1,125
Views
98
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Regular Articles

Why are there limits on theory of mind use? Evidence from adults' ability to follow instructions from an ignorant speaker

, , , , &
Pages 1201-1217 | Received 16 Oct 2008, Published online: 15 Oct 2009

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (11)

Massimiliano Conson, Mattia Siciliano, Isa Zappullo, Chiara Baiano, Luigi Trojano, Sara Salzano & Gabriella Santangelo. (2023) Measuring mindreading in preschoolers: the perspective battery (PERBAT). The Clinical Neuropsychologist 0:0, pages 1-20.
Read now
Serena Lecce, Irene Ceccato & Elena Cavallini. (2019) Investigating ToM in aging with the MASC: from accuracy to error type. Aging, Neuropsychology, and Cognition 26:4, pages 541-557.
Read now
Debby Damen, Marije van Amelsvoort, Per van der Wijst & Emiel Krahmer. (2019) Changing views: the effect of explicit perception-focus instructions on perspective-taking. Journal of Cognitive Psychology 31:3, pages 353-369.
Read now
Agnieszka Dębska & Joanna Rączaszek-Leonardi. (2018) What Makes Us More Egocentric in Communication? The Role of Referent Features and Individual Differences. Discourse Processes 55:1, pages 1-11.
Read now
Heather J. Ferguson, Ian Apperly & James E. Cane. (2017) Eye tracking reveals the cost of switching between self and other perspectives in a visual perspective-taking task. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 70:8, pages 1646-1660.
Read now
Amélie M. Achim, André Achim & Marion Fossard. (2017) Knowledge likely held by others affects speakers’ choices of referential expressions at different stages of discourse. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 32:1, pages 21-36.
Read now
Bradley D. Mattan, Pia Rotshtein & Kimberly A. Quinn. (2016) Empathy and visual perspective-taking performance. Cognitive Neuroscience 7:1-4, pages 170-181.
Read now
Gillian Humphrey & Iroise Dumontheil. (2016) Development of Risk-Taking, Perspective-Taking, and Inhibitory Control During Adolescence. Developmental Neuropsychology 41:1-2, pages 59-76.
Read now
Toshiyuki Himichi, Hiroyo Fujita & Michio Nomura. (2015) Negative emotions impact lateral prefrontal cortex activation during theory of mind: An fNIRS study. Social Neuroscience 10:6, pages 605-615.
Read now
J. Jessica Wang, Dongo Diana Miletich, Richard Ramsey & Dana Samson. (2014) Adults see vision to be more informative than it is. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 67:12, pages 2279-2292.
Read now
ElizabethS. Nilsen & David Duong. (2013) Depressive symptoms and use of perspective taking within a communicative context. Cognition and Emotion 27:2, pages 335-344.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (87)

Napoleon Katsos, Blanche Gonzales de Linares, Ekaterina Ostashchenko & Elspeth Wilson. (2023) Perspective-taking in deriving implicatures: The listener's perspective is important too. Cognition 241, pages 105582.
Crossref
Christian Tarchi, Lidia Casado-Ledesma, Giulia Sanna & Margherita Conti. (2023) The relationship between theory of mind and multiple-document comprehension in university students: preliminary research findings. European Journal of Psychology of Education.
Crossref
Yingjia Wan, Yipu Wei, Baorui Xu, Liqi Zhu & Michael K. Tanenhaus. (2023) Musical coordination affects children's perspective‐taking, but musical synchrony does not. Developmental Science 26:5.
Crossref
Steven Samuel. (2022) A curse of knowledge or a curse of uncertainty? Bilingualism, embodiment, and egocentric bias. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 76:8, pages 1740-1759.
Crossref
Justin Feng, Sohyun Cho & Gigi Luk. (2023) Assessing Theory of Mind in bilinguals: A scoping review on tasks and study designs. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition, pages 1-15.
Crossref
Ahmed Khorsheed & Nicole Gotzner. (2023) A closer look at the sources of variability in scalar implicature derivation: a review. Frontiers in Communication 8.
Crossref
Rebecca L. Monk, Adam W. Qureshi, Graeme Knibb, Lauren McGale, Leonie Nair, Jordan Kelly, Hope Collins & Derek Heim. (2023) In people who drink more, facets of theory of mind may be impaired by alcohol stimuli. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 245, pages 109811.
Crossref
Steven Samuel, Geoff G. Cole & Madeline J. Eacott. (2022) It’s Not You, It’s Me: A Review of Individual Differences in Visuospatial Perspective Taking. Perspectives on Psychological Science 18:2, pages 293-308.
