Advanced search
Publication Cover
Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology Volume 41, 2011 - Issue 4
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,854
Views
173
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Impact of China's Large-Scale Ecological Restoration Program on the Environment and Society in Arid and Semiarid Areas of China: Achievements, Problems, Synthesis, and Applications

Shixiong Cao Key Laboratory of Soil and Water Conservation & Desertification Combat, Beijing Forestry University, Beijing, P.R. China
Pages 317-335 | Published online: 02 Feb 2011

Citations (173)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (5)

Aiora Zabala & Caroline A. Sullivan. (2018) Multilevel assessment of a large-scale programme for poverty alleviation and wetland conservation: lessons from South Africa. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 61:3, pages 493-514.
Read now
Patricia J. Hartman. (2017) Reviews of Science for Science Librarians: Forestry as a Climate Change Mitigation Tool. Science & Technology Libraries 36:3, pages 219-234.
Read now
Kui Cai & Ziling Gong. (2014) Community livelihood and its dependence on nature resources under pressure of conservation. Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment 12:1, pages 80-87.
Read now
Lishan Ran, Xixi Lu & Jianchu Xu. (2013) Effects of Vegetation Restoration on Soil Conservation and Sediment Loads in China: A Critical Review. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology 43:13, pages 1384-1415.
Read now
Di Liang, Bojie Fu, Yihe Lü, Yu Liu, Guangyao Gao, Yifeng Li & Zhaoxia Li. (2012) Effects of retired steepland afforestation on soil properties: A case study in the Loess Plateau of China. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section B — Soil & Plant Science 62:6, pages 547-555.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (168)

Yong Xu, Yun-Gui Lu, Bin Zou, Ming Xu & Yu-Xi Feng. (2024) Unraveling the enigma of NPP variation in Chinese vegetation ecosystems: The interplay of climate change and land use change. Science of The Total Environment 912, pages 169023.
Crossref
Xianghua Zhang, Jonah Busch, Yingli Huang, Luuk Fleskens, Huiyan Qin & Zhenhua Qiao. (2023) Cost of mitigating climate change through reforestation in China. Frontiers in Forests and Global Change 6.
Crossref
Jan Christoph Axmacher, Weiguo Sang, Ewan Brennan, Maryse Diekman, Yunhui Liu, Alice Marples, Hongliang Shi, Zhongzhou Sui, Xiaojie Sun, Eleanor Warren-Thomas, Xin Yang, Zhenrong Yu, Fan Bai, Liangtao Li, Changliu Wang, Xin Wang & Yi Zou. (2023) Regional sets of diverse, specialized ground beetle and plant assemblages recolonise China’s restored temperate forest landscapes. Forest Ecology and Management 549, pages 121479.
Crossref
Zhenyu Ni, Bing Song, Weiwei Sun, Xianqiang Meng, Xiangdong Yang & Enlou Zhang. (2023) Anthropogenic environmental evolution of ganggeng lake in the East Asian monsoon marginal zone over the past century. Quaternary International 670, pages 24-31.
Crossref
Yu Peng, Xiaobing Peng, Mingze Yin, Jiaxin He & Li Ma. (2023) The welfare effects of impoverished rural areas: Review and research prospects. Heliyon 9:9, pages e19513.
Crossref
Juan He, Yao Li, Xueyi Shi & Haiyan Hou. (2023) Integrating the impacts of vegetation coverage on ecosystem services to determine ecological restoration targets for adaptive management on the Loess Plateau, China. Land Degradation & Development.
Crossref
Hao Yu, Lin Da, Yalun Li, Yanqiong Chen, Qingdan Geng, Zhibin Jia, Yun Zhang, Jinhua Li & Caixia Gao. (2023) Industrial symbiosis promoting material exchanges in Ulan Buh Demonstration Eco-industrial Park: A multi-objective MILP model. Journal of Cleaner Production 414, pages 137578.
Crossref
Xinyang Ji, Jinzhong Yang, Jianyu Liu, Xiaomin Du, Wenkai Zhang, Jiafeng Liu, Guangwei Li & Jingkai Guo. (2023) Analysis of Spatial-Temporal Changes and Driving Forces of Desertification in the Mu Us Sandy Land from 1991 to 2021. Sustainability 15:13, pages 10399.
Crossref
Tao Pan, Wenhui Kuang, Hua Shao, Chi Zhang, Xiaoyu Wang & Xinqing Wang. (2023) Urban expansion and intra-urban land evolution as well as their natural environmental constraints in arid/semiarid regions of China from 2000–2018. Journal of Geographical Sciences 33:7, pages 1419-1441.
Crossref
Jiayu Xia, Duyuzheng Ren, Xuhui Wang, Bo Xu, Xingyao Zhong & Yajiang Fan. (2023) Ecosystem Quality Assessment and Ecological Restoration in Fragile Zone of Loess Plateau: A Case Study of Suide County, China. Land 12:6, pages 1131.
Crossref
Chong Liu, Liren Xu, Donglin Li, Yinran Huang, Jiemin Kang, Bo Peng, Xuanrui Huang & Zhidong Zhang. (2023) Spatiotemporal Variations and Determinants of Supply–Demand Balance of Ecosystem Service in Saihanba Region, China. Forests 14:6, pages 1100.
Crossref
Jianlun Zhao, Shuguang Liu, Zhao Wang, Haiqiang Gao, Shuailong Feng, Baojing Wei, Zhaozhen Hou, Fangmeng Xiao, Lei Jing & Xiaoping Liao. (2023) The Impact of Land Use and Landscape Pattern on Ecosystem Services in the Dongting Lake Region, China. Remote Sensing 15:9, pages 2228.
Crossref
Yuming Lu, Maokui Lyu, Xiaoling Xiong, Cui Deng, Yongmeng Jiang, Min Zeng & Jinsheng Xie. (2023) Understory ferns promote the restoration of soil microbial diversity and function in previously degraded lands. Science of The Total Environment 870, pages 161934.
Crossref
Xiao Zhang, Jun Wang, Mingyue Zhao, Yan Gao & Yanxu Liu. (2023) Variations of Ecosystem Services Supply and Demand on the Southeast Hilly Area of China: Implications for Ecosystem Protection and Restoration Management. Land 12:4, pages 750.
