Advanced search
Publication Cover
Exceptionality
A Special Education Journal
Volume 19, 2011 - Issue 2
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,344
Views
89
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

A Quantitative Synthesis of Methodology in the Meta-Analysis of Single-Subject Research for Students with Disabilities: 1985–2009

Daniel M. Maggin University of Connecticut
,
Breda V. O'Keeffe University of Connecticut
&
Austin H. Johnson University of Connecticut
Pages 109-135 | Received 22 Nov 2010, Accepted 14 Feb 2011, Published online: 04 May 2011

Citations (89)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (11)

Milica Miočević, Fayette Klaassen, Mariola Moeyaert & Gemma G. M. Geuke. (2023) Optimal Practices for Mediation Analysis in AB Single Case Experimental Designs. The Journal of Experimental Education 0:0, pages 1-18.
Read now
Mariola Moeyaert, Panpan Yang & Yukang Xue. (2023) Individual Participant Data Meta-Analysis Including Moderators: Empirical Validation. The Journal of Experimental Education 0:0, pages 1-18.
Read now
Fahad Alresheed & Wendy Machalicek. (2023) A systematic comparison of non-overlap metrics and visual analysis in single-case experimental design. Evidence-Based Communication Assessment and Intervention 0:0, pages 1-19.
Read now
Eunkyeng Baek, Wen Luo & Maria Henri. (2022) Issues and solutions in meta-analysis of single-case design with multiple dependent variables using multilevel modeling. The Journal of Experimental Education 90:4, pages 934-961.
Read now
Sally Lindsay & Azar Varahra. (2022) A systematic review of self-determination interventions for children and youth with disabilities. Disability and Rehabilitation 44:19, pages 5341-5362.
Read now
Shaista Anayat & Gowhar Rasool. (2022) Artificial intelligence marketing (AIM): connecting-the-dots using bibliometrics. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice 0:0, pages 1-22.
Read now
Laleh Jamshidi, Mieke Heyvaert, Lies Declercq, Belén Fernández-Castilla, John M. Ferron, Mariola Moeyaert, S. Natasha Beretvas, Patrick Onghena & Wim Van den Noortgate. (2022) A systematic review of single-case experimental design meta-analyses: characteristics of study designs, data, and analyses. Evidence-Based Communication Assessment and Intervention 0:0, pages 1-25.
Read now
Eunkyeng Baek & John M. Ferron. (2021) Bayesian Analysis for Multiple-baseline Studies Where the Variance Differs across Cases in OpenBUGS. Developmental Neurorehabilitation 24:2, pages 130-143.
Read now
Wilhelmina van Dijk & Nicholas A. Gage. (2019) The effectiveness of visual activity schedules for individuals with intellectual disabilities: A meta-analysis. Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability 44:4, pages 384-395.
Read now
Ming Ming Chiu & Carly A. Roberts. (2018) Improved analyses of single cases: Dynamic multilevel analysis. Developmental Neurorehabilitation 21:4, pages 253-265.
Read now
Brett Furlonger, Steven Kiley, Dennis Moore, Marghrita Busacca & Philip Chittleborough. (2018) Using a single-case experimental design to evaluate a cognitive-behavioural self-management counselling intervention. Asia Pacific Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy 9:1, pages 46-60.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (78)

Henry H. Zink, Ethan R. Van Norman & David A. Klingbeil. (2023) Multiple baseline and multiple probe design studies targeting academic skills: Trends over time in effect sizes. Psychology in the Schools.
Crossref
Eunkyeng Baek, Wen Luo & Kwok Hap Lam. (2023) Meta-Analysis of Single-Case Experimental Design using Multilevel Modeling. Behavior Modification 47:6, pages 1546-1573.
Crossref
Mariola Moeyaert, Panpan Yang, Xinyun Xu & Esther Kim. (2021) Characteristics of Moderators in Meta-Analyses of Single-Case Experimental Design Studies. Behavior Modification 47:6, pages 1510-1545.