Crossref
Estefania Loza, Frédérique Amsellem, Tiziana Zalla, Ariane Cartigny, Marion Leboyer, Richard Delorme, Franck Ramus & Baudouin Forgeot d′Arc. (2023) A mind-reading puzzle: Autistic people are more efficient at a theory-of-mind task. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 101, pages 102105.
Crossref
N. (Nina) Jakubeit, C. (Carithea) Richards & A. (Alberto) Martinetti. (2023) Designing a problem analysis toolkit in the context of humanitarian engineering. Procedia CIRP 119, pages 1065-1070.
Crossref
Camille Chamois. (2022) Apprendre à parler à Dieu comme on apprend à goûter un vin…Learning to Talk to God as One Learns to Taste a Wine…. L'Homme:243-244, pages 223-242.
Crossref
Melissa Pearl Caldwell, Him Cheung, Sum-Kwing Cheung, Jian-Bin Li & Tik-Sze Carrey Siu. (2022) Visuospatial perspective-taking in social-emotional development: enhancing young children’s mind and emotion understanding via block building training. BMC Psychology 10:1.
Crossref
A. Henry, P. Allain & C. Potard. (2022) Relationships between Theory of Mind and Attachment Styles in Emerging Adulthood. Journal of Adult Development 29:3, pages 179-191.
Crossref
Chiara Basile, Serena Lecce & Floris Tijmen van Vugt. (2022) Synchrony During Online Encounters Affects Social Affiliation and Theory of Mind but Not Empathy. Frontiers in Psychology 13.
Crossref
Abhilasha Das & Moosath Harishankar Vasudevan. (2022) Reading Patterns, Engagement Style and Theory of Mind. Psychological Studies 67:2, pages 252-260.
Crossref
Annalisa Valle, Teresa Rinaldi, Andrea Greco, Robert Pianta, Ilaria Castelli & Antonella Marchetti. (2022) Mentalization and attachment in educational relationships at primary school. RICERCHE DI PSICOLOGIA:1, pages 1-23.
Crossref
Suzanne L. K. Stewart & Julie A. Kirkham. (2020) Predictors of Individual Differences in Emerging Adult Theory of Mind. Emerging Adulthood 10:2, pages 558-565.
Crossref
Noémie Moreau, Emmanuelle Taché & Maud Champagne‐Lavau. (2021) Speaking with virtual humans: Assessing social cognition in traumatic brain injury with a second‐person perspective task. Journal of Neuropsychology 16:1, pages 75-96.
Crossref
Manuel Sprung, Juliane Burghardt, Monica Mazza & Friedrich Riffer. (2022) Editorial: Misunderstanding Others: Theory of Mind in Psychological Disorders. Frontiers in Psychology 13.
Crossref
Menghui WU, Jiushu XIE & Zhu DENG. (2022) The debate between inhibition and attribution of egocentric bias in visual perspective taking. Advances in Psychological Science 30:1, pages 179-187.
Crossref
Rebecca L. Monk, Lauren Colbert, Gemma Darker, Jade Cowling, Bethany Jones & Adam W. Qureshi. (2020) Emotion and liking: how director emotional expression and knowledge of (dis)liking may impact adults’ ability to follow the instructions of an ignorant speaker. Psychological Research 85:7, pages 2755-2768.
Crossref
Yei-Yu Yeh, Chi-Chin Wang, Shih-kuen Cheng & Chui-De Chiu. (2021) Dissociation of posture remapping and cognitive load in level-2 perspective-taking. Cognition 214, pages 104733.
Crossref
Camille Chamois. (2021) Le perspectivisme est-il une « théorie de l’esprit locale » ?Is Perspectivism a “Local Theory of Mind” ?. L'Homme:238, pages 35-62.
Crossref
Debby Damen, Marije van Amelsvoort, Per van der Wijst, Monique Pollmann & Emiel Krahmer. (2021) Lifting the curse of knowing: How feedback improves perspective-taking. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 74:6, pages 1054-1069.
Crossref
Anne Weigand, Irene Trilla, Lioba Enk, Garret O’Connell, Kristin Prehn, Timothy R. Brick & Isabel Dziobek. (2021) How Much of Me Do I See in Other Minds? Modulating Egocentricity in Emotion Judgments by tDCS. Brain Sciences 11:4, pages 512.
Crossref
Shanshan Zhen, Avijit Chowdhury & Rongjun Yu. (2021) The neural underpinnings of allocentric thinking in a novel signaling task. NeuroImage 230, pages 117808.
Crossref
Steven Samuel, Geoff G. Cole & Madeline J. Eacott. (2020) Two independent sources of difficulty in perspective-taking/theory of mind tasks. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 27:6, pages 1341-1347.
