Advanced search
Publication Cover
International Journal of Control Volume 50, 1989 - Issue 5
Submit an article Journal homepage
70
Views
113
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Extended model set, global data and threshold model identification of severely non-linear systems

S. A. BILLINGS Department of Control Engineering, University of Sheffield, Mappin Street, Sheffield, SI, 3JD, England, U.K.
&
S. CHEN Department of Control Engineering, University of Sheffield, Mappin Street, Sheffield, SI, 3JD, England, U.K.
Pages 1897-1923 | Received 10 Feb 1989, Published online: 16 May 2007

Citations (113)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (16)

D. Karagiannis, D. Stamatelos, V. Kappatos & Th. Spathopoulos. (2017) An investigation of shape memory alloys as actuating elements in aerospace morphing applications. Mechanics of Advanced Materials and Structures 24:8, pages 647-657.
Read now
Yuzhu Guo, L.Z. Guo, S.A. Billings & Hua-Liang Wei. (2015) An iterative orthogonal forward regression algorithm. International Journal of Systems Science 46:5, pages 776-789.
Read now
Gnaba Sarah, Tarek Garna, Kais Bouzrara, José Ragot & Hassani Messaoud. (2014) Online identification of the bilinear model expansion on Laguerre orthonormal bases. International Journal of Control 87:3, pages 441-463.
Read now
X. Wu, Z. Q. Lang & S. A. Billings. (2008) The design of energy transfer filters for energy focus filtering. International Journal of Control 81:2, pages 214-226.
Read now
D. G. Dimogianopoulos, J. D. Hios & S. D. Fassois. (2007) Integral minimum variance-like control for pooled non-linear representations with application to an aircraft system. International Journal of Control 80:5, pages 721-730.
Read now
Sunil L. Kukreja . (2005) A suboptimal bootstrap method for structure detection of non-linear output-error models with application to human ankle dynamics. International Journal of Control 78:12, pages 937-948.
Read now
F. Previdi & M. Lovera. (2004) Identification of non-linear parametrically varying models using separable least squares. International Journal of Control 77:16, pages 1382-1392.
Read now
K. L. Lee & S. A. Billings. (2003) A new direct approach of computing multi-step ahead predictions for non-linear models. International Journal of Control 76:8, pages 810-822.
Read now
S. C. Mcloone, S. Mcginnity & G. W. Irwin. (2002) Comparison of two construction algorithms for local model networks. International Journal of Systems Science 33:13, pages 1059-1072.
Read now
S. A. Billings & Zi-Qiang Lang. (2002) Non-linear systems in the frequency domain: Energy transfer filters. International Journal of Control 75:14, pages 1066-1081.
Read now
D. Coca & S. A. Billings. (2001) Non-linear system identification using wavelet multiresolution models. International Journal of Control 74:18, pages 1718-1736.
Read now
Q. M. ZHU & S. A. BILLINGS. (1996) Fast orthogonal identification of nonlinear stochastic models and radial basis function neural networks. International Journal of Control 64:5, pages 871-886.
Read now
S. A. BILLINGS & Q. M. ZHU. (1995) Model validation tests for multivariable nonlinear models including neural networks. International Journal of Control 62:4, pages 749-766.
Read now
LUIS A. AGUIRRE & S. A. BILLINGS. (1995) Improved structure selection for nonlinear models based on term clustering. International Journal of Control 62:3, pages 569-587.
Read now
M. POTTMANN, H. UNBEHAUEN & D. E. SEBORG. (1993) Application of a general multi-model approach for identification of highly nonlinear processes-a case study. International Journal of Control 57:1, pages 97-120.
Read now
S. CHEN, S. A. BILLINGS, C. F. N. COWAN & P. M. GRANT. (1990) Non-linear systems identification using radial basis functions. International Journal of Systems Science 21:12, pages 2513-2539.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (97)

Zhi Zhang, Shuhua Bai, Baiqing He, Jinliang Huang, Lei Wu & Wenzhan Zhang. (2023) Modeling and State-of-Charge Coestimation for a Lithium-ion Battery Based on a Class of Nonlinear Time Series Model. Modeling and State-of-Charge Coestimation for a Lithium-ion Battery Based on a Class of Nonlinear Time Series Model.
