Abstract
Internationally, both in popular and scientific media, debates occasionally emerge concerning the possible (negative) consequences of feminisation tendencies in the teaching staff. In these discussions, various assumptions about the ‘nature’ of male and female teachers and masculinity and femininity are expressed. Male and female teachers are often presumed to differ in teaching styles, capacities and effects on both the teaching profession and the pupils. The arguments used in these debates only seldom refer to particular theoretical grounds or to empirical evidence. Moreover, apart from Sandra Acker’s essay ‘Gender and teachers’ work’ in Citation1995, educational research lacks an up‐to‐date review of teacher gender. Therefore, this article aims to provide insight into contemporary theoretical gender perspectives. It also intends to connect these with empirical research that takes teacher gender into account. Most of the research studies referred to in this article do not explicitly state their underlying theoretical principles. Yet, since these studies have distinct research foci, research questions, methodologies and conclusions, they appear to depart from a variety of gender conceptualisations. Therefore, in this article the differences between these conceptualisations will be examined and the divergent theoretical assumptions underlying these studies will be revealed. The two most widespread and disparate perspectives in gender theory are the essentialist perspectives on the one hand and the constructionist perspectives on the other. The differences between them are made up by the degree to which explanations are deterministic and focused on the individual rather than on the social and cultural level. Drawing upon this theoretical contrast, we divided the body of research on teacher gender into two divergent research traditions: sex differences research and gender dynamics research. The research questions, underlying theoretical principles and methodologies of these two traditions are examined.
Notes
1. Such as Good et al., Citation1973; Vroegh, Citation1976; Bennett, Citation1982; Gold & Reis, Citation1982; Harris et al., Citation1986; McIntyre, Citation1988; Mancus, Citation1992; Evetts, Citation1993; Feldman, Citation1993; Hancock et al., Citation1993; Mallam, Citation1993; Ehrenberg et al., Citation1994; Kalaian & Freeman, Citation1994; Warwick & Jatoi, Citation1994; Duru‐Bellat, Citation1995; Lee et al., Citation1995; Brennan et al., Citation1996; Brookhart & Loadman, Citation1996; Relich, Citation1996; Rowden & Carlson, Citation1996; Jules & Kutnick, Citation1997; Lush, Citation1997; Montecinos & Nielsen, Citation1997; Galguera, Citation1998; Lewis & Warin, Citation1998; Brady & Eisler, Citation1999; Hopf & Hatzichristou, Citation1999; Johnston et al., Citation1999; Leone‐Perkins et al., Citation1999; Li, Citation1999; Rosenblatt et al., Citation1999; Bress, Citation2000.
2. Such as Huberman, Citation1993; Dey, Citation1995; Drevets et al., Citation1996; Ross et al., Citation1996; Wilkinson, Citation1998; Byrne, Citation1999; de Heus & Diekstra, Citation1999; Lens & De Jesus, Citation1999; Ma & MacMillan, Citation1999; Hawe et al., Citation2000; Huang, Citation2001; Barber, Citation2002.
Good
,
T. L.
,
Sikes
,
J. N.
and
Brophy
,
J. E.
1973
.
Effects of teacher sex and student sex on classroom interaction
.
Journal of Education Psychology
,
65
(1)
:
74
–
87
.
Vroegh
,
K.
1976
.
Sex of teacher and academic achievement: a review of research
.
Elementary School Journal
,
76
(7)
:
389
–
405
.
Bennett
,
S. K.
1982
.
Student perceptions of and expectation for male and female instructors: evidence relating to the question of gender bias in teaching evaluation
.
Journal of Educational Psychology
,
74
(2)
:
170
–
179
.
Gold
,
D.
and
Reis
,
M.
1982
.
Male teacher effects on young children: a theoretical and empirical consideration
.
Sex Roles
,
8
(5)
:
493
–
513
.
Harris
,
M. J.
,
Rosenthal
,
S.
and
Snodgrass
,
S. E.
1986
.
The effects of teacher behavior expectations, gender, and behavior on pupil academic performance and self‐concept
.
Journal of Educational Research
,
79
(3)
:
174
–
179
.
McIntyre
,
L. L.
1988
.
Teacher gender: a predictor of special education referral?
.
Journal of Learning Disabilities
,
21
(6)
:
382
–
383
.
Mancus
,
D. S.
1992
.
Influence of male teachers on elementary‐school children’s stereotyping of teacher competence
.
Sex Roles
,
26
(3–4)
:
109
–
128
.
Evetts
,
J.
1993
.
Women in engineering: educational concomitants of a non‐traditional career choice
.
Gender and Education
,
5
(2)
:
167
–
179
.
Feldman
,
A.
1993
.
