Advanced search
Publication Cover
Society & Natural Resources
An International Journal
Volume 27, 2014 - Issue 9
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,579
Views
64
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Insights and Applications

Winners and Losers in Marine Conservation: Fishers' Displacement and Livelihood Benefits from Marine Reserves

Joshua E. Cinner Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland, AustraliaCorrespondence[email protected]
,
Tim Daw School of International Development, University of East Anglia, Norwich, United Kingdom; Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden
,
Cindy Huchery Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland, Australia
,
Pascal Thoya Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute, Mombasa, Kenya
,
Andrew Wamukota School of Natural Sciences, Linnaeus University, Kalmar, Sweden
,
Maria Cedras Seychelles Fishing Authority, Victoria, Seychelles
&
Caroline Abunge Wildlife Conservation Society, Coral Reef Conservation Program, Mombasa, Kenya
 show all
Pages 994-1005 | Received 18 Nov 2012, Accepted 03 Aug 2013, Published online: 04 Aug 2014

Citations (64)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (7)

Anna Louise Harker, T.A. Stojanovic, A.M Majalia, C. Jackson, S. Baya & K. Dadley Tsiganyiu. (2022) Relationships between Livelihoods, Well-Being, and Marine Protected Areas: Evidence from a Community Survey, Watamu Marine National Park and Reserve, Kenya. Coastal Management 50:6, pages 490-513.
Read now
Melody Lynch & Sarah Turner. (2022) Rocking the boat: intersectional resistance to marine conservation policies in Wakatobi National Park, Indonesia. Gender, Place & Culture 29:10, pages 1376-1398.
Read now
Ebuka Benedict Okeke, Somadina Mmaduakonam Obodoefuna, Mohammad Mazbah Uddin & Lingfeng Huang. (2022) Using Stakeholders’ Perception to Evaluate the Prospects of Establishing Marine Protected Areas in the Niger Delta Coastal Ecosystem. Coastal Management 50:2, pages 106-123.
Read now
Diana V. Burbano & Thomas C. Meredith. (2020) Conservation Strategies Through the Lens of Small-Scale Fishers in the Galapagos Islands, Ecuador: Perceptions Underlying Local Resistance to Marine Planning. Society & Natural Resources 33:10, pages 1194-1212.
Read now
Vinay R. Kamat & Mai-Lei Woo Kinshella. (2018) Food insecurity and coping strategies in a marine protected area in southeastern Tanzania. Ecology of Food and Nutrition 57:3, pages 187-205.
Read now
Catriona Bride Meyer-McLean & Melissa Nursey-Bray. (2017) Getting off the conflict treadmill: community engagement and marine park policy in South Australia, Australia. Australian Journal of Maritime & Ocean Affairs 9:4, pages 240-264.
Read now
Merrill Baker-Médard. (2017) Gendering Marine Conservation: The Politics of Marine Protected Areas and Fisheries Access. Society & Natural Resources 30:6, pages 723-737.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (57)

Eliana Ferretti, Nicolas I. Lewis, Simon F. Thrush, Serena Lucrezi & Jenny R. Hillman. (2023) Making a place special—The development of Restorative Marine Ecotourism at a dive destination village. Frontiers in Sustainable Tourism 2.
Crossref
Stefan Partelow, Achim Schlüter, Natalie C. Ban, Simon Batterbury, Maarten Bavinck, Nathan J. Bennett, Raimund Bleischwitz, Jessica Blythe, Tanja Bogusz, Annette Breckwoldt, Joshua E. Cinner, Marion Glaser, Hugh Govan, Rebecca Gruby, Vanessa Hatje, Anna-Katharina Hornidge, Grete K. Hovelsrud, John N. Kittinger, Lotta Clara Kluger, Sophia Kochalski, Alexander Mawyer, Emma McKinley, Julia Olsen, Jeremy Pittman, Maraja Riechers, Marie-Catherine Riekhof, Kathleen Schwerdtner Manez, Rebecca J. Shellock, Rapti Siriwardane-de Zoysa, Nathalie A. Steins, Kristof Van Assche & Sebastian Villasante. (2023) Five social science intervention areas for ocean sustainability initiatives. npj Ocean Sustainability 2:1.
Crossref
Deqiang Ma, Jonathan Rhodes, Carissa J. Klein & Martine Maron. (2023) Redistribution of fishery benefits among commercial and recreational fishers caused by offsetting. Marine Policy 158, pages 105881.
