Opportunistic nationalism and racism: race, nation, and online mobilization in the context of the Polish Independence March 2020

ABSTRACT

The article is dedicated to the issue of the online racism among football fans at the time of the COVID-19 pandemic when due to national restrictions, participation in football matches was unavailable, by the example of the 2020 Polish Independence March. In particular, the research is dedicated to the fans’ mobilization to participate in the March. The main research questions include: (1) What actors/groups did fans perceive as the main antagonists in the context of the Independence March?; (2) Was the racist content present in the discourse?; (3) Did fans refer to the COVID-19 pandemic in the context of the Independence March?. The research has been pursued through qualitative content analysis of a topic dedicated to the 2020 Independence March on the most prominent internet forum of Polish football fans kibice.net.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1. Hill et al. ‘Against Modern Football’.

2. Boulianne, ‘Social media use and participation’.

3. Hill et al. ‘Against Modern Football’; Doidge, Kossakowski and Mintert. Ultras. The passion and performance of contemporary football fandom.

4. Podaliri and Balestri, ‘The ultras, racism and football culture in Italy’; Cleland and Cashmore, ‘Football fans’ views of racism in British football’.

5. Bradbury, ‘From racial exclusions to new inclusions’.

6. Burdsey, Racism and English Football.

7. Tosa, ‘Sport Nationalism in South Korea’.

8. Jaskułowski and Majewski, ‘The UEFA European Football Championship 2012 and pop nationalism in Poland’.

9. Edensor, National Identity, Popular Culture and Everyday Life.

10. Bairner, National sports and national landscapes.

11. Arnold, ‘Sport and Official Nationalism in Modern Russia’.

12. Berend, ‘What is Central and Eastern Europe?’

13. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom; Molnar and Whigham, ‘Radical right populist politics in Hungary’.

14. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom, 143–145.

15. Ibid., 172–174.

16. Llopis-Goig, ‘Racism, Xenophobia and Intolerance’.

17. BBC Sport, ‘Bulgaria fans’ racism’.

18. BBC Sport, ‘England to report racist abuse of players in Montenegro’

19. BBC Sport, ‘Taison: Shakhtar’s Brazil midfielder after sending-off following alleged racist abuse’.

20. Barna and Hunyadi, ‘Report on Xenophobia and Radical Nationalism in Hungary’.

21. Mareš, Right-Wing Extremism in the Czech Republic.

22. Kušnierová, ‘Ultras in Trnava’; Nociar, Right-Wing Extremism in Slovakia; Harsányi, Report on hooliganism, racism, antisemitism and intolerance in Slovak football.

23. Obradovic-Wochink, ‘Racism in Serbian football fan culture’; Bakic, Right-Wing Extremism in Serbia, 3–5; Ames, ‘Serbian football’s eye-watering racism problem shows no sign of abating’.

24. Zivanovic, ‘Red Star Belgrade Face Punishment for Anti-Muslim Banner’.

25. Tomić, ‘On the “right” side?’,106–107.

26. Arnold and Veth, ‘Racism and Russian Football Supporters’ Culture. A Case for Concern?’; Arnold, ‘Systematic Racist Violence in Russia’; Glathe, ‘Football Fan Subculture in Russia’.

27. Independent, ‘Racist Zenit St Petersburg fans protest over signing of Malcom with banner’; BBC Sport, ‘Zenit St Petersburg fans want black and gay players excluded’.

28. FARE, ‘Incident list’.

29. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom; Burski and Woźniak, ‘The sociopolitical roots of antisemitism among football fandom’.

30. Kossakowski, Hooligans, ultras, activist. Polish football fandom in sociological perspective.

31. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom.

32. Włoch, Raport dotyczący wybranych przejawów dyskryminacji (rasizm, antysemityzm, ksenofobia i homofobia) w polskim sporcie ze szczególnym uwzględnieniem środowiska kibiców sportowych; Sztejnberg and Jasiński, ‘Postawy studentów wobec rasizmu i dyskryminacji rasowej na polskich stadionach’.

33. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom, 101.

34. Purski, Czuję się obywatelem Polski.

35. Nosal and Organista, ‘Dark-skinned pioneers in European national football teams’, 11.

36. Eurosport, ‘Kiedyś bananami w Olisadebe, teraz to piłkarze odpowiadają’.

37. Pankowski, Hateful. Monitoring racism, discrimination and hate crime in Polish and Ukrainian Football 2009–2011.

38. Rek-Woźniak and Woźniak, ‘BBC’s Documentary “Stadiums of Hate” and Manufacturing of the News: Case Study in Moral Panics and Media Manipulation’.

39. Łukianow and Kocyba, ‘The Right in the Streets’.

40. Taylor, ‘“White Europe”’.

41. Charlish and Ptak, ‘Far-right Polish Independence Day march draws thousands despite ban’.

42. Wiącek, ‘The Rhetoric of the “March of Independence” in Poland (2010–2017) as the Answer for the Policy of Multiculturalism in EU and the Refugee Crisis’.

43. Stadionowi Oprawcy, ‘LIVE Marsz Niepodległości’.

44. Bond ‘COVID-19: the return of football fans’.

45. Mazurkiewicz, ‘The Mass Mobilization of Polish Football Fans in the Face of Covid-19’; Perasović ‘Covid-19 and the Mobilisation of Ultras in Croatia’; Gennoy, ‘Coronavirus: German football ultras pull together in trying times’.

46. Ford, ‘Hooligans in 2020’.

47. Honza, ‘Demonstracja’.

48. Stadionowi Oprawcy, ‘Jedenasty Marsz Niepodległości’.

49. Castells, ‘Communication, Power and Counter-Power in the Network Society’.

50. Boulianne, ‘Social media use and participation: a meta-analysis of current research’.

51. See: Schreier, ‘Qualitative Content Analysis’, 170–183.

52. Forman and Damschroder, ‘Qualitative Content Analysis’, 41.

53. Hseih and Shannon, ‘Three approaches to qualitative content analysis’, 1278.

54. See: Kossakowski, Antonowicz and Jakubowska, ‘The reproduction of hegemonic masculinity in football fandom’.

55. Stowarzyszenie, ‘Cel’.

56. See: Burski and Woźniak, ‘The sociopolitical roots of antisemitism’.

57. Magdziarz and Santora, ‘Women Converge on Warsaw’.

58. Sportowy. ‘Strajk Kobiet: Kogo poprze kibic?’.

59. Jajecznik, ‘The Nationalist Movement in Poland’, 53–54.

60. Kossakowski, Nosal and Woźniak, Politics, ideology and football fandom; Kossakowski and Besta, ‘Football, Conservative Values, and a Feeling of Oneness with the Group’; Grodecki, ‘Occasional Nationalists. The National Ideology of Ultras’.

61. Spaaij, ‘Football hooliganism as a transnational phenomenon’, 426.

62. Mudde, The Far Right Today, 62.

63. Nielsen, ‘Stronger than the state?’, 1040,1043.

64. Glathe, ‘Football Fan Subculture in Russia’.

65. Idem, The Ideology of the Extreme Right, 10.