Advanced search
Publication Cover
European Planning Studies Volume 20, 2012 - Issue 5: Path Dependence and New Path Creation in Renewable Energy Technologies
Submit an article Journal homepage
4,387
Views
108
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Part II: Geographies

Renewable Energy Technology and Path Creation: A Multi-scalar Approach to Energy Transition in the UK

Jürgen Essletzbichler Department of Geography, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UKCorrespondence[email protected]
Pages 791-816 | Received 01 Feb 2011, Accepted 01 Sep 2011, Published online: 26 Apr 2012

Citations (108)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (21)

Lisa Nieth & Verena Radinger-Peer. (2023) Universities as strategic agents in regional path development? A European comparison. European Planning Studies 31:10, pages 2128-2147.
Read now
Trond Nilsen & Rune Njøs. (2022) Emergence of new industries in peripheral regions: the role of narratives in delegitimation of onshore wind in the Arctic Finnmark region. Regional Studies, Regional Science 9:1, pages 603-617.
Read now
David Gibbs & Paul D. Jensen. (2022) Chasing after the wind? Green economy strategies, path creation and transitions in the offshore wind industry. Regional Studies 56:10, pages 1671-1682.
Read now
José A. Belso-Martinez, Isabel Diez-Vial & Maria Jose Lopez-Sanchez. (2020) Supporting organizations and leading firms: a transition towards social and environmental practices inside clusters. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 102:4, pages 358-383.
Read now
Rune Njøs, Svein Gunnar Sjøtun, Stig-Erik Jakobsen & Arnt Fløysand. (2020) Expanding Analyses of Path Creation: Interconnections between Territory and Technology. Economic Geography 96:3, pages 266-288.
Read now
Svein Gunnar Sjøtun & Rune Njøs. (2019) Green reorientation of clusters and the role of policy: ‘the normative’ and ‘the neutral’ route. European Planning Studies 27:12, pages 2411-2430.
Read now
Markus Grillitsch & Teis Hansen. (2019) Green industry development in different types of regions. European Planning Studies 27:11, pages 2163-2183.
Read now
Danny MacKinnon, Stuart Dawley, Andy Pike & Andrew Cumbers. (2019) Rethinking Path Creation: A Geographical Political Economy Approach. Economic Geography 95:2, pages 113-135.
Read now
Giuseppe Calignano, Rune Dahl Fitjar & Nina Hjertvikrem. (2019) Innovation networks and green restructuring: Which path development can EU Framework Programmes stimulate in Norway?. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 73:1, pages 65-78.
Read now
Markus Steen, Fabian Faller & Eli Fyhn Ullern. (2019) Fostering renewable energy with smart specialisation? Insights into European innovation policy. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 73:1, pages 39-52.
Read now
Camilla Chlebna & James Simmie. (2018) New technological path creation and the role of institutions in different geo-political spaces. European Planning Studies 26:5, pages 969-987.
Read now
Irina Papazu. (2018) Storifying Samsø’s Renewable Energy Transition. Science as Culture 27:2, pages 198-220.
Read now
Zhen Yu & David Gibbs. (2018) Sustainability transitions and leapfrogging in latecomer cities: the development of solar thermal energy in Dezhou, China. Regional Studies 52:1, pages 68-79.
Read now
Beck Collins, David Boyd & Rachel Curzon. (2017) Exploring local projects for sustainable energy in system transition: local perceptions of success. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management 29:9, pages 1076-1088.
Read now
Rikard H. Eriksson, Høgni Kalsø Hansen & Lars Winther. (2017) Employment growth and regional development: industrial change and contextual differences between Denmark and Sweden. European Planning Studies 25:10, pages 1756-1778.
Read now
Peter Kedron & Sharmistha Bagchi-Sen. (2017) Limits to policy-led innovation and industry development in US biofuels. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management 29:5, pages 486-499.
Read now
Peter Kedron. (2015) Environmental Governance and Shifts in Canadian Biofuel Production and Innovation. The Professional Geographer 67:3, pages 385-395.