B. Geletaw, N. Melessew & G.D. Reeves. (2023) Performance evaluation of SNB3GEO electrons flux forecasting model using LANL and GOES-13 observations. Advances in Space Research 71:6, pages 2833-2845.
Crossref
Michele Alessandrini, Laura Falaschetti, Giorgio Biagetti, Paolo Crippa & Claudio Turchetti. (2022) Nonlinear Dynamic System Identification in the Spectral Domain Using Particle-Bernstein Polynomials. Electronics 11:19, pages 3100.
Crossref
Mingfei Lu & Badong Chen. (2022) Orthogonal Maximum Correntropy Learning. Orthogonal Maximum Correntropy Learning.
Lucas A. Tavares, Petrus E. O. G. B. Abreu & Luis A. Aguirre. (2021) Nonlinearity compensation based on identified NARX polynomials models. Nonlinear Dynamics 107:1, pages 709-725.
Crossref
Pedro C. Nariyoshi & J.R. DellerJr.Jr.. (2021) Nonlinear extensions of new causality. Neuroscience Informatics 1:1-2, pages 100001.
Crossref
Said Munir & Martin Mayfield. (2021) Application of Density Plots and Time Series Modelling to the Analysis of Nitrogen Dioxides Measured by Low-Cost and Reference Sensors in Urban Areas. Nitrogen 2:2, pages 167-195.
Crossref
Petrus E.O.G.B. Abreu, Victor D.R. Dreke, Luis A. Aguirre & Claudio Garcia. (2021) Enabling Invariant Models to Describe Time-Varying Dynamics: A Case Study. IFAC-PapersOnLine 54:14, pages 1-6.
Crossref
Petrus E. O. G. B. Abreu, Lucas A. Tavares, Bruno O. S. Teixeira & Luis A. Aguirre. (2020) Identification and nonlinearity compensation of hysteresis using NARX models. Nonlinear Dynamics 102:1, pages 285-301.
Crossref
Sohaib Obeid, Goodarz Ahmadi & Ratneshwar Jha. (2020) NARMAX Identification Based Closed-Loop Control of Flow Separation over NACA 0015 Airfoil. Fluids 5:3, pages 100.
Crossref
Xia Zhou & Sha Liu. (2020) Adaptive Immune Multiobjective Algorithm for LSSVM-based NARMAX model. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 768:4, pages 042036.
Crossref
Tong Liu, Sheng Chen, Shan Liang & Chris J. Harris. (2020) Selective ensemble of multiple local model learning for nonlinear and nonstationary systems. Neurocomputing 378, pages 98-111.
Crossref
Sergii Mashtalir & Volodymyr Mashtalir. 2020. Advances in Spatio-Temporal Segmentation of Visual Data. Advances in Spatio-Temporal Segmentation of Visual Data 161 210 .
Tong Liu, Shan Liang, Sheng Chen & Chris J. Harris. (2019) A Multiple Local Model Learning for Nonlinear and Time-Varying Microwave Heating Process. A Multiple Local Model Learning for Nonlinear and Time-Varying Microwave Heating Process.
Toluleke E. Akinola, Eni Oko, Yuanlin Gu, Hua-Liang Wei & Meihong Wang. (2019) Non-linear system identification of solvent-based post-combustion CO2 capture process. Fuel 239, pages 1213-1223.
Crossref
Dorian FlorescuDaniel Coca. (2018) Identification of Linear and Nonlinear Sensory Processing Circuits from Spiking Neuron Data. Neural Computation 30:3, pages 670-707.
Crossref
Yevgeniy Bodyanskiy, Olena Vynokurova & Oleksii Tyshchenko. 2017. Handbook of Research on Machine Learning Innovations and Trends. Handbook of Research on Machine Learning Innovations and Trends 787 825 .
Dorian FlorescuDorian Florescu. 2017. Reconstruction, Identification and Implementation Methods for Spiking Neural Circuits. Reconstruction, Identification and Implementation Methods for Spiking Neural Circuits 81 112 .
