Advanced search
Publication Cover
International Journal of Hyperthermia Volume 18, 2002 - Issue 5
Submit an article Journal homepage
602
Views
57
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Article

Hyperthermic teratogenicity, thermal dose and diagnostic ultrasound during pregnancy: implications of new standards on tissue heating

M. W. Miller Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, School of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14642-0001, USA
,
W. L. Nyborg Department of Physics, The University of Vermont, Burlington, VT 05405-0001, USA
,
W. C. Dewey Radiation Oncology Research Laboratory, University of California at San Francisco, 1855 Folsom Street, MCB 200, San Francisco, CA 94103-0806, USA
,
M. J. Edwards Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences, University of Sydney and University of New South Wales, School of Anatomy, Sydney, NSW, Australia
,
J. S. Abramowicz Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Department of Radiology, School of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14642-0001, USA
&
A. A. Brayman Center for Industrial and Medical Ultrasound, Applied Physics Laboratory, 1013 NE 40th Street, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98105-6698, USA
Pages 361-384 | Published online: 09 Jul 2009

  • Miller MW, Ziskin MC. Biological consequences of hyperthermia. Ultrasound Med Biol 1989; 15: 707-22.
  • National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (US). Exposure Criteria for Medical Diagnostic Ultrasound. I: Criteria Based on Thermal Mechanisms. Bethesda, MD: NCRP Report No. 113; 1992.
  • National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (US). Exposure Criteria for Medical Diagnostic Ultrasound: Criteria Based on All Known Mechanisms. Bethesda, MD: NCRP Report 140; 2002, in press.
  • Sapareto SA, Dewey WC. Thermal dose determination in cancer therapy. Int J Radit Oncol 1984; 10: 787-800.
  • Westra A, Dewey WC. Variation in sensitivity to heat shock during the cell cycle of Chinese hamster cells in vitro. Int J Radiat Biol 1971; 19: 467-77.
  • Dewey WC. Arrhenius relationships from the molecule and cell to the clinic. Int J Hyperthermia 1994; 10: 457-83.
  • Johnson FH, Eyring H, Palissar MJ. The Kinetic Basis of Molecular Biology. New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, 1954; 3, 199, 220, 221, 232, 251, 272, 460.
  • Dewey WC, Hopwood LE, Sapareto SA, Gerweck LE. Cellular responses to combinations of hyperthermia and radiation. Radiology 1977; 123: 463-74.
  • van den Berg-Blok AE, Reinhold HS. Time-temperature relationship for hyperthermia induced stoppage of the microcirculation in tumors. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 1984; 10: 737-40.
  • Dewey WC, Li XL, Wong RS. Cell killing, chromosomal aberrations, and division delay as thermal sensitivity is modified during the cell cycle. Radiat Res 1990; 122: 268-74.
  • Zielke-Temme B, Hopwood L. Time-lapse cinemicrographic observations of heated G1phase Chinese hamster ovary cells. I. Division probabilities and generation times. Radiat Res 1982; 92: 320-31.
  • Raaphorst GP, Romano SL, Mitchell JB, Bedford JS, Dewey WC. Intrinsic differences in heat and/or x-ray sensitivity of seven mammalian cell lines cultured and treated under identical conditions. Cancer Res 1979; 39: 396-401.
  • Roizin-Towle L, Pirro JP. The response of human and rodent cells to hyperthermia Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 1991; 20: 751-6.
  • Mirkes PE. Effects of acute exposures to elevated temperatures on rat embryo growth and development in vitro. Teratology 1985; 32: 259-66.
  • Edwards MJ, Mulley R, Ring S, Wanner RA. Mitotic cell death and delay in mitotic activity in guinea pig embryos following brief maternal hyperthermia. J Embryol Exp Morph 1974; 32: 593-602.
  • Sarge KD, Bray AE, Goodson ML. Altered stress response in testis. Nature 1995; 374: 126.
  • Edwards MJ. Congenital defects in guinea pigs: fetal resorptions, abortions, and malformations following induced hyperthermia during early gestation. Teratology 1969; 2: 31328.
