3,841
Views
119
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

'Pedagogy, Identity and the Construction of a Theory of Symbolic Control': Basil Bernstein questioned by Joseph Solomon

Pages 265-279 | Published online: 28 Jun 2010

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (46)

Henry Kwok, Parlo Singh & Stephen Heimans. (2023) The regime of ‘post-truth’: COVID-19 and the politics of knowledge. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 44:1, pages 106-120.
Read now
David Holland-Smith. (2022) Habitus and practice: social reproduction and trajectory in outdoor education and higher education. Sport, Education and Society 27:9, pages 1071-1085.
Read now
Johan Muller. (2022) ‘The shadows of “boundary” remain’: curriculum coherence and the spectre of practice. Teaching in Higher Education 27:8, pages 1027-1041.
Read now
James Carson. (2022) ‘Re-thinking a Bachelor of Arts for the 21st-Century precariat’. Studies in Higher Education 47:7, pages 1477-1487.
Read now
Nick Pratt & Julie Shaughnessy. (2021) The effects of managerialism in higher education on doctoral theorising: time to think?. British Journal of Sociology of Education 42:8, pages 1123-1138.
Read now
Yaw Owusu-Agyeman. (2021) Transformational leadership and innovation in higher education: a participative process approach. International Journal of Leadership in Education 24:5, pages 694-716.
Read now
Christine M. Steenkamp, Ilse Rootman-le Grange & Kristian K. Müller-Nedebock. (2021) Analysing assessments in introductory physics using semantic gravity: refocussing on core concepts and context-dependence. Teaching in Higher Education 26:6, pages 871-886.
Read now
Eugenia Katartzi & Geoff Hayward. (2020) Transitions to higher education: the case of students with vocational background. Studies in Higher Education 45:12, pages 2371-2381.
Read now
Tien-Hui Chiang, Allen Thurston, Jiangtao Zhao, Yanli Hao, Jing Ma & Yonggui Dong. (2020) The practice of weak framing from teachers’ perceptions in China. British Journal of Sociology of Education 41:8, pages 1180-1199.
Read now
Deborah Youdell, Martin Lindley, Kimron Shapiro, Yu Sun & Yue Leng. (2020) From science wars to transdisciplinarity: the inescapability of the neuroscience, biology and sociology of learning. British Journal of Sociology of Education 41:6, pages 881-899.
Read now
Eugenia Katartzi & Geoff Hayward. (2020) Conceptualising transitions from vocational to higher education: bringing together Bourdieu and Bernstein. British Journal of Sociology of Education 41:3, pages 299-314.
Read now
Susan Giloi & Lynn Quinn. (2019) Assessment of Sustainable Design: The Significance of Absence. The Design Journal 22:6, pages 833-851.
Read now
Leigh Sperka. (2019) Selecting, understanding and applying theory as a neophyte researcher. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health 11:3, pages 348-363.
Read now
Marky Jean-Pierre. (2019) Language, education, and development: post-colonial societies and neoliberalism. British Journal of Sociology of Education 40:4, pages 507-522.
Read now
Charlene Tan. (2019) Competence or Performance? A Bernsteinian Analysis of Basic Competency Assessment in Hong Kong. British Journal of Educational Studies 67:2, pages 235-250.
Read now
David A. Griffiths, Margaret Inman, Harriet Rojas & Kent Williams. (2018) Transitioning student identity and sense of place: future possibilities for assessment and development of student employability skills. Studies in Higher Education 43:5, pages 891-913.
Read now
Leonel Lim. (2017) Regulating the unthinkable: Bernstein’s pedagogic device and the paradox of control. International Studies in Sociology of Education 26:4, pages 353-374.
Read now
Chrissie Boughey & Sioux McKenna. (2017) Analysing an audit cycle: a critical realist account. Studies in Higher Education 42:6, pages 963-975.
Read now
Marianne Dovemark & Ann-Sofie Holm. (2017) Pedagogic identities for sale! Segregation and homogenization in Swedish upper secondary school. British Journal of Sociology of Education 38:4, pages 518-532.