Read now
Markus Steen & Gard Hopsdal Hansen. (2014) Same Sea, Different Ponds: Cross-Sectorial Knowledge Spillovers in the North Sea. European Planning Studies 22:10, pages 2030-2049.
Read now
Stuart Dawley. (2014) Creating New Paths? Offshore Wind, Policy Activism, and Peripheral Region Development. Economic Geography 90:1, pages 91-112.
Read now
Matthias Brachert, Christoph Hornych & Peter Franz. (2013) Regions as Selection Environments? The Emergence of the Solar Industry in Germany from 1992 to 2008. European Planning Studies 21:11, pages 1820-1837.
Read now
Jerry Patchell & Roger Hayter. (2013) Environmental and evolutionary economic geography: time for eeg2?. Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography 95:2, pages 111-130.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (87)

Ju-Ying Yang & Jennifer Dodge. (2024) Local energy transitions as process: How contract management problems stymie a city's sustainable transition to renewable energy. Energy Policy 184, pages 113893.
Crossref
Kejia Yang. (2023) Spatial diffusion and niche shielding dynamics: Wind power development in China. Energy Research & Social Science 105, pages 103289.
Crossref
Paul Moritz Wiegmann, Madis Talmar & Sjoerd Bastiaan de Nijs. (2023) Forging a sharper blade: A design science research approach for transition studies. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 48, pages 100760.
Crossref
Kevin Joseph Dillman, Jukka Heinonen & Brynhildur Davíðsdóttir. (2023) A development of intergenerational sustainability indicators and thresholds for mobility system provisioning: A socio-ecological framework in the context of strong sustainability. Environmental and Sustainability Indicators 18, pages 100240.
Crossref
Joel A. Gordon, Nazmiye Balta-Ozkan & Seyed Ali Nabavi. (2023) Socio-technical barriers to domestic hydrogen futures: Repurposing pipelines, policies, and public perceptions. Applied Energy 336, pages 120850.
Crossref
Isabel Díez-Vial, Jose A. Belso-Martínez & Martín-de-Castro Gregorio. (2022) Extending Green Innovations Across Clusters: HOW can Firms Benefit Most?. International Regional Science Review 46:2, pages 149-178.
Crossref
Suyash Jolly, Markus Steen, Teis Hansen & Samson Afewerki. (2023) Renewable energy and industrial development in pioneering and lagging regions: the offshore wind industry in southern Denmark and Normandy. Oxford Open Energy 2.
Crossref
Hafidz Wibisono, Jon C. Lovett & Dhimas Bayu Anindito. (2022) The contestation of ideas behind Indonesia's rural electrification policies: The influence of global and national institutional dynamics. Development Policy Review 41:1.
Crossref
Jürgen Essletzbichler, Xenia Miklin, Hans Volmary & Michael Ornetzeder. 2023. APCC Special Report: Strukturen für ein klimafreundliches Leben. APCC Special Report: Strukturen für ein klimafreundliches Leben 481 497 .
Lukas Roebke, Markus Grillitsch & Lars Coenen. (2022) Assessing change agency in urban experiments for sustainability transitions. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 45, pages 214-227.
Crossref
Elkhan Richard Sadik-Zada. 2022. Zukünfte nachhaltiger Bioökonomie. Zukünfte nachhaltiger Bioökonomie 75 90 .
David Ayrapetyan, Nicolas Befort & Frans Hermans. (2022) The role of sustainability in the emergence and evolution of bioeconomy clusters: An application of a multiscalar framework. Journal of Cleaner Production 376, pages 134306.
Crossref
Sebastian Rohe & Camilla Chlebna. (2022) The evolving role of networking organizations in advanced sustainability transitions. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 183, pages 121916.
Crossref
Idiano D’Adamo, Pasquale Marcello Falcone, Enrica Imbert & Piergiuseppe Morone. (2020) Exploring regional transitions to the bioeconomy using a socio-economic indicator: the case of Italy. Economia Politica 39:3, pages 989-1021.