  • Edwards MJ. Clinical disorders of fetal brain development defects due to hyperthermia In: Hetzel BS, Smith DW, eds, Fetal Brain Disorders-Recent Approaches to the Problem of Mental Deficiency. Amsterdam, Holland: Elsevier/North Holland Biomedical Press, 1981; 421-44.
  • Webster WS, Edwards MJ. Hyperthermia and the induction of neural tube defects in mice. Teratology 1984; 29: 417-25.
  • Germain MA, Webster WS, Edwards MJ. Hyperthermia as a teratogen: parameters determining hyperthermia-induced head defects in the rat. Teratology 1985; 31: 265-72.
  • Edwards MJ. Hyperthermia as a teratogen: a review of experimental studies and their clinical significance. Teratogen Carcinogen Mutagen 1986; 6: 563-82.
  • Kimmel CA, Cuff JM, Kimmel GL, Heredia DJ, Tudor N, Silverman PM, Chen J. Skeletal development following heat exposure in the rat. Teratology 1993; 47: 229-42.
  • Palmer AK. Sporadic malformations in laboratory animals and their influence on drug testing. In: Klingberg MA, Abramowici A, Churnke J., eds. Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, Vol. 27. Drugs and Fetal Development. New York, NY: Plenum Press, 1972; 45-60.
  • Edwards MJ. Congenital malformations in the rat following induced hyperthermia during gestation. Teratology 1968; 1: 173-8.
  • McClain RM, Hoar RM, Saltzman MB. Teratologie study of rats exposed to ultrasound Am J Obstet Gynecol 1972; 114: 39-42.
  • Arora KL, Cohen BJ, Beaudoin AR. Fetal and placenta! responses to artificially induced hyperthermia in rats. Teratology 1979; 19: 251-60.
  • Webster WS, Germain M, Edwards MJ. The induction of microphthalmia, encephalocele, and other head defects following hyperthermia during the gastrulation process in the rat. Teratology 1985; 31: 73-82.
  • Sasaki J, Yamaguchi A, Nabeshima Y, Shigemitsu S, Mesaki N, Kubo T. Exercise at high temperature causes maternal hyperthermia and fetal anomalies in rats. Teratology 1995; 51: 233-6.
  • National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (NCRP). Biological Effects of Ultrasound: Mechanisms and Clinical Implications. Bethesda, MD: NCRP Report No. 74; 1983.
  • Edwards MJ. Congenital defects in guinea-pigs: prenatal retardation of brain growth of guinea-pigs following hyperthermia during gestation. Teratology 1969; 2: 329-36.
  • Shiota K. Induction of neural tube defects and skeletal malformations in mice following brief hyperthermia in utero. Biol Neonate 1988; 53: 86-97.
  • Ventura SJ, Mosher WD, Curtin SC, Abma JC, Henshaw S. Trends in pregnancy rates for the United States, 1976-97: an update, Nat Vital Slat Rep 2001; 49: 1-9.
  • Skreb N, Frank Z. Developmental abnormalities in the rat induced by heat shock. J Embryol Exp Morph 1963; 11: 445-57.
  • Cockroft DL, New DAT. Abnormalities induced in cultured rat embryos by hyperthermia. Teratology 1978; 17: 277-84.
  • Walsh DA, Klein NW, Hightower LE, Edwards MJ. Heat shock and thermotoleranoe during early rat embryo development Teratology 1987; 36: 181-91.
  • Wanner RA, Edwards MJ, Wright RG. The effects of hyperthermia on the neuroepithelium of the 21-day guinea pig embryo: histologie and ultrastructural study. J Path 1976; 118:235-44.
  • Upfold JB, Smith MSR, Edwards MJ. Quantitative study of the effects of maternal hyperthermia on cell death and proliferation in the guinea pig brain on day 21 of pregnancy. Teratology 1989; 39: 173-9.
  • Breen JG, Claggett TW, Kimmel GL, Kimmel CA. Heat shock during rat embryo development in vitro results in decreased mitosis and abundant cell death. Reprod Toxicol 1999; 13: 31-9.
