Advanced search
Publication Cover
Journal of the Operational Research Society Volume 34, 1983 - Issue 7
Submit an article Journal homepage
18
Views
125
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
General Paper

The Development of System Dynamics as a Methodology for System Description and Qualitative Analysis

E. F. WolstenholmeUniversity of Bradford Management Centre
&
R. G. CoyleUniversity of Bradford Management Centre
Pages 569-581 | Published online: 20 Dec 2017

Citations (125)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (7)

Pratap Bhanu, T V Krishna Mohan, R K Amit & Venugopal Shankar. (2022) Factors affecting the market dynamics of lithium-ion battery for electric mobility: a system dynamics perspective. Journal of Simulation 0:0, pages 1-18.
Read now
Helen Lingard & Michelle Turner. (2017) Promoting construction workers’ health: a multi-level system perspective. Construction Management and Economics 35:5, pages 239-253.
Read now
G J Lyons & J Duggan. (2015) System dynamics modelling to support policy analysis for sustainable health care. Journal of Simulation 9:2, pages 129-139.
Read now
Mohammad Reza Khaji & Rasoul Shafaei. (2011) A system dynamics approach for strategic partnering in supply networks. International Journal of Computer Integrated Manufacturing 24:2, pages 106-125.
Read now
C Eden, F Ackermann, J M Bryson, G P Richardson, D F Andersen & C B Finn. (2009) Integrating modes of policy analysis and strategic management practice: requisite elements and dilemmas. Journal of the Operational Research Society 60:1, pages 2-13.
Read now
J Mingers. (2003) A classification of the philosophical assumptions of management science methods. Journal of the Operational Research Society 54:6, pages 559-570.
Read now
ERICF. WOLSTENHOLME. (1986) System enquiry using system dynamics. International Journal of Systems Science 17:1, pages 111-120.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (118)

George P. Richardson. (2024) Building confidence in exploratory models. System Dynamics Review.
Crossref
Victoria J. Mabin & Robert Y. Cavana. (2024) A framework for using Theory of Constraints thinking processes and tools to complement qualitative system dynamics modelling. System Dynamics Review.
Crossref
Lum Sonita Awah, Johanes Amate Belle, Yong Sebastian Nyam & Israel Ropo Orimoloye. (2024) A Systematic Analysis of Systems Approach and Flood Risk Management Research: Trends, Gaps, and Opportunities. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science 15:1, pages 45-57.
Crossref
Rameez R. Qureshi, David N. Ford & Charles M. Wolf. (2024) Descriptive design structure matrices for improved system dynamics qualitative modeling. System Dynamics Review.
Crossref
Pablo Newberry & Neil Carhart. (2023) Constructing causal loop diagrams from large interview data sets. System Dynamics Review 40:1.
Crossref
Benjamin L. Turner & Michael Goodman. (2023) Capturing the science behind the craft: a reporting framework to improve quality and confidence in nonsimulated models. System Dynamics Review.
Crossref
Rahul Ray Biswas & Anisur Rahman. (2023) Development and application of regional urban water security indicators. Utilities Policy 84, pages 101637.
Crossref
Martin Kunc, Federico Barnabè & Maria Cleofe Giorgino. (2023) Uncovering dynamic complexity in annual reports: a methodological approach using resource mapping. System Dynamics Review 39:4, pages 299-335.
Crossref
Libiao Bai, Tong Pan, Jieyu Bai, Shuyun Kang & Patrick X.W. Zou. (2023) Mechanism for generating and promoting manufacturing project portfolio synergy. Ain Shams Engineering Journal 14:7, pages 102022.
Crossref
Soumyajit Koley. (2023) Sustainability appraisal of arsenic mitigation policy innovations in West Bengal, India. Infrastructure Asset Management 10:1, pages 17-37.
Crossref
Yujie Zeng, Dedi Liu, Shenglian Guo, Lihua Xiong, Pan Liu, Jiabo Yin & Zhenhui Wu. (2022) A system dynamic model to quantify the impacts of water resources allocation on water–energy–food–society (WEFS) nexus. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 26:15, pages 3965-3988.
