK development plans: current practice and future directions . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design , 25 : 411 – 433 .
  • DETR, Department for the Environment, Transport and the Regions . 2000a . Guidance on Preparing Regional Sustainable Development Frameworks. , London : Department for the Environment, Transport and the Regions. .
  • DETR, Department for the Environment, Transport and the Regions . 2000b . Good Practice Guide on Sustainability Appraisal of Regional Planning Guidance. , London : Department for the Environment, Transport and the Regions. .
  • Dixon , J. 2002 . “ All at SEA? strategic environmental assessment in New Zealand ” . In Strategic Environmental Assessment in Australasia , Edited by: Marsden , S. and Dovers , S. 195 – 210 . Annandale , NSW : The Federation Press .
  • Dixon , J. 2005 . “ New Zealand ” . In Strategic Environmental Assessment and Land Use Planning , Edited by: Jones , C. , Baker , M. , Carter , J. , Jay , S. , Short , M. and Wood , C. 158 – 173 . London : Earthscan .
  • Dixon , J. and Fookes , T. 1995 . Environmental assessment in New Zealand: prospects and practical realities . Australian Journal of Environmental Management , 2 ( 1 ) : 104 – 111 .
  • DoE, Department of the Environment . 1991 . Policy Appraisal and the Environment. , London : Department of the Environment. .
  • DoE, Department of the Environment . 1993 . Environmental Appraisal of Development Plans. , London : Department of the Environment. .
  • DPMC, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet . 2003 . Sustainable Development for New Zealand: Programme of Action. , Wellington , NZ : Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. .
  • DTA, David Tyldesley and Associates . 1995 . Methodology for Environmental Appraisal of Scottish Development Plans. , Edinburgh : David Tyldesley and Associates for the Scottish Office and Gordon District Council. .
  • DTA, David Tyldesley and Associates . 2003 . Environmental Assessment of Development Plans. , Edinburgh : Scottish Executive Development Department Interim Planning Advice prepared by David Tyldesley and Associates. .
  • Ericksen , N. J. , Berke , P. R. , Crawford , J. L. and Dixon , J. E. 2004 . Plan-making for Sustainability: the New Zealand Experience. , Aldershot : Ashgate. .
  • Esson , G. , Reekie , B. and Jackson , T. 2004 . Objective-led SEA in a Scottish local authority . European Environment , 14 ( 3 ) : 153 – 164 .
  • Fisher , D. 1992 . The Resource Management Legislation of 1991: a Juridical Analysis of its Objectives in Resource Management. , Wellington , NZ : Booker and Friend. .
  • Fookes , T. 2000 . “ Environmental assessment under the Resource Management Act 1991 ” . In Environmental Planning and Management in New Zealand Edited by: Memon , P. A. and Perkins , H. C. 80 – 93 . Palmerston North NZ: Dunmore Press
  • Fookes , T. 2002 . Auckland's Regional Growth Strategy 2050: an application of strategic environmental assessment , Auckland , NZ : University of Auckland . Department of Planning Working Paper Series
  • Glasson , J. and Gosling , J. 2001 . SEA and regional planning — overcoming the institutional constraints: some lessons from the EU . European Environment , 11 ( 2 ) : 89 – 102 .
  • Gleeson , B. 2000 . “ The politics of consent notification ” . In Environmental Planning and Management in New Zealand , Edited by: Memon , P. A. and Perkins , H. C. 115 – 122 . Palmerston North , NZ : Dunmore Press .
  • Jackson , T. and Dixon , J. The New Zealand Resource Management Act: an exercise in delivering sustainable development through an ecological modernisation agenda . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design. , in press
  • Jackson , T. and Illsley , B. M. 2006 . Strategic environmental assessment as a tool of environmental governance: Scotland's extension of the European Union SEA Directive . Journal of Environmental Planning and Management , 49 ( 3 ) : 361 – 383 .
  • Jackson , T. and Illsley , B. M. Analysis of the theoretical rationale for using strategic environmental assessment to deliver environmental justice in the light of the Scottish Environmental Assessment Act . Environmental Impact Assessment Review. , in press
  • Jordan , A. , Wurzel , R. K W and Zito , A. R. 2003 . ‘New’ Instruments of Environmental Governance: National Experiences and Prospects. , London : Frank Cass. .
  • Marsden , S. 2002 . “ Strategic environmental assessment: an international overview ” . In Strategic Environmental Assessment in Australasia , Edited by: Marsden , S. and Dovers , S. 1 – 23 . Annan-dale , NSW : The Federation Press .