College‐students views of male and female college‐teachers. 2. Evidence from students’ evaluations of their classroom teachers
.
Research in Higher Education
,
34
(2)
:
151
–
211
.
Hancock
,
G. R.
,
Shannon
,
D. M.
and
Trentman
,
L. L.
1993
.
Student and teacher gender in rating of university faculty: results from five colleges of study
.
Journal of Personnel Evaluation in Education
,
6
:
235
–
248
.
Mallam
,
W. A.
1993
.
Impact of school‐type and sex of the teacher on female students’ attitudes toward mathematics in Nigerian secondary schools
.
Educational Studies in Mathematics
,
24
:
223
–
229
.
Ehrenberg
,
R. G.
,
Goldhaber
,
D. D.
and
Brewer
,
D. J.
1994
.
Do teachers’ race, gender, and ethnicity matter? Evidence from NELS88. Working paper no. 4669
,
Cambridge
:
National Bureau of Economic Research
.
Kalaian
,
H. A.
and
Freeman
,
D. J.
1994
.
Gender differences in self‐confidence and educational beliefs among secondary teacher candidates
.
Teaching and Teacher Education
,
10
(6)
:
647
–
658
.
Warwick
,
D. P.
and
Jatoi
,
H.
1994
.
Teacher gender and student achievement in Pakistan
.
Comparative Education Review
,
38
(3)
:
377
–
399
.
Duru‐Bellat
,
M.
1995
.
Filles et garçons à l’école, approches sociologiques et psycho‐sociales
.
Revue Française de Pédagogique
,
110
:
75
–
109
.
Lee
,
V. E.
,
Loeb
,
S.
and
Marks
,
H. M.
1995
.
Gender differences in secondary school teachers’ control over classroom and school policy
.
American Journal of Education
,
103
:
259
–
301
.
Brennan
,
M. D.
,
Robinson
,
C. K.
and
Shaughnessy
,
M. F.
1996
.
Gender comparison of teachers’ sense of efficacy
.
Psychological Reports
,
78
:
122
Brookhart
,
S. M.
and
Loadman
,
W. E.
1996
.
Characteristics of male elementary teachers in the U.S.A., at teacher education program entry and exit
.
Teaching and Teacher Education
,
12
(2)
:
197
–
210
.
Relich
,
J.
1996
.
Gender, self‐concept and teachers of mathematics: effects on attitudes to teaching and learning
.
Educational Studies in Mathematics
,
30
:
179
–
195
.
Rowden
,
G. V.
and
Carlson
,
R. E.
1996
.
Gender issues and students’ perceptions of instructors’ immediacy and evaluation of teaching and course
.
Psychological Reports
,
78
(3)
:
835
–
839
.
Jules
,
V.
and
Kutnick
,
P.
1997
.
Student perceptions of a good teacher: the gender perspective
.
British Journal of Educational Psychology
,
67
(4)
:
497
–
511
.
Lush
,
B.
1997
.
Gender and teaching: a study of teacher gender and verbal interaction patterns in same‐sex and mixed‐sex groups in the classroom. Postgraduate dissertation abstract
,
Surrey
:
English Language Institute, University of Surrey
.
Montecinos
,
C.
and
Nielsen
,
L. E.
1997
.
Gender and cohort differences in university students’ decisions to become elementary teacher education major
.
Journal of Teacher Education
,
48
(1)
:
47
–
54
.
Galguera
,
T.
1998
.
Students’ attitudes toward teachers’ ethnicity, bilinguality and gender
.
Hispanic Journal of Behavioural Sciences
,
20
(4)
:
411
–
428
.
Lewis
,
C.
and
Warin
,
J.
1998
.
“
Gender differences: the child’s perspective
”
. In
Men as workers in services for young children: issues of a mixed gender workforce
,
Edited by:
Owen
,
C.
,
Cameron
,
C.
and
Moss
,
P.
91
–
105
.
London
:
The Institute of Education, University of London
.
Brady
,
K. L.
and
Eisler
,
R. M.
1999
.
Sex and gender in the college classroom: a quantitative analysis of faculty–student interactions and perceptions
.
Journal of Educational Psychology
,
91
(1)
:
127
–
145
.
Hopf
,
D.
and
Hatzichristou
,
C.
1999
.
Teacher gender‐related influences in Greek schools
.
British Journal of Educational Psychology
,
69
(1)
:
1
–
18
.
Johnston
,
J.
,
Mc Keown
,
E.
and
Mc Ewen
,
A.
1999
.
Choosing primary teaching as a career: the perspectives of males and females in training
.
Journal of Education for Teaching
,
25
(1)
:
55
–
64
.
Leone‐Perkins
,
M.
,
Schnuth
,
R.
and
Kanter
,
T.
1999
.