Crossref
Ali Zolghadr, Ehsan Gharaie & Nader Naderpajouh. (2022) Barriers to innovation in the housing sector: Economic justifiability of offsite construction for housebuilders. Journal of Building Engineering 52, pages 104490.
Crossref
Virupaxi Bagodi & Prasannna P. Raravi. (2021) A holistic study of factors governing small and medium enterprises in India. Journal of Modelling in Management 17:2, pages 812-847.
Crossref
Andrea Caporuscio, Maria Cristina Pietronudo, Francesco Schiavone & Daniele Leone. (2022) Unlocking value with a crowdsourcing configuration of smart city: a system dynamic simulation. The TQM Journal.
Crossref
Udita Sanga, Amadou Sidibé & Laura Schmitt Olabisi. (2021) Dynamic pathways of barriers and opportunities for food security and climate adaptation in Southern Mali. World Development 148, pages 105663.
Crossref
Zhao Xin-gang, Xu Lei & Zhou Ying. (2021) How to promote the effective implementation of China's Renewable Portfolio Standards considering non-neutral technology?. Energy, pages 121748.
Crossref
Sudesh Sharma, Mat Walton & Suzanne Manning. (2021) Social Determinants of Health Influencing the New Zealand COVID-19 Response and Recovery: A Scoping Review and Causal Loop Diagram. Systems 9:3, pages 52.
Crossref
Robert G. Dyson, Frances A. O’Brien & Devan B. Shah. (2021) Soft OR and Practice: The Contribution of the Founders of Operations Research. Operations Research 69:3, pages 727-738.
Crossref
Hao Zhang, Anthony Veltri, Javier Calvo-Amodio & Karl R. Haapala. (2021) Making the business case for sustainable manufacturing in small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises: A systems decision making approach. Journal of Cleaner Production 287, pages 125038.
Crossref
João Alberto Arantes do Amaral. (2021) Using project-based learning to teach project-based learning: lessons learned ,. Pro-Posições 32.
Crossref
Gavin Melles, Stefan Lodewyckx & Hariharan Thangatur Sukumar. 2021. COVID-19: Paving the Way for a More Sustainable World. COVID-19: Paving the Way for a More Sustainable World 311 330 .
Jacqueline Y. Sánchez-García & Carlos López-Hernández. 2020. Strategy, Power and CSR: Practices and Challenges in Organizational Management. Strategy, Power and CSR: Practices and Challenges in Organizational Management 85 99 .
Arnaud Diemer & Claudiu Eduard Nedelciu. 2020. Sustainable Cities and Communities. Sustainable Cities and Communities 760 773 .
Arnaud Diemer & Claudiu Eduard Nedelciu. 2019. Sustainable Cities and Communities. Sustainable Cities and Communities 1 14 .
David F. Andersen, Eliot Rich & Roderick Macdonald. 2020. System Dynamics. System Dynamics 253 271 .
Elias Hartvigsson, Erik Oscar Ahlgren & Sverker Molander. (2019) Tackling complexity and problem formulation in rural electrification through conceptual modelling in system dynamics. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 37:1, pages 141-153.
Crossref
Maria Cleofe Giorgino, Federico Barnabè & Martin Kunc. (2019) Integrating qualitative system dynamics with accounting practices: The case of integrated reporting and resource mapping. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 37:1, pages 97-118.
Crossref
Yolanda Obaze. (2019) The transformative community-based humanitarian service ecosystem. Journal of Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management 9:3, pages 410-437.
Crossref
Bahadir K. Akcam, Senem Guney & Anthony M. Cresswell. (2019) Research Design and Major Issues in Developing Dynamic Theories by Secondary Analysis of Qualitative Data. Systems 7:3, pages 40.
Crossref
Farzad Pargar, Jaakko Kujala, Kirsi Aaltonen & Sampsa Ruutu. (2019) Value creation dynamics in a project alliance. International Journal of Project Management 37:5, pages 716-730.
Crossref
Stefano Armenia, Eduardo Ferreira Franco, Fabio Nonino, Emanuele Spagnoli & Carlo M. Medaglia. (2018) Towards the Definition of a Dynamic and Systemic Assessment for Cybersecurity Risks. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 36:4, pages 404-423.
