6,279
Views
91
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Reports and Reflections

Confusing Claims for Data: A Critique of Common Practices for Presenting Qualitative Research on Learning

&

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (18)

Kason Ka Ching Cheung & Kevin W. H. Tai. (2023) The use of intercoder reliability in qualitative interview data analysis in science education. Research in Science & Technological Education 41:3, pages 1155-1175.
Read now
Mara Kirdani-Ryan, Amy J. Ko & Emilia A. Borisova. (2023) “Taught to be automata”: Examining the departmental role inshaping initial career choices of computing students. Computer Science Education 0:0, pages 1-27.
Read now
Alenka Poplin, Erin Duffer & Georg Gartner. (2023) Well-being evocative places: validating the conceptual model of an evocative place based on the inter-rater reliability test. International Journal of Cartography 9:1, pages 114-135.
Read now
Henriikka Vartiainen & Matti Tedre. (2023) Using artificial intelligence in craft education: crafting with text-to-image generative models. Digital Creativity 34:1, pages 1-21.
Read now
David DeLiema, Ashley Hufnagle, V.N. Vimal Rao, Justin Baker, Jesslyn Valerie & Jasmine Kim. (2023) Methodological innovations at the intersection of video-based educational research traditions: Reflections on relevance, data selection, and phenomena of interest. International Journal of Research & Method in Education 46:1, pages 19-36.
Read now
Maarit Arvaja, Anneli Sarja & Paula Rönnberg. (2022) Pre-service subject teachers’ personal teacher characterisations after the pedagogical studies. European Journal of Teacher Education 45:5, pages 653-669.
Read now
Maarit Arvaja & Anneli Sarja. (2021) Dialogic Tensions in Pre-Service Subject Teachers’ Identity Negotiations. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research 65:2, pages 318-330.
Read now
Daniel Morales-Doyle, Maria Varelas, David Segura & Marcela Bernal-Munera. (2021) Access, Dissent, Ethics, and Politics: Pre-service Teachers Negotiating Conceptions of the Work of Teaching Science for Equity. Cognition and Instruction 39:1, pages 35-64.
Read now
Leontien W. M. Bossink, Annette A. J. Van der Putten & Carla Vlaskamp. (2020) Physical-activity support for people with intellectual disabilities: a theory-informed qualitative study exploring the direct support professionals’ perspective. Disability and Rehabilitation 42:25, pages 3614-3620.
Read now
Scott Pattison, Ivel Gontan, Smirla Ramos-Montañez, Todd Shagott, Melanie Francisco & Lynn Dierking. (2020) The identity-frame model: A framework to describe situated identity negotiation for adolescent youth participating in an informal engineering education program. Journal of the Learning Sciences 29:4-5, pages 550-597.
Read now
Leema K. Berland, Rosemary S. Russ & Cori P. West. (2020) Supporting the Scientific Practices through Epistemologically Responsive Science Teaching. Journal of Science Teacher Education 31:3, pages 264-290.
Read now
C. Aaron Price & A. Chiu. (2018) An experimental study of a museum-based, science PD programme’s impact on teachers and their students. International Journal of Science Education 40:9, pages 941-960.
Read now
Emma Hospelhorn & Josh Radinsky. (2017) Method for Analyzing Gestural Communication in Musical Groups. Discourse Processes 54:7, pages 504-523.
Read now
J. Radinsky, D. Milz, M. Zellner, K. Pudlock, C. Witek, C. Hoch & L. Lyons. (2017) How planners and stakeholders learn with visualization tools: using learning sciences methods to examine planning processes. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 60:7, pages 1296-1323.
Read now
Josh Radinsky & Iris Tabak. (2017) Outgoing Editors’ Note: The Journal of the Learning Sciences as a Mirror of Trends in the Field. Journal of the Learning Sciences 26:1, pages 1-6.
Read now
Tina A. Grotzer, Katarzyna Derbiszewska & S. Lynneth Solis. (2017) Leveraging Fourth and Sixth Graders’ Experiences to Reveal Understanding of the Forms and Features of Distributed Causality. Cognition and Instruction 35:1, pages 55-87.
Read now
Charles Hoch, Moira Zellner, Dan Milz, Josh Radinsky & Leilah Lyons. (2015) Seeing is not believing: cognitive bias and modelling in collaborative planning. Planning Theory & Practice 16:3, pages 319-335.
