Medical students’ general and radiology-specific motivation: Correlations, stability and associations with learning strategies and ability beliefs

Abstract

Purpose

This study investigated general and subject-specific motivational beliefs from the perspectives of self-determination theory (i.e. intrinsic, identified, introjected, and extrinsic motivation) and achievement goal theory (i.e. mastery, performance-approach, and -avoidance goal orientation including the respective classroom goal structures), their interrelations, their stability over time, and their associations with desirable outcomes (i.e. deep-level learning strategies, self-concept of ability). It was hypothesized that motivational beliefs are interrelated but demonstrate a distinct correlational pattern depending on whether they were assessed as general or subject-specific motivation. In addition, motivational beliefs were hypothesized to relate to learning strategies and ability beliefs.

Methods

Medical students (n = 146) participated in this longitudinal study with measurement points at the beginning and end of a semester. The questionnaire included established motivational scales to assess motivational beliefs and desirable outcomes. Measurement models were tested using confirmatory factor analyses; correlations of scale means were investigated to assess the nomological network of motivational beliefs.

Results

As expected, intrinsic and identified motivation were associated with mastery goal orientation and with desirable outcome variables, such as the use of deep-level learning strategies. General and subject-specific motivation exhibited distinct correlational patterns. Motivation was relatively stable over time. Results did not confirm the factor structure of classroom goal structure.

Conclusions

The study emphasizes the benefit of a subject-specific conceptualization of motivation and the need for a careful adaptation of theoretical constructs from the secondary school context to make them fruitful for the promotion of medical students’ motivation. Medical teachers can use established motivational interventions (e.g. using an individual frame of reference for feedback) to support students’ adaptive motivational beliefs (e.g. self-determined motivation, mastery goals). Given the subject specificity of motivation, it seems beneficial to promote adaptive motivation in the respective medical specialty regardless of students’ general motivational characteristics.

Keywords:

• Motivation
• self-determination theory
• achievement goal theory
• intrinsic motivation
• learning strategies

Disclosure statement

The authors have no declarations of interest to report.

Additional information

Funding

The author(s) reported there is no funding associated with the work featured in this article.

Notes on contributors

Julia Gorges

Julia Gorges, Prof. Dr., Institute of Educational Science, Philipps-University Marburg, Marburg, Germany.

Laureen Fröhlich

Laureen Fröhlich, M.A., Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Hospital, Philipps-University Marburg.

Andreas H. Mahnken

Andreas H. Mahnken, Prof. Dr., Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Hospital, Philipps-University Marburg.