Advanced search
Publication Cover
International Peacekeeping Volume 23, 2016 - Issue 2
Submit an article Journal homepage
5,442
Views
99
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

The fallacy of constructing hybrid political orders: a reappraisal of the hybrid turn in peacebuilding

Roger Mac GintyCorrespondence[email protected]
&
Oliver Richmond
Pages 219-239 | Published online: 05 Nov 2015

Citations (99)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (49)

Lydia Letsch. (2023) Preventing/countering violent and hateful extremism in Morocco and Tunisia – understanding the role of civil society and international assistance. Conflict, Security & Development 23:5, pages 483-500.
Read now
Katelyn Cassin & Benjamin Zyla. (2023) UN Reforms for an Era of Pragmatic Peacekeeping. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 17:3, pages 294-312.
Read now
Charles T. Hunt. (2023) How Many Turns Make a Revolution? Whither the ‘Dialogue of the Deaf’ Between Peacebuilding Scholars and Practitioners. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 0:0, pages 1-18.
Read now
Ivan Gusic. (2022) Peace between Peace(s)? Urban Peace and the Coexistence of Antagonists in City Spaces. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 16:5, pages 619-640.
Read now
Anthony Ware & Costas Laoutides. (2021) Whose analysis? Trial of a new participatory conflict analysis for Do No Harm/conflict-sensitive development planning. Conflict, Security & Development 21:5, pages 673-696.
Read now
'Funmi Olonisakin, Alagaw Ababu Kifle & Alfred Muteru. (2021) Shifting ideas of sustainable peace towards conversation in state-building. Conflict, Security & Development 21:4, pages 409-430.
Read now
Ryo Uchida. (2021) Where does hybridity originate? Interfacing between local and international actors in Sri Lankan postconflict peacebuilding. Contemporary South Asia 29:3, pages 343-357.
Read now
Gearoid Millar. (2021) Trans-Scalar Ethnographic Peace Research: Understanding the Invisible Drivers of Complex Conflict and Complex Peace. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 15:3, pages 289-308.
Read now
Mona Lilja & Mikael Baaz. (2021) The unfortunate omission of entangled resistance in the ‘local turn’ in peace-building: the case of ‘forced marriage’ in the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC). Conflict, Security & Development 21:3, pages 273-292.
Read now
Cathy A. Wilcock. (2021) From Hybridity to Networked Relationality: Actors, Ideologies and the Legacies of Sudan’s Comprehensive Peace Agreement. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 15:2, pages 221-243.
Read now
Holly Dunn. (2021) Emergent Hybrid Legality: A Study of Legal Encounters in the DRC. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 15:2, pages 201-220.
Read now
Cathy A. Wilcock. (2020) Hybridising diasporic resistance to homeland peacebuilding: a case study of UK Sudanese activists and Sudanese peace. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 46:11, pages 2443-2461.
Read now
Nicole George$suffix/text()$suffix/text() & Pauline Soaki$suffix/text()$suffix/text(). (2020) “Our struggle, our cry, our sweat”: challenging the gendered logics of participation and conflict transition in Solomon Islands. International Feminist Journal of Politics 22:4, pages 572-593.
Read now
Justin Williams. (2020) The ‘Ethnographic Turn’ in Peacebuilding: Emancipation, Emotion, and Ethics. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 14:3, pages 459-463.
Read now
Anine Hagemann. (2020) Understanding intervention through multiplicity: protection politics in South Sudan. Globalizations 17:3, pages 498-515.
Read now
Pol Bargués-Pedreny. (2020) Resilience is “always more” than our practices: Limits, critiques, and skepticism about international intervention. Contemporary Security Policy 41:2, pages 263-286.
Read now
Lou Pingeot. (2020) International Peacebuilding as a Case of Structural Injustice. International Peacekeeping 27:2, pages 263-288.
Read now
Roberta Holanda Maschietto. (2020) Integrating subjectivities of power and violence in peacebuilding analysis. Third World Quarterly 41:3, pages 379-396.
Read now
Funs Titulaer & Martijn Kitzen. (2020) The Population-Centric Turn in Special Operations: A Possible Way Ahead for SOF Informed by a Cross-Disciplinary Analysis of State-Building Interventions. Special Operations Journal 6:1, pages 35-54.