Bidyadhar Subudhi & Pedda Suresh Ogeti. (2016) Non‐linear autoregressive moving average with exogenous input model‐based adaptive control of a wind energy conversion system. The Journal of Engineering 2016:7, pages 218-226.
Crossref
Zhi Zhang. (2015) Modeling a lithium-ion battery based on a threshold model. Modeling a lithium-ion battery based on a threshold model.
Shichun Chi, Shasha Ni & Zhenping Liu. (2015) Back Analysis of the Permeability Coefficient of a High Core Rockfill Dam Based on a RBF Neural Network Optimized Using the PSO Algorithm. Mathematical Problems in Engineering 2015, pages 1-15.
Crossref
Sidney Bruce Shiki, Vicente LopesJrJr & Samuel da Silva. (2013) Identification of nonlinear structures using discrete-time Volterra series. Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering 36:3, pages 523-532.
Crossref
Paraskevi A. Samara, John S. Sakellariou, George N. Fouskitakis, John D. Hios & Spilios D. Fassois. (2013) Aircraft virtual sensor design via a Time-dependent Functional Pooling NARX methodology. Aerospace Science and Technology 29:1, pages 114-124.
Crossref
Stephen A Billings. 2013. Nonlinear System Identification. Nonlinear System Identification 119 147 .
Stephen A Billings. 2013. Nonlinear System Identification. Nonlinear System Identification 61 104 .
Stephen A Billings. 2013. Nonlinear System Identification. Nonlinear System Identification 17 59 .
Gnaba Sarah, Tarek Garna, Kais Bouzrara & Hassani Messaoud. (2013) Identification of the bilinear-Laguerre model on a sliding window. Identification of the bilinear-Laguerre model on a sliding window.
Fei Ye, Yong Sun & Qinmin Yang. (2013) An Adaptive Linear Element Based Method for Identification of Linear Parameter Varying Models. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 46:20, pages 309-314.
Crossref
Charles R. Farrar & Keith Worden. 2012. Structural Health Monitoring. Structural Health Monitoring 245 294 .
Ihsan Mohd Yassin, Mohd Nasir Taib, Ramli Adnan, Mohd Khairul Mohd Salleh & Mustafar Kamal Hamzah. (2012) MySQL database lookup table for Binary Particle Swarm optimization-based system identification. MySQL database lookup table for Binary Particle Swarm optimization-based system identification.
Ihsan Mohd Yassin, Mohd Nasir Taib, Ramli Adnan, Mohd Khairul Mohd Salleh & Mustafar Kamal Hamzah. (2012) Effect of swarm size parameter on Binary Particle Swarm optimization-based NARX structure selection. Effect of swarm size parameter on Binary Particle Swarm optimization-based NARX structure selection.
Subhashish Mohanty, Aditi Chattopadhyay & John N. Rajadas. (2012) Dynamic Strain Mapping and Real-Time Damage-State Estimation Under Random Fatigue Loading. AIAA Journal 50:4, pages 769-777.
Crossref
R. S. Gad, N. Vetrekar, I. Nazareth, J. S. Parab & G. M. Naik. (2012) Human tissue diagnostics for physiological information using Hyperspectral Image model. Human tissue diagnostics for physiological information using Hyperspectral Image model.
Sheng Chen, Xia Hong & Chris J. Harris. (2011) Grey-box radial basis function modelling. Neurocomputing 74:10, pages 1564-1571.
Crossref
D. Spina, B. G. Lamonaca, M. Nicoletti & M. Dolce. (2011) Structural monitoring by the Italian Department of Civil Protection and the case of 2009 Abruzzo seismic sequence. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering 9:1, pages 325-346.
Crossref
R. S. Gad, J. S. Parab & G. M. Naik. (2010) Note: Multivariate system spectroscopic model using Lorentz oscillators and partial least squares regression analysis. Review of Scientific Instruments 81:11.
