Institutional logics analysis in higher education research

ABSTRACT

While institutional logics theory has increasingly been applied in higher education research, especially in the past five years, agreement is lacking on how to approach institutional logics analysis. This results in proliferating institutional logics in higher education studies and often confuses newcomers to the field as to how to use institutional logics in their empirical research. As a response to this situation, our study outlines the state-of-the-art application of institutional logics in higher education studies through scrutinising 59 articles that apply institutional logics in organisation studies in the field of higher education. Specifically, we ask the following research questions: What approaches to institutional logics analysis are used in higher education studies? What institutional logics are identified/applied in higher education studies? What challenges are evident in applying institutional logics in higher education studies? How does the use of institutional logics in higher education research contribute to institutional logics theory? The most profound outcomes of our literature analysis are: First, we construct a novel typology of approaches to institutional logics analysis that is positioned on two-dimensions: the reasoning applied (deductive vs. inductive), and the level at which the logic is examined (societal vs. field/local); Second, we create an exhaustive list of institutional logics (over 50) applied and identified in these studies; Third, we discover major challenges in using institutional logics in higher education research. Finally, we clearly define societal-level and field-level logics and suggest a rationalisation of institutional logics approaches in order to fully utilise the explanatory power of institutional logics.

KEYWORDS:

• Institutional logics
• institutional theory
• organisation studies
• university
• literature review

Acknowledgement

The authors would like to acknowledge the institutional theory insights of Dr Jordi Comas which inspired and informed an early draft of this paper. Our thanks are also given to the participants of the New Institutionalism Workshop 2020 for their questions, remarks and suggestions as well as the editors and reviewers of Studies in Higher Education for their constructive comments.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).