1,753
Views
52
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Regular Articles

How robust are prediction effects in language comprehension? Failure to replicate article-elicited N400 effects

ORCID Icon, &
Pages 954-965 | Received 01 Jun 2016, Accepted 22 Sep 2016, Published online: 18 Oct 2016

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (10)

Fabian Schlotterbeck, Petra Augurzky & Rolf Ulrich. (2023) Degree of incrementality is modulated by experimental context – ERP evidence from German quantifier restriction. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 38:3, pages 390-410.
Read now
Sofia Frade, Ana P. Pinheiro, Andrea Santi & Ana Raposo. (2022) Is second best good enough? An EEG study on the effects of word expectancy in sentence comprehension. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 37:2, pages 209-223.
Read now
Wing-Yee Chow & Di Chen. (2020) Predicting (in)correctly: listeners rapidly use unexpected information to revise their predictions. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 35:9, pages 1149-1161.
Read now
Nicole A. Himmelstoss, Sarah Schuster, Florian Hutzler, Rosalyn Moran & Stefan Hawelka. (2020) Co-registration of eye movements and neuroimaging for studying contextual predictions in natural reading. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 35:5, pages 595-612.
Read now
Caterina Laura Paolazzi, Nino Grillo, Artemis Alexiadou & Andrea Santi. (2019) Passives are not hard to interpret but hard to remember: evidence from online and offline studies. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 34:8, pages 991-1015.
Read now
Spyridoula Cheimariou, Thomas A. Farmer & Jean K. Gordon. (2019) Lexical prediction in the aging brain: The effects of predictiveness and congruency on the N400 ERP component. Aging, Neuropsychology, and Cognition 26:5, pages 781-806.
Read now
Arnold R. Kochari & Monique Flecken. (2019) Lexical prediction in language comprehension: a replication study of grammatical gender effects in Dutch. Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 34:2, pages 239-253.
Read now
Aine Ito, Andrea E. Martin & Mante S. Nieuwland. (2017) Why the A/AN prediction effect may be hard to replicate: a rebuttal to Delong, Urbach, and Kutas (2017). Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 32:8, pages 974-983.
Read now
Katherine A. DeLong, Thomas P. Urbach & Marta Kutas. (2017) Is there a replication crisis? Perhaps. Is this an example? No: a commentary on Ito, Martin, and Nieuwland (2016). Language, Cognition and Neuroscience 32:8, pages 966-973.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (42)