Crossref
Neil McGregor & Godfrey Yeung. (2022) Strategic coupling, path creation and diversification: Oil-related development in the ‘Straits Region’ since 1959. The Extractive Industries and Society 11, pages 101085.
Crossref
Christelle Khalaf, Gilbert Michaud & G. Jason Jolley. (2021) Toward a New Rural Typology: Mapping Resources, Opportunities, and Challenges. Economic Development Quarterly 36:3, pages 276-293.
Crossref
Eyup Dogan, Muhammad Zubair Chishti, Nooshin Karimi Alavijeh & Panayiotis Tzeremes. (2022) The roles of technology and Kyoto Protocol in energy transition towards COP26 targets: Evidence from the novel GMM-PVAR approach for G-7 countries. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 181, pages 121756.
Crossref
Utsav Bhattarai, Tek Maraseni & Armando Apan. (2022) Assay of renewable energy transition: A systematic literature review. Science of The Total Environment 833, pages 155159.
Crossref
Eyene Okpanachi, Terhemba Ambe-Uva & Anas Fassih. (2022) Energy regime reconfiguration and just transitions in the Global South: Lessons for West Africa from Morocco’s comparative experience. Futures 139, pages 102934.
Crossref
Cheng Wang, Tao Lv, Rongjiang Cai, Jianfeng Xu & Liya Wang. (2022) Bibliometric Analysis of Multi-Level Perspective on Sustainability Transition Research. Sustainability 14:7, pages 4145.
Crossref
Carla De Laurentis & Peter J. G. Pearson. (2021) Policy-relevant insights for regional renewable energy deployment. Energy, Sustainability and Society 11:1.
Crossref
Seona Park & Sun-Jin Yun. (2021) Multiscalar energy transitions: Exploring the strategies of renewable energy cooperatives in South Korea. Energy Research & Social Science 81, pages 102280.
Crossref
Gemma Delafield, Caspar Donnison, Philippa Roddis, Theodoros Arvanitopoulos, Alexandros Sfyridis, Sebastian Dunnett, Thomas Ball & Kathryn G. Logan. (2021) Conceptual framework for balancing society and nature in net-zero energy transitions. Environmental Science & Policy 125, pages 189-201.
Crossref
M.A. Hannan, Ali Q Al-Shetwi, Pin Jern Ker, R.A. Begum, M. Mansor, S.A. Rahman, Z.Y. Dong, S.K. Tiong, T.M. Indra Mahlia & K.M. Muttaqi. (2021) Impact of renewable energy utilization and artificial intelligence in achieving sustainable development goals. Energy Reports 7, pages 5359-5373.
Crossref
Teruyuki Shimizu & Yasunori Kikuchi. (2021) Regional suitability for energy carriers in Japan considering socioeconomic conditions and environmental performance. Journal of Cleaner Production 318, pages 128461.
Crossref
J. Schallenberg-Rodriguez & F. Inchausti-Sintes. (2021) Socio-economic impact of a 200 MW floating wind farm in Gran Canaria. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 148, pages 111242.
Crossref
Maria Morgunova. (2021) The role of the socio-technical regime in the sustainable energy transition: A case of the Eurasian Arctic. The Extractive Industries and Society 8:3, pages 100939.
Crossref
William Wang, Vicente Moreno-Casas & Jesús Huerta de Soto. (2021) A Free-Market Environmentalist Transition toward Renewable Energy: The Cases of Germany, Denmark, and the United Kingdom. Energies 14:15, pages 4659.
Crossref
Lars Coenen, Teis Hansen, Amy Glasmeier & Robert Hassink. (2021) Regional foundations of energy transitions. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 14:2, pages 219-233.
Crossref
Jerry Patchell & Roger Hayter. (2021) Greening the cloud: oligopoly-driven institutional transformations of the US electricity grid for commercial and industrial power purchases. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 14:2, pages 253-282.
Crossref
Hans-Christian Busch. (2021) Frugal innovation in energy transitions: insights from solar energy cases in Brazil. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 14:2, pages 321-340.