Read now
Parlo Singh. (2017) Pedagogic governance: theorising with/after Bernstein. British Journal of Sociology of Education 38:2, pages 144-163.
Read now
Tobias Werler & Margaret Klepstad Færevaag. (2017) National testing data in Norwegian classrooms: a tool to improve pupil performance?. Nordic Journal of Studies in Educational Policy 3:1, pages 67-81.
Read now
Annette Rasmussen & Karen Andreasen. (2016) Implicit knowledge of general upper secondary school in a bridge-building project. Ethnography and Education 11:3, pages 316-330.
Read now
Polychronis Sifakakis, Anna Tsatsaroni, Antigone Sarakinioti & Menie Kourou. (2016) Governance and knowledge transformations in educational administration: Greek responses to global policies. Journal of Educational Administration and History 48:1, pages 35-67.
Read now
Peter Hay, Richard Tinning & Craig Engstrom. (2015) Assessment as pedagogy: a consideration of pedagogical work and the preparation of kinesiology professionals. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy 20:1, pages 31-44.
Read now
Nick Pratt, Michael Tedder, Ruth Boyask & Peter Kelly. (2015) Pedagogic relations and professional change: a sociocultural analysis of students' learning in a professional doctorate. Studies in Higher Education 40:1, pages 43-59.
Read now
Anthony Chee Siong Leow, Doune Macdonald, Peter Hay & Louise McCuaig. (2014) Health-education policy interface: the implementation of the Eat Well Be Active policies in schools. Sport, Education and Society 19:8, pages 991-1013.
Read now
Leonel Lim. (2014) Critical thinking and the anti-liberal state: the politics of pedagogic recontextualization in Singapore. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 35:5, pages 692-704.
Read now
Hauke Straehler-Pohl & Uwe Gellert. (2013) Towards a Bernsteinian language of description for mathematics classroom discourse. British Journal of Sociology of Education 34:3, pages 313-332.
Read now
Kyriaki Anagnostopoulou, Vassilia Hatzinikita, Vasilia Christidou & Kostas Dimopoulos. (2013) PISA Test Items and School-Based Examinations in Greece: Exploring the relationship between global and local assessment discourses. International Journal of Science Education 35:4, pages 636-662.
Read now
Paul Ashwin. (2012) How often are theories developed through empirical research into higher education?. Studies in Higher Education 37:8, pages 941-955.
Read now
James Badger. (2010) Classification and framing in the case method: discussion leaders' questions. Journal of Further and Higher Education 34:4, pages 503-518.
Read now
Natalie Canning & Sue Callan. (2010) Heutagogy: spirals of reflection to empower learners in higher education. Reflective Practice 11:1, pages 71-82.
Read now
Xavier Rambla & Antoni Veger. (2009) Pedagogising poverty alleviation: a discourse analysis of educational and social policies in Argentina and Chile. British Journal of Sociology of Education 30:4, pages 463-477.
Read now
WayneW. Au. (2008) Devising inequality: a Bernsteinian analysis of high‐stakes testing and social reproduction in education. British Journal of Sociology of Education 29:6, pages 639-651.
Read now
Margaret Zeegers & Deirdre Barron. (2008) Discourses of Deficit in Higher Degree Research Supervisory Pedagogies for International Students. Pedagogies: An International Journal 3:2, pages 69-84.
Read now
Gerasimos Koustourakis. (2007) The new educational policy for the reform of the curriculum and the change of school knowledge in the case of Greek compulsory education. International Studies in Sociology of Education 17:1-2, pages 131-146.
Read now
Xavier Bonal & Xavier Rambla. (2003) Captured by the Totally Pedagogised Society: Teachers and teaching in the knowledge economy. Globalisation, Societies and Education 1:2, pages 169-184.
Read now
Roy Nash. (2001) Class, 'Ability' and Attainment: A problem for the sociology of education. British Journal of Sociology of Education 22:2, pages 189-202.