Read now
Dahlia Simangan. (2020) A Case for a Normative Local Involvement in Post-Conflict Peacebuilding. International Peacekeeping 27:1, pages 77-101.
Read now
Patricia Sellick. (2019) ‘Boots on the ground’: walking in occupied Palestinian territory. Mobilities 14:6, pages 875-889.
Read now
Roberto Belloni & Francesco N. Moro. (2019) Stability and Stability Operations: Definitions, Drivers, Approaches. Ethnopolitics 18:5, pages 445-461.
Read now
Catherine Goetze. (2019) Learning in Peacebuilding – Mission Impossible?. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 13:3, pages 340-356.
Read now
Volker Boege & Patricia Rinck. (2019) The Local/International Interface in Peacebuilding: Experiences from Bougainville and Sierra Leone. International Peacekeeping 26:2, pages 216-239.
Read now
Xavier Mathieu. (2019) Critical peacebuilding and the dilemma of difference: the stigma of the ‘local’ and the quest for equality. Third World Quarterly 40:1, pages 36-52.
Read now
Rowan Popplewell. (2019) Civil society, hybridity and peacebuilding in Burundi: questioning authenticity. Third World Quarterly 40:1, pages 129-146.
Read now
Gearoid Millar. (2018) Engaging Ethnographic Peace Research: Exploring an Approach. International Peacekeeping 25:5, pages 597-609.
Read now
Gearoid Millar. (2018) Ethnographic Peace Research: The Underappreciated Benefits of Long-term Fieldwork. International Peacekeeping 25:5, pages 653-676.
Read now
Pol Bargués-Pedreny & Elisa Randazzo. (2018) Hybrid peace revisited: an opportunity for considering self-governance?. Third World Quarterly 39:8, pages 1543-1560.
Read now
Dahlia Simangan. (2018) When hybridity breeds contempt: negative hybrid peace in Cambodia. Third World Quarterly 39:8, pages 1525-1542.
Read now
Jonathan Joseph. (2018) Beyond Relationalism in Peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12:3, pages 425-434.
Read now
Pol Bargués-Pedreny & Xavier Mathieu. (2018) Beyond Silence, Obstacle and Stigma: Revisiting the ‘Problem’ of Difference in Peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12:3, pages 283-299.
Read now
Marta Iñiguez de Heredia. (2018) The Conspicuous Absence of Class and Privilege in the Study of Resistance in Peacebuilding Contexts. International Peacekeeping 25:3, pages 325-348.
Read now
Ruth Hanau Santini & Simone Tholens. (2018) Security Assistance in a Post-interventionist Era: The Impact on Limited Statehood in Lebanon and Tunisia. Small Wars & Insurgencies 29:3, pages 491-514.
Read now
Jacob Phillipps. (2018) The role of epistemic communities: local think tanks, international practitioners and security sector reform in Kosovo. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 18:2, pages 281-299.
Read now
Philippe Le Billon. (2018) Peacebuilding and white-collar crime in post-war natural resource sectors. Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal 3:1, pages 80-97.
Read now
Dahlia Simangan. (2018) Domino Effect of Negative Hybrid Peace in Kosovo's Peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12:1, pages 120-141.
Read now
Claire Q. Smith & Tom Jarvis. (2018) Ending Mass Atrocities: An Empirical Reinterpretation of ‘Successful’ International Military Intervention in East Timor. International Peacekeeping 25:1, pages 1-27.
Read now
Miranda Forsyth, Lia Kent, Sinclair Dinnen, Joanne Wallis & Srinjoy Bose. (2017) Hybridity in peacebuilding and development: a critical approach. Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal 2:4, pages 407-421.
Read now
M. Anne Brown. (2017) Hybridity and dialogue – approaches to the hybrid turn. Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal 2:4, pages 446-463.
Read now
Susanne Schmeidl & Nick Miszak. (2017) The Afghan Local Police: unpacking a hybrid security arrangement. Third World Thematics: A TWQ Journal 2:4, pages 538-556.