  • MfE, Ministry of the Environment . 2000 . What Are The Options? A Guide to Using Section 32 of the Resource Management Act. , Wellington , NZ : Ministry of the Environment. .
  • PCE, Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment . 2002 . Creating Our Future: Sustainable Development for New Zealand. , Wellington , NZ : Office of the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment. .
  • PKC, Perth and Kinross Council . 2002a . Towards a Sustainable Future: Sustainability Appraisal — Finalized Perth and Kinross Structure Plan. , Perth , , UK : Perth and Kinross Council Planning and Development Services. .
  • PKC, Perth and Kinross Council . 2002b . Towards a sustainable future: Perth and Kinross Structure Plan finalized written statement , Perth , , UK : Perth and Kinross Council Planning and Development Services .
  • RMA, Resource Management Act . 1991 . Resource Management Act 1991. , Wellington , NZ : Brooker and Friend. .
  • SE, Scottish Executive . 2003 . A partnership for a better Scotland: joint statement by the leaders of the Scottish Labour Party and the Scottish Liberal Democrats , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive .
  • SEDD, Scottish Executive Development Department . 1999a . Environmental Impact Assessment (Scotland) Regulations 1999: Circular 15/99 , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Development Department .
  • SEDD, Scottish Executive Development Department . 1999b . Planning Advice Note 58: environmental impact assessment (PAN 58) , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Development Department .
  • SEDD, Scottish Executive Development Department . 2002 . Scottish Planning Policy: the Planning System (SPP1). , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Development Department. .
  • SEEG, Scottish Executive Environment Group . 2002 . Meeting the Needs: Priorities, Actions and Targets for a Sustainable Scotland. , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Environment Group. .
  • SEEG, Scottish Executive Environment Group . 2004 . Strategic Environmental Assessment: A Consultation Paper on the Proposed Environmental Assessment (Scotland) Bill. , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Environment Group. .
  • SEEG, Scottish Executive Environment Group . 2005 . The Environmental Assessment (Scotland) Bill 2005: Summary of consultation comments and Scottish Executive response , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Environment Group . Paper 2005/3
  • SEIS, Scottish Executive Information Service . 2005 . News release on Environmental Assessment Bill 03/03/2005 , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Information Service .
  • SESDD . 2005 . Choosing our Future: Scotland's New Sustainable Development Strategy. , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Executive Sustainable Development Division .
  • Short , M. , Jones , C. , Carter , J. , Baker , M. and Wood , C. 2003 . Current practice in the strategic environmental assessment of development plans in England . Regional Studies , 38 ( 2 ) : 177 – 190 .
  • Skelton , P. and Memon , A. 2002 . Adopting sustainability as an overarching environmental policy: a review of Section 5 of the RMA . Resource Management Journal , X ( 1 ) : 1 – 10 .
  • Smith , P. and Sheate , W. R. 2001 . Sustainability appraisal of English regional plans: incorporating the requirements of the EU Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive . Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal , 19 ( 4 ) : 263 – 276 . December
  • SO, Scottish Office . 1998 . Travel choices for Scotland: the Scottish Integrated Transport , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Office . White Paper Cm 4010
  • SPCB, Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body . 2005 . Environmental Assessment (Scotland) Bill: Explanatory Notes and Other Accompanying Documents. , Edinburgh , , UK : Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. .
  • Therivel , R. and Minas , P. 2002 . Ensuring effective sustainability appraisal . Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal , 20 ( 2 ) : 81 – 91 . June
  • Therivel , R. , Wilson , E. , Thompson , S. , Heaney , D. and Pritchard , D. 1992 . Strategic Environmental Assessment. , London : Earthscan. .
  • Walsh , F. and Brand , J. 1998 . Environmental appraisal in Scotland – local editority experiences , Glasgow : University of Strathclyde . Papers on Planning no 32
  • WCC, Waitakere City Council . 1995 . Section 32 record — a record of action taken and documentation prepared by Waitakere City Council in discharge of its duties pursuant to Section 32 of the Resource Management Act in respect of the proposed district plan , Auckland , NZ : Waitakere City Council .
  • Willis , G. 2003 . Drafting Issues, Objectives, Policies and Methods in Regional Policy Statements and District Plans. , Wellington , NZ : Enfocus Limited for Ministry for the Environment. .
  • WWF-Scotland, Worldwide Fund for Nature . 2001 . Scotland still lacks a coherent sustainable development strategy despite latest initiative , London : Faversham House Group . Press release. Edie Weekly Summaries, 19 October

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.