Advanced search
Publication Cover
Combustion Science and Technology Volume 187, 2015 - Issue 7
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,190
Views
90
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Modeling Lifted Jet Flames in a Heated Coflow Using an Optimized Eddy Dissipation Concept Model

M. J. EvansSchool of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, AustraliaCorrespondence[email protected]
,
P. R. MedwellSchool of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
&
Z. F. TianSchool of Mechanical Engineering, The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
Pages 1093-1109 | Received 13 Apr 2014, Accepted 23 Dec 2014, Published online: 11 Apr 2015

Citations (90)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (8)

Yucheng Kuang, Boshu He, Chaojun Wang, Wenxiao Tong & Di He. (2024) Numerical Research for MILD Burners with Different configurations. Combustion Science and Technology 196:3, pages 421-438.
Read now
Lorenzo Giuntini, Lorenzo Frascino, Giovanni Battista Ariemma, Giancarlo Sorrentino, Chiara Galletti & Raffaele Ragucci. (2023) Modeling of Ammonia MILD Combustion in Systems with Internal Recirculation. Combustion Science and Technology 195:14, pages 3513-3528.
Read now
Eva-Maria Wartha, Markus Bösenhofer & Michael Harasek. (2021) Characteristic Chemical Time Scales for Reactive Flow Modeling. Combustion Science and Technology 193:16, pages 2807-2832.
Read now
Kareem I. Khidr, Yehia A. Eldrainy & Mohamed M. El-Kassaby. (2021) Investigating the Potential of Different Modeling Setups in Simulating a Flameless Furnace Using Global and Detailed Kinetic Mechanisms. Combustion Science and Technology 193:5, pages 727-761.
Read now
Xuren Zhu, Xi Xia & Peng Zhang. (2020) Stability of Buoyant Inverse Diffusion Methane Flames with Confinement Effects. Combustion Science and Technology 192:9, pages 1650-1667.
Read now
Ivar S. Ertesvåg. (2020) Analysis of Some Recently Proposed Modifications to the Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC). Combustion Science and Technology 192:6, pages 1108-1136.
Read now
Mohammadreza Farokhi & Madjid Birouk. (2019) A hybrid EDC/Flamelet approach for modelling biomass combustion of grate-firing furnace. Combustion Theory and Modelling 23:4, pages 716-747.
Read now
Alfonso Chinnici, Zhao Feng Tian, Jin Han Lim, Graham Jerrold Nathan & Bassam B. Dally. (2019) Thermal performance analysis of a syngas-fuelled hybrid solar receiver combustor operated in the MILD combustion regime. Combustion Science and Technology 191:1, pages 2-17.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (82)

Muddada Srinivasarao, Bok Jik Lee & Vanteru Mahendra Reddy. (2024) Modified Reacting Solver: A Simplified Approach for Capturing the Molecular and Flow Diffusivities for the Nonpremixed MILD Flames. ACS Omega 9:14, pages 15804-15817.
Crossref
Jordan A.C. Kildare, Michael J. Evans, Zhao Tian & Paul R. Medwell. (2024) Estimation and testing of single-step oxidation reactions for hydrogen and methane in low-oxygen, elevated pressure conditions. Fuel 360, pages 130589.
Crossref
Maliheh Saravani Ghayour & Seyed Reza Shabanian. (2024) CFD Study and RSM Optimization of Acetylene Production in Partial Oxidation Process. Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering 41:3, pages 729-747.
Crossref
Arthur Péquin, Salvatore Iavarone, Riccardo Malpica Galassi & Alessandro Parente. (2023) Supervised Clustering for Optimal Sub-model Selection in Reactor-Based Models. Flow, Turbulence and Combustion 112:3, pages 931-955.
Crossref
M. Srinivasarao, Deayoung Jun, Bok Jik Lee & V. Mahendra Reddy. (2024) Numerical analysis of the enrichment of CH4/H2 in ammonia combustion in a hot co-flow environment. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 55, pages 1071-1089.
