361
Views
30
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Are direct or indirect measures of comparative risk better predictors of concern and behavioural intentions?

Pages 149-165 | Received 10 Jan 2008, Accepted 10 Jul 2008, Published online: 31 Oct 2008

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (6)

Jason P. Rose, Keith A. Edmonds, Olivia Aspiras, Megh Kumar, Kayla Scamaldo, Julia R. Richmond, Matthew T. Tull & Kim L. Gratz. (2023) The impact of stay-at-home orders on vulnerability assessments and precautionary intentions during a pandemic. Psychology, Health & Medicine 28:5, pages 1368-1379.
Read now
Lu Zhang, Wei Wei & Nan Hua. (2022) Service security breaches: the impact of comparative optimism. The Service Industries Journal 42:15-16, pages 1190-1210.
Read now
Keith A. Edmonds, Jason P. Rose, Olivia G. Aspiras & Megh S. Kumar. (2022) Absolute and comparative risk assessments: evidence for the utility of incorporating internal comparisons into models of risk perception. Psychology & Health 37:11, pages 1414-1430.
Read now
K.A. Laferriere, E.J. Crighton, J. Baxter, L. Lemyre, J.R. Masuda & F. Ursitti. (2016) Examining inequities in children’s environmental health: results of a survey on the risk perceptions and protective actions of new mothers. Journal of Risk Research 19:3, pages 271-287.
Read now
Sherine El-Toukhy. (2015) Parsing Susceptibility and Severity Dimensions of Health Risk Perceptions. Journal of Health Communication 20:5, pages 499-511.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (24)

Hallgeir Sjåstad & Jay Van Bavel. (2023) The Best-Case Heuristic: Relative Optimism in Relationships, Politics, and a Global Health Pandemic. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.
Crossref
Jillian O’Rourke Stuart, Paul D. Windschitl, Elaine Bossard, Kathryn Bruchmann, Andrew R. Smith, Jason P. Rose & Jerry Suls. (2023) Which measures of perceived vulnerability predict protective intentions—and when?. Journal of Behavioral Medicine.
Crossref
Jason P. Rose, Keith A. Edmonds & Chloe N. Beeler. (2023) Dimensional and social comparisons in a health fitness context. Journal of Behavioral Medicine.
Crossref
Atsushi Kimura, Tomonori Saito, Yoshiko Yamane & Takahito Shimada. (2023) Effect of optimistic bias on crime prevention behaviors regarding fraud among elderly people楽観バイアスが高齢者の特殊詐欺対策行動に及ぼす影響. The Japanese journal of psychology 94:2, pages 120-128.
Crossref
Sungeun Chung, Youllee Kim & Minsun Shim. (2022) Types of Perceived Risk Likelihood and Prediction of Preventive Behaviors : Absolute vs. Comparative, and Conditional vs. Unconditional Risk Perceptions. Korean Journal of Journalism & Communication Studies 66:2, pages 155-187.
Crossref
Jason P. Rose & Keith A. Edmonds. (2021) Social Comparisons for Following Health Recommendations and Their Relation to Worry and Intentions During COVID-19. European Journal of Health Psychology 28:4, pages 141-151.
Crossref
Kim L Gratz, Julia R Richmond, Sherry E Woods, Katherine L Dixon-Gordon, Kayla M Scamaldo, Jason P Rose & Matthew T Tull. (2021) Adherence to Social Distancing Guidelines Throughout the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Roles of Pseudoscientific Beliefs, Trust, Political Party Affiliation, and Risk Perceptions. Annals of Behavioral Medicine 55:5, pages 399-412.
Crossref
Annette R Kaufman, Jenny E Twesten, Jerry Suls, Kevin D McCaul, Jamie S Ostroff, Rebecca A Ferrer, Noel T Brewer, Linda D Cameron, Bonnie Halpern-Felsher, Jennifer L Hay, Elyse R Park, Ellen Peters, David R Strong, Erika A Waters, Neil D Weinstein, Paul D Windschitl & William M P Klein. (2020) Measuring Cigarette Smoking Risk Perceptions. Nicotine & Tobacco Research 22:11, pages 1937-1945.
Crossref
Matthew T. Tull, Anna C. Barbano, Kayla M. Scamaldo, Julia R. Richmond, Keith A. Edmonds, Jason P. Rose & Kim L. Gratz. (2020) The prospective influence of COVID-19 affective risk assessments and intolerance of uncertainty on later dimensions of health anxiety. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 75, pages 102290.
Crossref
Juliette Richetin, Daniela Osterini & Mark Conner. (2019) Predicting engaging in cosmetic surgery: A test of the role of doing and not doing cognitions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 50:1, pages 53-62.
Crossref
Jane E. Miller, Paul D. Windschitl, Teresa A. Treat & Aaron M. Scherer. (2020) Comparisons as Predictors of People’s Beliefs About the Importance of Changing Their Health Behaviors. European Journal of Health Psychology 27:1, pages 14-29.
Crossref
Jason P. Rose & Erin Vogel. 2020. Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences. Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences 4754 4758 .
Laura D. Seligman, Erin F. Swedish, Jason P. Rose & Jessica M. Baker. (2018) An Initial Investigation of the Use of Comparative Referents to Assess Social Anxiety. European Journal of Psychological Assessment 34:6, pages 367-375.
Crossref
Adam J.L. Harris. (2017) Understanding the coherence of the severity effect and optimism phenomena: Lessons from attention. Consciousness and Cognition 50, pages 30-44.
Crossref
Vera Hoorens, Carolien Van Damme, Marie Helweg-Larsen & Constantine Sedikides. (2017) The hubris hypothesis: The downside of comparative optimism displays. Consciousness and Cognition 50, pages 45-55.
Crossref
Alexander Persoskie, Anh B. Nguyen, Annette R. Kaufman & Cindy Tworek. (2017) Criterion validity of measures of perceived relative harm of e-cigarettes and smokeless tobacco compared to cigarettes. Addictive Behaviors 67, pages 100-105.
Crossref
Jason P. Rose, Olivia Aspiras, Erin Vogel, Heather Haught & Lindsay Roberts. (2017) Comparative Optimism and Event Skewness. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 30:2, pages 236-255.
Crossref
Jason P. Rose & Erin Vogel. 2017. Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences. Encyclopedia of Personality and Individual Differences 1 4 .
Anine H. Riege & Karl Halvor Teigen. (2017) Everybody Will Win, and All Must Be Hired: Comparing Additivity Neglect with the Nonselective Superiority Bias. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 30:1, pages 95-106.
Crossref
Anne W Taylor, Kay Price & Simon Fullerton. (2013) A survey to assist in targeting the adults who undertake risky behaviours, know their health behaviours are not optimal and who acknowledge being worried about their health. BMC Public Health 13:1.
Crossref
Jason P Rose & Barbara Nagel. (2012) Relation between comparative risk, absolute risk, and worry: The role of handedness strength. Journal of Health Psychology 18:7, pages 866-874.
Crossref
Jerry Suls, Jason P. Rose, Paul D. Windschitl & Andrew R. Smith. (2013) Optimism Following a Tornado Disaster. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 39:5, pages 691-702.
Crossref
Jason P Rose. (2012) Debiasing comparative optimism and increasing worry for health outcomes. Journal of Health Psychology 17:8, pages 1121-1131.
Crossref
Leah D. Sheppard, Richard D. Goffin, Rhys J. Lewis & James Olson. (2011) The Effect of Target Attractiveness and Rating Method on the Accuracy of Trait Ratings. Journal of Personnel Psychology 10:1, pages 24-33.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.