  • Edwards MJ, Wanner RA, Mulley RC. Growth and development of the brain in normal and heat-retarded guinea pigs. Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol 1976; 2: 439-50.
  • Walsh D, Li K, Zeng F, Zhe L, Edwards MJ. Heat shock genes and cell cycle regulation in early mammalian development In: Mayer J, Brown IR, eds. Heat Shock Proteins in the Nervous System. London, UK: Academic Press, 1994; 123-44.
  • Walsh DA, Morris VB. Heat shock affects cell cycling in the neural plate of cultured rat embryos a flow cytometric study. Teratology 1989; 40: 583-92.
  • Walsh DA, Li K, Spiers J, Crowther CE, Edwards MJ. Regulation of the inducible heat shock 71 genes in early neural development of cultured rat embryos. Teratology 1989; 40: 321-34.
  • Dobbing J, Sands J. Growth and development of the brain and spinal cord of the guinea pig. Brain Res. 1970; 17: 115-23.
  • Li ZL, Shiota K. Stage-specific homeotic vertebral transformations in mouse fetuses induced by maternal hyperthermia during somitogenesis. Develop Dynamics 1999; 216: 336-48.
  • Nilsen NO. Vascular abnormalities due to hyperthermia in chick embryos. Teratology 1984; 30: 237-51.
  • Webster WS, Lipson AH, Brown-Woodman PDC. Uterine trauma and limb defects. Teratology 1987; 35: 253-60.
  • Webster WS, Lipson AH, Brown-Woodman PDC, Osborn RA. Moebius unmasked: pathogenesis of the moebius syndrome in an animal model. Teratology 1988; 38: 199.
  • Edwards MJ. Congenital defects in guinea pigs following induced hyperthermia during gestation. Archiv. Pathol. 1967; 84: 42-8.
  • Mirkes PE. Effects of acute exposure to elevated temperatures on rat embryo growth and development in vitro. Teratology 1985; 32: 259-66.
  • Mirkes PE, Doggett B. Accumulation of heat shock protein 72 (hsp 72) in postimplantation rat embryos after exposure to various periods of hyperthermia (40-43°C) in vitro: evidence that heat shock protein 72 is a biomarker of heat induced embryotoxicity. Teratology 1992; 46: 251-9.
  • Kimmel GL, Cuff JM, Kimmel CA, Heredia DJ, Tudor N, Silverman PM. Embryonic development in vitro following short-duration exposure to heat. Teratology 1993; 47: 24351.
  • Cuff JM, Kimmel GL, Kimmel CA, Heredia DJ, Tudor N, Chen J. Relationship between abnormal somite development and axial skeletal defects in rats following heat exposure. Teratology 1993; 48: 259-66.
  • Angles JM, Walsh DA, Li K, Barnett SB, Edwards MJ. Effects of pulsed ultrasound and temperature on the development of rat embryos in culture. Teratology 1990; 42: 285-93.
  • Nakashima K, Kawamata A, Fujiki I, Fujiki Y. The individual and combined effects of xirradiation and hyperthermia on early somite mouse embryos in culture. Teratology 1991; 44: 635-9.
  • Shepard TH. Catalog of Teratogenic Agents, 8th edn. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1989.
  • Smith DW, Clarren SK, Harvey MAS. Hyperthermia as a possible teratogenic agent. J Pediatrics 1978; 92: 878-83.
  • Erickson JD. Risk factors for birth defects: data from the Atlanta birth defects casecontrol study. Teratology 1991; 43: 41-51.
  • Milunsky A, Ulcickas M, Rothman KJ, Willett W, Jick S, Jick H. Maternal heat exposure and neural tube defects. J Amer Med Assoc 1992; 268: 882-5.
  • Sohar E, Shoenfeld Y, Shapiro Y, Ohry A, Cabili S. Effects of exposure to Finnish sauna. Israel Med ScI 1976; 12: 1275-82.
  • Chambers CD, Johnson KA, Dick LM, Felix RJ, Jones KL. Maternal fever and birth outcome: a perspective study. Teratology 1998; 58: 251-7.