Crossref
James E. Pustejovsky, Daniel M. Swan & Kyle W. English. (2019) An Examination of Measurement Procedures and Characteristics of Baseline Outcome Data in Single-Case Research. Behavior Modification 47:6, pages 1423-1454.
Crossref
Tuhina Agarwal & Devon Ramey. (2023) Identifying and Validating Indices of Happiness and Unhappiness in Autistic Children and Examining Them as Quality of Life Indicators During Presession Pairing. Advances in Neurodevelopmental Disorders.
Crossref
John R. WeiszKatherine E. Venturo-ConerlyOlivia M. FitzpatrickJennifer A. Frederick & Mei Yi Ng. (2023) What Four Decades of Meta-Analysis Have Taught Us About Youth Psychotherapy and the Science of Research Synthesis. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology 19:1, pages 79-105.
Crossref
Thomas R. Kratochwill, Robert H. Horner, Joel R. Levin, Wendy Machalicek, John Ferron & Austin Johnson. (2023) Single-case intervention research design standards: Additional proposed upgrades and future directions. Journal of School Psychology 97, pages 192-216.
Crossref
Joshua M. Pulos, Kristi L. Morin, Corey Peltier, Tracy E. Sinclair & Kendra L. Williams-Diehm. (2023) Effects of the SDLMI on Academic and Nonacademic Behaviors: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Behavioral Education.
Crossref
Valentina A. Contesse, Nicholas A. Gage & Holly B. Lane. (2021) Practical Use of Single-Case Research Design to Target Improved Behavioral Outcomes for Students With SLD. Learning Disability Quarterly 46:1, pages 32-45.
Crossref
Rumen Manolov & Patrick Onghena. (2022) Defining and assessing immediacy in single‐case experimental designs. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior 118:3, pages 462-492.
Crossref
Eunkyeng Baek & Wen Luo. (2022) Modeling multiple dependent variables in meta-analysis of single-case experimental design using multilevel modeling. Behavior Research Methods 55:7, pages 3760-3771.
Crossref
Bryan G. Cook, Austin H. Johnson, Daniel M. Maggin, William J. Therrien, Erin E. Barton, John Wills Lloyd, Brian Reichow, Elizabeth Talbott & Jason C. Travers. (2021) Open Science and Single-Case Design Research. Remedial and Special Education 43:5, pages 359-369.
Crossref
Megan Fedewa, Laci Watkins, Lucy Barnard-Brak & Yusuf Akemoglu. (2022) A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Single Case Experimental Design Play Interventions for Children with Autism and Their Peers. Review Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders.
Crossref
Kelli A. Sanderson, Samantha E. Goldman & Amanda Rojas. (2021) A Review and Analysis of Single-Case Research Examining Adolescent Participation in IEP Meetings. The Journal of Special Education 56:2, pages 97-109.
Crossref
Orhan Aydin & René Tanious. (2022) Performance criteria‐based effect size ( PCES ) measurement of single‐case experimental designs: A real‐world data study . Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 55:3, pages 891-918.
Crossref
Matt Tincani & Jason Travers. 2022. Avoiding Questionable Research Practices in Applied Psychology. Avoiding Questionable Research Practices in Applied Psychology 269 285 .
Maxfield Trevor, Eun-Young Park & Kwang-Sun Cho Blair. (2021) A Meta-Analysis of Safety Skills Interventions for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities. Education and Treatment of Children 44:4, pages 309-331.
Crossref
Runyue Han, Hugo K.S. Lam, Yuanzhu Zhan, Yichuan Wang, Yogesh K. Dwivedi & Kim Hua Tan. (2021) Artificial intelligence in business-to-business marketing: a bibliometric analysis of current research status, development and future directions. Industrial Management & Data Systems 121:12, pages 2467-2497.
Crossref
Art Dowdy, Corey Peltier, Matt Tincani, W. Joel Schneider, Donald A. Hantula & Jason C. Travers. (2021) Meta‐analyses and effect sizes in applied behavior analysis: A review and discussion. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 54:4, pages 1317-1340.