Crossref
Arthur Péquin, Michael J. Evans, Alfonso Chinnici, Paul R. Medwell & Alessandro Parente. (2023) The reactor-based perspective on finite-rate chemistry in turbulent reacting flows: A review from traditional to low-emission combustion. Applications in Energy and Combustion Science 16, pages 100201.
Crossref
Di He, Yusong Yu, Xinwu Zhang, Yan Jia & Chaojun Wang. (2023) Reynolds number-based global modification of EDC constants and simulation of a syngas and a piloted CH4/air flames. Energy 284, pages 129284.
Crossref
D.B. Proud, M.J. Evans, J.A. Kildare, Q.N. Chan & P.R. Medwell. (2023) Pressurised combustion in hot and low-oxygen environments: Chemiluminescence imaging and modelling. Fuel 349, pages 128538.
Crossref
Hazem S. A. M. Awad, Khalil Abo-Amsha, Umair Ahmed, Nedunchezhian Swaminathan & Nilanjan Chakraborty. (2023) A Priori Direct Numerical Simulation Assessment of MILD Combustion Modelling in the Context of Reynolds Averaged Navier–Stokes Simulations. Flow, Turbulence and Combustion 111:3, pages 799-823.
Crossref
Yuzuru Nada, Yoshiyuki Kidoguchi, Ryosuke Isoda, Hiroto Honjo, Masayuki Matsumoto & Kazuya Sugiyama. (2023) Four-step global kinetics mechanism for diluted combustion fueled with kerosene. Fuel 346, pages 128322.
Crossref
Lorenzo Giuntini, Lorenzo Frascino, Giovanni Battista Ariemma, Chiara Galletti, Giancarlo Sorrentino & Raffaele Ragucci. (2023) Performance Assessment of Modeling Approaches for Moderate or Intense Low-Oxygen Dilution Combustion in a Scale-Bridging Burner. Energy & Fuels 37:13, pages 9500-9513.
Crossref
Yong Hu, Yong Jiang & Kin-Pang Cheong. (2023) Tabulated Chemistry Approach for the Simulation of MILD Combustion: Effects of Scalar Mixing and Chemistry Tabulation. ACS Omega 8:11, pages 10288-10302.
Crossref
Erica Quadarella, Arthur Péquin, Alessandro Stagni, Alessandro Parente, Tiziano Faravelli & Hong G. Im. (2023) A generalized partially stirred reactor model for turbulent closure. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 39:4, pages 5329-5338.
Crossref
Zhenghong Zhao, Zewu Zhang, Xiaojian Zha, Ge Gao, Wenchao Mao, Fan Wu, Xiaoshan Li, Cong Luo & Liqi Zhang. (2023) Fuel-NO formation mechanism in MILD-oxy combustion of CH4/NH3 fuel blend. Fuel 331, pages 125817.
Crossref
Liutao Sun, Kai Xie, Rui Sun, Zewu Zhang, Yonghong Yan, Mengfan Yuan & Jiangquan Wu. (2023) Bluff-body MILD combustion regime for semicoke and bituminous coal mixtures with effect of oxidizer O2 concentration in O2/N2 and oxy-fuel (O2/CO2) atmospheres. Fuel 331, pages 125793.
Crossref
D.B. Proud, M.J. Evans, Q.N. Chan & P.R. Medwell. (2022) Characteristics of turbulent flames in a confined and pressurised jet-in-hot-coflow combustor. Journal of the Energy Institute 105, pages 103-113.
Crossref
Rafał Buczyński, Ilona Uryga-Bugajska & Mieszko Tokarski. (2022) Recent advances in low-gradient combustion modelling of hydrogen fuel blends. Fuel 328, pages 125265.
Crossref
Di He, Yusong Yu, Hao Ma, Hongbo Liang & Chaojun Wang. (2022) Extensive Discussions of the Eddy Dissipation Concept Constants and Numerical Simulations of the Sandia Flame D. Applied Sciences 12:18, pages 9162.