Read now
Parlo Singh, Karen Dooley & Peter Freebody. (2001) Literacy Pedagogies that may 'make a difference'. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education 29:1, pages 49-71.
Read now
Karen Dooley, Beryl Exley & Parlo Singh. (2000) Social justice and curriculum renewal for Samoan students: an Australian case study. International Journal of Inclusive Education 4:1, pages 23-41.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (73)

Areti VogopoulouAntigone SarakiniotiPolychronis SifakakisAnna Tsatsaroni. (2024) European foreign language policies, national language testing and ambivalence towards the introduction of the logics of standardisation. European Journal of Language Policy 16:1, pages 27-57.
Crossref
Qian Zhao & Zezhi Zheng. (2024) Knowledge-Building in Classroom: A Multimodal Semantic Wave Model. Sage Open 14:2.
Crossref
Álvarez Fernando, Pérez Hernán, Aravena Soledad & Quezada Camilo. (2024) Discriminación auditiva de fonemas modificados experimentalmente para el logro de tareas de análisis fonémico. Revista de Logopedia, Foniatría y Audiología 44:2, pages 100486.
Crossref
Deb Brosseuk. (2022) Mixing performance and competence pedagogic orientations to assessment of writing and text production in the early years. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood 25:1, pages 48-61.
Crossref
Yaw Owusu-Agyeman & Enna Moroeroe. 2023. Transformational Leadership Styles for Global Leaders. Transformational Leadership Styles for Global Leaders 20 36 .
Flavio Martins, Luciana Cezarino, Lara Liboni, Trevor Hunter, Andre Batalhao & Marco Antonio Catussi Paschoalotto. (2023) Unlocking the potential of responsible management education through interdisciplinary approaches. Sustainable Development.
Crossref
Qiliang Xu & Qianhua Ouyang. (2023) Unleashing the power of meta-knowledge: Towards cumulative learning in interpreter training. Interpreting and Society 3:2, pages 169-194.
Crossref
R. Cubero-Pérez, M. Cubero, J. A. Matías-García & M. J. Bascón. (2023) Learner identity in secondary post-compulsory education students from Areas in Need of Social Transformation: an example of resilience. European Journal of Psychology of Education.
Crossref
Igor’ Kontorovich & Tikva Ovadiya. (2023) How narratives about the secondary-tertiary transition shape undergraduate tutors’ sense-making of their teaching. Educational Studies in Mathematics 113:1, pages 125-146.
Crossref
Satria Fadil Persada, Yogi Tri Prasetyo, I. Gusti Ayu Pramoedya Maharani, Bahalwan Apriyansyah, Ardvin K. S. Ong, Michael Nayat Young, Reny Nadlifatin, Etsa Astridya Setiyati, Mardhatillah Shanti, Riesta Devi Kumalasari, Sahnaz Ubud, Raden Aditya Kristamtomo Putra, Helena Hanindya Kartika Putri, Gilbert Aldrich Gunawan, Ida Bagus Ananta Wijaya, Asih Zunaidah, Gabriella Sagita Putri, Yuventia Prisca, Anak Agung Ngurah Perwira Redi & Mohammad Razif. (2023) How Tourists Reacted to Ecotourism during COVID-19: Insights on Its Sustainability from a Multivariate Analysis Based on the Case of Banyuwangi. Sustainability 15:2, pages 1440.
Crossref
Jovana Anđelković. (2023) Accountability of employees in public administration. Bizinfo Blace 14:1, pages 111-116.
Crossref
Masaaki Katsuno. 2023. International Handbook on Education Development in the Asia-Pacific. International Handbook on Education Development in the Asia-Pacific 1835 1851 .
Din-Yuang Huang. 2023. Learning Technology for Education Challenges. Learning Technology for Education Challenges 255 264 .
Ximena Martínez. 2023. Intercultural Education in Chile. Intercultural Education in Chile 87 108 .
Flavio Martins, Luciana Cezarino & Lara Liboni. 2023. The Route Towards Global Sustainability. The Route Towards Global Sustainability 177 193 .