Elise van Wonderen & Mante S. Nieuwland. (2023) Lexical prediction does not rationally adapt to prediction error: ERP evidence from pre-nominal articles. Journal of Memory and Language 132, pages 104435.
Crossref
Wei Wei, Zirui Huang, Chen Feng & Qingqing Qu. (2023) Predicting phonological information in language comprehension: evidence from ERP representational similarity analysis and Chinese idioms. Cerebral Cortex 33:15, pages 9367-9375.
Crossref
Essa Qurbi. (2023) Second language word processing in sentence contexts: pre-lexical prediction versus post-lexical integration. East European Journal of Psycholinguistics.
Crossref
Valentina N. Pescuma, Dina Serova, Julia Lukassek, Antje Sauermann, Roland Schäfer, Aria Adli, Felix Bildhauer, Markus Egg, Kristina Hülk, Aine Ito, Stefanie Jannedy, Valia Kordoni, Milena Kuehnast, Silvia Kutscher, Robert Lange, Nico Lehmann, Mingya Liu, Beate Lütke, Katja Maquate, Christine Mooshammer, Vahid Mortezapour, Stefan Müller, Muriel Norde, Elizabeth Pankratz, Angela G. Patarroyo, Ana-Maria Pleşca, Camilo R. Ronderos, Stephanie Rotter, Uli Sauerland, Gohar Schnelle, Britta Schulte, Gediminas Schüppenhauer, Bianca Maria Sell, Stephanie Solt, Megumi Terada, Dimitra Tsiapou, Elisabeth Verhoeven, Melanie Weirich, Heike Wiese, Kathy Zaruba, Lars Erik Zeige, Anke Lüdeling & Pia Knoeferle. (2023) Situating language register across the ages, languages, modalities, and cultural aspects: Evidence from complementary methods. Frontiers in Psychology 13.
Crossref
Milena Rabovsky. 2023. Language Electrified. Language Electrified 527 550 .
Sun-Young Lee & Yunju Nam. (2022) Electrophysiological evidence for a subject-first strategy in visually situated auditory sentence processing in Korean. Acta Psychologica 231, pages 103799.
Crossref
Victoria R. Poulton & Mante S. Nieuwland. (2022) Can You Hear What’s Coming? Failure to Replicate ERP Evidence for Phonological Prediction. Neurobiology of Language 3:4, pages 556-574.
Crossref
Katja I. Haeuser & Jutta Kray. (2022) How odd: Diverging effects of predictability and plausibility violations on sentence reading and word memory. Applied Psycholinguistics 43:5, pages 1193-1220.
Crossref
Samer Nour Eddine, Trevor Brothers & Gina R. Kuperberg. 2022. 123 206 .
Robert Kluender. 2021. The Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Syntax. The Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Syntax 641 686 .
Fernanda Ferreira & Zhuang Qiu. (2021) Predicting syntactic structure. Brain Research 1770, pages 147632.
Crossref
Chiara Gambi. 2021. Prediction in Second Language Processing and Learning. Prediction in Second Language Processing and Learning 188 206 .
Aine Ito & Martin J. Pickering. 2021. Prediction in Second Language Processing and Learning. Prediction in Second Language Processing and Learning 26 46 .
José Alemán Bañón, David Miller & Jason Rothman. (2020) EXAMINING THE CONTRIBUTION OF MARKEDNESS TO THE L2 PROCESSING OF SPANISH PERSON AGREEMENT. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 43:4, pages 699-728.
Crossref
Jessie S. Nixon & Fabian Tomaschek. (2021) Prediction and error in early infant speech learning: A speech acquisition model. Cognition 212, pages 104697.
Crossref
José Alemán Bañón & Clara Martin. (2021) The role of crosslinguistic differences in second language anticipatory processing: An event-related potentials study. Neuropsychologia 155, pages 107797.
Crossref
Yuri G. Pavlov, Nika Adamian, Stefan Appelhoff, Mahnaz Arvaneh, Christopher S.Y. Benwell, Christian Beste, Amy R. Bland, Daniel E. Bradford, Florian Bublatzky, Niko A. Busch, Peter E. Clayson, Damian Cruse, Artur Czeszumski, Anna Dreber, Guillaume Dumas, Benedikt Ehinger, Giorgio Ganis, Xun He, José A. Hinojosa, Christoph Huber-Huber, Michael Inzlicht, Bradley N. Jack, Magnus Johannesson, Rhiannon Jones, Evgenii Kalenkovich, Laura Kaltwasser, Hamid Karimi-Rouzbahani, Andreas Keil, Peter König, Layla Kouara, Louisa Kulke, Cecile D. Ladouceur, Nicolas Langer, Heinrich R. Liesefeld, David Luque, Annmarie MacNamara, Liad Mudrik, Muthuraman Muthuraman, Lauren B. Neal, Gustav Nilsonne, Guiomar Niso, Sebastian Ocklenburg, Robert Oostenveld, Cyril R. Pernet, Gilles Pourtois, Manuela Ruzzoli, Sarah M. Sass, Alexandre Schaefer, Magdalena Senderecka, Joel S. Snyder, Christian K. Tamnes, Emmanuelle Tognoli, Marieke K. van Vugt, Edelyn Verona, Robin Vloeberghs, Dominik Welke, Jan R. Wessel, Ilya Zakharov & Faisal Mushtaq. (2021) #EEGManyLabs: Investigating the replicability of influential EEG experiments. Cortex.
Crossref
Torgrim Solstad, Evangelia Daskalaki & Juhani Järvikivi. (2021) Expectations in language processing and production: an introduction to the special issue. Linguistics 59:2, pages 319-331.
Crossref
Petra Augurzky, Vera Hohaus & Rolf Ulrich. (2020) Context and Complexity in Incremental Sentence Interpretation: An ERP Study on Temporal Quantification. Cognitive Science 44:11.
Crossref
Michael G. Cutter, Andrea E. Martin & Patrick Sturt. (2020) Readers detect an low-level phonological violation between two parafoveal words. Cognition 204, pages 104395.
Crossref