Crossref
Ihsan M. Yassin, Mohd N. Taib, Azlee Zabidi, Hasliza Abu Hassan & Husna Zainol Abidin. (2010) Comparison between NARX parameter estimation methods with Binary Particle Swarm Optimization-based structure selection method. Comparison between NARX parameter estimation methods with Binary Particle Swarm Optimization-based structure selection method.
Wei Yu, David Wilson, Brent Young & Thomas Harris. (2009) Variance decomposition of nonlinear systems. Variance decomposition of nonlinear systems.
D. Achela FernandoAsaad Y. Shamseldin. (2009) Investigation of Internal Functioning of the Radial-Basis-Function Neural Network River Flow Forecasting Models. Journal of Hydrologic Engineering 14:3, pages 286-292.
Crossref
Sheng CHEN. (2009) Orthogonal-Least-Squares Forward Selection for Parsimonious Modelling from Data. Engineering 01:02, pages 55-74.
Crossref
Sunil L. Kukreja. (2008) Structure Computation of Quiet Spike Flight-Test Data During Envelope Expansion. Journal of Aircraft 45:5, pages 1579-1584.
Crossref
O.K. Cheremnykh, V.I. Sidorenko & V.A. Yatsenko. (2008) Nonlinear dynamical-information magnetosphere models for space weather forecasting. Kosmìčna nauka ì tehnologìâ 14:1, pages 77-84.
Crossref
Z.Q. Lang, S.A. Billings, R. Yue & J. Li. (2007) Output frequency response function of nonlinear Volterra systems. Automatica 43:5, pages 805-816.
Crossref
Sunil L. Kukreja & Martin J. Brenner. (2007) Nonlinear Black-Box Modeling of Aeroelastic Systems Using Structure Detection Approach: Application to F/A-18 Aircraft Data. Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics 30:2, pages 557-564.
Crossref
Sunil L. Kukreja & Martin J. Brenner. 2007. Identification and Control. Identification and Control 117 145 .
Z.Q. Lang, S.A. Billings, G.R. Tomlinson & R. Yue. (2006) Analytical description of the effects of system nonlinearities on output frequency responses: A case study. Journal of Sound and Vibration 295:3-5, pages 584-601.
Crossref
Hong-li Shi, Yuan-li Cai & Zu-lian Qiu. (2006) System identification based on NARMAX model using Hopfield networks. Journal of Shanghai University (English Edition) 10:3, pages 238-243.
Crossref
Gaëtan Kerschen, Keith Worden, Alexander F. Vakakis & Jean-Claude Golinval. (2006) Past, present and future of nonlinear system identification in structural dynamics. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 20:3, pages 505-592.
Crossref
Sunil L. Kukreja & Martin J. Brenner. (2006) Nonlinear Aeroelastic System Identification with Application to Experimental Data. Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics 29:2, pages 374-381.
Crossref
S. Chen. (2006) Local regularization assisted orthogonal least squares regression. Neurocomputing 69:4-6, pages 559-585.
Crossref
Sheng Chen, Xia Hong, C.J. Harris & Xunxian Wang. (2005) Identification of nonlinear systems using generalized kernel models. IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology 13:3, pages 401-411.
Crossref
S.L. Kukreja, R.E. Kearney & H.L. Galiana. (2005) A Least-Squares Parameter Estimation Algorithm for Switched Hammerstein Systems With Applications to the VOR. IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 52:3, pages 431-444.
Crossref
Gianluca Zito & Ioan Doré Landau. (2005) A METHODOLOGY FOR IDENTIFICATION OF NARMAX MODELS APPLIED TO DIESEL ENGINES. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 38:1, pages 374-379.
Crossref
Z Q Lang, M Futterer & S A Billings. (2005) THE IDENTIFICATION OF A CLASS OF NONLINEAR SYSTEMS USING A CORRELATION ANALYSIS APPROACH. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 38:1, pages 208-212.
Crossref
G. Zito & I.D. Landau. (2005) Narmax model identification of a variable geometry turbocharged diesel engine. Narmax model identification of a variable geometry turbocharged diesel engine.
Yeon-Sun Choi. (2004) Nonlinear parameter identification of partial rotor rub based on experiment. KSME International Journal 18:11, pages 1969-1977.