Crossref
Cristina Ruano-Chamorro, Georgina G. Gurney, Michele L. Barnes, Stefan Gelcich & Joshua E. Cinner. (2023) Disparities in the impacts of co-management on fishers’ livelihoods. Sustainability Science 18:6, pages 2723-2733.
Crossref
M. Fortnam, T. Chaigneau, L. Evans & L. Bastian. (2023) Practitioner approaches to trade‐off decision‐making in marine conservation development. People and Nature.
Crossref
Anthony Charles. 2023. Sustainable Fishery Systems. Sustainable Fishery Systems 547 629 .
Graeme S. Cumming, Maja Adamska, Michele L. Barnes, Jon Barnett, David R. Bellwood, Joshua E. Cinner, Philippa J. Cohen, Jennifer M. Donelson, Katharina Fabricius, R. Quentin Grafton, Alana Grech, Georgina G. Gurney, Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Andrew S. Hoey, Mia O. Hoogenboom, Jacqueline Lau, Catherine E. Lovelock, Ryan Lowe, David J. Miller, Tiffany H. Morrison, Peter J. Mumby, Martin Nakata, John M. Pandolfi, Garry D. Peterson, Morgan S. Pratchett, Timothy Ravasi, Cynthia Riginos, Jodie L. Rummer, Britta Schaffelke, Thomas Wernberg & Shaun K. Wilson. (2023) Research priorities for the sustainability of coral-rich western Pacific seascapes. Regional Environmental Change 23:2.
Crossref
Cheryl Joy Fernandez-Abila, Elaine Grace Fernandez & Rodelio Subade. (2023) Public Perception of Ecosystem Services in the Marine Protected Areas of Northern Iloilo (Philippines). Journal of Coastal Research 39:5.
Crossref
A Belackova, NT Willenbrink, JMS Gonçalves & B Horta e Costa. (2023) Potential protection effects in a small marine reserve: a demersal community analysis from stereo baited remote underwater video. Marine Ecology Progress Series 708, pages 79-100.
Crossref
Alice Rogers. (2022) Managing reefs for productivity. Nature Sustainability 6:2, pages 122-123.
Crossref
Raphael Seguin, David Mouillot, Joshua E. Cinner, Rick D. Stuart Smith, Eva Maire, Nicholas A. J. Graham, Matthew McLean, Laurent Vigliola & Nicolas Loiseau. (2022) Towards process-oriented management of tropical reefs in the anthropocene. Nature Sustainability 6:2, pages 148-157.
Crossref
Junko Toyoshima, Iwao Fujii, Miko Maekawa, Tomohiko Tsunoda, Noriko Kamada, Hiroka Hidaka, Yasuhiro Tojo & Kazuko Ikeda. (2022) Assessing effectiveness of satoumi activities in Japanese coastal areas from ecological and socioeconomic perspectives. Ocean & Coastal Management 230, pages 106354.
Crossref
Rainey Windayati, Bachtiar W. Mutaqin, Muh Aris Marfai, Evita Hanie Pangaribowo, Muhammad Helmi & Moh. Gamal Rindarjono. (2022) Assessment of coral-reef ecosystem services in West Buleleng Conservation Zone, Bali, Indonesia. Journal of Coastal Conservation 26:5.
Crossref
Veronica Relano, Tiffany Mak, Shelumiel Ortiz & Daniel Pauly. (2022) Stakeholder Perceptions Can Distinguish ‘Paper Parks’ from Marine Protected Areas. Sustainability 14:15, pages 9655.
Crossref
Haley K. Fox, Thomas C. Swearingen, Allen C. Molina & Camilla M. Kennedy. (2022) Oregon recreational fishers’ knowledge, support, and perceived impacts of marine reserves. Ocean & Coastal Management 225, pages 106241.
Crossref
Lara Funk, A. Meriwether W. Wilson, Charlotte Gough, Kitty Brayne & Noelinaud Robert Djerryh. (2022) Perceptions of access and benefits from community-based aquaculture through Photovoice: A case study within a locally managed marine area in Madagascar. Ocean & Coastal Management 222, pages 106046.