Crossref
Chuanpeng Cheng, Tao Zhang, Fengting Yang, Qingkang Li, Qianyu Wang, Mingjie Xu, Shengtong Li & Huimim Wang. (2023) Effects of thinning on forest soil and stump respiration in a subtropical pine plantation. Forest Ecology and Management 531, pages 120797.
Crossref
Pingfan Wei, Jinmin Chen, Yubao Duan, Yanfang Song, Zhijian Wang & Zhiyong Yuan. (2022) More accurate, consistent, and reliable data for amphibian species are needed from China's nature reserves. Conservation Science and Practice 5:2.
Crossref
Nigussie Haregeweyn, Atsushi Tsunekawa, Mitsuru Tsubo, Ayele Almaw Fenta, Kindiye Ebabu, Matthias Vanmaercke, Pasquale Borrelli, Panos Panagos, Mulatu Liyew Berihun, Eddy J. Langendoen, Zerihun Nigussie, Tadesual Asamin Setargie, Benedict Nzioki Maurice, Taye Minichil, Asres Elias, Jian Sun & Jean Poesen. (2023) Progress and challenges in sustainable land management initiatives: A global review. Science of The Total Environment 858, pages 160027.
Crossref
Cong Wang, Bojie Fu, Yihe Lü & Yunfei Liu. (2023) Socioeconomic development alters the effects of ‘green’ and ‘grain’ on evapotranspiration in China's loess plateau after the grain for green programme. Journal of Environmental Management 328, pages 117013.
Crossref
Jiameng Xu, Junhui Liu & Jixi Gao. (2023) Quantitative assessment of vegetation suitability in China based on carbon-water balance. Journal of Cleaner Production 387, pages 135735.
Crossref
Dongliang Dang, Xiaobing Li, Shengkun Li, Xiang Li, Xin Lyu, Huashun Dou, Mengyuan Li, Siyu Liu, Xiaojing Xuan & Kai Wang. (2022) Changing rural livelihood activities may reduce the effectiveness of ecological restoration projects. Land Degradation & Development 34:2, pages 362-376.
Crossref
Honghao Niu, Laurent Marquer, Dorothy Sack, Guizai Gao, Jiangyong Wang, Meng Meng & Dongmei Jie. (2023) Middle to late Holocene plant cover variation in relation to climate, fire, and human activity in the Songnen grasslands of northeastern China. Frontiers in Plant Science 13.
Crossref
Junjie Zhai, Ling Wang, Yuan Liu, Chengyuan Wang & Xuegang Mao. (2023) Assessing the effects of China's Three-North Shelter Forest Program over 40 years. Science of The Total Environment 857, pages 159354.
Crossref
Wenqi Song, Yuhao Feng & Zhiheng Wang. (2022) Ecological restoration programs dominate vegetation greening in China. Science of The Total Environment 848, pages 157729.
Crossref
Yue Liu, Huanhuan Liu, Yin Chen, Chengcheng Gang & Yifan Shen. (2022) Quantifying the contributions of climate change and human activities to vegetation dynamic in China based on multiple indices. Science of The Total Environment 838, pages 156553.
Crossref
Tiago Shizen Pacheco Toma & Elise Buisson. (2022) Taking cultural landscapes into account: Implications for scaling up ecological restoration. Land Use Policy 120, pages 106233.
Crossref
Renji Wu, Haiping Tang & Yunjing Lu. (2022) Exploring subjective well-being and ecosystem services perception in the agro-pastoral ecotone of northern China. Journal of Environmental Management 318, pages 115591.
Crossref
Junze Zhang, Shuai Wang, Prajal Pradhan, Wenwu Zhao & Bojie Fu. (2022) Mapping the complexity of the food-energy-water nexus from the lens of Sustainable Development Goals in China. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 183, pages 106357.
Crossref
Jianfeng Sun, Guangdong Li, Ying Zhang, Weishan Qin & Mengyao Wang. (2022) Identification of priority areas for afforestation in the Loess Plateau region of China. Ecological Indicators 140, pages 108998.
Crossref
Liang He, Jianbin Guo, Qunou Jiang, Ziyou Zhang & Songping Yu. (2022) How did the Chinese Loess Plateau turn green from 2001 to 2020? An explanation using satellite data. CATENA 214, pages 106246.
Crossref
Chen Gong, Qingyue Tan, Guobin Liu & Mingxiang Xu. (2022) Advantage of mixed trees in the trade-off between soil water storage and tree biomass: A meta-analysis from artificially planted forests in Chinese Loess Plateau. CATENA 214, pages 106232.
Crossref
Yuanjie Deng, Lei Jia, Yajun Guo, Hua Li, Shunbo Yao, Liqi Chu, Weinan Lu, Mengyang Hou, Binbin Mo, Yameng Wang, Haiyu Yang & Tongyue Zhang. (2022) Evaluation of the Ecological Effects of Ecological Restoration Programs: A Case Study of the Sloping Land Conversion Program on the Loess Plateau, China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19:13, pages 7841.
Crossref
Xin Chen, Le Yu, Zhenrong Du, Yidi Xu, Jiyao Zhao, Haile Zhao, Guoliang Zhang, Dailiang Peng & Peng Gong. (2022) Distribution of ecological restoration projects associated with land use and land cover change in China and their ecological impacts. Science of The Total Environment 825, pages 153938.
Crossref
Qing Yang, Gengyuan Liu, Feni Agostinho, Biagio F. Giannetti & Zhifeng Yang. (2022) Assessment of ecological restoration projects under water limits: Finding a balance between nature and human needs. Journal of Environmental Management 311, pages 114849.
Crossref
Jichuan Sheng & Hui Wang. (2022) Participation, income growth and poverty alleviation in payments for ecosystem services: The case of China's Wolong Nature Reserve. Ecological Economics 196, pages 107433.
Crossref
Chunhui Duan, Jinghao Li, Yanan Chen, Zhi Ding, Mingguo Ma, Jing Xie, Li Yao & Xuguang Tang. (2022) Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Terrestrial Vegetation and Its Driver Analysis over Southwest China from 1982 to 2015. Remote Sensing 14:10, pages 2497.