Travis M. Noakes, David Bell & Timothy D. Noakes. (2022) Who is watching the World Health Organisation? ‘Post-truth’ moments beyond infodemic research. The Journal for Transdisciplinary Research in Southern Africa 18:1.
Crossref
Shiyong Wu, Wenxin Chen, Wei Chen & Wen Zheng. (2022) Effects of Cultural Intelligence and Imposter Syndrome on School Belonging through Academic Resilience among University Students with Vocational Backgrounds. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19:13, pages 7944.
Crossref
Wenxin Chen, Yi Lin, Xiaoyan Yu, Wen Zheng, Shiyong Wu, Mingxi Huang, Wei Chen & Shuyi Zhou. (2022) The Relationship between Bicultural Identity Integration, Self-Esteem, Academic Resilience, Interaction Anxiousness, and School Belonging among University Students with Vocational Qualifications. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19:6, pages 3632.
Crossref
Gilder Davila. (2022) Japanese school administrators’ experiences after the implementation of the Top Global University Project language policy. SN Social Sciences 2:2.
Crossref
Maura Striano. 2022. Educazione degli Adulti: politiche, percorsi, prospettive. Educazione degli Adulti: politiche, percorsi, prospettive 223 230 .
Masaaki Katsuno. 2022. International Handbook on Education Development in Asia-Pacific. International Handbook on Education Development in Asia-Pacific 1 17 .
Sarah Pearce. (2021) The role of British Schools Overseas in promoting and upholding British values: using transmission context in policy analysis. Journal of Research in International Education 20:3, pages 191-210.
Crossref
Geoff Hayward, Eugenia Katartzi, Hubert Ertl & Michael Hoelscher. 2021. Degrees of Success. Degrees of Success 189 217 .
Tien-Hui Chiang, Pingping Zhang, Yonggui Dong, Allen Thurston, Laiting Cui & Jun-ren Liu. (2021) How is regulative discourse recontextualized into instructional discourse in Basil Bernstein’s code theory? A study of the interplay between recognition and realization rules based on primary school teachers’ perceptions. International Journal of Educational Research 108, pages 101765.
Crossref
Maria Gebbels, Xiongbin Gao & Wenjie Cai. (2020) Let’s not just “talk” about it: reflections on women’s career development in hospitality. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management 32:11, pages 3623-3643.
Crossref
Keith S. Taber. (2019) Conceptual confusion in the chemistry curriculum: exemplifying the problematic nature of representing chemical concepts as target knowledge. Foundations of Chemistry 22:2, pages 309-334.
Crossref
Milena Miałkowska-Kozaryna. (2020) Teacher, speak slang! – language as the basic tool of the teacher's work. Problemy Opiekuńczo-Wychowawcze 587:2, pages 34-41.
Crossref
Thabisile Nkambule. 2020. Rurality, Social Justice and Education in Sub-Saharan Africa Volume II. Rurality, Social Justice and Education in Sub-Saharan Africa Volume II 101 125 .
Christopher DeLuca, Jill Willis, Bronwen Cowie, Christine Harrison, Andrew Coombs, Andrew Gibson & Suzanne Trask. (2019) Policies, Programs, and Practices: Exploring the Complex Dynamics of Assessment Education in Teacher Education Across Four Countries. Frontiers in Education 4.
Crossref
Valgerður S. Bjarnadóttir, Elisabet Öhrn & Monica Johansson. (2019) Pedagogic practices in a deregulated upper secondary school: Students’ attempts to influence their teaching. European Educational Research Journal 18:6, pages 724-742.
Crossref
J. Zoe Jordens & Nick Zepke. (2017) Quality Teaching in Science: an Emergent Conceptual Framework. Research in Science Education 49:5, pages 1415-1432.
Crossref
Iuliia Platonova & Ignatius G.P. Gous. (2019) The online educated or online indoctrinated human? Discourse analysis as a method to study ideologies disseminated by online courses. HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies 75:1.