Crossref
Argnue Chitiyo, Seth A. King, Margaret D. Krizon, Cephas N. Ablakwa & Andrew M. Markelz. (2020) A Methodological Review of Research Syntheses Involving Reading Interventions for Students With Emotional and Behavioral Disorders. Behavioral Disorders 46:4, pages 214-225.
Crossref
Alan E. Kazdin. (2020) Single‐case experimental designs: Characteristics, changes, and challenges. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior 115:1, pages 56-85.
Crossref
Prathiba Natesan Batley, Ateka A. Contractor & Stephanie V. Caldas. (2020) Bayesian Time‐Series Models in Single Case Experimental Designs: A Tutorial for Trauma Researchers. Journal of Traumatic Stress 33:6, pages 1144-1153.
Crossref
Dongil Kim, Yeji An, HyeYun Gladys Shin, Jaeho Lee & Soyoung Park. (2020) A meta-analysis of single-subject reading intervention studies for struggling readers: using Improvement Rate Difference (IRD). Heliyon 6:11, pages e05024.
Crossref
John O. Cooper, Timothy E. Heron & William L. Heward. 2020. Análisis aplicado de conducta, tercera edición. Análisis aplicado de conducta, tercera edición.
Art Dowdy, Matt Tincani & W. Joel Schneider. (2020) Evaluation of publication bias in response interruption and redirection: A meta‐analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 53:4, pages 2151-2171.
Crossref
Seth A. King, Douglas Kostewicz, Olivia Enders, Taneal Burch, Argnue Chitiyo, Johanna Taylor, Sarah DeMaria & Milsha Reid. (2020) Search and Selection Procedures of Literature Reviews in Behavior Analysis. Perspectives on Behavior Science.
Crossref
Prathiba Natesan Batley, Tom Minka & Larry Vernon Hedges. (2020) Investigating immediacy in multiple-phase-change single-case experimental designs using a Bayesian unknown change-points model. Behavior Research Methods 52:4, pages 1714-1728.
Crossref
Mariola Moeyaert, Rumen Manolov & Emily Rodabaugh. (2018) Meta-Analysis of Single-Case Research via Multilevel Models: Fundamental Concepts and Methodological Considerations. Behavior Modification 44:2, pages 265-295.
Crossref
Antony J Porcino, Larissa Shamseer, An-Wen Chan, Richard L Kravitz, Aaron Orkin, Salima Punja, Philippe Ravaud, Christopher H Schmid & Sunita Vohra. (2020) SPIRIT extension and elaboration for n-of-1 trials: SPENT 2019 checklist. BMJ, pages m122.
Crossref
Nicholas A. Gage, Todd Haydon, Ashley S. MacSuga-Gage, Emily Flowers & Lyndsie Erdy. (2019) An Evidence-Based Review and Meta-Analysis of Active Supervision. Behavioral Disorders 45:2, pages 117-128.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Bryan G. Cook & Lysandra Cook. (2019) Making Sense of Single‐Case Design Effect Sizes. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice 34:3, pages 124-132.
Crossref
Bart Michiels & Patrick Onghena. (2018) Nonparametric meta-analysis for single-case research: Confidence intervals for combined effect sizes. Behavior Research Methods 51:3, pages 1145-1160.
Crossref
Robyn L. Tate, Michael Perdices, Ulrike Rosenkoetter, Skye McDonald, Leanne Togher, William Shadish, Robert Horner, Thomas Kratochwill, David H. Barlow, Alan Kazdin, Margaret Sampson, Larissa Shamseer & Sunita Vohra. (2019) Reprint of “The Single-Case Reporting Guideline In BEhavioural Interventions (SCRIBE) 2016: Explanation and Elaboration”. Pratiques Psychologiques 25:2, pages 119-151.
Crossref
Elif Tekin-Iftar, Seray Olcay-Gul & Belva C. Collins. (2018) Descriptive Analysis and Meta Analysis of Studies Investigating the Effectiveness of Simultaneous Prompting Procedure. Exceptional Children 85:3, pages 309-328.