Damien S. Fleur, Monique Flecken, Joost Rommers & Mante S. Nieuwland. (2020) Definitely saw it coming? The dual nature of the pre-nominal prediction effect. Cognition 204, pages 104335.
Crossref
Niels O. Schiller, Bastien P.-A. Boutonnet, Marianne L. S. De Heer Kloots, Marieke Meelen, Bobby Ruijgrok & Lisa L.-S. Cheng. (2020) (Not so) Great Expectations: Listening to Foreign-Accented Speech Reduces the Brain’s Anticipatory Processes. Frontiers in Psychology 11.
Crossref
Thomas P. Urbach, Katherine A. DeLongWen-Hsuan Chan & Marta Kutas. (2020) An exploratory data analysis of word form prediction during word-by-word reading. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117:34, pages 20483-20494.
Crossref
Emily L. Coderre, Elizabeth O’Donnell, Emme O’Rourke & Neil Cohn. (2020) Predictability modulates neurocognitive semantic processing of non-verbal narratives. Scientific Reports 10:1.
Crossref
Milena Rabovsky. (2020) Change in a probabilistic representation of meaning can account for N400 effects on articles: A neural network model. Neuropsychologia 143, pages 107466.
Crossref
Bruno Nicenboim, Shravan Vasishth & Frank Rösler. (2020) Are words pre-activated probabilistically during sentence comprehension? Evidence from new data and a Bayesian random-effects meta-analysis using publicly available data. Neuropsychologia 142, pages 107427.
Crossref
Essa Batel. (2019) Context Effect on L2 Word Recognition: Visual Versus Auditory Modalities. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 49:2, pages 223-245.
Crossref
Nyssa Z. Bulkes, Kiel Christianson & Darren Tanner. (2020) Semantic constraint, reading control, and the granularity of form-based expectations during semantic processing: Evidence from ERPs. Neuropsychologia 137, pages 107294.
Crossref
Aine Ito, Chiara Gambi, Martin J. Pickering, Kim Fuellenbach & E. Matthew Husband. (2020) Prediction of phonological and gender information: An event-related potential study in Italian. Neuropsychologia 136, pages 107291.
Crossref
José Alemán Bañón & Clara Martin. (2019) Anticipating information structure: An event-related potentials study of focus assignment via the it-cleft. Neuropsychologia 134, pages 107203.
Crossref
Francesco Mantegna, Florian Hintz, Markus Ostarek, Phillip M. Alday & Falk Huettig. (2019) Distinguishing integration and prediction accounts of ERP N400 modulations in language processing through experimental design. Neuropsychologia 134, pages 107199.
Crossref
Viviana Haase, Maria Spychalska & Markus Werning. (2019) Investigating the Comprehension of Negated Sentences Employing World Knowledge: An Event-Related Potential Study. Frontiers in Psychology 10.
Crossref
Hossein Karimi, Trevor Brothers & Fernanda Ferreira. (2019) Phonological versus semantic prediction in focus and repair constructions: No evidence for differential predictions. Cognitive Psychology 112, pages 25-47.
Crossref
Heidi Solberg Økland, Ana Todorović, Claudia S. Lüttke, James M. McQueen & Floris P. de Lange. (2019) Combined predictive effects of sentential and visual constraints in early audiovisual speech processing. Scientific Reports 9:1.
Crossref
Falk Huettig & Ernesto Guerra. (2019) Effects of speech rate, preview time of visual context, and participant instructions reveal strong limits on prediction in language processing. Brain Research 1706, pages 196-208.
Crossref
Mante S. Nieuwland. (2019) Do ‘early’ brain responses reveal word form prediction during language comprehension? A critical review. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 96, pages 367-400.
Crossref
Katherine A. DeLong, Wen‐hsuan Chan & Marta Kutas. (2018) Similar time courses for word form and meaning preactivation during sentence comprehension. Psychophysiology, pages e13312.
Crossref
Andrew Armstrong, Nyssa Bulkes & Darren Tanner. (2018) QUANTIFICATIONAL CUES MODULATE THE PROCESSING OF ENGLISH SUBJECT-VERB AGREEMENT BY NATIVE CHINESE SPEAKERS. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 40:4, pages 731-754.
Crossref
Chiara Gambi, Fiona Gorrie, Martin J. Pickering & Hugh Rabagliati. (2018) The development of linguistic prediction: Predictions of sound and meaning in 2- to 5-year-olds. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 173, pages 351-370.
Crossref
Chin Lung Yang, Charles A. Perfetti, Li-Hai Tan & Ying Jiang. (2018) ERP indicators of L2 proficiency in word-to-text integration processes. Neuropsychologia 117, pages 287-301.
Crossref
Irene F. Monsalve, Mathieu Bourguignon & Nicola Molinaro. (2018) Theta oscillations mediate pre-activation of highly expected word initial phonemes. Scientific Reports 8:1.
Crossref
Mante S Nieuwland, Stephen Politzer-Ahles, Evelien Heyselaar, Katrien Segaert, Emily Darley, Nina Kazanina, Sarah Von Grebmer Zu Wolfsthurn, Federica Bartolozzi, Vita Kogan, Aine Ito, Diane Mézière, Dale J Barr, Guillaume A Rousselet, Heather J Ferguson, Simon Busch-Moreno, Xiao Fu, Jyrki Tuomainen, Eugenia Kulakova, E Matthew Husband, David I Donaldson, Zdenko Kohút, Shirley-Ann Rueschemeyer & Falk Huettig. (2018) Large-scale replication study reveals a limit on probabilistic prediction in language comprehension. eLife 7.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.