Crossref
Cheng-hui TAN, Shan-shan MA, Chuan-lin ZHU, Yuan ZHAO, Xuan-yi WANG, De-ming SHU & Dian-zhi LIU. (2022) 人际互动中的“自我-他人”区分:多水平的探索. Advances in Psychological Science 28:11, pages 1890-1900.
Crossref
J. Jessica Wang, Natalia Ciranova, Bethany Woods & Ian A. Apperly. (2020) Why are listeners sometimes (but not always) egocentric? Making inferences about using others’ perspective in referential communication. PLOS ONE 15:10, pages e0240521.
Crossref
Steven Samuel, Anna Frohnwieser, Robert Lurz & Nicola S Clayton. (2020) Reduced egocentric bias when perspective-taking compared with working from rules. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 73:9, pages 1368-1381.
Crossref
Joseph Sweetman & George A. Newman. (2020) Attentional efficiency does not explain the mental state × domain effect. PLOS ONE 15:6, pages e0234500.
Crossref
Adam W. Qureshi, Rebecca L. Monk, Dana Samson & Ian A. Apperly. (2019) Does interference between self and other perspectives in theory of mind tasks reflect a common underlying process? Evidence from individual differences in theory of mind and inhibitory control. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 27:1, pages 178-190.
Crossref
Wenjie Wu, Elizabeth Sheppard & Peter Mitchell. (2019) Interpreting signals in other people's behavior to sense things about them and to infer things about their world. Social and Personality Psychology Compass 13:12.
Crossref
J. Jessica Wang, Philip Tseng, Chi-Hung Juan, Steven Frisson & Ian A. Apperly. (2019) Perspective-taking across cultures: shared biases in Taiwanese and British adults. Royal Society Open Science 6:11, pages 190540.
Crossref
Qiyang Gao, Wei Chen, Zhenlin Wang & Dan Lin. (2019) Secret of the Masters: Young Chess Players Show Advanced Visual Perspective Taking. Frontiers in Psychology 10.
Crossref
Debby Damen, Per van der Wijst, Marije van Amelsvoort & Emiel Krahmer. (2018) Perspective-Taking in Referential Communication: Does Stimulated Attention to Addressees’ Perspective Influence Speakers’ Reference Production?. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 48:2, pages 257-288.
Crossref
Rachel Newey, Kami Koldewyn & Richard Ramsey. (2019) The influence of prosocial priming on visual perspective taking and automatic imitation. PLOS ONE 14:1, pages e0198867.
Crossref
Les Sikos, Samuel B. Tomlinson, Conor Heins & Daniel J. Grodner. (2019) What do you know? ERP evidence for immediate use of common ground during online reference resolution. Cognition 182, pages 275-285.
Crossref
Steven Samuel, Edward W Legg, Robert Lurz & Nicola S Clayton. (2018) Egocentric bias across mental and non-mental representations in the Sandbox Task. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 71:11, pages 2395-2410.
Crossref
Evelien M. Barendse, Marc P. H. Hendriks, Geert Thoonen, Albert P. Aldenkamp & Roy P. C. Kessels. (2018) Social behaviour and social cognition in high-functioning adolescents with autism spectrum disorder (ASD): two sides of the same coin?. Cognitive Processing 19:4, pages 545-555.
Crossref
Lin Zhao, J. Jessica Wang & Ian A. Apperly. (2018) The cognitive demands of remembering a speaker’s perspective and managing common ground size modulate 8- and 10-year-olds’ perspective-taking abilities. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 174, pages 130-149.
Crossref
Jed T. Elison & Maria D. Sera. 2018. Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology. Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology 114 146 .
Hilda Pinheiro da Costa, Jennifer K. Vrabel, Virgil Zeigler-Hill & Jennifer Vonk. (2018) DSM-5 pathological personality traits are associated with the ability to understand the emotional states of others. Journal of Research in Personality 75, pages 1-11.
Crossref
Jennifer Susan McClung & Stephen David Reicher. (2018) Representing other minds: Mental state reference is moderated by group membership. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 76, pages 385-392.
Crossref
Francesc Sidera, Georgina Perpiñà, Jèssica Serrano & Carles Rostan. (2016) Why Is Theory of Mind Important for Referential Communication?. Current Psychology 37:1, pages 82-97.
Crossref
Jane Rebecca Conway & Geoffrey Bird. (2018) Conceptualizing degrees of theory of mind. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115:7, pages 1408-1410.
Crossref
Paula Rubio-Fernández. (2016) The director task: A test of Theory-of-Mind use or selective attention?. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 24:4, pages 1121-1128.
