2,053
Views
73
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original

The effectiveness of academic admission interviews: an exploratory meta-analysis

&
Pages 335-340 | Published online: 03 Jul 2009

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (19)

Hak Yung Ng, Jane Anderson, Lorna Marson & David Hope. (2023) A “Red Flag” system adds value to medical school admissions interviews. Medical Teacher 0:0, pages 1-6.
Read now
Paula Lehane, Zita Lysaght & Michael O’Leary. (2023) A validity perspective on interviews as a selection mechanism for entry to initial teacher education programmes. European Journal of Teacher Education 46:2, pages 293-307.
Read now
Ali Khodi, Hossein Khezerlou & Hassan Sahraei. (2022) Dependability and utility of using e-portfolios in assessing EFL learners’ speaking proficiency. Computer Assisted Language Learning 0:0, pages 1-23.
Read now
Matthew G.T. Denney & Robert Tynes. (2021) The Effects of College in Prison and Policy Implications. Justice Quarterly 38:7, pages 1542-1566.
Read now
Eline Sneyers & Kristof De Witte. (2018) Interventions in higher education and their effect on student success: a meta-analysis. Educational Review 70:2, pages 208-228.
Read now
Clare Kreiter, Marie O’Shea, Catherine Bruen, Paul Murphy & Teresa Pawlikowska. (2018) A meta-analytic perspective on the valid use of subjective human judgement to make medical school admission decisions. Medical Education Online 23:1.
Read now
Jacqueline E. McLaughlin, David Singer & Wendy C. Cox. (2017) Candidate Evaluation Using Targeted Construct Assessment in the Multiple Mini-Interview: A Multifaceted Rasch Model Analysis. Teaching and Learning in Medicine 29:1, pages 68-74.
Read now
Allan Pau, Yu Sui Chen, Verna Kar Mun Lee, Chew Fei Sow & Ranjit De Alwis. (2016) What does the multiple mini interview have to offer over the panel interview?. Medical Education Online 21:1.
Read now
Robert Schweitzer, Nigar Khawaja, Esben Strodl, Jason Lodge, Joe Coyne & Robert King. (2014) Towards a model for student selection in clinical psychology. Clinical Psychologist 18:3, pages 125-132.
Read now
Nikki Bibler Zaidi, Christopher Swoboda, Leigh Lihshing Wang & R. Stephen Manuel. (2014) Variance in attributes assessed by the multiple mini-interview. Medical Teacher 36:9, pages 794-798.
Read now
Mavourneen Casey, David Wilkinson, Jennifer Fitzgerald, Diann Eley & Jason Connor. (2014) Clinical communication skills learning outcomes among first year medical students are consistent irrespective of participation in an interview for admission to medical school. Medical Teacher 36:7, pages 640-642.
Read now
Allan Pau, Kamalan Jeevaratnam, Yu Sui Chen, Abdoul Aziz Fall, Charmaine Khoo & Vishna Devi Nadarajah. (2013) The Multiple Mini-Interview (MMI) for student selection in health professions training – A systematic review. Medical Teacher 35:12, pages 1027-1041.
Read now
Maciej Walkiewicz, Malgorzata Tartas, Mikolaj Majkowicz & Waldemar Budzinski. (2012) Academic achievement, depression and anxiety during medical education predict the styles of success in a medical career: A 10-year longitudinal study. Medical Teacher 34:9, pages e611-e619.
Read now
J.A. Cleland, F.H. French, P.W. Johnston & on behalf of the Scottish Medical Careers Cohort Study Group. (2011) A mixed-methods study identifying and exploring medical students’ views of the UKCAT. Medical Teacher 33:3, pages 244-249.
Read now
Malgorzata Tartas, Maciej Walkiewicz, Mikolaj Majkowicz & Waldemar Budzinski. (2011) Psychological factors determining success in a medical career: A 10-year longitudinal study. Medical Teacher 33:3, pages e163-e172.
Read now
Tyrone Donnon, Elizabeth Oddone-Paolucci & Claudio Violato. (2009) A predictive validity study of medical judgment vignettes to assess students’ noncognitive attributes: A 3-year prospective longitudinal study. Medical Teacher 31:4, pages e148-e155.
Read now
Edward Helmes & Nancy A. Pachana. (2008) Value of interviews for admission to clinical training programs: Perspective of program directors. Australian Psychologist 43:4, pages 249-256.