Crossref
Yuanjie Deng, Wencong Cai, Mengyang Hou, Xiaolong Zhang, Shiyuan Xu, Nan Yao, Yajun Guo, Hua Li & Shunbo Yao. (2022) How Eco-Efficiency Is the Forestry Ecological Restoration Program? The Case of the Sloping Land Conversion Program in the Loess Plateau, China. Land 11:5, pages 712.
Crossref
Gary J. Brierley, Meiqin Han, Xilai Li, Zhiwei Li & He Qing Huang. (2022) Geo‐eco‐hydrology of the Upper Yellow River. WIREs Water 9:3.
Crossref
Bojie Fu, Xutong Wu, Zhuangzhuang Wang, Xilin Wu & Shuai Wang. (2022) Coupling human and natural systems for sustainability: experience from China's Loess Plateau. Earth System Dynamics 13:2, pages 795-808.
Crossref
Haiyan Zheng, Chiyuan Miao, Xiaoyan Li, Dongxian Kong, Jiaojiao Gou, Jingwen Wu & Shuping Zhang. (2022) Effects of Vegetation Changes and Multiple Environmental Factors on Evapotranspiration Across China Over the Past 34 Years. Earth's Future 10:4.
Crossref
Haiwei Zhao, Chaoyang Wu & Xiaoyue Wang. (2022) Large-scale forest conservation and restoration programs significantly contributed to land surface greening in China. Environmental Research Letters 17:2, pages 024023.
Crossref
Ting Zhou, Weiwei Shen, Xiao Qiu, Hong Chang, Hongbo Yang & Wu Yang. (2022) Impact evaluation of a payments for ecosystem services program on vegetation quantity and quality restoration in Inner Mongolia. Journal of Environmental Management 303, pages 114113.
Crossref
Shijin Wang & Yanqiang Wei. (2022) Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau Greening and Human Well-Being Improving: The Role of Ecological Policies. Sustainability 14:3, pages 1652.
Crossref
Baohua Zhang, Daxiang Liu & Huaizhi Su. (2022) Single pullout experiment and reinforcement properties of basalt fiber in vegetation concrete. Scientific Reports 12:1.
Crossref
Xin GENG, Shi HU, Yu XIAO & Xun-ming WANG. (2022) Land use pattern optimization and evaluation based on ESV of agro-pastoral ecotone in Northeast China. JOURNAL OF NATURAL RESOURCES 37:7, pages 1799.
Crossref
Renfei Yang, Fu Ren, Wenxuan Xu, Xiangyuan Ma, Hongwei Zhang & Wenwen He. (2022) China's ecosystem service value in 1992–2018: Pattern and anthropogenic driving factors detection using Bayesian spatiotemporal hierarchy model. Journal of Environmental Management 302, pages 114089.
Crossref
Jian Li, Shuang Liu, Tao Hong, Weibin You & Xisheng Hu. (2021) Does leakage exist in China’s typical protected areas? Evidence from 13 national nature reserves. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 29:5, pages 6822-6836.
Crossref
Zhi Ding, Ying Liu, Lunche Wang, Yanan Chen, Pujia Yu, Mingguo Ma & Xuguang Tang. (2021) Effects and implications of ecological restoration projects on ecosystem water use efficiency in the karst region of Southwest China. Ecological Engineering 170, pages 106356.
Crossref
Yangyang Liu, Hanyu Ren, Cheng Zheng, Ronglei Zhou, Tianming Hu, Peizhi Yang, Wei Zhang, Zhenqian Wang, Yan Li, Zhaoying Zhang & Zhongming Wen. (2021) Untangling the effects of management measures, climate and land use cover change on grassland dynamics in the Qinghai–Tibet Plateau, China. Land Degradation & Development 32:17, pages 4974-4987.
Crossref
Xiaoyu Zhang, Duanyang Xu & Ziyu Wang. (2021) Optimizing spatial layout of afforestation to realize the maximum benefit of water resources in arid regions: A case study of Alxa, China. Journal of Cleaner Production 320, pages 128827.
Crossref
Chen Gong, Qingyue Tan, Guobin Liu & Mingxiang Xu. (2021) Impacts of tree mixtures on understory plant diversity in China. Forest Ecology and Management 498, pages 119545.
Crossref
Xutong Wu, Jianguo Liu, Bojie Fu, Shuai Wang & Yongping Wei. (2021) Integrating multiple influencing factors in evaluating the socioeconomic effects of payments for ecosystem services. Ecosystem Services 51, pages 101348.
Crossref
Hongliang Gu & Min Chen. (2021) Comprehensive Insights into Spatial-Temporal Evolution Patterns, Dominant Factors of NDVI from Pixel Scale, as a Case of Shaanxi Province, China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 18:19, pages 10053.
Crossref
Yangyang Liu, Ronglei Zhou, Hanyu Ren, Wei Zhang, Zhixin Zhang, Zhaoying Zhang & Zhongming Wen. (2021) Evaluating the dynamics of grassland net primary productivity in response to climate change in China. Global Ecology and Conservation 28, pages e01574.
Crossref
Xin Xu & Daojun Zhang. (2021) Evaluating the effect of ecological policies from the pattern change of persistent green patches–A case study of Yan'an in China's Loess Plateau. Ecological Informatics 63, pages 101305.
Crossref
Xutong Wu, Shuai Wang & Bojie Fu. (2021) Multilevel analysis of factors affecting participants’ land reconversion willingness after the Grain for Green Program. Ambio 50:7, pages 1394-1403.
Crossref
Chen Gong, Qingyue Tan, Guobin Liu & Mingxiang Xu. (2020) Mixed-species plantations enhance soil carbon stocks on the loess plateau of China. Plant and Soil 464:1-2, pages 13-28.
Crossref
Kelil Siraj, Taye Sisay, Negeyo Desta, Seboka Feyisa, Agonafer Hayleyesus, Negash Tadessa & Kusa Bultu. (2021) Evaluation of selected multipurpose tree species and moisture conservation structures for degraded dryland rehabilitation in Dugda Dawa District, Southern Ethiopia. Journal of Horticulture and Forestry 13:2, pages 58-68.
Crossref
Xuemei Zhang, Yuemin Yue, Xiaowei Tong, Kelin Wang, Xiangkun Qi, Chuxiong Deng & Martin Brandt. (2021) Eco-engineering controls vegetation trends in southwest China karst. Science of The Total Environment 770, pages 145160.