  • Romijn JA, Treffers PE. Anencephaly in the Netherlands: a remarkable decline. Lancet 1983; 1: 64-5.
  • Seller MJ, Hancock PC. Is recurrence rate of neural tube defects declining? Lancet 1985; 1 : 175.
  • Owens JR, Simpkin JM, Harris F. Recurrence rates for neural tube defects. Lancet 1985; 1: 1282.
  • Holmes LB, Driscoll SG, Atkins L. Etiologic heterogeneity of neural-tube defects. New Engl J Med 1976; 294: 365-9.
  • Medical Research Council. Prevention of neural tube defects: results of the Medical Research Council vitamin study. Lancet 1991; 338: 131-7.
  • Czeizel AE, Dudas I. Prevention of the first occurrence of neural-tube defects by periconceptional vitamin supplementation. New Engl J Med 1992; 327: 1832-35.
  • Limb CJ, Holmes LB. Anencephaly: changes in prenatal detection and birth status, 19721990. Am J Obstet Gyn 1994; 170: 1333-8.
  • Zimmer EZ, Avaham Z, Sujoy P, Goldstein I, Bronshtein AM. The influence of prenatal ultrasound on the prevalence of congenital anomalies at birth. Prenat Diagnosis 1997; 17: 623-8.
  • Takabayashi T, Sato S, Sato A, Ozawa N, Sou S, Yajima A, Suzuki M. Influence of pulsewave ultrasonic irradiation on the prenatal development of mouse. Tohoku J Exp Med 1985; 147: 403-10.
  • Kimmel CA, Stratmeyer ME, Galloway WD, Laborde JB, Brown N, Pinkavitch F. The embryotoxic effects of ultrasound exposure on pregnant ICR mice. Teratology 1983; 27: 245-51.
  • Kim HL, Picciano MF, O'Brien Jr, WD. The combined effect of ultrasonic exposure and protein restriction on maternal and fetal mice. Ultrasound Med Biol 1983; 9: 165-75.
  • Kimmel CA, Stratmeyer ME, Galloway WD, Brown NT, Laborde JB, Bates HK. Developmental exposure of mice to pulsed ultrasound. Teratology 1989; 40: 387-93.
  • Shoji R, Murakami U, Shimizu T. Influence of Low-intensity ultrasonic irradiation on prenatal development of two inbred mouse strains. Teratology 1975; 12: 227-31.
  • Stolzenbeig SJ, Torbit CA, Edmonds PD, Taenzer JC. Effects of ultrasound on the mouse exposed at different stages of gestation: acute studies. Radiat Environ Biophysics 1980; 17: 245-70.
  • Child SZ, Carstensen EL, Gates AH, Hall WJ. Testing for the teratogenicity of pulsed ultrasound in mice. Ultrasound Med Biol 1988; 14: 493-8.
  • Takeuchi H, Nakazawa T, Kumakiri K, Kusano R. Experimental studies on ultrasonic doppler method in obstetrics. Ada Obstet Gyn Jap 1970; 17: 11-16.
  • Pizzarello DJ, Vivino A, Madden B, Wolsky A, Keegan AF, Backer M. Effect of pulsed low-power ultrasound on growing tissues. I. Developing mammalian and insect tissue. Exp Cell Biol 1978; 46: 179-91.
  • Sikov MR, Hildebrand BP. Effects of ultrasound on the prenatal development of the rat. Part I. 3.2 MHz continuous wave at nine days of gestation. J. Clin. Ultrasound 1976; 4: 357-63.
  • Child SZ, Carstensen EL, Davis H. A test for the effects of low-temporal-average-intensity pulsed ultrasound on the rat fetus. Exp Cell Biol 1984; 52: 207-10.
  • Abraham V, Ziskin MC, Heyner S. Temperature elevation in the rat fetus due to ultrasound exposure. Ultrasound Med Biol 1989; 15: 443-9.
  • Barnett SB, Walsh DA, Angles JA. Novel approach to evaluate the interaction of pulsed ultrasound with embryonic development Ultrasonics 1990; 28: 166-70.