Crossref
Nicholas J. Curtis, Kyle E. Niemeyer & Chih-Jen Sung. (2022) Accelerating reactive-flow simulations using vectorized chemistry integration. Computer Physics Communications 278, pages 108409.
Crossref
Liutao Sun, Rui Sun, Yonghong Yan, Zewu Zhang, Wei Ke & Jiangquan Wu. (2022) Bluff-body MILD combustion of large-proportion semicoke-blend under various secondary air velocities. Fuel 320, pages 123908.
Crossref
Amir Mardani & Aslan Nazari. (2022) Dynamic adjustment of the Eddy Dissipation Concept model for turbulent/combustion interactions in mixed combustion regimes. Combustion and Flame 241, pages 111873.
Crossref
Liutao Sun, Rui Sun, Yonghong Yan, Mengfan Yuan & Jiangquan Wu. (2022) Investigation of air-MILD and oxy-MILD combustion characteristics of semicoke and bituminous coal mixtures in a 0.3 MW fuel-rich/lean fired furnace. Fuel Processing Technology 231, pages 107247.
Crossref
Ghobad Bagheri & Matteo Pelucchi. 2022. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications 377 420 .
Saurabh Sharma & Sudarshan Kumar. 2022. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications 45 79 .
Ruggero Amaduzzi, Arthur Péquin & Alessandro Parente. 2022. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications 261 310 .
Mameri Abdelbaki. 2022. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications. Fundamentals of Low Emission Flameless Combustion and Its Applications 311 359 .
Yucheng Kuang, Boshu He, Chaojun Wang, Wenxiao Tong & Di He. (2021) Numerical analyses of MILD and conventional combustions with the Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC). Energy 237, pages 121622.
Crossref
Yu Zhang, Stijn Vangaever, Gilles Theis, Mike Henneke, Geraldine J. Heynderickx & Kevin M. Van Geem. (2021) Feasibility of biogas and oxy-fuel combustion in steam cracking furnaces: Experimental and computational study. Fuel 304, pages 121393.
Crossref
Mohammadreza Zharfa & Nader Karimi. (2021) Intensification of MILD combustion of methane and hydrogen blend by the application of a magnetic field- a numerical study. Acta Astronautica 184, pages 259-268.
Crossref
Yaojie Tu, Shunta Xu, Mengqian Xie, Zean Wang & Hao Liu. (2021) Numerical simulation of propane MILD combustion in a lab-scale cylindrical furnace. Fuel 290, pages 119858.
Crossref
Mengqian Xie, Fangqin Dai & Yaojie Tu. (2021) A numerical study of accelerated moderate or intense low-oxygen dilution (MILD) combustion stability for methane in a lab-scale furnace by off-stoichiometric combustion technology. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering 32, pages 108-118.
Crossref
E. Ebrahimi Fordoei, Kiumars Mazaheri & Amirreza Mohammadpour. (2021) Numerical study on the heat transfer characteristics, flame structure, and pollutants emission in the MILD methane-air, oxygen-enriched and oxy-methane combustion. Energy 218, pages 119524.
Crossref
Guochang Wang, Kin-Pang Cheong, Jicang Si & Jianchun Mi. (2021) Nonpremixed Flameless Combustion in a Furnace: Influence of Burner Configuration. Energy & Fuels 35:4, pages 3333-3347.
Crossref
Mengmeng Ren, Shuzhong Wang, N. Romero-Anton, Junxue Zhao, Chong Zou & Dirk Roekaerts. (2021) Numerical study of a turbulent co-axial non-premixed flame for methanol hydrothermal combustion: Comparison of the EDC and FGM models. The Journal of Supercritical Fluids 169, pages 105132.
Crossref
Amiratabak Azarinia & Hossein Mahdavy-Moghaddam. (2021) Comprehensive numerical study of molecular diffusion effects and Eddy Dissipation Concept model in MILD combustion. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 46:13, pages 9252-9265.