Crossref
Zhi Ding, Hui Zheng, Ying Liu, Sidong Zeng, Pujia Yu, Wei Shi & Xuguang Tang. (2021) Spatiotemporal Patterns of Ecosystem Restoration Activities and Their Effects on Changes in Terrestrial Gross Primary Production in Southwest China. Remote Sensing 13:6, pages 1209.
Crossref
Zihao Ma, Jiahong Guo, Weiming Li, Zhaoyang Cai & Shixiong Cao. (2021) Regional differences in the factors that affect vegetation cover in China. Land Degradation & Development 32:5, pages 1961-1969.
Crossref
Léa Kervroëdan, Romain Armand, Freddy Rey & Michel‐Pierre Faucon. (2020) Trait‐based sediment retention and runoff control by herbaceous vegetation in agricultural catchments: A review. Land Degradation & Development 32:3, pages 1077-1089.
Crossref
Li Yurui, Zhang Xuanchang, Cao Zhi, Liu Zhengjia, Lu Zhi & Liu Yansui. (2021) Towards the progress of ecological restoration and economic development in China's Loess Plateau and strategy for more sustainable development. Science of The Total Environment 756, pages 143676.
Crossref
Chen Gong, Qingyue Tan, Guobin Liu & Mingxiang Xu. (2021) Forest thinning increases soil carbon stocks in China. Forest Ecology and Management 482, pages 118812.
Crossref
Duanyang Xu & Dajing Li. (2020) Variation of wind erosion and its response to ecological programs in northern China in the period 1981–2015. Land Use Policy 99, pages 104871.
Crossref
Diwen Cai, Quansheng Ge, Xunming Wang, Baoli Liu, Andrew S Goudie & Shi Hu. (2020) Contributions of ecological programs to vegetation restoration in arid and semiarid China. Environmental Research Letters 15:11, pages 114046.
Crossref
Qingfu Liu, Qing Zhang, Yongzhi Yan, Xuefeng Zhang, Jianming Niu & Jens-Christian Svenning. (2020) Ecological restoration is the dominant driver of the recent reversal of desertification in the Mu Us Desert (China). Journal of Cleaner Production 268, pages 122241.
Crossref
Haiwei Zhao, Ruidong Wu, Jinming Hu, Feiling Yang, Junjun Wang, Yang Guo, Jian Zhou, Yiting Wang, Chen Zhang & Zhixue Feng. (2020) The contrasting east–west pattern of vegetation restoration under the large‐scale ecological restoration programmes in southwest China. Land Degradation & Development 31:13, pages 1688-1698.
Crossref
Chao Ding, Wenjiang Huang, Yao Li, Shuang Zhao & Fang Huang. (2020) Nonlinear Changes in Dryland Vegetation Greenness over East Inner Mongolia, China, in Recent Years from Satellite Time Series. Sensors 20:14, pages 3839.
Crossref
Xin Wen & Lin Zhen. (2020) Soil erosion control practices in the Chinese Loess Plateau: A systematic review. Environmental Development 34, pages 100493.
Crossref
Le Yin, Erfu Dai, Du Zheng, Yahui Wang, Liang Ma & Miao Tong. (2020) What drives the vegetation dynamics in the Hengduan Mountain region, southwest China: Climate change or human activity?. Ecological Indicators 112, pages 106013.
Crossref
Gaojuan Zhao, Youxin Shen, Wenyao Liu, Beilin Tan, Zhenjiang Li & Qinghe Wang. (2020) Quantifying the effect of shading and watering on seed germination in translocated forest topsoil at a subtropical karst of China. Forest Ecology and Management 459, pages 117811.
Crossref
Wei Zhou, Jianlong Li & Tianxiang YueWei Zhou, Jianlong Li & Tianxiang Yue. 2020. Remote Sensing Monitoring and Evaluation of Degraded Grassland in China. Remote Sensing Monitoring and Evaluation of Degraded Grassland in China 83 104 .
Siqi Yang, Wenwu Zhao, Paulo Pereira & Yanxu Liu. (2019) Socio-cultural valuation of rural and urban perception on ecosystem services and human well-being in Yanhe watershed of China. Journal of Environmental Management 251, pages 109615.
Crossref
Chen Qian, Liqun Shao, Xianhui Hou, Bangbang Zhang, Wei Chen & Xianli Xia. (2019) Detection and attribution of vegetation greening trend across distinct local landscapes under China's Grain to Green Program: A case study in Shaanxi Province. CATENA 183, pages 104182.
Crossref
Yangyang Liu, Zhaoying Zhang, Linjing Tong, Muhammad Khalifa, Qian Wang, Chengcheng Gang, Zhenqian Wang, Jianlong Li & Zhengguo Sun. (2019) Assessing the effects of climate variation and human activities on grassland degradation and restoration across the globe. Ecological Indicators 106, pages 105504.
Crossref
Wenqing Li, John Aloysius Zinda & Zhiming Zhang. (2019) Does the “Returning Farmland to Forest Program” Drive Community-Level Changes in Landscape Patterns in China?. Forests 10:10, pages 933.
Crossref
Xutong Wu, Shuai Wang, Bojie Fu, Yan Zhao & Yongping Wei. (2019) Pathways from payments for ecosystem services program to socioeconomic outcomes. Ecosystem Services 39, pages 101005.
Crossref
Dajing Li & Duanyang Xu. (2019) Sand fixation function response to climate change and land use in northern China from 1981 to 2015. Aeolian Research 40, pages 23-33.
Crossref
Panlong Wu, Jan C. Axmacher, Xuedong Li, Xiao Song, Zhenrong Yu, Huanli Xu, Teja Tscharntke, Catrin Westphal & Yunhui Liu. (2019) Contrasting effects of natural shrubland and plantation forests on bee assemblages at neighboring apple orchards in Beijing, China. Biological Conservation 237, pages 456-462.
Crossref
Jie Pei, Li Wang, Xiaoyue Wang, Zheng Niu, Maggi Kelly, Xiao-Peng Song, Ni Huang, Jing Geng, Haifeng Tian, Yang Yu, Shiguang Xu, Lei Wang, Qing Ying & Jianhua Cao. (2019) Time Series of Landsat Imagery Shows Vegetation Recovery in Two Fragile Karst Watersheds in Southwest China from 1988 to 2016. Remote Sensing 11:17, pages 2044.