Crossref
Mirjana Pejic Bach, Emil Tustanovski, Andrew W.H. Ip, Kai-Leung Yung & Vasja Roblek. (2019) System dynamics models for the simulation of sustainable urban development. Kybernetes 49:2, pages 460-504.
Crossref
Hördur Haraldsson & Rannveig Ólafsdóttir. (2018) Evolution of Tourism in Natural Destinations and Dynamic Sustainable Thresholds over Time. Sustainability 10:12, pages 4788.
Crossref
Mehdi Zomorodian, Sai Hin Lai, Mehran Homayounfar, Shaliza Ibrahim, Seyed Ehsan Fatemi & Ahmed El-Shafie. (2018) The state-of-the-art system dynamics application in integrated water resources modeling. Journal of Environmental Management 227, pages 294-304.
Crossref
Sushil. (2018) Incorporating polarity of relationships in ISM and TISM for theory building in information and organization management. International Journal of Information Management 43, pages 38-51.
Crossref
Camilo Andres Navarro Forero. (2018) Organizational Entropy - Case of Study: The Colombian Peace Process. Organizational Entropy - Case of Study: The Colombian Peace Process.
Tuomas Kuhmonen. (2018) Systems view of future of wicked problems to be addressed by the Common Agricultural Policy. Land Use Policy 77, pages 683-695.
Crossref
Aly Elmasry & Andreas Größler. (2018) Supply chain modularity in system dynamics. System Dynamics Review 34:3, pages 462-476.
Crossref
Lucas Dawson, Marine Elbakidze, Per Angelstam & Johanna Gordon. (2017) Governance and management dynamics of landscape restoration at multiple scales: Learning from successful environmental managers in Sweden. Journal of Environmental Management 197, pages 24-40.
Crossref
Sondoss Elsawah, Suzanne A. Pierce, Serena H. Hamilton, Hedwig van Delden, Dagmar Haase, Amgad Elmahdi & Anthony J. Jakeman. (2017) An overview of the system dynamics process for integrated modelling of socio-ecological systems: Lessons on good modelling practice from five case studies. Environmental Modelling & Software 93, pages 127-145.
Crossref
Santosh Kumar Prusty, Pratap K. J. Mohapatra & C. K. Mukherjee. (2016) Using Generic Structures in System Dynamics Model Building: Reflection from Modeling for Indian Shrimp Industry. Systemic Practice and Action Research 30:1, pages 19-44.
Crossref
Ehsan Nabavi, Katherine A. Daniell & Husain Najafi. (2017) Boundary matters: the potential of system dynamics to support sustainability?. Journal of Cleaner Production 140, pages 312-323.
Crossref
David C. Earnest & Erika Frydenlund. 2017. Guide to Simulation-Based Disciplines. Guide to Simulation-Based Disciplines 237 259 .
Shouhong Wang & Hai Wang. (2016) A Soft OR Approach to Fostering Systems Thinking: SODA Maps Plus Joint Analytical Process. Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education 14:3, pages 337-356.
Crossref
Rafael Laurenti, Jagdeep Singh, Rajib Sinha, Josepha Potting & Björn Frostell. (2015) Unintended Environmental Consequences of Improvement Actions: A Qualitative Analysis of Systems' Structure and Behavior. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 33:3, pages 381-399.
Crossref
James P. Thompson, Susan Howick & Valerie Belton. (2016) Critical Learning Incidents in system dynamics modelling engagements. European Journal of Operational Research 249:3, pages 945-958.
Crossref
Jian‐Hung Chen & Yijen Chen. (2014) The evolution of public industry R&D institute – the case of ITRI. R&D Management 46:1, pages 49-61.
Crossref
B. C. Dangerfield. 2016. Operational Research for Emergency Planning in Healthcare: Volume 2. Operational Research for Emergency Planning in Healthcare: Volume 2 296 315 .