  • LeIe PP. Ultrasonic teratology in mouse and man. Excerpta Medico Int Congr Series 1975; 363: 22-7.
  • Carstensen EL, Gates AH. The effects of pulsed ultrasound on the fetus. J Ultrasound Med 1984; 3: 145-7.
  • Carstensen EL, Gates AH. Ultrasound and the fetus. In: Nyborg WL, Ziskin MC eds. Biological Effects of Ultrasound. New York, NY: Churchill Livingstone, Inc., 1985; 85-95.
  • Tarantal AF, Hendrickx AG. Evaluation of the bioeffects of prenatal ultrasound exposure in the cynomolgus macaque (Macaco fascicularis): I. Neonatal/infant observations. Teratology 1989; 39: 137-47.
  • Tarantal AF, Hendrickx AG. Evaluation of the bioeffects of prenatal ultrasound exposure in the cynomolgus macaque (Macaco fascicularis): II. Growth and behavior during the first year. Teratology 1989; 39: 149-62.
  • American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine (AIUM). Officiai Statement an In Vivo Mammalian Bioeffects. Bethesda, MD: AIUM, 1987.
  • American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine (AIUM). Official Statement on Safety in Training and Research. Bethesda, MD: AIUM, 1988.
  • American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine (AIUM). Official Statement on In Vivo Mammalian Bioeffects. Bethesda, MD: AIUM, 1993.
  • World Federation for Ultrasound in Medicine and Biology. WFUMB symposium on safety of ultrasound in medicine. Ultrasound Med Biol 1998; 24 (Suppl 1): 51-55.
  • American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine, and the National Electrical Manufacturers' Association. Standard for Real-Time Display of Thermal and Mechanical Acoustic Output Indices on Diagnostic Ultrasound Devices. Bethesda, MD: AIUM, 1992.
  • Food and Drug Administratioa Center for Devices and Radiological Health. Use of Mechanical Index in Place of Spatial Peak, Pulse Average Intensity in Determining Substantial Equivalence. Rockville, MD: FDA, 1994.
  • Food and Drug Administration, Center for Devices and Radiological Health. 510(k) Guide for Measuring and Reporting Acoustic Output of Diagnostic Ultrasound Medical Devices. Rockville, MD: FDA, 1985.
  • Food and Drug Administration, Center for Devices and Radiological Health. Revised 510(k) Diagnostic Ultrasound Guidance for 1993. Rockville, MD: FDA, 1993.
  • Food and Drug Administration, Center for Devices and Radiological Health. 510 (k) Diagnostic Ultrasound Guidance Update for 1991. Rockville, MD: FDA, 1991.
  • Abramowicz JS. Ultrasound contrast media and their use in obstetrics and gynecology. Ultrasound Med Biol. 1997; 23: 1287-98.
  • Kremkau FW, Merritt CR, Carson PL, Needleman L, Nelson TR, Pretorius DH, Rubin JM. The American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine and the Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound-future directions in diagnostic ultrasound. Radiology 1998:209:305-11.
  • O'Brien Jr. WD, Miller D. Diagnostic ultrasound should be performed without upper intensity limits. Point-counter point Med Phys 2001 ; 28: 1-3.
  • Ewigman BG, Crane JP, Frigoletto FD, LeFevre ML, Bain RP, McNellis D. Effect of prenatal ultrasound screening on perinatal outcome. RADIUS study group. New Engl J Med 1993; 329: 821-7.
  • Campbell JD, Elford RW, Brant RF. Case-control study of prenatal ultrasonography in children with delayed speech. Can Med Assoc 1993; 149: 1435-40.
  • Newnham JP, Evans SF, Michael CA, Stanley FJ, Landau LI. Effects of frequent ultrasound during pregnancy: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 1993; 342: 887-91.
  • Kieler H, Ah Is ten G, Haglund B, Salvesen K, Axelsson O. Routine ultrasound screening in pregnancy and the children's subsequent neurologic development Obstet Gynecol 1998:91:750-6.