Crossref
Siddharth Sareen. (2021) Legitimating power: Solar energy rollout, sustainability metrics and transition politics. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space, pages 251484862110249.
Crossref
Bogdan Klepacki, Barbara Kusto, Piotr Bórawski, Aneta Bełdycka-Bórawska, Konrad Michalski, Aleksandra Perkowska & Tomasz Rokicki. (2021) Investments in Renewable Energy Sources in Basic Units of Local Government in Rural Areas. Energies 14:11, pages 3170.
Crossref
Franz Tödtling, Michaela Trippl & Alexandra Frangenheim. (2020) Policy options for green regional development: Adopting a production and application perspective. Science and Public Policy 47:6, pages 865-875.
Crossref
Patrizio Giganti & Pasquale Marcello Falcone. (2021) Socio-technical transitions and innovation niches: the case of the virtual and augmented reality in Europe. AIMS Energy 9:4, pages 755-774.
Crossref
S. Ruggiero, H. Busch, T. Hansen & A. Isakovic. (2021) Context and agency in urban community energy initiatives: An analysis of six case studies from the Baltic Sea Region. Energy Policy 148, pages 111956.
Crossref
Sebastian Losacker & Ingo Liefner. (2020) Regional lead markets for environmental innovation. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 37, pages 120-139.
Crossref
Camilla Chlebna & Jannika Mattes. (2020) The fragility of regional energy transitions. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 37, pages 66-78.
Crossref
Zhen Yu & David Gibbs. (2019) Unravelling the role of green entrepreneurs in urban sustainability transitions: A case study of China’s Solar City. Urban Studies 57:14, pages 2901-2917.
Crossref
Christos Nikolakakos, Umer Mushtaq, Peter Palensky & Milos Cvetkovic. (2020) Improving Frequency Stability with Inertial and Primary Frequency Response via DFIG Wind Turbines equipped with Energy Storage System. Improving Frequency Stability with Inertial and Primary Frequency Response via DFIG Wind Turbines equipped with Energy Storage System.
Xiyan Mao, Xinchen Luan & Xianjin Huang. (2020) How does inter-sectoral linkage affect the environmental performance of a transitioning region: Evidence from the Yangtze River Economic Belt, China. Resources, Environment and Sustainability 1, pages 100002.
Crossref
Johannes Suitner & Martha Ecker. (2020) “Making energy transition work”: Bricolage in Austrian regions’ path-creation. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 36, pages 209-220.
Crossref
Marcel Bednarz & Tom Broekel. (2020) Pulled or pushed? The spatial diffusion of wind energy between local demand and supply. Industrial and Corporate Change 29:4, pages 893-916.
Crossref
Carla De Laurentis. (2020) Mediating the form and direction of regional sustainable development: The role of the state in renewable energy deployment in selected regions. European Urban and Regional Studies 27:3, pages 303-317.
Crossref
Martijn van den Berge, Anet Weterings & Floor Alkemade. (2020) Do existing regional specialisations stimulate or hinder diversification into cleantech?. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 35, pages 185-201.
Crossref
Sam Wilkinson, Michael Davidson & Gregory M. Morrison. (2020) Historical transitions of Western Australia’s electricity system, 1880-2016. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 34, pages 151-164.
Crossref
Daphne Ngar-yin Mah. (2020) Conceptualising government-market dynamics in socio-technical energy transitions: A comparative case study of smart grid developments in China and Japan. Geoforum 108, pages 148-168.
Crossref
Roger Hayter & Jerry Patchell. 2020. International Encyclopedia of Human Geography. International Encyclopedia of Human Geography 467 477 .
Canfei He & Xiyan MaoCanfei He & Xiyan Mao. 2020. Environmental Economic Geography in China. Environmental Economic Geography in China 177 197 .
Ping Huang. (2019) The verticality of policy mixes for sustainability transitions: A case study of solar water heating in China. Research Policy 48:10, pages 103758.