Balagopal G. Menon & Biswajit Mahanty. (2015) Assessing the Effectiveness of Alternative Policies in Conjunction with Energy Efficiency Improvement Policy in India. Environmental Modeling & Assessment 20:6, pages 609-624.
Crossref
Mohammad Shamsuddoha. 2015. Sustaining Competitive Advantage Via Business Intelligence, Knowledge Management, and System Dynamics. Sustaining Competitive Advantage Via Business Intelligence, Knowledge Management, and System Dynamics 155 399 .
Mehrnaz Akbari Roumani, Chun Che Fung & Pema Choejey. (2015) Assessing economic impact due to cyber attacks with System Dynamics approach. Assessing economic impact due to cyber attacks with System Dynamics approach.
Jia Wang, Wen Sheng Li, Liang Chun Li & Peng Wang. (2014) Research on Equipment Support Force Prensent Situation and Countermeasure. Applied Mechanics and Materials 644-650, pages 5817-5820.
Crossref
Rafael Laurenti, David Lazarevic, Sofia Poulikidou, Valeria Montrucchio, Luigi Bistagnino & Björn Frostell. (2014) Group Model-Building to identify potential sources of environmental impacts outside the scope of LCA studies. Journal of Cleaner Production 72, pages 96-109.
Crossref
Mridula Sahay & Kuldeep Kumar. (2014) Enhancing the corporate performance through system dynamics modelling. Corporate Ownership and Control 11:2, pages 167-177.
Crossref
Virupaxi Bagodi & Biswajit Mahanty. (2013) Double loop learning in the Indian two‐wheeler service sector. The Learning Organization 20:4/5, pages 264-278.
Crossref
Giorgio Gallo. (2012) Conflict Theory, Complexity and Systems Approach. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 30:2, pages 156-175.
Crossref
Sora Lee, Youngjung Geum, Hakyeon Lee & Yongtae Park. (2012) Dynamic and multidimensional measurement of product-service system (PSS) sustainability: a triple bottom line (TBL)-based system dynamics approach. Journal of Cleaner Production 32, pages 173-182.
Crossref
Ali Mirchi, Kaveh Madani, David WatkinsJr.Jr. & Sajjad Ahmad. (2012) Synthesis of System Dynamics Tools for Holistic Conceptualization of Water Resources Problems. Water Resources Management 26:9, pages 2421-2442.
Crossref
Rajat Dhawan, Marcus O'Connor & Mark Borman. (2011) The effect of qualitative and quantitative system dynamics training: an experimental investigation. System Dynamics Review 27:3, pages 313-327.
Crossref
Peter Otto & William Siemer. (2009) Learning from cognitive feedback mapping and simulation: A group modeling intervention. Systèmes d'information & management Volume 14:4, pages 9-30.
Crossref
David F. Andersen, Eliot Rich & Roderick MacDonald. 2011. Complex Systems in Finance and Econometrics. Complex Systems in Finance and Econometrics 655 670 .
David F. Andersen, Eliot Rich & Roderick MacDonald. 2009. Encyclopedia of Complexity and Systems Science. Encyclopedia of Complexity and Systems Science 7051 7067 .
Margherita Pagani & Charles H. Fine. (2008) Value network dynamics in 3G–4G wireless communications: A systems thinking approach to strategic value assessment. Journal of Business Research 61:11, pages 1102-1112.
Crossref
Thomas D. ClarkJrJr & Mary C. Jones. (2008) An experimental analysis of the dynamic structure and behavior of managerial support systems. System Dynamics Review 24:2, pages 215-245.
Crossref
David C. Lane. (2008) The emergence and use of diagramming in system dynamics: a critical account. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 25:1, pages 3-23.
Crossref
John Morecroft & Eric Wolstenholme. (2007) System dynamics in the U.K.: a journey from Stirling to Oxford and beyond. System Dynamics Review 23:2-3, pages 205-214.
Crossref
Robert Y. Cavana, David M. Boyd & Richard J. Taylor. (2007) A systems thinking study of retention and recruitment issues for the New Zealand Army electronic technician trade group. Systems Research and Behavioral Science 24:2, pages 201-216.