Read now
Iris Tabak & Josh Radinsky. (2014) Editors’ Note. Journal of the Learning Sciences 23:1, pages 1-3.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (73)

Shirly Avargil, Daphna Shwartz-Asher, Shari R. Reiss & Yehudit Judy Dori. (2023) Professors’ retrospective views on chemistry career choices with a focus on gender and academic stage aspects. Sustainable Chemistry and Pharmacy 36, pages 101249.
Crossref
Noelle Brown, Benjamin Xie, Ella Sarder, Casey Fiesler & Eliane S. Wiese. (2023) Teaching Ethics in Computing: A Systematic Literature Review of ACM Computer Science Education Publications. ACM Transactions on Computing Education.
Crossref
Jaemarie Solyst, Ellia Yang, Shixian Xie, Amy Ogan, Jessica Hammer & Motahhare Eslami. (2023) The Potential of Diverse Youth as Stakeholders in Identifying and Mitigating Algorithmic Bias for a Future of Fairer AI. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7:CSCW2, pages 1-27.
Crossref
Elias Euler & Bor Gregorcic. (2023) Visual display of qualitative information: Implications of using illustrations to depict video data. Physical Review Physics Education Research 19:2.
Crossref
Bernd Carsten Stahl & Tonii Leach. (2022) Assessing the ethical and social concerns of artificial intelligence in neuroinformatics research: an empirical test of the European Union Assessment List for Trustworthy AI (ALTAI). AI and Ethics 3:3, pages 745-767.
Crossref
John Button, Diren Pamuk Turner & David Hammer. (2023) How chemists handle not-knowing in reasoning about a novel problem. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 24:3, pages 956-970.
Crossref
Shali Wu. (2023) Guided Reflection in Business Education: An Example from Leadership Development. Business Communication Research and Practice 6:2, pages 98-104.
Crossref
Courtney Ngai, Mary E. Pilgrim, Daniel L. Reinholz, Karen Falkenberg, Chris Geanious, Joel C. Corbo, Sarah B. Wise, Clara E. Smith & Amelia Stone-Johnstone. (2023) Guiding principles for change in undergraduate education: An analysis of a departmental team’s change effort. Physical Review Physics Education Research 19:2.
Crossref
Eric W Burkholder, Olivia C Miller & Lena F Blackmon. (2023) Investigating the epistemology of physics students while reflecting on solutions. European Journal of Physics 44:4, pages 045701.
Crossref
Jenny T. Liang, Maryam Arab, Minhyuk Ko, Amy J. Ko & Thomas D. LaToza. (2023) A Qualitative Study on the Implementation Design Decisions of Developers. A Qualitative Study on the Implementation Design Decisions of Developers.
Jason Yip, Kelly Wong, Isabella Oh, Farisha Sultan, Wendy Roldan, Kung Jin Lee & Jimi Huh. (2023) Co-design Tensions Between Parents, Children, and Researchers Regarding Mobile Health Technology Design Needs and Decisions: Case Study. JMIR Formative Research 7, pages e41726.
Crossref
Peter E. Branney, Joanna Brooks, Laura Kilby, Kristina Newman, Emma Norris, Madeleine Pownall, Catherine V. Talbot, Gareth J. Treharne & Candice M. Whitaker. (2023) Three steps to open science for qualitative research in psychology. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 17:4.
Crossref
Eve Manz & Betsy Beckert. (2021) Quantification in Empirical Activity. Science & Education 32:2, pages 447-480.
Crossref
Tellervo Härkki. (2022) Mobile gaze tracking and an extended linkography for collaborative sketching and designing. International Journal of Technology and Design Education 33:2, pages 379-413.
Crossref
Valerie K. Otero, Danielle Boyd Harlow & David E. Meltzer. 2023. The International Handbook of Physics Education Research: Special Topics. The International Handbook of Physics Education Research: Special Topics 25-1 25-32 .
David Hammer. 2023. The International Handbook of Physics Education Research: Special Topics. The International Handbook of Physics Education Research: Special Topics 22-1 22-12 .
Alannah Oleson, Meron Solomon, Christopher Perdriau & Amy Ko. (2023) Teaching Inclusive Design Skills with the CIDER Assumption Elicitation Technique. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 30:1, pages 1-49.
Crossref
Jessica Díaz, Jorge Pérez, Carolina Gallardo & Ángel González-Prieto. (2023) Applying Inter-Rater Reliability and Agreement in collaborative Grounded Theory studies in software engineering. Journal of Systems and Software 195, pages 111520.
Crossref
Jennifer K. Knight, Daniel C. Weaver, Melanie E. Peffer & Zachary S. Hazlett. (2022) Relationships between Prediction Accuracy, Metacognitive Reflection, and Performance in Introductory Genetics Students. CBE—Life Sciences Education 21:3.