Crossref
Paul Maharg & Julian Webb. 2019. Critical Perspectives on the Scholarship of Assessment and Learning in Law: Volume 1: England. Critical Perspectives on the Scholarship of Assessment and Learning in Law: Volume 1: England 25 49 .
Einat Heyd-Metzuyanim & Galit Shabtay. (2019) Narratives of ‘good’ instruction: teachers’ identities as drawing on exploration vs. acquisition pedagogical discourses. ZDM 51:3, pages 541-554.
Crossref
Richard Pountney & Graham McPhail. (2019) Crossing boundaries: Exploring the theory, practice and possibility of a ‘Future 3’ curriculum. British Educational Research Journal 45:3, pages 483-501.
Crossref
Neil M. Speirs. 2019. Social Responsibility and Sustainability. Social Responsibility and Sustainability 123 137 .
Susan L Robertson & Tore Sorensen. (2017) Global transformations of the state, governance and teachers’ labour: Putting Bernstein’s conceptual grammar to work. European Educational Research Journal 17:4, pages 470-488.
Crossref
Lisa Beccaria, Megan Y.C.A. Kek & Henk Huijser. (2018) Exploring nursing educators' use of theory and methods in search for evidence based credibility in nursing education. Nurse Education Today 65, pages 60-66.
Crossref
Zvi Bekerman & Michalinos ZembylasZvi Bekerman & Michalinos Zembylas. 2018. Psychologized Language in Education. Psychologized Language in Education 149 166 .
Nikola Leufer & Nina Bohlmann. 2018. Inside the Mathematics Class. Inside the Mathematics Class 83 102 .
Roland Reichenbach. 2018. International Handbook of Philosophy of Education. International Handbook of Philosophy of Education 1429 1445 .
Craig Skerritt. (2017) The code for success? Using a Bernsteinian perspective on sociolinguistics to accentuate working-class students’ underachievement in the Republic of Ireland. Irish Journal of Sociology 25:3, pages 274-296.
Crossref
Russell Tytler, David Symington & John Cripps Clark. (2016) Community-School Collaborations in Science: Towards Improved Outcomes Through Better Understanding of Boundary Issues. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education 15:4, pages 643-661.
Crossref
Nick Pratt & Peter Kelly. (2016) The cultural construction of subject discipline knowledge: comparing ‘abstraction’ in two international contexts. Research in Comparative and International Education 11:4, pages 434-448.
Crossref
Iuliia Platonova, Elena Tarasova & Anastasia Golubinskaya. (2015) Creolized Text as a form of Modern Educational Discourse. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 214, pages 788-796.
Crossref
Karen Guo & Noella Mackenzie. (2015) Signs and Codes in Early Childhood: An Investigation of Young Children's Creative Approaches to Communication. Australasian Journal of Early Childhood 40:2, pages 78-87.
Crossref
Melinda A. Lemke. 2015. Neoliberalizing Educational Reform. Neoliberalizing Educational Reform 53 77 .
John Preston & Magdalini Kolokitha. 2015. City Evacuations: An Interdisciplinary Approach. City Evacuations: An Interdisciplinary Approach 1 20 .
Emil A. Sobottka. (2014) Multidisziplinäre Kooperation versus ProfessionsexklusivitätMultidisciplinary cooperation versus exclusive responsibility. Soziale Passagen 6:1, pages 85-105.
Crossref
Cate Watson. (2012) Effective professional learning communities? The possibilities for teachers as agents of change in schools. British Educational Research Journal 40:1, pages 18-29.
Crossref
Margaret A. L. Blackie. (2014) Creating semantic waves: using Legitimation Code Theory as a tool to aid the teaching of chemistry. Chem. Educ. Res. Pract. 15:4, pages 462-469.
Crossref
James Scotland. (2014) Operating in global educational contact zones: How pedagogical adaptation to local contexts may result in the renegotiation of the professional identities of English language teachers. Teaching and Teacher Education 37, pages 33-43.