Crossref
Graham W. Winch & Carmine Bianchi. (2006) Drivers and dynamic processes for SMEs going global. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development 13:1, pages 73-88.
Crossref
Marna Hoard, Jack Homer, William Manley, Paul Furbee, Arshadul Haque & James Helmkamp. (2005) Systems modeling in support of evidence-based disaster planning for rural areas. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 208:1-2, pages 117-125.
Crossref
Eric Wolstenholme. (2004) Using generic system archetypes to support thinking and modelling. System Dynamics Review 20:4, pages 341-356.
Crossref
David Andersen. (2004) The 2004 Jay Wright Forrester Award ‐ citation for the winner : Eric F. Wolstenholme. System Dynamics Review 20:4, pages 337-440.
Crossref
E. F. Wolstenholme. (2003) Towards the definition and use of a core set of archetypal structures in system dynamics. System Dynamics Review 19:1, pages 7-26.
Crossref
Jack Homer & Rogelio Oliva. (2001) Maps and models in system dynamics: a response to Coyle. System Dynamics Review 17:4, pages 347-355.
Crossref
Geoff Coyle. (2001) Rejoinder to Homer and Oliva. System Dynamics Review 17:4, pages 357-363.
Crossref
Mohammed Quaddus & Arunee Intrapairot. (2001) Management policies and the diffusion of data warehouse: a case study using system dynamics-based decision support system. Decision Support Systems 31:2, pages 223-240.
Crossref
Sucheta Nadkarni & Prakash P Shenoy. (2001) A Bayesian network approach to making inferences in causal maps. European Journal of Operational Research 128:3, pages 479-498.
Crossref
H.C. Guo, L. Liu, G.H. Huang, G.A. Fuller, R. Zou & Y.Y. Yin. (2001) A system dynamics approach for regional environmental planning and management: A study for the Lake Erhai Basin. Journal of Environmental Management 61:1, pages 93-111.
Crossref
David C. Lane. (1999) Social theory and system dynamics practice. European Journal of Operational Research 113:3, pages 501-527.
Crossref
Jac A. M. Vennix. (1999) Group model-building: tackling messy problems. System Dynamics Review 15:4, pages 379-401.
Crossref
Robert Y. Cavana, Philip K. Davies, Rachel M. Robson & Kenneth J. Wilson. (1999) Drivers of quality in health services: different worldviews of clinicians and policy managers revealed. System Dynamics Review 15:3, pages 331-340.
Crossref
Richard E Plant, Thomas A Kerby, Lowell J Zelinski & Daniel S Munk. (1998) A qualitative simulation model for cotton growth and development. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture 20:2, pages 165-183.
Crossref
George P. Richardson. (1996) Problems for the future of system dynamics. System Dynamics Review 12:2, pages 141-157.
Crossref
Jac A. M. Vennix. (1995) Building consensus in strategic decision making: System dynamics as a group support system. Group Decision and Negotiation 4:4, pages 335-355.
Crossref
George P. Richardson & David F. Andersen. (2006) Teamwork in group model building. System Dynamics Review 11:2, pages 113-137.
Crossref
Pankaj, Kiran Seth & Sushil. (1994) A fuzzy set theoretic approach to qualitative analysis of causal loops in system dynamics. European Journal of Operational Research 78:3, pages 380-393.
Crossref
D. P. Dash & P. N. Murthy. (1994) Boundary judgment in system dynamics modeling: An investigation through the science of complexity. Systems Practice 7:4, pages 465-475.
Crossref
David C. Lane. (2006) With a little help from our friends: How system dynamics and soft OR can learn from each other. System Dynamics Review 10:2-3, pages 101-134.
Crossref
D. P. Dash. (1994) System dynamics: Changing perspectives. Systems Practice 7:1, pages 87-98.
Crossref
Ali N. Mashayekhi. (2006) Transition in the New York State solid waste system: A dynamic analysis. System Dynamics Review 9:1, pages 23-47.
Crossref
R. G. Coyle. (2006) A system dynamics model of aircraft carrier survivability. System Dynamics Review 8:3, pages 193-212.