Crossref
Haibo Zheng, Liwei Zhang, Pengtao Wang & Yingjie Li. (2019) The NPP-Based Composite Indicator for Assessing the Variations of Water Provision Services at the National Scale. Water 11:8, pages 1628.
Crossref
Jun Ma, Xiangming Xiao, Renhui Miao, Yao Li, Bangqian Chen, Yao Zhang & Bin Zhao. (2019) Trends and controls of terrestrial gross primary productivity of China during 2000–2016. Environmental Research Letters 14:8, pages 084032.
Crossref
Xutong Wu, Shuai Wang, Bojie Fu, Xiaoming Feng & Yongzhe Chen. (2019) Socio-ecological changes on the Loess Plateau of China after Grain to Green Program. Science of The Total Environment 678, pages 565-573.
Crossref
Yangying Liu, Shang Wang, Zhujun Wang, Zhaojing Zhang, Huayu Qin, Ziyan Wei, Kai Feng, Shuzhen Li, Yueni Wu, Huaqun Yin, Hui Li & Ye Deng. (2019) Soil microbiome mediated nutrients decline during forest degradation process. Soil Ecology Letters 1:1-2, pages 59-71.
Crossref
Wangya Han, Guohua Liu, Xukun Su, Xing Wu & Li Chen. (2019) Assessment of potential land degradation and recommendations for management in the south subtropical region, Southwest China. Land Degradation & Development 30:8, pages 979-990.
Crossref
Wenjia Peng, Brian E. Robinson, Hua Zheng, Cong Li, Fengchun Wang & Ruonan Li. (2019) Telecoupled Sustainable Livelihoods in an Era of Rural–Urban Dynamics: The Case of China. Sustainability 11:9, pages 2716.
Crossref
Maokui Lyu, Jinsheng Xie, Christian P. Giardina, Matthew A. Vadeboncoeur, Xiaojuan Feng, Minhuang Wang, Liisa Ukonmaanaho, Teng-Chiu Lin, Yakov Kuzyakov & Yusheng Yang. (2019) Understory ferns alter soil carbon chemistry and increase carbon storage during reforestation with native pine on previously degraded sites. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 132, pages 80-92.
Crossref
Wei Weng, Luís Costa, Matthias K.B. Lüdeke & Delphine C. Zemp. (2019) Aerial river management by smart cross-border reforestation. Land Use Policy 84, pages 105-113.
Crossref
Jing Zhang, Colin Brown, Guanghua Qiao & Bao Zhang. (2019) Effect of Eco-compensation Schemes on Household Income Structures and Herder Satisfaction: Lessons From the Grassland Ecosystem Subsidy and Award Scheme in Inner Mongolia. Ecological Economics 159, pages 46-53.
Crossref
Yizhao Chen, Weimin Ju, Shaojie Mu, Xinran Fei, Yuan Cheng, Pavel Propastin, Wei Zhou, Cuijuan Liao, Luxiao Chen, Rongjun Tang, Jiaguo Qi, Jianlong Li & Honghua Ruan. (2019) Explicit Representation of Grazing Activity in a Diagnostic Terrestrial Model: A Data‐Process Combined Scheme. Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems 11:4, pages 957-978.
Crossref
Bo Jiang, Yang Bai, Christina P. Wong, Xibao Xu & Juha M. Alatalo. (2019) China’s ecological civilization program–Implementing ecological redline policy. Land Use Policy 81, pages 111-114.
Crossref
Yang Xiao & Zhiyun Ouyang. (2018) Spatial-temporal Patterns and Driving Forces of Water Retention Service in China. Chinese Geographical Science 29:1, pages 100-111.
Crossref
Qi Feng, Chengqi Xia, Wenping Yuan, Li Chen, Yafeng Wang & Shixiong Cao. (2019) Targeted control measures for improving the environment in a semiarid region of China. Journal of Cleaner Production 206, pages 477-482.
Crossref
Ping Liu, Runsheng Yin & Minjuan Zhao. (2019) Reformulating China's ecological restoration policies: What can be learned from comparing Chinese and American experiences?. Forest Policy and Economics 98, pages 54-61.
Crossref
Chun Feng, Zhe Wang, Yan Ma, Songling Fu & Han Y.H. Chen. (2019) Increased litterfall contributes to carbon and nitrogen accumulation following cessation of anthropogenic disturbances in degraded forests. Forest Ecology and Management 432, pages 832-839.
Crossref
Jingyong Ma, Tianshan Zha, Xin Jia, Yun Tian, Charles P.-A. Bourque, Peng Liu, Yujie Bai, Yajuan Wu, Cai Ren, Haiqun Yu, Feng Zhang, Caixian Zhou & Wenjing Chen. (2018) Energy and water vapor exchange over a young plantation in northern China. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 263, pages 334-345.
Crossref
Lishan Shan, Xiang Yu, Lingxiao Sun, Bin He, Haiyan Wang & Tingting Xie. (2018) Seasonal differences in climatic controls of vegetation growth in the Beijing–Tianjin Sand Source Region of China. Journal of Arid Land 10:6, pages 850-863.
Crossref
Enkhjargal Volodya, Min Yeo & Yong Kim. (2018) Trends of Ecological Footprints and Policy Direction for Sustainable Development in Mongolia: A Case Study. Sustainability 10:11, pages 4026.
Crossref
Yi Xi, Shushi Peng, Philippe Ciais, Matthieu Guimberteau, Yue Li, Shilong Piao, Xuhui Wang, Jan Polcher, Jiashuo Yu, Xuanze Zhang, Feng Zhou, Yan Bo, Catherine Ottle & Zun Yin. (2018) Contributions of Climate Change, CO2, Land-Use Change, and Human Activities to Changes in River Flow across 10 Chinese Basins. Journal of Hydrometeorology 19:11, pages 1899-1914.
Crossref
Jianjun Cao, Xiaofang Zhang, Ravinesh Deo, Yifan Gong & Qi Feng. (2018) Influence of stand type and stand age on soil carbon storage in China’s arid and semi-arid regions. Land Use Policy 78, pages 258-265.