Preceptor–student interactions in ambulatory clerkship: gender differences in student evaluations of teaching
.
Teaching and Learning in Medicine
,
11
(3)
:
164
–
167
.
Li
,
Q.
1999
.
Teachers’ beliefs and gender differences in mathematics: a review
.
Educational Research
,
41
(1)
:
63
–
76
.
Rosenblatt
,
Z.
,
Talmud
,
I.
and
Ruvio
,
A.
1999
.
A gender‐based framework of the experience of job insecurity and its effects on work attitudes
.
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology
,
8
(2)
:
197
–
217
.
Bress
,
P.
2000
.
Gender differences in teaching styles
.
Forum
,
38
(4)
:
26
Huberman
,
M.
1993
.
The lives of teachers
,
London
:
Cassell
.
Dey
,
E. L.
1995
.
The activities of undergraduate teaching faculty
.
Thought and Action
,
11
(1)
:
43
–
62
.
Drevets
,
R. K.
,
Benton
,
S. L.
and
Bradley
,
F. O.
1996
.
Students’ perceptions of parents’ and teachers’ qualities of interpersonal relations
.
Journal of Youth and Adolescence
,
25
(6)
:
787
–
803
.
Ross
,
J. A.
,
Cousins
,
J. B.
and
Gadalla
,
T.
1996
.
Within‐teacher predictors of teacher efficacy
.
Teaching & Teacher Education
,
12
(4)
:
385
–
400
.
Wilkinson
,
I. A. G.
1998
.
Dealing with diversity: achievement gaps in reading literacy among New Zealand students
.
Reading Research Quarterly
,
33
(2)
:
144
–
167
.
Byrne
,
B. M.
1999
.
“
The nomological network of teacher burnout: a literature review and empirically validated model
”
. In
Understanding and preventing teacher burnout: a sourcebook of international research and practice
,
Edited by:
Vandenberghe
,
R.
and
Huberman
,
A. M.
15
–
37
.
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
de Heus
,
P.
and
Diekstra
,
R. F. W.
1999
.
“
Do teachers burn out more easily? A comparison of teachers with other social professions on work stress and burnout symptoms
”
. In
Understanding and preventing teacher burnout: a sourcebook of international research and practice
,
Edited by:
Vandenberghe
,
R.
and
Huberman
,
A. M.
269
–
284
.
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Lens
,
W.
and
De Jesus
,
S. N.
1999
.
“
A psychosocial interpretation of teacher stress and burnout
”
. In
Understanding and preventing teacher burnout: a sourcebook of international research and practice
,
Edited by:
Vandenberghe
,
R.
and
Huberman
,
A. M.
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Ma
,
X.
and
MacMillan
,
R. B.
1999
.
Influences of workplace conditions on teachers’ job satisfaction
.
Journal of Educational Research
,
93
(1)
:
39
–
47
.
Hawe
,
E.
,
Tuck
,
B.
,
Manthei
,
R.
,
Adair
,
V.
and
Moore
,
D.
2000
.
Job satisfaction and stress in New Zealand primary teachers
.
New Zealand Journal of Educational Sciences
,
35
(2)
:
193
–
205
.
Huang
,
S.‐Y. L.
2001
.
Teachers’ perceptions of high school environments
.
Learning Environments Research
,
4
(2)
:
159
–
173
.
Barber
,
T.
2002
.
A special duty of care: exploring the narration and experience of teacher caring
.
British Journal of Sociology of Education
,
23
(3)
:
383
–
395
.
Lens
,
W.
and
De Jesus
,
S. N.
1999
.
“
A psychosocial interpretation of teacher stress and burnout
”
. In
Understanding and preventing teacher burnout: a sourcebook of international research and practice
,
Edited by:
Vandenberghe
,
R.
and
Huberman
,
A. M.
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Ma
,
X.
and
MacMillan
,
R. B.
1999
.
Influences of workplace conditions on teachers’ job satisfaction
.
Journal of Educational Research
,
93
(1)
:
39
–
47
.
Rosenblatt
,
Z.
,
Talmud
,
I.
and
Ruvio
,
A.
1999
.
A gender‐based framework of the experience of job insecurity and its effects on work attitudes
.
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology
,
8
(2)
:
197
–
217
.
Hawe
,
E.
,
Tuck
,
B.
,
Manthei
,
R.
,
Adair
,
V.
and
Moore
,
D.
2000
.
Job satisfaction and stress in New Zealand primary teachers
.
New Zealand Journal of Educational Sciences
,
35
(2)
:
193
–
205
.
Huang
,
S.‐Y. L.
2001
.
Teachers’ perceptions of high school environments
.
Learning Environments Research
,
4
(2)
:
159
–
173
.