Crossref
Nihal ŞEN & Sedat ŞEN. (2019) Tek Denekli Deneysel Çalışmalarda Etki Büyüklüğü Hesaplaması: Regresyona Dayalı Olmayan Yöntemlerin İncelenmesiCalculation of Effect Size in Single-Subject Experimental Studies: Examination of Non-Regression-Based Methods. Eğitimde ve Psikolojide Ölçme ve Değerlendirme Dergisi 10:1, pages 30-48.
Crossref
Melissa A. Collier-Meek, Lisa M.H. Sanetti, Joel R. Levin, Thomas R. Kratochwill & Ashley M. Boyle. (2019) Evaluating implementation supports delivered within problem-solving consultation. Journal of School Psychology 72, pages 91-111.
Crossref
Min Kyung Mize, Yujeong Park & Tara Moore. (2018) Computer-assisted vocabulary instruction for students with disabilities: Evidence from an effect size analysis of single-subject experimental design studies. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 34:6, pages 641-651.
Crossref
Despoina Damianidou, Judith Foggett, Michael Arthur-Kelly, Gordon Lyons & Michael L. Wehmeyer. (2018) Effectiveness of Technology Types in Employment-Related Outcomes for People with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: an Extension Meta-analysis. Advances in Neurodevelopmental Disorders 2:3, pages 262-272.
Crossref
Kathleen N. Zimmerman, Jennifer R. Ledford, Katherine E. Severini, James E. Pustejovsky, Erin E. Barton & Blair P. Lloyd. (2018) Single-case synthesis tools I: Comparing tools to evaluate SCD quality and rigor. Research in Developmental Disabilities 79, pages 19-32.
Crossref
Kathleen N. Zimmerman, James E. Pustejovsky, Jennifer R. Ledford, Erin E. Barton, Katherine E. Severini & Blair P. Lloyd. (2018) Single-case synthesis tools II: Comparing quantitative outcome measures. Research in Developmental Disabilities 79, pages 65-76.
Crossref
Laleh Jamshidi, Mieke Heyvaert, Lies Declercq, Belén Fernández-Castilla, John M. Ferron, Mariola Moeyaert, S. Natasha Beretvas, Patrick Onghena & Wim Van den Noortgate. (2018) Methodological quality of meta-analyses of single-case experimental studies. Research in Developmental Disabilities 79, pages 97-115.
Crossref
James E. Pustejovsky. (2018) Using response ratios for meta-analyzing single-case designs with behavioral outcomes. Journal of School Psychology 68, pages 99-112.
Crossref
Bart Michiels, Mieke Heyvaert & Patrick Onghena. (2017) The conditional power of randomization tests for single-case effect sizes in designs with randomized treatment order: A Monte Carlo simulation study. Behavior Research Methods 50:2, pages 557-575.
Crossref
Christopher J. Lemons, Seth A. King, Kimberly A. Davidson, Cynthia S. Puranik, Stephanie Al Otaiba & Deborah J. Fidler. (2018) Personalized reading intervention for children with Down syndrome. Journal of School Psychology 66, pages 67-84.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Kathleen Lynne Lane & James E. Pustejovsky. (2017) Introduction to the Special Issue on Single-Case Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses. Remedial and Special Education 38:6, pages 323-330.
Crossref
Nicholas A. Gage, Bryan G. Cook & Brian Reichow. (2017) Publication Bias in Special Education Meta-Analyses. Exceptional Children 83:4, pages 428-445.
Crossref
Allison Levy, Iser G. DeLeon, Catherine K. Martinez, Nathalie Fernandez, Nicholas A. Gage, Sigurdur Óli Sigurdsson & Michelle A. Frank-Crawford. (2017) A quantitative review of overjustification effects in persons with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 50:2, pages 206-221.
Crossref
Katherine Ledbetter-Cho, Russell Lang, Laci Watkins, Mark O'Reilly & Claudia Zamora. (2017) Systematic review of collateral effects of focused interventions for children with autism spectrum disorder. Autism & Developmental Language Impairments 2, pages 239694151773753.