Crossref
Xin Cheng, Chuanmin Shuai, Jiali Liu, Jing Wang, Yue Liu, Wenjing Li & Jing Shuai. (2018) Topic modelling of ecology, environment and poverty nexus: An integrated framework. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 267, pages 1-14.
Crossref
Lin Huang, Wei Cao, Xinliang Xu, Jiangwen Fan & Junbang Wang. (2018) Linking the benefits of ecosystem services to sustainable spatial planning of ecological conservation strategies. Journal of Environmental Management 222, pages 385-395.
Crossref
Fandjinou Kossi, Zhang Kebin, Folega Fousseni & Yang Xiaohui. (2018) Sustainable land management and ecological service assessment in Northwest of China: Case study of Yanchi, Peoples Republic of China. African Journal of Agricultural Research 13:31, pages 1551-1563.
Crossref
Brett A. Bryan, Lei Gao, Yanqiong Ye, Xiufeng Sun, Jeffery D. Connor, Neville D. Crossman, Mark Stafford-Smith, Jianguo Wu, Chunyang He, Deyong Yu, Zhifeng Liu, Ang Li, Qingxu Huang, Hai Ren, Xiangzheng Deng, Hua Zheng, Jianming Niu, Guodong Han & Xiangyang Hou. (2018) China’s response to a national land-system sustainability emergency. Nature 559:7713, pages 193-204.
Crossref
Martin Brandt, Yuemin Yue, Jean Pierre Wigneron, Xiaowei Tong, Feng Tian, Martin Rudbeck Jepsen, Xiangming Xiao, Aleixandre Verger, Arnaud Mialon, Amen Al-Yaari, Kelin Wang & Rasmus Fensholt. (2018) Satellite-Observed Major Greening and Biomass Increase in South China Karst During Recent Decade. Earth's Future 6:7, pages 1017-1028.
Crossref
Junze Zhang, Luo Mengting, Yue Hui, Chen Xiyun & Feng Chong. (2018) Critical thresholds in ecological restoration to achieve optimal ecosystem services: An analysis based on forest ecosystem restoration projects in China. Land Use Policy 76, pages 675-678.
Crossref
Genowefa Blundo-Canto, Vincent Bax, Marcela Quintero, Gisella S. Cruz-Garcia, Rolf A. Groeneveld & Lisset Perez-Marulanda. (2018) The Different Dimensions of Livelihood Impacts of Payments for Environmental Services (PES) Schemes: A Systematic Review. Ecological Economics 149, pages 160-183.
Crossref
Fan Yang, Yan Gao, Lili Sun, Shuaishuai Zhang, Jiaojiao Li & Ying Zhang. (2018) Effective sorption of atrazine by biochar colloids and residues derived from different pyrolysis temperatures. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 25:19, pages 18528-18539.
Crossref
Haiyan Zhang, Jiangwen Fan, Wei Cao, Huaping Zhong, Warwick Harris, Guoli Gong & Yaxian Zhang. (2018) Changes in multiple ecosystem services between 2000 and 2013 and their driving factors in the Grazing Withdrawal Program, China. Ecological Engineering 116, pages 67-79.
Crossref
Nannan Li, Dorothy Sack, Guizai Gao, Lidan Liu, Dehui Li, Xiuyun Yang, Dongmei Jie, Hongyan Liu, Jichen Shi & Chengcheng Leng. (2017) Holocene Artemisia -Chenopodiaceae-dominated grassland in North China: Real or imaginary? . The Holocene 28:5, pages 834-841.
Crossref
Juan F. Fernández‐Manjarrés, Samuel Roturier & Anne‐Gaël Bilhaut. (2018) The emergence of the social‐ecological restoration concept. Restoration Ecology 26:3, pages 404-410.
Crossref
Tadele Demisachew, Moges Awdenegest & Dananto Mihret. (2018) Impact evaluation on survival of tree seedling using selected in situ rainwater harvesting methods in Gerduba Watershed, Borana Zone, Ethiopia. Journal of Horticulture and Forestry 10:4, pages 43-51.
Crossref
Yang Xiao & Qiang Xiao. (2018) Identifying key areas of ecosystem services potential to improve ecological management in Chongqing City, southwest China. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 190:4.
Crossref
Siegmund Missall, Abdulla Abliz, Ümüt Halik, Niels Thevs & Martin Welp. (2018) Trading Natural Riparian Forests for Urban Shelterbelt Plantations—A Sustainability Assessment of the Kökyar Protection Forest in NW China. Water 10:3, pages 343.
Crossref
Xiu Cheng, Ruyin Long & Hong Chen. (2017) Obstacle diagnosis of green competition promotion: a case study of provinces in China based on catastrophe progression and fuzzy rough set methods. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 25:5, pages 4344-4360.
Crossref
Lulu Zhang & Kai Schwärzel. (2017) China’s Land Resources Dilemma: Problems, Outcomes, and Options for Sustainable Land Restoration. Sustainability 9:12, pages 2362.
Crossref
Chun Feng, Yan Ma, Songling Fu & Han Y.H. Chen. (2017) Soil Carbon and Nutrient Dynamics Following Cessation of Anthropogenic Disturbances in Degraded Subtropical Forests. Land Degradation & Development 28:8, pages 2457-2467.
Crossref
Lei Ma, Chunyu Shen, Duo Lou, Shenglei Fu & Dongsheng Guan. (2017) Patterns of ecosystem carbon density in edge-affected fengshui forests. Ecological Engineering 107, pages 216-223.
Crossref
Qiang Xiao, Jianping Tao, Yang Xiao & Feng Qian. (2017) Monitoring vegetation cover in Chongqing between 2001 and 2010 using remote sensing data. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 189:10.
Crossref
Shu Hu, Yujin Li, Wanzhong Wang, Juying Jiao, Meng Kou, Qiulong Yin & Haiyan Xu. (2017) The antioxidation-related functional structure of plant communities: Understanding antioxidation at the plant community level. Ecological Indicators 78, pages 98-107.
Crossref
Yifan Song, Zhongxiao Guo, Yajing Lu, Denghua Yan, Zilong Liao, Huiwen Liu & Yingjie Cui. (2017) Pixel-Level Spatiotemporal Analyses of Vegetation Fractional Coverage Variation and Its Influential Factors in a Desert Steppe: A Case Study in Inner Mongolia, China. Water 9:7, pages 478.