Crossref
Edward W. Legg, Laure Olivier, Steven Samuel, Robert Lurz & Nicola S. Clayton. (2017) Error rate on the director's task is influenced by the need to take another's perspective but not the type of perspective. Royal Society Open Science 4:8, pages 170284.
Crossref
Deanna L. Gagne & Marie Coppola. (2017) Visible Social Interactions Do Not Support the Development of False Belief Understanding in the Absence of Linguistic Input: Evidence from Deaf Adult Homesigners. Frontiers in Psychology 8.
Crossref
SUSAN A. GRAHAM, VALERIE SAN JUAN & MELANIE KHU. (2016) Words are not enough: how preschoolers’ integration of perspective and emotion informs their referential understanding. Journal of Child Language 44:3, pages 500-526.
Crossref
Elizabeth S. Nilsen & Sarah A. Bacso. (2017) Cognitive and behavioural predictors of adolescents' communicative perspective‐taking and social relationships. Journal of Adolescence 56:1, pages 52-63.
Crossref
Emma J. Kilford, Emily Garrett & Sarah-Jayne Blakemore. (2016) The development of social cognition in adolescence: An integrated perspective. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 70, pages 106-120.
Crossref
Daniel Joel Shaw, Kristína Czekóová & Michaela Porubanová. (2016) Orthogonal-compatibility effects confound automatic imitation: implications for measuring self–other distinction. Psychological Research.
Crossref
Charlotte E. Hartwright, Robert M. Hardwick, Ian A. Apperly & Peter C. Hansen. (2016) Resting state morphology predicts the effect of theta burst stimulation in false belief reasoning. Human Brain Mapping 37:10, pages 3502-3514.
Crossref
Nancie Im-Bolter, Alba Agostino & Keely Owens-Jaffray. (2016) Theory of mind in middle childhood and early adolescence: Different from before?. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 149, pages 98-115.
Crossref
J. Jessica Wang, Muna Ali, Steven Frisson & Ian A. Apperly. (2016) Language complexity modulates 8- and 10-year-olds’ success at using their theory of mind abilities in a communication task. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 149, pages 62-71.
Crossref
Ana Luísa Barreto, R. M. Pasco Fearon, Ana Osório, Elizabeth Meins & Carla Martins. (2015) Are adult mentalizing abilities associated with mind-mindedness?. International Journal of Behavioral Development 40:4, pages 296-301.
Crossref
Kyriakos Antoniou, Chris Cummins & Napoleon Katsos. (2016) Why only some adults reject under-informative utterances. Journal of Pragmatics 99, pages 78-95.
Crossref
Elif Gökçen, Norah Frederickson & K. V. Petrides. (2016) Theory of Mind and Executive Control Deficits in Typically Developing Adults and Adolescents with High Levels of Autism Traits. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 46:6, pages 2072-2087.
Crossref
Toshio YamagishiHaruto TakagishiAlan de Souza Rodrigues FerminRyota Kanai, Yang LiYoshie Matsumoto. (2016) Cortical thickness of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex predicts strategic choices in economic games. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113:20, pages 5582-5587.
Crossref
Dale J. Barr. 2016. Visually Situated Language Comprehension. Visually Situated Language Comprehension 261 290 .
Uwe Peters. (2015) Human thinking, shared intentionality, and egocentric biases. Biology & Philosophy 31:2, pages 299-312.
Crossref
Steven Samuel, Karen Roehr-Brackin & Debi Roberson. (2015) ‘She says, he says’: Does the sex of an instructor interact with the grammatical gender of targets in a perspective-taking task?. International Journal of Bilingualism 20:1, pages 40-61.
Crossref
Valerie San Juan, Melanie Khu & Susan A. Graham. (2015) A New Perspective on Children's Communicative Perspective Taking: When and How Do Children Use Perspective Inferences to Inform Their Comprehension of Spoken Language?. Child Development Perspectives 9:4, pages 245-249.
Crossref
Iroise Dumontheil. (2015) Development of the social brain during adolescence. Psicología Educativa 21:2, pages 117-124.
Crossref
Kathryn L. Mills, Iroise Dumontheil, Maarten Speekenbrink & Sarah-Jayne Blakemore. (2015) Multitasking during social interactions in adolescence and early adulthood. Royal Society Open Science 2:11, pages 150117.
Crossref
Idalmis Santiesteban, Michael J. Banissy, Caroline Catmur & Geoffrey Bird. (2015) Functional lateralization of temporoparietal junction - imitation inhibition, visual perspective-taking and theory of mind. European Journal of Neuroscience 42:8, pages 2527-2533.