Crossref
Estradivari, Dominic A. Andradi-Brown, Amkieltiela, Christian N. Handayani, Fikri F. Sjahruddin, Muh. Firdaus Agung, Stuart J. Campbell, Kelly Claborn, Matheus De Nardo, Helen E. Fox, Louise Glew, Amehr Hakim, Muhammad Erdi Lazuardi, Hellen Nanlohy, Wira Sanjaya, Edy Setyawan, Natelda R. Timisela, Laura Veverka, Nara Wisesa Wiwardhana, Marthen Welly, Imam Musthofa Zainudin & Gabby N. Ahmadia. (2022) Marine conservation in the Sunda Banda Seascape, Indonesia. Marine Policy 138, pages 104994.
Crossref
Delphi Ward, Jessica Melbourne-Thomas, Gretta T. Pecl, Karen Evans, Madeline Green, Phillipa C. McCormack, Camilla Novaglio, Rowan Trebilco, Narissa Bax, Madeleine J. Brasier, Emma L. Cavan, Graham Edgar, Heather L. Hunt, Jan Jansen, Russ Jones, Mary-Anne Lea, Reuben Makomere, Chris Mull, Jayson M. Semmens, Janette Shaw, Dugald Tinch, Tatiana J. van Steveninck & Cayne Layton. (2022) Safeguarding marine life: conservation of biodiversity and ecosystems. Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries 32:1, pages 65-100.
Crossref
Erin C. Betley, Amanda Sigouin, Pua’ala Pascua, Samantha H. Cheng, Kenneth Iain MacDonald, Felicity Arengo, Yildiz Aumeeruddy‐Thomas, Sophie Caillon, Marney E. Isaac, Stacy D. Jupiter, Alexander Mawyer, Manuel Mejia, Alexandria C. Moore, Delphine Renard, Lea Sébastien, Nadav Gazit & Eleanor J. Sterling. (2021) Assessing human well‐being constructs with environmental and equity aspects: A review of the landscape. People and Nature.
Crossref
Kirsten Grorud-Colvert, Jenna Sullivan-Stack, Callum Roberts, Vanessa Constant, Barbara Horta e Costa, Elizabeth P. Pike, Naomi Kingston, Dan Laffoley, Enric Sala, Joachim Claudet, Alan M. Friedlander, David A. Gill, Sarah E. Lester, Jon C. Day, Emanuel J. Gonçalves, Gabby N. Ahmadia, Matt Rand, Angelo Villagomez, Natalie C. Ban, Georgina G. Gurney, Ana K. Spalding, Nathan J. Bennett, Johnny Briggs, Lance E. Morgan, Russell Moffitt, Marine DeguignetEllen K. Pikitch, Emily S. Darling, Sabine JessenSarah O. Hameed, Giuseppe Di CarloPaolo Guidetti, Jean M. Harris, Jorge TorreZafer Kizilkaya, Tundi Agardy, Philippe Cury, Nirmal J. Shah, Karen Sack, Ling Cao, Miriam Fernandez & Jane Lubchenco. (2021) The MPA Guide: A framework to achieve global goals for the ocean. Science 373:6560.
Crossref
Marije Schaafsma, Felix Eigenbrod, Alexandros Gasparatos, Nicole Gross-Camp, Craig Hutton, Fiona Nunan, Kate Schreckenberg & Kerry Turner. (2021) Trade-off decisions in ecosystem management for poverty alleviation. Ecological Economics 187, pages 107103.
Crossref
María Virginia Gabela-Flores & Amy Diedrich. (2021) Exploring leadership dynamics in community-based marine protected areas. Marine Policy 129, pages 104569.
Crossref
Radisti A. Praptiwi, Carya Maharja, Matt Fortnam, Tomas Chaigneau, Louisa Evans, Leuserina Garniati & Jito Sugardjito. (2021) Tourism-Based Alternative Livelihoods for Small Island Communities Transitioning towards a Blue Economy. Sustainability 13:12, pages 6655.
Crossref
Michael Kriegl, Xochitl E. Elías Ilosvay, Christian von Dorrien & Daniel Oesterwind. (2021) Marine Protected Areas: At the Crossroads of Nature Conservation and Fisheries Management. Frontiers in Marine Science 8.
Crossref
Claire Collins, Ana Nuno, Aloka Benaragama, Annette Broderick, Isuru Wijesundara, Dilhara Wijetunge & Tom B. Letessier. (2021) Ocean‐scale footprint of a highly mobile fishing fleet: Social‐ecological drivers of fleet behaviour and evidence of illegal fishing. People and Nature 3:3, pages 740-755.