Crossref
Larissa Shamseer, Margaret Sampson, Cecilia Bukutu, Christopher H. Schmid, Jane Nikles, Robyn Tate, Bradley C. Johnston, Deborah Zucker, William R. Shadish, Richard Kravitz, Gordon Guyatt, Douglas G. Altman, David Moher, Sunita Vohra, Douglas G. Altman, Cecilia Bukutu, Jocalyn Clark, Elise Cogo, Nicole B. Gabler, Gordon Guyatt, Richard Kravitz, Janine Janosky, Bradley C. Johnston, Bob Li, Jeff Mahon, Robin Marles, David Moher, Jane Nikles, Margaret Sampson, Christopher H. Schmid, William R. Shadish, Larissa Shamseer, Robyn Tate, Sunita Vohra & Deborah Zucker. (2016) CONSORT extension for reporting N-of-1 trials (CENT) 2015: explanation and elaboration. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 76, pages 18-46.
Crossref
Kylee Hurl, Jade Wightman, Stephen N. Haynes & Javier Virues-Ortega. (2016) Does a pre-intervention functional assessment increase intervention effectiveness? A meta-analysis of within-subject interrupted time-series studies. Clinical Psychology Review 47, pages 71-84.
Crossref
Marc J. Lanovaz & John T. Rapp. (2015) Using Single-Case Experiments to Support Evidence-Based Decisions. Behavior Modification 40:3, pages 377-395.
Crossref
Mickey Losinski, Nicole Wiseman, Sherry A. White & Felicity Balluch. (2015) A Meta-Analysis of Video-Modeling Based Interventions for Reduction of Challenging Behaviors for Students With EBD. The Journal of Special Education 49:4, pages 243-252.
Crossref
Jeffrey C. Valentine, Emily E. Tanner‐Smith, James E. Pustejovsky & T. S. Lau. (2016) Between‐case standardized mean difference effect sizes for single‐case designs: a primer and tutorial using the scdhlm web application. Campbell Systematic Reviews 12:1, pages 1-31.
Crossref
Ghaleb H. Alnahdi. (2015) Single-subject designs in special education: advantages and limitations. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs 15:4, pages 257-265.
Crossref
Jennie L. Farmer, David H. Allsopp & John M. Ferron. (2014) Impact of The Personal Strengths Program on Self-Determination Levels of College Students With LD and/or ADHD. Learning Disability Quarterly 38:3, pages 145-159.
Crossref
Mieke Heyvaert, Lore Saenen, Bea Maes & Patrick Onghena. (2015) Comparing the percentage of non-overlapping data approach and the hierarchical linear modeling approach for synthesizing single-case studies in autism research. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 11, pages 112-125.
Crossref
Monica E. Carr. (2014) A Sensitivity Analysis of Three Nonparametric Treatment Effect Scores for Single-Case Research for Participants with Autism. Review Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2:1, pages 67-78.
Crossref
Lindsay M. Fallon, Melissa A. Collier-Meek, Daniel M. Maggin, Lisa M. H. Sanetti & Austin H. Johnson. (2015) Is Performance Feedback for Educators an Evidence-Based Practice? A Systematic Review and Evaluation Based on Single-Case Research. Exceptional Children 81:2, pages 227-246.
Crossref
Rumen Manolov, Georgina Guilera & Vicenta Sierra. (2014) Weighting strategies in the meta-analysis of single-case studies. Behavior Research Methods 46:4, pages 1152-1166.
Crossref
Mieke Heyvaert, Lore Saenen, Jonathan M. Campbell, Bea Maes & Patrick Onghena. (2014) Efficacy of behavioral interventions for reducing problem behavior in persons with autism: An updated quantitative synthesis of single-subject research. Research in Developmental Disabilities 35:10, pages 2463-2476.
