442
Views
8
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Methodology for collision-frequency analysis of wind-turbine installation vessels

ORCID Icon, ORCID Icon, & ORCID Icon
Pages 423-439 | Received 05 Aug 2019, Accepted 20 Feb 2020, Published online: 05 Mar 2020

Figures & data

Figure 1. Examples of collisions with offshore structures (a and b) and a typical WTIV (c). (a) Passing vessel collision by fishing vessel, (b) Attendant vessel collision involving supply vessel, (c) Typical WTIV (Jan De Nul Group: https://www.jandenul.com/).

Figure 1. Examples of collisions with offshore structures (a and b) and a typical WTIV (c). (a) Passing vessel collision by fishing vessel, (b) Attendant vessel collision involving supply vessel, (c) Typical WTIV (Jan De Nul Group: https://www.jandenul.com/).

Figure 2. Collision probability for a specific route.

Figure 2. Collision probability for a specific route.

Figure 3. Calculating the frequency of collisions with drifting vessels.

Figure 3. Calculating the frequency of collisions with drifting vessels.

Table 1. Field-related vessel- collision statistics (OGP Citation2010).

Figure 4. Procedure for calculating risk of collisions between ships and WTIVs.

Figure 4. Procedure for calculating risk of collisions between ships and WTIVs.

Figure 5. Definition of each ship’s route.

Figure 5. Definition of each ship’s route.

Figure 6. Target offshore platform and operating site. (a) Layout of typical WTIV; (b) Target operating site: North Sea (www.4coffshore.com/offshorewind/).

Figure 6. Target offshore platform and operating site. (a) Layout of typical WTIV; (b) Target operating site: North Sea (www.4coffshore.com/offshorewind/).

Table 2. Number of ships and the probability of each ship type being in the area.

Figure 7. Major routes in the WTIV location. (a) Major routes, (b) Traffic data of all (2086) vessels.

Figure 7. Major routes in the WTIV location. (a) Major routes, (b) Traffic data of all (2086) vessels.

Table 3. Defined major routes.

Table 4. Probability of passing plan failure (P1), watchkeeping failure and alert failure (P2·P3).

Table 5. Probability of averting collision by radar (M1).

Table 6. Collision frequencies (/yr) of passing vessels on Route A.

Table 7. Collision frequencies (/yr) of fixed, mobile and WTIV platforms on all routes.

Table 8. Impact energy of passing vessel collisions based on gross weight and representative speed.

Table 9. Ship traffic data by ship type and physical mass (gross weight).

Table 10. Frequency of passing vessel collisions (/yr) with WTIVs by ship type and gross weight.

Figure 8. Exceedance frequency of passing vessel collision. (a) With the gross weight categories suggested by Spouge (Citation1999), (b) With the 1000-tonne-interval weight categories.

Figure 8. Exceedance frequency of passing vessel collision. (a) With the gross weight categories suggested by Spouge (Citation1999), (b) With the 1000-tonne-interval weight categories.

Figure 9. Example of wind directions affecting drifting collisions on Route B.

Figure 9. Example of wind directions affecting drifting collisions on Route B.

Table 11. Probability of wind direction and speed for the North Sea (near Bergen, Norway).

Table 12. Frequency (/yr) of collisions by drifting vessels.

Table 13. Impact energy of drifting vessel collisions by gross weight and speed.

Table 14. Finalised frequency of collisions with drifting vessels (/yr) by ship type and gross weight.

Figure 10. Exceedance frequency of drifting vessel collision. (a) With the gross weight categories suggested by Spouge (Citation1999), (b) With the 1000-tonne-interval weight categories.

Figure 10. Exceedance frequency of drifting vessel collision. (a) With the gross weight categories suggested by Spouge (Citation1999), (b) With the 1000-tonne-interval weight categories.

Table 15. Expected number of visiting vessels at target WTIV and attendant collision frequency.

Figure 11. Major routes in the facility’s location.

Figure 11. Major routes in the facility’s location.

Table 16. Impact energy of collisions with an attendant vessel using the traditional approach (only head-on collisions).

Table 17. Example of impact energy for all possible collision angles with an attendant Supply vessel_1.

Figure 12. Major routes in the facility’s location.

Figure 12. Major routes in the facility’s location.

Figure 13. Best fit of selected probability density functions. (a) Ship type, (b) Gross weight, (c) Ship speed, (d) Collision angle.

Figure 13. Best fit of selected probability density functions. (a) Ship type, (b) Gross weight, (c) Ship speed, (d) Collision angle.

Figure 14. Comparison of the candidate methods for assessing DAL for passing vessel collisions.

Figure 14. Comparison of the candidate methods for assessing DAL for passing vessel collisions.

Table A1. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route A.

Table A2. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route B.

Table A3. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route C.

Table A4. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route D.

Table A5. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route E.

Table A6. Collision frequencies (/y) of passing vessels on Route F.

Table A7. Frequency (/y) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route A.

Table A8. Frequency (/y) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route B.

Table A9. Frequency (/y) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route C.

Table A10. Frequency (/y) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route D.

Table A11. Frequency (/y) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route E.

Table A12. Frequency (/yr) of collisions with drifting vessels on Route F.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.