Read now
Seyyed-Abdolhamid Mirhosseini, Mojgan Afifezadeh & Leila Tajik. Admission into graduate programmes of English language education: a critical comparative exploration. Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education 0:0, pages 1-11.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (54)

Michael Barth, Arne Güllich, Brooke N. Macnamara & David Z. Hambrick. (2023) Quantifying the Extent to Which Junior Performance Predicts Senior Performance in Olympic Sports: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Sports Medicine.
Crossref
Stefanos A. Tsikas & Kambiz Afshar. (2023) Clinical experience can compensate for inferior academic achievements in an undergraduate objective structured clinical examination. BMC Medical Education 23:1.
Crossref
Stephanie L. Shaver, Daniel S. FoyCarla L. Gartrell. (2023) Attitudes toward Virtual Admissions Interviews among Applicants to a Veterinary School. Journal of Veterinary Medical Education 50:1, pages 89-93.
Crossref
Sang Eun Woo, James M. LeBreton, Melissa G. Keith & Louis Tay. (2022) Bias, Fairness, and Validity in Graduate-School Admissions: A Psychometric Perspective. Perspectives on Psychological Science 18:1, pages 3-31.
Crossref
Idit F. Liberty, Lena Novack, Reli Hershkovitz & Amos Katz. (2022) The roles of personal interview and cognitive abilities at admission to medical school in predicting performance of medical students in their internal medicine sub-internship. BMC Medical Education 22:1.
Crossref
Stefanos A. Tsikas. (2022) Can selection interviews predict OSCE performance? Evidence from Hannover Medical School. Zeitschrift für Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualität im Gesundheitswesen 173, pages 85-91.
Crossref
Christine M. Carmichael, Kerry Callahan Mandulak & Diana Watkins. (2022) Interviews for Graduate Admissions in Communication Sciences and Disorders: Methods From Two CSD Programs. Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups 7:2, pages 426-437.
Crossref
Nicole Duval Reisfeld & Stacy Lyn Kaplan. (2022) Predicting Clinical Skills in Graduate Health Sciences Applicants: A Systematic Review. Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups 7:2, pages 445-462.
Crossref
Katy Mitchell, Jennifer Ellison, Elke Schaumberg, Peggy Gleeson, Christina Bickley, Anna Naiki & Severin Travis. (2021) Examining Demographic and Preadmission Factors Predictive of First Year and Overall Program Success in a Public Physical Therapist Education Program. Journal of Physical Therapy Education 35:3, pages 203-209.
Crossref
Muhammad Adnan Maqbool, Aroona Hashmi, Mehboob Ul Hassan & Fasiha Altaf. (2021) STUDENTS PERCEPTION ABOUT THE ROLE OF INTERVIEW DURING M.PHIL AND PH.D. ADMISSION AT A PUBLIC SECTOR UNIVERSITY OF LAHORE, PUNJAB-PAKISTAN. Humanities & Social Sciences Reviews 9:4, pages 121-132.
Crossref
María Elena Oliveri. 2020. Higher Education Admissions Practices. Higher Education Admissions Practices 1 118 .
A. Susan M. Niessen & Rob R. Meijer. 2020. Higher Education Admissions Practices. Higher Education Admissions Practices 76 95 .
Anastasia Kurysheva, Harold V. M. van Rijen & Gönül Dilaver. (2019) How do admission committees select? Do applicants know how they select? Selection criteria and transparency at a Dutch University. Tertiary Education and Management 25:4, pages 367-388.
Crossref
SL Raidal, J Lord, L Hayes, J Hyams & J Lievaart. (2019) Student selection to a rural veterinary school. 2: predictors of student performance and attrition. Australian Veterinary Journal 97:7, pages 211-219.
Crossref
Claudia Cunningham, Fiona Patterson & Jennifer Cleland. (2018) A literature review of the predictive validity of European dental school selection methods. European Journal of Dental Education 23:2, pages 73-87.
Crossref
Katy Mitchell, Jennifer Ellison & Peggy Gleeson. (2019) Current Practices and Perceptions of Admission Criteria at Physical Therapist Education Programs in the United States. Journal of Physical Therapy Education 33:1, pages 55-63.
Crossref
Anthony JerantMark C. HendersonErin GriffinTheodore R. HallCarolyn J. KellyEllena M. PetersonDavid WofsyDaniel J. TancrediFrancis J. SousaPeter Franks. (2019) Do Admissions Multiple Mini-Interview and Traditional Interview Scores Predict Subsequent Academic Performance? A Study of Five California Medical Schools. Academic Medicine 94:3, pages 388-395.