Crossref
Henriikka Vartiainen, Hanna Vuojärvi, Kaija Saramäki, Miikka Eriksson, Ilkka Ratinen, Piritta Torssonen, Petteri Vanninen & Sinikka Pöllänen. (2022) Cross‐boundary collaboration and knowledge creation in an online higher education course. British Journal of Educational Technology 53:5, pages 1304-1320.
Crossref
Alannah Oleson, Benjamin Xie, Jean Salac, Jayne Everson, F. Megumi Kivuva & Amy J. Ko. (2022) A Decade of Demographics in Computing Education Research: A Critical Review of Trends in Collection, Reporting, and Use. A Decade of Demographics in Computing Education Research: A Critical Review of Trends in Collection, Reporting, and Use.
Jayne Everson & Amy J. Ko. (2022) “I would be afraid to be a bad CS teacher”: Factors Influencing Participation in Pre-Service Secondary CS Teacher Education. “I would be afraid to be a bad CS teacher”: Factors Influencing Participation in Pre-Service Secondary CS Teacher Education.
Maryam Arab, Thomas D. LaToza, Jenny Liang & Amy J. Ko. (2022) An Exploratory Study of Sharing Strategic Programming Knowledge. An Exploratory Study of Sharing Strategic Programming Knowledge.
Vonna L Hemmler, Allison W Kenney, Susan Dulong Langley, Carolyn M Callahan, E. Jean Gubbins & Shannon Holder. (2020) Beyond a coefficient: an interactive process for achieving inter-rater consistency in qualitative coding. Qualitative Research 22:2, pages 194-219.
Crossref
Juan Velasco, Laura Buteler, Carlos Briozzo & Enrique Coleoni. (2022) Learning entropy among peers through the lens of coordination class theory. Physical Review Physics Education Research 18:1.
Crossref
Benjamin Xie, Alannah Oleson, Jayne Everson & Amy J. Ko. (2022) Surfacing Equity Issues in Large Computing Courses with Peer-Ranked, Demographically-Labeled Student Feedback. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 6:CSCW1, pages 1-39.
Crossref
Henriikka Vartiainen, Lotta Pellas, Juho Kahila, Teemu Valtonen & Matti Tedre. (2022) Pre-service teachers’ insights on data agency. New Media & Society, pages 146144482210796.
Crossref
Jayne Everson, F. Megumi Kivuva & Amy J. Ko. (2022) "A Key to Reducing Inequities in Like, AI, is by Reducing Inequities Everywhere First". "A Key to Reducing Inequities in Like, AI, is by Reducing Inequities Everywhere First".
Keenan Noyes, Clare G. Carlson, Jon R. Stoltzfus, Christina V. Schwarz, Tammy M. Long & Melanie M. Cooper. (2022) A Deep Look into Designing a Task and Coding Scheme through the Lens of Causal Mechanistic Reasoning. Journal of Chemical Education 99:2, pages 874-885.
Crossref
Muhammad Adeel Mannan & Adeel Ansari. (2022) SPMM: A Model Taxonomy for Designing and Managing Quality System. IEEE Access 10, pages 76720-76730.
Crossref
Jennifer S. Avena, Betsy B. McIntosh, Oscar N. Whitney, Ashton Wiens & Jennifer K. Knight. (2021) Successful Problem Solving in Genetics Varies Based on Question Content. CBE—Life Sciences Education 20:4.
Crossref
Paul J. Thomas, Devang Patel & Alejandra J. Magana. (2021) Characterizing Student Proficiency in Software Modeling in Terms of Functions, Structures, and Behaviors. ACM Transactions on Computing Education 21:3, pages 1-25.
Crossref
Field M. Watts & Solaire A. Finkenstaedt-Quinn. (2021) The current state of methods for establishing reliability in qualitative chemistry education research articles. Chemistry Education Research and Practice 22:3, pages 565-578.
Crossref
Hoda Ehsan, Abeera P. Rehmat & Monica E. Cardella. (2020) Computational thinking embedded in engineering design: capturing computational thinking of children in an informal engineering design activity. International Journal of Technology and Design Education 31:3, pages 441-464.
Crossref
Lucy Simko, Britnie Chin, Sungmin Na, Harkiran Kaur Saluja, Tian Qi Zhu, Tadayoshi Kohno, Alexis Hiniker, Jason Yip & Camille Cobb. (2021) Would You Rather: A Focus Group Method for Eliciting and Discussing Formative Design Insights with Children. Would You Rather: A Focus Group Method for Eliciting and Discussing Formative Design Insights with Children.