  • Barnett SB, ter Haar GR, Ziskin MC, Nyborg WL, Maeda K, Bang J. Current status of research in biophysical effects of ultrasound Ultrasound Med Biol 1994; 20: 205-18.
  • International Non-ionizing Radiation Committee of the International Radiation Protection Associatioa IRPA/INIRC guidelines: protection of the patient undergoing a magnetic resonance examination. Health Physics 1991; 61: 923-8.
  • Hill CR. Acoustic intensity measurements on ultrasonic diagnostic devices. In: Bock J, Ossoinig, KC, eds. Ultrasonographia Medico. Vienna: Vienna Academy of Medicine, 1970; 21-7.
  • Rooney JA. Determination of acoustic power outputs in the microwatt-milliwatt range. Ultrasound Med Biol 1973; 1: 13-6.
  • Carson PL, Fischella PR, Oughton TV. Ultrasonic power and intensities produced by diagnostic ultrasound equipment Ultrasound Med Biol 1978; 3: 341-50.
  • Duck FA, Starritt HC, Aindow JD, Perkins MA, Hawkins AJ. The output of pulse-echo equipment a survey of powers, pressures and intensities. Br J Radial 1985; 58:989-1001.
  • Stewart HF, Silvis PX, Smith SW. Patient-exposure data for doppler ultrasound in clinics. In: Kisslo J, Adam D, Mach DB, eds. Diagnostic Ultrasound. VoI 17. Basic Doppler Echocardiography. NY: Churchchill-Livingstone, 1986; 187-95.
  • National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements (US). Biological Affects of Ultrasound: Mechanisms and Clinical Implications. Bethesda, MD: NCRP Report No. 74. 1983.
  • Robertson VJ, Baker KG. A review of therapeutic ultrasound effectiveness studies. Physical Ther 2001; 81: 1339-50.
  • McLeod DR, Fowlow SB. Multiple malformations and exposure to therapeutic ultrasound during organogenesis. Am J Med Genetics 1989; 34: 317-9.
  • Patton CA, Harris GR, Phillips RA. Output levels and bioeffects indices from diagnostic ultrasound exposure data reported to the FDA. IEEE UFFC. 1994; 41: 353-9.
  • Shaw A, Pay NM, Preston RC. Assessment of the likely thermal index values for pulsed doppler ultrasonic equipment-stages II and III: experimental assessment of scanner/transducer combinations. National Physical Laboratory (NPL). Middlesex, UK: NPL Report CMAM 1998, 12:71.
  • Bacon DR, Shaw A. Experimental validation of predicted temperature rises in tissuemimicking materials. Phys Med Biol 1993; 38: 1647-59.
  • Jago JR, Henderson J, Whittingham TA, Willson K. How reliable are manufacturer's reported acoustic output data? Ultrasound Med Biol 1995; 21: 135-6.
  • Whittingham TA. The acoustic output of diagnostic machines. In: ter Haar G, Duck FA, eds. The Safe Use of Ultrasound in Medical Diagnosis, London, UK: British Medical Ultrasound Society/British Institute of Radiology, 2000; 16-31.
  • Li GC, Lazlo A. Thermotolerance in mammalian cells: a possible role for the heat shock proteins. In: Atkinson BG, Waiden DB, eds. Changes in Eurkaryotic Gene Expression in Response to Environmental Stress. NY: NY Academy of Sciences Press, 1985; 349-71.
  • Lindquist S, Craig EA. The heat-shock proteins. Ann Rev Genetics 1988; 22: 631-77.
  • Howarth DH, Bliss WR. Tansley review no. 51. Gene expression under temperature stress. New Phytol 1993; 125: 1-26.
  • Drewniak JL, Carnes KI, Dunn F. In Vitro ultrasonic heating of fetal bone. J Acoust Sci Am 1989; 86: 1254-8.
  • Carstensen EL, Child SZ, Norton S, Nyborg W. Ultrasonic heating of the skull. J Acoust. Soc Am 1990; 87: 1310-7.
  • O'Neill TP, Winkler AJ, Wu J. Ultrasound heating in a tissue-bone phantom. Ultrasound Med Biol 1994; 20: 579-88.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.