Crossref
Shixiong Cao, Di Shang, Hui Yue & Hua Ma. (2017) A win-win strategy for ecological restoration and biodiversity conservation in Southern China. Environmental Research Letters 12:4, pages 044004.
Crossref
Xiaowei Tong, Kelin Wang, Yuemin Yue, Martin Brandt, Bo Liu, Chunhua Zhang, Chujie Liao & Rasmus Fensholt. (2017) Quantifying the effectiveness of ecological restoration projects on long-term vegetation dynamics in the karst regions of Southwest China. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 54, pages 105-113.
Crossref
Rattan Lal. 2017. Encyclopedia of Soil Science, Third Edition. Encyclopedia of Soil Science, Third Edition 804 810 .
Lin Zhen & Jie Hu. 2017. Multifunctional Land-Use Systems for Managing the Nexus of Environmental Resources. Multifunctional Land-Use Systems for Managing the Nexus of Environmental Resources 29 51 .
Wei Liu, Cheng Peng, Zhifen Chen, Yue Liu, Juan Yan, Jianqiang Li & Tao Sang. (2016) Sustainable bioenergy production with little carbon debt in the Loess Plateau of China. Biotechnology for Biofuels 9:1.
Crossref
Junyi Zhang, Minghong Dai, Lachun Wang & Weici Su. (2016) Household livelihood change under the rocky desertification control project in karst areas, Southwest China. Land Use Policy 56, pages 8-15.
Crossref
Yi Zou, Weiguo Sang, Eleanor Warren-Thomas & Jan Christoph Axmacher. (2016) Geometrid moth assemblages reflect high conservation value of naturally regenerated secondary forests in temperate China. Forest Ecology and Management 374, pages 111-118.
Crossref
Yang Gao, Guirui Yu, Tiantian Yang, Yanlong Jia, Nianpeng He & Jie Zhuang. (2016) New insight into global blue carbon estimation under human activity in land-sea interaction area: A case study of China. Earth-Science Reviews 159, pages 36-46.
Crossref
Qirui Li, T. Amjath-Babu, Peter Zander, Zhen Liu & Klaus Müller. (2016) Sustainability of Smallholder Agriculture in Semi-Arid Areas under Land Set-aside Programs: A Case Study from China’s Loess Plateau. Sustainability 8:4, pages 395.
Crossref
Feng-Rui Li, Ji-Liang Liu, Te-Sheng Sun, Ling-Fa Ma, Lu-Lu Liu & Kun Yang. (2016) Impact of established shrub shelterbelts around oases on the diversity of ground beetles in arid ecosystems of Northwestern China. Insect Conservation and Diversity 9:2, pages 135-148.
Crossref
Anna Tengberg, Frank Radstake, Kebin Zhang & Bruce Dunn. (2014) Scaling up of Sustainable Land Management in the Western People's Republic of China: Evaluation of a 10‐Year Partnership. Land Degradation & Development 27:2, pages 134-144.
Crossref
Peng Tian, Xingmin Mu, Jianli Liu, Jinfei Hu & Chaojun Gu. (2016) Impacts of Climate Variability and Human Activities on the Changes of Runoff and Sediment Load in a Catchment of the Loess Plateau, China. Advances in Meteorology 2016, pages 1-15.
Crossref
Qi Feng, Hua Ma, Xuemei Jiang, Xin Wang & Shixiong Cao. (2015) What Has Caused Desertification in China?. Scientific Reports 5:1.
Crossref
Hongyan Cai, Xiaohuan Yang & Xinliang Xu. (2015) Human-induced grassland degradation/restoration in the central Tibetan Plateau: The effects of ecological protection and restoration projects. Ecological Engineering 83, pages 112-119.
Crossref
Lihe Yin, Yangxiao Zhou, Jinting Huang, Jochen Wenninger, Eryong Zhang, Guangcai Hou & Jiaqiu Dong. (2015) Interaction between groundwater and trees in an arid site: Potential impacts of climate variation and groundwater abstraction on trees. Journal of Hydrology 528, pages 435-448.
Crossref
Shixiong Cao & Junze Zhang. (2015) Political risks arising from the impacts of large-scale afforestation on water resources of the Tibetan Plateau. Gondwana Research 28:2, pages 898-903.
Crossref
Huoxing Zhu, Bojie Fu, Shuai Wang, Linhai Zhu, Liwei Zhang, Lei Jiao & Cong Wang. (2015) Reducing soil erosion by improving community functional diversity in semi-arid grasslands. Journal of Applied Ecology 52:4, pages 1063-1072.
Crossref
Zi-Qiang Yuan, Howard Epstein & Feng-Min Li. (2015) Factors affecting the recovery of abandoned semi-arid fields after legume introduction on the Loess Plateau. Ecological Engineering 79, pages 86-93.
Crossref
Mingyong Zhu. (2014) Soil erosion assessment using USLE in the GIS environment: a case study in the Danjiangkou Reservoir Region, China. Environmental Earth Sciences 73:12, pages 7899-7908.
Crossref
B. Cheng, Y. Lv, Y. Zhan, D. Su & S. Cao. (2013) Constructing China's Roads as Works of Art: A Case Study of “Esthetic Greenway” Construction in the Shennongjia Region of China. Land Degradation & Development 26:4, pages 324-330.
Crossref
Jun Yang, Guanghui Dai & Shurong Wang. (2015) China’s National Monitoring Program on Ecological Functions of Forests: An Analysis of the Protocol and Initial Results. Forests 6:12, pages 809-826.
Crossref
D. H. Mao, Z. M. Wang, L. Li, Z. H. Miao, W. H. Ma, C. C. Song, C. Y. Ren & M. M. Jia. (2015) Soil organic carbon in the Sanjiang Plain of China: storage, distribution and controlling factors. Biogeosciences 12:6, pages 1635-1645.
Crossref
Qiaoling Yan, Jiaojun Zhu, Xiao Zheng & Changjie Jin. (2015) Causal effects of shelter forests and water factors on desertification control during 2000–2010 at the Horqin Sandy Land region, China. Journal of Forestry Research 26:1, pages 33-45.
Crossref
Heran Zheng & Shixiong Cao. (2014) Threats to China’s Biodiversity by Contradictions Policy. AMBIO 44:1, pages 23-33.