Crossref
Eric F. Wolstenholme. (1992) The definition and application of a stepwise approach to model conceptualisation and analysis. European Journal of Operational Research 59:1, pages 123-136.
Crossref
Jac A.M. Vennix & Jan W. Gubbels. (1992) Knowledge elicitation in conceptual model building: A case study in modeling a regional Dutch health care system. European Journal of Operational Research 59:1, pages 85-101.
Crossref
Kurt Heidenberger. (1992) Strategic decision support in preventive health care. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 26:2, pages 129-146.
Crossref
Chee Sing Yap. 1991. Systems Thinking in Europe. Systems Thinking in Europe 583 590 .
George P. Richardson. 1991. Qualitative Simulation Modeling and Analysis. Qualitative Simulation Modeling and Analysis 144 169 .
Yash P. Gupta & Mahesh C. Gupta. (1990) A process model to study the impact of role variables on turnover intentions of information systems personnel. Computers in Industry 15:3, pages 211-238.
Crossref
Paul Keys. (1990) System dynamics as a systems-based problem-solving methodology. Systems Practice 3:5, pages 479-493.
Crossref
Jac A. M. Vennix, Jan W. Gubbels, Doeke Post & Henk J. Poppen. (2006) A structured approach to knowledge elicitation in conceptual model building. System Dynamics Review 6:2, pages 194-208.
Crossref
Eric F. Wolstenholme. (2016) A current overview of system dynamics. Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control 11:4, pages 171-179.
Crossref
R. G. Coyle. 1989. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems 599 607 .
Nicola Bianchi. 1989. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems 495 501 .
Th. Goumas, Ar. Papasavvas & D. V. Papaconstantinou. 1989. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems. Computer-Based Management of Complex Systems 407 414 .
P. Keys. (2016) System dynamics: a methodological perspective. Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control 10:4, pages 218-224.
Crossref
John D.W. Morecroft. (1988) System dynamics and microworlds for policymakers. European Journal of Operational Research 35:3, pages 301-320.
Crossref
E.F. Wolstenholme. (1988) Defence operational analysis using system dynamics. European Journal of Operational Research 34:1, pages 10-18.
Crossref
E.F. Wolstenholme. (2016) A systems approach to combat modelling. Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control 9:1, pages 45-51.
Crossref
Nathaniel J. Mass. (2006) Methods of conceptualization. System Dynamics Review 2:1, pages 76-80.
Crossref
E. F. Wolstenholme. (2006) Algorithmic control modules for system dynamics models. System Dynamics Review 2:1, pages 1-19.
Crossref
Faleh H. M. Al‐Khayat & John S. Edwards. (2011) An options‐choice methodology for technological projects in developing countries. Systems Research 3:3, pages 123-133.
Crossref
George P. Richardson. (2006) Problems with causal‐loop diagrams. System Dynamics Review 2:2, pages 158-170.
Crossref
R.G. Coyle. (1986) Comment on ‘System dynamics and operational research: An appraisal’. European Journal of Operational Research 23:3, pages 403-406.
Crossref
R. G. Coyle & R. Goad. 1986. Modeling and Analysis of Conventional Defense in Europe. Modeling and Analysis of Conventional Defense in Europe 59 81 .
John D. W. Morecroft. (2006) The feedback view of business policy and strategy. System Dynamics Review 1:1, pages 4-19.
Crossref
E.F. Wolstenholme & R.K. Holmes. (1985) The design of colliery information and control systems. European Journal of Operational Research 20:2, pages 168-181.
Crossref
R. G. Coyle. (1985) A system description of counter insurgency warfare. Policy Sciences 18:1, pages 55-78.
Crossref
R.G. Coyle. (1984) East and west and north and south. Futures 16:6, pages 594-609.
Crossref
J.A. Sharp & D.H.R. Price. (1984) System dynamics and operational research: An appraisal. European Journal of Operational Research 16:1, pages 1-12.
Crossref
Mathias Beck, Lukas Klaus Schoenenberger & Andrea Schenker-Wicki. (2012) How Managers Can Deal with Complex Issues: A Semi-Quantitative Analysis Method of Causal Loop Diagrams Based on Matrices. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.