Crossref
Mohammad Mahmudul Islam. (2021) Social Dimensions in Designing and Managing Marine Protected Areas in Bangladesh. Human Ecology 49:2, pages 171-185.
Crossref
Veronica van der Schyff, Marinus du Preez, Karin Blom, Nee Sun Choong Kwet Yive, Jana Klánová, Petra Přibylová, Ondřej Audy, Jakub Martiník & Hindrik Bouwman. (2021) Chlorinated and brominated persistent compounds in hard coral, soft coral, and parrotfish from remote Mascarene islands. Chemosphere 267, pages 129316.
Crossref
María José Brain & Laura Nahuelhual. 2021. Ecosystem Services in Patagonia. Ecosystem Services in Patagonia 271 286 .
Claire Collins, Tom Bech Letessier, Annette Broderick, Isuru Wijesundara & Ana Nuno. (2020) Using perceptions to examine human responses to blanket bans: The case of the thresher shark landing-ban in Sri Lanka. Marine Policy 121, pages 104198.
Crossref
M.J Brain, L. Nahuelhual, S. Gelcich & F. Bozzeda. (2020) Marine conservation may not deliver ecosystem services and benefits to all: Insights from Chilean Patagonia. Ecosystem Services 45, pages 101170.
Crossref
Nathan J. Bennett, Antonio Calò, Antonio Di Franco, Federico Niccolini, Daniela Marzo, Ilenia Domina, Charalampos Dimitriadis, Francisco Sobrado, Marie-Catherine Santoni, Eric Charbonnel, Maria Trujillo, Jose Garcia-Charton, Leila Seddiki, Valentina Cappanera, Josipa Grbin, Luka Kastelic, Marco Milazzo & Paolo Guidetti. (2020) Social equity and marine protected areas: Perceptions of small-scale fishermen in the Mediterranean Sea. Biological Conservation 244, pages 108531.
Crossref
Diana V. Burbano, Thomas C. Meredith & Monica E. Mulrennan. (2020) Exclusionary decision-making processes in marine governance: The rezoning plan for the protected areas of the ‘iconic’ Galapagos Islands, Ecuador. Ocean & Coastal Management 185, pages 105066.
Crossref
Dale P. Rodmell, Alex J. Caveen & Magnus L. Johnson. 2020. Marine Protected Areas. Marine Protected Areas 99 112 .
Hannah L. Harrison, Sophia Kochalski, Robert Arlinghaus & Øystein Aas. (2019) ‘Do you care about the river?' A critical discourse analysis and lessons for management of social conflict over Atlantic salmon ( Salmo salar ) conservation in the case of voluntary stocking in Wales . People and Nature 1:4, pages 507-523.
Crossref
David A. Gill, Samantha H. Cheng, Louise GlewErnest AignerNathan J. Bennett & Michael B. Mascia. (2019) Social Synergies, Tradeoffs, and Equity in Marine Conservation Impacts. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 44:1, pages 347-372.
Crossref
Cheryl Chan, Derek Armitage, Steven M. Alexander & Donovan Campbell. (2019) Examining linkages between ecosystem services and social wellbeing to improve governance for coastal conservation in Jamaica. Ecosystem Services 39, pages 100997.
Crossref
Alexander Tilley, Shaun P. Wilkinson, Jeppe Kolding, Juliana López-Angarita, Mario Pereira & David J. Mills. (2019) Nearshore Fish Aggregating Devices Show Positive Outcomes for Sustainable Fisheries Development in Timor-Leste. Frontiers in Marine Science 6.
Crossref
Nathan J. Bennett, Jessica Blythe, Andrés M. Cisneros-Montemayor, Gerald G. Singh & U. Rashid Sumaila. (2019) Just Transformations to Sustainability. Sustainability 11:14, pages 3881.
Crossref
Nathan J. Bennett, Antonio Di Franco, Antonio Calò, Elizabeth Nethery, Federico Niccolini, Marco Milazzo & Paolo Guidetti. (2019) Local support for conservation is associated with perceptions of good governance, social impacts, and ecological effectiveness. Conservation Letters 12:4.