Read now
Caitlin Ryan & Helen Basini. (2017) UNSC Resolution 1325 national action plans in Liberia and Sierra Leone: An analysis of gendered power relations in hybrid peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 11:2, pages 186-206.
Read now
Vanessa F. Newby. (2017) Positive hybridity? Unpacking UN security sector reform in South Lebanon. Contemporary Politics 23:2, pages 156-174.
Read now
Debora Valentina Malito. (2017) Neutral in favour of whom? The UN intervention in Somalia and the Somaliland peace process. International Peacekeeping 24:2, pages 280-303.
Read now
Pol Bargués–Pedreny. (2017) Connolly and the never-ending critiques of liberal peace: from the privilege of difference to vorarephilia. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 30:2-3, pages 216-234.
Read now
Joanne Wallis. (2017) Is ‘good enough’ peacebuilding good enough? The potential and pitfalls of the local turn in peacebuilding in Timor-Leste. The Pacific Review 30:2, pages 251-269.
Read now
Philipp Lottholz & Nicolas Lemay-Hébert. (2016) Re-reading Weber, re-conceptualizing state-building: from neo-Weberian to post-Weberian approaches to state, legitimacy and state-building. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 29:4, pages 1467-1485.
Read now
Irene Costantini. (2016) Conflict dynamics in post-2011 Libya: a political economy perspective. Conflict, Security & Development 16:5, pages 405-422.
Read now
Catherine Baker & Jelena Obradovic-Wochnik. (2016) Mapping the Nexus of Transitional Justice and Peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 10:3, pages 281-301.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (50)

Tyler Cawthray & Melissa Bull. (2023) The Spatial Dimension of Police Legitimacy: An Exploration of Two Pacific Island States. Asian Journal of Criminology.
Crossref
Theresa Reinold. (2023) How to ‘make law count’: Lessons from the Comisión Internacional contra la Impunidad en Guatemala (CICIG) for the Effectiveness of Hybrid Governance . International Journal of Law in Context, pages 1-19.
Crossref
Katrin Travouillon. (2023) The power of uptake: Negative emotions and the (neo)liberal limits of imagination in transitions to justice and peace. Cooperation and Conflict.
Crossref
Jacob Eriksson & Isaac Grief. (2023) The Iraqi state's legitimacy deficit: Input, output and identity‐based legitimacy challenges. Global Policy 14:2, pages 363-372.
Crossref
Sophie Roborgh. (2023) Localisation in the balance: Syrian medical‐humanitarian NGOs' strategic engagement with the local and international. Disasters 47:2, pages 519-542.
Crossref
Noah B. TaylorNoah B. Taylor. 2023. Existential Risks in Peace and Conflict Studies. Existential Risks in Peace and Conflict Studies 5 40 .
Ellen M. Lust. 2022. Everyday Choices. Everyday Choices.
Amanda Fish. (2022) The Applicability of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Ethno-Religious Conflict: A Case Study of the Uighur-Han Conflict in Xinjiang, China. Asian International Studies Review 23:1, pages 53-86.
Crossref
Henry Redwood, Tiffany Fairey & Jasmin Hasić. (2022) Hybrid Peacebuilding in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Participatory Arts and Youth Activism as Vehicles of Social Change. Journal of Peacebuilding & Development 17:1, pages 42-57.
Crossref
Yoshiaki Furuzawa. 2022. Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, & Conflict. Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, & Conflict 358 364 .
Dahlia Simangan. 2022. Micro-evidence for Peacebuilding Theories and Policies. Micro-evidence for Peacebuilding Theories and Policies 17 38 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 235 269 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 207 234 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 135 176 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 59 87 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 33 58 .
Jacob PhillippsJacob Phillipps. 2022. Local Researchers and International Practitioners. Local Researchers and International Practitioners 1 32 .
Volker Boege. 2022. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 969 981 .
Volker Boege. 2022. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 551 561 .
Elena B. Stavrevska & Sarah Smith. 2022. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 637 644 .
Oliver Jütersonke, Kazushige Kobayashi, Keith Krause & Xinyu Yuan. (2021) Norm Contestation and Normative Transformation in Global Peacebuilding Order(s): The Cases of China, Japan, and Russia. International Studies Quarterly 65:4, pages 944-959.