Crossref
Marco Capasso, Teis Hansen, Jonas Heiberg, Antje Klitkou & Markus Steen. (2019) Green growth – A synthesis of scientific findings. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 146, pages 390-402.
Crossref
Stuart Dawley, Danny MacKinnon & Robert Pollock. (2019) Creating strategic couplings in global production networks: regional institutions and lead firm investment in the Humber region, UK. Journal of Economic Geography 19:4, pages 853-872.
Crossref
Jonathan Köhler, Frank W. Geels, Florian Kern, Jochen Markard, Elsie Onsongo, Anna Wieczorek, Floortje Alkemade, Flor Avelino, Anna Bergek, Frank Boons, Lea Fünfschilling, David Hess, Georg Holtz, Sampsa Hyysalo, Kirsten Jenkins, Paula Kivimaa, Mari Martiskainen, Andrew McMeekin, Marie Susan Mühlemeier, Bjorn Nykvist, Bonno Pel, Rob Raven, Harald Rohracher, Björn Sandén, Johan Schot, Benjamin Sovacool, Bruno Turnheim, Dan Welch & Peter Wells. (2019) An agenda for sustainability transitions research: State of the art and future directions. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 31, pages 1-32.
Crossref
Danny MacKinnon, Stuart Dawley, Markus Steen, Max-Peter Menzel, Asbjørn Karlsen, Pascal Sommer, Gard Hopsdal Hansen & Håkon Endresen Normann. (2019) Path creation, global production networks and regional development: A comparative international analysis of the offshore wind sector. Progress in Planning 130, pages 1-32.
Crossref
Pia Buschmann & Angela Oels. (2019) The overlooked role of discourse in breaking carbon lock‐in: The case of the German energy transition. WIREs Climate Change 10:3.
Crossref
Canfei He, Xiyan Mao & Xiangdong Zhu. (2018) Industrial dynamics and environmental performance in urban China. Journal of Cleaner Production 195, pages 1512-1522.
Crossref
Jorge Niosi. 2018. Innovation Systems, Policy and Management. Innovation Systems, Policy and Management 1 24 .
. 2018. Innovation Systems, Policy and Management. Innovation Systems, Policy and Management.
Tiago Neves Sequeira & Marcelo Serra Santos. (2018) Renewable energy and politics: A systematic review and new evidence. Journal of Cleaner Production 192, pages 553-568.
Crossref
Yifan Cai & Yuko Aoyama. (2018) Fragmented authorities, institutional misalignments, and challenges to renewable energy transition: A case study of wind power curtailment in China. Energy Research & Social Science 41, pages 71-79.
Crossref
Alex Ramiller & Patrick Schmidt. (2018) Scale limits to sustainability: Transdisciplinary evidence from three Danish cases. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 27, pages 48-58.
Crossref
Harm van den Heiligenberg, Gaston Heimeriks, Marko Hekkert, Rob Raven & Jifke Sol. (2018) Contrasting Regional Habitats for Urban Sustainability Experimentation in Europe. Sustainability 10:5, pages 1624.
Crossref
Vanessa Burg, Gillianne Bowman, Matthias Erni, Renato Lemm & Oliver Thees. (2018) Analyzing the potential of domestic biomass resources for the energy transition in Switzerland. Biomass and Bioenergy 111, pages 60-69.
Crossref
Carla De Laurentis & Peter J.G. Pearson. (2018) Understanding the material dimensions of the uneven deployment of renewable energy in two Italian regions. Energy Research & Social Science 36, pages 106-119.
Crossref
Asbjørn Karlsen. (2018) Framing industrialization of the offshore wind value chain – A discourse approach to an event. Geoforum 88, pages 148-156.
Crossref
Norbert Kersting & Roland Roth. 2018. Handbuch Energiewende und Partizipation. Handbuch Energiewende und Partizipation 1147 1164 .
Sarah DeborSarah Debor. 2018. Multiplying Mighty Davids?. Multiplying Mighty Davids? 37 102 .
Carla De Laurentis, Malcolm Eames & Miriam Hunt. (2016) Retrofitting the built environment ‘to save’ energy: Arbed, the emergence of a distinctive sustainability transition pathway in Wales. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 35:7, pages 1156-1175.