Crossref
Steven Lillis, Liza Lack, Allan Mbita & Melissa Ashford. (2019) Using the Multiple Mini Interview for selection into vocational general practice training. Journal of Primary Health Care 11:1, pages 75.
Crossref
Fiona Patterson, Eamonn Ferguson & Lara Zibarras. 2018. Understanding Medical Education. Understanding Medical Education 375 388 .
Steven E. Gay, Sally A. Santen, Rajesh S. Mangrulkar, Thomas H. Sisson, Paula T. Ross & Nikki L. Bibler Zaidi. (2017) The influence of MCAT and GPA preadmission academic metrics on interview scores. Advances in Health Sciences Education 23:1, pages 151-158.
Crossref
Mirjana Knorr, Johanna Hissbach & Wolfgang Hampe. 2018. Selection and Recruitment in the Healthcare Professions. Selection and Recruitment in the Healthcare Professions 113 138 .
Marshall RossIan WalkerLara CookeMaitreyi RamanPietro RavaniSylvain CoderreKevin McLaughlin. (2017) Are Female Applicants Rated Higher Than Males on the Multiple Mini-Interview? Findings From the University of Calgary. Academic Medicine 92:6, pages 841-846.
Crossref
R. McAndrew, J. Ellis & R. A. Valentine. (2017) Does a selection interview predict year 1 performance in dental school?. European Journal of Dental Education 21:2, pages 108-112.
Crossref
Nikki L. Bibler Zaidi, Christopher M. Swoboda, Benjamin M. Kelcey & R. Stephen Manuel. (2016) Hidden item variance in multiple mini-interview scores. Advances in Health Sciences Education 22:2, pages 337-363.
Crossref
Steven E. Gay, Sally A. Santen, Rajesh S. Mangrulkar, Thomas H. Sisson, Paula T. Ross & Nikki L. Bibler Zaidi. (2016) The Influence of MCAT and GPA Preadmission Academic Metrics on Interview Scores. Academic Medicine 91:11, pages S14-S15.
Crossref
Guilaine Kinouani, Jeyda Ibrahim, Julie Baah, Julie Baah, Amen Hasham & Vasiliki Stamatopoulou. (2016) ‘I tried to sound like someone I thought courses would choose’: Navigating marginalised experiences during clinical psychology interviews. Clinical Psychology Forum 1:283, pages 3-7.
Crossref
Anne-Victoire Fayolle, Catherine Passirani, Elisabeth Letertre, Aline Ramond, Dominique Perrotin, Jean-Paul Saint-André & Isabelle Richard. (2016) Sélection des étudiants en médecine : facteurs prédictifs de réussite ; une revue systématique de la littérature. La Presse Médicale 45:5, pages 483-494.
Crossref
Sheryl MacMath & Barbara Salingré. (2015) Evaluating intake variables for a teacher education programme: Improving student success and process efficiency. Studies in Educational Evaluation 47, pages 76-82.
Crossref
Sandra Nicholson & Jennifer Cleland. 2015. Researching Medical Education. Researching Medical Education 231 244 .
J. I. Foley & K. Hijazi. (2015) Predictive value of the admissions process and the UK Clinical Aptitude Test in a graduate-entry dental school. British Dental Journal 218:12, pages 687-689.
Crossref
Malgorzata Tartas, Maciej Walkiewicz, Waldemar Budzinski, Mikolaj Majkowicz & Krzysztof Wojcikiewicz. (2014) The sense of coherence and styles of success in the medical career: a longitudinal study. BMC Medical Education 14:1.
Crossref
Nana Sartania, John D McClure, Helen Sweeting & Allison Browitt. (2014) Predictive power of UKCAT and other pre-admission measures for performance in a medical school in Glasgow: a cohort study. BMC Medical Education 14:1.
Crossref
Amber J. Heck. (2014) Students’ Activities in a Pre-matriculation Course as a Predictor of Initial Academic Performance in Medical School. Medical Science Educator 24:3, pages 239-243.
Crossref
Michelle L. Finch, Debra Rose Wilson, Kelly Symonds & Kim Floyd-Tune. (2014) Being Interviewed for Admission to a BSN Program: A Qualitative Inquiry. Advances in Nursing 2014, pages 1-5.