Crossref
Jenny Lorentzen. (2021) Frictional interactions on Women, Peace and Security in Mali. The Journal of Modern African Studies 59:4, pages 463-483.
Crossref
Sophia Dingli. (2020) Conceptualising peace and its preconditions: The anti-Pelagian imagination and the critical turn in peace theory. Journal of International Political Theory 17:3, pages 468-487.
Crossref
Katelyn Cassin & Benjamin Zyla. (2021) The End of the Liberal World Order and the Future of UN Peace Operations: Lessons Learned. Global Policy 12:4, pages 455-467.
Crossref
Ferth Vandensteen Manaysay & Jovanie Camacho Espesor. 2021. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 99 125 .
Cedric de Coning & Lawrence McDonald-Colbert. 2021. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 37 58 .
Yuji Uesugi. 2021. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Operationalisation of Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 1 20 .
Morgan Brigg & Nicole George. (2020) Emplacing the spatial turn in peace and conflict studies. Cooperation and Conflict 55:4, pages 409-420.
Crossref
Ryerson Christie & Gilberto Algar-Faria. (2020) Timely interventions: Temporality and peacebuilding. European Journal of International Security 5:2, pages 155-178.
Crossref
Pol Bargués. (2020) Peacebuilding without peace? On how pragmatism complicates the practice of international intervention. Review of International Studies 46:2, pages 237-255.
Crossref
Johannes Jüde. (2018) The possibility of state formation and the limitations of liberal international state-building. Journal of International Relations and Development 23:1, pages 92-116.
Crossref
Obodai Torto. 2020. The Palgrave Handbook of African Political Economy. The Palgrave Handbook of African Political Economy 413 432 .
Gijsbert M. van Iterson ScholtenGijsbert M. van Iterson Scholten. 2020. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers 199 238 .
Gijsbert M. van Iterson ScholtenGijsbert M. van Iterson Scholten. 2020. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers 65 94 .
Gijsbert M. van Iterson ScholtenGijsbert M. van Iterson Scholten. 2020. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers. Visions of Peace of Professional Peace Workers 27 64 .
Kevin P. Clements & Yuji Uesugi. 2020. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 139 152 .
Yuji Uesugi & Megumi Kagawa. 2020. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 37 60 .
Yuji Uesugi. 2020. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia. Hybrid Peacebuilding in Asia 1 14 .
Volker Boege. 2020. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 1 13 .
Volker Boege. 2019. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 1 11 .
Elena B. Stavrevska & Sarah Smith. 2020. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies. The Palgrave Encyclopedia of Peace and Conflict Studies 1 8 .
Sarah G Phillips. (2019) Proximities of Violence: Civil Order Beyond Governance Institutions. International Studies Quarterly 63:3, pages 680-691.
Crossref
Catherine Baker. (2019) Between the Round Table and the Waiting Room: Scholarship on War and Peace in Bosnia-Herzegovina and Kosovo after the ‘Post-Cold War’. Contemporary European History 28:1, pages 107-119.
Crossref
SungYong LeeSungYong Lee. 2019. Local Ownership in Asian Peacebuilding. Local Ownership in Asian Peacebuilding 1 26 .
Pamina Firchow. 2018. Reclaiming Everyday Peace. Reclaiming Everyday Peace.
Sina Birkholz, Tilmann Scherf & Ursula C Schroeder. (2018) International interventions seen from the ‘Middle’: Perceptions of intermediary actors in Côte d’Ivoire and Lebanon. Cooperation and Conflict, pages 001083671876863.
Crossref
Stefano Recchia. (2018) Should humanitarian interveners promote democracy after genocide?. International Theory 10:1, pages 1-30.
Crossref
Gearoid Millar. 2018. Ethnographic Peace Research. Ethnographic Peace Research 1 19 .
Shahar Hameiri & Lee Jones. (2017) Beyond Hybridity to the Politics of Scale: International Intervention and ‘Local’ Politics. Development and Change 48:1, pages 54-77.
Crossref
. (2016) BIBLIOGRAPHY. Leiden Journal of International Law 29:4, pages 1121-1124.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.