Crossref
Salvatore Iavarone, Arthur Péquin, Zhi X. Chen, Nguyen Anh Khoa Doan, Nedunchezhian Swaminathan & Alessandro Parente. (2021) An a priori assessment of the Partially Stirred Reactor (PaSR) model for MILD combustion. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 38:4, pages 5403-5414.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li, Michael J. Evans, Jingjing Ye, Paul R. Medwell & Alessandro Parente. (2021) Numerical and experimental investigation of turbulent n-heptane jet-in-hot-coflow flames. Fuel 283, pages 118748.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li & Alessandro Parente. (2020) A Review of the Numerical Investigations of Jet-In-Hot-Coflow Burner With Reactor-Based Models. Frontiers in Mechanical Engineering 6.
Crossref
Sebastian Klukas, Marcus Giglmaier, Nikolaus A. Adams, Moritz Sieber, Sebastian Schimek & Christian Oliver Paschereit. (2020) Anchoring of turbulent premixed hydrogen/air flames at externally heated walls. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 45:56, pages 32547-32561.
Crossref
Michał T. Lewandowski, Zhiyi Li, Alessandro Parente & Jacek Pozorski. (2020) Generalised Eddy Dissipation Concept for MILD combustion regime at low local Reynolds and Damköhler numbers. Part 2: Validation of the model. Fuel 278, pages 117773.
Crossref
Michał T. Lewandowski, Alessandro Parente & Jacek Pozorski. (2020) Generalised Eddy Dissipation Concept for MILD combustion regime at low local Reynolds and Damköhler numbers. Part 1: Model framework development. Fuel 278, pages 117743.
Crossref
A. Chinnici, G.J. Nathan & B.B. Dally. (2020) Experimental and numerical study of the influence of syngas composition on the performance and stability of a laboratory-scale MILD combustor. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science 115, pages 110083.
Crossref
Kumar Aanjaneya, Weiyu Cao, Yawei Chen, Claus Borgnakke & Arvind Atreya. (2020) A numerical study of confined turbulent jets for homogeneous combustion with oxygen enrichment. Fuel 261, pages 116449.
Crossref
Hua Zhou, Tianwei Yang, Bassam Dally & Zhuyin Ren. (2020) LES/TPDF investigation of the role of reaction and diffusion timescales in the stabilization of a jet-in-hot-coflow CH4/H2 flame. Combustion and Flame 211, pages 477-492.
Crossref
Michael J. Evans & Paul R. Medwell. (2019) Understanding and Interpreting Laser Diagnostics in Flames: A Review of Experimental Measurement Techniques. Frontiers in Mechanical Engineering 5.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li, Riccardo Malpica Galassi, Pietro Paolo Ciottoli, Alessandro Parente & Mauro Valorani. (2019) Characterization of jet-in-hot-coflow flames using tangential stretching rate. Combustion and Flame 208, pages 281-298.
Crossref
Mohammad Mansourian & Reza Kamali. (2019) Modifying the constant coefficients of Eddy-dissipation concept model in moderate or intense low-oxygen dilution combustion using inverse problem methodology. Acta Astronautica 162, pages 546-554.
Crossref
Salvatore Iavarone, Marianna Cafiero, Marco Ferrarotti, Francesco Contino & Alessandro Parente. (2019) A multiscale combustion model formulation for NO predictions in hydrogen enriched jet flames. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 44:41, pages 23436-23457.
Crossref
Arash G. Nouri, Peyman Givi & Daniel Livescu. (2019) Modeling and simulation of turbulent nuclear flames in Type Ia supernovae. Progress in Aerospace Sciences 108, pages 156-179.
Crossref
Amir Mardani & Hamed Karimi Motaalegh Mahalegi. (2019) Hydrogen enrichment of methane and syngas for MILD combustion. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 44:18, pages 9423-9437.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li, Alberto Cuoci & Alessandro Parente. (2019) Large Eddy Simulation of MILD combustion using finite rate chemistry: Effect of combustion sub-grid closure. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 37:4, pages 4519-4529.