Crossref
Kirsten Grorud-Colvert, Vanessa Constant, Jenna Sullivan-Stack, Katherine Dziedzic, Sara L. Hamilton, Zachary Randell, Heather Fulton-Bennett, Zechariah D. Meunier, Silke Bachhuber, Alissa J. Rickborn, Barbara Spiecker & Jane Lubchenco. (2019) High-profile international commitments for ocean protection: Empty promises or meaningful progress?. Marine Policy 105, pages 52-66.
Crossref
Charlotte Wiederkehr, Augustin Berghöfer & Kei Otsuki. (2019) Ostrom’s Governance Principles and Sustainable Financing of Fish Reserves. Human Ecology 47:1, pages 13-25.
Crossref
Justin Raycraft. (2019) Conserving Poverty: Destructive Fishing Gear Use in a Tanzanian Marine Protected Area. Conservation and Society 17:3, pages 297.
Crossref
Brock J. Bergseth, Georgina G. Gurney, Michele L. Barnes, Adrian Arias & Joshua E. Cinner. (2018) Addressing poaching in marine protected areas through voluntary surveillance and enforcement. Nature Sustainability 1:8, pages 421-426.
Crossref
Asha McNeill, Julian Clifton & Euan S. Harvey. (2018) Attitudes to a marine protected area are associated with perceived social impacts. Marine Policy 94, pages 106-118.
Crossref
Bethany J. Harvey, Kirsty L. Nash, Julia L. Blanchard & David P. Edwards. (2018) Ecosystem-based management of coral reefs under climate change. Ecology and Evolution 8:12, pages 6354-6368.
Crossref
Linwood H Pendleton, Gabby N Ahmadia, Howard I Browman, Ruth H Thurstan, David M Kaplan & Valerio Bartolino. (2018) Debating the effectiveness of marine protected areas. ICES Journal of Marine Science 75:3, pages 1156-1159.
Crossref
Lucia Ordoñez-Gauger, Laurie Richmond, Steven Hackett & Cheryl Chen. (2018) It's a trust thing: Assessing fishermen's perceptions of the California North Coast marine protected area network. Ocean & Coastal Management 158, pages 144-153.
Crossref
Juliana López-Angarita, Alexander Tilley, Juan M. Díaz, Julie P. Hawkins, E. Fernando Cagua & Callum M. Roberts. (2018) Winners and Losers in Area-Based Management of a Small-Scale Fishery in the Colombian Pacific. Frontiers in Marine Science 5.
Crossref
Vinay R. Kamat. (2018) Dispossession and disenchantment: The micropolitics of marine conservation in southeastern Tanzania. Marine Policy 88, pages 261-268.
Crossref
Alicia Said, Douglas MacMillan, Michael Schembri & Joseph Tzanopoulos. (2017) Fishing in a congested sea: What do marine protected areas imply for the future of the Maltese artisanal fleet?. Applied Geography 87, pages 245-255.
Crossref
RY Fidler, RG Turingan, AT White & MNR Alava. (2017) Reef-wide beneficial shifts in fish population structure following establishment of marine protected areas in Philippine coral reefs. Marine Ecology Progress Series 570, pages 187-202.
Crossref
Shauna L. Mahajan & Tim Daw. (2016) Perceptions of ecosystem services and benefits to human well-being from community-based marine protected areas in Kenya. Marine Policy 74, pages 108-119.
Crossref
Katharina Beyerl, Oliver Putz & Annette Breckwoldt. (2016) The Role of Perceptions for Community-Based Marine Resource Management. Frontiers in Marine Science 3.
Crossref
Shanna Grafeld, Kirsten Oleson, Michele Barnes, Marcus Peng, Catherine Chan & Mariska Weijerman. (2016) Divers' willingness to pay for improved coral reef conditions in Guam: An untapped source of funding for management and conservation?. Ecological Economics 128, pages 202-213.
Crossref
Nathan James Bennett. (2016) Using perceptions as evidence to improve conservation and environmental management. Conservation Biology 30:3, pages 582-592.
Crossref
Carla Guenther, David López-Carr & Hunter S. Lenihan. (2015) Differences in lobster fishing effort before and after MPA establishment. Applied Geography 59, pages 78-87.
Crossref
Joshua E. Cinner & Tim R. McClanahan. (2015) A sea change on the African coast? Preliminary social and ecological outcomes of a governance transformation in Kenyan fisheries. Global Environmental Change 30, pages 133-139.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.