Tobias Ludwig, Burkhard Priemer & Doris Lewalter. (2019) Assessing Secondary School Students’ Justifications for Supporting or Rejecting a Scientific Hypothesis in the Physics Lab. Research in Science Education 51:3, pages 819-844.
Crossref
Alannah Oleson, Brett Wortzman & Amy J. Ko. (2020) On the Role of Design in K-12 Computing Education. ACM Transactions on Computing Education 21:1, pages 1-34.
Crossref
O. Handmaker, B.L. Keeler & D. Milz. (2021) What type of value information is most valuable to stakeholders? Multi-sector perspectives on the utility and relevance of water valuation information. Environmental Science & Policy 115, pages 47-60.
Crossref
Andrew Elby & Sevda Yerdelen-Damar. (2020) Rethinking the relationship between instructors and physics education researchers. Physical Review Physics Education Research 16:2.
Crossref
Michael F. J. Fox, Benjamin M. Zwickl & H. J. Lewandowski. (2020) Preparing for the quantum revolution: What is the role of higher education?. Physical Review Physics Education Research 16:2.
Crossref
Jason C. Yip, Kung Jin Lee & Jin Ha Lee. (2019) Design partnerships for participatory librarianship: A conceptual model for understanding librarians co designing With digital youth. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 71:10, pages 1242-1256.
Crossref
Elias Euler, Bor Gregorcic & Cedric Linder. (2020) Variation theory as a lens for interpreting and guiding physics students’ use of digital learning environments. European Journal of Physics 41:4, pages 045705.
Crossref
Thomas D. LaToza, Maryam Arab, Dastyni Loksa & Amy J. Ko. (2020) Explicit programming strategies. Empirical Software Engineering 25:4, pages 2416-2449.
Crossref
Jeffrey A. Greene, Nikki G. Lobczowski, Rebekah Freed, Brian M. Cartiff, Cynthia Demetriou & A. T. Panter. (2019) Effects of a Science of Learning Course on College Students’ Learning With a Computer. American Educational Research Journal 57:3, pages 947-978.
Crossref
Alannah Oleson, Meron Solomon & Amy J. Ko. (2020) Computing Students' Learning Difficulties in HCI Education. Computing Students' Learning Difficulties in HCI Education.
Brendan Eagan, Jais Brohinsky, Jingyi Wang & David Williamson Shaffer. (2020) Testing the reliability of inter-rater reliability. Testing the reliability of inter-rater reliability.
Nora McDonald, Sarita Schoenebeck & Andrea Forte. (2019) Reliability and Inter-rater Reliability in Qualitative Research. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 3:CSCW, pages 1-23.
Crossref
Onofrio Rosario Battaglia, Benedetto Di Paola & Claudio Fazio. (2019) Unsupervised quantitative methods to analyze student reasoning lines: Theoretical aspects and examples. Physical Review Physics Education Research 15:2.
Crossref
Elias Euler, Elmer Rådahl & Bor Gregorcic. (2019) Embodiment in physics learning: A social-semiotic look. Physical Review Physics Education Research 15:1.
Crossref
Angela J. Little, Bridget Humphrey, Abigail Green, Abhilash Nair & Vashti Sawtelle. (2019) Exploring mindset’s applicability to students’ experiences with challenge in transformed college physics courses. Physical Review Physics Education Research 15:1.
Crossref
Amy J. Ko, Thomas D. LaToza, Stephen Hull, Ellen A. Ko, William Kwok, Jane Quichocho, Harshitha Akkaraju & Rishin Pandit. (2019) Teaching Explicit Programming Strategies to Adolescents. Teaching Explicit Programming Strategies to Adolescents.
Jérôme Santini, Tracy Bloor & Gérard Sensevy. (2018) Modeling Conceptualization and Investigating Teaching Effectiveness. Science & Education 27:9-10, pages 921-961.
Crossref
Susan De La Paz & Daniel M. Levin. (2017) Beyond “They Cited the Text”: Middle School Students and Teachers’ Written Critiques of Scientific Conclusions. Research in Science Education 48:6, pages 1433-1459.
Crossref
Dimitri R. Dounas-Frazer, Laura Ríos, Benjamin Pollard, Jacob T. Stanley & H. J. Lewandowski. (2018) Characterizing lab instructors’ self-reported learning goals to inform development of an experimental modeling skills assessment. Physical Review Physics Education Research 14:2.
Crossref
Filitsa Dingyloudi & Jan-Willem Strijbos. (2018) Just plain peers across social networks: Peer-feedback networks nested in personal and academic networks in higher education. Learning, Culture and Social Interaction 18, pages 86-112.