Crossref
Marco Ferrarotti, Zhiyi Li & Alessandro Parente. (2019) On the role of mixing models in the simulation of MILD combustion using finite-rate chemistry combustion models. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 37:4, pages 4531-4538.
Crossref
M.J. Evans, C. Petre, P.R. Medwell & A. Parente. (2019) Generalisation of the eddy-dissipation concept for jet flames with low turbulence and low Damköhler number. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 37:4, pages 4497-4505.
Crossref
André A.V. Perpignan, Arvind Gangoli Rao & Dirk J.E.M. Roekaerts. (2018) Flameless combustion and its potential towards gas turbines. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 69, pages 28-62.
Crossref
M. Ferrarotti, M. Fürst, E. Cresci, W. de Paepe & A. Parente. (2018) Key Modeling Aspects in the Simulation of a Quasi-industrial 20 kW Moderate or Intense Low-oxygen Dilution Combustion Chamber. Energy & Fuels 32:10, pages 10228-10241.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li, Michał T. Lewandowski, Francesco Contino & Alessandro Parente. (2018) Assessment of On-the-Fly Chemistry Reduction and Tabulation Approaches for the Simulation of Moderate or Intense Low-Oxygen Dilution Combustion. Energy & Fuels 32:10, pages 10121-10131.
Crossref
A. Chinnici, G.J. Nathan & B.B. Dally. (2018) Combined solar energy and combustion of hydrogen-based fuels under MILD conditions. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 43:43, pages 20086-20100.
Crossref
Kin-Pang Cheong, Guochang Wang, Jianchun Mi, Bo Wang, Rong Zhu & Wei Ren. (2018) Premixed MILD Combustion of Propane in a Cylindrical Furnace with a Single Jet Burner: Combustion and Emission Characteristics. Energy & Fuels 32:8, pages 8817-8829.
Crossref
Michał T. Lewandowski, Paweł Płuszka & Jacek Pozorski. (2018) Influence of inlet boundary conditions in computations of turbulent jet flames. International Journal of Numerical Methods for Heat & Fluid Flow 28:6, pages 1433-1456.
Crossref
Markus Bösenhofer, Eva-Maria Wartha, Christian Jordan & Michael Harasek. (2018) The Eddy Dissipation Concept—Analysis of Different Fine Structure Treatments for Classical Combustion. Energies 11:7, pages 1902.
Crossref
Michał T. Lewandowski & Ivar S. Ertesvåg. (2018) Analysis of the Eddy Dissipation Concept formulation for MILD combustion modelling. Fuel 224, pages 687-700.
Crossref
Jingjing Ye, Paul R. Medwell, Konstantin Kleinheinz, Michael J. Evans, Bassam B. Dally & Heinz G. Pitsch. (2018) Structural differences of ethanol and DME jet flames in a hot diluted coflow. Combustion and Flame 192, pages 473-494.
Crossref
Xudong Jiang, Pengfei Li, Junjun Guo, Fan Hu, Feifei Wang, Jianchun Mi & Zhaohui Liu. (2018) Detailed investigation of NO mechanism in non-premixed oxy-fuel jet flames with CH4/H2 fuel blends. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 43:17, pages 8534-8557.
Crossref
Nguyen Anh Khoa Doan, Nedunchezhian Swaminathan & Yuki Minamoto. (2018) DNS of MILD combustion with mixture fraction variations. Combustion and Flame 189, pages 173-189.
Crossref
Tianwen Chen, Qi Zhang, Jinfu Wang & Tiefeng Wang. (2017) Simulation of industrial-scale gas quenching process for partial oxidation of nature gas to acetylene. Chemical Engineering Journal 329, pages 238-249.
Crossref
Zhiyi Li, Alberto Cuoci, Amsini Sadiki & Alessandro Parente. (2017) Comprehensive numerical study of the Adelaide Jet in Hot-Coflow burner by means of RANS and detailed chemistry. Energy 139, pages 555-570.
Crossref
Yaojie Tu, Wenming Yang & Hao Liu. (2017) A Refined Global Reaction Mechanism for Gently Preheated MILD Combustion of Methane. Energy & Fuels 31:9, pages 10144-10157.