Crossref
Mellony Graven & Stephen Lerman. 2014. Encyclopedia of Mathematics Education. Encyclopedia of Mathematics Education 434 438 .
. 2013. Making a Difference in Theory. Making a Difference in Theory 210 220 .
Lisbeth Lundahl & Maria Olson. (2013) Democracy lessons in market-oriented schools: The case of Swedish upper secondary education. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice 8:2, pages 201-213.
Crossref
Anne Adams, Elizabeth Fitzgerald & Gary Priestnall. (2013) Of Catwalk Technologies and Boundary Creatures. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 20:3, pages 1-34.
Crossref
Parlo Singh, Mariann Märtsin & Kathryn Glasswell. (2013) Knowledge work at the boundary: Making a difference to educational disadvantage. Learning, Culture and Social Interaction 2:2, pages 102-110.
Crossref
Anne Adams. 2012. Digital Identity and Social Media. Digital Identity and Social Media 159 175 .
Lisbeth Lundahl. (2012) Educational Theory in an Era of Knowledge Capitalism. Studies in Philosophy and Education 31:3, pages 215-226.
Crossref
John Preston. 2012. Disaster Education. Disaster Education 1 10 .
Nikleia Eteokleous-Grigoriou, Garifalos Anagnostou & Simeon Tsolakidis. 2012. Research on e-Learning and ICT in Education. Research on e-Learning and ICT in Education 109 123 .
Martin S McNamara, Gerard M Fealy, Mary Casey, Ruth Geraghty, Maree Johnson, Phil Halligan, Pearl Treacy & Michelle Butler. (2011) Boundary matters: clinical leadership and the distinctive disciplinary contribution of nursing to multidisciplinary care. Journal of Clinical Nursing 20:23-24, pages 3502-3512.
Crossref
Lisbeth Lundahl. (2011) Paving the Way to the Future? Education and Young Europeans' Paths to Work and Independence. European Educational Research Journal 10:2, pages 168-179.
Crossref
Park-Sunmee. (2010) The Impact of Curriculum Structure on Textbook Diversification in Social Studies. The Journal of The Korean Association of Geographic and Environmental Education 18:3, pages 251-267.
Crossref
Rhona Sharpe, Helen Beetham & Sara de Freitas. 2010. Rethinking Learning for a Digital Age. Rethinking Learning for a Digital Age 164 174 .
Martin S McNamara. (2010) Where is nursing in academic nursing? disciplinary discourses, identities and clinical practice: a critical perspective from Ireland. Journal of Clinical Nursing 19:5-6, pages 766-774.
Crossref
Rosângela Saldanha Pereira & Xavier Rambla. (2009) La reproducción de las desigualdades educativas a través del fenómeno de la "sobre-edad" en Brasil. Educação e Pesquisa 35:2, pages 287-301.
Crossref
Natasa Vujisic-Zivkovic. (2009) Pedagogisation as a conceptual framework for understanding modern education. Zbornik Instituta za pedagoska istrazivanja 41:2, pages 247-263.
Crossref
Martin S. McNamara. (2008) Of bedpans and ivory towers? Nurse academics’ identities and the sacred and profane: A Bernsteinian analysis and discussion paper. International Journal of Nursing Studies 45:3, pages 458-470.
Crossref
. 2008. Actualité de Basil Bernstein. Actualité de Basil Bernstein 295 299 .
Christian W. Beck. (2007) Utviklingen i Basil Bernsteins utdanningssosiologi med vekt på de senere år. Norsk pedagogisk tidsskrift 91:3, pages 245-256.
Crossref
Ana M. Morais, Isabel P. Neves & Margarida Afonso. (2005) Teacher training processes and teachers’ competence—a sociological study in the primary school. Teaching and Teacher Education 21:4, pages 415-437.
Crossref
Rosanne Evangelista Dias & Alice Casimiro Lopes. (2003) Competências na formação de professores no Brasil: o que (não) há de novo. Educação & Sociedade 24:85, pages 1155-1177.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.