Crossref
Jeremy M. Hills & Evanthie Michalena. (2017) Renewable energy pioneers are threatened by EU policy reform. Renewable Energy 108, pages 26-36.
Crossref
Cristian Matti, Davide Consoli & Elvira Uyarra. (2016) Multi level policy mixes and industry emergence: The case of wind energy in Spain. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 35:4, pages 661-683.
Crossref
Hanna Martin & Roman Martin. (2016) Policy capacities for new regional industrial path development – The case of new media and biogas in southern Sweden. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 35:3, pages 518-536.
Crossref
Richard Cowell, Geraint Ellis, Fionnguala Sherry-Brennan, Peter A. Strachan & David Toke. (2017) Energy transitions, sub-national government and regime flexibility: How has devolution in the United Kingdom affected renewable energy development?. Energy Research & Social Science 23, pages 169-181.
Crossref
Andreas Röhring,. (2016) Die Konstituierung dezentraler Handlungsräume erneuerbarer Energien – Chancen und Herausforderungen für die Kreation neuer Entwicklungspfade. Vierteljahrshefte zur Wirtschaftsforschung 85:4, pages 103-113.
Crossref
Fabian Faller. (2016) Räumliche Praktiken der Energiewende am Beispiel der Biogaserzeugung in Rheinland-Pfalz. Raumforschung und Raumordnung | Spatial Research and Planning 74:3.
Crossref
Fabian Faller. (2016) Räumliche Praktiken der Energiewende am Beispiel der Biogaserzeugung in Rheinland-Pfalz. Raumforschung und Raumordnung 74:3, pages 199-211.
Crossref
Fabian Faller. (2016) A practice approach to study the spatial dimensions of the energy transition. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 19, pages 85-95.
Crossref
Marc Wolfram & Niki Frantzeskaki. (2016) Cities and Systemic Change for Sustainability: Prevailing Epistemologies and an Emerging Research Agenda. Sustainability 8:2, pages 144.
Crossref
Elvira Uyarra, Philip Shapira & Alan Harding. (2016) Low carbon innovation and enterprise growth in the UK: Challenges of a place-blind policy mix. Technological Forecasting and Social Change 103, pages 264-272.
Crossref
Marc Wolfram. 2016. Quantitative Regional Economic and Environmental Analysis for Sustainability in Korea. Quantitative Regional Economic and Environmental Analysis for Sustainability in Korea 3 22 .
Ulrich Dewald & Martina Fromhold-Eisebith. (2015) Trajectories of sustainability transitions in scale-transcending innovation systems: The case of photovoltaics. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 17, pages 110-125.
Crossref
Teis Hansen & Lars Coenen. (2015) The geography of sustainability transitions: Review, synthesis and reflections on an emergent research field. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 17, pages 92-109.
Crossref
Alessandro Marra, Paola Antonelli, Luca Dell’Anna & Cesare Pozzi. (2015) A network analysis using metadata to investigate innovation in clean-tech – Implications for energy policy. Energy Policy 86, pages 17-26.
Crossref
S. Dawley, D. MacKinnon, A. Cumbers & A. Pike. (2015) Policy activism and regional path creation: the promotion of offshore wind in North East England and Scotland. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society 8:2, pages 257-272.
Crossref
Mark Bailoni. (2015) Les évolutions du modèle énergétique britannique face aux enjeux géopolitiques internesThe future of British energy production in front of internal geopolitical issues. VertigO:Volume 14 Numéro 3.
Crossref
Roger Hayter & Jerry Patchell. 2015. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences 568 575 .
Lukas Roebke, Markus Grillitsch & Lars Coenen. (2022) Assessing Change Agency in Urban Experiments for Sustainability Transitions. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Kejia Yang, Johan Schot & Bernhard Truffer. (2020) Shaping the Directionality of Sustainability Transitions: The Diverging Development Patterns of Solar PV in Two Chinese Provinces. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.