Crossref
Yun, Joonmo & Kim Dong-il. (2014) A Meta-Analysis of Reading Fluency Interventions for Students with Reading Difficulties using IRD Index. Journal of Special Education 21:1, pages 196-217.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Amy M. Briesch, Sandra M. Chafouleas, Tyler D. Ferguson & Courtney Clark. (2013) A Comparison of Rubrics for Identifying Empirically Supported Practices with Single-Case Research. Journal of Behavioral Education 23:2, pages 287-311.
Crossref
Pei-Lin Weng, Yukiko Maeda & Emily C. Bouck. (2014) Effectiveness of Cognitive Skills-Based Computer-Assisted Instruction for Students With Disabilities. Remedial and Special Education 35:3, pages 167-180.
Crossref
Timothy A. Slocum, Ronnie Detrich, Susan M. Wilczynski, Trina D. Spencer, Teri Lewis & Katie Wolfe. (2014) The Evidence-Based Practice of Applied Behavior Analysis. The Behavior Analyst 37:1, pages 41-56.
Crossref
William R. Shadish, Larry V. Hedges & James E. Pustejovsky. (2014) Analysis and meta-analysis of single-case designs with a standardized mean difference statistic: A primer and applications. Journal of School Psychology 52:2, pages 123-147.
Crossref
Mieke Heyvaert & Patrick Onghena. (2014) Randomization tests for single-case experiments: State of the art, state of the science, and state of the application. Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science 3:1, pages 51-64.
Crossref
TSUYOSHI YAMADA. (2013) Research trends in educational measurement division and the application of open-source R in educational psychological research. The Annual Report of Educational Psychology in Japan 52:0, pages 64-76.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin & Sandra M. Chafouleas. (2012) Introduction to the Special Series. Remedial and Special Education 34:1, pages 3-8.
Crossref
Jonathan M. Campbell. (2012) Commentary on PND at 25. Remedial and Special Education 34:1, pages 20-25.
Crossref
Thomas E. Scruggs & Margo A. Mastropieri. (2012) PND at 25. Remedial and Special Education 34:1, pages 9-19.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Amy M. Briesch & Sandra M. Chafouleas. (2012) An Application of the What Works Clearinghouse Standards for Evaluating Single-Subject Research. Remedial and Special Education 34:1, pages 44-58.
Crossref
Kimberly J. Vannest & Heather S. Davis. 2013. Evidence-Based Practices. Evidence-Based Practices 93 119 .
Maaike Ugille, Mariola Moeyaert, S. Natasha Beretvas, John Ferron & Wim Van den Noortgate. (2012) Multilevel meta-analysis of single-subject experimental designs: A simulation study. Behavior Research Methods 44:4, pages 1244-1254.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Lindsay M. Fallon, Lisa M. Hagermoser Sanetti & Laura M. Ruberto. (2017) Training Paraeducators to Implement a Group Contingency Protocol: Direct and Collateral Effects. Behavioral Disorders 38:1, pages 18-37.
Crossref
Daniel M. Maggin, Austin H. Johnson, Sandra M. Chafouleas, Laura M. Ruberto & Melissa Berggren. (2012) A systematic evidence review of school-based group contingency interventions for students with challenging behavior. Journal of School Psychology 50:5, pages 625-654.
Crossref
M. Heyvaert, B. Maes, W. Van den Noortgate, S. Kuppens & P. Onghena. (2012) A multilevel meta-analysis of single-case and small-n research on interventions for reducing challenging behavior in persons with intellectual disabilities. Research in Developmental Disabilities 33:2, pages 766-780.
Crossref
Jennifer B. Ganz, John L. Davis, Emily M. Lund, Fara D. Goodwyn & Richard L. Simpson. (2012) Meta-analysis of PECS with individuals with ASD: Investigation of targeted versus non-targeted outcomes, participant characteristics, and implementation phase. Research in Developmental Disabilities 33:2, pages 406-418.
Crossref
Ae-Hwa Kim, 김은숙, 서선진, 박현, 김의정 & Eun-Kyung Kim. (2011) Trends and Issues in Field of Special Education through a Synthesis of Journals. Journal of Special Education 18:2, pages 49-78.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.