Crossref
Michelle H. Wilkerson, Alfredo Bautista, Roger G. Tobin, Bárbara M. Brizuela & Ying Cao. (2016) More than meets the eye: patterns and shifts in middle school mathematics teachers’ descriptions of models. Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education 21:1, pages 35-61.
Crossref
Rachel A. Thomas & Vanessa Svihla. (2017) Changing Student Conceptions of Arid, Urban Watershed Management. Journal of Contemporary Water Research & Education 161:1, pages 92-104.
Crossref
Bor Gregorcic, Gorazd Planinsic & Eugenia Etkina. (2017) Doing science by waving hands: Talk, symbiotic gesture, and interaction with digital content as resources in student inquiry. Physical Review Physics Education Research 13:2.
Crossref
Onofrio Rosario Battaglia, Bendetto Di Paola & Claudio Fazio. (2017) A quantitative analysis of Educational Data through the Comparison between Hierarchical and Not-Hierarchical Clustering. EURASIA Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education 13:8.
Crossref
Vanessa Svihla, Jill Marshall, Ara Winter & Yang Liu. (2017) Progress toward Lofty Goals: A Meta-synthesis of the State of Research on K-12 Engineering Education (Fundamental). Progress toward Lofty Goals: A Meta-synthesis of the State of Research on K-12 Engineering Education (Fundamental).
Jamie Gomez, Vanessa Svihla & Abhaya Datye. (2017) Jigsaws & Parleys: Strategies for engaging sophomore level students as a learning community. Jigsaws & Parleys: Strategies for engaging sophomore level students as a learning community.
Meeko Oishi, Vanessa Svihla & Victor Law. (2017) Improved Learning Through Collaborative, Scenario-based Quizzes in an Undergraduate Control Theory Course. Improved Learning Through Collaborative, Scenario-based Quizzes in an Undergraduate Control Theory Course.
Claudio Fazio, Onofrio Rosario Battaglia, Benedetto Di Paola & Dominique Persano Adorno. 2017. Key Competences in Physics Teaching and Learning. Key Competences in Physics Teaching and Learning 79 94 .
Maarit Arvaja. (2016) Building teacher identity through the process of positioning. Teaching and Teacher Education 59, pages 392-402.
Crossref
Jerusha O. Conner, C. Nathan Ober & Amanda S. Brown. (2016) The Politics of Paternalism: Adult and Youth Perspectives on Youth Voice in Public Policy. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 118:8, pages 1-48.
Crossref
Tanya Chichekian, Bruce M. Shore & Diana Tabatabai. (2016) First-Year Teachers’ Uphill Struggle to Implement Inquiry Instruction. SAGE Open 6:2, pages 215824401664901.
Crossref
Onofrio Rosario Battaglia, Benedetto Di Paola & Claudio Fazio. (2016) A New Approach to Investigate Students’ Behavior by Using Cluster Analysis as an Unsupervised Methodology in the Field of Education. Applied Mathematics 07:15, pages 1649-1673.
Crossref
Moin Syed & Sarah C. Nelson. (2015) Guidelines for Establishing Reliability When Coding Narrative Data. Emerging Adulthood 3:6, pages 375-387.
Crossref
Dimitri R. Dounas-Frazer & Daniel L. Reinholz. (2015) Attending to lifelong learning skills through guided reflection in a physics class. American Journal of Physics 83:10, pages 881-891.
Crossref
Jeffrey Alan Greene, Cheryl Mason Bolick, William P. Jackson, Alfred M. Caprino, Christopher Oswald & Megan McVea. (2015) Domain-specificity of self-regulated learning processing in science and history. Contemporary Educational Psychology 42, pages 111-128.
Crossref
Tammie Visintainer & Marcia Linn. (2015) Sixth-Grade Students’ Progress in Understanding the Mechanisms of Global Climate Change. Journal of Science Education and Technology 24:2-3, pages 287-310.
Crossref
Pryce Davis, Michael Horn, Florian Block, Brenda Phillips, E. Margaret Evans, Judy Diamond & Chia Shen. (2015) “Whoa! We’re going deep in the trees!”: Patterns of collaboration around an interactive information visualization exhibit. International Journal of Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning 10:1, pages 53-76.
Crossref
Walter M. Stroup & Uri Wilensky. (2014) On the Embedded Complementarity of Agent-Based and Aggregate Reasoning in Students’ Developing Understanding of Dynamic Systems. Technology, Knowledge and Learning 19:1-2, pages 19-52.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.