Crossref
S. Chen, X. Hong, C.J. Harris & P.M. Sharkey. (2004) Sparse Modeling Using Orthogonal Forward Regression With PRESS Statistic and Regularization. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, Part B (Cybernetics) 34:2, pages 898-911.
Crossref
S. Chen, X. Hong & C.J. Harris. (2003) Sparse kernel regression modeling using combined locally regularized orthogonal least squares and d-optimality experimental design. IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 48:6, pages 1029-1036.
Crossref
S.L. Kukreja, H.L. Galiana & R.E. Kearney. (2003) NARMAX representation and identification of ankle dynamics. IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering 50:1, pages 70-81.
Crossref
Q M Zhu & L Z Guo. (2016) A pole placement controller for non-linear dynamic plants. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part I: Journal of Systems and Control Engineering 216:6, pages 467-476.
Crossref
S M Ahmad, M H Shaheed, A J Chipperfield & M O Tokhi. (2005) Non-linear modelling of a one-degree-of-freedom twin-rotor multi-input multi-output system using radial basis function networks. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part G: Journal of Aerospace Engineering 216:4, pages 197-208.
Crossref
S. Chen. (2002) Multi-output regression using a locally regularised orthogonal least-squares algorithm. IEE Proceedings - Vision, Image, and Signal Processing 149:4, pages 185.
Crossref
Georgios B Giannakis & Erchin Serpedin. (2001) A bibliography on nonlinear system identification. Signal Processing 81:3, pages 533-580.
Crossref
M.A. Balikhin, I. Bates & S. Walker. (2001) Identification of linear and nonlinear processes in space plasma turbulence data. Advances in Space Research 28:5, pages 787-800.
Crossref
M. V. CORRÊA, L. A. AGUIRRE & E. M. A. M. MENDES. (2012) MODELING CHAOTIC DYNAMICS WITH DISCRETE NONLINEAR RATIONAL MODELS. International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos 10:05, pages 1019-1032.
Crossref
D.L. Yu, J.B. Gomm & D. Williams. (2000) Neural model input selection for a MIMO chemical process. Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence 13:1, pages 15-23.
Crossref
Li Cheng, Xu Kejun & Liang Bin. (2000) Parameter identification of dynamic nonlinear model based on FLANN. Parameter identification of dynamic nonlinear model based on FLANN.
Zi-Qiang Lang & S.A. Billings. (2000) Evaluation of output frequency responses of nonlinear systems under multiple inputs. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems II: Analog and Digital Signal Processing 47:1, pages 28-38.
Crossref
O.M. Boaghe & S.A. Billings. (2000) Dynamic Wavelet and Equivalent Models. European Journal of Control 6:2, pages 120-131.
Crossref
E. Ronco & P. J. Gawthrop. (1999) Incremental polynomial model-controller network: a self-organising nonlinear controller. IEE Proceedings - Control Theory and Applications 146:6, pages 527-534.
Crossref
D. COCA & S.A. BILLINGS. (1999) A DIRECT APPROACH TO IDENTIFICATION OF NONLINEAR DIFFERENTIAL MODELS FROM DISCRETE DATA. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 13:5, pages 739-755.
Crossref
Ioannis G. Sargantanis & M. N. Karim. (2004) Variable structure NARX models: Application to dissolved‐oxygen bioprocess. AIChE Journal 45:9, pages 2034-2045.
Crossref
S. A. BILLINGS & D. COCA. (2011) DISCRETE WAVELET MODELS FOR IDENTIFICATION AND QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS OF CHAOTIC SYSTEMS. International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos 09:07, pages 1263-1284.
Crossref
Boz̊ena KostekBoz̊ena Kostek. 1999. Soft Computing in Acoustics. Soft Computing in Acoustics 231 243 .
Iulian B Ciocoiu. (1998) Time series analysis using RBF networks with FIR/IIR synapses. Neurocomputing 20:1-3, pages 57-66.
Crossref
L.A. Aguirre & C.R.F. Jácome. (1998) Cluster analysis of NARMAX models for signal-dependent systems. IEE Proceedings - Control Theory and Applications 145:4, pages 409-414.