Crossref
M.J. Evans, A. Chinnici, P.R. Medwell & J. Ye. (2017) Ignition features of methane and ethylene fuel-blends in hot and diluted coflows. Fuel 203, pages 279-289.
Crossref
Jingjing Ye, Paul R. Medwell, Michael J. Evans & Bassam B. Dally. (2017) Characteristics of turbulent n-heptane jet flames in a hot and diluted coflow. Combustion and Flame 183, pages 330-342.
Crossref
Michael J. Evans, Paul R. Medwell, Zhao F. Tian, Jingjing Ye, Alessio Frassoldati & Alberto Cuoci. (2017) Effects of oxidant stream composition on non-premixed laminar flames with heated and diluted coflows. Combustion and Flame 178, pages 297-310.
Crossref
Yaojie Tu, Hao Liu & Wenming Yang. (2017) Flame Characteristics of CH 4 /H 2 on a Jet-in-Hot-Coflow Burner Diluted by N 2 , CO 2 , and H 2 O . Energy & Fuels 31:3, pages 3270-3280.
Crossref
Amir Mardani. (2017) Optimization of the Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC) model for turbulence-chemistry interactions under hot diluted combustion of CH4/H2. Fuel 191, pages 114-129.
Crossref
Chiara Galletti, Benjamin J. Isaac & Alessandro Parente. (2017) Selection of appropriate constraints for dimension reduction in MILD combustion simulations via RCCE. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 36:3, pages 4287-4295.
Crossref
M.J. Evans, P.R. Medwell, H. Wu, A. Stagni & M. Ihme. (2017) Classification and lift-off height prediction of non-premixed MILD and autoignitive flames. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 36:3, pages 4297-4304.
Crossref
Mohammadreza Farokhi & Madjid Birouk. (2016) Application of Eddy Dissipation Concept for Modeling Biomass Combustion, Part 2: Gas-Phase Combustion Modeling of a Small-Scale Fixed Bed Furnace. Energy & Fuels 30:12, pages 10800-10808.
Crossref
M. Farokhi & M. Birouk. (2016) Application of Eddy Dissipation Concept for Modeling Biomass Combustion, Part 1: Assessment of the Model Coefficients. Energy & Fuels 30:12, pages 10789-10799.
Crossref
Paul R. Medwell, Michael J. Evans, Qing N. Chan & Viswanath R. Katta. (2016) Laminar Flame Calculations for Analyzing Trends in Autoignitive Jet Flames in a Hot and Vitiated Coflow. Energy & Fuels 30:10, pages 8680-8690.
Crossref
M T Lewandowski & J Pozorski. (2016) Assessment of turbulence-chemistry interaction models in the computation of turbulent non-premixed flames. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 760, pages 012015.
Crossref
Yaojie Tu, Kai Su, Hao Liu, Sheng Chen, Zhaohui Liu & Chuguang Zheng. (2016) Physical and Chemical Effects of CO 2 Addition on CH 4 /H 2 Flames on a Jet in Hot Coflow (JHC) Burner . Energy & Fuels.
Crossref
Alessandro Parente, Mohammad Rafi Malik, Francesco Contino, Alberto Cuoci & Bassam B. Dally. (2016) Extension of the Eddy Dissipation Concept for turbulence/chemistry interactions to MILD combustion. Fuel 163, pages 98-111.
Crossref
F. Wang, P. Li, J. Mi, J. Wang & M. Xu. (2015) Chemical kinetic effect of hydrogen addition on ethylene jet flames in a hot and diluted coflow. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 40:46, pages 16634-16648.
Crossref
Michael Evans, Paul Medwell, Zhao F. Tian, Alessio Frassoldati, Alberto Cuoci & Alessandro Stagni. (2015) Ignition Characteristics in Spatially Zero-, One- and Two-Dimensional Laminar Ethylene Flames. Ignition Characteristics in Spatially Zero-, One- and Two-Dimensional Laminar Ethylene Flames.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.