Crossref
Yong-guang Wang, Jian-fei Shi, David L. Roberts, Xiao-ying Jiang, Zhi-hua Shen, Yi-quan Wang & kai Wang. (2015) Theory-of-mind use in remitted schizophrenia patients: The role of inhibition and perspective-switching. Psychiatry Research 229:1-2, pages 332-339.
Crossref
Samantha P. Fan, Zoe Liberman, Boaz Keysar & Katherine D. Kinzler. (2015) The Exposure Advantage. Psychological Science 26:7, pages 1090-1097.
Crossref
Ahmad M. Abu-Akel, Stephen J. Wood, Peter C. Hansen & Ian A. Apperly. (2015) Perspective-taking abilities in the balance between autism tendencies and psychosis proneness. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 282:1808, pages 20150563.
Crossref
Idalmis Santiesteban, Punit Shah, Sarah White, Geoffrey Bird & Cecilia Heyes. (2014) Mentalizing or submentalizing in a communication task? Evidence from autism and a camera control. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 22:3, pages 844-849.
Crossref
Heather J. Ferguson, Ian Apperly, Jumana Ahmad, Markus Bindemann & James Cane. (2015) Task constraints distinguish perspective inferences from perspective use during discourse interpretation in a false belief task. Cognition 139, pages 50-70.
Crossref
Elisabeth E.F. Bradford, Ines Jentzsch & Juan-Carlos Gomez. (2015) From self to social cognition: Theory of Mind mechanisms and their relation to Executive Functioning. Cognition 138, pages 21-34.
Crossref
Edward William Legg, Ljerka Ostojić & Nicola Susan Clayton. (2015) Food sharing and social cognition. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science 6:2, pages 119-129.
Crossref
Ben Meijering, Niels A. Taatgen, Hedderik van Rijn & Rineke Verbrugge. (2014) Modeling inference of mental states. Interaction Studies. Social Behaviour and Communication in Biological and Artificial Systems Interaction Studies / Social Behaviour and Communication in Biological and Artificial Systems Interaction Studies 15:3, pages 455-477.
Crossref
J. Robert Thompson. (2014) Signature Limits in Mindreading Systems. Cognitive Science 38:7, pages 1432-1455.
Crossref
Carla Sharp & Salome Vanwoerden. (2014) Social Cognition: Empirical Contribution: The Developmental Building Blocks of Psychopathic Traits: Revisiting the Role of Theory of Mind. Journal of Personality Disorders 28:1, pages 78-95.
Crossref
Sarah-Jayne BlakemoreKathryn L. Mills. (2014) Is Adolescence a Sensitive Period for Sociocultural Processing?. Annual Review of Psychology 65:1, pages 187-207.
Crossref
Adam Qureshi, Christopher Peters & Ian Apperly. 2014. Virtual, Augmented and Mixed Reality. Designing and Developing Virtual and Augmented Environments. Virtual, Augmented and Mixed Reality. Designing and Developing Virtual and Augmented Environments 305 316 .
Yong-guang Wang, David L Roberts & Bai-hua Xu. (2013) Dissociation of understanding from applying others’ false beliefs in remitted schizophrenia: evidence from a computerized referential communication task. BMC Psychiatry 13:1.
Crossref
STEPHEN A. BUTTERFILL & IAN A. APPERLY. (2013) How to Construct a Minimal Theory of Mind. Mind & Language 28:5, pages 606-637.
Crossref
Hauke Hillebrandt, Iroise Dumontheil, Sarah-Jayne Blakemore & Jonathan P. Roiser. (2013) Dynamic causal modelling of effective connectivity during perspective taking in a communicative task. NeuroImage 76, pages 116-124.
Crossref
Elizabeth S. Nilsen, Leilani Mangal & Kristi MacDonald. (2013) Referential Communication in Children With ADHD: Challenges in the Role of a Listener. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 56:2, pages 590-603.
Crossref
Stephanie E. Miller & Stuart Marcovitch. (2012) How Theory of Mind and Executive Function Co-develop. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 3:4, pages 597-625.
Crossref
Iroise Dumontheil, Hauke Hillebrandt, Ian A. Apperly & Sarah-Jayne Blakemore. (2012) Developmental Differences in the Control of Action Selection by Social Information. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 24:10, pages 2080-2095.
Crossref
Idalmis Santiesteban, Sarah White, Jennifer Cook, Sam J. Gilbert, Cecilia Heyes & Geoffrey Bird. (2012) Training social cognition: From imitation to Theory of Mind. Cognition 122:2, pages 228-235.
Crossref
Heather J. Ferguson & Richard Breheny. (2012) Listeners' eyes reveal spontaneous sensitivity to others' perspectives. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48:1, pages 257-263.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.