Crossref
Steve A. Billings & X. Hong. (1998) Dual-orthogonal radial basis function networks for nonlinear time series prediction. Neural Networks 11:3, pages 479-493.
Crossref
H.O. Gulcur, M. Demirer & T. Demiralp. (1998) An RBF approach to single trial VEP estimation. An RBF approach to single trial VEP estimation.
S.A. Billings & S Chen. 1998. Control and Dynamic System. Control and Dynamic System 231 278 .
M.O. Tokhi & R. Wood. (1997) Active noise control using radial basis function networks. Control Engineering Practice 5:9, pages 1311-1322.
Crossref
I. Scott & B. Mulgrew. (1997) Nonlinear system identification and prediction using orthogonal functions. IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing 45:7, pages 1842-1853.
Crossref
D.L. Yu, J.B. Gomm & D. Williams. (1997) Selection of Neural Model Order and Time-Delay for MIMO Non-Linear Systems and a Case Study on a CSTR Process. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 30:11, pages 227-232.
Crossref
Chi F. Fung, Steve A. Billings & Wan Luo. (1996) On-line Supervised Adaptive Training Using Radial Basis Function Networks. Neural Networks 9:9, pages 1597-1617.
Crossref
Guang L. Zheng & Steve A. Billings. (1996) Radial Basis Function Network Configuration Using Mutual Information and the Orthogonal Least Squares Algorithm. Neural Networks 9:9, pages 1619-1637.
Crossref
M. Thomson, S.P. Schooling & M. Soufian. (1996) The practical application of a nonlinear identification methodology. Control Engineering Practice 4:3, pages 295-306.
Crossref
W. Luo, S.A. Billings & K.M. Tsang. (1996) On-line Structure Detection and Parameter Estimation with Exponential Windowing for Nonlinear Systems. European Journal of Control 2:4, pages 291-304.
Crossref
W. Luo & S.A. Billings. (1995) Adaptive model selection and estimation for nonlinear systems using a sliding data window. Signal Processing 46:2, pages 179-202.
Crossref
Chu Kwong Chak, Gang Feng & Chi Ming Cheng. (1995) Orthogonal polynomials neural network for function approximation and system modeling. Orthogonal polynomials neural network for function approximation and system modeling.
L.A. Aguirre & S.A. Billings. (1994) Model reference control of regular and chaotic dynamics in the Duffing-Ueda oscillator. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Fundamental Theory and Applications 41:7, pages 477-480.
Crossref
Q.M. Zhu & S.A. Billings. (1994) Identification of Polynomial & Rational Narmax Models. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 27:8, pages 259-264.
Crossref
Guan-Chun Luh & G. Rizzoni. (1994) Identification of a nonlinear MIMO IC engine model during I/M240 driving cycle for on-board diagnosis. Identification of a nonlinear MIMO IC engine model during I/M240 driving cycle for on-board diagnosis.
S. Chen, S. McLaughlin & B. Mulgrew. (1994) Complex-valued radial basic function network, Part I: Network architecture and learning algorithms. Signal Processing 35:1, pages 19-31.
Crossref
K.C. Lin & K.N. Reid. (1993) An Approach to Modeling and Identification of Systems with Signal-Dependent Parameters. IFAC Proceedings Volumes 26:2, pages 945-952.
Crossref
Mike Hapgood. 1993. Intelligent Information Retrieval: The Case of Astronomy and Related Space Sciences. Intelligent Information Retrieval: The Case of Astronomy and Related Space Sciences 153 171 .
Carlos J. Pantaleón-Prieto & Aníbal R. Figueiras-Vidal. 1993. New Trends in Neural Computation. New Trends in Neural Computation 525 530 .
Martin Pottman & Dale E. Seborg. (1992) Identification of non-linear processes using reciprocal multiquadric functions. Journal of Process Control 2:4, pages 189-203.
Crossref
S. Chen, C.F.N. Cowan & P.M. Grant. (1991) Orthogonal least squares learning algorithm for radial basis function networks. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 2:2, pages 302-309.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.