Crossref
Qi Feng, Feng-Rui Li, Ji-Liang Liu, Te-Sheng Sun & Li-Juan Chen. (2014) Ground-dwelling arthropod community response to native grassland conversion in a temperate desert of northwestern China. Journal of Insect Conservation 19:1, pages 105-117.
Crossref
Yi Zou, Weiguo Sang, Shunzhong Wang, Eleanor Warren-Thomas, Yunhui Liu, Zhenrong Yu, Changliu Wang & Jan Christoph Axmacher. (2015) Diversity patterns of ground beetles and understory vegetation in mature, secondary, and plantation forest regions of temperate northern China. Ecology and Evolution 5:3, pages 531-542.
Crossref
Yafeng Wang, Liding Chen, Yang Gao, Shuai Wang, Yihe Lü & Bojie Fu. (2014) Carbon Sequestration Function of Check-Dams: A Case Study of the Loess Plateau in China. AMBIO 43:7, pages 926-931.
Crossref
Runsheng Yin, Can Liu, Minjuan Zhao, Shunbo Yao & Hao Liu. (2014) The implementation and impacts of China's largest payment for ecosystem services program as revealed by longitudinal household data. Land Use Policy 40, pages 45-55.
Crossref
Adam M. Komarek, Xiaoping Shi & Nico Heerink. (2014) Household-level effects of China's Sloping Land Conversion Program under price and policy shifts. Land Use Policy 40, pages 36-44.
Crossref
Yang Gao, Xianjin Zhu, Guirui Yu, Nianpeng He, Qiufeng Wang & Jing Tian. (2014) Water use efficiency threshold for terrestrial ecosystem carbon sequestration in China under afforestation. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 195-196, pages 32-37.
Crossref
H. J. König, L. Zhen, K. Helming, S. Uthes, L. Yang, X. Cao & H. Wiggering. (2014) ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF THE SLOPING LAND CONVERSION PROGRAMME ON RURAL SUSTAINABILITY IN GUYUAN, WESTERN CHINA. Land Degradation & Development 25:4, pages 385-396.
Crossref
Lihe Yin, Yangxiao Zhou, Jinting Huang, Jochen Wenninger, Guangcai Hou, Eryong Zhang, Xiaoyong Wang, Jiaqiu Dong, Jun Zhang & Stefan Uhlenbrook. (2013) Dynamics of willow tree (Salix matsudana) water use and its response to environmental factors in the semi-arid Hailiutu River catchment, Northwest China. Environmental Earth Sciences 71:12, pages 4997-5006.
Crossref
Wei Liu, Jia Mi, Zhihong Song, Juan Yan, Jianqiang Li & Tao Sang. (2014) Long-term water balance and sustainable production of Miscanthus energy crops in the Loess Plateau of China. Biomass and Bioenergy 62, pages 47-57.
Crossref
Zhisheng An, Youbin Sun, Hong Chang, Peizhen Zhang, Xiaodong Liu, Yanjun Cai, Zhangdong Jin, Xiaoke Qiang, Weijian Zhou, Li Li, Zhengguo Shi, Liangcheng Tan, Xiaoqiang Li, Xinbao Zhang & Zhao Jin. 2014. Late Cenozoic Climate Change in Asia. Late Cenozoic Climate Change in Asia 491 581 .
G. Singh, D. Mishra, K. Singh & R. Parmar. (2013) Effects of rainwater harvesting on plant growth, soil water dynamics and herbaceous biomass during rehabilitation of degraded hills in Rajasthan, India. Forest Ecology and Management 310, pages 612-622.
Crossref
Chunyan Luo, Li Chen, Hui Zhao, Suoyan Guo & Guosheng Wang. (2013) Challenges facing socioeconomic development as a result of China's environmental problems, and future prospects. Ecological Engineering 60, pages 199-203.
Crossref
Hua Ma, Yunqi Wang, Hui Yue & Binglin Zhong. (2013) The threshold between natural recovery and the need for artificial restoration in degraded lands in Fujian Province, China. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 185:10, pages 8639-8648.
Crossref
G.S. Li, J.J. Qu, Q.J. Han, H.Y. Fang & W.F. Wang. (2013) Responses of three typical plants to wind erosion in the shrub belts atop Mogao Grottoes, China. Ecological Engineering 57, pages 293-296.
Crossref
Yang Gao, Guirui Yu & Nianpeng He. (2013) Equilibration of the terrestrial water, nitrogen, and carbon cycles: Advocating a health threshold for carbon storage. Ecological Engineering 57, pages 366-374.
Crossref
Binglin Zhong, Shaoyun Peng, Qiao Zhang, Hua Ma & Shixiong Cao. (2013) Using an ecological economics approach to support the restoration of collapsing gullies in southern China. Land Use Policy 32, pages 119-124.
Crossref
Li Chen & Shixiong Cao. (2013) Lack of integrated solutions hinders environmental recovery in China. Ecological Engineering 54, pages 233-235.
Crossref
Wenying Jiang, Yufen Cheng, Xiaoxiao Yang & Shiling Yang. (2013) Chinese Loess Plateau vegetation since the Last Glacial Maximum and its implications for vegetation restoration. Journal of Applied Ecology 50:2, pages 440-448.
Crossref
Xinglian Wang, Yunqi Wang & Yujie Wang. (2013) Use of exotic species during ecological restoration can produce effects that resemble vegetation invasions and other unintended consequences. Ecological Engineering 52, pages 247-251.
Crossref
Haiyun Chen, Ganesh Shivakoti, Ting Zhu & David Maddox. (2011) Livelihood Sustainability and Community Based Co-Management of Forest Resources in China: Changes and Improvement. Environmental Management 49:1, pages 219-228.
Crossref
Minghua Zhang & Jianming Xu. (2011) Nonpoint Source Pollution, Environmental Quality, and Ecosystem Health in China: Introduction to the Special Section. Journal of Environmental Quality 40:6, pages 1685-1694.
Crossref
WenQi Song, Yuhao Feng & Zhiheng Wang. (2022) Ecological Restoration Programs Dominate Vegetation Greening in China. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Stephen Howes & Paul Wyrwoll. (2012) Asia’s Wicked Environmental Problems. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.