Crossref
Katrina Scior, Caroline E. Bradley, Henry W. W. Potts, Katherine Woolf & Amanda C de C Williams. (2014) What predicts performance during clinical psychology training?. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 53:2, pages 194-212.
Crossref
Phillip Eugene Jones, Susan Simpkins & Jennie Alicea Hocking. (2014) Imperfect physician assistant and physical therapist admissions processes in the United States. Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions 11, pages 11.
Crossref
Julia Levashina, Christopher J. Hartwell, Frederick P. Morgeson & Michael A. Campion. (2014) The Structured Employment Interview: Narrative and Quantitative Review of the Research Literature. Personnel Psychology 67:1, pages 241-293.
Crossref
David WilkinsonMavourneen G CaseyDiann S Eley. (2014) Removing the interview for medical school selection is associated with gender bias among enrolled students. Medical Journal of Australia 200:2, pages 96-99.
Crossref
R. McAndrew & R. Greatrix. (2014) The UKCAT test: developments, research and its use by dental schools in the UK. British Dental Journal 216:4, pages 191-194.
Crossref
Margit I Vermeulen, Marijke M Kuyvenhoven, Nicolaas P A Zuithoff, Yolanda van der Graaf & Roger A M J Damoiseaux. (2013) Dutch postgraduate GP selection procedure; reliability of interview assessments. BMC Family Practice 14:1.
Crossref
Fiona Patterson, Eamonn Ferguson & Alec L Knight. 2013. Understanding Medical Education. Understanding Medical Education 401 420 .
Sabine Tötemeyer. (2013) Selecting the right students. Veterinary Record 173:15, pages 366-367.
Crossref
N. P. H. Hudson, S. M. Rhind, D. J. Shaw, G. M. Giannopoulos, C. A. Phillips & R. J. Mellanby. (2013) The influence of interview on decision making and selection of prospective veterinary undergraduate students. Veterinary Record 173:15, pages 368-368.
Crossref
E. Jaramillo G. Luis & Martín C. Elena. (2012) Evaluación integral de residentes de psiquiatría: un complemento del proceso de admisión al programa. Revista Colombiana de Psiquiatría 41, pages 104S-112S.
Crossref
Lotte Dyhrberg O’Neill, Birgitta Wallstedt, Berit Eika & Jan Hartvigsen. (2011) Factors associated with dropout in medical education: a literature review. Medical Education 45:5, pages 440-454.
Crossref
HyeRin Roh. (2010) The Admission Interview in Medical Schools. Korean Medical Education Review 12:2, pages 13-18.
Crossref
Andrew B Lumb, Matthew Homer & Amy Miller. (2010) Equity in interviews: do personal characteristics impact on admission interview scores?. Medical Education 44:11, pages 1077-1083.
Crossref
Bonnie Lynch, Rhoda MacKenzie, Jon Dowell, Jennifer Cleland & Gordon Prescott. (2009) Does the UKCAT predict Year 1 performance in medical school?. Medical Education 43:12, pages 1203-1209.
Crossref
N. P. H. Hudson, S. M. Rhind, L. J. Moore, S. Dawson, M. Kilyon, K. Braithwaite, J. Wason & R. J. Mellanby. (2009) Admissions processes at the seven United Kingdom veterinary schools: a review. Veterinary Record 164:19, pages 583-587.
Crossref
Lotte D O’Neill, Lars Korsholm, Birgitta Wallstedt, Berit Eika & Jan Hartvigsen. (2009) Generalisability of a composite student selection programme. Medical Education 43:1, pages 58-65.
Crossref
David WilkinsonJianzhen ZhangGerard J ByrneHaida LukeIeva Z OzolinsMalcolm H ParkerRaymond F Peterson. (2008) Medical school selection criteria and the prediction of academic performance. Medical Journal of Australia 188:6, pages 349-354.
Crossref
Ralph R Utzman, Daniel L Riddle & Dianne V Jewell. (2007) Author Response. Physical Therapy 87:9, pages 1197-1198.
Crossref
Jean-François Lemay, Jocelyn M Lockyer, V Terri Collin & A Keith W Brownell. (2007) Assessment of non-cognitive traits through the admissions multiple mini-interview. Medical Education 41:6, pages 573-579.
Crossref
Chris McManusDavid Powis. (2007) Testing medical school selection tests. Medical Journal of Australia 186:3, pages 118-119.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.